Aug.02.

2010 12:15

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 1/ 19

UCS-840 (RRV lI?OOO)

. REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL INTERVENTION

PLAlNTIFJ:I(S) :

Edolphus To\\ir'il;l

DEX NO. DA ~'E PUReI fASED:

JUly2t, 2010' .; '.

For Clerk Only

Supreme.

fAS entry date

RJIDate

I,' "

I,,,

DEFENDANt(S):

Kevin Pov.iell. andth.aBOarcjOf'f;lect.ciris.in inll ¢Ity of. NawVork '.

Date Issuejoined: ,':'!,"'-/A.:_.· .~.c....;._~ ..... BillofpllrticuWs Refved(YIN):

T' . J Y

. " .'.

NAiijiUroF"iiIDiCiAi·lNiER\WiTIQN·(~h~Jk9iill"t;;;~·b~j;;-ANi5·~;~t~~-{;;f~;~;;rtl~~) .. · ··--·-·- .. · .. ·· .. ~ .. · · ·m-m ,.-,- •••• ,-mn--m 'mm_n : .

Request :for preliminary (;()~ncc

Notice of'medical or dental malprectice

action (specizy:, . . '. ') .

] Note of'issue and/or ccrtificateof reediness

Notice of motion (rerum date:.,..·:.,......· .....,.....:...,- __ _.:.__,:-----:'..........;,~

Rclief'sought . .." ., "

Order to ~PQW tau~ . . .' , ". .

(c1ci-kenter feturn date~,_;;,l'JJ.;,:;· gQirt;,:_'.::.._' ,.,..1.:.,;< 20;".._10_·.....;,· . ....;.;..._;_ __ ..o......:----l

ReliefsouglU' .16vaildBtedli:!19t1liiJngp(!tltiol")'

. .] Statemenr of net worth

Writ of habeas COl,'PUS

. .'

J. Other {l}i parte anP1icatiQIl (soecifv:

] ]

"'Other Commercial

.occ ·0(:

.J Other (~pcdfy:
_ ..
TOn:rS
Malpractice
Medical/Podiamc ·MM·
..
] Dental -DM
] *Othw' Professional ·OPM
.1 MOUlt V chicle ·MV
.J ~~Od\lct8 Liability -PI.
Environmental -BN
J Asbestos -ASH
Breast Implant ·HI
] *Other NOll;liAence ·O"JN
- ... -~.,------,-I"""'I
l ~Qthe)" TOrt. (including -OT
intc::~t-il:!)J,al)
•· __ ··_,··,····· .. "1 ... , ... /, .•. " ...... _ .. ,.,_.,." •.... ,.,, . ... ,--_ .. _ .. " .... _. - .' _\-'-' .... ._ ..... "'-"---'--'--'-'~---'----'---__;_-...; .. _",,'~ .... __ .,_._)

NATURE QF,ACTIONORPRQCEEDING (Cheek ONE box only)

MATlUMmsl~ .

I: • ] Contested "eM

[. .] Uncontested -liM

COMMER£!AL

[ . ] Contract

-CONI'

j :J

Corporate

Insurance (where insurer is a party, except arbitration)

uec (including seles, negotiabier.instl'uments)

-CORP . ~lNS

. ',:' '" '. .".

_. _' ~""""""",\_.~' I·,.,;,. ...... .._ ...... _ ..... .wn....:..._. ~_

. .

Rli:AJ, PROPfJll:V

t ] Tax Ccrtiorai-i

I . J F oreclosure

[ Condcrunation

[I LandlQtd/felllul!

[ . . J *Qthcr Real Prooertv

-TAX: ·FOR -COND

-n

~ORP

SPEOO PB.QCEEPINGS

t . J Art. 75 (Arbitration)

r .' J . Art. 77 (Trusts)

.'] Art, 78

x J Election Law

·ART7~ -ART7? .Al{T711

.gLEe

~.I[!U;RMATI.ERS .

[I ..

-urn

r. I: [

GU<lJ'J i!ul~hip (MHL ArL 81) "Other Mental IIyglel'c "'Othet.$pecial Proceeding

"GlJARD81 -M'HYG

-OSp

Aug.02.2010 12:16

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 2/ 19

Is this action/proceeding against a

YES·· NO

[X I Municip!llity

(Specjry __ ~-,-....;...~_---,--,--,-_-,--,- __ --,

'tllS NO

I I I X·

Public Authority:

(Rpeciry7"-. ---'-- ..;._ _

YF.S NO

. K.tJ . Ores !his action/proceeding seekequirablerelief?

.1 . [ . KJ .. Doesthis .action/pTt)cccdlng seek-recovery for pet:ltlnal injury?

·.·1 )( . J Does this aCtlol)iproceedingseek recovery for prOperty damage?

Prg-NJllC.IJme Ff!~

(This applies to allcases except conte~ted msrrimemals and tax certiorari cases)

E~timated time period·fbl· case to be telldy fui trial (from fiiing IJfRJlt6 filing of Note cfIssue):

)(. Expedited; O,R months

Standard. 9·12 ril.onths

.. Comp 1(1X: 13·15 months

ContellCdM.e!ri9l!i.i!dlU Qnly; (Check and give date)

No

Was a Notice of No Necessity filed?

A TIQRNEV(S) FOkPLAINTIFF(S):

~ . Name

~ ALTERANDBARBARO

No

Yes, Date :._: ..... _ .. ~

Addnss

·26 COURT S:rREET,R()OM)M~,·I3R()OKi-YN, NEWYQRK 1.1:242

. .

T8Ie:(718f2~7.086Q ..

. .

ATTORNE~(S)·~OR DE·FENDANT(S): ..

~

&PL N/A·

.. ~.

~SelfRep~~utf;IJ;p;iU;tle8~piesllntmg tt1~JlJ~iY(;S, wmi~~i an aitomcy,sn~~i;l cnc~~ cne"Se!t Kep,"box ~ci ent~f tllclrnmne, acoress, lindphone'll-Ln the space provided above for attorney~,

lNSlIRANcg CARRIERS:

None·· .: .:

RI~L!TEDCASF,S! (}Ii NONl';, wrjte"NONE" h!d2l!):

Ii!.!! lwl£U

None

I AFFJ:R.M: UNDERPENAL TY OF PERJURY TI1A~r, TO MYKNOWLED(IE, OTHER THAN AS NOTl:\llABOVE, TIHIRn AR F AND HA. VE BEEN NO RELA1TID ACTIONS OR PROC'BEDlNGS, NOR HAS A REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL INTERVEHllON PREVIOUSLY HEHN FILED IN TITIS

ACTION OR f'ROCEEDfNG. /~-I {~_,~ ...

Dated: Brooklyn, New York, July 19, 2010 ~::::,,:-:-::::r:l~_rLi.....:;j;,..,v _:I .:.........:_ _

(l)IGNij(jM) """'1 "'-~.-- .. --

aERNARo·MrtcHELLAI~TER

(PH~NT OR.TIPE NAME) P~liti~n~~

AUORNllY FOR

AITACH RmER RHEFTIFNECESSARY TO l'ROVlDE REQUIRED INFORMATION

m7?l.1

2110/00 HUM

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 3/ 19

02 2010 12:16 Aug. .

