Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Exhibit 1: Capitalisation Structure Initiating with a BUY on ELTYIJ 8.625% Conv. Notes due 03/15
In IDR bn We are initiating with a BUY on ELTYIJ 8.625% Conv. Notes due 03/15 on its
(1)
LTM Period 30 June 2010 Last FY Pro Forma sufficient NAV coverage, attractiveness on relative value, cash flow visibility
Sales 1,227.7 1,227.7 from toll roads and hotels business, coupled with a strong macroeconomic
EBITDA 241.3 241.3 outlook for the Indonesian economy. However, key risks include Bakrieland’s
EBITDA Margin 19.7% 19.7% (ELTY) expansion plan which is likely to require additional debt financing.
ST bank loans 27.5 27.5 Conservative NAV Estimate Adequately Covers Convertible Bonds
Onshore bank debt 2,089.0 2,089.0 Outstanding
Total Bank Debt 2,116.4 2,116.4
Following ELTY's recent land acquisitions in Bogor and Jonggol, we estimate
that the NAV of the company's land bank, toll road, and equity stake in PT
Loans from other fin. Institutions 408.7 1,775.7
Sentul City covers the convertible bonds more than five times after deducting all
Capital leases 3.7 3.7
other bank and onshore debt. Thus, in the worst case scenario, we think that
Total Bank & Fin. Institutions 2,528.9 3,895.9
the recovery on the bonds should be at least par.
ELTYIJ 11.9% 03/11 220.0 220.0
ELTYIJ 12.85% 03/13 280.0 280.0 ELTYIJ’15s Appear Attractive On Relative Value
ELTYIJ 15.48% 07/11 Sukuk 60.0 60.0 We believe that ELTYIJ’15s is attractive on a relative value basis vs. other
ELTYIJ 16% 07/12 Ijarah Sukuk 90.0 90.0 Indonesian real estate credits. ELTYIJ’15s trades around 14.3% yield for a
Total Onshore IDR Debt 3,178.9 4,545.9 gearing (Total debt / Total assets) of ~34% while recently restructured Pakuwon
ELTYIJ 8.625% CBs 03/15 1,144.7 1,144.7 Jati offers similar yield but has a higher gearing level at 40%.
Amortisation of issuance costs (5.9) (5.9)
Total Debt 4,317.7 5,684.7 More Stable Cash Flow From Toll Road, Hotels and Rental
Cash and cash equivalents 591.4 5,152.4 Operations Coming on Stream
Restricted cash 85.5 85.5 ELTY’s investments in toll roads and hotels may provide more stable cash flow
Net Debt 3,640.9 446.9
in the medium term. Recurring revenues increased from 15% of total revenues
in H1 09 to 29% in H1 10.
Equity market cap & MI 8,096.9 8,096.9 Favourable Housing Market Dynamics
Enterprise value 11,737.7 8,543.7 We believe that the dynamics for Indonesian real estate market is improving:
• Relaxation of foreign ownership rules;
Bank Debt / EBITDA 8.8x 8.8x • Jakarta apartments are cheap and rental yields high compared to regional
Bank & Fin. Inst. Debt / EBITDA 10.5x 16.1x peers;
Onshore IDR Debt / EBITDA 13.2x 18.8x • Mortgage industry in Indonesia is underdeveloped; and
Total debt / EBITDA 17.9x 23.6x • Housing demand may be greater than supply.
Net debt / EBITDA 15.1x 1.9x
EV / EBITDA 48.6x 35.4x But Further Indebtedness Likely for Expansion Plan
Source: SJS Markets estimates Despite the significant equity raising in July 2010, we believe that ELTY will
require additional funding for new project developments in the next couple of
(1) Pro Forma adjustments includes: IDR 3.2trn from rights
issue, IDR 917bn 'loan' from Societe Strasbourg and USD 50mn years, assuming that the company does not deviate from its current expansion
loan from Avenue Capital. plans. The additional funding will be applied to develop Lido Lake Resort, Bukit
Pro Forma adjustments do not include the use of proceeds from Jonggol and the Ciawi-Sukabumi toll road.
the rights issue.
BOND DETAILS
Thus, in the worst case scenario, we think that the recovery on the bonds should be
at least par.
The Kanci-Pejagan toll road was valued at development costs of IDR 2.2trn as
reported in ELTY’s 2009 annual report.
Furthermore, our conservative NAV does not include rental income from investment
properties. Investment properties owned by ELTY include portions of Wisma Bakrie
1 and 2, Bakrie Tower, Lifestyle Centre, The Jungle Water Park, Orchard Walk, and
hotels.
