Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
5Activity
P. 1
26/11 Attacks: Looking into the Legal Questions (Saroj Kumar Rath). Social Research Reports, Volume 9, 2010.

26/11 Attacks: Looking into the Legal Questions (Saroj Kumar Rath). Social Research Reports, Volume 9, 2010.

Ratings: (0)|Views: 228 |Likes:
Published by expertprojects
Title: 26/11 Attacks: Looking into the Legal Questions
Author: Saroj Kumar Rath
(PhD is Research Associate, Hosei University, Tokyo, Japan)
Abstract:
During the 26/11 Mumbai attack Ajmal Kasab was intercepted alive by the Mumbai police and the capture of a foreign terrorist led to an intricate legal battle as Mumbai police filed an 11,280 page chargesheet. The FBI filed four Chargesheets in the same case in a US court. The investigative mechanism adopted by the US and India for 26/11 attacks case inspire different degree of confidence. As for the terrorist crime, much is said for its prevention, and even the Afghan War against Taliban is said to be future security of the US and the world. But punishment without fail is very much important for prevention. The legal trial of the Mumbai case is different as legal structure of counts of indictment of such a crime which are thought to be applied in ordinary crime which occur in ordinary life, does not appropriately reflect actual social reality of the crime, of it's gravity, of it's structural whole, of each criminal's role. How far India’s and US’ investigation in the Mumbai attacks case establishes the design, plan and purpose of the crime? Is the post crime legal procedure of India and the US is deterrence for terror attack or otherwise? The article examines these questions both theoretically and empirically, with specific analysis of the chargesheet filed by the Mumbai police and FBI. Theoretically I identify various aspects – legal infrastructure, forensic data, electronic interception, intelligence input and conventional method of investigation – and hypothesized that there are different level of conviction for the same crime in both these countries.
Title: 26/11 Attacks: Looking into the Legal Questions
Author: Saroj Kumar Rath
(PhD is Research Associate, Hosei University, Tokyo, Japan)
Abstract:
During the 26/11 Mumbai attack Ajmal Kasab was intercepted alive by the Mumbai police and the capture of a foreign terrorist led to an intricate legal battle as Mumbai police filed an 11,280 page chargesheet. The FBI filed four Chargesheets in the same case in a US court. The investigative mechanism adopted by the US and India for 26/11 attacks case inspire different degree of confidence. As for the terrorist crime, much is said for its prevention, and even the Afghan War against Taliban is said to be future security of the US and the world. But punishment without fail is very much important for prevention. The legal trial of the Mumbai case is different as legal structure of counts of indictment of such a crime which are thought to be applied in ordinary crime which occur in ordinary life, does not appropriately reflect actual social reality of the crime, of it's gravity, of it's structural whole, of each criminal's role. How far India’s and US’ investigation in the Mumbai attacks case establishes the design, plan and purpose of the crime? Is the post crime legal procedure of India and the US is deterrence for terror attack or otherwise? The article examines these questions both theoretically and empirically, with specific analysis of the chargesheet filed by the Mumbai police and FBI. Theoretically I identify various aspects – legal infrastructure, forensic data, electronic interception, intelligence input and conventional method of investigation – and hypothesized that there are different level of conviction for the same crime in both these countries.

More info:

Categories:Types, Research, Science
Published by: expertprojects on Apr 01, 2010
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