.'

,.I

'f

At a SpaclatElection Part 1 ' .,of the ' ,supreiiie COlJn 'Qf :the' State of New York,heldih . and for. the County of .

f<ings,.l .. ", _ \~t· ,the _. '~Im' reme:...· to, urt",

" '... .._ ~...,~-. ,4,; ..................... t.4t\.

. .Co.Urtti0\.l~10ereoTi on ." e .~i.~· . day ..

of.July.2010. . ....'. . ' ..

. PRESf:NT: HON:·~,t\.~~~c:1...~~.,~~ :, ·JUSTICE

~~~~.~~~~.~~~~~~~~-~~~~~ ... -,'" "~·~,;-~~;-~X·

In the M$tter.oftheApplicationof

EOOl..PHUSTQVVNS •

Candidat~-A9grieved, .

, ' " , .

'. petft.iprieT,· ..'.

. KEVIN POWELL

". ~espondent~Candid~te~

-and-

BOAftP .OF ~LECT10NS'N . THE CITY' OF NEW •• YORK,',

. ' .. Re~p6ndent,. .

Ft)ran Order Pursuant to Sections 16-1 OO,16~ 102

··and .,16,,116 ·Ofthe Election" Law,: oedl~rh,glnvalid, the ..

De$jgna~in9Pet~l()n :PurportingtoD~$ignate the .

R$sPQndent(skCan.did~te( s ) for the f>uplicPffice or . pa~ PO$ltlonpfB.eQr§i,ntatiY~lQQQngr~$s frQrri."th~ . 10.ti.~o'li!!§jii~oaIDlstri~!,:§.t@teQf,~~'X9rl·inJhe Oeh1O"c(tiI~IQPnfl1ary· Election .to be. ,held Sf.?pteOlber

" .. ,14.;, 2.010; ' snd JQRestrain the:$s.id ',actll,RO'OF . 'e~e~nIOM~ fr"m' Printing and PI~qil'lg.th~'N~rhes·of .' . $aid·can~ki~t$(~)Up6h. toe .. officlal$allo!s of$ucn

Prim 8r,r ElectiQn.. ..., ..

. ";.+111~~_ .. ~ .. _ .. ~~.~,;..:.n...:.'"",:""-;\,:",,,~~,,,-wt._,,,~,,,,,,,,~~,,,,,, ~.,~a."'~~_~~,,,,,,,_ .. .-.x

. . ..

ORC)ERtOSHOW .

CAUSE10.1NVALfOATE· .. DESIGNATING PETITIO.'" .

. " :" " . " .'

verlftadthe1sTl-idl3Y 6fJUly,2000, and~pon. the original' designating petition

OSC.!NVAl

Aug.02.2010 12:17

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 4/ 19

"

"

'.

. . .

designating the Respondent(s )-Cand id I;It&( s) as candidate(s) for" public offioe or party.

". "". .

position' of Repr~sentativein .congre:ss· frorii the' 10~11 cQngres~ion~1 . District,' KIngs

County, BQro~gh oLBrookiyn, N~'N York, in t~eDemocratic p.ai1y~ri~.ary Electi~rit()be' . "held:Septern~~r"t4';~201-o;-~nd-Up'orr~u-ihe' proeeedihgs"her~tofore'haa" herein, it Is . hereby'

..... .·t..,ert '. , '. ." '.:

••. A·'iJ';!itiPRt:tthE!'~espondents her~in,show'cau8ebfifor~this CourtAta

.Sp~cialltJ.·:t~~lectfon·.·jill$l.Part .' '. \. , to b~held:anhe$upremeCourt : ..

CGl,lrthouse, . 360 · AQams Street, Borough of Brooklyn, .Cltyqf New Yorkl ..... R.oom . . $'1 \ ..' j on thetddayof August ,201 0 l~t9:30' o'clook' i~.theforenoon~ithatday .

or ~8$oon.theii'eaft~r as counsel can be heard. whyan·.or·dershould'nofbe m(1d~ arid

entered herein; . .' .' '.' . ..' '.' '. .

1. ··6""1~~;'g iI1$ufficient,.d9tectiVe.jnvtlli~, n uil.a~dVcid th.deSi9n~~g· .

' .. petitionfiied With·the BOARD OF ELECTIONS IN THE CITY OF NEW .

YO~~, . purporting to .. de$'gnate,theR~~P9I1dent(s)~CaAdidate(~) 'as

.' . parti9;ula.rized ,In the annexed petition as ca"diqate(s) for the september' 14,2016' D~n,ocratic Party~rim.ary.Electic:Hi; and

. 2. Enj'oiriing, restrainIng, and p'rohibitlng the' BOA~D,OF ELECTIONS IN

.," I "'. • ..

'THECITYOF NgW'(OfU(fromptiritjn9andPlaCjn~r·thenanie$ ottne

saidR~5Pondent{s)~~andidate(s)on theofficralb~llotS, ;tobe~sedat the.

. . .' .' ' ." " .' , :' ...

~ " ,,' ,

. SepteJ1l~er '1412010' Dli;!mocratic P~rty Primary Electionfor·th~10th.

,',' .." . ". , . .

. . . . . '. .

. Congressional.District, 'Kings COut1ty, 'Borough o.fBroOklyn,. New York

s~tElI.an.d.whyth.e :. Petltioners should not . have • sucn other and. further . ..'

• ,. ' I • , •• ., ' •

osc"rNV~L .

Aug.02.2010 12:17

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 5/ 19

. /~

..JJ,' .."

. '. ORDEREO',thatttleRespondentBOARD OF ELECTIONS IN:THE . CITY OF NEW YORK be .and is hereby ordered anddlrect~Qto produce'upon~he hearlngoft~i~ Order tQ.BhQW causeal1d 'onaU,adjoummentsihereof, theafores~id o~signating '. petitibnJ)urp~rting to. de~i9natEi the said. Respo~~ent(s) .~ GaMdiclate(s), tp9:ethe(With

. the objecti~nsarid $pecifi(lations'relatingtothe'~fo~aid!le$ignating petition,: the .:

. ", ' '. ""', '. ," '. "'.' ...' . .... ' .

.. :,': "',, ",:: ',\ .,,' "'." ,."." ',.,'" .,: " " " ' -. " ... ,' , .:\ ',' ''', ,'.,.,,' -: .' , . .', ,', ",

.' .: permane.nt:pers0r1al VO.tef registratioh. pollre<::ords .ofvotE!rs Elt1d offiei~1 maps·for the'

··.10th :C6ri9re$~ibnaIOi$trict,CityofNeWYOrk,arid··th~ report()f.th~ Clerks ofthe~aid. .

..' • , ,,' • ' • • • I • I. • ,. ' • ," ~ • ' ,', •

" •. ,',' .~" ,." ': ,', ',:',,, ,:. ,",'i ',",", ', .. ,' : . '..... ,'''. .' ",', " ," .. " I '\. • : " , • • • ': • , '. ::' ,', • " ,,'., :""', 'ri ',' '," ", ' ':,." " ..

BOARD OFE;L;CTIONS made:onstlch obj&ctlonS3nd specifications for. exarnlnatlcn

'by th;~~our1.. -.

SUFFICIENT CAUSE APPEARINGTHEREFORE,Jeave is hereby gr9nted to the . Petiti9ne~s)tosu.bmit,.uponthe return' day 6fthis. Order to' Show CalJ~e' Brydany 'adjOurMme'ntsthereof, ~ndlh~ arg~mi~ntthereof, sUch 'a~dlti~nal' eviden~et exhib.lt$; . and otherproof 8sn~aybe'ne~s's~ry,

· SUFFIQJ5NT CAUSE APPEAR!NG THE~EFORE, .

.........•..... ~ .

