Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Diploma in Psychology
Define the study of Psychology
The word ‘psychology’ originates from two Greek words, psyche, which means mind and
logos, which means study; therefore the literal translation of ‘psychology’ is ‘the study of the
mind’.
There have been many definitions of psychology over the past 200 years. Some of those
definitions are outlined below.
“… the Science of Mental Life, both of it phenomena and of their conditions… the
Phenomena are such things as we call feelings, desires, cognition, reasoning, decisions and
the like”. (James, 1890)
“… that division of Natural Science which takes human behaviour – the doings and sayings,
both learned and unlearned – as its subject matter”. (Watson, 1919)
“…the scientific study of behaviour. Its subject matter includes behavioural processes that are
observable, such as gestures, speech and physiological changes, and processes that can only
be inferred, such as thoughts and dreams”. (Clark and Miller 1970)
The birth of the study of psychology as a separate entity is attributed to Wilhelm Wundt,
German in 1879. Wundt and his colleagues attempted to explain the workings of the mind
through the study of their own introspections (the study of how they thought). Wundt’s
attempts to understand the structure of thought processes is known as structuralism.
By the early 20th century, an American, John B Watson began to question the validity of
Wundt’s work based on the premise that one’s persons introspection on their thought process
was purely subjective and that if another person produced different results, how could the
‘correctness’ of either result be proved. Watson postulated that psychologists should focus on
behaviour as it is measurable and observable by more than one person; therefore, the study of
behaviour was objective. Watson’s form of psychology became known as behaviourism and
replaced structuralism. There were many different pieces of research which focussed on
learning or conditioning and behaviourism remained to the fore of research until around the
1950’s when a new approach to understanding psychology was developed. This new
approach became known as cognitive psychology.
Cognitive psychologists believed that the behaviouralists had simplified the thought process
that Wundt had tried to identify with their conditioning theories. Cognitive psychologist
called these processes, cognition or cognitive processes and they saw people are being
information processors. Although the workings of the mind, thought processes or mental
processes can only be inferred, they are now accepted as being a valid subject matter for
psychologists as long as they can be demonstrated publicly, for example, through memory
tests or problem-solving tasks.
The behaviouralism and cognitive approaches have dominated must of the psychology debate
over the last century, however, broadly speaking, a distinction can be made between the study
of psychology today into academic and applied branches of psychology.
Academic psychologists are usually attached to an educational institution and carry out both
pure research and applied research. Pure research is research with the purpose of gaining
more knowledge while applied research is research with the objective of solving a particular
problem. Applied research is usually funded by government institutions.
In my answer to question three below on the types of psychology, I will differentiate between
the process approach and person approach to psychology and how applied psychology is a
sub category of the person approach to psychology.
Explain the relationship between Psychology and other social sciences (consider
sociology, psychiatry and psychotherapy)
Firstly, in order to understand the relationship between psychology and the other social
sciences, it is useful to briefly outline what each of the above means or refers to.
As I outlined above, there have been many different approaches to psychology and over time,
the definition of psychology has changed. To put it in more simple terms, psychology deals
with the way the mind works and motivation. Psychologists can have many different careers
in many different organisations and industries.
Sociology is defined as the study of the origin, development, organisation and functioning of
human society.
Psychiatry is much more precise than psychology. Psychiatrists are medical doctors with
qualifications in psychiatry. Psychiatry, however, is concerned with the treatment of mental
disorders as opposed to how the mind works. As I previously discussed, psychologists try to
understand the workings of the mind, both from a negative and positive point of view.
From examining the definitions of each of the above, it is obvious that psychology, by
attempting to understand how the mind works, both from a physical sense and a process sense
is linked with the social sciences.
Sociologists may apply the learning of psychology to understand why people are motivated to
organise themselves into groups and tribes. Sociologists, by understanding the behaviour of
individuals or at least why people behave in a particular way may gain a better insight into
why a society functions as it does.
A psychiatrist will apply the learnings from individual psychology to clinical psychology in
an attempt to treat psychological abnormality.
Psychotherapy will also apply the learnings from various approaches to psychology to
formulate treatments such as psychotherapy as mentioned above. For example, Freud’s work
on psychoanalytic theory and how the unconscious mind works laid the foundations for
psychoanalysis – a form of psychotherapy.
