!

REPRINTFROM

!MERICAN3CIENTIST
THEMAGAZINEOF3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY

4HISREPRINTISPROVIDEDFORPERSONALANDNONCOMMERCIALUSE&ORANYOTHERUSEPLEASESENDAREQUESTTO0ERMISSIONS
!MERICAN3CIENTIST0/"OX2ESEARCH4RIANGLE0ARK.#53!ORBYELECTRONICMAILTOPERMS AMSCIORG
©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETYANDOTHERRIGHTSHOLDERS

©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY2EPRODUCTION
 !MERICAN 3CIENTIST 6OLUME 
WITHPERMISSIONONLY#ONTACTPERMS AMSCIORG
1FSDFQUVBM
1MFBTVSF
BOE
UIF
#SBJO
!NOVELTHEORYEXPLAINSWHYTHEBRAINCRAVESINFORMATION
ANDSEEKSITTHROUGHTHESENSES

)RVING"IEDERMANAND%DWARD!6ESSEL

! S YOU PICKED UP THIS MAGAZINE

AND LEAFED THROUGH IT JUST NOW
YOUR EYE LIKELY WAS DRAWN TO CERTAIN
A SIMPLE PREFERENCE FOR CERTAIN TYPES
OF STIMULI THEN PROCEEDS TO MORE SO
PHISTICATED LEVELS OF PERCEPTION AND
4HE*OYSOF/PIOIDS
4HEREISAMPLEEVIDENCETHATTHEBRAIN
IS WIRED FOR PLEASURE )NDEED HUMAN
IMAGES WORDS OR PHRASES $ID YOU COGNITION THAT DRAW ON ASSOCIATIONS BEINGSHAVEBEENSEARCHINGFORCHEMI
MERELY GLANCE AT A SERIES OF UNRELATED THEBRAINMAKESWITHPREVIOUSEXPERI CALSUBSTANCESTOSTIMULATETHESENEURAL
PICTURES AS YOU TURNED THE PAGESˆOR ENCES7HENTHEHUNGERBECOMESEVEN SYSTEMSFORTHOUSANDSOFYEARS!MONG
DID YOU STOP TO EXAMINE ONE CLOSELY MODERATELY STARVED BOREDOM SETS IN THE MOST REWARDING SUBSTANCES EVER
ANDREADITSCAPTION)FSOWHATCOM #ONSIDERFOREXAMPLETHELASTTIMEYOU DISCOVERED ARE COMPOUNDS DERIVED
PELLED YOU TO WANT MORE 7HY IS IT ENJOYED STARING AT A BLANK WALL OR LIS FROM THE OPIUM POPPY (ISTORICAL RE
THATYOUFINDTHEEXPERIENCEOFLOOKING TENING TO A REPETITIVE AIRPORT SECURITY CORDS OF THE POPPYS CULTIVATION DATE
ATSOMEILLUSTRATIONSORTEXTSMOREEN ANNOUNCEMENT BACK TO  BC IN LOWER -ESOPOTA
GAGINGORREWARDINGTHANOTHERS )N OUR VIEW INFOVORE BEHAVIOR IS MIAWHERETHE3UMERIANSREFERREDTOIT
)F YOURE BEGINNING TO SUSPECT THAT ACTIVATEDONLYWHENOTHERMOTIVESARE ASHULGILTHEhJOYPLANTv(OWEVERTHE
THIS ARTICLE IS NOTHING BUT A MARKET NOTENGAGED7HENPEOPLEARETRYING ACTIVEINGREDIENTOFOPIUMMORPHINE
ING SURVEY RELAX
4HESE QUESTIONS ARE TO SATISFY A NEED FOR FOOD ARE AVOID WASNOTIDENTIFIEDUNTILTHEEARLYPART
IN FACT MATTERS OF SERIOUS INTEREST FOR ING HARM OR ARE OTHERWISE INVOLVED OF THE TH CENTURY (EROIN A MORE
NEUROSCIENTISTSSTUDYINGCOGNITIONAND IN SOME GOAL ORIENTED BEHAVIOR THEN POTENT OPIATE WAS SYNTHESIZED FROM
PERCEPTION!LLOFUSHAVEFELTTHEPLEA THEINFOVOROUSINSTINCTSTAKEALESSAC MORPHINEJUSTAFEWDECADESLATER
SUREOFACQUIRINGINFORMATIONˆAVIEW TIVE ROLE 4HE INFOVORE SYSTEM IS DE !FTER MILLENNIA OF EXPERIMENTATION
OFADRAMATICLANDSCAPEACONVERSATION SIGNEDTOMAXIMIZETHERATEATWHICH ITSQUITEOBVIOUSTHATOPIATESALTERTHE
WITHAFRIENDOREVENAGOODMAGAZINE PEOPLEACQUIREKNOWLEDGEUNDERCON BRAINS ACTIVITY BUT IT WASNT UNTIL THE
ARTICLE CAN ALL BE PROFOUNDLY GRATIFY DITIONS WHERE THERE MAY BE NO IM EARLY S THAT SCIENTISTS UNDERSTOOD
ING "UT WHY IS THIS SO 7HAT MAKES MEDIATENEEDFORTHEINFORMATION/F WHYTHISISSO)N3OLOMON3NYDER
THESEEXPERIENCESSOPLEASURABLE COURSETHEKNOWLEDGEOBTAINEDMAY AND#ANDACE0ERTATTHE*OHNS(OPKINS
7E BELIEVE THAT THE ENJOYMENT OF HAVE SOME PRACTICAL VALUE IN THE FU 5NIVERSITY3CHOOLOF-EDICINEDISCOV
SUCH EXPERIENCES IS DEEPLY CONNECTED TURE"UTEVENIFTHEREISNODIRECTUSE EREDTHATOPIATESTARGETCERTAINMOLECU
TO AN INNATE HUNGER FOR INFORMATION OF THE NEW INFORMATION THERE IS IN LARRECEPTORSLOCATEDONTHESURFACESOF
(UMANBEINGSAREDESIGNEDTOBEhIN EVOLUTIONARYTERMSADAPTIVEVALUETO BRAINCELLS7HENOPIATESBINDTOTHESE
FOVORESv)TSACRAVINGTHATBEGINSWITH ITS ACQUISITION 0EOPLE GENERALLY PER OPIOIDRECEPTORSTHEYMODULATETHEACTIV
CEIVE THOSE WHO ARE KNOWLEDGEABLE ITY OF THE CELLS .EUROBIOLOGISTS HAVE
AS BEING MORE INTELLIGENT A TRAIT THAT SINCEDESCRIBEDATLEASTTHREEMAJORSUB
)RVING"IEDERMANISTHE(AROLD7$ORNSIFE
IS STRONGLY CORRELATED WITH MATE SE TYPESOFOPIOIDRECEPTORSIDENTIFIEDBY
0ROFESSOROF.EUROSCIENCEINTHE$EPARTMENTSOF
0SYCHOLOGYAND#OMPUTER3CIENCEANDTHEDIREC
LECTIONINEVERYHUMANCULTURETHATS THE 'REEK LETTERS MU DELTA AND KAPPA
TOROFTHE)MAGE5NDERSTANDING,ABORATORYAT BEENSTUDIED 4HE MU OPIOID RECEPTORS READILY BIND
THE5NIVERSITYOF3OUTHERN#ALIFORNIA(ISCUR )F INFOVORE BEHAVIOR IS SO VALUABLE MORPHINEANDAREALSOACTIVATEDBYEN
RENTRESEARCHINTERESTSSPANTHEDOMAINOFVISUAL TO OUR SPECIES ONE WOULD EXPECT THE DOGENOUSMORPHINE LIKESUBSTANCES)N
COGNITIONWITHEMPHASISONTHEREPRESENTATION BRAIN TO HAVE CELLULAR AND MOLECULAR  THESE ENDOMORPHINS WERE ISOLATED
OFSHAPEFOROBJECTFACEANDSCENERECOGNITION MECHANISMS THAT ENCOURAGE THE AC IN BRAIN TISSUE BY SCIENTISTS AT 4ULANE
%DWARD!6ESSELISAPOSTDOCTORALFELLOWATTHE QUISITION OF INFORMATION 7E BELIEVE 5NIVERSITY3CHOOLOF-EDICINE
#ENTERFOR.EURAL3CIENCEAT.EW9ORK5NIVER WEHAVEIDENTIFIEDSUCHASYSTEMAND .OT SURPRISINGLY MU OPIOID RECEP
SITY(ISCURRENTRESEARCHCONTINUESTOINVESTIGATE ITISASSOCIATEDWITHAREWARDNETWORK TORS ARE GENERALLY LOCALIZED TO PARTS OF
VISUALPREFERENCEAESTHETICSINFORMATIONFORAG
THATRELIESONTHEBRAINSNATURALOPI THECENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMTHATAREIM
INGANDSCENEPERCEPTIONTHROUGHBEHAVIORALAND
BRAIN IMAGINGSTUDIES!DDRESSFOR"IEDERMAN
OIDS(EREWEPRESENTAHYPOTHESISFOR PLICATEDINTHEMODULATIONOFPAINAND
$EPARTMENTSOF0SYCHOLOGYAND#OMPUTER3CI HOWTHISMECHANISMWORKS!LTHOUGH REWARD )N THE EARLY S HOWEVER
ENCE5NIVERSITYOF3OUTHERN#ALIFORNIA(EDCO OUR MODEL PERTAINS TO THE BRAINS VI -ICHAEL,EWISATTHE.ATIONAL)NSTITUTE
.EUROSCIENCES"UILDING2OOM-# SUAL SYSTEM WE BELIEVE THAT SIMILAR OF -ENTAL (EALTH AND HIS COLLEAGUES
7ATT7AY,OS!NGELES#!n MECHANISMSMAYBEINVOLVEDINOTHER DISCOVERED THESE RECEPTORS IN A PART OF
)NTERNETBIEDER USCEDU SENSESASWELL THE MACAQUE MONKEY CEREBRAL CORTEX

