L+19 jl + ,J&LA d L J, d,U&L

-+9~ J, \9 \A ,jjd&9,1 ,J l+l d ~ $ ~ & \ & L i dhCS$py

9 pJ?1 dfi dIrsd$f"Y) ~ ; 9 j j ( ~ d93c&"&"'jtiL)
J ~ 9 &
('I& 4 3 b&I9 d\.1;& fib (&&d;d+&l
+-~;l$~, & $41 ($i h ~ ~ ,+Y!.
r b9,
~ 1 ,J ~ $

")Ai db&lbt4L.l *%3, u'.ti-'91iLe &L: '31,44.3j&>J 3611;

4L9~!s't&d$1b>bl*b jl;L,b$ke&%+&k9&
uY61jlLYY*i)Lk\
)3)\5&bu 4 3 &bjbL.).Cdlb39!&&i)i

p-~ 1 $ , 3 ~ t & - ~ t ~ ) \ J + j ; k & jlGp\AW a k L l L \FAA

jtSL d;d+&l dl& .JL p b "YZl i)lJ9~
djI9;)%d)+K-~
jl
9 by jl'& d9>JJ9> AG ,bb &IjK&lhO
*b1J3j
dIrs~&
9- l"P' 9 d 1 9 j J 9 ylJ' )J kL
Q~

b~,Aijy& eLPjL J , K . J ~ & : . ) jI- ~~ C54b>)3djIphwYd;I

\ ? Y e

6 3 9 9 '>Isj &-IJLL ~ l + L ,bjepi A-sJb )J G)& jl b ,

wL,j j L . / ~ ~ ~ ) ~ ~ - ~ ; l j l dji ~ ~J~.LLS&
) l ~ ~ ~ K & L
. ( ( d d 3 1 b h &:)I; [&I CS$@y L& b I j . 4 +
(Mannheim, 1986, P.76)
~ od~ d ~ ~ [ ~ 9 (y);~k9;h141
L I , ~ ) I s & ~0p;i9 ~ 1 3
p 8 I + jL9, 9 &b .)ybijq) J.bjkICSI*
39j bhl. 'j~ual;
)3 \AT- JLL (jldiJ, bj19 dl .&L el, Le Conservateur
$2 .(1986,P.76)3% o ~ b L ; )& + \Arb JL 1- ; U I +,
-.y " 4 I.~) X , ~ ~ K ~ J ~ ) ~ ~ I )6% ~ ~ K ~ L ; L ~
&L. .+
dy!$1 &-,I2 +I .dL _ (T)rsXJiY31 &A9;
(\V9.)
+ !,&li;;/3+ 4(>9!c149)l )J & dbjL2
kJ9+ 4 5 Je ~ +~ II;GA~I9llj .A)$& 3, jL;I d L ; 3 d J 3
U;J (Kuper, 1996, P. 131) ~ 4 )+
, ;~ i ,I c S ) U & L
& k d h J~&l)K&LXO & b . ~ + b & > $ d b \ ~ ~ 6 & ~
J' kb;lxJ J @ ~ ~ ~ $ I ~ I ) J ( ' ) & >J~>> 4 ~ & k
t ( b ) h ~ dabjrl
, jI A-9~,Is?I; rb \AT- ,+-
E ~ j , o k c a a~LIj~ib d~.s~~A~J~&~\~+p
dIP~-l$ + ;?;, j J b d~~ )L! + \V. ~ b >9 &L;
jl kj'
jl eL L d j K d i i b j i db-k &- j~ &Ifip> y>

.J.; *b! [d,Ll L!$1 +WIO.Y3)d dbdd'+y

L &\i (A)u+ b& d Lb-1b>@ "bjy\ L&& CSjb&b
9 LdLPI+ >h; Jjjl &I Qi(;.J.;L& 5 ,yk&bLp
-+!!?*b+-
;&- J+ &Ij ,J
+ 2b G+
cs,K&to "+
GLL, ,,, ,Li &t, ,
.(Kuper, 1996, P. 132)
~le
++L~lho L d k b 9 d l & cu'.lJ& 143 IUYGI
 +%-,
... +d fi ( y A ) ~ d J ~ j ~ ; ; ( c G w ~'&6
~ <dl$~l,>(")'&+ (\y).dJ~k+ ( \ r ) d $( ' ~ ~

-
4Lpj &I j3 &&LO jl &Id& 6-1 63s *9j djjbhh .~;!43% 4;IjI && jl-djK&[X. p@ $b &cLP p3 6 &I31 j 3