PT Bakrie Swasakti Utama Mixed development Rasuna Epicentrum Kuningan, Central Jakarta 174.4 12.0 2,093.3 69.6% 1,457.4
PT Bakrie Pangripta Loka Residential Sentra Timur Residence Kota Baru, East Jakarta 16.0 5.5 88.0 100.0% 88.0
PT Graha Andrasentra Propertindo Residential Bogor Nirwana Residence Bogor, West Jawa 6,780.0 0.2 1,356.0 99.8% 1,353.0
Commercial The Jungle Water Park Bogor, West Jawa 23.0 0.2 4.6 99.8% 4.6
Commercial The Jungle Mall Bogor, West Jawa 10.6 0.2 2.1 99.8% 2.1
Commercial Orchard Walk Bogor, West Jawa 15.4 0.2 3.1 99.8% 3.1
Commercial Aston Bogor Hotel & Resort Bogor, West Jawa 141.3 32.3% 45.6
New Development ~60ha land acquisition Bogor, West Jawa 600.0 0.3 200.0 100.0% 200.0
PT Dutaperkasa Unggullestari Residential Ijen Nirwana Residence Malang 125.0 1.5 187.5 65.0% 121.9
PT Mutiara Permata Biru Residential Batam Nirwana Residence Batam 271.0 0.4 108.4 98.8% 107.1
PT Sanggraha Pelita Sentosa Residential Graha Taman Sukabumi Sukabumi 24.0 0.5 12.0 99.3% 11.9
PT Krakatau Lampung Tourism Dev. Hotel & Resort Krakatoa Nirwana Resort Lampung 998.0 0.2 152.5 90.0% 137.3
PT Libratindo Gemilang Hotel & Resort Balikpapan Nirwana S&R Balikpapan 32.0 2.0 62.8 100.0% 62.8
PT Berkah Puhu Lestari Hotel & Resort Ubud Nirwana Villas Ubud, Bali 42.0 0.4 15.5 100.0% 15.5
PT Samudra Asia Nasional Hotel & Resort Pullman Bali Legion Nirwana Bali 335.0 99.8% 334.2
PT Bali Nirwana Resort Hotel & Resort Nirwana Bali Resort Bali 170.0 4.0 673.4 52.6% 353.9
New Development Lido Lake Resort Sukabumi 10,370.0 350.0 100.0% 350.0
PT Bukit Jonggol Asri New Development Bukit Jonggol Jonggol 125,000.0 0.0 2,094.6 51.0% 1,068.3
New Development Karang Tengah Jonggol 5,000.0 0.2 1,000.0 51.0% 510.0
PT Sentul City Tbk Equity stake PT Sentul City Sentul 5.3% 178.5
PT Semesta Marga Raya Infrastructure Kanci-Pejagan toll road 2,200.0 100.0% 2,200.0
Subtotal 8,605.0
Add: Cash as of 30 June 2010 591.4
Less: Advances from customers (113.4)
Less: All bank and onshore debt excl. ELTY'15s (3,178.9)
Value available to CB holders 5,904.1
A plan to move the administrative capital to Bukit Jonggol could be a huge positive
for land price in the area and is likely to benefit ELTY which has acquired significant
land bank in Jonggol at relatively low cost.
As part of ELTY rights issue in the middle of the year, the company acquired
13,000 hectares (130mn sqm) land bank in the Bukit Jonggol area. The company
plans to apply IDR 1trn (~USD 1.1bn) to acquire a 51% stake in PT Bukit Jonggol
Asri, which is the project holding company for the Bukit Jonggol land.
According to ELTY, the land acquisition costs is around USD 2psm and selling
price could be between USD 50-150psm.
Exhibit 3: Pro Forma Shareholding We take comfort that at least a portion of ELTY’s future land acquisition costs have
Structure been funded by equity rather than new indebtedness.
Shareholder % Owned
ELTY completed a one-for-one rights issue in July 2010 in which the company
Avenue Capital 12%
raised IDR 3.2trn to fund project developments. Despite raising less than the IDR
Bakrie & Brothers 14%
5.4trn that was originally sought by the company, ELTY was able to obtain a further
Danatama Makmur 9% IDR 917bn of funds from Strasbourg Societe, an independent third party, as well as
Public 65% USD 50mn loan from Avenue Capital to make up for the short fall. The funds from
Source: Company and SJS Markets
Note: Shareholders pro forma for ELTY’s rights
Strasbourg Societe were applied to the Bukit Jonggol acquisition in which the
issue. investor has a Profit Sharing Agreement with ELTY. The loan from Avenue Capital
was applied to debt repayments for the Kanji-Pejagan toll road.