Under the process approach we find physiological, cognitive and comparative psychology.
Physiological psychologists are interested in the physical aspects of behaviour. Physiological
psychologists examine the effects that, for example, tiredness and stress have on behaviour.
Physiological psychologists try to identify which areas of the brain are specifically associated
with particular types of behaviour.
Cognitive psychology is the study of how we take in information and make sense of it – the
process of perception and cognition. Where physiological psychology is interested in the
physical aspects of behaviour, cognitive psychology tries to understand processes such as
memory, decision making and problem solving.
Comparative psychology also falling under the process approach is concerned with how
human differ and resemble other species. Comparative psychology, over time, has given an
insight into learning and conditioning. Probably one of the most famous pieces of
comparative psychology work is the work of Pavlov and his pavlovian conditioning.
The second approach to psychology is the person approach. Under this heading I will outline
the main types of psychology, namely, social, developmental and individual psychology.
Social psychology is concerned with interpersonal relationships and how our behaviour is
influenced by our interactions with others. Social psychologists, amongst other areas,
examine why people hold prejudices and discriminate against others.
Developmental psychology focuses on cognitive, social and emotional changes that occur
over the lifespan of people. Many developmental psychologists have accepted that
development continues throughout the entire life of a person.
The third type of psychology under the person approach is Individual psychology which
focuses on what makes people differ from one another. Individual psychology examines
personality, intelligence and psychological abnormality, which is closely linked with clinical
psychology – one of the applied branches of person psychology.
As a sub-heading of the person approach to psychology, I should outline that there are many
applied fields of psychology. Applied psychology is where psychological skills are applied to
different situations, examples of which include clinical psychology, counselling psychology,
educational psychology, occupational psychology and health psychology.
What is meant by the term ‘self awareness’ and how does this relate to the ‘self-
concept’?
Self-awareness is the ability to understand and accept both the positive and negative aspects
of our own personality. Self-awareness if the experience of one’s own individuality. Self-
awareness relates to the self-concept in that if we are aware of ourselves in the context of our
self-image and where it is in relation to our ideal-self we can work towards achieving our
ideal-self. Having a clear understanding of ourselves and our self esteem needs can give us an
understanding of what we need to do to achieve “self-actualisation”.
What is a ‘hypothesis’?
A hypothesis is a testable statement that psychologists will try to verify or refute. When
someone formulates a hypothesis, he or she does so with the intention of testing it, and he or
she should not know the outcome of potential tests before the hypothesis is made. When
formulating a hypothesis, the ideals of the scientific method are often kept in mind, so the
hypothesis is designed to be testable in a way which could be replicated by other people. It is
also kept clear and simple, and the hypothesis relies on known information and reasoning.
Describe the two types of hypotheses which can be used to formulate research questions.
Give an example for each.
There are two types of hypothesis;
1. An Experimental Hypothesis
2. A Null Hypothesis
An experimental hypothesis states that there will be a significant difference between the
groups that are being studied. An example of an experimental hypothesis is that using a
particular medication will have an effect on a person’s mood.
A null hypothesis is a hypothesis that states there will be no significant difference between
the performances of the two groups. A null hypothesis would be one stating that viewing
violent television programmes will not increase aggressive behaviour.
Describe three important considerations for achieving an appropriate sample when
conducting research.
When conducting research the three important considerations are as follows;
1. Participants
2. Population
3. Sample
The animals or people who are the subjects of research are called the participants.
Generally, the hypothesis put forward will determine the type of participants in the research.
For example, if the hypothesis put forward involves pre-school children, then obviously it is
important that the participants are exactly that. The next important consideration is that the
participants are representative of the population. Generally, a small number of participants
will be investigated, therefore, it is important to select participants in such a way that the
conclusions of the research can be generalised for the entire population. The third important
consideration is the sample. A sample is either random or representative. For a sample to be
truly random all members of the population should have an equal chance of being selected.
