Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Michael C. Constantinou
Professor
Department of Civil, Structural, and Environmental
Engineering
University at Buffalo, State University of New York
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
SCOPE OF PRESENTATION
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Professors A. M. Reinhorn and A.S. Whittaker,
Univ. at Buffalo
Doctoral and post-doctoral students:
Prof N.
Prof. N Makris,
Makris Prof.
Prof P.
P Tsopelas,
Tsopelas Prof.
Prof M.Symans,
M Symans
Prof. O. Ramirez, Prof. P. Roussis, Dr. A.S. Mokha,
Dr. A. Kasalanati, Dr. J. Quarshie, Dr. E.D. Wolff,
Dr. Ani N. Sigaher, Dr. E. Pavlou, Dr. C.
Chrysostomou, Dr. D. Fenz, Dr. Y. Kalpakidis
Current students:
A. Sarlis, Dhiman Basu, F. Fadi
Research Sponsors: NSF, NCEER, MCEER, FEMA,
State of NY, Department of Commerce, California
Department of Transportation, Industry
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
SEISMIC ISOLATION
A method of construction
and a technology in which
a system is used to provide
period lengthening and ability
to absorb energy
isolator flexibility
force reduction
displacement increase
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
SEISMIC ISOLATION
Displacements
isolator flexibility
period shift
isolator displacement
• energy dissipation
building
g displacement
p
• damage reduction
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
SEISMIC ISOLATION
Energy dissipation
hysteretic
high-damping rubber
yielding of lead
friction
external hardware
hybrid
y systems
y
viscous
external hardware
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ISOLATION HARDWARE
Isolation bearings
Elastomeric
Low-damping rubber (NR)
High-damping rubber (HDR)
Lead-rubber (LR)
Sliding
Friction Pendulum (FP)
Sliding with Restoring Force
Sliding with Yielding Devices
(Elastoplastic)
Energy dissipation devices
Viscous dampers
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ISOLATION HARDWARE
Elastomeric
El t i Bearings
B i for
f Sakhalin
S kh li I Orlan
O l Platform
Pl tf
Tested at University at Buffalo, 2004
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ISOLATION HARDWARE
LR bearing
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LEAD--RUBBER BEARING
LEAD
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LEAD--RUBBER BEARING
LEAD
150
L e a d -ru b b e r B e a rin g 120
2 0 o C , ve l.= 2 5 0 m m /s
Ve rtic a l L o a d = 1 1 0 0 k N 90
60
Lateral Force (kN)
30
-1 2 0 -9 0 -6 0 -3 0
0
0 30 60 90 120
TEMP=20OC
-3 0
-6 0
-9 0
-1 2 0
-1 5 0
D i sp l a c e m e n t (m m )
150
L e a d -ru b b e r B e a rin g
120
-2 6 o C fo r 4 8 h rs
ve l.= 2 5 0 m m /s 90
Ve rtic a l L o a d = 1 1 0 0 k N
60
e (kN)
30
Lateral Force
-1 2 0 -9 0 -6 0 -3 0
0
-3 0
0 30 60 90 120
TEMP=-25OC
-6 0
-9 0
-1 2 0
-1 5 0
D i sp l a c e m e n t (m m )
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ISOLATION HARDWARE
FP bearing
g
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
FP BEARING
Salkhalin
S lkh li II b
bearings
i
Largest seismic isolators
700mm displacement
87,400kN gravity load
130,000kN max load
Full-scale testing
Reduced scale dynamic
testing (load of up to
13,000kN, velocity of
1m/sec).
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ADAPTIVE ISOLATORS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ADAPTIVE ISOLATORS
DOUBLE FP BEARING
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ADAPTIVE ISOLATORS
DOUBLE FP BEARING
RIGID-BILINEAR
HYSTERETIC BEHAVIOR
OFFERS ADVANTAGE OF
REDUCTION OF
SECONDARY SYSTEM
RESPONSE
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ADAPTIVE ISOLATORS
DOUBLE FP BEARING
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ADAPTIVE ISOLATORS
TRIPLE FP BEARING
TRIPLE FP BEARING: AN ADAPTIVE SYSTEM
RESULTS FROM TESTING AT UB
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ADAPTIVE ISOLATORS
TRIPLE FP BEARING
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ADAPTIVE ISOLATORS
TRIPLE FP BEARING
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ADAPTIVE ISOLATORS
TRIPLE FP BEARING
Series Model
Parallel Model
Comparison of Experimental
and Analytical Results
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LARGE--SCALE DYNAMIC
LARGE
TESTING
LARGE-SCALE TESTING
MACHINE OF EPS
67,000 kN
1 meter/sec
2500mm STROKE
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
FP BEARING
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LARGE--SCALE DYNAMIC
LARGE
TESTING
SRMD Test Machine
Horizontal capacity
4500 kN per actuator
2500 mm stroke
1.8 meters/sec
19.3m3/min servovalves
Vertical capacity
72 MN
Used for testing of
bearings for
Benicia Martinez bridge
(FP)
Coronado bridge (LRB)
I-40 bridge (FP)
Erzurum Hospital (LRB)
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BRIDGES
Corinth Canal Bridges,
Greece, 1996
Twin, prestressed concrete box
girder bridges.