The rights issue removes the immediate need for ELTY to claim receivables due
from Limitless World International Services 6 Ltd (LWIS), a subsidiary of Dubai
World, which recently restructured its debt obligations. In June 2008, ELTY
divested 30% of the Rasuna Epicentrum project to the Dubai related entity, in which
the USD 110mn proceeds was earmarked to fund the development of Rasuna
Epicentrum. As of 30 June 2010, receivables due from LWIS amounted to USD
43.2mn.
Furthermore, ELTY may also be looking at other parties to replace LWIS. We think
that another more cash rich partner may have the capacity to inject new funds to
help finance part of the future development costs.
Exhibit 4: ELTY's Capital Raising and Use of Proceeds in Last Six Months
USD mn IDR bn
Date Description Use Proceeds Use Proceeds
Mar 2010 USD 155mn ELTYIJ 8.625% Conv. Notes 03/15 155.0 1,411
Working capital (10.0) (91)
Refinancing (25.0) (228)
General corporate (Rasuna Epicentrum and Bogor) (70.0) (637)
Equity swap - CS (50.0) (455)
Jun 2010 Strasbourg Societe Profit Share Agreement Funds(1) 98.6 917.0
Partial payment for 25% stake in Bukit Jonggol (98.6) (917.0)
H2 2010 USD 50mn Bridge Loan from Avenue Capital(2) 50.0 450.0
Repayment of loans relating to Kanji Pejagan toll road (50.0) (450.0)
Notes:
(1) We understand that Strasbourg has the option to convert the profit sharing agreement into a 25%
stake in Bukit Jonggol Asri.
(2) Per local press reports and our discussions with ELTY's management
ELTY’s investments in toll roads and hotels may provide more stable cash flow in
the medium term. In 2014, with the Ciawi-Sukabumi toll road completed, we
estimate that ELTY could generate ~IDR 800-900bn in revenues from toll roads.
The diversification of revenues to toll roads is already taking hold with the
completion of the Kanci-Pejagan toll road in January 2010. For the first six months
of the year, the toll road generated IDR 28.8bn in revenues or ~5% of total
revenues for the company.
Income from ELTY’s hotel business already accountS for 15% of H1 10 revenues,
up from 6% in H1 09. We expect the hotels business to remain a significant part of
the company’s revenues going forward.
35% 800
Recurring revenues increased
from 15% of total in H1 09 to
700
29% in H1 10. 30%
600
25% 9.0%
500
20%
(IDR bn)
400
15%
2.9% 300
15.0%
10% 9.0%
200
12.1%
5% 100
6.0% 5.0%
0% - - 0
H1 09
H2 09
H1 10
ELTYIJ’15s trade around 14.3% yield for a gearing of ~34% while recently
restructured Pakuwon Jati has similar yield but higher gearing level at 40%.
Exhibit 6: Indonesia and Philippines Real Estate Credits Yield (%) vs. Gearing
15%
PWON'15
ELTYIJ'15
14%
13%
12%
11%
YTW
10%
9%
8%
VLLPM'15
7% LPKRIJ'15
6%
15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45%
Total Debt/Total Assets
In June 2010, the local media quoted a spokesperson from the Ministry of Public
Housing saying that the ministry was in the process of changing the regulations
relating to foreign ownership of Indonesian properties.
According to recent media reports, new regulations to be put in place are still
unlikely to allow full foreign ownership, but instead could simplify the lease renewal
process. Thus, instead of renewing the lease for right to use every 25 years,
foreigners could be granted a 70 year lease on the onset in acquiring a property.
We understand that the regulations may only apply to high-end condominiums in
Jakarta.
We believe that real estate in Indonesia has significant room for price appreciation
in the medium term. Per data from www.globalpropertyguide.com, the price per
square meter for apartments in Jakarta is one of the cheapest among regional
peers.
18,000
Jakarta apartments have the 16,422
lowest price per square meter 16,000
…
14,000 12,884
12,000 11,324
10,265
10,000
8,000
4,000 3,072
2,668
2,033
2,000 1,424 1,381
Cambodia
Hong Kong
Japan
India
China
Thailand
Malaysia
Indonesia
Philippines
Singapore
Secondly, rental yields in Jakarta are the highest in the region which could provide
stable income for investors (Source: www.globalpropertyguide.com).
5.7%
6%
4.3%
3.8% 3.6% 3.6%
4%
3.1%
2.7%
2%
0%
Cambodia
Indonesia
Malaysia
Thailand
Japan
India
China
Hong Kong
Philippines
Singapore
Taiwan
Source: www.globalpropertyguide.com
We think that the long term fundamentals for real estate companies in Indonesia
are promising given strong forecasted GDP growth, population growth and supply
demand imbalance.
Firstly, the Indonesia economy has been resilient and was one of the fastest
growing economies in the ASEAN region in 2009 despite the global financial crisis.
