Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COLLEGE OF LAW
Alabang, Muntinlupa
OUTLINE
Aquino, 1 to 10
Sangco, 1 to 10
B. Quasi-Delict
2176 CC
Barredo v. Garcia 73 Phil 607
Elcano v. Hill, 77 SCRA 98
Cinco v. Canonoy 90 SCRA 369
Baksh v. CA 219 SCRA 115
Dulay vs. CA 243 SCRA 220 (1995)
Aquino, pp.5-10
I Sangco, Philippine Law on Torts and Damages, pp. 407-413
C. Damages
Aquino, 843-945
Board of Liquidators vs. Heirs of Kalaw 20 SCRA 987 (1967)
Custodio vs. CA, supra
A. Elements
2176 CC
Garcia v. Florido 52 SCRA 420
Andamo v. CA 191 SCRA 195
Taylor v. Manila Electric Company 16 Phil 8
Tayag v. Alcantara 98 SCRA 723
1. Act or omission
2. Caused damage
I Sangco pp. 87-90
3. Fault or negligence
1. Quasi-delict v. Delict
Art. 2177 CC
Art 365 RPC
Barredo v. Garcia, 73 Phil 607
People v. Ligon 152 SCRA 39
Padilla v. CA 129 SCRA 558
Cruz v. CA, 282 SCRA
Philippine Rabbit v. People, GR No. 147703 (2004)
People vs. Ligon, 152 SCRA 419 (1987)
Aquino, pp 24-26
I Sangco, pp. 115-120
IV Herrera, Remedial Law pp.155-203 [Read: Section 3 Rule 111 of the Rules of Court]
1170-1172
1174 CC
2178 CC
IV. NEGLIGENCE
A. Concept of Negligence
1. Definition; Elements
Art. 20, CC
1173 CC
Picart v. Smith 37 Phil 809
V Tolentino, 506-507
2. Standard of Conduct
I Sangco 7-8
2. Special Cases
a. Children
c. Intoxication
d. Insanity
2180, 2182 CC
US v. Baggay 20 Phil 142
B. Degrees of Negligence
2231 CC
Marinduqe v. Workmen’s, 99 Phil 48
I Sangco 10-12
C. Proof of Negligence
1. Burden of proof
2. Presumption
F. Defenses
1. Plaintiff’s Negligence
2179 CC
Manila Electric v. Remonquillo 99 Phil 117 GR No. L-8328 (1956)
Bernardo v. Legaspi 29 Phil 12
Bernal v. House 54 Phil 327
PLDT v. CA GR No 57079
2. Contributory Negligence
2179, 2214CC
Genobiagon v CA 178 SCRA 422
Rakes v. Atlantic GR No 1719 (1907)
Philippine Bank of Commerce v. CA 269 SCRA 695
3. Fortuitous Event
1174 CC
Juntilla v. Funtanar, 136 SCRA 624
Hernandez v. COA, 179 SCRA 39
Gotesco Investment v. Chatto 210 SCRA 18
Servando v. Phil Steam 117 SCRA 832
National Power v. CA GR Nos. 103442-45 (1993)
Southeastern College v. CA GR No. 126389
4. Assumption of Risk
5. Due diligence
6. Prescription
7. Double recovery
2177 CC
V. CAUSATION
A. Proximate Cause
1. Definition
a. Remote
b. Concurrent
3. Tests
a. “But for”
b. Substantial Factor
c. Cause v. Condition
A. Possessor of Animals
2183 CC
Vestil v. IAC 179 SCRA 47
2193 CC
Dingcong v. Kanaan 72 Phil 14
1711 CC cf 1712
Afable v. Singer Sewing Machine 58 Phil 39
D. Product Liability
2187 CC
Art 50 –52, 97, 99, 106-107 Consumer Act
Sec. 11 RA 3720
Coca-cola v. CA 227 SCRA 293
II Sangco 714-734
1314 CC
Gilchrist v. Cuddy 29 Phil 542
So Ping Bun v. CA (120554) (September 21, 1999)
Aquino 795-801
2189 CC
Guilatco v. City of Dagupan (61516) 171 SCRA 382
G. Presumption of Negligence
Articles 2185, 2188, 2190, 2191, 2192 and 2193, Civil Code
A. The Tortfeasor
B. Vicarious Liability
1. Parents
2. Guardians
Sangco, 360-366
218-219 FC
2180 CC
