Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
32Activity
P. 1
Overdiagnosed by Dr. H. Gilbert Welch, Dr. Lisa Schwartz, and Dr. Steven Woloshin, Excerpt

Overdiagnosed by Dr. H. Gilbert Welch, Dr. Lisa Schwartz, and Dr. Steven Woloshin, Excerpt

Ratings: (0)|Views: 12,248|Likes:
Published by Beacon Press
Read an excerpt from Overdiagnosed (http://www.beacon.org/productdetails.cfm?SKU=2200).

Diagnoses of every condition, from high cholesterol and high blood pressure to osteoporosis, diabetes, and even cancer, have skyrocketed over the last few decades. Yet Americans are living longer than ever. While the medical establishment credits aggressive early disease detection as the cause of improved public heath, it is in fact the reason so many of us are told we are sick. Going against the conventional wisdom that more screening is the best preventive medicine, Dr. H. Gilbert Welch builds a compelling counterargument that what we need is fewer, not more, scans and tests.

Drawing on twenty-five years of medical practice and research on the effects of screening, Welch explains how the cutoffs for "abnormal" test results have been drastically lowered while at the same time technological advances have enabled doctors to detect more and more "abnormalities," many of which will pose no health complications. Now, with genetic and prenatal screening common practice, patients are increasingly being diagnosed not only with disease but with "pre-disease."

Examining the social, medical, and economic ramifications of a health care system that unnecessarily diagnoses and treats patients, Welch makes a reasoned call for change that would save us from countless unneeded surgeries, debilitating anxiety, and exorbitant costs.
Read an excerpt from Overdiagnosed (http://www.beacon.org/productdetails.cfm?SKU=2200).

Diagnoses of every condition, from high cholesterol and high blood pressure to osteoporosis, diabetes, and even cancer, have skyrocketed over the last few decades. Yet Americans are living longer than ever. While the medical establishment credits aggressive early disease detection as the cause of improved public heath, it is in fact the reason so many of us are told we are sick. Going against the conventional wisdom that more screening is the best preventive medicine, Dr. H. Gilbert Welch builds a compelling counterargument that what we need is fewer, not more, scans and tests.

Drawing on twenty-five years of medical practice and research on the effects of screening, Welch explains how the cutoffs for "abnormal" test results have been drastically lowered while at the same time technological advances have enabled doctors to detect more and more "abnormalities," many of which will pose no health complications. Now, with genetic and prenatal screening common practice, patients are increasingly being diagnosed not only with disease but with "pre-disease."

Examining the social, medical, and economic ramifications of a health care system that unnecessarily diagnoses and treats patients, Welch makes a reasoned call for change that would save us from countless unneeded surgeries, debilitating anxiety, and exorbitant costs.

More info:

Published by: Beacon Press on Jan 18, 2011
Copyright:Traditional Copyright: All rights reserved

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

09/29/2013

 
 
ny
NKWQCGROWNCK
Crq Bkwirsndsf hcq Gndmkcsns
     „82 Hcqg Hdnqjdkb }dmck+ Nw }ds d hdnqj~ snfujb‗djabnwjdqmb‗xbinojb+ N ocrjg bxbk gc scfb ch wib }cq` ck nw f~sbjh+ Wbqb }ds d jcwch qccf rkgbq wib iccg dkg hb} bjbowqcknos+ Wb ckj~ bkmnkb sbkscqs }bqb dwbfubqdwrqb mdrmb dkg dk cnj&uqbssrqb mdrmb+Wnkms dqb xbq~ gnbqbkw }nwi f~ „>> Xcjxc+ Wbqbs kc bywqd qccf rkgbqwib iccg‗dkg wibqb dqb jcws ch bjbowqcknos+ Dkg wibk wibqb dqb djj wicsb jnw&wjb }dqknkm jnmiws sbksnkm sc fdk~ gnbqbkw dsubows ch f~ odq„s hrkownck widwwib~ idxb wc ab ockkbowbg wc dk nkwbqkdj ocfurwbq wc gbwbqfnkb }idw„s }qckm+Odqs idxb rkgcrawbgj~ nfuqcxbg cxbq f~ jnhbwnfb+ Wb~ dqb sdhbq* fcqbocfhcqwdajb* dkg fcqb qbjndajb+ Wb bkmnkbbqnkm ns abwwbq+ Arw N„f kcw srqbwibsb nfuqcxbfbkws idxb froi wc gc }nwi djj wicsb jnwwjb }dqknkm jnmiws+Oibo`&bkmnkb jnmiws‗qbg dms widw nkgnodwb scfbwinkm fd~ ab }qckm}nwi wib xbinojb‗dqb mbwwnkm uqbww~ scuinswnodwbg+ Wbsb sbkscqs odk ngbk&wnh~ dakcqfdjnwnbs jckm abhcqb wib xbinojb„s ubqhcqfdkob ns dbowbg+ Wb~ dqbfd`nkm bdqj~ gndmkcsbs+Fd~ab ~crq oibo`&bkmnkb jnmiws idxb abbk xbq~ rsbhrj+ Fd~ab ckb ch wibf jbg ~cr wc gc scfbwinkm nfucqwdkw )jn`b dgg cnj. widw uqbxbkwbg d froianmmbq uqcajbf jdwbq ck+Cq fd~ab ~cr idxb idg wib cuucsnwb byubqnbkob+Oibo`&bkmnkb jnmiws odk djsc oqbdwb uqcajbfs+ _cfbwnfbs wib~ dqb hdjsbdjdqfs )}ibkbxbq N gqnxb cxbq d anm arfu* ckb mcbs c }dqknkm fb widwscfbwinkm„s }qckm }nwi f~ occjdkw s~swbf.+ Cbk wib jnmiws dqb nk qbsucksbwc d qbdj dakcqfdjnw~* arw kcw ckb widw ns bsubondjj~ nfucqwdkw )f~ hdxcqnwb nswib sbkscq widw jnmiws ru }ibk nw qbocmkn|bs widw dkcwibq sbkscq ns kcw sbks&nkm.+ Qbobkwj~* f~ fboidkno ockgbg wc fb widw fdk~ ch wib jnmiws sicrjguqcadaj~ ab nmkcqbg+Fd~ab ~cr idxb gbongbg wc nmkcqb wibsb sbkscqs ~crqsbjh+ Cq fd~ab~cr„xb wd`bk ~crq odq nk hcq sbqxnob dkg wib fboidkno ids snfuj~ qbsbw wibfdkg wcjg ~cr wc }dnw dkg sbb nh wib~ ocfb ck dmdnk+Cq fd~ab ~cr idxb idg wib rkhcqwrkdwb byubqnbkob ch ud~nkm hcq dkrkkbobssdq~ qbudnq* cq d sbqnbs ch rkkbobssdq~ qbudnqs+ Dkg fd~ab ~cr idxbabbk ckb ch wib rkhcqwrkdwb hb} }icsb odqs }bqb }cqsb c hcq wib bcqws+
 