+. J* ~;103fi +92 j3 ~;~I$LJJ $1' h- ijJ

&b$;51 +
,. JA-J~; A dlaojp j~hi9 ) ,! ~ &I++.,,,
a~;~~~+~~K&[X.jld~~w&&~LLl~i;&~-lfY) +tLjlb9+& j & ~ 9 $31;) & +(~JLcY)~>s
10 ~2
L .-k
djjip? &k 3$cp &
,
j & - ) d b l j9~ 3G&brOL j3hi LPIJL 9 c k k l d 6 & + % & 41 ji d 3 ~ 9
,LL dp cSbe.Y9
J j y )3 G\'l+ + 6J;I dlJ\d b r b (j19YLP ~ ~ j K L 9 j&L-I;a + d;rr? !j d j K & b tl+l : A L d
('q)*;g~pCSb G+b 6 J& J3 lj t+ @ U l&J+ ( & 9 '.
dx+ d j U & L ( \ :313
jI s-2".9 >Ijj G W L j~&I (1964,P291) ~ 6 j j~
p b$$ &+LL + LLG ('')6&y &jK&[X.
up-h° +I 9 j ? ~ j ? o ~ ~ I + 441 906 4 : d ~ d j b j d b j p j~L+C1&-~CSjK~[X.(~~LU,djK
4 &-) hj+ , d l j K & L > L - l U.+ dl?& .3Gd d&-LI L dj&+I) L A - !9 ~ L i & CI S b & - ~ l C S d j w
j b$j)l ,LL 9 d;4$ J+ + C S ~ L j LLSCYJ
Ig ' d 3 e 9 d l 9 ('v)(&lJK&[X.
AW7 &%lj 33Jd ,+ jyb .+i &a ,+& dbCS$i;e > j CS)u&[X.
~ (E--8 c6-+ &I j 3 :d))-$dls&ibC4
3+ &I 9 3Ad +kt1 3 j y (>J b 3 3 jl) LiJ;jCO C& j 3 L+J: %, i~9liL.
j3 + .-I cRBj jl A ~& L- 9&
$A& +I j 3 " ) . ~ ~ P I J G ~ I 6jik;l j 3 ~ P jl ; + jh dJ); &I.J&j 9 jKCSj&CSbd81 j 3 d3LG db>4$3
3jyhi jl~l+l&6 j o & jdjS&[x. j l j L j i d b % , ~ W L .-ldj,,t9 & E 1 9 J ~ 9 d ~ * ; ; ( ~ p ; ~ y d 1 4 ; ~ + L l f l i
I + .dLP
- 0 p L 6 y j g j jy1 JJ ?k;j 3 d j L IL , jldl++
(Wilson-1973, P.5-12) + 3& elybpO; hl+~
+) (7
(!9),,9^7- ('A),aJk . J k a ) 3 ~ 2 5 , 5-1
LIpl ~ ~ p ~p l ; t -
j 3 ,pli ~ ~ p 9 p - L CSa.~+LP
pllj(7')(~[bl)
,CSJU&LL.
jI JA :&& dlIJ&bC4 1. J-&<+ 31P1(je &L )gty ~ ~ ~ ~ g $ ~ J $ j j 5-3'jkId
l d 9
&IB+JL~ ~ z j ~~6 lj~i hi(,IP;.~
~ i 4-1 & l,
dj~&lx. 4;IjK&& LA^+ lj ,pli$jj~+LhL+.~+LPplljh~31yd
,I~L;d ~ ji3j1, ( 4 ; ~ ; L J;I&IS &I d)&,+ L~~ $1 .3jji + s 9dbldYfJ1d'&j3 -4. e
.&LL4 b3k . .I -y,\
OF)9 9
'p-15u.,. 1
y *4!b$;51d61;;( & a j K d &'.LC ,-bbhL1J~;jj 3 Jb,39j+;1* bIJK&b
csbz&1, + 9 2 4 ~ p 3 CSb~A&
p d J L 0 3 y d % ? \ d' ~~ 3 2 J~h 1 9 CSj91e 4; 9 &I+ & 1 p h J

: , 3
l L
p i
l .& &I$ JYl; dbe,b L ("B 4;b 4 ; + ~ Y ~ l p-LLj (je .(Rossiter, 1964, PP290-1) & h19;~;
J1 .&$& & L+!J &JL
JJL -3 4;j.f + &\9 C;b&j+ JI$ b &L+& 9 d 3 $ d b j p j l bbL"I >IjJ
;3 j 0 3 b

,It63 ck+ A-FI$ & j 3 e9dbd+ 1) C S j K 4 ) h 4CSL

'~ &12&1~&4 b L j3L>4j-f~j bCr?&1jL4Lpj>k+19p9$
' ; . ~ L ! , ~ I & + ~ ~ L . Lj ~~ ~ ~ + j~3 -tk oj &~d j (~ -j9 i 63% j \ >?+b 3 ~ 9 85 d j K & b &$&I b
L LI3fiuk ) K & L % I) [aL]dSj+-Pd;u+ cSkIG 1) &b d3fi;u ,tLV'~jb 4;LFL&jd4 + > k 9 ~ p l - ~ +
(Rossiter, 1964, P..,b& E
,L +J, &I&,L'j +;I ,K&1 bol;bjL, 4~ Id .+. I ;d+l dLI ,++
292) ,jb + JbG G L L L I d b d3jbx4 ( y y ) ( d &I b ~
& l, 93 2 + L L I I L L )I$J b l f Y ) ,&): q p
cSJ+y L3iJL hgJi (jEj .wq & & U j& d b f k +
h
,-I.J;I ,
~b - k ( r \ ) L& , )1 K i I +,d 'b& ( y r ) d j ~ a j l . ~ 9 ,(1) ! & h q ,bU &b 93 + 1)
&+I &X2 ,JL &-$ ;I++& & bSi;&I d~l$l d,$ey kLCSIAfjYb)(o b S ( y y ) C S J t~ 9~ J~ ( U ) ~ ~ d &
2 + - y . jI
J ~L I i + J 3j&+d9 jl 9039! + ,+9 d Y Lb++~t+~
.j.~~
+ LI;JI )K&[X. G)lj t! 9 +JLi dlJ1~
d3P ('"\)?&
( j 9 j ~ ) ~ f i ~ ~ ~ k j ~ ~ ~ U + ; 1 1 4 ;d5;4I4yl ! l hJ;l d ~ J ~ , &
+ydL&l+lL!$A b LJI;+ +;;.ol Ju;;@9l
3, +;,Ip !& +iLjl5 j L l i l + 9 ~ o $ I ~ ~ ~ J ; + .(FAY-T +,\TvY a
33jjj,&I+ 3?)L~I+ . ~ U ~ ~ L ~ X ~ I + I ~ I ,3+ hp; ( y Q ) . ~ , ~ p ~ d l j \ 4;41~,+ &--G+ 4; LI +-+
L., +
&Llb+5C Y u l b ? I B J j ~ 2 L bQjIj3 9 r 9 3 *);j3 c S j K & L :spa dJIJ&it3ra
4 cj-+J +;Ifi &@~ldb,+ &I; d G l o d l y 9 6Lf.&\ & )3 GI+ 6 &ILL -1 $$, J9!-Ap-
~ 9 ~ ~ , 5 h ~ Y - ))Lo+-G l ~ j ~y 3 ~ 3f13 12 JK&bd3s )bjjI &b@I dF + j L >I I&$ ,pl, 4 d L *>+U
4 -1 -1 $, L-L 4 5 6 - 3 d4;5;. ( 3 b + c;iqj &I;)&~I,il Iw+ 4;ljgJa l p k j~6 LI &LL&-, JFl ,dL+l
3 9 ~ 3 ~ ~ d j K jld*& L *.J;~LJ~~J~X;~~+
;.JyL ,?+F
I
; 3
, &+ + adY-Gl J+ & b e + 1 + &1?. J\'L ~LQI
P;?p J;I& 4006 J+ 9 by [ i l k & ] +
+ dJI& )J .-I 63% L U y ~ I ,-++ &_ CSjK&t3C. -L)+, (Rossiter, 1964, djK&LLo -L p&& &,
h9
J~~,,J Li;k9+ +Kg
plL d~Li5I + . G ~ iLL. ~ J 9 C);$
~ A-h!++ ("B 9 ~ l + ,plLS19j ~jp )3 P291) - 6