Mercado v. CA (L-14342) 108 Phil 414 (1960)
Palisoc v. Brillantes (L-29025) 41 SCRA 548 (1971)
Amadora v. CA L-47745 (April 15, 1988)
Pasco v.CFI (L-54357) 160 SCRA 785 (1988)
Ylarde v. Aquino (L-33722) 163 SCRA 697 (1988)
Salvosa v. IAC (L-70458) 166 SCRA 274 (1988)
St Francis v. CA (82465) 194 SCRA 340 (1991)
PSBA v. CA 205 (84698) 205 SCRA 729 (1992)
Soliman v. Tuason (66207) 209 SCRA 47 (1992)
St. Mary’s Academy v. Carpitanos (143363) (Feb 6 2002)
5. Employers
6. State
C. Others
1723 CC
1. Proprietors of Buildings
2190- 2192CC
2. Employees
3. Engineer/Architect
32 CC
1 Sangco pp 228-255 (1993)
33 CC
353-359 RPC
Marcia v. CA 205 Phil 147
Madeja v. Caro 211 Phil 469
Arafiles v. Phil Journalists GR No 135306 (2003)
1. Defamation
2. Fraud
Salta v. De Veyra 202 Phil 527
3. Physical Injuries
C. Neglect of Duty
34 CC
1 Sangco 334-335 (1993)
35 CC
1 Sangco 335-338 (1993)
A. Abuse of Rights
19 CC
Velayo v. Shell 100 Phil 186
Saudi Arabia v. CA 297 SCRA 469
Globe Mackay v. CA 176 SCRA 778
Albenson v. CA G.R. No. 88694. January 11, 1993.
Amonoy v. Gutierrez 351 SCRA 731
UE v. Jader 325 SCRA 804 GR No 132344 (2000)
Garciano v. CA 212 SCRA 436
Barons Marketing v.CA 286 SCRA 96
BPI v. CA 296 SCRA 260
21 CC
1. Elements
2. Examples
b. Malicious prosecution
Art. 2219, CC
Aquino, 384-391
Lao vs. Associated Anglo American Tobacco, 325 SCRA 694
Que v. IAC 169 SCRA 137
Drilon v. CA 270 SCRA 211
c. Public Humiliation
d. Unjust Dismissal
X OTHER TORTS
A. Dereliction of Duty
27 CC
Amaro v. Samanguit, L-14986 July 31, 1962
B. Unfair Competition
28 CC
26 CC
St Louis v. CA GR No L-46061 (1984)
Concepcion v. CA Gr No 120706 (2000)
XI. DAMAGES
2195, 2197 CC
Heirs of Borlado vs. Vda. De Bulan
G.R. 114118 (2001)
Lazatin vs. Twano 2 SCRA 842 (1961)
B. Kinds of Damages
1. Actual or Compensatory
a. Kinds
b. Extent
2201-2202 CC
c. Certainty
d. Damage to property
PNOC v.CA, supra
2206 CC
Ramos v. CA G.R. No. 124354 (1999)
Gatchalian v. Delim 203 SCRA 126
f. Attorney’s Fees
2208 CC
Quirante v. IAC G.R. No. 73886 (1989)
g. Interest
2209-2213 CC
Crismina Garments v. CA G.R. No. 128721 (1999)
h. Mitigation of Liability
2. Moral
a. Concept
2217 CC
Kierulf v. CA 269 SCRA 433
2219-2220 CC
Francisco v. GSIS 7 SCRA 577
Expert Travel v. CA G.R. No. 130030 (1999)
i. Unfounded Suits
3. Nominal
2221-2223 CC
Ventanilla v. Centeno 1 SCRA 215
Robes-Francisco v. CFI 86 SCRA 59
People v. Gopio 346 SCRA 408
Armovit v. CA 184 SCRA 476
4. Temperate
2224-2225 CC
Pleno v. CA G.R. No. 56505 (1988)
People v. Singh 360 SCRA 404
People v. Plazo 350 SCRA 433
5. Liquidated
2226-2228 CC
6. Exemplary or Corrective
2229-2235 CC
PNB v. CA 256 SCRA 44
Del Rosario v. CA 267 SCRA 158
REFERENCES
AQUINO, TIMOTEO B., Torts And Damages (2001)
SANGCO, CESAR J. Philippine Law on Torts and Damages, Rev. Ed., Quezon City, JMC Press
(1984), Vols. I & II
TOLENTINO, ARTURO Commentaries and Jurisprudence on the Civil Code of the Philippines
Vols. I, IV and V, Quezon City
CIVIL CODE OF THE PHILIPPINES
FAMILY CODE
REVISED PENAL CODE