Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Minor Project
For
Paper Code: MMJN 255
Master of Mass Media
GGS IP University
Delhi
Name: MAMTA
Enrolment No.:0202034008
MMM III Semester
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Certificate
This is to certify that _MAMTA_, a student of Master of Mass media Guru
Gobind Singh Indraprastha University, enrolled for the batch 2008-10, with
Enrolment no. _0202034008_ completed her Minor Research Project ‘Food
Security and Its Media Coverage’ as part of Course Code: MMJN– 255.
GGSIP University
New Delhi
Date: 1.12.2009
1
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Declaration
I, _Mamta_, a student of Master of Mass Media (MMM), with enrolment
number _0202034008_, batch_2008_, at Centre for Media Studies (CMS),
Guru Gobind Singh Indraprastha University Delhi, have undertaken Minor
Research Project (Course Code MMJN– 255) as prescribed in the third Semester.
This report based on my research and is submitted herewith for evaluation in the
Third Semester.
Date: 1.12.2009
Mamta
2
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Preface
This report is based on the research which I have undertaken as prescribed
in the syllabus of the third semester of Master of Mass Media.
In the first part of the report a brief introduction of the topic, objective of
the research and the research methodology adopted is given. In the next section
complete description and analysis of the collected data is provided. Third section
of the report is about the results of the research. In the last I have tried to discuss
the topic and various aspects related to it and its contemporary relevance.
3
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Acknowledgement
I am really grateful to Mr. Sarvesh Dutt Tripathi who gave me his guidance
in completing this project. This project is part of our paper Minor Project in
which we had to conduct a minor research study on a topic of current relevance.
It helped us in analysing, investigating and organising the data and writing the
paper on the basis of the research conducted.
4
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Contents
Certificate
Declaration
Preface
Acknowledgement
• Abstract
• Introduction
• Objectives
• Research Methodology
2. Content Analysis /10-14
• Table 1
• Table 2
3. Conclusion /15-16
4. Discussion /17-29
• Global Food Situation
• Effect of Economic Crisis on Food Security
• Right to Food
• Malnourishment
• Issues of BPL
5
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
• Green Revolution
• Unemployment
• Growing Landlessness
• Green Revolution
5. Bibliography/30
6
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
When our country was faced with severe food scarcity in the 1960s media
played a big role in popularising the Green Revolution and made it a big success
with our country becoming self sufficient in food production. Over past few years
agricultural crisis with rising food prices has resulted into food insecurity. There
have been several reports and discussions on food security and right to food law.
After taking charge for the second term the United Progressive Alliance
government promised to enact the National Food Security Act as part of its 100
day’s agenda. However, the government could not present its draft in the
Parliament within 100 days leading to delay in the implementation of Food
Security Act. But this development sparked off a debate in the media about the
need for Food Security and other issues related to it in the wake of draught like
situation in the country and rising food prices. The poor monsoon and prevailing
drought conditions in large parts of the country have once again turned the
attention of policymakers to the problems of agriculture and food security.
Against this backdrop the purpose of this research is to find out how Indian print
media is covering the issue.
Introduction
Food security refers to its availability and access to all. The right to food for
the citizens is considered to be a basic human right in any welfare state or society.
Food security exists when the population does not live in hunger or fear of
starvation. United Nation’s Food and Agriculture Organization describes food
security as “when all people, at all times, have physical and economic access to
sufficient, safe and nutritious food to meet their dietary needs and food
preferences for an active and healthy life.” According to United States
Department of Agriculture “Food security for a household means access by all
members at all times to enough food for an active, healthy life. Food security
includes at a minimum (1) the ready availability of nutritionally adequate and
safe foods, and (2) an assured ability to acquire acceptable foods in socially
7
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
The right to food is a part of the founding human rights texts of the post-
world war II era, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948 (UDHR), the
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1976 (ICCPR) and the
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights 19761 (ICESCR).
Other international legal instruments that incorporate the right to food include
human rights treaties on the rights of women, children, refugees, disabled
persons, and instruments relating to the conduct of states during armed conflict.
8
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
human right. It is estimated that about 35,000 people around the world die each
day from hunger and a large number of people (mainly women, children, and the
elderly) suffer from malnutrition.
Objectives
The objective of this research is to find out how much coverage newspapers
are giving to the issues of food security. Some questions were formulated and
through the research process I tried to find out answers to them.
3. Are newspaper reports covering the food security, raising other issues
related to
o Unemployment
o PDS
o Malnourishment
9
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
5. Are they discussing the role of existing policies like ICDS, Antodaya Anna
Yojana and NREGA in providing food security to the poor?
6. Are they raising the point that most of the people don’t have BPL cards
and other aspects related to it?
Research Methodology
For conducting content analysis two national daily newspapers, namely, The
Indian Express and The Hindu were selected. Articles related to food security
were collected from the two newspapers published from August 15 to September
15, 2009. After collecting the data qualitative and quantitative content analysis
was done. A list of issues related to food security was made and on the basis of the
list how many issues were covered in the reports were determined. For
conducting quantitative content analysis I tried to find out how many reports
appeared in both the newspapers in a month’s time and how much print area has
been dedicated to them in the whole newspaper. To measure the print area of a
report in the whole newspaper total percentage area of a report was calculated.