L Ll ;pSL hsJ3 J J ~ I 4 3)
b 3 9 9 " Y,G)Jd j K & L
Z I &I jl .-I d;gJ jl? d L ~ j +&Ay jI d+ ("B 9 dk+l ,+ 'I
?by & h L +)(+.12) 9 jjlj + 3k.J L 9 ~ L J J ? ~dbJ> JIYtJ- j K & L 9 C);& +
~ 3 1 8 1L W +
.gq h7 U ~ ~ ~ 4.cS4L..9
A 4 9 djLi t+jI L>9j: $1 b j p &I )3 .LLA j9b
-I. ck&l &i+,jbl&; &&& &lfY) & j K & L ) ) LP;
Ll6;6$ )I9 3 j p bbjl
~ &Ij> 4JcS$-3 3 L I .&I&$ 3)9U
9 ~b d > L J s Y & 9 +&,A+-C);j$JLSb)&9 b-3 d t L l (y')gLb~- L$-J;I~~ cCr?l$)ILSI he &lgC);&
. .

rv 1 YA b , ~ d4twg; -4
.Ub3p&LL &I9 I+ L ~ ) 9 )3
i 4d3+I, +ig
d)K&bu (JGJI) &b9+ly+ h) +I> 1;'L dl
& k & 9 d c p & 3 9 ? p . ~ 1 ~ ; 9 ~ 1 4 ~ 0 9d 1 ~ f &p ~ ~] J ~ P L S ~
&Q=;$ g%1;:.3+,yI+ Jw~))~dhha~>#b3LLSb$S+

h9.GL e-p
cX, 4; ~ ) g ;d! & ( j I j K & L dlx )K'(j> p93
j> JJl(d&ha jl dJL,8 - 9 j 5 1 jl .-I OAS
)1$3 J1@ +A 4
& dbbjp $ b & l b G & l ~ $cub jld# dbJ&
(Rossiter, 1964, P. 292)u.&i, )&+ $jYi
.c.~IoJI+$I;
&)LS&L
&,.,J+
hol_8

&L *.+

)I+ ,@)>+-&-

+->
&t
,+G~LI,
d)U&L >LA&&

JL] .cdl ~ J F&I9

C(
L, jL G
L

&&.09
-

c s l r a ~&-+L&u
), . ( d l y+)
L bL+)l)>~+)&

.+l)~i&b)~9b&&-
9

?I.
.+

. j l b G d $ *

I) hi;)I++
41 h41Ji;~
kbj,+

c~)-J

i t j cjo-)b chb)A- jkl

cj&I, 6 ) h~b .>,I> 1) pj'i ++&J+

d,p4& U 9 >csb+L- &d+9

cdI &-J;~G~LL., & 4 ~,LIj
l

L 3%9 >k+l-
@LJ +L

A-.+ +19
j p 9 b j19d;;b4 kbI,j9,>

dy

?Ix )> &)L &L_);'L+'

,K.+ >ldjl&)Kd&L>)y)>I)&g9>;uL

&b&)&~CS)K&bU)&>kjldb~j
>jl-'v,4(j)~cSbd9>

9 d).h JJ;j
&>-lJ
b p > p d)b
d 9 3 ~ 1 J . )>
~ ~ 1 4 ).I. ~ie;6

)ki) JL.

&.-I
J+;itb

&l+d'd>kl

j l j b +j.>+&

)bL, L L LhS-, e. ( > W ,LL,jG

>-I% er )&+
oLA b&-lJ &I & db> +)> 9 bhl b >)+*

:~lr.j,~lsL~Ld)K&L,&>~1-j..)bb~&7
9 bu!L && jl )bj-.&4,
,J
p9ls (y ; 1 )h
ql;l, db&19 L dl+\$1
&&$+

~b 6 4 %

j x 9 a ' 4 ) I P ~~?LJ)PoI)o*;x+ LsGIJ

.+ b j j g b&
.u> t )b G
+j

)& .+

h ~ ) d
~

(Mannheim, 1989, PP. 72-6) I-.

,jblJ-

j$J> JL )> & &--,L-

b J)IL &)I;. +L

~ ~
&
.+ 6 i;J 4d l ) K & L &
jld)K&L

,.,6

& & b ~ ) ~ > ) > , j $ ~ $ J ~,&Ldb\*

41
9 .
,GIp
-
LO
(1986, P. 76)
& J ~~
b9Y&
JFI jIdI&y+ &,JJ ~,i.&!,~i~l+
& S I + ~ + - ) L ~ ~ U + ~ ~ ' ) ~ $ C . & ~ ; Gr;'
t 1 ~ ' p . i
-

I ) > ~ l , L ~&b)M9x 4&J;l&-y!

