Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
5Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Pleasure into Pain, Pain into Pleasure: Mary Shelley and John Keats' Romantic Solution to a Classic Problem (Nov. 2001; Scanned)

Pleasure into Pain, Pain into Pleasure: Mary Shelley and John Keats' Romantic Solution to a Classic Problem (Nov. 2001; Scanned)

Ratings: (0)|Views: 664 |Likes:

More info:

Published by: Patrick McEvoy-Halston on Jun 30, 2008
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

05/01/2013

pdf

text

original

- /
F( t c
k ;)
/ i l s
c "f:/
'l\G _ o ? O a r{.
P le a s u r ein to P a in ,P a in in to P le a s u r e :
M a ry S h e lle ya n d J o h n K e a ts '
R o m a n ticS o lu tio nt o a C la s s icP ro b le m
+ j
P a tric k M c E v o y -H a ls to n
9 7 1 2 5 7 6
E ric M ille r
E n g lis h2 0 0 8
} \ ,
{
I
W h e n I re a da t le a s tsom e o f th e c r i t i q u e so f M a r yS h e lle y 's F r a n k e n s t e i n a n d J o h n
K e a ts 'o d e s - - e s p e c ia lly

h is"O de to a G r e c i a n(J rn "--, a n d t o t h e d e g r e et h a t I ta k e th e ir c ritiq u e s s e r i o u s l y ,I f e e l I m u s t q u e s tio n w h e t h e r i t i s m i s l e a d i n g t o c a l l e i t h e r o f t h e m R o m a n tic s .M a ry S h e lle y ,w ife o f P e rc yS h e lle y ,d a u g h te r,

a s s h e ,a c c o r d i n gt o Thom as
J e f f e r s o n H o g g , t o l d P e r c yo n t h e i r f i r s t m e e tin g ,"o f G o d w in a n d M a r y
[W o lle s to n e c ra ft]"(3 7 ) i ss u re ly a R o m a n t i cw r i t e r , i s n ' ts h e ? A c c o r d i n g t o m a n y ,n o t
s o . M a u r ic e H in d le , fo r e x a m p le ,
ina n i n t r o d u c t i o nt o a P e n g u i nC l a s s i c se d itio no f
F r a n k e n s te inw ritte n w ith h is w id e a u d ie n c ein m in d ,a n d w h o th u s ,w e m ig h t a s s u m e ,
b e
h e s ita n tt o p re -ju d g eth e w o rk fo r re a d e rsn e w to th e w o rk ,is n e v e rth e le s s

c o n fid e n t e n o u g ho f its in d is p u ta b ilityto te ll u s th a t " . . . its lF ra n k e n s te in's ] m o r a l l e s s o nt h a t p rid e m u s th a v e its fa ll s h o u ld b e o b v io u sto th e m o s tin d iffe re n tre a d e r"(v iii).

T h e id e a
o f th e o v e r-re a c h in gh e ro is a R o m a n tic s ta p le ;a ta le th a t e x p lo re sth is id e a w ith th e
in te n tio no f o ffe rin g a m o r a lle s s o n c e r ta in lyis n o t. H in d le a c c e p tsa s o b v io u s("[t]h e re
s e e m sl ittle d o u b tth a t . . .) a ju d g e m e n tb y P . D . F le c k ,th a tF ra n k e n s te inis a n o v e l

w h ic h " c o n ta in si n a n im a g in a tiv efo rm h e r c r itic is mo f[P e rc y ]S h e lle y ''( 4 ) .S o th a t'sr t : M a r y ' s l a s t n a m e m is le a d m ein to e x p e c t i n g h e r t o f o c u s o n t h eR o m a n tice x p lo r a tio no f th e life o f a g re a t,b u t d o o m e dm a n ,w h e n s h erig h tly b e lo n g sin m y m in d 's c a ta lo g u eo f

