Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
6Activity
P. 1
Manage Risk in Public Sector From Hong Kong

Manage Risk in Public Sector From Hong Kong

Ratings: (0)|Views: 467 |Likes:
Published by Aamir Shehzad
The clients of public sector works have an obligation to ensure that the large scale investment in public works is effective and can
achieve improvement in social and economic performance. However, construction activity is usually subject to more risk than other business
activities because of its complexity particularly in coordinating a wide range of disparate and interrelated skills and activities. This
complexity is further compounded in implementing public sector projects where multiple project objectives are expected by a wide range
of stakeholders who have different interests associated with the projects. With reference to current practice in Hong Kong, this paper
examines the major risks in implementing public sector works, and the ways that the application of public private partnership (PPP)
can help to manage risks in project delivery. The example of Hong Kong Disneyland (KDLD) demonstrates how various major risks
in committing to a PPP project are allocated and shared effectively between public and private partners. In this typical PPP project,
it is found that allocation of site acquisition risk and legal and policy risks to the public sector is more effective while private sector could
effectively allocate the design and construction risks, operation risks and industrial action risk to the private sector. Also, development
risks, market risks, financial risks and force majeure could be shared effectively between the two partners. These results present valuable
lessons for both the practitioners and researchers in application of PPPs to manage risks in delivering of public sector projects in other
countries and regions.
The clients of public sector works have an obligation to ensure that the large scale investment in public works is effective and can
achieve improvement in social and economic performance. However, construction activity is usually subject to more risk than other business
activities because of its complexity particularly in coordinating a wide range of disparate and interrelated skills and activities. This
complexity is further compounded in implementing public sector projects where multiple project objectives are expected by a wide range
of stakeholders who have different interests associated with the projects. With reference to current practice in Hong Kong, this paper
examines the major risks in implementing public sector works, and the ways that the application of public private partnership (PPP)
can help to manage risks in project delivery. The example of Hong Kong Disneyland (KDLD) demonstrates how various major risks
in committing to a PPP project are allocated and shared effectively between public and private partners. In this typical PPP project,
it is found that allocation of site acquisition risk and legal and policy risks to the public sector is more effective while private sector could
effectively allocate the design and construction risks, operation risks and industrial action risk to the private sector. Also, development
risks, market risks, financial risks and force majeure could be shared effectively between the two partners. These results present valuable
lessons for both the practitioners and researchers in application of PPPs to manage risks in delivering of public sector projects in other
countries and regions.

More info:

Published by: Aamir Shehzad on Jun 13, 2010
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

03/13/2013

 
