ClaassenResearch.com Page
2
of
9How is this market different than past markets?
When I first spoke of the coming secular bear market in the very late 1990’s, a period whenan investor’s idea of diversification was owning Intel, Cisco, AOL and Akamai in three differentaccounts, I was greeted with the verbal equivalent of tomatoes. I believe by now we can all agreethat the current environment is very different than a secular bull market. Oureconomic growth isfragile and our markets are not experiencing a prolonged period of earnings and P/E expansion,driven from an historical low base, as required for a multi decade advance.Our current market is also not driven by typical business growth. Yes, the percent returnsof fundamental valuations are up from last year’s very deep trough, but still far shy of past yearsand the levels needed to support employment growth. (The Fed is not keeping rates low forentertainment purposes.)The gorilla in the room is the Federal Reserve. We all know this cyclical bull market isliquidity driven. Theunprecedentedlevel of U.S. and global liquidity pumped into the economymake this cyclical bull market “different” than the bull markets that ended in 1929, 1968, 1987,2000 or even 2007. As the dissenting FOMC Governor Thomas Hoenig is trying to warn,somehow somewhere, excess liquidity always finds its way into the markets. We have seenthis inJapan since 1993as each cyclical bull market is fueled by a new round of quantitative easing, thencomes to an abrupt halt. The same can said for China’s Shanghai Index,which advanced 108%from October ’08 to August ’09.
As a side note
: After a 108.76% return off its October ‘08low, the Shanghai Index is off about 18% from its August ’09 high and has struggled in a roughly sideways pattern sincethen.While many investors view the weak performance as a leading economic indicator for the US,another possibility is that China’s equity market is enduring the same “investor rotation” as did theUS market in 2000. Readers may remember that US equities peaked in 2000 as the internetbubble burst,and the investment of choice switched from equities to real estate. Money flowingfrom the equity market drove the real estate bubble higher for another five to seven years(depending on your local). Although the US economy did experience a relatively minor recessionfrom March through November 2001, it wasn’t until the real estate bubble burst that the economyfell into the current Great Recession. With China’s rising real estate pricesand declining equities,it appears to me that a similar scenario is unfolding; money is simply moving from equities intoreal estate. But, that is a discussion we can detailat another time.
How is this market similar to past markets?
If wedefine the current environment as a cyclical bull market within a secular bear trend,what are the similar time periods with which we can compare?Certainly, Japan’s equity market from 1992 is filled with liquidity driven cyclical bullmarkets to which we might compare the current market rally. Unfortunately, we have very littledata other than price and volume. Thus, almost all we can say is Japan’s bull marketsduring the
Add a Comment