Professional Documents
Culture Documents
and Burnout
HEATHER A. MCPHILLIPS, MD, MPH, BONITA STANTON, MD, BARRY ZUCKERMAN, MD, AND F. BRUDER STAPLETON, MD
Objective To determine factors associated with satisfaction and burnout in pediatric department chairs.
Study design A 1-time online survey of 250 current and former pediatric chairs who were members of Association of
Medical School Pediatric Department Chairs anytime between 1993 and 2005. The questionnaire included demographics,
satisfaction levels, stress experienced, and time spent on various work activities. We also included the Maslach Burnout
Inventory—Human Services Survey and the abbreviated Workplace Climate Questionnaire. Burnout was defined as high
scores on the depersonalization or emotional exhaustion subscales of the Maslach Burnout Inventory—Human Services
Survey.
Results Our response rate was 62%; most chairs (65%) reported being very satisfied with their job. Approximately 30% of
chairs for <5 years experienced burnout, compared with 15% of chairs who held their positions for >5 years (P < .05). Factors
associated with burnout included years as chair (odds ratio [OR], 0.9; 95% CI, 0.80-0.99), >1 night worked per week (OR,
5.9; 95% CI, 1.5-22.9), high workload (OR, 3.0; 95% CI, 1.3-6.7), and lack of supportive work environment (OR, 2.2; 95%
CI, 1.1-4.2).
Conclusion Steps should be taken to decrease burnout in chairs, including policies that promote physician well being as
integral to successful departments. (J Pediatr 2007;151:425-30)
he role of academic pediatric department chair has slowly evolved from a largely teaching, scholarly leadership role to
T more of an executive management position.1 This evolution has been influenced by the growth in faculty numbers, the
complexity of providing specialty pediatric clinical services in highly competitive markets, the challenging National
Institutes of Health funding environment, and the added administrative responsibilities for chairs.1 Recently, Stapleton et al
reported that an average of 17% of North American academic pediatric chairs leave their position each year.2 They also noted
a paucity of women chairs and a shorter tenure for women chairs than for their male counterparts. Turnover in departmental
leaders can create significant instability, and replacement requires significant faculty time and institutional resources. Although
this turnover rate is similar to other senior academic leadership positions, factors contributing to pediatric chair satisfaction and
job burnout have not been studied.
Burnout is a psychological syndrome characterized by chronic interpersonal stressors
at work. The 3 dimensions of burnout are emotional exhaustion, feelings of cynicism and
detachment (depersonalization), and a sense of ineffectiveness and lack of accomplish-
ment.3 Unlike depression, burnout only describes a person’s relationship to his or her
From the Department of Pediatrics, Uni-
work.3 Burnout in physicians has been related to suboptimal patient care, poor health, versity of Washington School of Medicine,
sleep disturbances, and impaired job performance and may increase the risk of substance Seattle, WA (H.M., F.B.S.); Department of
abuse problems.4-7 Pediatrics, Wayne State University School
of Medicine, Detroit, MI (B.S.); Department
Most academic pediatric chairs in North America are members of the Association of Pediatrics, Boston University School of
of Medical School Pediatric Department Chairs (AMSPDC). We conducted an anony- Medicine (B.Z.), Boston, MA.
mous web-based survey of members of AMSPDC to determine the prevalence of burnout Submitted for publication Aug 17, 2006;
last revision received Jan 9, 2007; accepted
and how burnout related to the roles and responsibilities of chairs and to chair turnover. Mar 12, 2007.
On the basis of earlier research in this field, we hypothesized that burnout may be Reprint requests: Heather A. McPhillips, De-
associated with high workload, lack of mentorship, time spent in less rewarding tasks partment of Pediatrics, Children’s Hospital
and Regional Medical Center, 4800 Sand
Point Way NE G0061, Seattle, WA 98105.
aWCQ Abbreviated version of the Workplace DP Depersonalization E-mail: heather.mcphillips@seattlechildrens.
Climate Questionnaire EE Emotional exhaustion org.
aAWQ Abbreviated version of the Approaches to MBI-HSS Maslach Burnout Inventory—Human Services 0022-3476/$ - see front matter
Work Questionnaire Survey Copyright © 2007 Mosby Inc. All rights
AMSPDC Association of Medical School Pediatric OR Odds ratio reserved.