>&)JekL
~ 4 4 ~ ) > d + ~ ) b, L L +4:h)LJLj
(y . h i 9 A -d 9 Jdhd+(\ :jl L)&4
>L+l LG, (Y 9 jh;, > L A 1,&)> i d 9 >A)'&9 plx-;l(Y

cf.93 9 cf.kjl&j;,n >&I

)J >p

(Mannheim, 1986, P. 84) .-I

.+ & &Ixb. > g d
,J

.JJ

j~4

)#L> k l b k . . $L dJ,ybl+

(Habermas, 1989. P. 23-8)

j x \ 4 5 3 ~ l 2%
y
I&
..r

I c;
l

d).h 9 cf.L+l JJ;j

J + d~> 9 b L- 4 9 p+
jl A-p ljJ.>jLd
.(1986,P.53) JL,l+c 41 .J+ ~ J t&)1
;;,.+
) ~

dID,j,C
Q&

J+-

JL;>
, L~
6

~ ~ ) . +

:!\&9bG

dl jl J)> 6 L l hi5 6 -1

)K

(\
-
4 J&' >)I

I) >I+l>k+l>$

+ & )> 6 b u &L" 9d).hc~9+&Jp;~. e L;k;lr!)~

~;I)K&[xo &-l;1.1;g4
~di+) &lt dleu+ *r; CGI &)?;rl
A--XI1) LJlJ-dj19j)4! &-~;l',LLhd
4)6hI JL . > j L 4 p I) &Y-I chb)9 >)1X;I4 & L+I+ b a 3 &
L
+
+ d3iA .+
4 J;LA t+
4

;;;)I.&
u~;I,GI,~,> ++

c-0-

)>

&9d
9
I ,I) ,
4
jl
JI

)J J+
i
G Y ~))I &+ .(d2 &)K&L
JJ;~

... &I>,
$;)Id
)

b ~ )hlw .+ GL+

9 &+
4 )

d k - 2 1 )
A].4bK&Lw
9 d-b-
6 c u l l L ... [lJP+)

~ Y ~ I d&L9
&K&L

LSJP

dl jl .bi+

G Y i k b&

)9&
.-I
SI&L
4'9b
) J

,j+ jb jp CSL
&)K&L

1 - d+k

9GL4A-,+;l+d&.+

p & c 6 1 U b jx

dL & L >)+*
y (d+IL)

+Jk ++
cSbb~l

EW
d+b)

9 [d~La;41-]

399
)J
I,]
4 4; 9 & 4 9 ) .+ 4; & K & L ; %
JLIJ~; 9s

)> p k d ) K & L

L &li ~c;Y)9 ba& A- .+ +L ,j+JF1

k
b-, 9 k ) K & L
I

y 2 Loj..b 2 +&4 4 ;& ~Iy

L~L+

J;J~&

csbb>dh

.&Ld p L

+
>YL

L- 9 +L)
J ) I + ~ (J+,jb)
p~

di.A

d9) dhih 9kpi

l

3U;".l;
&L-J.+;~).L

+YL)
i;c.;r~+ k ~ j y ~

jp CS$-~ ,b

d+
I>;Ll;>.

.(\V.-\

cSL,

gcl+d
p

9 L$)l+l
~ I hbl+ 6&b,,Lj,l9

~ &1?1;!.++I d
s d,K&Lwj)&~.bL;+
9 <>H~>b;il+

.(Habermps, 1989, P. 22) (($2 &bl+

,\YF- d a > L
.1"4bcs).h 9d~~~i,,l+ddb~p;
)p
)>
&-:J;JIJ~ b l \ 9 6 da,
cS$gr
19
j1
1

jl ,+
crl+

3wliz;jh C+

b:
d ~ ]

c& >+[+L $+o&I~LljIISL 9 b$+ 'j&hj,)Y+

jI'jl)K&L+

)&jl g
'$4
,
)>

)>&9)3
PC.bj,$&
jl
d4~a

w+
...[ &] d Y a i;u,Jlly.j'&-)~ dk-d 9 > U L G ) y a .+& Ll.>)l>
jJ ... -1+,d1~4
,U&J
J+
-,P;L-

bJ)9i
[d>l)l] J+ j U L 9 9 &)i 9 '-1

b j tL, 6);; ~ 4 ~ b ) -9 1i b+
& j! $ 4 b 9 & >+ >+
(T &LC&

p D ' \ \

.C.dlO>%,+.!&,I
+ &L db&L j l d l ~ l JJ+
P ID+- -Gb4 k L CS<+
~

)J SyW+I&dl+I

C S ) L S & L + & b b + l jl &-w dL9) ;LY&ld&

,(\YAY) &LAb
L +I~I)J+ &s9
~ i * ?Ip
jl

~ p jl bbi

uL;;;l
L.+ &-j&
q,L&bj -,

s
jl

i+9+
k-l+,~S,K~l&L+,lL6;*1~-1

d L I 2 ~ ~ J P J PG ~ d $ @ r c ~ & > 9 +iP$;&

dL_l+ ep;.+ hi )J 6 (ale*) jK+ &-l(yr

go>j
b31;J"Aj)l

L dL jl
J
$ L ;IJJJ%L .+ hY,[&l

e)J;.+ &L 1) bi;u,

.+ly.j' ; ~ ~ & -Lb~ J~B i) J... ~ y ~JLhj+J91
t i

) ~ ~L ~ ) L ~ x ; I ) ++ C+ phi+
c ; ; ; Y ) ~ J++
~ 91
&&

~ .,9)4
51s
$1
J,L>)lL +1,C

4 61bjb

.+A. d a > jl&++~;

9 pl+,>,

~ &

td9 >kc1
L- ,J;b3?
e~!