For example, if you could access the department of social and family affairs (DSFA) database
of PPS numbers and have a computer programme select numbers - that would be a random
sample. It may not always be possible to conduct research using a random sample so a
representative sample should be used. Continuing the example above, if you cannot access
the entire database of the DSFA you may be able to access the database for south Dublin, if
the participants are chosen at random within this limited database the sample will be
representative of the population. The final important point to note on sample is the size of the
sample. If research is conducted with a small sample, the results may not be representative of
the entire population, therefore it is more difficult to generalise the findings of the research.
The bigger the sample is the easier is will be to generalise the findings to the entire
population, provided that the sample is representative of the population in the first instance.
To illustrate this, if research is conducted after a football match in Croke Park the likelihood
is that there will be a large sample of participants, however, the sample may not be
representative of the population as it would be made up of participants who attend GAA
matches.
What is meant by the ‘experimental method’?
The experimental method is usually taken to be the most scientific of all methods when
conducting research. The experimental method involves the deliberate manipulation of one
variable, while trying to keep all other variables constant. For example, when conducting to
investigate how long it takes a ball to slide down a slope, the incline of the slope is changed
(manipulated), however, the ball is always placed at the top of the slope (constant). In this
experiment the incline of the slope is known as an independent variable and the time taken
for the ball to roll down the slope is the dependant variable. I will explain this in more detail
in my answer to the next question.
Some of the emotions we experience are happiness, sadness, anger, aggression, submission.
What physical signs may be indicative of experiencing emotions?
Some physical signs of emotion are;
Smiling, indicating happiness
Butterflies in the stomach signalling fear
Blushing indicating embarrassment
As I mentioned above, these signs are physiological changes over which we have little or no
control.
Describe the arguments of one researcher which supports and one researcher which
challenges this theory.
In 1966 Vallins carried out experiments which supported the James-Lange Theory. Vallins
provided participants in his experiment with feedback on their heart rate while watching
slides of Playboy pin-ups.
Using what is known as the false-feedback paradigm the participants were given false
feedback that their heart beat faster when particular slides were shown. The participants
judged the slides on which there was an apparent heart rate increase as being more attractive
than those slides which did not show any heart rate increase.
Vallins suggested that overt behaviour may cause subjective feelings.
The Canon-Baird Theory greatly challenges the James-Lange Theory by saying that there
were four major weaknesses in it.
1. It assumes that for each subjectively distinct emotion there is a corresponding set of
physiological changes. However as we know, there are a number of different
emotions which can be associated with the same physiological changes.
2. Even if the above assumption was true, the physiological changes may not necessarily
produce an emotional state.
3. Physiological arousal may not be necessary to experience emotion.
4. The speed with which we often experience emotions seems to exceed the speed of the
response of the viscera, so how could the physiological changes be the source of
sudden emotion?
Canon argued that the same visceral changes occur in very different emotional states and in
non-emotional states. Canon suggested that the James-Lange Theory was built on the
assumption that different emotional stimuli induce different patterns of ANS activity which
result in different emotional experiences.
According to the Canon-Baird Theory, the ANS responds in the same way to all emotional
stimuli. This means that there must be more to our emotional experience than simply
physiological arousal; otherwise we could not be able to distinguish one emotional state from
another.
The figure below shows the subjective emotion is independent of the physiological changes
involved. The emotion producing stimulus is processed by the thalamus (in the brain). This
sends impulses to the cortex, where the emotion is consciously experienced and to the
hypothalamus, which sets in motion certain autonomic physiological changes.
Perception of
emotion arousing
stimulus
Perception of
Thalamus sends emotion arousing
impulse to stimulus
hypothalamus
What is meant by cognitive appraisal?
Cognitive appraisal theory claims that some minimal cognitive analysis always precedes
emotional experience, although this can be unconscious and automatic.
In his work, Lazarus (1982) proposed that cognitive appraisal invariably precedes any
reaction though it may not involve conscious processing.
Which psychologist is associated with the cognitive labelling theory? What did this
researcher conclude?
The psychologist associated with cognitive labelling theory is Stanley Schechter. Schachter
concluded that the James-Lange Theory was mistaken in claiming that physiological changes
caused the feeling of emotion.