. . '.~~.:serviceof.a copy .of. thla order: together with a copy o£the

pap~1'& .uponwhlch It Isgrantedj :uP9n the' ReISPondent(s)be ry,adeeith~r

. '," .... .' . .' ..... '. .... ..

"(1) bydelivering,'thE(:same 'to each:$uohRe$pohdentpersonally, p.urs~ant to.' CPLff§~08(1), tin or before the2SlhdayofJuly, :?01(), or .

· . (2) .~y~nclosinQ .th~same lna securely seaI6dan(:t(jl,J]y.prepald wrapper,.' . ·sddressed.toeachsuch Resp6hdent-C~ndidateafthe address .serfO~h in.his or her

· .' '. .

Petition filed'with the BpardofElections inthe City Of NewYork·an9 by mailing the ..

• • .' I •• \' ••• ' • • • .' •

saniei~~:PostOfficebranoh,reg:ularly maintained' bylhe United States Postal SerVice'

.' . . ....,'. '., '. . . . / .

QSC-INVAL

a

Aug.02.2010 12:17

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 6/ 19

t : =

, .

, .

" .....

In the City~of. NeVi York, with proof of mailing by c~rtificate of mailing, on. or before the ....

. ' ..

. 2Sthday Of JUIYl 2010, or

.... " ",. "" .

'. (3)byafflXir'lgthesame'tqthe • ." ...... d6oic)fthe resJdencebf each such .

.. '" ' . .' ~: . ..' . '.' '.. ' " . "

Responderit:.t:~rididate··afthe,'afjdres~s·et :forth: in:h is. or her Petition filed 'wlththe" Board

. ",,'" ',', . ,,', . ," .. . ',' . ". \ " .' '. ." ",

,,', 'I

',', ' " ., • ': '. ,"'" '"".." :,,', ," .: _.. ': ,,',', ,', ..' ':', . ", :' ~, :".' " \', "',,' "', :",' , "',' , ..• ' " v ',: " "

'. '6fEleCtipn$l~tffeCiWQfNew York;arldby'~n¢l()singthe same :.in ,asectirely'sealed .'.

. '.".,' " " ",." : ~." ' , ' " - . ' . ",. , .' . ."" .' . ' ,'" . ' ' , '. " .

arid:::duiy Pt~P~ld .wrQ~per, ..•.. ·~d(kessed /to~~eh,~yctl . 'Re~pondent~Candidate ···at tn,e

. .: ,.' .'" . :. . ,,' ... " ',' ,'".. '.

~~dre$s$etforth'in hjsor· hefpe.fiti6nfiled.wlth the8oardCif.:Ere~lbnsjr'1·theCity of' NewYorlCandpyd.epositing'ssrile iJ1BIPost Office regularly rnailitalned by the United

. ' , ",', ,. . , " " , ' , .

'S~t~s P6stafsarviC:einth~ City6fNe;~ York, withpmof~fmamng by certificate of •. mailhig,:~n;~tb~fore'the 27th d~yorJuly; 20101 or

. '. {4}b)t~ffixirig ••. th~.'~am~to.·the·"""''''' .doorof.the;reSidence .ofeach: s'uch' . 'R~spon~e~t-q@ndid~t~:~t:theaddress s~north inNs or her Petition filed with ,the Bti~ rd

. ,

'ofEleqions In·the. GJiy: & ~eviYork, andbyenolbsing lh~satTle in asecureiY'sealed .

• "', " 1,/ • • .',' " • ",', "", " '''" " ... ,' ...

. 'and(l~lypr~paid: wrapper," actdOO$aed to each suChRe~pondent-Ca~did~te atJhe

• ,"',.',' • I '." "',' ',' " " ",' ..' " ",' ."

adq~~!i!.~~tforth··in· :hls'or ,her P~tjtionfil~ wr~h •.. theaoard. o(~lecti(ms in 'the·Gttyof

.' .. , ," .' . ',' , '., ". .. .' , '. '.

New.Yor;k arid by depositillg ·the: same'~ith'acarrter that guarantees serviG6 by

•. ,..;~~"t .' .... . ". . .•.. , .. ' , " .. . ..... . .' '.'

. ovemiShi'aelive,yon or befcire the 2e1f1day Of July, 20·10; .

'.' . and that such.s·erolce·sh6lH be deemed due, timely, good and.sufficient s~fvice.

Hen, ..•..... . ..... -, ..... .

"Justiceofthe 'Suprema Court of ,the .. . . State of NeW Yqtk

g~&H.~~···. . ' - .. - .. ". ¥\II..,.T

Aug.02.2010 12:18

THE-UPS-STORE

. ".,

... ~

'. '91.';" Wd .: 2Z10r U IUZ .

O~~1~lf3 -. ..' .

'11"31' ~;.I ··~.h""\'" SrHJtl1

. ,11 U . " Q'~\ I~r I."~,,\ ".r..; .;J I 'Ii' ;. " .

, ,'''\ ,,'

13472960131

..

~·~"·':"iN~kiO .. '~, '.. .' . . .

It· ''''....... . . · .. ~..I··<~.I.:-.. . .. .

. ··n,;,r.~ 4fI' ro': .:' • ".'H'I"'~";'<"< .ll.;.' .... " ..'

. . .... ,-:.<.._ '.' .... p' ~~'. Jou..-.. ." "'_". '. '.':-r.-.~'.;(.. :.I!'" ;" .. ",~ .

. '"_'''<lI,,''''' .. .,...~ 1;~: .. , r », '_'.

li,. i>~'. ~ ". t<1:~~J~~ .. ' :'"It-.,";~ .•

~"'*'.~ .- ..." . : . '7"'"lC" ifq{ ':~~J'j'" ..: .• ·'1'1

""- .. "-:T l<w ......... ~ "'11. ... to· .

~.,.~~'. "..,~ :M.':' .'" .&'';'~~I..1 _'·"t· ' ........ .. ,,,' t"'".+iII ~"'.~;·'

. .... 1'71;.11"",; •. a..:.'~_J' ,,_. ~. .: .".'.'

; •• \I"! "'." ". .'''~. ......... . ..... ~ ...... '.1 ..

. ,·: .. "."W1J.~~':~~~~.:·

.... . (.,.... . ....,_ t("...... ... '."

' .. ' ." ,., '.~;';!)'\ •• -~~ .. ~"_ '_~ ..

.' .. ' . .' . .', .'~ ~ ~"'*r~'l~~ .

PAGE. 7/ 19

. <

Aug.02.2010 12:18

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 8/ 19

SUPREME COURTOFTHE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTYbFKiNGS .. .. .. . . ...

.. . -~"".-.-~-.,;.~---~.,.--.~--~.-,;;.,.:..-----------.:.-----;.--------------.,.---.-------x

In the Matb~roftheApplication of .

EDOLPHUSTOWNS,

. Candidate Aggrieved, . ··lndexNo.

Pe{itiQri~r ,

-against-

KEVIN POWELL,·

Raspcndent-Oandldate, .. . -and-

. .

BOAR[). OF· ELECTIONS IN THE. CITY OF NEW YORK,.

PETITION. TO· INVALIDATE .

Q~~IG~ATING PETITION

.•• Respondent, For .an OrderPursuant. to Sections 16..:100,16;.102·

· and 16;.116oftheElection UlWj Declaring lnvalidths . basigriating .. Petition purportil)Q topeSignate .' the.

· Responderit(s);;Candidate(s) for the PublicOffice.qr. party positionofRepresentativein Congressfrpni the 10th Congressional [)istrict,Stat~.of New York in .the.