While its neighbours such as Malaysia, Singapore and Thailand suffered negative
economic growth, Indonesia’s economy grew at 4.6% in 2009. Per Bloomberg
consensus estimates, Indonesia’s GDP is expected to grow at 6% and 6.3% in
2010 and 2011, respectively. The GDP growth rate is expected to be the third
highest among the G-20 nations after China and India.
7.0%
Indonesia expected to be
third fastest growing
economy among G-20 nations 6.5% 6.5%
6.3% 6.3%
for 2010 and 2011.
6.0%
6.0% 6.0%
5.7%
5.5% 5.5%
Forecast
5.0% 5.0%
4.8%
4.5% 4.6%
4.0%
2010E
2011E
2012E
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
Source: Bloomberg
In our opinion, Indonesia’s credit rating may have the potential to be upgraded to
investment grade within the next 18 to 24 months. Recently, Indonesia’s Finance
Minister said that he believed that an investment grade rating for the country could
be achieved by early 2011, depending on the government’s success in increasing
tax revenues.
Per data from Demographia World, the population in the Greater Jakarta region
(DKI Jakarta, Bogor, Depok, Tangerang, and Bekasi, or Jabodetabek) will increase
to 32.7mn and 37mn by 2025 and 2030, respectively. As a result, the Greater
Jakarta region is expected to have the highest population globally by 2030 ahead of
Tokyo.
Thus, we believe that there is genuine and stable demand for real estate in the
region which would be particularly beneficial for ELTY’s newly acquired Bukit
Jonggol, Sentul City and Lido Lake developments in the outskirts of Jakarta.
40
37.0
35 32.7
30
26.6
25 23.3
20
15
11.6
10 8.0
5.7
5
0
2010E
2025E
2030E
1961
1971
1980
2000
Source: Historical per Indonesia government census, 2010 data from Wikipedia, and forecast per
Demographia World
We think that there could be more demand for homes relative to supply in the
Jabodetabek area. This supply demand imbalance could be beneficial for the
longer term prospects of ELTY’s Bogor, Lake Lido, and Bukit Jonggol
developments.
We think that this assumption is justified. Per data from the US Census Bureau,
there could be around 40mn Indonesians between 25 to 34 years old. This is a
good indicator of potential housing demand, in our opinion. Assuming 2 persons
per household and this age group to purchase a house within a ten year period, the
potential number of new house formations could be 2mn p.a. Thus, assuming some
of this population will continue to live with their parents and some do not marry, the
assumption of 800,000 units of annual demand is not unreasonable.
The potential in the market has not gone unnoticed by ELTY’s competitors. For
example, Lippo Karawaci recently announced plans to invest into residential
townships in the eastern parts of the country.
Firstly, the mortgage loans to GDP ratio suggest that Indonesia is underleveraged
and the mortgage loan industry has substantial room for growth. Indonesia’s
mortgage loans as a percentage of GDP was 2.2% according to data from CEIC,
which is the lowest in the region. In comparison, Thailand, China, and Malaysia had
mortgage to GDP ratios of 10.5%, 14%, and 26.2%, respectively.
100%
89.7%
80% 73.3%
69.8%
61.3%
60%
46.2%
41.8%
40% 35.0%
26.2% 26.1%
21.1%
20% 14.0%
10.5%
5.2%
3.4% 2.2%
0%
US
UK
HK
Malaysia
Japan
China
Thailand
Indonesia
Philippines
Singapore
Korea
New Zealand
Australia
Taiwan
India
Source: CEIC
Exhibit 12: Annual % Growth Rate in GDP per Capita on Constant Local
Currency
10
-
(YoY % Chg)
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
(5)
(10)
(15)
Source: Bloomberg
Exhibit 13: GDP Per Capita as of 31 December 2008 (Constant Prices in USD)
30,000
Despite strong economic 27,991
growth in recent years,
Indonesia’s GDP per capita is 25,000
still relatively low compared
to regional peers.
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,151
5,000
2,640
1,965
1,225 1,087 647
0
Malaysia
Thailand
China
Indonesia
Philippines
Vietnam
Singapore
Source: Bloomberg
14
13
12
(%) 11
10
Forecast
9
Q4 10E
Q2 11E
Q4 11E
Q4 05
Q2 06
Q4 06
Q2 07
Q4 07
Q2 08
Q4 08
Q2 09
Q4 09
Q2 10
Source: Bloomberg consensus forecasts
Despite raising nearly IDR 6trn (USD 656mn) in equity and debt over the last six
months, we believe that ELTY could require additional funding of ~IDR 2.7trn (USD
294mn) for new project developments in the next couple of years, assuming that
the company does not deviate from its current expansion plans.