©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY2EPRODUCTION
WWWAMERICANSCIENTISTORG -AYn*UNE
WITHPERMISSIONONLY#ONTACTPERMS AMSCIORG
 +EN2EDDING#ORBIS
&IGURE0EOPLEDERIVEGREATPLEASUREFROMVIEWINGADRAMATICANDCHANGINGVISTA3UCHSCENESMAYSTIMULATEAREWARDSTRUCTUREINTHEBRAIN
THATSEEKSINFORMATIONTHROUGHTHESENSES4HEAUTHORSPROPOSETHATTHISSYSTEMMIGHTWORKBYEMPLOYINGTHEOPIOIDRECEPTORSTHATMODULATE
PLEASURE4HEYHAVETESTEDTHISHYPOTHESISBYUSINGFUNCTIONALMAGNETIC RESONANCEIMAGINGF-2) TOOBSERVEACTIVITYINTHEBRAINSOFSUBJECTS
LOOKINGATAVARIETYOFVISUALSTIMULI

THATISINVOLVEDINPROCESSINGVISUALIN FORASIMILARGRADIENTINTHEHOMOLOGOUS TEMPORAL CORTEX WHICH INTEGRATE LOCAL

FORMATION7HATSESPECIALLYINTRIGUING HUMANAREAS4HERECEPTORSARESPARSEST INFORMATION TO DETECT SURFACES OBJECTS
IS THEIR FINDING THAT THE RECEPTORS ARE INTHEEARLYSTAGESOFTHISPATHWAYTHE FACES AND PLACES CONTAIN GREATER NUM
DISTRIBUTEDINAGRADIENTTHATGRADUALLY SO CALLED6TO6AREASWHEREANIM BERS OF OPIOID RECEPTORS 4HE RECEPTORS
INCREASESINDENSITYALONGTHESO CALLED AGEISPROCESSEDASLOCALBITSOFCONTOUR AREDENSESTINTHELATERSTAGESOFRECOGNI
VENTRALVISUALPATHWAYWHICHISINVOLVED COLOR AND TEXTURE )NTERMEDIATE STAGES TIONINTHEPARAHIPPOCAMPALCORTEXAND
INTHERECOGNITIONOFANOBJECTORASCENE OF VISUAL PROCESSING SUCH AS THE LATER RHINALCORTEXWHEREVISUALINFORMATION
3UBSEQUENT WORK HAS FOUND EVIDENCE AL OCCIPITAL AREA AND VENTRAL OCCIPITO ENGAGESOURMEMORIES