. Democratic. PrimarY Election to . be h~ld .. September .' 12~ 2000,. and to Restrain the said.BOARDOF ELECTION$Jrom Printing arid . Placing the Names of saidCandiqate(s) . Upon the . official .. Ballots of Such .

... Primary Election. ... . .

· . -. ......... +-' ....... ~~~~~':"~~_.~_~~_~ ~~ __ ~,_ ... _~It".". ... ..;.",...,..:~ ..... ~_~ .. ~...;_~-----~~-,~--~-----~ X'

. . '. \

TO THESUPREMEC~URT OF THE· S;ATE·O~NEW YORR: .

The Petitioner(s) respectfully show and Allege that:

1. That· at all . times hereinafter mentloriec, . the Candidatets) . Aggrieved, ....

EDOLPHUS TOWNS,· was and stili is a dulyqualifie.d votens) of the State ofNew York,

- 1-

• I'" ',' '," ,I',"'.

\' I' "," ~-, •• , ." •• ,,': "/,., .,',.,. .' ","" /", '" '/ ","" :'

""'(":",,1,,' , .' .

Aug.02.2010 12:19

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 9/ 19

running· in the September .14~ 2·010, PnrnaryElecnon, in the 1 o" Congressional District in the state cif New York.

2: .•...• That at .all of the times hereinafter mentioned,theRespondent SOARD OF. ELECTIONS IN THE CITY OF·. NEW YORK .was and ls charged with the

. responsibilityotthesupervisionof theconduct of the official elections heldintheCitY ~f·

.',' ,,' '. ' '.. .' . . \'"

.~e\N York,i?CIHdi~gthf3dutiesof rec~iviry98fldfilingdE!~.ignatingpetjtjonsfQrpubljc . .. offlceor pa~y . position in ·poHtiC:~l's~bdivisicms.I()¢ated··~ntfn9Iywithjn the Gityof·New

. York; the revieW anddetermihationofbbjec;tions· ahdspecifi6ations o(objectiOhS to SUChdeSignatjngp~titions,.m~intairiin~:the'per~an~ntPersonal voter regIstration· POll· . recordS8hdofficiai maps for all election districtslCJc~ted within the Citypf New York,

.' I ' ," '. • • .,. ' ,

. ',' ..." ,"',. . " .' ..

811(j the preparation of officialPrlmaty, SpecIal and General .Elelctlon ballots,

3.· Thaton or about JUly.12th 2010, there were filed with the .sOARD OF

. ELECTIONS IN THE CITY OF NEW YORK certain papers~lIegedlY constituting a

. ,"". . .. ' . " . " ...'. . . ' .

. petition. purportingtodesignateJor thesePt~mbe:r 14,2010, Dernocratlc Party Primary

.' '... ..' ..'. .

. Election thE!. folloWihgperson(s) forlthe Public office and/or P~rty Positionastrereinafter: ' .....

. \ .' .

set forth:

. .

. .tia!rul..!2LC.lmdkl.&

. KEVIN POWELL

Ey!)IIC Office or party er.iSilion .

. ~Q.q Place OfB!ilSi('lence

.' ..

.. .

Memberofthe U.S . Congress from the ro" Congressional

. ·Oistrict~icicated· in· Kings. Cpunty, State ofNewYork

176 Johnson Street, Apt. B~B· ... . . Brooklyn; New York ·11201

• I ' •

~ 2 - .

PgT-INVAl.

'" 'I,' ,.,,'" ,.',\

',."' ..

Aug.02.2010 12:19

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 10/ 19

4. ,Upon informati'on' and .bellet, that the aforesaid, all~ged desigriating

. ." . "

petition filed by or onbehalfofR~Spondent-Ca'ndida~e'is ,insuffidenttineffectivet false,

fra~dulent" .and invalid, does not conform to the provisions of, lheElect'ioriLsw and ,otherlaW6,of theSt~teof N~w'York: and the rufes,and,regulations ,of the BOARD OF ,

ELECTJONSJN THECITY OF'NEW YORK, and is null and Void by reas~nof the facts

:" .".',' ", I', ,,' .'. .'," ',". ,,' ' ••

and a/legations~etforth hen3in,'and the HespoDdenfBDARD OF ELECTIONS IN T~E , , , CrIT OF NEW YORK 'Sho.uld ,be restrained, and~njoin~d 'from ',p,rintingthe naIT1es'of

said '. Respondent(s} Candldate(s) upon the official, ballots "of said Democratic' party

, '

,PrimAry Election,

5. LJPOl')inforrnation and belief"that 'the d$S'ignatingpetitiol1 de$ignatingthe,

~espondent(s), ~,'Candidate($)' for the .aforesald pubUc,offlce and/or party position is invalid by, reason of the folloW!og facts: "

(a) That the .petition doe~ not. contain the, minimum number of, requir~d, vafid

'signatures of enrollee andJorregistered voters for' the. respective

Candldate. ' "',

Thafl11any of the signatures were not parSon~lIysignedbythepersons w~o'sel1a01esappearupon the saidpetitions, 'but their names were Signed '\NithouttheJrauthprity and without their knowledge: .'

(b) •

Th~t' many.bf,thesignershavenot registered Jrom',re,$idenCes' given,,'in ' sald-petmonanc werenotand are not'qualifiedelector;rof the Election

, Distri'ctsstated and their Hames can not be counted as valid.' '

. " " . ., '. ' . . ' , ,',

. ,':' ",

(0)

Th~tma!1Y ofthesignersdidnotidentifyfheJTlselves to the.subscnbinq '

'witheS:sesassetfortl1,iri the designa,ting petition. ' '

," :Thatmany ofthe signers did not subscribe their names to thepetiti~nin the presence of the' subscribirig witnesses on the dates indicated .on the

petiti()n. ' . " , , '

'That signatures to the said petitionwe.reobtainedin vlolatlon of law.

(e)

(f)

, ~,3-

,PET·INVAl

•• ,_, ... ,.,.,', , •••• , •• ,,_: .... ,\"" •• ':' ,,',,,.,, •• ,,:,,.I,,,.n •• 1., .• 1'"1" •• , ••• 1".,,.

. ,,\,', ",\':,,,,,. .

Aug.02.2010 12:19

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 11/ 19

. . , .

That' each o(thec()v~r s i,.eets otme .petltion is Improperly ftlledout, thus