While sharing the belief with the James-Lange Theory that physiological changes precede the
feeling of emotion, Schachter argued that we have to ‘decide’ which particular emotion we
are feeling, or in other words, what label we attribute our arousal to. This label, Schachter
postulated depends on what we attribute the arousal to.
Schachter’s approach is also known as the two factor theory of emotion with factor one being
physiological arousal, which is necessary for the experience of emotion and factor two being
how we interpret the arousal.
The experiment that demonstrated this cognitive theory of emotion is known as the
‘adrenaline experiment’ which was conducted by Schachter in 1962.
Describe some of the physical and mental effects of long term stress. Provide some
examples from your own experience.
Long term stress can lead to serious health problems. Some of the physical effects are
hypertension (high blood pressure), asthma, coronary heart disease and peptic ulcers. Some
of the mental effects of stress are depression and sleeping disorders.
In my experience as a HR Manager I have encountered a number of people who have
suffered from depression for varying reasons. One employee had an accident at work which
caused his absence from work for an extended period of time. Even though he had recovered
from his physical injuries he suffered from depression for a number of reasons including, a
fear of the accident happening again and the loss of the ‘routine’ of life i.e. coming to work,
not only to do the job but for the social interaction with other employees.
Explain how when looking at two-dimensional images our visual system can see objects
as three dimensional.
When you look at an object, that object is known as the distal stimulus. That object will
produce an image on the retina of the eye. This retinal image is sometimes known as the
proximal stimulus. The actual experience of seeing the object is called the percept.
Ordinarily, we don’t see double images, because the brain combines two images in a process
called stereopsis. This allows us to experience one 3-D sensation rather than two different
images.
What do ambiguous figures and distorted illusions suggest about visual perception?
An ambiguous figure is one that can be seen in two different ways and a distorted illusion is a
visual display in which the viewer is likely to make mistakes in judgement of size.
This suggests that visual perception is an active, constructive process in which our visual
system constructs a percept of ‘what is out there’ in the world. Other examples that support
this argument aside from the two above are paradoxical figures (impossible objects) and
fictions.
What did Gregory (1983) mean by the statement “I wouldn’t separate the hypothesis
from the perception … perceptions are predictive hypotheses”.
Gregory’s theory of perception as inference states the view that perception is an active
process involving selection, inference and interpretation.
Essentially what this means is that our visual system receives information and then
reconstructs it, faced with certain stimuli the brain makes an inference or hypothesis as to
what is going on.
In my opinion, Gregory means that one cannot separate the hypothesis, i.e. what the brain
infers is going on, as that hypothesis is what we perceive, or is our perception of what is
going on.
Gregory’s theory does not explain why, if perception is essentially constructive, why so many
people have such common perceptual experiences, however, his theory seems to hold up
when stimuli are ambiguous or incomplete.
There are depth cues that require two eyes. These are known as binocular depth cues.
Examples of binocular depth cues are;
1. Convergence is when we look at an object, both our eyes pointing directly at it. If the
object is near then our eyes will converge quite a lot. When we look at distant objects
our eyes converge much less. The brain receives information about how much the
eyes are converging, which provides distance information.
2. Retinal disparity occurs when, because our two eyes are set some distance apart they
don’t get quite the same view of objects. The resulting difference between the images
on the two retinas is called retinal disparity. The nearer the object is the greater the
disparity will be, so the brain is able to judge distance.
Name five factors affecting perception and explain why this is the case for each.
1. Motivation – Someone with a particular need will be perceive in different ways. An
example of this is as follows; if you are thinking about buying a new car, a mini for
example, you will more than likely ‘notice’ more minis on the road.
2. Values also influence perception. For example, Lambert et al (1949) found that when
children were taught to value something more highly than they had previously done,
they perceived the valued thing as being larger. This effect is known as perceptual
augmentation.
3. Previous experience of a particular situation will affect how we perceive. In my role
as a HR Manager my perception of a particular disciplinary issue may be altered
because I had previously dealt with a similar situation in the past.
4. Instructions – To highlight how instructions can influence perception I refer to the
Vallins experiment in 1966 when participants were given feedback about their heart
rate when looking at playboy images. As a result of the (false) feedback given, the
participants perceived certain images to be more attractive than others.