©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY2EPRODUCTION
 !MERICAN 3CIENTIST 6OLUME 
WITHPERMISSIONONLY#ONTACTPERMS AMSCIORG
 7HY WOULD A MECHANISM THATS IN
VOLVED IN REDUCING PAIN AND PROVID OCCIPITAL
ING REWARD BE ASSOCIATED WITH A SYS LOBE
TEM CONCERNED WITH PROCESSING VISUAL
INFORMATION &URTHERMORE WHY IS THE LATERAL
GREATEST DENSITY OF RECEPTORS FOUND IN OCCIPITAL
THEPARAHIPPOCAMPALCORTEXASO CALLED CORTEX
ASSOCIATIONAREA7ETHINKTHATTHEMU
OPIOIDRECEPTORSARETHEKEYTOTHEPLEA 6
SURESWEDERIVEFROMACQUIRINGNEWIN
FORMATIONTHEPLEASUREWEHOPEYOURE
DERIVINGFROMREADINGTHISARTICLE
#ONSIDER THE FUNCTION OF ASSOCIATION
6
AREAS4HEYAREREPOSITORIESFORBOTHSE
MANTICMEMORIESSUCHASFACTSANDCON
CEPTS AND EPISODIC MEMORIES SUCH AS PARAHIPPOCAMPAL
AUTOBIOGRAPHICALEXPERIENCESINCLUDING CORTEX
THETIMEPLACEANDEMOTIONSASSOCIATED 6
WITHANEVENT 4HESEAREASAREACTIVATED TEMPORAL
WHENTHEBRAINTRIESTOINTERPRETWHATITS LOBE VENTRALOCCIPITOTEMPORAL
SEEINGORHEARING)FASTIMULUSCONTAINS CORTEX CEREBELLUM
AGREATDEALOFINTERPRETABLEINFORMATION
IT SHOULD LEAD TO MORE NEURAL ACTIVITY EYE
INTHEASSOCIATIONAREASANDHENCETOA
OPTIC
GREATER RELEASE OF ENDOMORPHINS AND NERVE
INCREASED STIMULATION OF MU OPIOID RE RHINAL
OPTIC
CEPTORS!S MORE OPIOID RECEPTORS ARE CORTEX
TRACT
STIMULATED THERE SHOULD BE A BOOST IN
THEPLEASANTEFFECTSASSOCIATEDWITHOPI PARAHIPPOCAMPAL PARAHIPPOCAMPAL
OIDS3OFOREXAMPLEAVISUALSTIMULUS CORTEX GYRUS
THAT ELICITS MANY EPISODIC OR SEMANTIC
MEMORIESSHOULDBEMOREPLEASINGOR
MORE INTERESTING THAN A STIMULUS THAT
BRINGSFORTHFEWERMENTALASSOCIATIONS
(UMAN BEINGS ALSO PREFER NOVELTY
&OR EXAMPLE ALTHOUGH ONE MAY THOR
OUGHLYENJOYAPARTICULARCONVERSATION
THE SAME CONVERSATION A SECOND TIME
AROUNDWOULDBEBANAL4HESAMECAN
BESAIDFORANYNUMBEROFVISUALSTIMU #O3
LATIONSˆTHEVISUALPLEASUREEXPERIENCED
ON FIRST SEEING A PAINTING A MOVIE OR
VENTRAL FUSIFORM
EVENAMAGNIFICENTVISTALIKETHE'RAND GYRUS
OCCIPITOTEMPORAL
#ANYONMAYBEUNREPEATABLE(OWDOES CORTEX
OURHYPOTHESISACCOUNTFORTHEREDUCTION
INREWARDWHENASTIMULUSISREPEATED COLLATERAL
LATERAL
7ETHINKTHATAPHENOMENONCALLED OCCIPITAL
SULCUS
COMPETITIVE LEARNING MAY BE INVOLVED AREA 66
,ETSASSUMETHATANINITIALPRESENTATION 660
6 LINGUAL
OF A STIMULUS PATTERN ACTIVATES A LARGE 6 GYRUS
POPULATION OF NEURONS ! RELATIVELY &IGURE7ITHINTHEBRAINTHEVENTRALVISUALPATHWAYTOPREDARROWS ISINVOLVEDINTHEREC
SMALLNUMBEROFTHESECELLSARESTRONGLY OGNITIONOFANOBJECTORASCENE%ARLYSTAGESOFVISUALPROCESSINGINAREAS6TO6 ANALYZEAN
ACTIVATED WHILE MUCH LARGER NUMBERS IMAGESCONTOURSCOLORSANDTEXTURES)NTERMEDIATESTAGESTHELATERALOCCIPITALAREAANDVENTRAL
ARE MODERATELY OR WEAKLY ENGAGED OCCIPITO TEMPORALCORTEXOR6/4 INTEGRATELOCALINFORMATIONTODETECTSURFACESOBJECTSFACES
/NE MODEL OF NEURAL PLASTICITY CALLED ANDPLACES7ITHINTHE6/4AREGIONWITHINTHECOLLATERALSULCUS#O3 RESPONDSSTRONGLYTO
(EBBIANLEARNINGHOLDSTHATTHESTRENGTH IMAGESOFPLACESSUCHASBUILDINGSHOUSESANDVISTAS,ATERSTAGESOFRECOGNITIONINAREASSUCH
AS THE PARAHIPPOCAMPAL CORTEX AND RHINAL CORTEX ARE ACTIVATED WHEN THE BRAIN INTERPRETS THE
OF A SYNAPTIC CONNECTION BETWEEN TWO
STIMULUSINTHECONTEXTOFSTOREDMEMORIES3URPRISINGLYTHESEVISUALAREASALSOCONTAINMU
NEURONSINCREASESWITHTHEREPETITIONOF
OPIOIDRECEPTORSBOTTOMBLACKDOTS WHICHAREINVOLVEDINTHEMODULATIONOFPAINANDPLEA
ASTIMULUSSOTHATITBECOMESPROGRES SUREINOTHERPARTSOFTHEBRAIN4HEYARESPARSEINTHEEARLIERSTAGESANDGROWINCREASINGLYDENSE
SIVELY EASIER FOR A PRESYNAPTIC NEURON INTHELATERSTAGES!CCORDINGTOTHEAUTHORSHYPOTHESISVISUALSTIMULITHATCONTAINAGREATDEAL
TO ACTIVATE A POSTSYNAPTIC NEURON ON OFINTERPRETABLEINFORMATIONSHOULDACTIVATEMANYOPIOIDRECEPTORSINTHELATERSTAGESANDSO
SUBSEQUENT OCCASIONS 4HE GREATER THE PROVIDETHEGREATESTPLEASURE!TTOPEDGESOFVENTRALAREASAREPROJECTEDONTOTHELATERALSURFACE
ACTIVITYOFTHEPOSTSYNAPTICNEURONTHE ANDDENOTEDBYDASHES%XACTLOCATIONSOFALLAREASMAYDIFFERFROMONEINDIVIDUALTOANOTHER

