Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
What makes man truly human?

What makes man truly human?



|Views: 1,468|Likes:
Published by Glenn Rey Anino

More info:

Published by: Glenn Rey Anino on Oct 21, 2010
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





What Makes Man Truly Human?Glenn Rey AninoDepartment of PhilosophyUniversity of San CarlosHuman beings would live confidently as human when the understanding of what it is to be truly human comes into light. Hence, it is necessary in this essay to raise the fundamentalquestion: What makes man truly human? I will begin by considering that to be a truly human onemust have a concrete body that has an appetite like that of an animal to desire something for itssatisfaction and survival. Science calls it as instinct, e.g., man desires food when he is hungry.Moreover, this is not what man wholly is for he is at the same time more than to an animal. Todefend this claim perhaps it is useful to quote Jostein Gaardner who once wrote:“When these basic needs have been satisfied- will there still be something thateverybody needs? Man cannot live by bread alone. Of course everyone needsfood…but there is something else- … and that is to figure out who we are andwhy we are here?”
This passage wants to emphasize that there is a primacy for the satisfaction of our needs; but wedo not remain at this level because we have another desire which is more important than thesatisfaction of our bodily needs. This is true for human because he is also endowed withintelligence peculiar to him. This power manifests in man’s capacity to ask himself abouthimself. Questions such as “who am I?” and “what am I living for?” are concrete examples.Dogs and cats may play but only man asks. We may ask: what is the significance of questioningin relation to man? Sartre says:
Jostein Gaardner,
Sophie’s Worl 
d, translated by Paulette Moller (London: Phoenix House, 1994), 12.
“Every question presupposes a being who questions and a being which isquestioned... The question is a kind of expectation, that is, I expect from this being a revelation of its being or of its way of being.”
Sartre follows the Socratic motto “Know Thyself” and “the unexamined life is not worth living”
as the beginning of all discoveries and understanding of man. For Sartre, man is an open-ended being because he is a questioner about himself. He always discovers something new abouthimself. It is in the discipline of questioning that man knows who he is and what he can be because man can give an answer to the questions. The moment that we know about ourselves of who we are and why we are here follows the motivation of our action. This action is to figure outwhat we want to become in our life. Both man and other animals are born in similar naturalcondition but both do not end in similar way, that is, man is the only being who is capable of changing the course of his life. Animals may die without accomplishing anything aside fromwhat we expect them to do naturally. But in the case of man, he is able to have a differencecontrary to what we expected. Man discovers the reality that he is a “being-in-the-world”
Jean-Paul Sartre,
 Being and Nothingness: A Phenomenological Essay on Ontology,
translated by Hazel E.Barnes (New York: Philosophical Library, 1943), 35.
 Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Symposium,
translated by Moses Hadas (Chicago: Regnery Gateway,Inc., 1953), 3. Here, Socrates is urging his fellow Athenian to live a noble and moral life. This can be done by doingthe highest good of man which is to know oneself through self- examination. The moment that one’s life isexamined man can establish a firm ground for his actions because a person needs knowledge if something is to bedone. It follows that “to know good is to do good.” The reason why Socrates insists on knowledge of oneself is thatthe good is virtue and virtue is knowledge. To be a virtuous man then is to be knowledgeable.However, Sartre does not completely follow the line of thought of Socrates. What he agrees with Socratesis only the primacy and necessity of revealing or knowing oneself and also it does not follow that a person is morallygood only because he know what is the good.
Martin Heidegger argues: “The compound expression ‘Being-in-the-world’ indicates in the very way wehave coined it, that it stands for a unitary phenomenon. This primary datum must be seen as a whole.” MartinHeidegger, Being
and Time
, translated by John Macquarrie and Edward Robinson (New York: Harper & Row
 because he dwells in the world but how he looks at the world is different from what it really is.In this given argument, freedom becomes the extension of man’s intelligence.To be free is to consider that each individual is the author of himself through the choiceshe makes.
It is manifested in the ability of man to control and determine his own plan in thefuture because he is a “being- ahead- of – itself.”
Only man prepares what is for tomorrow. Inthis case then, man is in charge of his own life and be responsible for its consequences not onlyfor himself but also to all people. Freedom without a corresponding responsibility is caprice. Wecannot separate ourselves from the relationship of other people. This is what Marcel means bysaying “to exist is to co- exist.”
Thus, what makes man truly human is his dignity that comprises the co-equalconsideration of body and the enrichment of intelligence leading toward freedom. Through
Publishers, Inc., 1962), 76. Being-in- the- world is terminology coined by Martin Heidegger to refer to the nature of human-existence or 
To be in the world is to concretely find oneself that he exist and stays in the world asan area of its making.
In this case, man is free in a way that he is the source of all values that he is going to live for. Value is not just equated to something material or sensory values but those values that are not apart from the question of being,what does it mean to be, or from life. In the existentialist perspective, value is that which a person lives and dies for or it is the answer to the existential and important question: what am I living for. In this case, value is related to truthfor how can a person happen to live and to die for something that is false.
This is one of the characters of man as
according to Heidegger. It means that man is capable of  planning his future which is ahead of his present time. This is only possible when man understand his own facticityor throwness into the world. He knows that he is born in a certain and specific condition and understands hisfacticity as not of his own making. By understanding, he also accepts. Through this, the world has already a meaning but
reinterprets the given meaning of world by creating a new meaning depending on his project towards thefuture. Despite of man’s throwness, he is still free to choose how is going to appropriate meaning for himself towards future possibilities.
Each existentialist has its different degree on recognizing the role of other individual but they meet at one point of realization that they do not exist alone in the world. For Marcel, to be a truly human is to value thesubjectivity of others in a community. Man is not a solitary being because he is surrounded a community wherethere are many subjects like him and is called for an active participation with others. In his essay, Manuel B. Dy, Jr.said: “For Gabriel Marcel,
esse est co-esse:
to exist ies to co-exist, to participate in the fullness of Being (God)through love, fidelity and faith.” Manuel Dy, “Existentialism and Man’s Search for Meaning” in
 Philosophy of Man,
edited by Manuel Dy (Makati City: Goodwill Trading Co., Inc., 2001), 33.

Activity (14)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads
Jpscribd liked this
kleomarlo liked this
Rossana Bay liked this
Jpscribd liked this
Ocin Azodnem liked this
Anita Paz liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->