Department Chairs PA Personal accomplishment
10.1016/j.jpeds.2007.03.016
425
(administrative workload), and personal work styles.8 Fur- self-reported feelings of being emotionally overextended and
thermore, burnout may lead to turnover in department chairs. exhausted by work. The depersonalization (DP) subscale
Our survey results have identified a number of features of the measures unfeeling and impersonal responses toward people
current work practices of pediatric chairs that are highly the respondent is providing service for including clinical care,
associated with stress and burnout. Understanding these teaching, and mentoring. The personal accomplishment (PA)
stressors might allow for greater focus on training or repri- assesses feelings of competence and achievement in working
oritization in an effort to prolong the satisfaction and tenure with people. The MBI-HSS contains 22 items scored on a
of chairs. Likert-type scale of 0 to 6. Responses are then summed for
each subscale to reach a total score for EE, DP, and PA. Total
METHODS scores in each subscale can then be categorized as low, aver-
We conducted a cross-sectional survey of current and age, or high on the basis of normative data from the MBI-
former pediatric department chairs to determine factors asso- HSS for medicine.9 Maslach defines burnout as scores in the
ciated with job satisfaction and burnout. We obtained names high range in both EE and DP and scores in the low range in
and e-mail addresses of former and current pediatric depart- PA. Earlier studies in physicians have found that burnout may
ment chairs who were members of AMSPDC anytime be- exist in the setting of average to high scores in PA.6,11,12 On
tween 1993 and 2005. An e-mail was sent to all 250 addresses the basis of other studies of physician burnout, we defined
requesting participation in an anonymous web-based survey burnout as scoring in the high range on either the EE subscale
to determine factors associated with high turnover in pediatric or the DP subscale.6,13
department chairs. The link to the survey and instructions to We hypothesized that both workload and work style
access the survey were included in the e-mail. Reminders were would be associated with burnout in physicians. To measure
e-mailed twice to the entire cohort after the initial contact work style, we used the aAWQ, which has been described in
requesting their participation. Participants were assured of the detail elsewhere.10 The questionnaire consists of 13 questions
anonymity of their responses. divided in 3 scales measuring different approaches to work:
deep, surface-rational, and surface-disorganized. The deep
scale assesses intrinsic motivation and inclination to engage in
Survey Instrument meaningful learning. The surface-rational scale assesses pref-
The web-based questionnaire contained 3 sections and erence for memory and detailed, highly-structured work. The
35 major questions, 9 of which asked for multiple responses. surface-disorganized scale contains questions related to being
Former chairs were instructed to answer the questions as they disorganized, impulsive, or using ineffective work habits. To
pertained to their time as chair. The first section asked de- measure workload, we used the 9-item aWCQ. Similar to the
mographic information, including age at appointment as aAWQ, the aWCQ is divided into 3 subscales: workload,
chair, marital status during appointment, sex, and position choice-independence, and supportive-receptive. The work-
before becoming chair. The second section contained ques- load scale assessed perceptions of heavy workload by depart-
tions pertaining to job characteristics and job satisfaction. ment chairs. The choice-independence scale assessed the de-
These questions included multiple choice questions on num- gree to which the chair felt he or she controlled what work to
ber of vice-chairs, association with a free-standing children’s do and how to do it. The supportive-receptive scale as-
hospital, work hours including nights per week worked and sessed whether the chair’s colleagues were supportive and
vacation time, size of department, and time spent on various helpful and whether he or she felt that his/her interests and
administrative, teaching, and clinical duties during a typical ideas were taken seriously. In both questionnaires, respon-
month as chair. Overall satisfaction with aspects of being dents were asked to assess their level of agreement with
chair and stress experienced with aspects of being chair were each statement on a 4-point Likert scale. Responses were
assessed by using a 5-point rating system (not at all satisfied then summed for each of the 3 subscales to give a total
to very satisfied and not at all stressful to very stressful). The score. To test the association with burnout, we divided
final section included 3 validated instruments: the Maslach each of the subscales’ total scores in tertiles for both the
Burnout Inventory—Human Services Survey (MBI-HSS),9 aAWQ and the aWCQ.
an abbreviated version of the Approaches to Work Question-
naire (aAWQ), and an abbreviated version of the Workplace
Statistical Analysis
Climate Questionnaire (aWCQ).10 All these instruments
have been previously validated in surveys of physicians in a All statistical analyses were performed with Stata soft-
variety of specialties. ware version 8. The primary hypothesis tested was that chairs
with ⱕ5 years experience are more likely to experience job
burnout. Assuming a rate of burnout in experienced chairs of
Survey Measures 10%, we had 0.80 power to detect a 2-fold increase in burnout
The primary outcome of interest was physician burnout in less-experienced chairs. Descriptive statistics were used to
on the MBI-HSS. The MBI-HSS contains 3 subscales: emo- characterize the overall sample. We used t tests to compare
tional exhaustion, depersonalization, and personal accom- parametric means and 2 tests to determine associations in
plishment. The emotional exhaustion (EE) subscale measures categorical variables. The Fisher exact test was used to com-
being chair, and 30% stated that they were somewhat satisfied
with being chair overall. More than 60% of chairs responded
total of 137 respondents completed all questions on the MBI-
that they were very satisfied with their roles teaching, men-
HSS. Of those respondents, 17% scored high on the EE
toring students, and mentoring faculty. The highest degrees
subscale, 13% scored high on the DP subscale, and 32%
of dissatisfaction were reported in the categories of fundrais-
scored low on the PA subscale. Fifteen of 137 respondents
ing (33% minimally satisfied), academic writing (31% mini-
(11%) scored high on both EE and DP, and all 15 of those
mally satisfied), and balancing work and family (20% mini-
respondents scored average (N ⫽ 11) or low (N ⫽ 4) on PA.
mally satisfied).