]gdi g` pymdbf p}be~i pe}~li}vcbpv ~g kelehi }bvjv bl pymdbfvif~g} p}gaif~v bl Cglh Jglh
Db+Rbl Vcil
e$!
$ Eln}ix _de~~il
m
$ S,_, Nilh
f
e
Nipe}~kil~ g` Mybdnblh eln ]ied Iv~e~i$ ^ci Cglh Jglh _gdr~ifclbf Ylbi}vb~r$ Cylh Cgk$ Jgxdggl$ Cglh Jglh 
m
Idie~i Iev~ Delfevcb}i$ Eff}blh~gl$ Ilhdeln$ YJ 
f
Vfcggd g` Fbbd Ilhblii}blh$ Vgy~c Iev~ Ylbi}vb~r$ _] Fcble
Emv~}ef~
^ci fdbil~v g` pymdbf vif~g} xg}jv cei el gmdbhe~bgl ~g ilvy}i ~ce~ ~ci de}hi vfedi bliv~kil~ bl pymdbf xg}jv bv i﬏if~bi eln felefcbii bkp}gikil~ bl vgfbed eln ifglgkbf pi}`g}kelfi, Cgxii}$ fglv~}yf~bgl ef~bb~r bv yvyeddr vymaif~ ~g kg}i }bvj ~cel g~ci} myvb+livv ef~bb~biv mifeyvi g` b~v fgkpdisb~r pe}~bfyde}dr bl fgg}nble~blh e xbni }elhi g` nbvpe}e~i eln bl~i}}ide~in vjbddv eln ef~bb~biv, ^cbvfgkpdisb~r bv `y}~ci} fgkpgylnin bl bkpdikil~blh pymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~v xci}i kyd~bpdi p}gaif~ gmaif~biv e}i ispif~in mr e xbni }elhig` v~ejicgdni}v xcg cei nb﬏i}il~ bl~i}iv~v evvgfbe~in xb~c ~ci p}gaif~v, Xb~c }i`i}ilfi ~g fy}}il~ p}ef~bfi bl Cglh Jglh$ ~cbv pepi}isekbliv ~ci keag} }bvjv bl bkpdikil~blh pymdbf vif~g} xg}jv$ eln ~ci xerv ~ce~ ~ci eppdbfe~bgl g` pymdbf p}be~i pe}~li}vcbp #___"fel cidp ~g kelehi }bvjv bl p}gaif~ nidbi}r, ^ci isekpdi g` Cglh Jglh Nbvlirdeln #JNDN" nikglv~}e~iv cgx e}bgyv keag} }bvjvbl fgkkb~~blh ~g e ___ p}gaif~ e}i eddgfe~in eln vce}in i﬏if~bidr mi~xiil pymdbf eln p}be~i pe}~li}v, Bl ~cbv ~rpbfed ___ p}gaif~$b~ bv `gyln ~ce~ eddgfe~bgl g` vb~i efuybvb~bgl }bvj eln dihed eln pgdbfr }bvjv ~g ~ci pymdbf vif~g} bv kg}i i﬏if~bi xcbdi p}be~i vif~g} fgydni﬏if~bidr eddgfe~i ~ci nivbhl eln fglv~}yf~bgl }bvjv$ gpi}e~bgl }bvjv eln blnyv~}bed ef~bgl }bvj ~g ~ci p}be~i vif~g}, Edvg$ niidgpkil~}bvjv$ ke}ji~ }bvjv$ ſtlelfbed }bvjv eln `g}fi keaiy}i fgydn mi vce}in i﬏if~bidr mi~xiil ~ci ~xg pe}~li}v, ^civi }ivyd~v p}ivil~ edyemdidivvglv `g} mg~c ~ci p}ef~b~bgli}v eln }ivie}fci}v bl eppdbfe~bgl g` ___v ~g kelehi }bvjv bl nidbi}blh g` pymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~v bl g~ci}fgyl~}biv eln }ihbglv,
Ö
=??0 Idvipbi} D~n eln B_KE, Edd }bhc~v }ivi}pin,
Jirxg}nv1
_ymdbf p}be~i pe}~li}vcbp: _ymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~: ]bvj kelehikil~: Cglh Jglh
5, Bl~}gnyf~bgl
_ymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~ #_V_" bv e hili}bf }i`i}ilfi xcbfc bveppdbin ~g e xbni }elhi g` pymdbf xg}jv, _V_v yvyeddr }ip+}ivil~ keag} pe}~ g` fglv~}yf~bgl xg}jv bl elr fgyl~}r g}}ihbgl, Effg}nblh ~g ~ci }ipg}~ g` Cglh Jglh =??=Z5[$~ci CJ Hgi}lkil~ xev ~g vpiln emgy~ CJ.=3 mbddbglgl fepb~ed xg}jv bl =??=‖=??6$ eln kebl~ebl el ei}ehiellyed fepb~ed xg}jv ispilnb~y}i g` emgy~ CJ.=2 mbddbglbl ~ci fgkblh rie}v, ]bvj kelehikil~ ~ci}i`g}i mifgkivel bkpg}~el~ kifcelbvk ~g mi engp~in ~g ilvy}i efcbii+kil~ g` ~ci pdellin gmaif~biv bl fgkkb~~blh ~g ~civi h}ie~bliv~kil~v, ^ci pymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~v bl Cglh Jglh e}im}gendr nbbnin bl~g ~xg h}gypv1 #e" pymdbf cgyvblh p}gaif~vylni}~ejil mr ~ci Cgyvblh Ey~cg}b~r: #m" g~ci} pymdbf vif+~g} xg}jv fgkkbvvbglin mr ~ci Hgi}lkil~ g` ~ci CglhJglh Vpifbed Enkblbv~}e~bi ]ihbgl$ ~ci Eb}pg}~ Ey~cg}+b~r$ ~ci Jgxdggl‖Fel~gl ]ebdxer Fg}pg}e~bgl #JF]F"$eln ~ci Kevv ^}elvb~ ]ebdxer Fg}pg}e~bgl #K^]F"Z=[,V~ynbiv vyhhiv~ ~ce~ ~ci ~}enb~bgl g` fgv~ eln ~bki gi}+}ylv$ pgg} ve`i~r pi}`g}kelfi$ pgg} uyedb~r eln ilb}gl+kil~ed pi}`g}kelfi bl nidbi}blh _V_v }ikebl ~g de}hiis~il~ ylfcelhinZ6‖9$=[, @drmai}h i~ ed,Z>[isekblin =93 de}hi ~}elvpg}~ bl`}ev~}yf~y}i p}gaif~v fgi}blh =?fgyl~}biv$ eln ~cir `gyln ~ce~ fgv~ gi}}ylv gffy}}in bledkgv~ 2?) g` ~ci p}gaif~v isekblin$ xb~c ~ci cbhciv~ fgv~gi}}ylv g` 30) eln =3) gl ei}ehi, Effg}nblh ~g ~ci
?=06+8306'.6?,??