The need for additional funding was also mentioned by ELTY’s President Director
recently. According to local press reports, the President Director said that the
company’s PT Bakrie Toll subsidiary may be seeking IDR 1 to 1.5trn in new bonds
to help finance construction of the Ciawi-Sukabumi toll road and refinance existing
indebtedness.
Exhibit 15: Summary of Major Funding Requirements in Next Two Years (SJS
Markets Estimates, Excludes Project Finance Loans)
Amount
Project Type IDR bn USD mn
Lake Lido Township development 75 8.2
Bukit Jonggol Asri Township development 179 19.6
Ciawi-Sukabumi Toll road 1,080 118.7
Repayment to Strasbourg Bukit Jonggol Asri 917 100.8
Acquisition of ~15% PT Sentul City Tbk Equity stake 428 47.0
Total 2,678 294.3
Notes:
• The above analysis excludes project finance loans and includes only the 'equity' portion that needs to
be funded at the holding company level.
• Payment to Strasbourg relates to the IDR 917bn provided by the Strasbourg Societe as part of the
Profit Sharing Agreement
Our analysis above does not include the project finance debt that will probably have
to be undertaken at the project company level. For example, we estimate that the
total development costs for the Ciawi-Sukabumi toll road could be IDR 5.4trn in
total, in which we estimate the ELTY will have to raise ~IDR 1trn in equity or debt at
the PT Bakrie Toll subsidiary level.
We believe that ELTY may require further financing to fund new township
developments in Lido Lake Resort and Bukit Jonggol.
Exhibit 16: Major Property Development Projects for Next Few Years
Bukit Karang
(1) (1) (2)
Project Lido Lake Jonggol Tengah Total
Land costs (IDR bn) 350 2,095 1,000
Size (mn sqm) 10.4 125.0 5.0
Land cost per sqm (IDR) 33,751 16,757 200,000
Assumptions
ASP (IDR psm) 450,000 450,000 1,800,000
Gross margin(3) 45.0% 45.0% 45.0%
EBITDA margin(3) 20.0% 20.0% 20.0%
Project development period 5 years 15 years 15 years
Based on a back of the envelope calculation, we estimate that ELTY may require
~IDR 2.3trn in project finance loans and ~IDR 250bn in equity to fund the
development of the Lake Lido Resort and Bukit Jonggol Asri projects, assuming
that ELTY has to finance a minimum of 10% of the project via equity. Our estimate
is based on our estimated construction, SG&A, and marketing costs divided equally
throughout the estimated life of the projects.
During the later stages of project development, we expect contracted sales to pick
up and fund part of the construction costs and repay project finance loans. The
equity portion of the projects will be funded by ELTY either through internal sources
or loans at the PT Bakrieland Development Tbk level.
On top of these major developments, we think that ELTY will also have to fund
development costs for the following projects outlined in Exhibit 18. For Rasuna
Epicentrum, ELTY has already allocated IDR 250bn from its rights issue proceeds
to fund development.
Exhibit 18: Other Property Development Projects for Next Few Years
Land Bank
Development (000 sqm) Comments
Rasuna Epicentrum 174 Includes The Grove and Wave Condominium projects.
Bogor Nirwana Residence 6,780 Landed residential
~60ha land, Bogor 600 New land acquisition per rights issue
Ijen Nirwana Residence 125 Residential development in Malang, East Jawa
Batam Nirwana Residence 271 Residential development in Batam Island, off Singapore
Graha Taman Sukabumi 24 Landed residential
Hence on a more positive note, the amount of new indebtedness could be lowered,
but we still expect the company to lever up at the project company level.
Toll road construction requires significant amounts of capital. For example, the
35km toll road between Kanci and Pejagan costs ELTY IDR 2.2trn in total
development costs or IDR 62.9bn per km by our calculations. To develop the Ciawi-
Sukabumi toll road alone (the next infrastructure project in line), we estimate that
the development costs could be up to IDR 5.4trn which could potentially be
completely debt funded.
For the already completed Kanci-Pejagan toll road, we estimate that ELTY may
have taken up ~IDR 1.8trn in project finance or approximately 80% of total
development costs. Assuming a similar capital structure for the construction of the
Ciawi-Sukabumi toll road, we estimate that ELTY will have to source ~IDR 1trn in
equity funding from internal sources and ~IDR 4.3trn in project finance debt.
At the end of September 2010, the local press reported that ELTY’s Bakrie Toll
Road subsidiary may be looking to raise IDR 1 to 1.5trn (USD 111 to 167mn) in
new bonds to refinance existing indebtedness and to fund new toll road
constructions. Furthermore, the construction of the Ciawi-Sukabumi toll road is
expected to draw IDR 391bn of the recent rights issue proceeds.