©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY2EPRODUCTION
WWWAMERICANSCIENTISTORG -AYn*UNE
WITHPERMISSIONONLY#ONTACTPERMS AMSCIORG
 FIRSTPRESENTATIONOFINPUT GREATER THE INCREASE IN THE STRENGTH OF
 " THECONNECTION
(OWEVERSTRONGLYACTIVATEDNEURONS
 # ALSOINHIBITTHOSENEURONSTHATAREONLY
WEAKLYENGAGEDSOTHEREPETITIONOFA
STIMULUS REDUCES THE ACTIVITY OF THESE
!  $ CELLS 7ITH REPEATED PRESENTATION OF A
PATTERNONLYAFEWNEURONSTHOSEWITH
 % THESTRONGESTCONNECTIONS WILLRESPOND
WHILETHERESTRESPONDWEAKLYIFATALL
)FMOSTOFTHEINITIALACTIVITYISGENERAT
 & EDBYNEURONSTHATWILLBESUBSEQUENTLY
INHIBITEDTHENREPETITIONRESULTSINANET
REDUCTIONOFNEURALACTIVITY/NEADVAN
SECONDPRESENTATIONOFINPUT TAGEOFCOMPETITIVELEARNINGISTHATTHE
 " INHIBITEDNEURONSARENOWFREETOCODE
n
FOROTHERSTIMULUSPATTERNS
 # 3O OUR HYPOTHESIS PROPOSES THAT
n THERATEOFENDOMORPHINRELEASEINTHE
PARAHIPPOCAMPAL CORTEX DETERMINES
!  $ ATLEASTPARTIALLYTHEHUMANPREFERENCE
FOREXPERIENCESTHATAREBOTHNOVELBE
n CAUSE THEY HAVE YET TO UNDERGO COM
 % PETITIVE INTERACTIONS AND RICHLY INTER
n PRETABLEBECAUSESUCHPATTERNSWOULD
 & INITIALLYACTIVATEANABUNDANTSETOFAS
SOCIATIONSINBRAINAREASTHATMANIFEST
&IGURE#OMPETITIVELEARNINGBYNEURONSINVISUALASSOCIATIONAREASMAYEXPLAINWHYPEOPLE DENSEOPIOIDRECEPTORS 
PREFERNOVELVISUALSTIMULI4HEFIRSTPRESENTATIONOFASTIMULUSTOP MAYTRIGGERTHEACTIVITY 2EADERSFAMILIARWITHTHENEUROCHEM
OFMANYNEURONS"n& BUTTOVARYINGDEGREESSOMENEURONS$ MAYBEENGAGEDMORETHAN ISTRY OF OPIOIDS WHICH USUALLY ACT AS
OTHERS/NREPEATEDPRESENTATIONOFASTIMULUSBOTTOM ASTRONGLYENGAGEDNEURON$ INHIB INHIBITORYNEUROTRANSMITTERSMAYWON
ITSTHEWEAKLYACTIVATEDNEURONSRESULTINGINANETREDUCTIONINTHENUMBEROFACTIVENEURONS DERHOWOPIOIDACTIVITYRESULTSINPLEA
)FTHESENEURONSRELEASEMU OPIOIDSORHAVEMU OPIOIDRECEPTORSONTHEIRSURFACESADECREASE SURE)TTURNSOUTTHATINSEVERALSYSTEMS
INTHEIRACTIVITYSHOULDREDUCETHEPLEASUREASSOCIATEDWITHTHEREPEATEDSTIMULUS
WHERE NEURAL CONNECTIVITY HAS BEEN
STUDIEDNEURONSWITHMU OPIOIDRECEP
TORSMAKESYNAPTICCONNECTIONSWITHSO
CALLED'!"!ERGICNEURONSWHICHRELEASE
THEINHIBITORYNEUROTRANSMITTERGAMMA
AMINOBUTYRICACID'!"! 4HUSTHEAC
TIVATIONOFMU OPIOIDSSERVESTOINHIBIT
THESEINHIBITORYNEURONS)TAPPEARSTHAT
MUCH OF THE BRAIN IS IMMERSED IN AN
INHIBITORY h'!"! BATHv WHICH PROB
ABLY SERVES TO PREVENT SEIZURES CAUSED
BYENTRAINEDOSCILLATIONSOFNEURONALAC
A B TIVITY4HERELEASEOFENDOMORPHINSIN
HIBITSTHELOCALRELEASEOF'!"!ANDSO
ALLOWSLOCALEXCITATIONTOBEPROPAGATED
WITHGREATERINTENSITYTOTHESUCCEEDING
STAGESOFINFORMATIONPROCESSING
4HECOMPLEXRESPONSETOAPLEASING
STIMULUS IS MEDIATED BY A VARIETY OF
COGNITIVE MOTOR AND HORMONAL PATH
WAYS 7E ARE NOT SURE WHAT THE NEXT
STAGES MIGHT BE BUT THEY MAY ULTI
MATELYINCREASETHERELEASEOFDOPAMINE
WITHINTHECORPUSSTRIATUMASTRUCTURE
C D DEEP IN THE BRAIN THAT IS IMPLICATED IN
&IGURE3CENESWITHTHEGREATESTAMOUNTOFNOVELINTERPRETABLEINFORMATIONSHOULDSTIMULATE THECONTROLOFMOVEMENTCOGNITIONAND
THE MOST ACTIVITY IN THE VISUAL ASSOCIATION AREAS AND SO PRODUCE THE MAXIMUM PERCEPTUAL HABIT LEARNING 4HE CORPUS STRIATUM IS
PLEASURE FOR THE VIEWER !CCORDING TO THE AUTHORS THEORY SCENES A B C AND D SHOULD ELICIT DIRECTLY CONNECTED TO THE VISUAL AREAS
PROGRESSIVELYGREATERACTIVITYINVISUALASSOCIATIONAREASSUCHASTHEPARAHIPPOCAMPALGYRUS AND ALSO TO THE HIPPOCAMPUS AMYG
%XCEPTWHERENOTEDIMAGESCOURTESYOFTHEAUTHORS DALA AND PREFRONTAL AREAS OF THE BRAIN