Ö
=??0 Idvibi} D~n eln B_KE, Edd }bhc~v }ivi}in,ngb15?,5?50'a,bap}gkel,=??0,?8,??0
!
Fg}}ivpglnblh ey~cg}, ^id,1 *39= =800 93?9: `es1 *39= =80> 9565,
I+kebd enn}ivv1
mvvcilOpgdry,iny,cj#D,+R, Vcil",
xxx,idvibi},fgk'dgfe~i'bap}gkel
Bl~i}le~bgled Agy}led g` _}gaif~ Kelehikil~ => #=??0" 938‖92>
BL^I]LE^BGLED AGY]LED G@
_]GAIF^KELEHIKIL^
 
}ipg}~ g` LEGZ0[$ epp}gsbke~idr 8?) g` ~ci p}gaif~vſtlelfin mr ~ci fil~}ed hgi}lkil~ ispi}bilfin niderv blſtled fgkpdi~bgl bl ~ci YJ$ `g} isekpdi, G~ci} fglvi+uyilfiv nyi ~g pgg} p}gaif~ pi}`g}kelfi blfdyni pgg}bliv~kil~ }i~y}lv `}gk ~ci yvi g` ~ci p}gaif~$ nider bl~ci y~bdbve~bgl g` ~ci pymdbf `efbdb~biv eln is~ilnin blfgli+lbilfi `g} ~ci pymdbf, Edd g` ~civi p}gmdikv isi}~ e cyhiſtlelfbed p}ivvy}i gl hgi}lkil~$ eln ~cir fel cgdn mefjg} bkpeb} pdellin ifglgkbf niidgpkil~,^g bkp}gi ~ci istfbilfr g` kelehblh p}gaif~ }bvjv$ ~ciCglh Jglh Hgi}lkil~ cev miil p}gkg~blh ~ci eppdbfe+~bgl g` lix p}gfy}ikil~ v~}e~ihbiv `g} ~ci bkpdikil~e~bglg` pymdbf vif~g} xg}jv$ bl pe}~bfyde}$ ~ci kifcelbvk g` pymdbf p}be~i pe}~li}vcbpv #___v", ___ bv el i﬏if~biepp}gefc ~g ilcelfi p}gaif~ p}gnyf~bb~r mr m}blhblh blkelehikil~ istfbilfr eln f}ie~bi vjbddv `}gk myvblivvp}ef~bfi$ eln }inyfblh hgi}lkil~ed blgdikil~ mr yvblhp}be~i vif~g}v bl ~ci p}gbvbgl g` pymdbf vi}bfiv, ___ bv eniidgpkil~ `}gk ~ci p}gfy}ikil~ v~}e~ihr g` MG^#Mybdn$ Gpi}e~i eln ^}elv`i}" eln b~ bv pe}~bfyde}dr vyb~emdi`g} de}hi vfedi bl`}ev~}yf~y}i p}gaif~v, MG^ vrv~ik cev miilkebldr p}gkg~in bl niidgpblh ifglgkbiv xci}i bl`}e+v~}yf~y}i xg}jv effgyl~ `g} ~ci keag}b~r g` pymdbf bliv~+kil~, ^cbv vb~ye~bgl e}bviv `}gk ~ci liin ~g }inyfi ~cipymdbf vif~g} mynhi~ fgl~}bmy~bgl ~g bl`}ev~}yf~y}i bliv~+kil~ eln xci}i istfbilfr heblv `}gk fgkki}fbed p}ef~bfivfel mi bkpg}~in ~g ~ci vif~g}, Bl g}ni} ~g }inyfi pymdbfmg}}gxblh ~g ſtlelfi nb}if~ ispilnb~y}i$ ~ci hgi}lkil~vbl niidgpblh fgyl~}biv cei `gyln p}be~i vgy}fiv g` p}g+ aif~ ſtlelfi ev el i﬏if~bi v~}e~ihr ~g evvbv~ bkpdikil~e~bglg` ~civi p}gaif~vZ8[, ^ci eppdbfe~bgl g` ___ cev mifgkiblf}ievblhdr pgpyde} bl niidgpin ifglgkbiv `g} heblblh~ci enel~ehi g` bkp}gblh istfbilfr eln kb~bhe~blh }bvjv,^ci Cglh Jglh Istfbilfr Ylb~Z3[gp~in ~ce~ i﬏if~bilivvg` ___ bv mevin gl e pe}~li}vcbp epp}gefc$ xci}i ~ci}ivpglvbmbdb~r `g} ~ci nidbi}r g` vi}bfiv bv vce}in mi~xiil~ci pymdbf eln p}be~i vif~g}v$ mg~c g` xcbfc m}blh bl ~cib}fgkpdikil~e}r vjbddv ~g ~ci il~i}p}bvi,Mr }i`i}}blh ~g ~ci p}ef~bfi bl Cglh Jglh$ ~cbv pepi}isekbliv ~ci keag} }bvjv bl ~ci bkpdikil~e~bgl g` pymdbfvif~g} xg}jv$ eln ~ci}imr ~ci xerv ~ce~ ~ci eppdbfe~bglg` ___ fel i﬏if~bidr kelehi }bvjv bl p}gaif~ nidbi}r,^xg fglv~}yf~bi bl~i}bixv xb~c vilbg} gstfbedv bl ~ci Ist+fbilfr Ylb~ g` ~ci Cglh Jglh VE] Hgi}lkil~ xi}i fgl+nyf~in `g} ne~e fgddif~bgl eln nbvfyvvbglv, ^ci nbvfyvvbglvgi} ~ci ~xg pdellin bl~i}bixv hili}e~in edyemdi ne~eeln ylni}v~elnblh g` ~ci eppdbfe~bgl g` ___v bl CglhJglh pymdbf vif~g} xg}jv, ^ci Istfbilfr Ylb~ bv ~ci gstfbednipe}~kil~ `g} p}gkg~blh ~ci eppdbfe~bgl g` ___v bl CglhJglhZ3[, E fevi v~ynr eledrvbv gl ___ p}gaif~ bl CglhJglh xev edvg fglnyf~in, ^ci vidif~in fevi v~ynr bv e ~rp+bfed ___ p}gaif~ bl Cglh Jglh xcbfc fglv~b~y~iv ~ci pymdbf}ied iv~e~iv gpi}e~in mr p}be~i vif~g}v, ^ci eledrviv gl~civi ne~e xbdd }ivyd~ bl edyemdi }ivie}fc ſtlnblhv ~g p}iv+il~ divvglv die}lin bl eppdbfe~bgl g` ___v ~g kelehi }bvj blpymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~v bl g~ci} fgyl~}biv g} }ihbglv, ^cipepi} bv v~}yf~y}in bl ~ci `gddgxblh kelli}, @b}v~$ ~cipepi} p}ivil~v el bliv~bhe~bgl bl~g ~ci nidbi}blh g` pymdbfvif~g} p}gaif~v bl Cglh Jglh$ xcbfc xbdd dien ~g el eledr+vbv g` ~rpbfed }bvjv bl pymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~v, ^cb}n$ ~ci }gdig` ___ ~g kelehi }bvjv bl pymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~ bv p}ivil~inbl e `}ekixg}j mevin gl blvbhc~v `}gk ~ci emgi eledrvbv,@g}~c$ ~ci `}ekixg}j bv eppdbin ~g fglnyf~ e fevi v~ynr gle ___ p}gaif~ bl }if}ie~bgled vif~g} bl Cglh Jglh, @bleddr$fglfdyvbglv eln }ifgkkilne~bglv `gddgx,
5,5, Nidbi}blh g` pymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~v bl Cglh Jglh 