In our opinion, this potential bond deal and proceeds from rights issue could cover
the ‘equity’ portion of Ciawi-Sukabumi toll road construction, which will be funded at
the PT Bakrie Toll Road level. However, we think that a further IDR 4.3trn of project
finance debt could be consolidated into ELTY’s balance sheet before the toll road
becomes operational.
Exhibit 19: Major Toll Road Projects for Next Few Years
Ciawi- Pejagan- Batang- Pasuruan-
Toll Road Kanci-Pajagan Sukabumi Pemalang Semarang Probolinggo
Status Completed WIP Assessment Assessment Assessment
Length (km) 35 54 58 75 45
Construction time (mths) 18 36 23 30 18
Development cost per km (IDR bn) 63 100 60 60 60
Total development costs (IDR bn) 2,200 5,400 3,480 4,500 2,700
ELTY has limited track record in generating positive free cash flow. ELTY has not
generated positive Free Cash Flow or Cash flow from Operations for the last five
years. After excluding land acquisitions (included in ELTY’s definition of CFO), the
cash flow from operations was negative for the last three years.
In the near term, we do not expect ELTY to generate positive FCF as we expect
significant development costs for toll roads and township developments in
Sukabumi and Jonggol.
Exhibit 20: ELTY's EBITDA, CFO and FCF 2005 to 2009 (in IDR bn)
500
246 208
188
91 80 46
52
0
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
(159) (214)
(255) (288)
(500) (355) (366)
(470)
(552)
(1,000) (887)
(1,057)
(1,132)
(1,500)
(2,000) (1,860)
(2,035)
(2,500)
Exhibit 21: ELTY's EBITDA, CFO and FCF Q1 08 to Q2 10 (in IDR bn)
500
0
Q108 Q208 Q308 Q408 Q109 Q209 Q309 Q409 Q110 Q210
(500)
(1,000)
(1,500)
(2,000)
ELTY could lose support from its majority shareholder Avenue Capital. We
calculate that Avenue Capital may already have extracted most of the value from its
investment in ELTY. Furthermore, Avenue did not participate in the company’s
most recent rights issue which suggests that the latter may not believe that ELTY’s
equity could generate the required return going forward.
Assuming a current share price of IDR 180 per share, we estimate that Avenue
Exhibit 23: Sensitivity could achieve an IRR of ~33% for its investment over the past five years if it sold its
Analysis of IRR on Avenue’s remaining stake today. Even at a lower share price of IDR 100, we believe that
Investment vs. Share Price Avenue could still achieve an IRR of ~22%. Hence, we think that the downside for
Share
Avenue’s investment is limited and we should not expect further support from the
price
hedge fund should ELTY falter.
(IDR) IRR (%)
32.9%
50 11.7% Despite Avenue’s non-participation in ELTY’s most recent rights issue, the local
100 21.5% news reported that the fund may have extended a USD 50mn loan to the company
180 32.9% which was applied to repay certain indebtedness relating to the construction of the
200 35.3% Kanci-Pejagan toll road.
250 40.7%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
30.8% 30.8%
30.8%
24.4% 24.4% 24.3%
10%
12.0%
0%
Q1 09 Q2 09 Q3 09 Q4 09 Q1 10 Q2 10 PF Rights
30 10%
8.4% 5.4x 5.5x 10%
4.8x
20 5x
5%
5%
10
0 0% 0x 0%
Q1 09 Q2 09 Q3 09 Q4 09 Q1 10 Q2 10 Q1 09 Q2 09 Q3 09 Q4 09 Q1 10 Q2 10
EBITDA EBITDA Margin Total debt / EBITDA Total debt / Total assets
Exhibit 27: ELTY Debt Maturity Profile as of 30 June 2010 (in IDR bn)
1,600
1,400
1,200
1,000
800
600
400
200
0
Q3 10
Q4 10
Q1 11
Q2 11
Q3 11
Q4 11
Q1 12
Q2 12
Q3 12
Q4 12
Q1 13
Q2 13
Q3 13
Q4 13
Q1 14
Q2 14
Q3 14
Q4 14
Q1 15
Q2 15
Q3 15
Q4 15
Q1 16
Q2 16
Q3 16
Q4 16
Q1 17
Q2 17
Bank loans and financial institution Capital lease obligations ELTYIJ 11.9% 03/11 ELTYIJ 12.85% 03/13
ELTYIJ 15.48% 07/11 Ijarah Sukuk ELTYIJ 16% 07/12 Ijarah Sukuk ELTYIJ 8.625% Conv. Notes 03/15
105
100
95
90
85
80
75
Mar 10 Apr 10 May 10 Jun 10 Jul 10 Aug 10 Sep 10
725
625
525
425
325
225
125
25
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Following the company’s fourth rights issue which was completed in July 2010,
ELTY acquired significant land bank in Sukabumi and Jonggol earmarked for
township developments.