©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY2EPRODUCTION
 !MERICAN 3CIENTIST 6OLUME 
WITHPERMISSIONONLY#ONTACTPERMS AMSCIORG
ANYOFWHICHCOULDSERVEANINTERMEDI ESPECIALLYTHEPOSTERIORPORTION4HEAC TURESWEUSEDINOUREXPERIMENTSHAD
ARY ROLE IN REWARDING INFORMATION AC TIVITYINTHISAREAWASNOTTHERESULTOF AFEWTHINGSINCOMMON0REFERREDPIC
QUISITION WITH A NEUROCHEMICAL FRISSON A SIMPLE hFEED FORWARDv MECHANISM TURES OFTEN CONTAINED BROAD VIEWS OF
OFPLEASURE4HERELEASEOFDOPAMINEIN BECAUSEAREGIONINVOLVEDINTHEEARLY THE LANDSCAPE ESPECIALLY SCENES THAT
THECORPUSSTRIATUMISALSOBELIEVEDTO PROCESSING OF VISUAL INFORMATION THE PROVIDEDAHIDDENVANTAGEPOINTWHERE
BE INVOLVED IN THE CRAVINGS ASSOCIATED LATERALOCCIPITALAREASHOWEDITSGREAT ANOBSERVERCOULDVIEWTHETERRAINFROM
WITHDRUGADDICTION ESTACTIVITYWHENTHESUBJECTWASVIEW A PLACE OF REFUGE 3CENES WITH AN ELE
INGSCENESOFLOWPREFERENCE-OREOVER MENTOFMYSTERYWHERESOMETHINGWAS
4ESTINGWITH0ICTURES THE ACTIVITY IN A PORTION OF THE VENTRAL HAPPENINGORCOULDHAPPENWEREALSO
/URHYPOTHESISWOULDBEMERELYANOTH OCCIPITO TEMPORAL CORTEX CENTERED IN FAVORED -OREOVER NATURAL SETTINGS
ERSPECULATIONABOUTTHEBRAINIFITCOULD THECOLLATERALSULCUSANDADJACENTTOTHE WEREGENERALLYPREFERREDTOMAN MADE
NOT BE TESTED &ORTUNATELY THE TECHNOL PARAHIPPOCAMPALCORTEXDECLINEDWITH ENVIRONMENTS4HESEFACTORSACCOUNTED
OGY OF FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE EACH REPEATED PRESENTATION 4HIS DE FORABOUTPERCENTOFTHEVARIANCEIN
IMAGINGF-2) ALLOWSUSTOOBSERVETHE CLINEWITHREPETITIONTOOKPLACEFORALLOF AVERAGE RATINGS 4HEY ARE ALSO CONSIS
BRAINSRESPONSETOASTIMULUS!NF-2) THEIMAGESWHETHERTHEYWEREINITIALLY TENTWITHANTHROPOLOGICALEXPLANATIONS
SCANNER MEASURES THE FLOW OF BLOOD TO RATEDHIGHORLOWh%ARLYvVISUALAREAS WHICH SUGGEST THAT SUCH PREDILECTIONS
THEBRAINWITHAPRECISIONOFAFEWMILLI OFTHEBRAINSUCHAS6AND6DIDNOT ARISEFROMAPRIMITIVENEEDTOFINDTHE
METERSALLOWINGSCIENTISTSTOIDENTIFYRE SHOW A CONSISTENT DECLINE IN ACTIVITY BESTLOCATIONFORACAMPORAVILLAGE!
GIONSTHATAREUSINGSIGNIFICANTAMOUNTS WITHREPEATEDPRESENTATIONS HOUSEONAHILLTOPSTILLDEMANDSAPRE
OFOXYGENˆAMEASUREOFNEURALACTIVITY MIUMINTHEREALESTATEMARKET