in:,jalidijtingt~eentirepetition. "" ' "

,(h) ,ThCltrna~y t>rther~sp~qtive sVb~q~ibi~gVJitne$seSdid 'not actual!ysee the separatesignatorieis,s.ubsYfibetheir, individual signatures thereto. "','

(g)

(i) ,

, That.the~Ob$crjbing " witne~$es' of : some '; Of', all' ,of ,the' .sheets 'of ,,',tbe', "P!Jrp'ort~dPrti~iQll did'ncit::~i19w.,eaCh:f;lnd, everyone of the sig,natories of,

th'EtrespeCtiveshl:!ets'flutherith;:atedbythern, ' " ,

:' ' ",,/' .'.' ,':' "'. " .' "

'0) ,,' .. r'hijlt .. ~oiT1.e' Qf the" respective : statemehts of Witnesses on the ,pu rported ,', , ,'pe~itIQnw~r~llot'~(!tu~IIY'E:lxecut~d ,bythe'respyCtjY,ewitnessesori'the

, d€itesindicated." ,,' ,:,' , , '" , "" ' ' ,

" "

(k) " ' : ThatoHsome'of the fesp~ctive$heets of the porportedpetition I r:n:;iteri~L alt~ratlQns .. and/or . aqditiqns Were· therf3blimade'subse(JV~nt.· to . 'the ... .. obtaJplnQofth~·Siignaturf;is· thereon and/or 8ubsequenttothe execution" .'

thered,fbythesubscribingwifnesses: ' ,.. ,

. (I) ··Thai the purported petition IS replete. withfraudulent'dates' 'and'forged·

signatures arid/or initials of signa tori as aDd/o(sUbscdbing witnesses. . .

• • 'I .' I '.' •

That many: offbe .. sjgn~tur~s,affjxsdto.the, p~rported ,petition were so .. affixeda$,theresult··offalse,ancl fr~udUlentr$~resentationsmade tcthe

.. signers,Oy· 'the circlJl~to~(ll1t1 ,subscribing.· witness~s.of th~'p'etiti6n; .and the s,ignatu~es were affix~oin reliance 'upon .such.misrepresentatlons.". .

• • • "," • "'.1' ".

(rill··

. (n)

'(0) ..

PET-INVAL

T~~tonsomeorano.fthesheets.{)fthe p~rported'petition, there appear .... . ·signafutes otpersons who were' not properly apprised' as to tbe import or

thedocumenttheywere'$ubscribin9, . .. ,..... . .

That the purported petition is invalidby reas~n·bf·n,:>tbeing .incornpllance .

· with ·'aw, ".inctUc:iing,butnotlimited to··.the'f6I1ow,irigre'ason: (i)tha volumes are, notpropetly numbered;:(lj) 'me total number ·of volumesjs not ByGU rate Iy set forth foreach carididClte; (iii)thefirst, and last page$of.each

. volume ere not accuratelvsei forth for 6~ch cCilldidate;(ivJ theJQtai . nUmber of. pages. of each volumearenof,accurately. set forth for each candidate; (v)thetota Inu mberof sig natu rescontainedl neach volume. Is

· . not ac~ur1:itelY'.5~tfbrth for each candidate; (vi) the to{(lLnumber of p~g~s

. com prlsi ngth$ .petition' is notaccurately set forth tor e(lc.hc~nd Idate;( Vii) the, totalnutnberof signatures contained iii the petition is not accurately set forth fot, each candidate; (viii) the name ofths. d~signatedcandjdate(s), is not a~equat~Jy set forth; Ox) the p.erSQri{s) appearing as the desIgnated candida,te(s)is·notquaJified for nomiriation,:orelectionto ,the: position-or o,fficeOpecifled; (x): the .frue ·residencea'ddress: of the p,erson(s) desi,gnated is not adequately set forth; (xi)thedesc:ription of the pOSition

- 4 -

• '1","""'"

,'\" ,,\, "\.,,.1 .... ,,·"

n.", "',',' • ",'."" ",".: • ".

Aug.02.2010 12:20

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 12/ 19

or'9fficefor,whiCh designation. lspurportedly made is inadequate and/or

·'nacc(:jrate. . . . . . . ..,

.. Th,at th~,~on.tent of tile individual sheets. com pilS! ng the. purported' petition

ls:npUn c()mplian~:withJaw; inCluding JO( the.loUoWingreaSpns: (i) the. ," pr~all1bl~ is . insufficient andlori~'ad~qu$~e'; ,(i i)th~ n~me6fth~'gesignated' ,c~ndj,q~te(s)isn()t'(l~e,quat~lyset'fbrth; .. ·(iiI) .th~ ·per$on(s).~ppeatinga's ..... ' th~Q¢$lg[l.atecj,canqida1e(13):isnotqualified fo(nomina~ion. orel~ctio.n to' .

· the:pqSltionOfOf{ic~\ sp,Qcifi~~ ;(iv)Jhetrue'J$ls,q~nq~ad~re~s,6fth~ ..... '" 'p~~6n{s) designated is. riot '~eclJrateIY .S9tfOrth : (v).·the d$scription.ofth~ ..... ,pp~jtjC~~ or offiCfj, fGrw,hich.desj~n~.ti9n·i$purpqrte.dlY:lT1ada itljn.acJ~q~ate -.

· "otin~ccurat~;, (Vi).a committeetp fi lI\I'ac~n6ies' is, not properly a ppoipted;

· (v!D ~~e·.perS~r($)$,p'~9Ifl~d:jn .the,cprryrDitte.etQfiH·:vacandes'8re·not: .' q'yslififa(,f;. (V.iii) .thefoITn.~fth~ slgmiturearea. does .. ·hot:confopri1 to the: spepificatiQns of law; (ix)·tht?formof the 'statement-otwitness dossnot

c6nfdrm,tothespecificatloil~ of law. .: ' ... ' . . .'

. (q). "'That-the'pages' of the p~rportedpetitionare not.accuratetyor

. consecutivelypaginatect.· "'.' . . .' .

.... (r) . That njariyoithe slgnatoriassetfOithincomPlete, in$Uffl~en(oruritrue· .

· re$idenc~addresses, orncaodresses, . .'

.' (s).

(u)
(v)
..
.. ..
. (w)
(x)'
(y) '. (p)

Tha.tm~nyalteratjonsl interllneatione;: erasures and mutilationsappear in· dat~s,$ignatur.a$jaddresses,eleytiondlstracts, .and ass~mQJyt:li$b'icts' of

signers> .... . . .., . .' '.

Thatinsqmeinstances., thepersori .nstecas the.~ubscrlb'ng wjtnessin the' . introductiohof . the-statement of witness is not the same' person . who. executed.the statement of witness. .

.Thatseverai sighatures wet~ subscribed priodo the first day for signing designating petitions. ..' .. .. . ' .

