Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
4Activity
P. 1
Rabinder Singh - JUSTICE Tom Sargent Lecture 2010

Rabinder Singh - JUSTICE Tom Sargent Lecture 2010

Ratings: (0)|Views: 3,245|Likes:
Published by The Guardian

More info:

Published by: The Guardian on Oct 15, 2010
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

12/06/2013

 
JW[TCKG Tel [opaomt lglepcof fgktwpg 0>?>Tbg WH Kem{tctwtcem: Tclg iep Iwmdolgmtof Pgiepl5
Ct c{ om bemewp te boyg `ggm o{hgd te acyg tbc{ sgop–{ Tel [opaomt lglepcof fgktwpggygm tbewab C iggf wmqwofcicgd te ieffe cm tbg ieet{tg~{ ei tbg dc{tcmawc{bgd {~gohgp{be boyg acygm tbg fgktwpg cm tbg ~o{t- Cm ~optckwfop ct c{ pcabt tbot g {bewfdpglgl`gp Fepd @cmabol& be aoyg tbg fgktwpg cm 0>>?- Loms iwf{elg tpc`wtg{ boyg `ggm ~ocd te bcl {cmkg bc{ wmtclgfs dgotb fo{t lemtb- C ewfd fchg te odd jw{t o igepd{ ei ls em o{ om odyekotg be bod tbg ~pcycfgag ei o~~gopcma `giepg bcl- O{ o jwdag bg o{ wmiocfcmafs kewptgew{ omd iocp- Tbc{ kewmtps kom kewmt ct{gfi ieptwmotgtbot& ot tbc{ tpew`fcma tclg cm tbg gopfs 0?
{t
kgmtwps& ct o{ o`fg te twpm te tbc{ c{g lomiep lepof fgodgp{bc~ bgm ct o{ {e `odfs mggdgd- Cm tbg
 @gflop{b
ko{g bg pglcmdgdw{ ei ewp `gttgp {gfyg{: ci g bod fgit ~ge~fg fomawc{bcma cm ~pc{em ctbewt tpcof C dem–ttbcmh g ewfd boyg `ggm ~pewd ei ewp{gfyg{- C `gfcgyg tbot iep agmgpotcem{ te kelgFepd @cmabol–{ e~cmcem cm tbg
 @gflop{b
ko{g cff `g pgod `s omsemg be c{cmtgpg{tgd cm fc`gpts omd gqwofcts-
?
 O{ c{ gff,hmem& cm Los tbc{ sgop tbg Wmctgd Hcmadel gfgktgd o keofctcemaeygpmlgmt iep tbg icp{t tclg {cmkg tbg [gkemd Qepfd Qop- Em ?3 Los Mckh Kfgaa&tbg fgodgp ei tbg Fc`gpof Dglekpot{ omd Dg~wts ^pclg Lcmc{tgp& lodg o {~ggkb cmbckb bg ~pelc{gd tbg @pctc{b ~ge~fg tbot:‖Tbc{ aeygpmlgmt c{ aecma te ~gp{wodg sew te ~wt sewp ioctb cm ~efctck{ emkgoaocm- C ol met aecma te tofh o`ewt o ig mg pwfg{ iep L^{& met tbg edd ag{twpg ep acllckh bgpg ep tbgpg te lohg sew iggf o `ct lepg cmyefygd- C ol tofhcma o`ewt tbgle{t {camcickomt ~peapollg ei gl~egplgmt `s o @pctc{b aeygpmlgmt {cmkg tbg apgot
?
 
 O y [gkpgtops ei [totg iep tbg Belg Dg~optlgmt 
X0>>7\ 0 OK 92-
?
 
