103QHFOOC1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT1 SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK2 ------------------------------x23 THE FOOTBALL ASSOCIATION3 PREMIER LEAGUE LIMITED, et4 al.,45 Plaintiffs, New York, N.Y.56 v. 07 Civ. 3582 (LLS)67 YOUTUBE, INC., et al.,78 Defendants.89 ------------------------------x910 March 26, 201010 11:15 a.m.1111 Before:1212 HON. LOUIS L. STANTON,1313 District Judge141516171819202122232425SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.(212) 805-0300

203QHFOOC1 APPEARANCES12 PROSKAUER ROSE, LLP2 Attorneys for Class Plaintiffs3 BY: DIETRICH L. SNELL3 NOAH SISKIND GITTERMAN4 GREGG M. MASHBERG45 BERNSTEIN LITOWITZ BERGER & GROSSMANN, LLP5 Attorneys for Class Plaintiffs6 BY: JOHN C. BROWNE7 CADWALADER WICKERSHAM & TAFT, LLP7 Attorneys for Plaintiff The Football Association8 Premier League Limited8 BY: LOUIS M. SOLOMON99 SEYMOUR FAGAN10 Attorney for Plaintiff Robert Tur1011 MAYER BROWN, LLP11 Attorneys for Defendants YouTube and Google12 BY: ANDREW H. SCHAPIRO12 A. JOHN P. MANCINI13141516171819202122232425SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.(212) 805-0300

303QHFOOC1 (In open court)2 THE COURT: Because I didn't want to take anyone by3 surprise, my first question is why should any of this be4 confidential to any degree except, perhaps, for the actual text5 of what was supposed to be confidential and not disclosed?6 MR. SCHAPIRO: Your Honor, for the defendants, we have7 looked over the papers and we don't see anything that we would8 argue needs to remain confidential.9 MR. FAGAN: Your Honor, I am Mr. Seymour Fagan. I am10 the new face here. I came from Los Angeles for the purpose of11 this hearing.12 MR. SNELL: Excuse me, your Honor. I am sorry to13 interrupt, but for procedural clarity I think it is necessary14 to move Mr. Fagan's admission pro hac vice, and I would like to15 do that by oral application, if I may, at this time. The16 paperwork is going to be submitted in short order with the17 clerk's office.18 THE COURT: I am perfectly willing to address that.19 Before we turn to that, are you speaking for a plaintiff?20 MR. SNELL: Yes, your Honor.21 THE COURT: Can you give me your position on the22 confidentiality question I asked.23 MR. SNELL: Sure, your Honor. I am representing the24 class plaintiffs. At this time we don't have a position25 because it is not our material that is at the core of theSOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.(212) 805-0300