•. Thatseveralsjqnanires weredatedsubsequerit to the last daYfdrsigili~g '.

designatingpetith:1f1S'; . . ,. . " . .

. That many of those wh9se sigOi!tures ClPpsar onsaid purP6rteQ petition · ha'd, priorthereto,'~roh the.samedate; already signed same. ..

• '" .'." ." •• ', I.' .' •

That. in' some·. in-stances, the date of execution of witness statements is"

· missing, incomplete, or.insufflclent . .

. That Insever~linstan6esj'thedateofexecutionofa witness statement on asheet is prior tothed~t.e· one or more signatories signedthe.saidsheet.

-5 -

... ..". '," •• " ::', -.' ".. ••• I • i "" :,'~", I " " , " " /', \ ,:' "," " • ""\',,'

': '"'' ,~", .. " " "'''1\ "~I' ":

'" "/ ,:, ,,~., " ",'

Aug.02.2010 12:20

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 13/ 19

,,', .

(z)

. Th~t many signatories, dates, aqdresses,elebtioJ'l districts, and assembly

olstrictsappurtenanrto signature.sareillegibJe. .

(aa) ... That.somesignato.desfailE!d· tos~tfQrth·theirel~ctioh districf:Clnglor assemblydi.strict,orfail~d to ·accuratelysf3tforth 'said election .dlstnct ..

and/or assemblydistrlct. .

,',,' \ .

.. (bb) . That thecl~te orsClmesigrjaturesJsincompletE,!;missing or maccurate. •....

.,'n,'.

" .. \',

That many persons signing· st=-idpurport~.(j~etjtib.tl· $re· not ·rt?9iste'red· .: and/or.enro It~dvoters, a~ ·slf,tt~d, .j3Jthbug h they·allegeOli. thei rsheets that

.th~y arer~gis~ered:~ndlbren~oUe~~ .. ... .. . .. ., .

. (dd) . ThatrnanY5i~~ptbriesfailedto8eUorthth~irGQmpleteandtru·enames ..

• ',.' I', •• • • •• " , • •

... fee) .. That in severallnstancee.theaddressesse! forth for signers are incorrect .

arid, insomein$tances, said addressesde not exist. .

.(ff)

That. in-some .. instances. . the.subs~ripi~g witnesses on the. respsctiv& sheets Jailed to accurately set . forth ,orset . forth , at all, the . number of sighature:scontalned on the sheets. .. .

. " " .' . ;,,'

(gg) That -vartouacerecna who subscribed .their. names to. the purported .. petition do not reside. -in the poljtic~lIJur.isdictioi1 or geQgraphib area wh~reiri the • Responoent(s) . - . C~n¢jjdate(s)se.ek nomini:ttion,~nd/or·

election.· ..

(hh) . That·$ome'signatures of signers· and/orsubscribirig witnesses were $xecUted:in.pencilornot in ink ..

. .' . ',' ,,',,',

That some slgnat~resare ·~ated, leiter than the dates, of : sig·na~ures appearingthereaft(ir,on the.sarnesheet." ..

. ····OJ)·. Tha·tsqme.signatures .. are . dated prior than the· dates ·ofsignatures appearing above. them, on the same. sheet.

.. (ii)

'. ·(kk) .. Thai the names of persons appearing as signers. were print~dor not

handwritten; .. .

... (II) . ···That rria~y of' those whose signatur~sap.pear. upon said petition, had, prior thereto, or on. the same date. 5ign~d another petition for the same

office orpetltlon. . . . .

(mm) • That.on.the respective .·sheets,· morethanon« signatUre .appearsin the

saniehandwdting. . .

- 6-

. PET-INVAL

•• .. •• ..,'. ..1 •• " "" , •• , \ ",,,1,,,.. " ", \ \., "', • ,I' ' .. "".. \ :.: /', "I"~ .,' /" .,' ',. , /'",,,. ,I '~"" '~"'\'" •• • ... 1 •• " • • ••• , •• ~" .... I • "" •••

.. 1""".",

Aug.02.2010 12:21

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 14/ 19

(nn)Th~~ in· some metances, the person whose -. name appej;lrsasthe . ~lJbsciibjnglNitr)ElsSon:a she~t elso app~arsasasigriatory.on the $heet

(00) That on . respectjve~heets,theperspn t:lP·p~arjngas·the.subs9ribing

. 'YJlth~~"Sis:bot ar~g'i$ter~d voter as' st~h3dalthough .lt' is .stated . that such ..

. person Js a re~ister~d"voter... '. , .... '.

I: .',

(rlp)·' Thet.cn r~s.pectiv$s~ef3ts, t~e' nan1e'of thesub~Gribing witness: iSrl;issing .•. .

frOITl·t.he:intr:oq.Udion to.ttleWil[les$:$taternent. <>. . '.

(qq). That onresp~¢tive$h~ets,thesigriatLireofthesu~~6ribing'witnes$i$: .:

~issing;.. .... '. . . ... " .

..

(rr). . Th~trnal1Y:of.the, persqns who·.appear··cn re~P8ctive:' Sheets.as .

· $lJbscdbjrigwitne$.S~i;;are.nqt prop~rly,·regi~t~req to vote; notvyithst$OQfl1.9 '" that:'the 'Respondent"BOARD: OF ELECTIONS·IN·-t.HEC·ITYOFNEW·

· YQRI(' rna.ilit~ins·$ajdperSOns:a$ registered " v6t"ersin their 'permahent ..

. personalYqte r'registraticin 991 II~dgers. . ., .•. ,... . .

(sst· ·"[hatperSbt1·s; ·namElswere·:printed.up"o"n . the.· •. p.LlrPorted ,petition'. and .: .'. circulated thereonwithouttheirco:nsent. .:

.. ' '. .,' ,. ..,,:: ':. ' , .' ,:. '.

. (U)

Thi3t m~nYOf.theper80nswho·~pp:ear,aSsubSOribing~itne's~es on r~$p~ct'yeshe~ts.a reo notq U.~.I i,fled t~J~.9t·as subscribing .. Wit~~sse's ~n"tl1f:l pUfP()rted" petitiQnbecauli9 theyde.hotreslde in thepoliticaJ:unitwhereiri the R:espbride.nt;.Gandiqate(s)$eekrv~rninatioriandior electibn .. ' .. ' ...

~uu): Thar m~nY'of thesu.b$9r,ibing witnesses on respectivesh~~ts,setforth

incbrnplete;insuffide:nt; or untrue residence address.ee,dr n6addresses~:~" .. , ....

. \' . ~

.. (vv) .. Thatm'~nybfthe SLJb.$cribing.wjto~$ses. on resp$ctive ~heet~j: h'ad .•. prlbdp • · . the execution of th~·irwltoess.$tat~ments.;6ron the .sam~d~teisigned·.