1) ~ I J L.&Y-
jId)K&L

&a
+
..
(Y d S i , , +

Le

+-J

4;L-Ii

;b%bp

L.+ )+L 6
b&

)+

LW
+
3
&y+e'~;j.-+)u.Li)

~ ; I ) I ~ ~ L
21919 .I+

;La;93 'jJJe

cf.9$

d 3 9 b

.+ C S ) K & L
',Jb+
b+-g~
bd)K&L
+
gr 9, .+ b 6 j (rV).~19ix

db$+
jl~$)3

@
,
L1
hlj9>
i+l>b
4 '+JL

)J
9

4;

3
~
J',kjud 4: 0~1908)y;r ;)I* dI,?*b$d 4J 4- dl 41 o* 9
21: &Kjl &k:~jk&% lj jk 2 ('"JL .L&!&
9 LK J3 *L+I bbJ 4: 4?+ ,+G *L+l ijl* chb 63%
&
,-
.dB, 9,& ;)&
p ) ,J)S-&L~ +, j l d d c p
( d J ~ ~ + ~ b& (y"',g-i
9 cp 9 c p ~ r t ea
1 . jl:Gbd >yy + 4: '+& db(+K6~jb
(?3rp) b+-l j l d l O > f l ~ 1 d+ lj9 hb 9 *&I k19) 45'&&
I;$,& %lO;D(C-B jl PJF ,-JKdiib @ jl 4 j i JL ~ ~ 1 % ~
. 3 j I ~~p9 JQJ
639 db31JLuI~~fi J I;jl&J&
)

LW + g 4 L ; CSIfLb j& Ls,jLI ' y F ) ' L > 9 & ~ ~ & jI

d & l e ~ l p i + j l ; ; ~ -S,IJ+ &j4; ~ ~ ~->%I;
1 ~ 1 ; ~
31+\hAcf.L+tLbb3i+Ij-.d&k;)wl&b jl~$-L- jl
d 9 ~ -I ~;J~J&,G
J ~ J )+ irJsd j i LW 4: J A -I
9~ L
. d ~ J 3 ~ ~ 9 1 3 & [ ! ~ ~ L ~ ~ d 4 & 0 y j 9 j ~ ~ j ~

jl &&-&I& > b ~4: +I.& Li 1-

J~ J E u &Id 4 6 9
J~

d+ 6e-L (j eb;L&b9I3 d b ~ L j &+ L -J+&d j b + L p

.&I,& G4pixjldb,+ 6.5 &-j~ t j b dbdJ+Lu~
cSjl~+Ly ddLF 6%+&o+I I" all d ) K d A i b )$L CSID~+J
ctlji.C+ L d ) K & b 41)+- j3 &%1;! .3jL4 cs)IYUIiI

G+L 4w+ L bcji d&~J 4: 4~ L+>K >&Ij1SL

,J be &LA+ L 1 1 Z+ ,J -L)L 3$ M!d J i ~ + L p
,
'+ & I &IJ@\ 4 LdJl+L\l +j &I )3 45 29;; +2 02QJj-
+ O ~ I ~ ~ L ~ L , . , ~ +up~J~~~~4+dg.~~oJfiJl;li
&Y~jIp;t
~;)b,lu~~,1;(&+I$!,L;~~)U4iigL"p3y~l~
d 4 ~ 4lug'
j I+ 9 J$& o ~ h J+l &!,VLj+ dPbL jl cjL+hl
4 &J$ 3blSb+ &L + & I J K & b ;)Wr ... &tiJ d J L + L p
>IJ31 jLL 4(&.fhl+4 do% ,& + .bhId @L d&-,$
9 d,br+Lu. 9I-! cSle&+ )J @L GL L &L djKdiilxo
&k& &+ p & k d+ j k d 2 1...~ I > j 4iIjYL)+
l~ cSbjl;jL
j~ j L I ~ L i L ; I ~ l e ~ l l ~ ~ ~ &db9J ~.~l+I~~)dp~
(Longhurst, 1989, P.136) ((.&+& d3;; ,y ~b j Y &
:d!3i)kxj & j3 hi+& 1) ygb k19)
 jbiYId 'jI-o>dkd , j b ~ + j!i j >+ )> d)lj?l 9 GJA +., .I;pSd $I9$.~jS>j~.~k.JFl d++ & L I 2 8b, .L+ ,GL +
I) d ~ e ~ ~ ~ 3 u ~ ~ 9 j p ; i ' o ~ i f ~ ~ ~ I.$p ~ 9 ++ + ~LI+ 41,J)K&L & ~ ~
. &Lild4hiii'j~
.:' .-...- dj.(i)l&7L~-j LO*) +Lid d ~ l . & ) K & L ~ l j W ~ljl.~.~~.~l~.~i~;))~.ljW :-I>

Cg >-+
, i S j : ~ ~ 6i b ) L i~
~ t i)) i9
) l (~& h~+ j l C j l o 2 ~c;. I) O& d ~ ~ ~ * \ 5~ $.9~ . ~ ~ &~~ G,L
~ j ~ 1L ~S
$%"jld~ap LG +i+ d ~ + ~ +lIbi - L ~ ,I d ;& ;,~, ~ , . )+
. . . .. . .>,I>
I L O i I . j . ,J d+LSb&l;;pa~~~,~ +
Jgpr.gJ&i&+.+cSJK&h+
. " LS LS
Lb : As-LSb>. . .:.
LI 4u+ S L ' j b C L j
k.8<i .t

juid6j; + J&UW~\)~&Lxb&+.-l~~W+lLSba~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ + l + ~ L Y ) c ~ b U ~ ~ C i li;~r~j)~&"I&> ~ l ; ) l ) & ~ )LSbL% ~ ~ L- -1 G b &A. &191 jld9. . L ; L ~ J-!Lpi
I~~
, . - .*) + )+ 'jw
4 1 3 >)p)J &I++ + ('jl)K&L +) 1) JJ>~+l&.+.li &LGJYJ9 4iI)KdiiL &L-I, +
:.: . .&Ld a;4l,~,~,: :.~ - (Habermas, 1989, PP. viii-mi) .&Li cI+l
dple+9.+-Ljlji J44, J b I > ? L y , c j L j & b 2 h $ +
.. , . .A
\9A. d4~>)3 t,L JL ijL+ JA+&IJ+ +
4: +iA+
~, >.+I+ -9 j.~fl ~ k + ~ ,+b-.I;;-.
+ PI) )>

