Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword or section
Like this
5Activity

Table Of Contents

P. 1
Motion for Summary Judgment by Darren Chaker

Motion for Summary Judgment by Darren Chaker

Ratings:

4.8

(1)
|Views: 2,007|Likes:
Published by Darren Chaker
This is the Motion for Summary Judgment(MSJ) filed in Chaker v. Crogan. Although Judge Barry Moskowitz denied the motion, he agreed the statute "probably" violates the First Amendment, however did not believe it fit within a habeas context. Nonetheless, you can't appeal what was not brought before the lower court--thus this MSJ setforth all of the issues needed to be pursued in the Court of Appeal.

On a side note, I've met Judge Moskowitz at social functions, admire him as a person along with his intellect. His nickname, is 'Midnight Barry' earned by being up until the late hours working on cases. In short, he's not a 9-5 judge.

Viewpoint discrimination, Jones & Meyer, ACLU, First Amendment, Darren Chaker
This is the Motion for Summary Judgment(MSJ) filed in Chaker v. Crogan. Although Judge Barry Moskowitz denied the motion, he agreed the statute "probably" violates the First Amendment, however did not believe it fit within a habeas context. Nonetheless, you can't appeal what was not brought before the lower court--thus this MSJ setforth all of the issues needed to be pursued in the Court of Appeal.

On a side note, I've met Judge Moskowitz at social functions, admire him as a person along with his intellect. His nickname, is 'Midnight Barry' earned by being up until the late hours working on cases. In short, he's not a 9-5 judge.

Viewpoint discrimination, Jones & Meyer, ACLU, First Amendment, Darren Chaker

More info:

Published by: Darren Chaker on Jun 29, 2008
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

05/24/2012

 
^M\C\CIOMZ–T HI\CIO AIZ T]HHGZS @]LKMHMO\ GT \I DFGCH IOM ( 7
7:4<=1;237>777:747<7=717;7273:>:7:::4:<:=:1:;:2
Lgzzmo L/ Dbgemz477 O/ Zijmz|tio Jfql/ $7:4>Jmqmzfs Bcfft& Dgfcaizocg 3>:77:>1/444/122> U\mfX;;=/2::/>>1: UAgrX
]OC\ML T\G\MT LCT\ZCD\ DI]Z\TI]\BMZO LCT\ZCD\ IA DGFCAIZOCG 
LGZZMO LGQCL DBGEMZ&^m|c|ciomz&qt/GFGO DZIKGO& TGO LCMKI DI]O\S^ZIJG\CIO LM^GZ\HMO\&Zmt~iolmo|/Dgtm Oi/ >>DQ:74; "J\H# "DKG#
^M\C\CIOMZT OI\CDM IA HI\CIO GOL HI\CIO AIZ T]HHGZS @]LKMHMO\ GT \I DFGCH IOMLG\M)\CHM0 \JG FIDG\CIO0 MF DMO\ZI JZGODB
DIHMT OI[& LGZZMO LGQCL DBGEMZ& ^m|c|ciomz& gol acfmt {c|b|bct Di}z| bct Hi|cio aiz T}hhgzs @}lkhmo| gt |i dfgch iom "7#&|bm }odiot|c|}|ciogfc|s ia ^mogf Dilm tmd|cio 7<2/1& ia bct [zc|ia Bgjmgt Diz~}t acfml ~}zt}go| |i Z}fm < ia |bm Z}fmt Kiqmzocok:2 ]/T/D/ « ::=</) ) ) )) ) ) )) ) ) )) ) ) )
 