another'petitionfodhe sarneofflce or petition. . . ... .. '. '.

(WVf)· 'That maJ1:Y$ubScribi~gwitness~~ f~lled to .set forth their··election . district . and/orassembly districtor 'faiied .toaccorately. setfortb said ·"election

.. distriCt·alld/or ;:1s$~mt>iYdlstridt,·:~ '. ·· . . . . .. .

(xx)'. Thatma~1Yalterati6rls:,e.r~$Uresi·and "nJutil~tionsappe'ar. insignature's, .addr$ss~s. ~iecti()ri.cdis.tdcts;as$¢rribIYdi$triqt~~ n'umber of. signatures on .. ::lh~et;.d~tesi.· and/or.signatu"resin witn.ess .. statements on ... respective.

sheets. .. . .... . . . .

. (yY) Jhatin several iristances, signatures ofeignersBl'ld sub$cri~ing vilit.h~;:"~~§, ...

wereffaoed Or gorie·Over. ..

-7-

PET-INVAL

• • .1. I ..... _._~"_"""'I\\II"'·.M.I I ..... , ., ........ " .. "'.'." •• ". "". ,.... • .·~I.·.

". -.

... , .... ' .... ,'.

. .

..... : .. / "."' " , : ,' / .. : ,

• / ,' " ~.:-'.~ •• ''''',' .. ' 10 .

Aug.02.2010 12:21

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 15/ 19

.. That .. sornao! th~J~er~onswho.slgned.theirnal1Jes to, thepurpcxted·

'. petition . have transferred their ~nr()nrnent:'toother~(jqre.ssesarld/,cjr .' .

electiol"ldi!)trictssub~equent tosigni~g s~id petiti~n.... . ,

(a~i:l)' Th~t Jl~anY.oftheSigne~~ of the purponed petit!orIcfid· ~otdeclare orswear . . . to the .. p~r$on$:V~hQ 'secured theirsignaturesthi.=ltthe: statementscontained

thereiii.wf3're trll~. . . ..' . . .

'\':

(bbb) . J'he.·totalnlJmtu:!r:c)fsigOatureS$,elforth.~nd: cl~im ed ih' ea,ch:\vqiwne' .'

exce~dstheactual. humber of. stg natures which,oan~bevalidlY:oIajhlE;ld. as . .: ··~elr!y<ofthesigrratorifl$:ar~no.r qyi1Hfi~cUo~I9~as.: they~r~ ':not~~$jd~Pts,. . . '. ot':t~,~Ass~mbIY'>ahd/or 'Elec~iOIl':Disfrlct'f6r, 'w~'ich ,.eC)ch •• :.ljoILJme Js: •.. · .'

. ' 's,ubmltted, Thi~Jact:js'!;1ppateMtonthef~Ge·of.th€l, va.t;ioqs·$beets bfe~'ch '.

'.. volume,'·.... .....•. "., ,..... .. . . . /.' .: .' .: .•.. ".;::: .

', ...

(ccc)'fheft~ta.I·.numb~r: qfsignCltur~s ,s~t :.f6tfh:.and:.cl,aimeq hlthe p~fitj()n . e~ce$d$,the actual oumber:ofstg.natures~hlch ·cah:be vali~ly claimed. as mar,yofthl:l" signatories are not qu~iified t6S'rg~a$theY"~renotresldents ofthe:Asserntily.ari~/or El~ctioM 'Districtfo( which tht3Pt9tition··ls. s ubrnitted. . ThISf~ctlsapparei1tonth€dat:e ofthia varibussheets6f.the petltl(jr'L '.... .

. " ' , , , .' " ' . . . . ' " ,. ., .' .

"', (ddd). That·thepurpqrtedpetition .is invalid· for'. ot~'er re~sons;which Vvilr qe

. ·establi$hedupon the hearing'of the epplicatiqn', . , .'

. ' . ,,' . . ' . ' . ' . ',. ". . ' '.~.' .

(eeE}) . That.cbml11is$iOn~r8,of: Daedsand/or NotariesPublicfaiied tosrgn their'. narri~s : Qr~x~c4te' thfji(. dornmisS.ionsproperlydrp·~rsllarit't6 . applicable

l~w,r,lIle$ndlprJeguJation.: .. . .. .' ..

. '. , ,',' ,'. .' .

. (fff) .. ' ThatGpmmissiorierSpf Deeds and lor Notanes. Rublicfa'iled'td properlyfihs .

their c9mniiSs'iQ~swith th~prrjper auihoritiesPursuant,tci applicableiaw, .

rule'and/or regulatIon ". " "', . ., .'.

'(999) That· various'pe~ons who are listed'. as candidates .on the purported. . . .' .' petltlon-do h.o(r:~,s.ide. in the ". pplitiQal . ~urisdittlqn6r.geograptlic:area . . ." wl1!3'rei'n.the R'espondent(s).Candii:l~te(s)seeknomination and/or-election,

, " ' .' " .' 'I • " " """ '.. '"

. . '1.3, .. LJPor.information and b~lief, thartheR~spondEmt(SJ.mG~r1didate(s) doss" not resldeatfhepl~ce ··of residence asstflf~d rnthe.aUeged.:&~signatin~· petjtion~

: ......,..... '., '. . "'.' . '" .

14.upOhjnfOrmatlo~· and :beiief, that in cither,respects;r)1any ofthesiqnatures .

, . . ..'. .

and sheets may not becounted as validr andthat, in other respects, upon infprrllation'

• ". • • I '. '. '. "," ",. " •

aRdbelT~f~ the signers 'lathe purported petition, the C~rldidate, and the subsbrib'ihg:

. -8.-:.

PET-I NVAL

I •••• " • ',',.,/,. "',,'"

... ,. ':''''.',,,.

Aug.02.2010 12:22

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 16/ 19

. .",. "

. wltnesses wer~.paifie·stofraudulent ·.Condupt; .. and .: uppnihforrnation and' bE!Hef,: by

reason thereo{and' on the basisOfth$'all¢gatiril1$he~$tofore setforth herein,thesaid

• , " " ,,,,, ,', ': I •• ,"'. , " .', : '," :,",":>' . ,"'" , ,',.' ',' " .. ." :.".' .

p.urporteddesign~ting petitibnis permeated Withfraud.so.as to vitiate it initsentir~ty~ '.

I " ,. ", ",," " •• " ", ....

',15. T~~t,in;accorqarlc~with .pricir:deci,sionsqfthisahclother GourtSl' whose ."

. ",. '. ,," : \ ' . . '" .. ' . . . .. ",. /"

deci$jOns.·ar~·controllihg" petiti6t)er(~)..retain.·.the·dghtjO.··su~mit,proofe~taqlishing th.~··

• ' • I,'" I, ,'" •• " • '" •

invalidity. ofiridNi~U~1 signatures~ndsheets 01)' the. PlJrported.p.etitlpii not:heretbf~re ..

. ' \' \' " " .. :,': .. . .. ,' .. ' ' ' .. :

. '. ObJ~cted to.iand o( the p~tp?rtedpetiti(Jnitself; Jor : reason~' .~ofhElretofor~:specifled, .

. .,'.... .

and F>et!tjbne~(~))rit~ndto ex~rcise·$u¢h·right. .