5. Our perceptual set is probably the most influential factor in explaining perception. In
most cases we see what we expect to see. Our perceptual set is also known as a
schema (Vernon, 1955). An example of this is that if you flick through a deck of
playing cards you expect to see the hearts suit as being red in colour, however, if
someone changed some of the hearts cards from being red to black the likelihood is
that when flicking through the deck of cards you would still see the black hearts as
being red. This is because your perceptual set tells you that hearts are red.
Jenny and Michael visit the zoo. Jenny is told that a chameleon is to be found on some
plant life in the enclosure. Michael is not given this information. Both Jenny and
Michael look in the enclosure. Jenny sees the chameleon whereas Michael sees only a
plant. Why might this be?
One aspect of the context of perception is instruction. In this example Jenny was given
instructions that there was a chameleon in the enclosure. This instruction altered Jenny’s
perceptual set or expectation that there was a chameleon in the enclosure; therefore she was
more likely to see one.
Sarah and Tom are shown a video clip and asked to note the number of blue vehicles.
Sarah is offered a reward for counting the correct number (ten). No reward is
mentioned to Tom. Sarah comments that there were ten blue vehicles whereas Tom is
adamant that there were only five. Why might this be the case?
In this example Sarah is offered a reward for counting the correct number of blue vehicles. If
someone is offering you a reward, you are more likely to perceive things in a way that you
think the rewarder wants you to perceive them.
Give me an everyday example of a mistake our visual perception may make regarding
movement, size and distance (provide one example for each).
An example of a visual perception mistake in relation to movement is if you look at a
stationery spotlight in a completely dark room, the light will appear to move when it is not.
This is known as the autokinetic effect and is caused by small, uncontrollable eye movements
and the absence of a stimulating background against which movement can be measured.
An example of how we might make a mistake of size in terms of visual perception is
highlighted when we look at how film makers exploit our perception of size. If we look at the
space ships in the film ‘Star Wars’ we perceive them to be large space vessels many hundreds
of metres in size when in fact, they are small studio constructed models. Film makers exploit
the relative size depth cue to achieve this affect.
In order to highlight how we can make a mistake about distance, think about when you look
down at people from the top of a tall building. The people will appear as small ant-like
creatures; however, you know that they are people. Our perceptual system maintains shape
constancy; however it does not see size because of the distance from the people.
Name two aspects of everyday life where memory research can be applied?
The first area where memory research can be applied to everyday life is crime and the legal
process, particularly, eyewitness testimony. Elizabeth Loftus conducted a he body of research
in this area involving over 20,000 subjects. Her work has shown that eyewitness testimony is
often unreliable, that false memories can be triggered in up to 25% of individuals merely by
suggestion, and that memory can be interfered with and altered by simply giving incorrect
post-event information.
The second application of memory research to everyday life is in learning. There are different
approaches to learning, however, broadly speaking, learning is seen as being a process by
cognitive psychologists.
Aversion therapy has endured much criticism in previous decades in its use in abusing
patients. At a time when homosexuality was considered by some to be a mental illness, gay
people were made to undergo aversion therapy for their lifestyles. A number of fatalities have
also occurred during aversion therapy.
Information or skills related to one topic can sometimes either help or hinder the acquisition
of information or skills related to another topic. When learning from one situation assists
learning in another, this is referred to as positive transfer. This positive transfer is most likely
to occur when the learner
Sees the value of using what was learned in one situation in another.
For example, knowledge about the Revolutionary War may be helpful in understanding the
Civil War. Knowledge of French may help a student learn Spanish. Skill at tennis may help a
person learn racquetball.
When learning from one situation interferes with learning in another situation, this is referred
to as negative transfer. This negative transfer is most likely to occur when the learner
incorrectly believes there are common features, improperly links the information while
encoding it, or incorrectly sees some value in using information from one setting in another.
For example, knowledge of the Revolutionary War may actually confuse the student about
events in the Civil War. Knowledge of French may confuse the student with regard to
Spanish. Skill at tennis may cause a person to make mistakes at racquetball. Negative transfer
is usually detrimental to learning.