pgiepl{ ei tbg ?3
tb
kgmtwps- Tbg `caag{t {bohg w~ ei ewp dglekpoks {cmkg ?2;0 bgmtbg Apgot Pgiepl Okt pgdpg tbg `ewmdopcg{ ei @pctc{b dglekpoks& iep tbg icp{t tclggrtgmdcma tbg ipomkbc{g `gsemd tbg fomdgd kfo{{g{-“Qbcfg tbc{ pgieplcma zgof c{ gfkelg& ct c{ {fcabtfs {wp~pc{cma te bgop tbot tbgmg keofctcem aeygpmlgmt–{ ~pe~e{gd pgiepl{ opg aecma te `g tbg le{t iwmdolgmtof{cmkg ?2;0- Gygm offecma iep ~efctckof bs~gp`efg& tbc{ {ggl{ te acyg me kpgdct te tbgfo{t aeygpmlgmt& bckb kolg te eiickg cm ?331 ctb om ol`ctcew{ ~peapollg ei kem{tctwtcemof pgiepl omd cm fopag ~opt dgfcygpgd ct& oftbewab C cff {waag{t ct fgit {elgei tbg `caag{t qwg{tcem{ wmpg{efygd- Cm bc{ 0>>? fgktwpg Fepd @cmabol pgigppgd te‖tbg ifeed ei kem{tctwtcemof fgac{fotcem pgfgo{gd `s tbg @focp aeygpmlgmt oitgp tbg ?331gfgktcem-“
0
^peig{{ep Ygpmem @eadomep bo{ gygm dg{kpc`gd tbg ~okhoag ei kem{tctwtcemof pgiepl{ gmoktgd cm tbg fo{t ?; sgop{ o{ olewmtcma te tbg ‖mg @pctc{bkem{tctwtcem-“
;
Cm Ekte`gp ?331 ometbgp sewma omd gmgpagtck fgodgp bod jw{t kelg te ~egp- Ot tbot tclg Tems @focp {ocd tbc{: ‖Tbg Aeygpmlgmt c{ ~fgdagd te ledgpmc{g@pctc{b ~efctck{- Qg opg kellcttgd te o kel~pgbgm{cyg ~peapollg ei kem{tctwtcemofpgiepl- Qg `gfcgyg ct c{ pcabt te cmkpgo{g cmdcycdwof pcabt{& te dgkgmtpofc{g ~egp& tee~gm w~ aeygpmlgmt omd te pgiepl ^opfcolgmt-“
4
 Tbg locm igotwpg{ ei tbot ~peapollg ei kem{tctwtcemof pgiepl opg gff,hmemomd kom `g {wllopc{gd `pcgifs-
7
Icp{t& tbgpg o{ dgyefwtcem te [ketfomd& Qofg{ omd&ieffecma tbg Aeed Ipcdos Oapgglgmt ei ?332& Meptbgpm Cpgfomd- Dgyefwtcem o{ met
0
Fepd @cmabol& ‒Tbg Gyefycma Kem{ctwtcem– "JW[TCKG ommwof fgktwpg& 0>>?#& ~-0-
;
Ygpmem @eadomep& Tbg Mg @pctc{b Kem{tctwtcem "0>>3& Bopt ^w`fc{bcma#- [gg of{e tbg {olg owtbep–{‒Bwlom Pcabt{ omd tbg Mg @pctc{b Kem{tctwtcem– "JW[TCKG ommwof fgktwpg& 0>>3#-
4
^pclg Lcmc{tgp–{ ~pgiokg te tbg Qbctg ^o~gp ‒Pcabt{ @pewabt Belg–& KL ;120& bckb okkel~omcgdtbg cmtpedwktcem ei tbg Bwlom Pcabt{ @cff cm Ekte`gp ?331-
7
Iep lepg dgtocf {gg [cp Jokh @got{em& ‒Pgieplcma om Wmpcttgm Kem{tctwtcem– "@fokh{temg Fgktwpg&Eriepd& ?9 Los 0>>3#-
0
 
cl~e{gd `s tbg WH Aeygpmlgmt `wt o{ o~~peygd `s pgigpgmdwl cm gokb ei tbgpgfgyomt pgacem{- Tbg ~egp{ ei tbg [kettc{b ^opfcolgmt omd Grgkwtcyg cm ~optckwfop opg {tpema omd cdg,pomacma& keygpcma le{t opgo{ ei delg{tck ~efcks-[gkemdfs& tbg Bew{g ei Fepd{ o{ pgieplgd cm ?333 te pgleyg off `wt 30 ei tbg bgpgdctops ~ggp{- Begygp& ct ~peygd cl~e{{c`fg iep oapgglgmt te `g pgokbgd cm^opfcolgmt o`ewt bot dgapgg ei gfgktgd gfglgmt {bewfd `g cmkfwdgd cm o pgieplgdw~~gp kbol`gp& omd tbot c{ wmdew`tgdfs wmicmc{bgd `w{cmg{{- Ct c{ ~gpbo~{ cpemck tbottbg emfs lgl`gp{ ei tbg Bew{g ei Fepd{ be kom kfocl te boyg `ggm gfgktgd `somsemg opg tbg 30 bgpgdctopcg{ be opg fctgpoffs gfgktgd ipel olema tbgcp em ~ggp{-Tbgpg o{ o ~pe~e{of cm tbg @pem odlcmc{tpotcem–{ Kem{tctwtcemof Pgiepl omdAeygpmomkg @cff bckb ewfd boyg gmdgd tbg {s{tgl iep `s,gfgktcem{ bgm obgpgdctops ~ggp dcg{& `wt tbc{ bod te `g dpe~~gd cm tbg fo{t dos{ ei tbot odlcmc{tpotcemcm epdgp te iokcfctotg oapgglgmt ctb tbg E~~e{ctcem te offe tbg @cff te `g ~o{{gd `giepg tbg agmgpof gfgktcem tbc{ sgop- [e ct c{ tbot g {tcff boyg 30 bgpgdctops ~ggp{ cmewp fgac{fotwpg omd tbg emfs ~ge~fg be kom yetg iep tbgl cm `s,gfgktcem{ opg etbgp bgpgdctops ~ggp{- Tbcpdfs& tbg gfgktepof {s{tgl{ iep le{t tcgp{ ei aeygpmlgmt& bgtbgp cm tbgdgyefygd o{{gl`fcg{& tbg Apgotgp Femdem O{{gl`fs ep tbg Gwpe~gom ^opfcolgmt& gpgoff `o{gd em {elg {s{tgl ei ~pe~eptcemof pg~pg{gmtotcem- Begygp& tbg ~pelc{gdpgigpgmdwl iep gfgktepof pgiepl iep tbg Bew{g ei Kellem{ mgygp kolg: tbg pg~ept `sFepd Jgmhcm{& bckb pgkellgmdgd o {s{tgl ei gfgktcem hmem o{ ‖OY ^fw{“& bckbewfd boyg pgtocmgd kem{tctwgmks L^{ gfgktgd em tbg `o{c{ ei tbg Oftgpmotcyg Yetg `wt;

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->