Elastomeric and
flat sliding bearings.
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
Elastomeric (HDR) and
flat sliding
(DU metal in contact
with stainless steel)
bearings
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BRIDGES
BENECIA-MARTINEZ BRIDGE
SAN FRANCISCO BAY AREA, RETROFIT 2000
OVER 1200mm DISPLACEMENT CAPACITY
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BRIDGES
Woodrow Wilson
Bridge, 2004
Arch bridge
Open lines of vision
Bascule and fixed
spans look the same
Seismically isolated
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BRIDGES
LR BEARINGS
LR BEARINGS
WOODROW WILSON BRIDGE
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
100
80
CYCLES 1-5 WOODROW WILSON
60 BRIDGE
RAL FORCE (KIPS)
CYCLES 15401-15405 40
TRAVEL=1550 m LR BEARINGS
20
0
-1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
-20
LATER
-40
-60
-80
-100
DISPLACEMENT (INCH)
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
WOODROW WILSON BRIDGE
BEFORE
O WEAR TEST
S ( 1600m
1600 TRAVEL)) AFTER WEAR TEST
BEARING NO. 2 TEST B1 (5 cycles, 4.5 inch, 10in/sec) BEARING NO. 2 TEST B1 (5 CYCLES, 4.5 inch, 10 in/sec)
BEFORE WEAR TEST AFTER WEAR TEST
100 100
80 80
60 60
L FORCE (kips)
L FORCE (kips)
40 40
20 20
0 0
LATERAL
LATERAL
6
-6 4
-4 2
-2 0 2 4 6 6
-6 -4
4 -2
2 0 2 4 6
-20 -20
-40 -40
-60 -60
-80 -80
-100 -100
DISPLACEMENT (inch) DISPLACEMENT (inch)
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
60 60
40 40
TERAL FORCE (kips)
20 20
0 0
-4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
-20 -20
LAT
LA
-40 -40
-60 -60
DISPLACEMENT (inch) DISPLACEMENT (inch)
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BRIDGES
BOLU VIADUCT
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
ALL 1638
BEARINGS
FAILED
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
BOLU VIADUCT:
DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGE
FAILED YIELDING
STEEL DEVICES
AT EXPANSION
JOINT
LARGE
LONGITUDINAL
PERMANENT
DISPLACEMENT
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF
ELASTOPLASTIC ISOLATION
SYSTEMS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN INFRASTRUCTURE
LNG Tanks
Tanks, Greece
Greece, 1996
430 Friction-pendulum bearings
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN LNG TANKS
65,000 m3 CAPACITY, 75m DIAMETER,
35m HEIGHT (ISOLATOR TO ROOF)
1m INSULATION AT BOTTOM
1m THICK CONCRETE SLAB
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN LNG TANKS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN OFFSHORE
GAS AND OIL PLATFORMS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN OFFSHORE
PLATFORMS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
SAKHALIN ISLAND GAS/OIL
PLATFORMS
PILTUN AND LUNSKOYE PLATFORMS
SAKHALIN II PROJECT
LOCATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATION SYSTEM ON
TOP OF CONCRETE
GRAVITY BASE IN
PILTUN AND
LUNSKOYE
PLATFORMS
GOAL IS TO
PROTECT
ENTIRE STRUCTURE
ABOVE CONCRETE
GRAVITY BASE
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LUNSKOYE/PILTUN PLATFORMS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LUNSKOYE/PILTUN PLATFORMS
Lunskoye Piltun
Number of Conductors 27 45
GBS Caisson Size LxBxD (m) 105x88x13.5 105x88x13.5 Ice and wave
Number of GBS columns 4 4
Seismic
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LUNSKOYE/PILTUN
PLATFORMS--ICE LOADING
PLATFORMS
Ice present for 6 months, up to 2m thick
Horizontal loads per platform
260MN (103MN per leg) for 1-year return period
(operational)
324MN (124MN per leg) for 100-year return period
(frequent event) (18% of weight on each leg)
435MN (155MN per leg) for 10,000-year return period
Necessitated all services to be within legs
Design criteria
No damage to topsides for 100-year wave/ice
effects
Survival criteria for 10,000-year return period
wave/ice
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LUNSKOYE/PILTUN
PLATFORMS--SEISMIC LOADING
PLATFORMS
St
Strength
th Level
L l (SLE) D tilit LLevell (DLE)
Ductility
200-year return period 3000-year return period
No loss of life Structural damage
Essentially elastic acceptable
behavior (some local Collapse prevention
limited yielding allowed) Safety critical equipment
E i
Equipment t functional
f ti l f ll ffunctional
fully ti l
Shutdown and Means of escape intact
inspection likely No major environmental
damage
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LUNSKOYE/PILTUN
PLATFORMS--ISOLATORS
PLATFORMS
Isolators
SLE Response
R Single concave FP
Cast steel suitable for low
Calculations Without With temperatures
based on Radius of curvature 3962mm
isolation isolation
nominal Displacement capacity 700mm
properties Contact diameter 1752mm
Pendulum period 4.0 sec
Deck Accel.