Insight learning is the grasp of the solution to a problem without the intervening series of the
trial and error steps that are associated with most types of learning (e.g., a monkey housed
behind the bars of a cage who, without proceeding through countless hours of futile attempts
with one stick or the other, fits two sticks together to retrieve a banana outside the distance
measured by either stick alone).
What significance may the above three mentioned types of learning have in everyday
life?
Latent learning is the process of learning something that is capable of being activated
although not currently visible. Latent learning is linked with the idea of schemas. Tolman
(1932) developed the idea of cognitive maps that we hold in our minds. For example, if we
are trying to make a long and difficult journey we might try to remember specific landmarks
along the way, not recalling anything of what is between those landmarks. What has
happened here is that latent learning has helped to break the journey into smaller “digestible
chunks”. A method used by many trainers in technical training situations in everyday life.
Transfer learning is significant in that it is a process whereby we build on old learned
experiences to give us a head start when something new is to be learned or an unfamiliar
problem is faced and it may be used in everyday life. In my profession as a HR Manager I
have learned how to deal with situations where people’s roles change due to the introduction
of new technology or processes. I have learned from previous change management initiatives
how people tend to react in the face of changes to their role or work practices so I can
develop effective change management strategies.
Insight learning is relevant in everyday life in that it was seen by Gestalt psychologists as
involving perceptual restructuring of the elements that constitute a problem situation. On this
basis, insight learning has many everyday business applications, for example, business
leaders may be thought problem solving techniques based on insight learnings.
Explain what is meant by the nature-nurture debate.
The nature – nurture debate concerns the relative importance of an individual’s innate
qualities versus personal experiences in determining or causing individual differences in
physical and behavioural traits.
On one side there are the nativists who believe that various aspects of behaviour are innate,
meaning that we are born with certain behavioural traits.
On the other side are the empiricists who believe that these behaviours must be learned and
are influenced by the child’s experience in their environment.
Explain reciprocal behaviour, how this develops and how it relates to socialisation.
Reciprocal behaviour relates to the relationship that an infant forms during its first year with
its mother. The nature of this relationship is reciprocal - this means that it is a mutual
relationship between mother and child.
The infant learns that there are responses from the outside world to its actions, particularly
from its mother. Over time and through numerous shared experiences the infant becomes a
social being.
Reciprocal behaviour relates to socialisation as it is this bi-directional process that helps the
child to learn to live with other human beings, in other words, reciprocal behaviour is the start
of the long process of socialisation.
Describe privation.
Privation occurs when there is a failure to form an attachment to any individual. Privation is
different from deprivation in that deprivation assumes that a bond or attachment was formed
and subsequently taken away or deprived.
Summarise the findings of the Goldberg/Lewis study. What does this show?
Goldberg and Lewis conducted a study of 32 girls and 32 boys with their mothers. First
observations were made at 6 months old and further observations were made at 13 months
old. The experiment involved children being placed in a room with 9 different types of
objects including pegboards, doorknobs and toys. Firstly, the child played for 15 minutes
with their mother seated in the corner of the room. In a later play session the children’s
behaviour to partial separation from their mother was observed when a mesh barrier was
placed between them and their mother. The following is a summary of the findings of the
study;
Girls tended to choose cuddly toys or toys needing delicate and intricate movements. They
also tended to be more dependent on their mother whilst spending more time touching her
and talking to her. Typically, when separated from their mother girls moved to the centre of
the barrier and cried for their mother.
Boys enjoyed playing with bigger noisier toys that they could bang around. They tended to be
more active and less dependent on their mother. Finally, when separated from their mother
they sought where the wall met the barrier and tried to struggle their way through it.
What are the pros and cons of co-operation rather than competition?
The pros of co-operation rather than competition are that is that all the members of the group
have a shared common goal. By all of the members working towards the same goal they may
learn tolerance of people from other backgrounds and races.
The cons are that competitive rivalry within the group may cause in-groups within the group,
each protecting their own interests.
What are the pros and cons of educating people towards prejudice?
Separation and segregation may make it difficult for people to get to know each other as
people so by educating people we may re-draw the boundaries between ‘us’ and ‘them’. Re-
drawing these boundaries may lead to everyone being included, or no one being excluded.
The opposite of this then is that the group that all people are now included in may grow
prejudices to those who are not in the group!