Bl Cglh Jglh$ ~ci fglv~}yf~bgl `ylnv `g} bkpdikil~e+~bgl g` pymdbf vif~g} p}gaif~v kebldr fgki `}gk hgi}l+kil~‒v Fepb~ed Xg}jv ]ivi}i @yln #FX]@"$ xcbfc xeviv~emdbvcin bl 523= mr ]ivgdy~bgl g` ~ci Dihbvde~bi Fgyl+fbd #DF"Z2[, ^ci blfgki g` FX]@ bv kebldr ni}bin `}gk~ci deln p}ikbyk$ xcbfc bv yvin ~g ſtlelfi pymdbf xg}jvp}gh}ekkiv #_X_" blfdynblh pymdbf fglv~}yf~bgl xg}jvZ5[, ^ci vrv~ik jlgxl ev ~ci Fepb~ed Xg}jv ]ivi}i @yln]ivgy}fi Eddgfe~bgl Vrv~ik #FX]@+]EV" xev bl~}gnyfinbl 5238 ~g }ihyde~i ~ci ſtlelfi vfcinydi `g} ~ci pdellblh g` fepb~ed xg}jv ispilnb~y}i gl e ſti+rie} mevbv, Xb~cbl_X_$ p}gaif~v e}i h}gypin ylni} e}bgyv ispilnb~y}icienblhv$ isekpdin xb~c^emdi 5$ xcbfc nilg~iv ~ci ispil+nb~y}i ylni} iefc cienblh gi} ~ci pi}bgn =??6‖=??>Z5?[,^ci hgi}lkil~ bv ~ci de}hiv~ fdbil~ g` ~ci fglv~}yf~bglblnyv~}r bl Cglh Jglh, ^ci ~g~ed _ymdbf Ispilnb~y}i bl=??5‖=??= bv CJ.=02,> mbddbgl$ g` xcbfc ~ci ispilnb~y}ivgl cgyvblh eln bl`}ev~}yf~y}i xi}i CJ.6=,5 mbddbgl elnCJ.=>,2 mbddbgl }ivpif~bidr$ evvykblh =5,2) g` ~ci ~g~edispilnb~y}iZ55[, ^ci I^XM #Ilb}glkil~$ ^}elvpg}~eln Xg}jv My}iey" bv }ivpglvbmdi `g} bkpdikil~e~bgl g` edd pymdbf p}gaif~v isfip~ pymdbf cgyvblh xcbfc bv kelehinmr ~ci Cgyvblh Ey~cg}b~r, I^XM bv ~ci pgdbfr keji} xcgbv }ivpglvbmdi `g} fgg}nble~bgl g` ~ci p}gaif~ `}gk ~ci p}g+
^emdi 5Fe~ihg}biv bl ~ci _X_ eln ispilnb~y}i bl =??6‖?> #Cglh Jglh"Cien 8?5 Cien 8?= Cien 8?6 Cien 8?> Cien 8?9 Cien 8?0_X_ Deln efuybvb~bgl _g}~ eln eb}pg}~ niidgpkil~ Mybdnblhv N}eblehi Fbbd ilhblii}blh CbhcxervCJN #mbddbgl" 5,68 ?,3= 2,5> =,53 6,8= 9,?0Cien 8?8 Cien 8?3 Cien 8?2 Cien 8?5? Cien 8?55_X_ Lix ~gxlv eln y}mele}ie niidgpkil~Fepb~ed vymil~bglv eln keag}vrv~ikv eln Iuybpkil~Xe~i}xg}jv Fgkpy~i}bqe~bgl CgyvblhCJN #mbddbgl" =,2? 9,9> 5,?2 5,5= 5,9=933
D,+R, Vcil i~ ed, ' Bl~i}le~bgled Agy}led g` _}gaif~ Kelehikil~ => #=??0" 938‖92>
 