ELTY is also involved in the construction and operation of hotels and resorts. Some
of ELTY key resort developments include Aston Hotel Bogor, Pullman Bali Legian
Nirwana and Nirwana Bali Resort.
Bakrieland, was previously known as PT Elang Realty and was listed on the
Indonesian Stock Exchange on 30 October 1995.
Avenue Capital
12% PT Bakrie & Brothers
Tbk
14%
Public
65% Danatama Makmur
9%
Among the six members on the Board of Commissioners, Avenue Capital, ELTY’s
12% shareholder has two representatives.
ELTY’s President Director is Hiramsyah Sambudhy Thaib, who was the ex-CEO of
PT Bakrie Capital Indonesia between 2005 and 2007.
We estimate that ELTY could have a land bank of ~84.8mn sqm in site area after a
series of major land acquisitions with the proceeds from the company’s rights issue
in July 2010. Land bank acquired recently includes:
125mn sqm and 5mn sqm parcels of land in Bukit Jonggol and Karang
Tengah, respectively. ELTY’s attributable interest in PT Bukit Jonggol Asri,
the company which holds the land parcels, is 51%;
10.4mn sqm of land relating to the Lake Lido Resort, Sukabumi which already
has a golf course and resort hotel;
6mn sqm addition to land bank in Bogor; and
Additional land parcels in the Rasuna Epicentrum development in Central
Jakarta.
Exhibit 31: ELTY's Land Bank in Site Area as of July 2010 (estimate)
Malang, 0.1%
Batam, 0.3%
Bali, 0.2%
Jakarta, 0.2% Balikpapan, 0.0%
Following recent land Bogor, 8.7%
acquisitions, we estimate that Sukabumi, 12.3%
ELTY has an attributable land
bank of 84.8mn sqm mostly
located in Jabodetabek.
Jonggol, 78.2%
Jonggol
130mn sqm
Lake Lido
Resort, 10.4mn
sqm
Rasuna Epicentrum
The Rasuna Epicentrum is located in Central Jakarta adjacent to the Golden
Triangle or central business district. The project is 69.6% owned by ELTY and
30.4% owned by Limitless of Dubai World.
Rasuna Epicentrum,
ELTY
Source: Company
Source: Company
Source: Company
Source: Company
Source: Company
Bukit Jonggol
Bukit Jonggol is a vast land parcel (~130mn sqm including Karang Tengah) which
we understand will be earmarked for a new township development. The project is
51% owned by ELTY and was acquired recently with the proceeds from ELTY’s
fourth rights issue. Societe Strasbourg S.A. has a Profit Sharing Agreement in
which the investor may have the right to take a 25% stake in the project.
Source: Company
Infrastructure Projects
ELTY completed the 35km toll road between Kanci and Pejagan in December
2009. As we understand, construction work has begun on the 54km toll road
between Ciawi and Sukabumi.
Source: Company
29 Sep 10 Local news reported that ELTY subsidiary, Bakrie Toll Road, may be looking to raise IDR 1 to 1.5trn in
new bonds to refinance existing indebtedness and fund new toll road constructions.
16 Aug 10 ELTY may have secured USD 50mn loan from Avenue Capital.
08 Jul 10 ELTY completed its fourth rights issue of ~20bn shares at IDR 160 which raised IDR 3.2trn. Proceeds
were used to fund land acquisitions in Jonggol and Bogor.
28 Jun 10 Societe Strasbourg S.A. to provide USD 98.6mn (IDR 917bn) funding to ELTY as part of a Profit Sharing
Agreement for Bukit Jonggol land acquisition.
26 Jan 10 The Kanji-Pejagan toll road was officially opened by Indonesia's president.
Oct 09 ELTY consolidated project finance debt of ~IDR 1.36trn from Kanci-Pejagan toll road construction on to
its balance sheet by increasing its stake in PT Semesta Marga Raya to 65%.
Jul 09 Through PT Bakrie Nirwana Semesta, Bakrieland increased its capital investment in PT Bali Nirwana
Resort to 53%.
Jul 08 Through PT Bakrie Infrastructure, ELTY acquired 75% shares in PT Alberta Utilities, which owns 5%
shares of PT Aetra Air Jakarta (previously PT Thames PAM Jaya), a clean water provider company in
Eastern Jakarta.
06 Jun 08 Limitless, a subsidiary of Dubai World acquired a 30% stake in BSU, BDM and SP (mainly Rasuna
Epicentrum development) for USD 110mn.