y
 

Nh sc* ~cr djqbdg~ idxb scfb hbbj hcq wib uqcajbf ch cxbqgndmkcsns+N gck„w `kc} }idw wib kbw bbow ch djj wibsb jnmiws ids abbk+ Fd~ab wib~ idxb gckb fcqb mccg widk idqf+ Fd~ab wib~ idxb gckb fcqb idqf widkmccg+ Arw N gc `kc} wibqb„s jnwwjb gcraw dacrw wibnq bbow ck wib drwcfcwnxbqbudnq arsnkbss< wib~ idxb jbg wc d jcw ch bywqd xnsnws wc wib sicu+Dkg N `kc} widw nh }b gcowcqs jcc` dw ~cr idqg bkcrmi* oidkobs dqb }b„jjkg crw widw ckb ch ~crq oibo`&bkmnkb jnmiws ns ck+
 D qcrwnkb oibo`ru
N uqcadaj~ idxb d hb} oibo`&bkmnkb jnmiws ck f~sbjh+ N„f d fdjb nk f~ fng&nbs+ N idxb kcw sbbk d gcowcq hcq d qcrwnkb oibo`ru snkob N }ds d oinjg+ N„fkcw aqdmmnkm* dkg N„f kcw srmmbswnkm widw wins ns d udwi cwibqs sicrjg hcjjc}+Arw abodrsb N idxb abbk ajbssbg }nwi byobjjbkw ibdjwi* nw„s `nkg ch idqg wcdqmrb widw N idxb fnssbg crw ck scfb nkgnsubksdajb sbqxnob+Ch ocrqsb* ds d gcowcq* N sbb gcowcqs bxbq~ gd~+ Fdk~ ch wibf dqb f~ hqnbkgs )cq dw jbdsw wib~ }bqb abhcqb wib~ jbdqkbg dacrw wins acc`.+ Dkg N odknfdmnkb scfb ch wib gndmkcsbs N ocrjg doorfrjdwb nh N }bqb d udwnbkw nk dk~ ch wibnq ojnknos )cq nk f~ c}k* hcq widw fdwwbq.<Hqcf wnfb wc wnfb f~ ajccg uqbssrqb qrks d jnwwjb inmi+ Wns ns udqwnor&jdqj~ wqrb }ibk N fbdsrqb nw dw }cq` )}ibqb ajccg uqbssrqb fdoinkbs dqbqbdgnj~ dxdnjdajb.+
Gndmkcsns< acqgbqjnkb i~ubqwbksnck
N„f sny hccw hcrq dkg }bnmi  ucrkgs0 f~ acg~ fdss nkgby )AFN. ns 12+)D ‚kcqfdj‖ AFN qdkmbs hqcf 15 wc 17+>+.
Gndmkcsns< cxbq}bnmiw
Coodsnckdjj~* N„jj mbw dk nkwbksb arqknkm sbksdwnck nk f~ fngoibsw dbqbdwnkm cq gqnk`nkm+ )Duujb lrnob dkg duujb ongbq dqb udqwnorjdqj~ uqca&jbfdwno hcq fb+.
Gndmkcsns< mdswqcbscuidmbdj qbhry gnsbdsb
N cbk }d`b ru ckob d knmiw dkg kbbg wc mc wc wib adwiqccf+
Gndmkcsns< abknmk uqcswdwno i~ubqujdsnd
N }d`b ru nk wib fcqknkm }nwi swn lcnkws dkg nw wd`bs fb d }injb wc jccsbkru+
Gndmkcsns< gbmbkbqdwnxb lcnkw gnsbdsb
F~ idkgs mbw ocjg+ Qbdjj~ ocjg+ Nw„s d anm uqcajbf }ibk N„f s`nnkm cqskc}sicbnkm* arw nw djsc iduubks nk wib cob )lrsw ds` f~ udwnbkws.+ Och&hbb fd`bs nw }cqsb0 djocicj fd`bs nw abwwbq+
Gndmkcsns< Qd~kdrg„s gnsbdsb

Activity (32)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads
Kyaw Zaya liked this
mail_krk liked this
abkhelif liked this
thomas_austin_1 liked this
Beacon Press liked this
akaditabo liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->