Professional Documents
Culture Documents
comprising agents running around the Web performing complex actions for
their users. The speaker argued that we are far from the day this vision would become
Digital signature
multiagent systems to the languages of the Semantic Web can lead directly
to more powerful agent-based approaches—that Logic
Data
Web require ontologies. is, to the realization of my colleague’s “science fic-
tion” vision. Self- Ontology vocabuary
The integration of describing
document Resource Description
What is an ontology, really? Framework + RDF Schema
agent technology and There are a number of terms we sometimes abuse
in the AI community. These terms become even XML + Name space + XML Schema
ontologies could more confusing when we interact with other com-
munities, such as Web toolkit developers, who also Universal resource
Unicode
significantly affect the abuse them. One such term is ontology, which the indicator
Oxford English Dictionary defines as “the science
use of Web services and or study of being.” In AI, we usually attribute the
notion of ontology to, essentially, the specification Figure 1. The Semantic Web “layer cake”
presented by Tim Berners-Lee at the XML 2000
the ability to extend of a conceptualization—that is, defined terms and
conference.
relationships between them, usually in some formal
programs to perform and preferably machine-readable manner.1 Even
more complicated is the relationship between
tasks for users more ontologies and logics. Some people treat ontology ular topic. For example, the ontology of cooking and
as a subset of logic, some treat logic as a subset of cookbooks includes ingredients, how to stir and
efficiently and with less ontological reasoning, and others consider the terms combine the ingredients, the difference between
disjoint. simmering and deep-frying, the expectation that the
human intervention. In this article, I employ the term as it is currently products will be eaten or drunk, that oil is for cook-
being used in Semantic Web circles. I define ontol- ing or consuming and not for lubrication, and so
ogy as a set of knowledge terms, including the forth.
vocabulary, the semantic interconnections, and some In practice, it is useful to consider more complex
simple rules of inference and logic for some partic- logics and inference systems to be separate from an
Display-Service
Class:Service Type: Geographic
Format: Photo
Return: Display
Subclass Value: Weather
Service-Logic
TransferOccurs(#cost,Service) := External resource
Reached(ServState11),ServiceCost(#cost)
Figure 3. A potential service class and its properties on the Semantic Web.
many participants in the CoABS, DAML, and Cambridge, Mass., 2000, pp. 443–449.
TASK DARPA initiatives who offered comments
on earlier drafts. Finally, I am indebted to an 6. A.W. Appel and E.W. Felten, “Proof-
Carrying Authentication,” Proc. 6th ACM Conf.
T h e A u t h o r
anonymous reviewer who, shall we say, wasn’t
impressed by an earlier version of this article and Computer and Communications Security,ACM
Press, New York, 1999; www.cs.princeton. James Hendler is the
demanded copious changes. I made many of these Chief Scientist of
changes, which improved the article greatly. edu/~appel/papers/fpcc.pdf.
DARPA’s Information
7. D. Fensel et al., “The Component Model of Systems Office and
References UPML in a Nutshell,” Proc. 1st Working IFIP the program manager
Conf. Software Architecture (WICSA 1), responsible for agent-
1. T.R. Gruber, “A Translation Approach to Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1999, ftp.aifb. based computing. He
Portable Ontologies,” Knowledge Acquisition, uni-karlsruhe.de/pub/mike/dfe/paper/ is on leave from the
vol. 5, no. 2, 1993, pp. 199–220. upml.ifip.pdf. University of Mary-
land where he is a professor and head of both
2. P. Clark and B. Porter, “Building Concept 8. D. Fensel et al., “OIL in a Nutshell,” Proc. the Autonomous Mobile Robots Laboratory and
Representations from Reusable Compo- 12th European Workshop Knowledge Acqui- the Advanced Information Technology Labora-
nents,” Proc. 14th Nat’l Conf. Artificial Intel- sition, Modeling, and Management (EKAW- tory. He has joint appointments in the Depart-
ligence (AAAI-97), MIT Press, Cambridge, 00), Springer-Verlag, New York, 2000; www. ment of Computer Science, the Institute for
Mass., 1997, pp. 369–376. few.vu.nl/~frankh/postscript/EKAW00.pdf. Advanced Computer Studies, the Institute for
3. J. Hendler, “Is There an Intelligent Agent in 9. M. Genesereth et al., Knowledge Interchange Systems Research, and is also an affiliate of the
Your Future?” Nature, 11 Mar. 1999, www. Format Version 3.0 Reference Manual, http:// Electrical Engineering Department. He received
nature.com/nature/webmatters/agents/agents. logic.stanford.edu/kif/Hypertext/kif-manual. a PhD in artificial intelligence from Brown Uni-
html (current 19 Mar. 2001). html. versity. Hendler received a 1995 Fulbright Foun-
dation Fellowship, is a Fellow of the American
4. S. Junger, The Perfect Storm: A True Story of 10. V.S. Subrahmanian et al., Heterogeneous Agent Association for Artificial Intelligence, and is a
Men against the Sea, W.W. Norton and Co., Systems, MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., 2000. member of the US Air Force Science Advisory
London, 1997. Board. Contact him at jhendler@darpa.mil;
11. D. Lenat and R. Guha, Building Large Knowl- www.cs.umd.edu/~hendler.
5. J. Heflin and J. Hendler, “Dynamic Ontolo- edge-Based Systems: Representation and Infer-
gies on the Web,” Proc. 17th Nat’l Conf. Arti- ence in the CYC Project, Addison-Wesley,
ficial Intelligence (AAAI 2000), MIT Press, Reading, Mass., 1990.