Mar 08 ELTY issued IDR 500bn local currency bonds with maturities in 2011 and 2013.
30 Apr 07 Avenue Luxembourg Sarl acquired a further 12.7% of the shares in PT Bakrieland Development Tbk.
30 Apr 07 Third Rights Issue of 14bn shares at IDR 200 per share for a total of IDR 2,800bn (5 shares for 2 held).
7 free warrants were attached to every 50 shares issued.
09 Dec 05 Second Rights Issue of 4.2bn shares at IDR 150 per share or a total of IDR 630bn raised (3 shares for 1
held).
PT Bakrie & Brothers Tbk CGM1 Client Segregated (Avenue Capital) Danatama Makmur Public
65%
14% 9%
12%
PT Bakrie Swasakti Utama (BSU) PT Bakrie Nirwana Semesta (BNS) PT Graha Andrasentra Propertindo (GAP)
Indonesia Indonesia Indonesia
IDR 15bn Bank Bukopin Back-to-Back Facility IDR 11.4bn Bank Bukopin WC Facility IDR 156bn BRI WC Construction II Loan Facility
IDR 26bn BRI WC Construction I Loan Facility IDR 114bn BRI WC Construction III Loan Facility
IDR 250bn BRI WC Construction II Loan Facility IDR 74bn BRI Investment Loan Facility
IDR 46.8bn BRI Investment Loan Facility
IDR 75bn Bank Bukopin WC Construction Loan PT Bumi Daya Makmur (BDM)
IDR 135bn Bank Bukopin Loan Facility Indonesia
IDR 17.9bn Bank Syariah Mandiri Club Deal Facility
IDR 3.3bn Bank OCBC NISP Loan IDR 122bn Bank Tabungan Negara Credit Facility PT Samudera Asia Nasional (SAN)
Indonesia
PT Satria Cita Perkasa (SCP) Transglobal Finance Limited (TGF) Pan Galactic Invesment (PGI)
Indonesia British Virgin Island British Virgin Island
25% 15%
60%
PT Semesta Marga Raya (SMR)
Indonesia
Covenants Incurrence:
Interest Coverage > 2x
D/E < 2.25
The author of this report receives compensation based, among other factors, on profits of SJS Markets Limited,
which are partially derived from investment banking activities related to financial instruments covered in the
report.
This report is for information purposes only and is not an offer or solicitation for the purchase of sale of any
financial instrument, nor a confirmation of terms of any instrument or transaction. The information is obtained
from sources believed to be reliable but, neither SJS Markets Limited nor any of its associated companies
(altogether “SJS”), warrant or give any representations as to its completeness, reliability or accuracy and is not
responsible for errors of transmission of factual or analytical data or for errors of interpretation; nor shall it be
liable contractually or otherwise for damages arising out of any person’s reliance upon this information. Prices,
terms and availability are indicative only and are subject to change without notice. SJS is acting solely in the
capacity of a potential arms-length transaction counterparty, or broker, and not as your fiduciary or adviser of
any kind in any transaction and should not be relied upon as such.
Prior to entering into any transaction you should ensure that you fully understand the potential risks and rewards
of that transaction and that you independently determine that the transaction is appropriate for you given your
objectives, experience, financial and operational resources and other relevant circumstances and that you are
willing to assume all such risks. You should consult with as many as, and to the extent you deem necessary, you
own advisors regarding the tax, accounting, financial, business, investment, regulatory or legal aspects of this
information to assist you in making that determination. Generally, all transactions involve the risk of adverse or
unanticipated market developments, risk of counterparty default, risk of illiquidity, and other risks. Those risks
can be substantial and result in unlimited losses.
In evaluating the above information you must remember that past experience is no guarantee of future
performance or return. SJS may from time to time make a market in or otherwise buy and sell instruments
identical or economically related to the above information. SJS may also have an investment banking, corporate
advisory, or other commercial relationship with any issuers or counterparties mentioned above.
To the extent that the terms of a transaction as set forth in any written confirmation provided by SJS conflict
with any statement made herein, such confirmation shall govern. This document may not be reproduced,
distributed or published for any purpose. Additional information is available upon request.
RATING KEYS
BUY: reflects our opinion that the respective security(ies) is(are) underpriced and/or the risk/rewards trade off is
compelling; upside potential outweigh downside risk. HOLD: reflects our opinion that that the respective
security(ies) is(are) fairly priced and/or potential upsides and downside risks is mostly balanced. SELL: reflects
our opinion that the respective security(ies) is(are) overpriced and/or risk/reward trade off is not compelling;
downside risks outweigh upside potential.
SOURCES