Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
2Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
DTP Letters - Gordon Stewart

DTP Letters - Gordon Stewart

Ratings: (0)|Views: 220|Likes:

More info:

Published by: jeff.aufderheide2634 on Jun 01, 2010
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

06/01/2010

pdf

text

original

 
l' ",' I V
J
H
'i
I I Y
(I'"
(J
I.
1\
S
u()
W
GOIWO'"
1. S
II.WI\IO. " IJ
RUClIJU,
!lOSI"
r
AI
ULAS(JUW
< .ilO
\lNB
TH. 041.9% 7120
13th February, 1980
Mr. P. Allen,SucnHury,COUll'"Hue Oil surety of Medicinoll,.'lll~lJury Squ ••ru 1I0u"e,
3J/J7A
Ylll~bury Hquuru,
LO!WO~, £CLA ~I'P
Doar
Mr.
Allen,In reply to yours or 11th P~bru •ry, ! am ~orry to say that I do notaKroe with you thut ther.:
15
1I0thln.: llJorol
U
,t ctan
o
should b" <Jone. Let melouy UilU10 IlIlIt th" llJ1"ur~",,: ru":~<:r cOll!rununlC us 1;; tn" ~il!"ty o! the vElcci(le.II i" 110t 111 Iho "ul.l!lC lnt"re"l lO "'ltlono!u uddluomd In!ormil110n relating to
thu
:.tdc\.y or
thu
vucC'lnu,
willeh
hiJ~ t,;Oltl~
to Clur
lit\elltlon
cs:i ~
r~sult
of acollc,t.:,,,,rutJ
YC
r>ruHr~mmc
~Hd
w!1.!.ch JS
tub',l}'
b~rJuu.(I(,!
to Our
J.~port. ~
woulcJ
not
for 
U UlQm\:nt
qU\;S\l.UII
UT.
Po!lock
IS rq;nt to
r~por\ 
llJd(;iJcnuclll.ly
on
the
PtiLS:liludy l,nd "u
~!.,uulu
cdrtululy u.dke It
clt.!ar
10
o~r
rCIJvrt
thcsl
we.;
ure
quoting
Ululr
r<:~uj
l:i. \\'.l.thou"
~!aesl.:
T\;:."UJ
ts, I\u.•'cvcr, l'ur
rCI/Or.t
wll.l
L~ not
only
lflcumplot(; but
OltUlI
to
scrluu~
<,;'J';' \.
:'(:~:.lnl.
JlcHl
i
t
LJ~cJ\ ~~~
tcc:1
if,
t
the beglnning
thut
UhJ
PIIL.S
rC:iult~
wuuld
not lJu
~vtllltitJl(.1
!or
quotlllJ.; 1.n
our report,
J
for
onu woulcJ not
I , . . ,
v",'
ugroc<.J
that
coJl.;dJfJr~\.1on
w1tIJ
Uu.:.m
'H:ld 
bny
bent:'!lts
for us
'UHl
W()\J~(J
nuve
l"~lSh:d
UPOIl U
S~1J6U'..itU
cxerC~:iu
U~
an
e);lt:n~iun
o! that agreed
Wllll Pr"r,,~~or Uull"r allu in<l",,<1 'nlll nly~clr. All "f 01)' 1'""u1t" !ll.ve been wau"lr.Vl1ll,,~le lO you fron, tile Sl"rl UII<I1"111 COllllllU" to b,' ",""llllble, whether or
nul Our Panel
,"oet~
U";:Ulf1.
JlFoftts:tor
Uulh:T
h.J~ \'?xpn;:~:"o\:'"d tlJ~
same
vi.~w
Hbout
hl,s purl O.!
til"
.coll~bOrHtlvC'
stud)'.
Rc>gardlnll the flr.llure by th" OilS:> an<J the CSM lO respond to reportsin lIHI 1'••••••, ""'~ t1l••"wIH.r,', 1 01111110\aoc ••pl lllllt Ihv un::;:; ,,,,Il
UIV
CSM had not
un
thc8e r"port~ becllu~oa) they "'ore m"d" by members or represt!n tu t1 ve" of the DHS5 in
thd.r
O!~l~~Kl
C~PHC!tl~~
und
b) I broulCht thOlll quIto forclbly to Ihe unentlon or the CSM.Had Ill! Olho,.,; romilinold ~il"nt, I wuuld oot hElve ObJected to y,'ithholding cOWl1lentby th CSM un111 our report !.ul1 lIeen lSSUQU. '<J""Pl tc nurn"ro"s delays. Tho
sltuat10n chun.,;c"d
wl16n Dr.
Pollock
~uw
fit to ".ti.tiure
the
J.,JUlJI1C on more
than
one occus 10n thu t
th~ V,jj,~C11H'
wu.~
U
pcr!oc
ly
s.....
feu,
tha t fear:i
which
had been
expre""od wero "roundle~" unll tl", t puI'..,"ts lIod <Jo<:to'"'; ,:ou 1<J therefore use itw1thout ft>ur. The roas"ur~nK stllt"menls is~ue<J by 5Jr Charles Stullrt-llarris andby Protos"o., Du<J!:"oll and Mll!o,' wore
J"
til" Slimo ,'ein, allhoul:"h the NCES to whlch
they
ruf~r
18
nowllere
nooJ' CUJnplctlon.
'J'1I1:i WU:i SO Uluch
Kl vdriance with
whut,
lJy
thut
\l"lU,
uur
Comrnlttuo knew to bo the cu:.u thut a
cllution
it
not a
correcl1ve ~lalumunt Wl1" cOlrllllnly cal1tlu ror. 1'1'0 luck of a corrective statt!men.taruoun ts to U J'ell" 11
th",
of tile "u,u" <J1Snllll hl>l tory which cl1usod the problem inthe first pl&c", und luu lh O,"bu<J~lnun lu blamo your Do"artmenl in no uncertain
I
nns.
 