G,s4Lbi&+&Jwg- . :. : 6fi J P
dgJ&> :d> b9J b + !,b'ji &Lib I 8
; ; jLlJ- hbl+

-
< ~ ,:: , , ,,.., ., . .. .(\AY ,y '\VQ ,"Yp)
-,+d,d!,4;tiJ-~1plrjiLp c - u)-~.-Lt t-+--Lte,
u. L. r. &(O" &A
> , 2, , . , ...
J L j 5)s. )gs 2 d ) il/J(1 ~

f'i&Ju&h + 3 6.uaiih. i
A
, & f l u
. .
.- .J,U&kiih.
(Y [A&'+ +
1) 'jbdb~19L~ 9 Fb.;l&e91 &>b g b
. .

..d+hI. .L;,& I) +)I. d>h;j1I9 C p dbo+ d((.a')4-L.t, j b r & ~

A (+I
I---- ----- l . - - ~ ~ - - ,I + 1) JA+ +)J, , & Ijlhj
~ O ~ yDb
L L- JS& dbi+
. ,. & dhojp 9.&&&b6jY & &- 1) ~J]..L;;L~
LG1b
1 - ,jr,l,&[hP(Y [&Lid 4 I) LSbI;e
9 -I, 'a-
(Habermas, LIJ& L d$!,h5i159 d(oT),
pl+.+l>
,':\,.'
. . , . 4 I) J+ J+- LS+i&)~9 b~jir.1989, ~xxi)
::". f"lp #19 b ~ I L J ,&lard+;
)> ~ p
)J Cr?~~~+-~$.+. 4LLdk9d4&p>+l+'jl+ % J-,J ;jw e4 9 > 1 x ; .

,.
....' &I jFl LI -I b~ ~ l l ;;,& .~ +6 GI+ +
~5~)2; jb ++ ~YLG g k ,+icycp ql$++ 0e9 + dL, ~L
:: : 8 b b I J I I I & + jItb>L9; jI)K&L.(\AA ,y ,\WQ <"Y+) ~ . L ; j &
->d
),I
. L J , j b L I .d~ll;i I+- , & L l a h b l +d b ~ kb ~ j
&I9 d +IJ>+-l+ d&l)K'&h
&b&lJ & L x b jl o$L L S ~ & L ~ + 29))d~9 ~ L ~xr . 2 3d J 9 j ) p l d h b +
o*ISU&a dbJIA9 +).LA d k I &/)I ?Ix)> I) &)b >I* . & C L C J f s & ~ j J>.(l'.V,y4\V~)+LLbL;'9 I.;;3i!+I)>+
L+.d5LlJ>+l> .JA>& 3 d+:d'p>j t-IJ +.G &,.fpI>4 d L3 $&db 61- Lw ,j~ >++ &
>+J> ++ 1) i &+p LIP& d F p L jl)K&L&Lxb .. -. -- 4
(Habermas, 1989, PPmi-xxv) ( ( L I O J&bVi>+
)L;S ~ . . . dl+l..
I)&)l(&h(+) & & b J k db.%-I;! -. : ~ J s & \ x& o~ J H& ~ J> &b~b()$b&~>+G

.~:....
-:h Kj-jIj-5 + GJ&& ,jd&&,I 9 Sd++ &I+& 1) b > d L dl>,
4 0 d&$+
~
.
h k )++L Lb9 b&-) +-
CI!Ll+'i~-\ jld9 &- [! cp?cLI;.o 641) d ) K & h + 2 &LkLB JliL; J+ JL;>
.
. , .+& y1;91~r.3, ,1 J*?; $2, &L j l d 9 9, " ~ >,b >.+I> 9 >A+
,- j+ 4...tj;w
LSb>j)l k3 ) 9 + )! (& ~ L G l,) JJ\-7 )> .dd G,+ )LB 9 $&I/ 'j+b aLSj&.C 1 & (or)db
cz . ,. . .. [~
A
JA
hjLk)si9b
Y
qfl ;C
f LS~&~)'-F Y+ +I)) Lb A>~ s b b j Cp S ~ +
,
..,?. , I+

, Y - : 8 4 JLL- ~ ~ ) ~bJ ( ~~) + I ~ ~ L ) J & ~ I ( ~ ~ ) G L

a
. +l";'-
.-:S 9-@&l I;% JP9 ~dp+-V . J-. 9 $jJ1
JJ &&I d L L > 'bd31p
l ~ d l&Ll2
.. .. : ...
., ..:,jhU?b)
..' . ~ I ~ J u JZA .
. a+>+- 6~~
L.,+-l $-GIs9) +j1.k- - 0 3 t9+I) A)* >+
- 9 d>&l I&& .+~ U p
J )> 9b.G9 9 - b ,-,+2 &)b d 916 1~.L+JJ+;;-L~+.~+A,~.~~IJP;P
x db0jy

I
I
: ;4 Y i I JFI

. . .bdAd
2
.-I+
>+4%"G L L I cr14j)I>I*.;.19
9 , G b)> &I$+
+ +I>
4;bUi>+ jJJ i)l+-V

