Introduction to city-pick Venice

Jeff Cotton, creator of Fictional Cities

Venice is one of the most written-about and photographed cities. ‘There is

notoriously nothing more to be said on the subject’ wrote Henry James in 1909,
and he wasn’t the first to express that opinion. He went on to qualify the
statement (of course!) and then to write some more about Venice.

It’s bunk, of course, to say that there’s nothing new to be written, not least
because with the passing of time the changing attitudes to Venice (and much
more) are reflected strongly in what is written.

But talk of changing attitudes cannot mask the constants, at least as perceived
by outsiders – death, decay, decline and decadence have dominated the fiction
set in Venice as long as there’s been fiction. As Venice has been in visible
decline from its empty but picturesque 18th Century pomp – and some, such as
Ruskin, would say the 1480s - there’s been a whole lot of decay to be charted.

The mid-20th Century was the boom time for ‘serious’ contemporary fiction set in
Venice. Wilkie Collins’s The Haunted Hotel had got the spooky murder thing
going and Henry James’s The Aspern Papers began the crumbling decadence
strand, but it was Barry Unsworth, Daphne DuMaurier and Ian McEwan, among
many others, who later ran with both themes.

Less well known than Thomas Mann’s Death in Venice, Louis Begley’s Mistler's
exit and Robert Dessaix’s Night letters are also characteristic in having their
central characters going to Venice to die. With the strength of this association it’s
not surprising that murder mysteries set in Venice load down the shelves in the
English language sections of Venetian bookshops, despite the famously low
levels of serious crime in the city. Donna Leon’s Commissario Brunetti series is
the famous force in Venice-set crime fiction, but Edward Sklepowich’s wiiningly
unfrantic Urbino Macintyre mysteries evoke warm memories of The Thin Man’s
Nick and Norah Charles. Michael Dibdin’s detective Aurelio Zen was born in
Venice (the letter Z in the surname is a dead giveaway) but his only documented
visit is in the novel Dead lagoon, a wintry gem of Venetian writing.

Younger readers in need of dark post-Potter thrills are made welcome in Venice
too. Cornelia Funke’s playful The Thief Lord and Mary Hoffman’s moving City of
Masks both make magic of the more sinister side of Venice’s reputation for the
entertainment of younger (and older) readers. And then there’s Michelle Lovric’s
The Undrowned Child, the first in a series. It’s a dark and warm tale set in a dank
Venice where mermaids cook curries and fantastic books change lives.

This affinity between Venice and darkness makes it even more surprising that
relatively little Venice-set fiction has been set during the Second World War. The
original Jewish ghetto is sited in Venice as a gift location, almost, to novelists, but
only H. S. Bhabra’s Gestures and Joseph Kanon’s Alibi have really grasped the
nettle of 20th Century anti-Semitism and Nazism in Venice. The former like a
good old-fashioned novel of intersecting lives, the latter as a gripping thriller.

Lately there’s been a certain falling off of fiction set in modern-day Venice and a
swing towards the historical, particularly the 18th Century. But this is a fashion
that’s far from confined to fiction set in Venice, of course.

The republic’s maritime prime is notably readably dealt with in Thomas Quinn’s
The Lion of St Mark and The Sword of Venice, and The Lion of Venice by Mark
Frutkin tells the tale of Marco Polo’s trip East. Venice’s artistic renaissance
history is oddly mostly dealt with through the exploits of modern-day art
historians, who come across as somewhat unlovable individuals in David Adams
Cleveland’s With a gem-like flame and Juan Manuel de Prada’s The Tempest.
The few novels actually set during the renaissance period tend to concentrate on
a strong woman’s experience during repressive times - not a few nuns knocking
around here.

For strong localised phenomena (and more nuns) we look to Casanova and
Vivaldi, and the 18th Century Venice that they share. The very readable volumes
of Casanova’s own History of my Life have fed some equally enjoyable novels,
including M.R. Lovric’s Carnevale, and racy biographies, the most recent being
by Ian Kelly. Andrea di Robilant’s A Venetian Affair gives us more love and
intrigue during this period.

But Casanova’s world of debauchery and masked deception has recently given
way to fictional accounts of the life of Antonio Vivaldi. You’ll need both hands to
count the number of late-noughties novels dealing with speculation regarding
what one might politely call the composer’s domestic arrangements. Not much is
actually known about his life, and so the scope to invent, particularly with regard
to his relationship with his young protégé’s at the Pietà (and one Anna Giro in
particular) is considerable. The best of these novels have been The Four
Seasons by Laurel Corona, which features Vivaldi as something of a secondary,
though charismatic, character whilst exploring the lives of two sisters left at the
Pietà and Hidden harmonies: the Secret Life of Antonio Vivaldi by André Romijn,
which concentrates on the composer and makes some wild guesses at the
nature of his relationship with Anna Giro, but also deals deeply and revels in the
music. And then sprint 2011 sses the much-anticipated publication of the English
translation of Tiziano Scarpa’s Stabat Mater – and actula Venetian’s take on
Vivaldi, seen from the point of view of one of his students.

Sharing Casanova’s status as one of the essential primary sources is Marin

Sanudo, whose diaries, recently collected plushly by Patricia H. Labalme and
Larua Sanguinetti White in a book called Venice, Cità Excelentissima, show us a
renaissance Venice rife with political intrigue, mostly. Also during this period
Englishman Thomas Coryate provides some much less dry commentary, from a
visitor’s perspective. In the interests of research, he samples and describes
Venetian food and prostitutes with equal gusto and wonderment.

Ruskin’s Stones of Venice dominates the section of the library devoted to

attempts to define and distil Venice – it’s a big book and, some say, better read
about than read. More recent attempts have tended to be less substantial and
more journalistic. John Berendt’s City of Falling Angels exemplifies this
approach, and stirs up anger and controversy still, with accusations of faux-
dramatisation and self-serving misinterpretation most notably with regard to Ezra
Pound. Judith Martin’s No Vulgar Hotel pretty much nails the signs and
symptoms of Venice-love, whilst Bidisha’s Venetian Masters is less ingratiating.
Amongst the quirkier and more creative summaries Italo Calvino’s Invisible cities
is the famous standout, but there have been more accessible attempts at such
poetic distillation, like The Other Venice by Predrag Matvejević and Tiziano
Scarpa’s Venice is a fish. But the best-known of these attempts at definition is
Jan Morris’s Venice. Along with the Ruskin, guidebooks by Lorenzetti and Links,
and John Julius Norwich’s History it forms the foundation of the Venetian
bookshelf. Less well-known is William Dean Howells’ Venetian Life – the
American author’s diplomatic posting to Venice dropped him into an old world
wholly new to him and the resulting book is a gem of urbane humour set during
the Austrian occupation and hence well into the years of dark decline.

Everyone has their own bookshelf, of course, and their own idea of Venice.
Decay, canals, cats, gelati … we all start with the same basic ingredients, but the
extracts in this book are the spices that will make our experience of the city ― as
tourists or simply as armchair travellers ― that much more flavoursome.