7ITHF-2)WECANPRESENTASTIMULUSTO 4HE0SYCHOLOGYOF0LEASURE 7EALSOWISHTOEMPHASIZETHATPER
ASUBJECTWHILEOBSERVINGNEURALACTIVITY )T SHOULD NOT BE SURPRISING THAT THE CEPTUALPREFERENCESARISEFROMTHECON
IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE VENTRAL VISUAL BRAIN HAS INFORMATION ACQUISITION NECTIONS THE BRAIN MAKES WITH STORED
PATHWAY )F OUR HYPOTHESIS IS CORRECT MECHANISMS THAT REWARD US FOR LEARN INFORMATION4HATSBECAUSETHEBRAINS
hINTERESTINGvSTIMULISHOULDELICITGREATER INGABOUTTHEENVIRONMENT!SWEMEN ASSOCIATIONAREASHAVETHEGREATESTDEN
ACTIVITYINTHEVISUALASSOCIATIONAREASOF TIONEDEARLIERSUCHMECHANISMSWOULD SITY OF MU OPIOID RECEPTORS )N OTHER
THEBRAINSUCHASTHEPARAHIPPOCAMPAL HAVE AN EVOLUTIONARY ADVANTAGE 4HIS WORDS IT IS THE INTERPRETATION OF A VI
CORTEXBUTNOTNECESSARILYINTHOSEAREAS MAYEXPLAINWHYTHEHIGHLYRATEDPIC SUALPATTERNTHATLEADSTOTHEFEELINGSOF
INVOLVEDWITHTHEINITIALPROCESSINGFOR
VISUALINFORMATION
)N OUR EXPERIMENTS WE PRESENTED A
SERIES OF IMAGES DEPICTING REAL WORLD
SCENES TO A GROUP OF SUBJECTS WHOSE
BRAINSWERENOTOBSERVEDBYF-2)BUT
WHO WERE ASKED TO RATE THEIR RELATIVE
PREFERENCE FOR EACH PICTURE 4HE IM
AGES WERE PRESENTED SEVERAL TIMES TO
EACHSUBJECT7ITHEACHREPETITIONTHEIR
PREFERENCE FOR AN IMAGE DECLINED 4HE
SAME IMAGES WERE THEN SHOWN TO AN
OTHERGROUPOFSUBJECTSLYINGWITHINAN
F-2)SCANNER4HESESUBJECTSVIEWEDTHE
IMAGESPASSIVELYWITHOUTVOICINGTHEIR
PREFERENCES %ACH SCENE WAS PRESENTED
FOR ONESECONDAND THEN SHOWN AGAIN
AFTERTHESUBJECTVIEWEDANAVERAGEOF
OTHERSCENES4HEREWEREFIVEREPETITIONS
OFEACHSCENE)NORDERTOPROVIDECON
SISTENTCONTEXTFOREACHVIEWINGANDTO
PACETHEEXPERIMENTSOTHATANESTIMATE
OFEACHDISCRETEF-2)RESPONSECOULDBE
EXTRACTED WE INSERTED hBUFFERv IMAGES
STRATEGICALLYINTOEACHSEQUENCEWEALSO
CONTINUALLYINTRODUCEDNEWSCENESOVER
THE COURSE OF A SESSION SO THAT hFIRSTv
PRESENTATIONSOFIMAGESANDSUBSEQUENT
PRESENTATIONSWERESCATTEREDTHROUGHOUT
&IGURE  &UNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING F-2) ALLOWS SCIENTISTS TO OBSERVE THE
THEEXPERIMENT4HESETACTICSWEREALSO
BRAINSRESPONSETOAVISUALSTIMULUS)NONEEXPERIMENTSUBJECTSWEREPRESENTEDWITHASERIES
INTENDED TO REMOVE ANY CONFOUNDING OFSCENESSEE&IGURE THATWEREINDEPENDENTLYRATEDTOELICITDIFFERENTDEGREESOFPERCEPTUAL
EFFECTSOFTIMEWITHREPETITION PLEASURE3CENESTHATARERATEDASBEINGTHEMOSTPLEASURABLEORINTERESTING ELICITEDTHEGREAT
!S OUR THEORY PREDICTS SCENES THAT ESTACTIVITYINTHESUBJECTSVISUALASSOCIATIONAREASSEE&IGURE (EREASUBJECTISSHOWNJUST
WERERATEDHIGHLYELICITEDTHEMOSTF-2) BEFOREHERHEADENTERSTHEF-2)MACHINE3CENESAREPRESENTEDTHROUGHSPECIALIZEDGOGGLES
ACTIVITYINTHEPARAHIPPOCAMPALCORTEX WORNBYTHESUBJECT

©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY2EPRODUCTION
WWWAMERICANSCIENTISTORG -AYn*UNE
WITHPERMISSIONONLY#ONTACTPERMS AMSCIORG
&IGURE3CENESUSEDINF-2)EXPERIMENTSWEREINDEPENDENTLYRATEDBYSUBJECTSAShHIGHLYPREFERREDvTOPROW ORhNOTPREFERREDvBOTTOMROW 

PLEASURE 4HIS POINT IS NICELY ILLUSTRAT THEFAMILIARISPREFERREDTOTHEUNFAMIL BECOMES IMMEDIATELY SUBJECT TO COM
EDWITHTHEVISUALHUMOROFDROODLES IARSEEMSTOCONTRADICTOURHYPOTHESIS PETITIVELEARNINGWHICHREDUCESENDO
WHICH WERE POPULAR SEVERAL DECADES AND OUR RESULTS (OWEVER WE BELIEVE MORPHINRELEASEONTHENEXTEXPOSURE
AGO &IGURE   "Y ITSELF A DROODLE IS A THATTHEKEYHEREISTHESUBJECTSABILITY )N OTHER WORDS THE TIME COURSE OF
SIMPLE PATTERN THAT ELICITS LITTLE IN THE TOUNDERSTANDTHESTIMULUS&OREXAM PERCEPTUALANDCOGNITIVEPLEASURECAN
WAY OF A POSITIVE EMOTIONAL RESPONSE PLEASONESTRUGGLESTOCOMPREHENDA BEDESCRIBEDASANINVERTED5 SHAPED
2EADING THE DROODLES CAPTION MAKES NEW IDEA THERE IS INCREASED PLEASURE FUNCTION 4HE MERE EXPOSURE EFFECT
ITFUNNYBECAUSETHEREADERACTIVATESA WITH REPEATED EXPOSURE WHICH PEAKS SHOULD BE CONFINED TO THE RELATIVELY
TRAINOFASSOCIATIONSTHATRECONCILEWHAT AT WHAT HAS BEEN CALLED THE hCLICKv BRIEF ASCENDING INITIAL PORTION OF THIS
ISOTHERWISEAMEANINGLESSPATTERN OF COMPREHENSION )N OUR VIEW THAT FUNCTION )NSOFAR AS THE VAST RANGE OF
7HAT ABOUT THE HUMAN PREFERENCE CLICKCORRESPONDSTOTHERELEASEOFEN OUREXPERIENCESAREUNDERSTOODASTHEY
FORNOVELTY4HISISSUEISALITTLEMORE DOMORPHINS IN THE ASSOCIATION AREAS HAPPENTHEPHENOMENONOFINCREASED
COMPLICATED THAN ONE MIGHT EXPECT AS THE BRAIN MAKES RICH CONNECTIONS PREFERENCE WITH EXPOSURE SHOULD BE
&ORONETHINGTHEREAPPEARTOBESOME WITH STORED INFORMATION (ABITUATION THEEXCEPTIONRATHERTHANTHERULE
COUNTEREXAMPLES 7HAT PSYCHOLOGISTS AND DECLINE IN PREFERENCE MAY SET IN 7ESHOULDADDTHATTHETIMECOURSE
CALL THE MERE EXPOSURE EFFECT IN WHICH AFTERWARD AS THE ASSOCIATIVE ACTIVITY OF COGNITIVE PLEASURE MAY BE SOME
WHAT PROTRACTED FOR CHILDREN! CHILD
 MAYWISHTOHEARTHESAMESTORYREAD
TO HER OVER AND OVER AGAIN MUCH TO
THE CHAGRIN OF AN ADULT READER  EVEN
SIGNALCHANGEPERCENT