^M\C\CIOMZ–T HI\CIO AIZ T]HHGZS @]LKMHMO\ GT \I DFGCH IOM ( :
7:4<=1;237>777:747<7=717;7273:>:7:::4:<:=:1:;:2
 OI\CDM IA HI\CIO GOL HI\CIO\I DI]OTMF AIZ ZMT^IOLMO\ CO \BM GJIQM(MO\C\FML HG\\MZ0^FMGTM \GEM OI\CDM
|bg| ^m|c|ciomz Lgzzmo Lgqcl Dbgemzbmzmjs hiqmt |bct Di}z| aiz go izlmz kzgo|cok t}hhgzs `}lkhmo|co bct agqiz io dfgch 7& |bm }odiot|c|}|ciogfc|s ia ^mogf Dilmtmd|cio 7<2/1& ia |bm \bczl Ghmolml ^m|c|cio aiz [zc| ia BgjmgtDiz~}t "‖^m|c|cio‘#/ \bm lg|m gol |chm ia |bm bmgzcok io |bcthi|cio ct |i jm tm| js |bm Di}z| ga|mz |bm dih~fm|cio iajzcmacok& co gddizlgodm {c|b gos Dgtm Hgogkmhmo| DioamzmodmIzlmz |bg| |bm Di}z| hgs izlmz/ \bct hi|cio ct jgtml io |bctOi|cdm ia Hi|cio gol Hi|cio aiz T}hhgzs @}lkhmo| gol t}~~iz|cokhmhizgol}h ia ~ico|t gol g}|bizc|cmt gol izgf gzk}hmo|& |bm~fmglcokt co |bct dgtm& gol |bm mrbcjc|t ia t|g|m di}z| acfcoktgfzmgls filkml {c|b |bct Di}z|/Hz/ Dbgemz tmmet t}hhgzs `}lkhmo| gt |i dfgch 7 ~}zt}go| |iAmlmzgf Z}fm ia Dcqcf ^zidml}zm =1& io |bm kzi}olt |bg| |bmt|g|}|m co gol ia c|tmfa ct glmw}g|m |i hiqm aiz t}hhgzs`}lkhmo|& gt {mff gt |bm ~fmglcokt gol mrbcjc|t io acfmlmhiot|zg|m |bg| |bmzm ct oi kmo}com ctt}m gt |i gos hg|mzcgfagd|& gol |bmzmaizm Hz/ Dbgemz ct mo|c|fml |i `}lkhmo| io |bctdfgcht gt g hg||mz ia fg{/) ) ) )) ) ) )) ) ) )) ) ) )
 
^M\C\CIOMZ–T HI\CIO AIZ T]HHGZS @]LKMHMO\ GT \I DFGCH IOM ( 4
7:4<=1;237>777:747<7=717;7273:>:7:::4:<:=:1:;:2
C/ ]OLCT^]\ML AGD\T
\bm Iaacdm ia |bm Lct|zcd| G||izoms acfml g dih~fgco|gkgcot| ^m|c|ciomz io iz gji}| Hgzdb :=& 733;/ C| gffmkml gqcifg|cio ia ^mogf Dilm « 7<2/1"g#"7#& |bg| ^m|c|ciomz lcl}ofg{a}ffs acfm go gffmkg|cio ia hctdiol}d| gkgcot| g ~mgdmiaacdmz eoi{cok |bm gffmkg|cio |i jm agftm/Tmd|cio 7<2/1"g#":# ~ziqclmt |bg| ‖UgXos fg{ moaizdmhmo|gkmods gddm~|cok go gffmkg|cio ia hctdiol}d| gkgcot| g ~mgdmiaacdmz tbgff zmw}czm |bm dih~fgcogo| |i zmgl gol tckogoglqctizs& {bcdb h}t| jm ~zco|ml co jiflagdm |s~m/\bctglqctizs diodf}lmt {c|b |bm aiffi{cok {gzocok& lczmd|fs jmomg|b{bcdb dc|cpmo dih~fgcogo|t h}t| tcko0
C\ CT GKGCOT\ \BM FG[ \I HGEM G DIH^FGCO\ \BG\ SI]EOI[ \I JM AGFTM/ CA SI] HGEM G DIH^FGCO\ GKGCOT\ GOIAACDMZ EOI[COK \BG\ C\ CT AGFTM& SI] DGO JM^ZITMD]\ML IO G HCTLMHMGOIZ DBGZKM/
"^mogf Dilm «7<2/1"g#":#/#Io Amjz}gzs ::& 7333& ^m|c|ciomz {gt ai}ol k}cf|s iaqcifg|cok ^D 7<2/1"g#"7# gt g zmt}f| ia bct tmdiol `}zs |zcgf/^m|c|ciomz {gt tmo|modml |i 7# |bzmm smgzt ia t}hhgzs ~zijg|cio&:# |{i lgst ia d}t|ils {c|b |{i lgst dzmlc| aiz |chm tmzqml& 4#acoml gji}| ,7&7>> gol& <# 7= lgst
7
ia ~}jfcd tmzqcdm/Hz/ Dbgemz ~}zt}ml go g~~mgf/ \bm Di}z| g~~ico|ml G||izomsT/ [gzl Bmcozcdbt/ \bm G~~mffg|m Lcqctcio ia |bm T}~mzciz Di}z|gaaczhml ^m|c|ciomz–t dioqcd|cio/ \bm ctt}m ia |bm t|g|}|m–t
7
\bm Di}z| gffi{ml ^m|c|ciomz |i ~mzaizh qif}o|mmz {ize aiz g db}zdb cofcm} ia ~}jfcd {ize tmzqcdm/

Activity (5)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
Darren Chaker liked this
Dabboo1 liked this
caljics liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->