Explain what is meant by social facilitation.
Social facilitation is the tendency for people to be aroused into better performance on simple
tasks (or tasks at which they are expert or that have become autonomous) when under the eye
of others, rather than while they are alone (audience effect), or when they are working
alongside other people (coactor effect). Complex tasks (or tasks at which people are not
skilled), however, are often performed in an inferior manner in such situations. This effect
has been demonstrated in a variety of species. In humans, it is strongest among those who are
most concerned about the opinions of others, and when the individual is being watched by
someone he or she does not know, or cannot see well.
Explain the difference between facilitation and competition and the effects on individual
performance.
The difference between facilitation and competition is that during competition the person is
working or competing against another where as with facilitation is where the person is
working alongside another, for example they can see the other person perform. Although the
person is not in competition with the other they raise their performance on this basis. This
raising of performance is also prevalent when a person performs in front of an audience – the
audience effect.
The affect that the audience affect has on performance depends on how simple and well
learned a task is. In some cases the audience affect may actually inhibit the person’s ability to
learn new responses. This could stifle creativity or ‘thinking on your feet’.
The very presence of an audience will usually cause arousal however; this arousal will only
increase performance to a point. The performance level will also be influenced by whether
the audience is displaying encouragement or hostility.
The case of Kitty Genovese is the most famous example of the so-called bystander effect. It
is also the case that originally stimulated social psychological research in this area. Ms.
Genovese was stabbed to death in 1964 by a serial rapist and murderer. According to
newspaper accounts, the killing took place for at least a half an hour. The murderer attacked
Ms. Genovese and stabbed her, but then fled the scene after attracting the attention of a
neighbor. The killer then returned ten minutes later and finished the assault. Newspaper
reports after Genovese's death claimed that 38 witnesses watched the stabbings and failed to
intervene or even contact the police. This led to widespread public attention, and many
editorials.
What three factors may affect a bystander from acting effectively in the presence of
others and why is this the case for each?
There are three major factors that contribute to the bystander effect.
First, the presence of other people creates a diffusion of responsibility. Because there are
other observers, individuals do not feel as much pressure to take action, since the
responsibility to take action is thought to be shared among all of those present.
The second reason is the need to behave in correct and socially acceptable ways. When other
observers fail to react, individuals often take this as a signal that a response is not needed or
not appropriate. Other researchers have found that onlookers are less likely to intervene if the
situation is ambiguous. In the case of Kitty Genovese, many of the 38 witnesses reported that
they believed that they were witnessing a "lover’s quarrel," and did not realize that the young
woman was actually being murdered.
The third reason is the cost to the individual that is involved. To see how this applies in the
above case one should think that in 1964 there were no mobile phones so the witnesses would
have had to go out of their way to find a phone to make the call to the police. There would
also have been the fear of wasting police time and each person may have had an appointment
to be somewhere else.
How might the number of people in a group influence the majority on the formation of
norms? Consider evidence for and against.
In the basic Asch paradigm, the participants — the real subject and the confederates — were
all seated in a classroom. They were asked a variety of questions about the lines such as how
long is A, compare the length of A to an everyday object (which line was longer than the
other, which lines were the same length, etc.) The group was told to announce their answers
to each question out loud. The confederates always provided their answers before the study
participant, and always gave the same answer as each other. They answered a few questions
correctly but eventually began providing incorrect responses.
In a control group, with no pressure to conform to an erroneous view, only 1 subject out of 35
ever gave an incorrect answer. Solomon Asch hypothesized that the majority of people would
not conform to something obviously wrong; however, when surrounded by individuals all
voicing an incorrect answer, participants provided incorrect responses on a high proportion of
the questions (36.8%). 75% of the participants gave an incorrect answer to at least one
question.
The above results show that it was not the size of the group that matter but the unanimity of
the group that mattered in forming norms. The findings of Gerard (1968) and Latane & Wolf
(1981) found that the conformity rate would carry on increasing (but by less each time) the
more unanimous confederates were added.
Asch found that the following factors influenced conformity:
Group size – - Conformity does not increase in groups larger than four, so this is
considered the optimal group size.
Ambiguity - increasing the difficulty of the task – when the comparison lines were
made closer in length, the rate of conformity increased.