05/24/2012

pdf

 
_drxwac Rg|kwrlg| Lg`xgrd` \kldac Ykrf
 
\kldacRg|garlmRg~krx|
Earlm 2>1>
_kcweg 4
 
G}~grx ^rkjglx|# 2>1>
 
\KLDAC RG\GARLM RG^KRX\_kc. 4 + Earlm 2>1>
2
 \KLDAC RG\GARLM RG^KRX\
D\\@: 2>??%?=?1 -~rd`x$# D\\@: 2>?9%7481 -gcglxrk`dl$2?+11 AXXALF\: CKKFD@I D@XK XMG CGIAC QWG\XDK@\\arkj Fwear Raxm
 \kldac Rg|garlm Rg~krx|
# 2>1># vkc. 4# ~~. <%<?Xmg k`cd`g vgr|dk` ko xmd| arxdlcg la` bg okw`h ax:
yyy.rga|garlmrg~krx|.rk
 ^wbcd|mgh bt:G}~grx ^rkjglx| ^wbcd|md`i Mkw|gLkvgrgh bt D`hg} Lk~gr`dlw| D`xgr`axdk`acyyy.d`hg}lk~gr`dlw|.lke K` bgmaco ko:_drxwac Rg|kwrlg| Lg`xgr d` \kldac Ykrf yyy.a|d|xg`xa|kldaca.rk Ahhdxdk`ac |grvdlg| a`h d`okreaxdk` abkwx \kldac Rg|garlm Rg~krx| la` bg okw`h ax:
yyy.rga|garlmrg~krx|.rk
 
 
\KLDAC RG\GARLM RG^KRX\_kc. 4 + Earlm 2>1>
<
2?+11 AXXALF\: CKKFD@I D@XKXMG CGIAC QWG\XDK@\
\arkj Fwear Raxm
1
 Ab|xralx
Hwrd`i xmg 2?+11 Ewebad axxalf Ajeac Fa|ab ya| d`xgrlg~xgh acdvg bt xmgEwebad ~kcdlg a`h xmg la~xwrg ko a okrgdi` xgrrkrd|x cgh xk a` d`xrdlaxg cgiac baxxcg a|Ewebad ~kcdlg odcgh a` 11#2=> ~aig lmarig|mggx. Xmg OBD odcgh okwr Lmarig|mggx| d`xmg |aeg la|g d` a W\ lkwrx. Xmg d`vg|xdiaxdvg eglma`d|e ahk~xgh bt xmg W\ a`h D`hdaokr 2?+11 axxalf| la|g d`|~drg hdoogrg`x hgirgg ko lk`odhg`lg. A| okr xmg xgrrkrd|x lrdeg#ewlm d| |adh okr dx| ~rgvg`xdk`# a`h gvg` xmg Aoima` Yar aiad`|x Xacdba` d| |adh xk bgowxwrg |glwrdxt ko xmg W\ a`h xmg ykrch. Bwx ~w`d|meg`x ydxmkwx oadc d| vgrt ewlmde~krxa`x okr ~rgvg`xdk`. Xmg cgiac xrdac ko xmg Ewebad la|g d| hdoogrg`x a| cgiac|xrwlxwrg ko lkw`x| ko d`hdlxeg`x ko |wlm a lrdeg ymdlm arg xmkwimx xk bg a~~cdgh d`krhd`art lrdeg ymdlm kllwr d` krhd`art cdog# hkg| `kx a~~rk~rdaxgct rgocglx alxwac |kldacrgacdxt ko xmg lrdeg# ko dx)| iravdxt# ko dx)| |xrwlxwrac ymkcg# ko galm lrded`ac)| rkcg. Mky
1
^mH \arkj# Fwear Raxm d| Rg|garlm A||kldaxg# Mk|gd W`dvgr|dxt# Xkftk# Ja~a`. Ahhrg||d` Ja~a`: Hr. \arkj Fwear Raxm # L+k % ^rko. Lmdfafk XATA# ^k|x Lkhg: 1??%>>><# 1%28%18%1>8# Fkg`jd%ed`aed# \wid`aed%fw# Xkftk# Ja~a`. Ahhrg|| d` D`hda: Hr. \arkj FwearRaxm# 8<# Bramea~wxra Mk|xgc# Jayamarcac @gmrw W`dvgr|dxt# @gy Hgcmd “ 11>>?9# D`hda#Geadc: |arkj1|arkjNieadc.lke.

Activity (5)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
Snehal Patil liked this
schambless liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->