- Z ;.
. ...,.,.,,
ifI'2".,;;;~~,~-,"P-
'p
:
..
'~'~
.
13th
Febru~ry, 1~80
;i.e.}
0" " ~."~ U,, •1
,.po"
,m".,,•
n,",yd.l.y.d
~,~,,10'.••
d". ,.,'"~"
Si,M'
S,.,.n,HI"••
1." '"•'
hi' ,. "."
,~ti:cf'1>lllS
\.0 ,,11ow 'th.:lr results to lie ll:Joted
(~lId
llcl<nowledJ;OO), I aliiw11ling
' . , : : « . 1 .
~~r~6
't.hll\.ot
,t:
h1:; lUte Ilute II stut"m"nt nltCll not llu issuoll. I'!, however,
t,~i.:e"
PilL:?
or
'Ut; .
poliock
ro!usb to ullul/{ llIei r r<:sult5 to lie publ19tlel1,
I
shall
,." " ,,'M " ." " '" . • 
",.11'
.dd '"
.y
..,11", """',
I ,,
thC whc>lo
IIlisinOli5
illcludilll: uur COl'rl1spondcnCtlto lJe u IDutter
of 
recorl1 and
1
slUoll be,&rllwful lor your (.;on!l.l'lnuLiOn01 ttlis.
G.
'l'.
ST t."I'IA R T
 