Lower bound friction 0.040
(0 to +47m) 0.65 to 0.85 g 0.24 to 0.31g Upper bound friction 0.095
Range of nominal friction
0.04 to 0.06
Equipment -factors
Accel. 1.2 aging
1.2 to 4.4 g 0.6 to 2.0 g
1.1 travel of 2900m
(cranes, 1.4 temperature of -400C
flare, etc.) Adjustment factor 0.75, so that
max=1.60
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LUNSKOYE/PILTUN PLATFORMS
R
REDUCED
F
FULL SIZE PRDUCTION BEA
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
LUNSKOYE/PILTUN PLATFORMS
SCALING PROCESS
500
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN STORAGE TANKS
Case of cryogenic storage
tanks near populated
p p
seismically active area
(Sicily, Italy)
Demolition and rebuilding
not an option-cannot build
anything new in that area
Seismic isolation retrofit an
attractive option
Concept applicable to
refineries near populated
areas
SICILY, 2005, COURTESY OF ANDREA SANTAGELO
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN STORAGE TANKS
Soft first story
construction
t ti
Strengthening of columns
would transfer problem to
tank above and would
require strengthening of
foundation
Seismic isolation
(reduction of force) an
attractive option
Strengthening of columns
still needed
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN STORAGE TANKS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN STORAGE TANKS
Due to close spacing of
columns temporary
columns,
transfer of load not needed
(but support system
provided)
Isolators inserted without
need to preload (no use of
flat jacks)
Use of FP bearings with
transfer of P- moment on
strengthened column
below
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BUILDINGS
BUILT IN 1894, UNREINFORCED BRICK AND STONE, 5-STORY
Salt Lake City Hall WITH 12-STORY TOWER, 80m BY 40m. BEARINGS 450mm IN
208 LR bearings PLAN, 400mm TALL. SEISMIC ISOLATION RETROFIT
COMPLETED IN 1987. FIRST RETROFIT WITH ELASTOMERIC
239 Rubber bearings BEARINGS.
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BUILDINGS
• US Court of Appeals
Building, San Francisco
256 FP bearings
100m by 81m, 32500sm
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BUILDINGS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF SEISMIC
ISOLATORS IN BUILDINGS
AboveNet Building, 2001
San Francisco,
S F i 13000 sm
98 FP bearings
Seismic rehabilitation
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF HYBRID
SEISMIC ISOLATION SYSTEMS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF HYBRID
SEISMIC ISOLATION SYSTEMS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF HYBRID
SEISMIC ISOLATION SYSTEMS
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF DAMPERS IN
STRUCTURES
XIHOUMEN BRIDGE, CHINA, 2008 UNDER CONSTRUCTION
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
XIHOUMEN BRIDGE, CHINA
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
IMPLEMENTATION OF DAMPERS IN
STRUCTURES
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo
CONCLUSIONS
Seismic isolation is a relatively mature technology with a significant
range of applications
Technology may provide significant benefits provided that is properly
applied
Use of proper isolator for structure and seismic hazard.
Proper selection of seismic hazard.
Proper interpretation of seismic hazard.
Yet several problems in seismic protective systems technologies exist
and require understanding
Lifetime behavior of hardware (effects of time, history of loading and
environment).
Procedures for analysis and design to account for lifetime behavior,
uncertainty and variability in properties and uncertainty in seismic
excitation.
Modeling of hardware to describe instantaneous behavior (heating
effects, deterioration of strength and stiffness).
Scaling, similarity and testing.
16th Greek Concrete Conference, 2009 Civil, Structural & Environmental Eng. , University at Buffalo