Supplements are excluded while calculating total percentage area of a news
report or feature.
10
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Content Analysis
The data was collected from the two daily newspapers, The
Indian Express and The Hindu, published from August 15 to
September 15, 2009.
Table 1
The Indian
Issues Date Express The Hindu
Aug. 27
4. NREGA Aug. 15
Aug. 27
6. BPL Aug. 21
11
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Aug. 27
Sept. 14
Aug. 27
Aug. 21
Aug. 27
Aug. 31
12
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Aug. 27
13
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Table 2
14
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
2 column 2 column
4. Date: September 14
3 column
Total pages: 20
15
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Conclusion
The following charts show the total print area dedicated to the reports in
each newspaper.
Table 1 gives the list of various aspects related to food security covered in
the reports of both the newspapers. Overall seventeen of them were covered in
the two newspapers out of which eleven were covered by The Indian Express and
16
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
sixteen by The Hindu. However, the number of reports published in The Indian
Express was more.
TPDS and other welfare schemes and their role in providing food security
are also being discussed in the news reports. The flaws in their implementation
and problems with the targeted schemes were also mentioned in the reports.
All the reports in which the issue of BPL appeared raised the points that
there is need to identify the population afresh and state governments have issued
BPL cards to only few families.
17
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Discussion
18
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
purchasing power among the world’s poorest 800 million people remains a
primary obstacle to such strategies.
2009 has been a devastating year for the world’s hungry, marking a
significant worsening of an already disappointing trend in global food security
since 1996. The global economic slowdown, following on the heels of the food
crisis in 2006–08, has deprived an additional 100 million people of access to
adequate food. There have been marked increases in hunger in all of the world’s
major regions, and more than one billion people are now estimated to be
undernourished.
19
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
can have devastating and long-lasting impacts on those suffering now and future
generations. Food security is a foundation for building social and economic
development. It depends on agriculture to provide sustenance, incomes and
livelihoods for the world’s rural poor – 2.1 billion living on less than $2 per day.
Right to Food
20
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
There are some important points that need to be noted in any discussion of
food security. First, a targeted approach that seeks to restrict food security to
some defined poor households is cumbersome, expensive and ineffective. There
are the well known errors inherent in targeting, of unjustified exclusion of the
genuinely poor and unwarranted inclusion of the non-poor. The proportion of the
population that is nutritionally deprived is significantly larger than the "poor"
population, and in many states they are not completely overlapping categories
either. And in any case, households — and people within them — can fall in or out
of poverty, however defined, because of changing material circumstances.
Similarly they can also go from being food-secure to food-insecure in a short
time. The reasons can vary: crop failures, sharp rises in the price of food,
employment collapses, health issues that divert household spending, the
accumulation of debt, and so on. Monitoring each and every household on a
regular basis to check whether any of these or other features has caused it to
become food-insecure is not just administratively difficult, it is actually
impossible.
Second, the notion that a universal scheme that provides subsidised food to
all households is too expensive is not tenable either. Consider the maximal
possible estimate of such spending. If all households in the country are provided
35 kg of food grain per month, that would come to around 90 million tonnes. At
current levels of subsidy this would cost around Rs. 120,000 crores. This may
seem a lot, but the current food subsidy already amounts to around Rs. 50,000
crores, so this is an additional Rs. 70,000 crores — or around 1.5 per cent of the
gross domestic product.
Surely, this is not too much to allocate so as to ensure that no one goes
hungry in what should be a civilised society? In any case, compare the amount of
Rs. 70,000 with the huge amounts (nearly Rs. 300,000 crores) that have been
given away as tax benefits and other concessions to corporates over the past year,
and it becomes a trivial amount.
21
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
22
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
23
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
THE right-to-food (or RTF) campaign was formally launched in 2001 with
an innovative mix of strategies, merging streams of social activism that had
produced positive results in their own domains. The campaign depended in part
on formally petitioning the judiciary for the enforcement of the right of every
Indian to adequate nourishment. In this, it was inspired by preceding rulings of
the highest court, which held that in cases of Fundamental Rights, it was willing
to give little latitude to governmental pleas of financial stringency. Another tack
that the RTF campaign adopted was awareness building, to bring moral pressure
to bear on the administration at its interface with the people most vulnerable to
food insecurity. Typically, the method employed - borrowed from the closely
related campaign on the right to information - was the "jan sunwai" or public
hearing, at which official claims of funds disbursement and assets creation were
matched against the realities perceived by the supposed beneficiaries.
A number of hearings of the RTF petition have been held in the Supreme
Court since July 2001 and a series of orders of far-reaching significance issued. In
November 2001, the Supreme Court directed all States to introduce a mid-day
meal scheme (MDMS) for students in government and government-aided
schools. It also ordered that the Integrated Child Development Scheme (ICDS)
which was patchy and extremely selective in its coverage, be extended to provide
universal coverage for all children below the age of six. From figures that had
been submitted by commissioners appointed to assist in its deliberations, the
Supreme Court concluded that at the minimum, this required that the number of
anganwadi centres administering the ICDS needed to be increased from 600,000
to 1.4 million.
