Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1


Ratings: (0)|Views: 60|Likes:
Published by priyarajan26

More info:

Published by: priyarajan26 on Aug 28, 2010
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





Arun Kumar and Linet Ozdamar School of Mechanical & Production Engineering Nanyang Technological University50 Nanyang Avenue, SINGAPORE-639798Email:makumar@ntu.edu.sg
BBuussiinneessss p poocceesssseeeennggiinneeeeiinngg,,HHeeaalltthhccaaee..
As health care costs increase, there is a need for healthcare service providers to look for ways tocontain costs and to achieve a higher efficiency attheir operating facilities without sacrificingquality. This paper studies a case in employing business process reengineering techniques on oneaspect of a health care service – surgical work.The system is simulated focusing on the processesthat contribute to the effective functioning of anoperating theatre.
Business process reengineering (BPR) has become increasingly important in recent years.Customers now have the choice of different product and service providers, to provide themwith the same core product or service that theywant. Over the last fifteen years, companies have been forced to reengineering their business processes to stay competitive because customersare demanding better products and services.Improving and redesigning business processes is paramount for businesses to stay competitive.With the escalating health care costs, healthcareservice providers in Singapore are alsocontinuously seeking ways to stay competitiveand provide quality service to the customers.Little research has been done on the employmentof BPR in healthcare systems. Healthcare industryhas traditionally emphasized on breakthroughs inoperating procedures and technology in the bid tostay competitive. Healthcare service providers are beginning to understand that BPR initiativescould be a better solution to achievingcompetitive advantage.The operating theatre suite is a criticallyimportant segment of any healthcare organizationthat delivers surgical care to patients. It canconsume multitudes of resources, but at the sametime can generate significant revenue if managed properly. The conflict between the national goalof healthcare and the high cost of surgicaloperations is a powerful incentive to improve thequality of management of the surgical suite. For this reason, many hospitals are reengineering their operating theatre processes in an effort toestablish, restore or boost profitability whileretaining quality (Harris and Zitzmann 1998;Gabel et al. 1999). Reengineering techniquesenable healthcare service providers to take acareful look at the processes involved within theorganization, identifying redundancy andinefficiency that can be removed from the system.This research employs the concept of BPR toimprove the efficiency and effectiveness of certain processes involved in surgical operations.This paper intends to explore the possibilities of cost containment/reduction in a particular aspectof the healthcare industry with the application of BPR. A simulation model has been formulated toreduce any inefficiencies or bottlenecks inherentin the system under study. The scope of thisresearch is limited to an operating theatre suitewithin a hospital.
The aggregate per capita healthcare expenditurein Singapore has risen consistently for the lastthree decades from about S$150 in the 1960s toS$800 in the 1997 (Tan and Chew 1997). Thehealthcare industry in Singapore, like its globalcounterparts, has been facing tremendous pressures since the turn of the last century. Thechallenges faced by the industry in the near futureare as follows.The accelerated population ageing will haveserious implications to the provisions of healthcare for the elderly population who will occupy
Proceedings 18th European Simulation MulticonferenceGraham Horton (c) SCS Europe, 2004 ISBN 3-936150-35-4 (book) / ISBN 3-936150-36-2 (CD)
most of the hospital beds with a low turnover rate.Moreover, the entry of more private-sector hospitals and medical service will lead to moreattractive opportunities to health care professionals (Zhang 2001).There is a lack of health care professionals inSingapore. The local doctor-to-patient ratio was140 doctors for every 100,000 of the populationfor the year 2000. According to OECD data, theaverage ratios for the decade of the '90s for Australia and New Zealand were 240 and 218respectively (Wee 2002).
Business Process Reengineering in Healthcare
Managers use process reengineering methods todiscover the best processes for performing work,and that these processes be reengineered tooptimize productivity (Weicher et al. 1995).Hammer and Champy (1993) state that BPR refers to the fundamental rethinking and radicalredesign of business processes to achievedramatic improvements in critical, contemporarymeasures of performance, such as cost, qualityand speed. Business processes are sequences andcombinations of activities that deliver value to acustomer (Coulson-Thomas 1996). A core business process usually creates value by thecapabilities it gives the company for competitiveness. A limited number of such core business processes can be identified in anycompany, and enhancing those processes can leadto business improvement.Over the last few years, the reengineering concepthas evolved from a "radical change" to accountfor the contextual realism (Caron et al. 1994, Earl1995). Davenport and Short (1990) prescribe afive-step approach to BPR. They argue that process reengineering requires taking a broader view of both IT and business activity, and of therelationships between them. The rhetoric of BPR also encourages fundamental step, or frame- breaking change (Coulson-Thomas 1996). BPR isincreasingly recognized as a form of organizational change characterized by strategictransformation of interrelated organizational sub-systems producing varied levels of impact. Thisorganizational change perspective recognizes that business process reengineering is not a monolithicconcept but rather a continuum of approaches to process change (Kettinger et al. 1997). The faster the speed of change the more difficult andstressful it is to manage (Edwards and Walton1996).With 80 percent of the expenses tied to patientcare activities, hospitals and healthcare systemscan garner substantial savings and improveclinical practices by better managing their labor,supplies, equipment, and facilities. The benefitsof reinventing hospitals hold the tangible andrealistic promise of radically reducing cost whiledramatically increasing