Overall, 27 respondents (20%) met criteria for burnout—15
Chairs responded that they spend most of their time in
respondents scored high on both EE and DP, 9 scored high
a typical month on administration, with 61% of respondents
on EE alone, and 3 scored high on DP alone.
stating they spend ⬎40% of their time in this area. Most
Several factors were significantly associated with burn-
chairs reported spending ⬍10% of time in a typical month on
out in our analysis (Table II). Respondents who had been
roles in which they reported the highest degree of satisfaction:
chair for ⬍5 years had a significantly higher percentage of
mentoring students (93%), mentoring faculty (82%), and
burnout compared with respondents who had been chair for
teaching (59%).
⬎5 years (29% versus 15%, P ⬍ .05). When compared with
chairs in their positions for ⬎5 years, less experienced chairs
Factors Associated with Burnout were more likely to report working longer hours overall— 80%
Overall, both former and current pediatric department worked ⬎70 hours compared with 56% of more experienced
chairs experienced low levels of burnout in their role as chair. chairs (P ⬍ .05). Work hours were significantly associated
There was no significant difference between former and cur- with burnout. Chairs who reported longer hours in the office,
rent department chairs in percent burnout or factors associ- more hours worked away from home or office, ⬎1 evening per
ated with burnout. There was also no difference observed in week spent at work-related events, and less vacation per year
percent burnout between men and women chairs (20% men were more likely to experience burnout than chairs who
compared with 21% women were experiencing burnout). A reported working fewer hours in these categories and taking
Role of a Pediatric Department Chair: Factors Leading to Satisfaction and Burnout 427
Table II. Work hours and burnout in pediatric department chairs
Years chair Work hours
Hours
worked away Number of Number of weeks
Hours worked in from office/ evenings at Weeks of attending on
Number of office per typical home per work events vacation per inpatient service
years chair* week* week* per week† year* per year*
N (%) <5 >5 <50 51-60 >60 <10 >10 0 to 1 2ⴙ <2 3ⴙ 0 1 to 8 9ⴙ
No or minimal 110 (80) 34 (71) 75 (85) 53 (88) 44 (79) 11 (58) 67 (84) 30 (68) 42 (93) 67 (74) 51 (75) 59 (86) 25 (68) 63 (88) 22 (79)
burnout
High burnout 27 (20) 14 (29) 13 (15) 7 (12) 12 (21) 8 (42) 13 (16) 14 (32) 3 (7) 23 (26) 17 (25) 10 (14) 12 (32) 9 (13) 6 (21)
*Chi-square test, P ⬍ .05.
†Fisher exact test, P ⬍ .05.
more vacation. Chairs who reported they did not attend on an 10-point scale, were more likely to be experiencing burnout
inpatient service (specialty or general) were more likely to (Table IV).
experience burnout than chairs who spent 1 to 8 weeks on the In logistic regression, factors that were independently
inpatient attending service (32% versus 13% met criteria for significantly associated with burnout included number of
burnout, P ⬍ .05). years as chair, number of nights worked per week, and work-
The workload, choice-independence, and supportive- load and lack of supportive-receptive work environment mea-
receptive subscales of the aWCQ were all highly correlated sured on the aWCQ. A high score on the workload subscale
with both the EE and DP subscales on the MBI-HSS (P ⬍ of the aWCQ was associated with a nearly 3-fold increase in
.01). Respondents who reported higher workload levels, less burnout (Odds ratio [OR] 3.0; 95% CI, 1.3-6.7). Likewise, a
supportive work environments, and less choice-independence low score on the supportive-receptive subscale of the aWCQ
on the aWCQ were also significantly more likely to be expe- was associated with a 2-fold increased risk of burnout (OR,
riencing burnout (Table III). Both surface-rational and sur- 2.2; 95% CI, 1.1-4.2). The greater the number of years the
face-disorganized subscales of the aAWQ questionnaire cor- respondent had served as chair, the less likely they were to be
related with EE on the MBI-HSS (Pearson’s correlation experiencing burnout (OR, 0.9; 95% CI, 0.8-0.99). Finally,
coefficient, P ⬍ .01); however none of the 3 subscales on the working ⱖ2 nights per week in a typical week was associated
aAWQ were significantly associated with burnout. with a nearly 6-fold increased risk of burnout (OR, 5.9; 95%
Chairs who met the criteria for burnout were signifi- CI, 1.5-22.9).