24
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
was laid on poverty alleviation strategies, which in turn was supposed to have a
positive impact on food security. The food crisis in the mid-sixties demanded a
much wider government intervention to solve the problem, and therefore a Public
Distribution System (PDS) was established. The major achievement of the PDS
has been coverage of a substantial population of the country under its network,
although there were significant cross-state variations in the volume of off-take.
The PDS was criticised for its urban bias and its failure to serve effectively
the poorer sections of the population. However, the PDS has been subjected to
various systemic problems. One of the major problems was inefficiency in
functioning of the Food Corporation of India machinery, resulting in a huge
increase in operational cost. Other things like leakage through widespread
corruption, illegal sales, creation of false ration cards, accession of ration facilities
by relatively well-off households, etc. made the situation worse.
Malnourishment
25
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Issues of BPL
There are many flaws in identifying poor and ascertaining the BPL
households. There are as many poverty figures as the number of entities that have
undertaken this exercise. So, the government, represented by the Planning
Commission, says 27.5% people are below the poverty line. But other entities,
related and unrelated to the government, put it somewhere between 42% and
77%. Even among those that adopt the same methodology, there is wide variance.
Fact remains, in all government lists till date, there has been a reasonable
component of inclusion of the non-poor and exclusion of the very poor. “There
are two main reasons,” says development economist Jean Dreze. One, any scoring
method to identify poor families is bound to be a “hit and miss” affair. The causes
of poverty are diverse and cannot be reduced to a simple arithmetic formula, he
says. Two, even a theoretically perfect method would involve errors at the
implementation stage because of mistakes, cheating, social exclusion, etc. “This is
particularly the case when the scoring system is based on unverifiable criteria, as
happened in 1992, making it easy to cheat,” points out Dreze.
Public investment in the field of agriculture has also decreased from 3% of GDP
to 1.7%. With the expansion of industries and increase in population the area of
agricultural land has been decreasing.
Apart from this our food grain production is continuously being affected
either by flood or draught. There has been a sharp decline in crop productivity.
During 2008-09, agricultural growth dropped to a dismal 1.6 per cent.
26
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Green Revolution
The Green Revolution in wheat and rice has now reached a dead end; it has
not made an impact on cultivation in the rain-fed area and in respect of coarse
grains and pulses. Indeed, it has had an adverse effect on agricultural
environment. Both qualitative and quantitative has been the degradation of land,
water and bio-resources; water-logging and excessive salinity have rendered
fertile lands uncultivable. Post-harvest losses have been substantial.
There has been a sharp decline in the agricultural growth rate and
stagnation in agricultural production. The Planning Commission’s document The
Agricultural Strategy for the Eleventh Plan shows that the agricultural GDP
growth declined from 3.62% during 1984-85 to 1995-96 to 1.85% during 1995-96
to 2004-2005. The state wise trends indicate that the larger declines in
agricultural growth have occurred in states that are predominantly rain fed.
27
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Unemployment
One fourth population of the country doesn’t have the purchasing power to
buy food. Per capita annual food grain demand has fallen in 2004-05 to 157 kg,
the colonial average during 1937-41.
28
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Growing Landlessness
The proportion of rural households that did not have access to land for
cultivation in India has increased by 10.6 per cent between 1993-94 and 2004-05.
The data show that the incidence of households that do not cultivate land has
increased in almost all Indian States in the previous decade, Kerala, Jammu &
Kashmir and Assam being the only exceptions. The increase in the share of
households without access to land for cultivation is higher for Adivasi households
and non SC/ST households than for Dalit households.
29
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Government must expand the minimum support price (MSP) system, based
on the cost of production including reasonable rate of return on investment and
ensuring prompt and open-ended purchase for all major crops.
30
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
31
Food Security & Its Media Coverage
Bibliography
• Frontline
• Economic and Political Weekly
• Outlook
• Sablog
• Social Scientist
• http://www.mssrf.org/fs/atlas/atlas.htm
• http://www.righttofoodindia.org/orders/sc_judgment_revision_nutrition
al_and_financial_norms09.pdf
• www.unicef.org/socialpolicy/files/Food_security_in_India.ppt
• http://mdgs.un.org/unsd/mdg/Resources/Static/Products/Progress2009
/MDG_Report_2009_En.pdf
• http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/ess/documents/food_security_s
tatistics/country_profiles/eng/India_E.pdf
• Documents of All India Kisan Sabha and All India Agricultural Workers
Union
• Food Security: Indicators, measurement and the impact of trade openness
edited by Basudeb Guha-Khasnobis, Shabd S. Acharya, Benjamin Davis -
2008
• Indian agriculture in the new millennium: changing perceptions and
Development Policy edited by N. A. Mujumdar, Uma Kapila, Academic
Foundation (New Delhi, India), Indian Society of Agricultural Economics
– 2006
• Poverty and food security in India: Problems and policies edited by M.S.
Bhatt- 2004
• Economic reforms and food security: the impact of trade and technology in
South Asia edited by Suresh Chandra Babu, Ashok Gulati
32