letn May
lOSl
0,.
Joron 
Sadenoch,
Cl'Ullrrn..n ,
,Joint ~".mltto. on
VaccinatIon
and
Imml¥lbiic\tlon,
OcpaM,m."t'ol'
Health
&
Scx:141~eu,.!ty,
Eltlp;'UVlt ~
C.-uotlCl,
L.o.-',cOIJSEl GSV.
Oellr Or. Badenoch,
Re:xlrt on IAhoopin';)
Co •.•::;n
12.5.81
I
am vot-y
dlsuppol.ntcd
to
rind
trlAt the
tilA"limary
of' the above
RE:POrt,
to wnlch
)/O'Jr
Corr.mlttee contrlb",ted, continueR to U/"IOerstatetne rls'<s
O
pert",csls
vaccine
and
thlIt
there
Is so
lIltle
accurate
informatIon on
t,"'le
,."latlve
r!s:~,.
or
whooping
cough
Itt-elr.
Ae
yo",
know,
I have been at
vs,.laf'lce
with the
"'..Dr~:;:;ed
vi~woolnt of'
'l/Our
Comrr.lttse
'or s.~mp
tln.e
onthIs
rr.atter
b;;t 1
t.'lo:.J;:'t
t."at
tl'\e
report 0' the
Meade
~nel, to;lett-.arwIth
e o
"",ore thol"O ••gn
,;''""0,.
0.•
t.•••
e
Corr,mlttee on tne Safety
or 
Medicln.;:s, rr.!g!"\t
have
ted
tc a ~etter
"'et'\oo
or 
!Uisessln9
relative
rll.'«:;
In the
f'"'tur~
If
root
now.
VI.
hat
h'lS
l"1.a;J:)cned
l~
t."1..lt t'-.e summarv
or 
thlt
Report
and
~e
Et!1tcmonts
Iss•.•ed
by
t..-.e
OHSS and
!;;
Hl-l~d(~ferhardly at
llll
r'rom 
tne
recorr.rr.ar.'::rltlon,;
mz.ce
In
t9740, the
Cu:r')...•
rtn.er.ts.
The
edltorbl
In
tO~l\y'o
8f\'U
re~s:.ures Doctors
t."Il\t
pert;,;!"S
Is
•...<~<::clno
C3n
safel;Qe qlv~n to
scc/ceo
Int""t;3
;load
tbN
Q~ly two
w[Jl
h,;l\ffl
sa,:SoJS
rc:;ctlon~ with permanent
dl!:llblllt
L
This I~
C o
d<1nger-ou!:conclusion
to
dr~v.;-
(rom 
yO •••,.
Report.
Eno,"g') evloence was avallable tv
t.'1e
OHSS and to rr.errber-s
of  
)'0"'''
Committee to
AI"lfoWer
q;"cstlons
whlcn legltirr,atl:ly
arose
ane'
a~ noti,lf,,,wc"cd
In
the Report. For In£'t.V'\c~,
thCI"Ol
It;
n.:liltt~m;)t
to
~e:!.l
wlt."I
th<:1c~,;;er
. :0:'  
C o
."crc:>~,I:;e. there
I~l
n.; ,:,c
1
'''o J".1 t,c.;,: ••
r,,(llt
u.•..
;t
~t.l,.;:.
r-:
(:,;atl,ln
by
lao,:,rutory
,."fl.j t~",l:.; c.:.nn.;)t be eq•.•.:lted to ct'rcctlver.el!:i& ~nd safety In In'anl:-c:'and
C:"I!I~re".
i\:"\d  
tner'c if; no
correction
"r 
gl"vss
inaccvracles In
m.:lnltorlng,
root
o:"ll}
:Jf
tI-.i!
ci~..,~eel,;,.;t
..ll~(,)
of 
adverse
reactions
or
a.~yKind.
Tr,o. ,,"'::>C:l"tlon
mad,.,
;}Q
':M.te •• 
tiC ~
182
tnat ~tt'lCl<rate
Is slgniflcantl)' affected
by
I"Q.~
of vaccine
e.cc~ot.:mcl: ~
~tlstically ..ntbnableandthe
Oepartrr.ent
"!.IS
ddmitted
this
In
co"""~;:>or.c:••
,-,ce
wIth
me.
My
mAin purpose In
w,..lting
10
to
esk
1
1
might
help in
c!eslgnlng
a comp"eh~slve
prospcetl",e surveillance.
The NCES study was highly .n::orr,plete
In
tl1lS relJpect.
The
tv'<330de
I"' ••
nel was di.'c:oura!j1ed
frorr.
Arranging
survelliance
boc"use we were told that PHI..S had
al"ead)"
d c5 n e
so.
agree with
~eu,... .
Commlttee'sl
" . 7 " " - " • • • •
.'"
'
- - .
'"~.-''~''~''''''
..
~'''.'''
. . . • -
"',
.
...
~

Activity (2)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->