cantly less likely to report being satisfied with their role as
chair overall, were less satisfied with their balance between DISCUSSION
personal and professional life, and were more likely to report Although we observed a high rate of job satisfaction by
they would likely step down in the next year (Table IV). No pediatric department chairs in this study, 1 in 5 chairs met our
chairs who met the criteria for burnout (0 of 27) reported criteria for burnout. Symptoms of burnout can include emo-
being very satisfied with their balance between professional tional exhaustion, a sense of depersonalization with col-
and personal life, compared with 35 of 110 chairs without leagues, patients, or both, cynicism, and a feeling of lack of
burnout (32%, P ⬍ .001). Chairs who were experiencing personal accomplishment.3,5 Physician burnout has been
burnout were also more likely to report sleep problems and shown to affect patient care, job performance, personal health,
less likely to report having close friends outside work. Finally, and family life negatively. Unlike clinical depression, burnout
chairs who found faculty recruiting, meeting the expectations is a work-related syndrome often observed in occupations that
of the dean, meeting expectations of hospital administration, require a high level of interpersonal interactions and personal
and balancing family commitments with work commitments investment. Earlier studies have shown that work environ-
to be very stressful, rating their level of stress 8 to 10 on a ment, particularly lack of control over one’s own work, high
Role of a Pediatric Department Chair: Factors Leading to Satisfaction and Burnout 429
Implications 2. Stapleton FB, Jones D, Fiser DH. Leadership trends in academic pediatric
departments. Pediatrics 2005;116:342-4.
Similar to other studies of career satisfaction and burn- 3. Maslach C, Schaufeli WB, Leiter MP. Job burnout. Annu Rev Psychol
out in pediatricians,14 pediatric chairs tend to have an overall 2001;52:397-422.
4. Gundersen L. Physician burnout. Ann Intern Med 2001;135:145-8.
high degree of career satisfaction and relatively low levels of
5. Spickard A Jr, Gabbe SG, Christensen JF. Mid-career burnout in generalist and
burnout. Steps need to be taken, however, to decrease burnout specialist physicians. JAMA 2002;288:1447-50.
in new chairs. Possible interventions include more mentorship 6. Shanafelt TD, Bradley KA, Wipf JE, Back AL. Burnout and self-reported patient
from experienced chairs, training on managing expectations care in an internal medicine residency program. Ann Intern Med 2002;136:358-67.
7. Kushnir T, Cohen AH. Job structure and burnout among primary care pediatri-
from deans and hospital administration, workshops on strat- cians. Work 2006;27:67-74.
egies for successful recruiting, workshops on strategies for 8. Shiron A. Job-related burnout: a review. In: Quick JC, Tetrick LE, editors.
maintaining work/life balance, and role-modeling. Perhaps Handbook of occupational health psychology. Washington, DC: American Psycholog-
ical Association; 2003. p. 245-64.
most important, department mission statements should ex- 9. Maslach C, Jackson S, Leiter M. Maslach burnout inventory manual. 3rd ed.
plicitly state that physician well-being is a key component to Mountain View, CA: CPP; 1996.
the success of the department. Institutions should provide 10. McManus IC, Keeling A, Paice E. Stress, burnout and doctors’ attitudes to work
are determined by personality and learning style: a twelve-year longitudinal study of UK
resources to promote physician well-being to increase job- medical graduates. BMC Med 2004;2:29.
satisfaction and decrease burnout among all members of ac- 11. Johns MM III, Ossoff RH. Burnout in academic chairs of otolaryngology: head
ademic departments. Toward this end, AMSPDC scheduled and neck surgery. Laryngoscope 2005;115:2056-61.
12. Gabbe SG, Melville J, Mandel L, Walker E. Burnout in chairs of obstetrics and
a half-day workshop at its annual meeting in 2007 to foster gynecology: diagnosis, treatment, and prevention. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2002;
mentoring between pediatric department chairs and to begin 186:601-12.
to address burnout in academic pediatric departments. 13. Goitein L, Shanafelt TD, Wipf JE, Slatore CG, Back AL. The effects of
work-hour limitations on resident well-being, patient care, and education in an internal
medicine residency program. Arch Intern Med 2005;165:2601-6.
REFERENCES 14. Shugerman R, Linzer M, Nelson K, Douglas J, Williams R, Konrad R. Pediatric
1. Brent RL. The changing role and responsibilities of chairmen in clinical academic generalists and subspecialists: determinants of career satisfaction. Pediatrics 2001;
departments: the transition from autocracy. Pediatrics 1992;90:50-7. 108:E40.