·16~·· .. ' That-your:Petitiprier(s)request leaVE!an~Te·seiVe·.therighno submitupon· ..

. . '''. .. . .' .. - ... ., ,; ... .'.: ,'. ~'-- ~ ."-,', ..

. __ _ : . ......:. .. : ,\ .. '

, . .

theargUme;'t·al1dhEtaring.ofthisapplic~tion,f3~i~encebywaY·bf.affidl:tvits, testimony,'

'. .' ....... .'. ' .... ' . . ". " .

. . anddo.cUh1~l1t~~ proof to supstantiatl! and support this. appllcation, .

17. '. ThatPetltlonens) requestthe R,?spondehtBOARDOF !=LEGTIQNSIN .. lHE CITY OF NEWYOF~Kto produce upon the argument and haaring oUhis .

. ". ' . '. ..' . . .

'. applic~tjon the purported petitjOn',ObJections:;Sp~clfjCationSOf,6bjections, map~'I,ariq

.' '. ." .. ' . . . .

. records prcividedJorintheanriexed OrdertoShow Cause...

. 18. OthElrtha~this pr~~eedihg,your P~tjtioner(s)hava no . adequate, .

sufficient, or effective remedy or means.ctrellettn thy premises; .

. ·1~.lh.~r~er to' ef\ectil\lmediatepersonalservice of theanpeXeqOrder to ShowCaus$ahdthis Petition onthe Respol1dentBoARD bFELECTIONSl N THE.

. ." . . . '., . ~ . .'. . ..,'" . .... . ..' ..... . .

CITY o'F NEW YORK, the to;"n1'issIOrier~()f whorll~re 're(tuir~d at various tii,,~st~be on offlclalbuelneeeat places other than their officl~l:business office~,itis re~pectfUlly .: requestedthat'thts Court direct thatsucb service:may be made upon any Commissioner

. '.. .. '.. ..,. .,'. . . "". . ' ...

. Of EiectionS, or at the General Office (headquarters) of, thesaid'BOARD OF .

-9 -

PET·INVAl.

.' . .

... I ••• '. • r' . .:. \ ...... \ .. , .... ~, .• " .. ' .' \ ..:.

Aug.02.2010 12:22

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 17/ 19

ELECHONS·at32.: Broa~way,BOrough·Of Ma'nhattan,'NewYOrkdty,' NewYork, or at .

. " . ',' " ' , ',' ,', .... ', ,' ... " ", .'. ' .' ",

the. offIce of any Chief Clerk of said BOARD OF E.LECTIQNSii1a.nyboroughinNev~r

.,,' ." ' ., ",'" . ,. ',' ," .... " . " . .' ,', . ' , .

York City.

20. '. . No: previr)lJsapplica~.ion·by Petitionerts) has bsenmadefor the reli$f .. · . soughtherell1 orrorthe Order toShowCause:here~nto .annexed,Orfor: ·anysiJ11jl~r·.

," '" ". "'" """", ' . " . \' " " ", ,/"" ',', ,',,". " ' "

relief.

", I

.' VVHE'REFORE, 'yourPetitibner(S}TespeotfuJlypr~yfortheani1exed:order •... :

,',' ':',."" , .,'., ',". ' . ,,' " '. " ' ... '" " '''''', .. ,' .,,,,,,',, ,"':".,", .

. to show caus~andforafihaf.brde(grantingthe·r~lief:RnlYedf6rin the saM order tc ." .

. ",. ,',: .. ,':" . ' .. ,: .',",: " ""', ',' ... ,., ,""". """",.," . ' "",,',' "" "

.. ,show c811se.andfbr S.lJeh .other·and·'·further relief as to this·Cpurt·rtiaYSeen1jLi~ran(j ' .. '

• ".' .", " "'" • , " ,'I ",,, ,',,'" '" ., " .,' , ,,'" '. ", ,',. _""'~ ,.. ", .n, ' •

. proper

'.' in. the premises, .

DATED: Br90~lyhjNew York July 19th 201 O.

ALTER&BARBi\RO, E$aS, Attorneys f9rp;etitionef(s): . 26GourtStreet1S'uit~18t2 '. .. ' ..

. . .·.BroClklyo, NeW,.Y-ork 11236-3730 .: .

Tel: (718)237~0880 .

tit·· .

. ·7)J;} .. /~

Br ~~" ..• ' .•.

BERNA'RM. ALTER, a membeqJfth¢"fJrm

- 10 -

.... , 'I"" ".:, •• " • \,1,,' I " •• ".: ••• " .".~, • •

'/. ," '., .. , .. \ .

• • .'""".~. I.

Aug.02.2010 12:23

THE-UPS-STORE

13472960131

PAGE. 18/ 19

. STATE OF NEW YORK'

. ' ,\ . ' .

COUNTY OF KINGS

.. .

) jss.:

J

. rh~. Undersigned, being duly 8wom, deposes. aridsays:

That he is . the petitionerin the within pto~e~~ing;that .he has l~e~d the ....

.. .... . . . .

. foregoingpetitionandknows the contents thereof; that the same is trueofhis>·6r .

. .herownknowledge exceptasto those mattersthereinstatedto be or alleged on informationand beliefand.as to thosematters..he beli~.v~sjtto be true .. ·.· .' .

Swornto before methis

. \ '1 .. th day ofJtily 20 1 0 .'

...... "., •• " •• I" •• ,,_ , •• II"" .1" ..... ",:,. '"

: .... :,,,1,'."""\""", 'I .:, • ,/

13412960131

Aug.02.2010

12:23

, SUPREME ()OURTqF J'HESTATEOFNEWYORK ,,' , '" CO~NTYOF'KINGS

, . .-.,. ... ,;.~ ... ~~_, ... ~~~ .... ,;..,--~ ... ~-.:....,~_;~;. ... ~ ... -~~-~~~..:.~~*~~-~:.....:~ .. - ..... -~-~a,-.:.-· ... --- .. ~x' '

"EDOLPHl.J.S TOWNS' ·

PAGE. 19/ 19

lndexNo..

"ORoeRiTC>S~QW ,

Can', d,id, ate- A,g', grle, ved r ',' , ,CAYSE yC) Jfi.V~lIOATe ..' ,

" ,OESIGNATING,:PE'ttTlON

• • ". ~ ,I' ,.' , ••

,,' ..

.PetltiCiner, "

, , ',',:.against-"

.. , .

.. KEVINPO\NELt '" "

.' "", ' ....

'Respondent~C~ndidate!: ' "'~and.;,:'"

, 'BOARD OF ELECTIONSINT,HE CFrv()F'NEW " '

. .,'., , ' . ' ." .'.

YORK,

.: .'. ",' "" ' . ," . '. '", ..

• ,;,~ .... ~ ... ~-.....~:';~:"-"",:,"·~ .. ;~u ....... ...: .... ~:, ... .:.~_ .. _ ... ....:.~,:;..~~ ..... _ .. _ _'"""""_,,,,_": ••. , -~ .. - ... - ... ~ .. ~ .... .,,..""'..; ....... "':.:X. "

, ,ALTER and BARBARO, ESQS .. " '26COl1RT,Si{tEET~ ROOM 1'812"

'B,ROOK:LYN,N.Y.11242 ' ' ,

,Tele: '(71~}2j7~0880" '

, AttlU:~ey'~,f()rPetitioner'

........ , ."".'1, '" ,,'''.' ""." 'I •• ,,'1

, """.,',. ,,,, :., ',. 'I ,.' " ' •. ~. ,

\ .. ~ .. ~ ".. " .... ~, ,. ,"I :

, ,

_-: ~ i.,. __

, ' """" ,

,'. . \''',''. ,/,.' . '". , .... ~" " ,