TOTHEPOINTWHERESECTIONSOFTHESTORY
 ARE MEMORIZED VERBATIM (OWEVER
WHEN THE YOUNGSTER IS QUESTIONED
ABOUT THE STORYˆFOR EXAMPLE WHY A
PARTICULAR CHARACTER ACTED IN A CERTAIN
 WAYˆTHECHILDOFTENREVEALSALACKOF
COMPREHENSION )TS ONLY AFTER A CHILD
FULLYUNDERSTANDSTHEPOINTOFTHESTORY
THATSHETIRESOFHEARINGITAGAIN4HIS
 MAYBEANALOGOUSTOANADULTSEXPE
     RIENCE OF MASTERING CHALLENGING SUB
EXPOSURE JECTMATTER4HEPAYOFFISINTHECLICKOF
COMPREHENSION HOWEVER DIFFICULT THE
&IGURE!CTIVITYINTHEVISUALASSOCIATIONAREASOFTHEBRAINISEVIDENTINANF-2)IMAGELEFT
WHENASUBJECTISVIEWINGASCENETHATWASPERCEIVEDASBEINGPLEASURABLE(EREASTRONGSIG PATHTOTHATPOINT
NALCOLOREDREGIONS ISEVIDENTINPARTSOFTHEPARAHIPPOCAMPALGYRUSANDTHEFUSIFORMGYRUS )T MAY ALSO BE THE CASE THAT SOME
4HESIGNALDECREASESINSTRENGTHAVERAGECHANGEFROMBASELINERIGHT ASTHESUBJECTISEXPOSED CHILDHOODBEHAVIORDOESNOTENGAGETHE
TOREPEATEDVIEWINGSOFTHEIMAGE4HISISCONSISTENTWITHTHEIDEATHATCOMPETITIVENEURONAL REWARD SYSTEM CONSIDERED HERE 6IDEO
LEARNINGPLAYSAROLEINTHEHUMANPREFERENCEFORNOVELTY GAMES ARE REPLETE WITH REPETITIVE PER

©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY2EPRODUCTION
 !MERICAN 3CIENTIST 6OLUME 
WITHPERMISSIONONLY#ONTACTPERMS AMSCIORG
 4ALLFELLOW0RESS
A B C
&IGURE$ROODLESILLUSTRATETHENOTIONTHATTHEPLEASUREOFAVISUALPATTERNDEPENDSONITSINTERPRETABILITY"YITSELFADROODLEISASIMPLE
PATTERNTHATDOESNOTELICITMUCHOFARESPONSEBUTREADINGTHEDROODLESCAPTIONMAKESITAMUSINGBECAUSETHEREADERACTIVATESASSOCIA
TIONSTHATRECONCILEWHATISOTHERWISEAMEANINGLESSPATTERN#APTIONSFORTHESEDROODLESBYARTIST2OGER0RICEMIGHTREADASFOLLOWSAFOUR
ELEPHANTSSNIFFINGANORANGEBANEARLYBIRDCATCHINGAVERYSTRONGWORMANDCAMANINAMAILBOXSIGNALINGALEFTTURN

CEPTUALINPUTSTHATSEEMTOBEENDLESSLY THEPRIMARYAUDITORYCORTEXANDDENS SION WITH INFORMATION /UR PRELIMI

AMUSING TO YOUNG PEOPLE 7E SUSPECT ER IN THE SECONDARY AUDITORY CORTEX NARYWORKSUGGESTSTHATTHEQUESTFOR
THATCHILDRENCANTOLERATETHEREPETITION )N THE EARLY S THE 3TANFORD 5NI
KNOWLEDGE CAN NEVER BE SATEDˆAS
BECAUSE THEY ARE REWARDED WITH EVER
VERSITY PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGIST!VRAM LONG AS MU
OPIOID RECEPTORS REMAIN
INCREASINGSCORESUNTILTHEGAMEISMAS
'OLDSTEIN REPORTED THAT PEOPLE WHO UNBOUNDINTHEHUMANBRAIN
TERED )T WOULD BE RARE FOR SOMEONE TO NORMALLYEXPERIENCEDhCHILLSvWHILELIS

SEEK THE REPETITIVE STIMULUS OF A GAME TENINGTOCERTAINSTIRRINGPIECESOFMU
"IBLIOGRAPHY
WITHOUTHAVINGACCESSTOTHECONTROLLER
SIC DID NOT HAVE THE SAME SENSATIONS !LREJA--3HANABROUGH7,IUAND#,E