the quality of care provided (Harmon 1996).A case study at Karolinska Hospital in Sweden byJacob (1995), and Hout and Stalk (1993) revealsthat rising costs and a weakened economy in1990s were forcing the government to reassessand reduce health care expenditures. Karolinskafollowed Boston Consulting Group’s (BCG)Time-Based Management methods to reengineer the way work was done. BCG reorganized work at the hospital around patient flow by creating anew position of "nurse coordinator" in mostdepartments. By redesigning operating proceduresand staffing patterns, Karolinska was able to cutthe time required for preoperative testing frommonths to days, close 2 of 15 operating roomsand still increase the number of operations per day by 30 percent.Operating theatre management often involveshuman resources, information systems, finance, physical plant design and utilization, capitalequipment, clinical quality and efficiency andregulatory (Merriam-Webster 2002).Furthermore, surgical cases are conventionallyclassified into elective and emergency. Anelective case is one whereby the patient can waitat least three days without sustaining morbidity or mortality. A surgical group comprises of severalsurgeons who share allocated operating theatretime. The term
block time
is the time allocated toeach surgical group into which only the surgeons belonging to that surgical group can scheduletheir patients.Managing operating theatre suites is a difficulttask, because individual theatres and the entiresuite are highly complex and tense environments.Many personnel working in the suite are notunder the direct control of the operating theatremanager. The operating theatre schedule sets thestage for the daily flow of patients and staff. Oncethe day starts, however, deviations from thisschedule are frequent and expected. Emergencycases must be accommodated, cases may belonger or (rarely) shorter than scheduled, patientsmay be late or fail to arrive at all, and personnel
may call in sick or become ill during the course of the day (Gabel et al. 1999).Modern operating theatre management requiresan information system that includes an effectivescheduling system. Such a system has two basic but critical functions: performing the actualscheduling of cases, which involves finding outthe time available on the schedule, whether thattime occurs in a surgeon’s specific block time,and to facilitate intelligent management of resources. It must provide data on how resourcesare being used in relation to their availability(Harris et al. 1998). Block scheduling assigns asurgeon (or a surgical group) a block of time thatis exclusively for his cases.The anaesthesia service is often a separatedepartment; in some hospitals it is a divisionunder surgery department. In contrast withsurgical sub-specialties, anaesthetists specializingin specific clinical areas such as pediatricanaesthesia, obstetric anaesthesia and cardiacanaesthesia are not typically organized intodistinct departments. The anaesthesia departmentmust be organized in such a way as to ensureavailability of a sufficient number of anaesthesia providers for elective and emergency cases,which requires 24-hour-a-day coverage (Gabel etal. 1999).
Simulation in the Health Care Industry
The health care industry is a dynamic system withcomplex interactions, in which the simulationtechnique would play an indirect but vital role toachieve the optimal result (Zhang 2001). Keltonet al. (1998) state that the real power of thesimulation technique is fully realized when it isused to study a complex system. Numeroushealthcare service providers such as D. R.Hospital in North Carolina, and St John Hospitalin Detroit, U.S.A. have successfully employed thesimulation technique to help them inunderstanding their processes and to optimizethem (ProModel Corporation 2002).
The Department of Surgery at the SingaporeHospital oversees the operations of the surgicaltheatres. The main operating theatre complex atBlock 3 of the hospital grounds is where surgicaloperations of different specialties take place. Thelocal demand for surgery services has increasedover the last two decades. The capacity of theoperating theatres at the complex has reachedhigh levels of utilization, and action is necessaryto ensure that the department is able to cope withincreasing patient load. Due to the increasingdemand by patients on the services provided bythis operating theatre complex and the acuteshortage of manpower in the local health careindustry, the Department of Surgery has toemploy reengineering practices to achieve moreefficient and effective utilization with its existingresources.There are a total of 21 operating theatres at themain OT complex at Block 3 of the hospital. Inthe year 2000, the number of surgical operationsconducted at the hospital was 59,377, of whichabout 45% were outpatient (day) surgeries. Thedaily average was 162. Out of the 21 theatres, 19are allocated for elective surgery and operate 8hours a day (from 8:30 to 17:30), and theremaining 2 are employed as emergencyoperating theatres and operate 24 hours a day.Historical data was extracted from the hospital’sscheduling database for the period January toSeptember 2001. The data includes the percentageutilization of all the operating theatres, and thesurgeons’ log of all the surgical operationsconducted within the same period.Every day, each operating theatre is reserved for aspecific clinical discipline to carry out surgicaloperations. Some of the operating theatres areexclusively reserved for a particular discipline,whereas others may be used by differentdisciplines for each day of the week.
MedModel is a simulation-based powerfulsoftware tool for evaluating, planning or re-designing hospitals and other healthcare systems.It provides a basis for the comprehensiveevaluation of large and complex health caresystems. MedModel is also equipped with animpressive collection of pre-programmedconstructs. Before a model for the operatingtheatre complex can be developed, a flow chart of the operating theatre process is provided in Figure1 to illustrate the entities, resources and locationsinvolved. Figure 2 shows the layout of thecompleted simulation model. The proportion of elective surgical operations for each clinicaldiscipline varies greatly.To keep simulation as simple as possible, thismodel deals with only 8 operating theatres, each

Activity (5)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
Kiran Soni liked this
nikhilkharat liked this
Osahene liked this
jatmad liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->