qo ,^ .vt\
a u th o rsa n d th e ir w o rk s w ith th e " C la s s ic ," w ith ,ru y ]ry {" rc m s o n a n dh is w o rk "V a n ity
$ t
f\ . . J
- '/
o f H u m a n E e s ire .s ,"
th a ta rep r im a r ily in te r e s te d in ju d g in gs u c h a life a s fo o lis h . J o h n
K e a t s - - n o wh e m u s tb e aR o m a n tic :
if h e is n 't w h o is ? B u t d o e s n 'tK e a ts ,t o o ,o ffe ru s
le s s o n so f a s im ila rn a tu r eto J o h n s o n 'si n h is 'V a n ityo f H u m a nD e s ire s "?K e a ts '
" c o n c lu s io n "to h is " O d e to a G re c ia nIJrn "--""B e a u tyis tru th , tru th b e a u ty ,"--th a t
is a ll
I Y e k n o w o n e a r t h ,f f i d a l ly en e e d t ok n o w " (lin e 5 0 )--m a ynotbe ap a ir in g o f id e a s
l;4 "
;s f
I
- .-
, i; \ f lio
. " \ Y
/ \ .
{ r - o
f n
\
- a
^ |
\ s(u \
0 trt
-
\N a, /
X "
,'*u "6
\ ,
a 4
\
o c '\
'
r
2
J o h n s o nw o u ld a g re ew ith , it b u t s till s h a re sw ith "V a n ity o fH u m a nD e s ire s " a c o n c e rn
t o d is c o u ra g eu s fro m ourow n e x p lo ra tio n s .S o m ec r itic s d is p u teth a tth e la s ttw o
m o r a liz in glin e stru ly re p re s e n t
K e a ts 'ju d g e m e n t;m a n ys e e th e s ela s ttw o lin e sa s o u t o f
s y n c w ith th e re s to f th epoem ,w ith som es e n s i n g " a n o t h e r v o i c e " h e r e (p e rh a p sit's th e
\ A
S ,
v a s es p e a k in g ? );
butm anyc ritic sd o n o t. P e rh a p sIs h o u lda c c e p t
th eju d g e m e n t
o fth e s e
, /
c ritic s w h o n o tea n dp ra is e h is m o r a liz in g ,a n d r e - c a ta lo g u eh im a s w e ll?
B u tw a it. . . fro m m yow n e x p lo ra tio n s
o fF ra n k e n s te in
(1 8 3 1e d i t i o n )a n d o f K e a ts '
"O deto a G re c ia nIJ m ," Id o n o t d is p u teth a tb o th a u th o rs m o ra liz e ,n o r th a t th is

m o r a liz in gc a n s e e ms op ro m in e n t,s o o b v i o u s , a s t o a p p e a rth e "m o ra l" o f th e ir w o rk s ; b u t b e c a u s eI c o n s i d e rth e g re a tR o m a n tic ,a n d r o m a n t i cc o n flic tth a t b e t w e e no u r o w n rig h tto e x is ta n d b e h a p p y --w h a t

w eow eo u rs e lv e s --v e rs u s
"th e d is a p p ro v a l
o r
c o n d e m n a tio no f s ig n ific a n to th e rs ,s u c ha sp a re n ts "(B ra n d e n
6 3 )--w h a tth e y th in kw e
o w e th e m , a n d th a tth e g u ilt a n d fe a r th is d is a p p ro v a l
o r c o n d e m n a tio nin flic ts , b e c a u s e
o fi t s s o u rc e ,
i s im m e n s e ,
it is r e a lly n o s u r p r i s e t h a t t h ep a re n ts '
(e ld e rs ')m o r a liz in g

v o ic e s e e m st h e "v ic to r,"seem stod o m i n a t et h e s e w o r k s - - a n dit is c e r ta in ly s h o u ldn o t d is q u a liff e ith e ro f th e rn a s R o m a n tic .S o lo n g a s th e re is a s e n s eth a tth e m o r a liz in g v o ic e is p re s e n t,

a tle a s tinp a rt,fo r th ep u rp o s eo f b r in g in g to m in d its fu ll w e ig h ta n d
im p rin ts o a sre p re s e n t

fo r th ew rite r a re a ls e n s e"th a tth isis th ep ro b le m ,"--th is is w h y l w rite --a lo n gw ith as e n s eth a tth is v e ry s a m ev o ic e ,n o w e c h o in glo u d ly in th e ir m in d s ,is b e in g e x p lo r e da sp a rt o f a n a s s e s s m e rrt,

aju d g e m e n t o fit, th e w o rk is , in m y m in d ,a

R o m a n t i co n e . K e a t s"fre e z e s " a m o m e n t i n t i m ein h is"O de to a G r e c ia nU rn "--w h e n p le a s u r etu rn s to p a in - - a n dh is c o n c lu s io nt o th ep o e m is m e r e ly a n in d ic a tio n ,w h ic hi s a ls o re p re s e n te d

in th e s o rtso f im a g e s o n th e u rn , o f h is m o tiv e fo r w ritin gap o e m w h ic h
g J
S .
U fr!
s * f
$ 6 \-
) .r s
\( - g
-
,.1 ;'"(\(
(J o c sr '
. ( .
, l
r r '[lq z ttt"
'
1 "

Activity (5)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
dassbiplav liked this
dassbiplav liked this
abumofreh liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->