)NGENERALMANYREPETITIVEACTIVITIESEX
WHENTHEYRECEIVEDTHEDRUGNALOXONE RANTH/PIOIDSSUPPRESS)03#SINNEU

PRESSEDDURINGCHILDHOODMAYSERVETO A MU
OPIOID ANTAGONIST THAT PREVENTS RONSOFTHERATMEDIALSEPTUMDIAGONALBAND
OF"ROCA)NVOLVEMENTOFM
OPIOIDRECEPTORS
BUILD MOTOR SKILLS OR IMPROVE PERFOR
ENDOMORPHINS FROM BINDING TO THEIR ANDSEPTOHIPPOCAMPAL'!"!ERGICNEURONS
MANCERATHERTHANINCREASEKNOWLEDGE RECEPTORS 3UCH OBSERVATIONS SUGGEST *OURNALOF.EUROSCIENCEn
/UR HYPOTHESIS ALSO SUGGESTS THAT
THERE IS A PREFERRED RATE OF PRESENTING
INFORMATIONTHATMAYCORRESPONDTOTHE
OPIOIDRECEPTORSINTHEAUDITORY
RELEASEOFENDOMORPHINS0EOPLETYPICAL
THATATTHEVERYLEASTTHEPLEASURESWE 'OLDSTEIN!4HRILLSINRESPONSETOMUSIC
ASSOCIATEWITHSOUNDSMAYBEMEDIATED AND OTHER STIMULI 0HYSIOLOGICAL 0SYCHOLOGY
BYMU
n
CORTEX 7HETHER SIMILAR MECHANISMS (IRSCH * 2 + +IM . 2 2ELKIN * 6ICTOR
LYEXPERIENCEANAVERSIONTOPERCEPTUAL ARE INVOLVED IN TOUCH TASTE AND SMELL +
-,EE$2-ORENO3+ALIK2,$E
,A0AZ.2UBINAND23HAPLEY%XTRA

INPUTS THAT ARE PRESENTED MUCH MORE REMAINSTOBESEEN
STRIATELOCIFORTHEPERCEPTIONOFSTEREODEPTH
SLOWLYTHANTHERATEOFCOMPREHENSION )N ANY CASE OUR HYPOTHESIS MAY ANDILLUSORYCONTOURS%VIDENCEFROMF-2)
!FAMILIAREXAMPLEISTHEIMPATIENCEEX
ALSO EXTEND TO OTHER FORMS OF VISUAL 3UPPLEMENTTO)NVESTIGATIVE/PHTHALMOLOGYAND
PERIENCEDBYUSERSOFTHE)NTERNETWHO PREFERENCE&OREXAMPLEPEOPLEENJOY 6ISUAL3CIENCE
MUST WAIT FOR IMAGES TO BE DELIVERED VIEWINGIMAGESINSTEREOSTEREOGRAMS ,EWIS - % - -ISHKIN % "RAGIN 2 -
OVER A NARROW
BANDWIDTH MODEM HAVE BEEN A POPULAR FORM OF AMUSE
"ROWN#"0ERTAND!0ERT/PIATE
!RTIFACTS OF POPULAR CULTUREˆ-46 MENTFOROVERACENTURYEVENTHOUGH RECEPTORGRADIENTSINMONKEYCEREBRALCOR

TEX CORRESPONDENCE WITH SENSORY PROCESS

VIDEOS MODERN TELEVISION EDITING AND THEY PROVIDE LITTLE INFORMATION ABOUT INGHIERARCHIES3CIENCEn
VIDEOGAMESˆAREPACEDATTHEEDGEOF ASCENE&UNCTIONAL-2)STUDIESSHOW 3TANFORD)-AND!*#OOPER0RESYN

THEVIEWERSCOMPREHENSION/URWORK THAT SUBJECTS WHO ARE VIEWING STEREO APTIC—ANDDOPIOIDRECEPTORMODULATIONOF
IN THE LABORATORY SHOWS THAT INDIVIDU
IMAGES EXHIBIT DRAMATIC ACTIVITY IN '!"!!)03#SINTHERATGLOBUSPALLIDUSIN
ALSENJOYSEARCHINGFORTARGETIMAGESIN VISUAL
CORTEX REGIONS JUST OUTSIDE THE VITRO*OURNALOF.EUROSCIENCEn
RAPIDSERIALPRESENTATIONSABOUTMIL
PRIMARY VISUAL CORTEX 4HESE STEREO
:AJONC2"!TTITUDINALEFFECTSOFMERE
LISECONDSEACH ASLONGASTHEYCANMAIN
RESPONSIVE BRAIN AREAS MAY PROVE TO EXPOSURE *OURNAL OF 0ERSONALITY AND 3OCIAL
0SYCHOLOGY-ONOGRAPHn
TAINAREASONABLYHIGHLEVELOFACCURACY BE SUFFICIENTLY RICH IN ENDOMORPHIN
ACTIVITY ! SIMILAR NEURAL BASIS MAY
#ONCLUSION ALSO UNDERLIE OUR SPECIES FONDNESS
/UR PROPOSED MECHANISM FOR PERCEP
FORCOLOR4HELINGUALGYRUSHASBEEN
TUALPLEASUREHASFOCUSEDPRIMARILYON IMPLICATED IN PROCESSING INFORMATION œÀÊÀiiÛ>˜ÌÊ7iLʏˆ˜ŽÃ]ÊVœ˜ÃՏÌÊ̅ˆÃÊÊ
THEVISUALSYSTEMBUTWESUSPECTTHAT ABOUTTHECOLORANDTEXTUREOFANIM
ˆÃÃÕiʜvÊ
“iÀˆV>˜Ê-Vˆi˜ÌˆÃÌÊ"˜ˆ˜i\
OTHERSENSORYSYSTEMSMAYHAVEASIMI
AGEANDENDOMORPHINACTIVITYINTHIS
LARARRANGEMENT4HEREISFOREXAMPLE REGIONMAYACCOUNTFORTHISFONDNESS …ÌÌ«\ÉÉÜÜÜ°>“iÀˆV>˜ÃVˆi˜ÌˆÃÌ°œÀ}ÉÊÊ
A MU
OPIOID RECEPTOR GRADIENT IN THE SEE&IGUREBOTTOM  ÃÃÕi/"
ɈÃÃÕiÉn{£
AUDITORYSYSTEMOFTHEMACAQUE(ERE 4HERE IS MUCH THAT REMAINS TO BE
THE RECEPTORS ARE RELATIVELY SPARSE IN EXPLAINED ABOUT THE HUMAN OBSES

©3IGMA8I4HE3CIENTIFIC2ESEARCH3OCIETY2EPRODUCTION
WWWAMERICANSCIENTISTORG -AYn*UNE
WITHPERMISSIONONLY#ONTACTPERMS AMSCIORG