+ >hli)l+-9
G&-A
.JA+

.>
,
L $-9;
9; ‘jk&I
j L j j L ~LS%p&&)~
)J ((-"').L db& +
LSb9p
+99
..~il=,
~ $ ~ j ; t ' & ) + ~ b $ j ) I G ~ c k ; +BG+
&[BJliL; Abd &)J,L
J J~K~
& L~
l)'jLi&b2b IjJ I;b)J&i LS)lj
4Jjj Jb .&b>pl&L_lJi&- 4e~r,ab~/J~I~+'jI++ p+)babJ
+

... .. . . .
, ~ . ..
r.
.... +(iJ9>) +fb idlfi.b d>E!db9+ 1) .L;e);I1?& L x b & +
. . .. , . &G3&9J . .; <:
. . . &k9"14;4L_jgh;-blp --j- jL;lbPj9) fLjx~b+lji)&
.. ' 9bws;J k ) ~ p k , > ~ P s j + ~ b ~ h > & + & ~ i ;s+ ~b YL; , ;) ~;LIJJJ)K~~~$+ .-I &b-i 9
pl;c (articulation) d++
&+&l-d~h-l~
.';-'l+lddA~
j)
A-$L &A+
)(&)Jvo--)
Jw'(l$dF
&b *) ~
hsj,&b
-
#&
1 )
+
4)s~
9 + pL &)b L k i;;ldJ9+ &&I))
& dl* ~
l,j , ( b k d - &+I&.) ayy&-,i&$ do&+

3, &-) Jdj9b+.+ .-I C5JK&bu0; CS$Lku )) 1) d>$a

)3 d-l$Jl~l .>)I3 L9+"%I jl ee IJJIGI CSLb& r;Jh
.+ &i03+- &I$- +itjb &Kg> .++A dJb)l &h&19
49~,bi
+&LB) AL .+ L++-1;9-4 &,L GL $%
rjjG + 4 3 ~ ;j L j d h d )3~,p
~&31L.1 )3 4 3 9 &j b p
"%I) +J$+ ;-+-
d.L9 )blkjc; S ~ 9 &L
I C S J ~ I
,J,I>+L~ &Ld?jl a L 1 + @I) .(bV "Yiijl JA t L 9 +

1JuiyLyl)dh~~9 j)-b &-1JjJy-Yk +J% L C j &

j1bl;L 41:d& L .3+ Jbd J ~
pb Jpz9 U,,~~ l'
JQ'djL499 9 &) ;~JJ~J&-J~$9) cp+
L g+ ~ 4 p 9) jl .+J$ cs 4 ~ JJ) &> L?jd& c 5 6 3 6 L
9,9lii;41 jLJ)&9 d J b L J g i + h j + o d ~ 9 )
,bbF,2Fi~+ J&J~J~;% &).L 9 ~ AS~JYAI ~ b
.-I d9t.u~9k db\3'd~i] 9 dl&
iS,. + +ifk +'dlb>b &I9 dCS)K&h+
d h ~ b ) ! &)& d ~ m \ & \ J k l $-b1) -1 & & +b
+LF jh "Lljll L ! w(djL&+ 9 LSjL~lji d L l h -

--
4bG L;++ ( ~ t ( ~ L 3 1 h r I L S P 4 ri~(5-L;
jb 9 did+)
blPr,-3 d&J L r 3 9 b+ dl$& 9 I$& $6GX4u
.+!,;lid~++e+&-J~JjLLS~&l
&a& 9i...)&sA$cS~jp

JLS~,^,, 1jb,L. +i+ik&llbbj~ ,.+L!.)PJ~

J ) > j1 Ij &a& 9 b 3 j i p b I) jlp ?il;; )3 i)i Jklv.&9 &a& j 9 ) 3
9 j 9 ) 3 &\$a L de 4b8 9 3 8 d e 9 &Lo c S h L & 4 9 hi-1
dd;d9;+IdJ+ + L J K & L + L S j ~ 9 ; + l . + k ; ~ ~lc(?le)-j9e
L
9 dlfi* di )h) &h[;?
9 +-
9 & 1) J+ A
9 &J$
'dj19jJH dhbj&l + ,Lo9; ()-I$+-
jj-4 a&
&-I+ & 13.-I ~gi,KakY,l dlx ?;Y $+ 0 9 1 fk i;b
.&Lod Q& &I ; Y G &s J J 3 ;I a G
 + +6 c j i v " L &CO3Q
96 "rim fk &A+" &Jd
.sIoA.T

1 J'.&b+-Jw@
l $ J l ~&
+
.
cl J> &),+LA&L;I
>Jy + JL+ 2 +J9>\-~9 >+ --
-+k "

1.y L( I . & ,41+

J-I & 4 ~ o L~, ~ &
~ I I+ : 4 i ~ ~ kd9>-\
0
' JJ . J)"O , 9 GJ2 + d,b&s9J
,j+ ir%.L + +9+-~+,.i
.(\.V-\F , p a a\W. d A pb &&& ~b&L b jldg + 6Jl>d?,Lppk2 4
&1)34(; dd ,[~uI &+I P+ i ; ~ dGi
~ j J[Z-T. GLLI &G9 + +I9)LSIJ>+,Lp+ qI>?tjjl4ub JEI &LI Li;ii;
.>I& 112+-
9 &JA >JY d
LZ
J 9 ( j l 9 ~ ~) j l +( i o j p 9> J L l <+I> &LyL
':
9 ++ +->I ' ~ f?lj
~ jfF-
9 9 JL 9 >Ix> .~(~ l>l
.&)MI
31 - Reactionisn~ ' . .: + &jl9jje1-1 +-IJ 9 (&I>& J>) >+j .@ &IB+) L & +
32- Restorationist 4 <\TVF '+,A)
+>JJ-I JLy J,,& &'+I9 & > MirJG
I +
33- Discourse (T. \-\C
34- Edmond Burke 2- Chateaubnand

