The State is a condition, a certain relationship between human beings, a mode of behavior; we destroy it by contracting other relationships, bybehaving differently toward one another....We are the state, and we shall continue to be the state until we have created the institutions thatform a real community and society of men.
Schwache Stattsmanner, Schwacheres Volk!, June, 1910
Wed 29 Aug 2007 : Iirrationality in argument
The truth is not found on the page, but is a wayward sprite that bursts forth from the readers mind for reasonsof its own. I once thought that the Truth was a set comprised of all the things that were true, and the big truthcould be obtained by taking all its component propositions and evaluating them until nothing remained. Iwould approach my rhetorical battles as a logical reductionist, tearing down, atomizing, proving, disproving,discarding falsehoods and reassembling truths until the Truth was pure, golden and unarguable. But then,when truth matters most, when truth is the agent of freedom, I stood before Justice and with truth, lostfreedom. Here was something fantastical, unbelievable and impossible, you could prove that (A => B) and (B=> C) and (C => D) and (D => F) Justice would nod its head and agree, but then, when you turned to claimyour coup de grace, A => F irrevocably, Justice would demur and revoke the axiom of transitivity, for Justicewill not be told when F stands for freedom. Transitivity is evoked when Justice imagines F and finding thedream a pleasurable one sets about gathering cushions to prop up their slumber. Here then is the truth aboutthe Truth; the Truth is not bridge, sturdy to every step, a marvel of bound planks and supports from the knowninto the unknown, but a surging sea of smashed wood, flotsam and drowning sailors. So first, always pickyour poetic metaphor, to make the reader want to believe, then the facts, and -- miracle! -- transitivity willdescend from heaven, invoked as justification for prejudice.Often we suffer to read, "But if we believe X then we'll have to...", or "If we believe X it will lead to...". This hasno reflection on the veracity of X and so we see that outcomes are treated with more reverence than the Truth.It stings us, but natural selection has spun its ancestral yarns from physically realized outcomes, robustlyeschewing the vapor thread of platonism as an abomination against the natural order, fit only for the gossip of monks and the page.Yet just as we feel all hope is lost and we sink back into the miasma, back to the shadow world of ghosts andgods, a miracle arises; everywhere before the direction of self interest is known, people yearn to see whereits compass points and then they hunger for truth with passion and beauty and insight. He loves me. He lovesme not. Here then is the truth to set them free. Free from the manipulations and constraints of themendacious. Free to choose their path, free to remove the ring from their noses, free to look up into theinfinite voids and choose wonder over whatever gets them though. And before this feeling to cast blessingson the profits and prophets of truth, on the liberators and martyrs of truth, on the Voltaires, Galileos, andPrincipias of truth, on the Gutenburgs, Marconis and Internets of truth, on those serial killers of delusion, thosebrutal, driven and obsessed miners of reality, smashing, smashing, smashing every rotten edifice until all isruins and the seeds of the new.
Sat 16 Jun 2007 : Nataliya
)emailm e @ iq.org j u l i e n @post.harvard.eduphone+61 404 6705830404 670 583(within .au)skypemeatiqdotorgpostPO Box 4080University of MelbourneVictoria, 3052 Australia
Iirrationality inargumentNataliyaEveryone and noone wants tosave the worldThe United whatof America?Kurt VonnegutdiesDo electricsheep dream of f16's?Decisions madeby a groupreflect itsmembership Average shyintellectualsCarbonoffsettingThe right thing todoThe AustralianlagoonWitnessing AutomatedauthoritarianismDoing thepentagon poker The non linear effects of leakson unjustsystems of governanceThe pendingtotal annihilationof the USregime inSomaliaIP over PPPover DNS over IPblack hawkdown, white
converted by Web2PDFConvert.com