Unanimity – when one other person in the group gave a different answer to the others,
and therefore the group answer was not unanimous, conformity dropped.
Smith and Bond (1998) argued that whether conformity levels are ‘high’ or ‘low’ depends on
the cultural context. For example, the 37% conformity in Asch’s study may be considered
high in the USA, where independence and individualism are valued.
Shouval et al (1975) compared conformity to peer group pressure between 12-year-old Israeli
and Russian children, finding that the Russian children (in a more collectivist society) much
more conforming.
Smith and Bond compared conformity studies from several countries, noting that variations
between them made direct comparison impossible. But there were some patterns of in the
levels of conformity found:
Collectivist cultures (where the importance of one’s family, religion or race is
paramount) produced higher levels than individualist cultures (where independence is
most valued). For example, there was higher conformity in Japan than in France.
Common experiences among participants (for example Indian teacher in Fiji) showed
high levels of conformity to their group.
Students generally showed lower levels of conformity.
Why do positive and negative expectations affect why we conform to the expectations
generated by roles?
Positive and negative expectations affect why we conform to the expectations generated by
roles because by and large people will conform to the behaviour expected of them in a
particular role.
If we look at the self-fulfilling prophecy concept we see that people may behave to meet the
expectations of a particular label applied to them. So, if for example my boss continually tells
me that I lack attention to detail I may be less inclined to pay attention to detail because that
is what is expected of me. It is obvious from this example that the affect is negative so it is
important that we encourage positive rather than negative expectations.
We can further examine this matter by looking at the vicious circle of negative expectations.
If we continue the example above whereby I have paid less attention to detail as it is expected
of me it will lead to performance issues in my role. My boss then telling me that I have
performance issues may lead me to believe that I am no good at my job, which will cause
behaviour to meet that expectation, thus reducing my performance further.
One of the ways to alleviate negative expectations is to encourage people to focus on their
strengths. This has led my company to prescribe a book called Strengths Finder (Tom Rath,
2007) to the entire management team. The premise is that you discover your strengths and
work on those and also that you are aware of the strengths of the others on your team so the
team can perform better.
Explain how obedience may affect why individuals conform to the expectations
generated by roles.
Obedience, in human behaviour, is the quality of being obedient, which describes the act of
carrying out commands, or being actuated. Obedience differs from compliance, which is
behaviour influenced by peers, and from conformity, which is behaviour intended to match
that of the majority.
Humans have been shown to be surprisingly obedient in the presence of perceived legitimate
authority figures, as demonstrated by the Milgram experiment in the 1960s, which was
carried out by Stanley Milgram to discover how the Nazis managed to get ordinary people to
take part in the mass murders of the Holocaust. The experiment showed that obedience to
authority was the norm, not the exception and that a substantial proportion of people do what
they are told to do, irrespective of the content or consequences as long as they perceive that
the order comes from a legitimate authority.
References
Psychology, The Science of Mind and Behaviour, Fifth Edition; Richard Gross.
www.thefreedictionary.com
http://psychology.about.com
www.nhscareers.nhs.co.uk
www.wikipedia.com
www.businessballs.com
www.wisegeek.com
www.holah.karoo.net
www.parmly.luc.edu
www.answers.com
www.changingminds.org
www.social-science.co.uk
www.sciencedaily.com
www.helpguide.org
www.medicinenet.com
http://encartamsn.com
www.alleydog.com
www.usask.ca
www.studygs.net
http://frank.mtsu.edu
http://faculty.washington.edu
www.cranepsych.com
www.psychologistworld.com
http://atschool.eduweb.co.uk
www.encyclo.co.uk
http://education.calumet.purdue.edu
http://psychology.about.com
www.dreamhawk.com
www.wikipedia.org
www.aabt.org
www.minddisorders.com
http://psychologyfacts.blogspot.com
www.answers.com
www.absoluteastonomy.com
www.media-awareness.ca
http://teachnet.edb.utexas.edu
www.poorlad.com/psychology
www.answers.com
http://psych-ology.co.uk
http://findarticles.com
www.questia.com
www.homelearningcollege.com
www.learningat.ke7.org.uk