J+
."
35- Esteen~ 3- Ednlund Burk
36- Prestige 4- Whig
$,+ ; , '(Daniel Bell) J &I> :be &>I,.il IJ &,Lu +,gyLYV .,-J'+rr 9 L S J K A'dl4
~ -b
d ,. . .-L&, ,(Na:han Glazer) &L; '(Peter Berger) 6- Tories
(Edward Shils) ,I.- >,19>1 (Robert Nisbet) ++ ire!, '(Lipset) .: ... ?- Doctril~e
J&s
.A>& 8- Tenlprament
JiFL L! ,$Ld &-.;I JIB&+ 4;& 4u>&ALL94 &-Th 9- Libertarian
,' '-) 4) L- 9 .;+& jJ*9) &,+.
&+9 &&I &ls&Ls >, 'cilsL. ( \ W - )&I&lr& dJWIix,l)2 &dJ> jL9;L*JL;!I+.+-\.
'>A+ - ?& '>K&ib - J I d L L ) &+ 4,ITD1;&LB+ 9 IB& nlz;' + -b )> d l j d IJ ,/JK41;iba :>J9\4 cr9JY Aj;I &+
!-I 4+ L ( J K l a > L (... 9 j*-. .AJb
&IO>~J C.L &)IS&\, .d
,bl ,%I ;I 9 A24 IkY >,sy && d9>
39- Robert Eclesall &LI GI* b ~ L >gd
~ ,I> + ~
&,~l>l;i
d,~~>,i A~:,
40- Lipset . . .(\TFP , ,\TV. j L j J i )cc-1 *'L(Radicalism)
41- Raab >,y I,dl >,I>~ i+ ( :Reactionism - \ \
L ( ~ J45 +.AJ>

42- Bennett .(F\' 4 &,af.) j!j:+ji

43- O'sullivan dlsJ94 6 9 LbLjL ,Is>lBjdd14;Ji L qL j,b :Traditionism- \ Y
44- Buck Jk~ j9j: 2 JIOJL &I?. ,!~ ij ( 1 4 3UI~ tl Gi &&I

45- Aber Crolllbic .(An 4 r 3 L ) L;l$J1i,i ;)yjj >Jy

46- Rojer Scruton ls,Ul>jhiup LS,++I Lj19J l j i j :Cqnfomlism -\T
47- Idea AILIJ >+J'SJ 9 % 9 A*& IJ >YG)L.I~.
+
. +,&*j~l
48- Belief .(\" 4 ,;lLj .>;L&~*rhj
. .
49- Richard Wolin &-GU;lu hi 45+ 64uk &IBJA,~ ;I A,:Misoneisn1-\\C
,. ..* . . .
+$L;;I
' ,

50- Old.Consc,rvatists . LcJji+

,A.~ -L;+& !O
,> dP 4 o>).~I

,, 51- Ney Coi~servatists .(\COF

a, , '&A) i,i& O>> ,,+. .
5 % Young Conservatis1.s 15- ~ e m ~ r a & e n t a l
. .. .
. .
. . ...
53- Differentiation of Spheres 16- Situational
54- Cosruologica: World Views "I&" &bbl+'ijY, p W 4 u b b e &bijP e+y -\V
.I;?+ ,+ J
, I, JLI " 1 , ~ &,!L dhi+-
00 .bug 9 && '&l;FI
j'4, +2 s ) . -0 JGl1
j+
I, 9 fiL S ~ L ( ~ + jl LJ- 9 I I - Habit
&,bL
.>jL& h 0 j P 19- Inertia
56- Ali Shariati 20- Fear
57- Assimilation 21 - Enlulation
)tidGw J> ;1 +*~ dJ>
b~gdc&,+,,Lji~ J+
22- Residues
,+ :+ >+
-Ip ,j+@a,S Jl&T+ 'YT ,YY ' Y \ ,Y. ,\b a \ ? a\Y b '\C 23- Spirit of Novation
, G ~ 2d~b ~ j 9 J 'e,r; , &jdg;+19
d & - >~ ~ >->
41,))
'\rvn .i.1321.~+)t-) 24- Spirit of conservatism
.\TOY-\. o J L ; .@-JL ,pLI,
! -1 ((&A\+)) &L*! ,
! -'1 &#9) ,! &h0$I) -70
. b y Aj+\CT oJL.-i J> -b\ ... $jJl ?% J> p9> d k - J> 9 e14;iJ >y >, J31 dI, >, .cc-~))

60- Micro - Agent; ~b &I,! +I? -1' b~~oui,+l; LLI, 4+s,o>,i

61- Macro - Agent 2 & .,--I ";kj %i,. +,> 4. -I &>Y., & 1;:) JJ~ +t
62- Macro - Structural ~ &I,!
L :JJ~ +Gi OI] 9~ 6 d ~ o ~ + , ! ~

J.;$l &
+
, &"* &&'I L &>,b &puI <r
01;:&I,\
L- 'bd,lJ> &* + 4;IBsI I>9lg u ) & 6 9 + 1) + '& &LO!,l..'Lcr
"=-I
,&Nj >++@ J> 4-1 2-1J> &I ~~k
,+I >, 5 &. JU & d~ d&$+.~~Jcr
JL 3-1 ,>)I>
dl+ 6 +Id j.;j J ~ +
&
,,+I J I ~ ~ L - L ~ Z ~ & ~ C ; ) + , ~ L L - &
' L C ~ .&& + lJ91 L;kl,i ,JLIA.A
+ + ~ ~ ~ L(J?(;&b

.'.
JU j J W L JI, bb dbx b &lo>$&> IJ)py & .(YYT &2 '\W.

&. ck; jl j+CVJ& +' +9;

w b >J>g LL J> ) 26- Tolerance
JP- &$.> JK+ IJ94 &flI b9 +- .&2& & 27- Obscuratism
28- Maladjuslinent
64- Micro - Struct~ral