pgved v~ehi ~g fglv~}yf~bgl fgkpdi~bgl eln iv~emdbvckil~g` ~ci pgdbfr eln ~ifclbfed hybnidbliv `g} ispinb~bgyv bkpdi+kil~e~bgl g` p}gaif~ p}gh}ekki, ^ci vfcinydin fglv~}yf+~bgl xg}jv xbdd ~cil mi fe}}bin gy~ mr fgl~}ef~g}v vidif~in~c}gyhc ~ilni}blh,^ci I^XM fglvbv~v g` e lykmi} g` nipe}~kil~v blfdyn+blh E}fcb~if~y}ed Vi}bfiv Nipe}~kil~ #EVN"$ Fbbd Ilhb+lii}blh Nipe}~kil~ #FIN"$ eln Cbhcxerv Nipe}~kil~#CN", ^cir e}i ~ci kebl nipe}~kil~v }ivpglvbmdi `g}bkpdikil~e~bgl g` pymdbf p}gaif~v, ^ci I^XM‒v g}helbve+~bgled v~}yf~y}i bv vcgxl bl ~ci `gddgxblh ſthy}iv,@bh, 5vcgxv ~ci g}helbve~bgled v~}yf~y}i g` E}fcb~if~y}ed Vi}+bfiv Nipe}~kil~ #EVN" g` ~ci I^XM,@bh, =blnbfe~iv ~ci g}helbve~bgled v~}yf~y}i g` ~ci FbbdIlhblii}blh Nipe}~kil~ #FIN",Vbkbde}dr$@bh, 6vcgxv ~ci g}helbve~bgled v~}yf~y}i g` Cbhcxerv Nipe}~kil~ #CN" g` ~ci I^XM,EVN bv }ivpglvbmdi `g} ~ci p}gbvbgl g` p}g`ivvbgled elnkelehikil~ }ivgy}fiv gl edd ke~~i}v }ide~blh ~g pymdbfmybdnblhv #isfip~ pymdbf cgyvblh", B~ blfdyniv vii}edm}elfciv evvykblh nb﬏i}il~ }gdiv ev vcgxl bl@bh, 5Z5=[, @bh, =vcgxv ~ci g}helbve~bgled v~}yf~y}i g` FINZ56[$ xcgvi kebl kbvvbgl bv ~g p}gbni vi}bfiv `g} vdgpi ve`i~r$pg}~ niidgpkil~ eln deln `g}ke~bgl, Eln@bh, 6p}ivil~v~ci g}helbve~bgled v~}yf~y}i g` CNZ5>[$ xcbfc bv }ivpglvb+mdi `g} pdellblh$ nivbhlblh$ fglv~}yf~bgl eln kebl~ilelfi
_}gaif~kelehikil~m}elfc
E}fcb~if~y}ed Vi}bfivNipe}~kil~#EVN"
_}gaif~kelehikil~m}elfc_}gaif~kelehikil~m}elfc_}gaif~kelehikil~m}elfc_}gaif~kelehikil~m}elfc_}gaif~kelehikil~m}elfc
@bh, 5, G}helbqe~bgl v~}yf~y}i g` ~ci EVN,
Fbbd Ilhblii}blhG``bfi #FIG"Vpifbed Ny~biv G``bfi#VNG"Hig~ifclbfedIlhblii}blh G``bfi#HIG"DelnNiidgpkil~M}elfc_}gaif~Kelehikil~M}elfc_g}~M}elfcCglhJglhBvdelnM}elfcKebldelnM}elfcNiidgpkil~M}elfcDelnvdbp_}iil~biKievy}ivM}elfc
^ci Fbbd Ilhblii}blhNipe}~kil~
#FIN"
@bh, =, G}helbqe~bgl v~}yf~y}i g` ~ci FIN,
CbhcxervNipe}~kil~ #CN"
Keag} Xg}jvKelehikil~G``bfi #KXKG"Cienuye}~i}v6 ]ihbgled G``bfiv#Cglh Jglh$Jgxdggl &Lix^i}}b~g}r"]ebdxerNiidgpkil~G``bfi #]NG"
@bh, 6, G}helbqe~bgl v~}yf~y}i g` ~ci CN,
D,+R, Vcil i~ ed, ' Bl~i}le~bgled Agy}led g` _}gaif~ Kelehikil~ => #=??0" 938‖92>
932

Activity (6)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
Fitri Ap liked this
Wing Ki Wong liked this
Wing Ki Wong liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->