!"#$ & '( )*
!" $%& '"!$&( )$*$&) (!)$+!,$ ,-'+$.-+ $%& "-+$%&+" (!)$+!,$ -. ./-+!(*0&")*,-/* (!1!)!-"
+,-,. /0 01/234-5 67 "89 :;<'=#;-::'<8$7 >$8$<"? !"@ A'89B5 $: "?CD!?"B8:B((E5FC G"E$ H'CI JI&KLMFLN&L2OP.Q,RH3,.4 +,-,.+ 4.!-2,Q.H, /0S.-1,S -H4 SRQ-H +.2O3G.+5 $: "?C54$($89"8:ECTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTP
-+(&+ 2+*"$!"2 )'33*+4 5'(23&"$
/8 Q"<M; UJ5 UK&K5 !<$EB9$8: /6"@" EB#8$9 ;$"?:; M"<$ <$('<@ ?$#BE?":B'8IV,;$ !":B$8: !<':$M:B'8 "89 -(('<9"6?$ G"<$ -M:CW !=6C 1C H'C &&&L&X*5 &UX +:":C&&N YUK&KZ5 "E "@$89$9 67 :;$ S$"?:; G"<$ "89 .9=M":B'8 2$M'8MB?B":B'8 -M: '(UK&K5 !=6C 1C H'C &&&L&[U5 &UX +:":C &KUN YUK&KZ Y:;$ V-M:WZC,;BE M"E$5 M;"??$8#B8# :;$ G'8E:B:=:B'8"?B:7 '( :;$ -M:5 \"E (B?$9 @B8=:$E"(:$< :;$ !<$EB9$8: EB#8$9C 3: ;"E 6$$8 6<'=#;: 67 :;$ -::'<8$7E >$8$<"? "89P'<>'F$<8'<E '( :\$8:7LEB] E:":$E Y:;$ VE:":$ ^?"B8:B((EWZ
&
D :\' ^<BF":$ MB:B_$8E Y:;$VB89BFB9="? ^?"B8:B((EWZD "89 :;$ H":B'8"? 0$9$<":B'8 '( 389$^$89$8: A=EB8$EEYVH03AWZ YM'??$M:BF$?75 :;$ V^?"B8:B((EWZC ,;$ 9$($89"8:E "<$ :;$ R8B:$9 +:":$E4$^"<:@$8: '( S$"?:; "89 S=@"8 +$<FBM$E5 :;$ 4$^"<:@$8: '( ,<$"E=<75 :;$4$^"<:@$8: '( 1"6'<5 "89 :;$B< E$M<$:"<B$E YM'??$M:BF$?75 :;$ V9$($89"8:EWZC 3$@^;"EB_$9 '8M$ 6$('<$5 6=: B: 6$"<E <$^$":B8# "#"B8I :;BE M"E$ BE 8': "6'=:
&
,;$ E:":$E "<$ -?"6"@"5 -?"E`"5 -<B_'8"5 G'?'<"9'5 0?'<B9"5 >$'<#B"5 39";'5389B"8"5 3'\"5 a"8E"E5 1'=BEB"8"5 Q"B8$5 QBM;B#"85 QBEEBEEB^^B5 H$6<"E`"5 H$F"9"5H'<:; 4"`':"5 /;B'5 !$88E7?F"8B"5 +'=:; G"<'?B8"5 +'=:; 4"`':"5 ,$]"E5 R:";5b"E;B8#:'85 bBEM'8EB85 "89 b7'@B8#C
Case 3:10-cv-00091-RV -EMT Document 150 Filed 01/31/11 Page 1 of 78
!"#$ U '( )*
\;$:;$< :;$ -M: BE \BE$ '< =8\BE$ ?$#BE?":B'85 '< \;$:;$< B: \B?? E'?F$ '< $]"M$<6":$:;$ @7<B"9 ^<'6?$@E B8 '=< ;$"?:; M"<$ E7E:$@C 38 ("M:5 B: BE 8': <$"??7 "6'=: '=<;$"?:; M"<$ E7E:$@ ": "??C 3: BE ^<B8MB^"??7 "6'=: '=< ($9$<"?BE: E7E:$@5 "89 B: <"BE$EF$<7 B@^'<:"8: BEE=$E <$#"<9B8# :;$ G'8E:B:=:B'8"? <'?$ '( :;$ ($9$<"? #'F$<8@$8:Cc"@$E Q"9BE'85 :;$ M;B$( "<M;B:$M: '( '=< ($9$<"?BE: E7E:$@5 '8M$ ("@'=E?7'6E$<F$9I3( @$8 \$<$ "8#$?E5 8' #'F$<8@$8: \'=?9 6$ 8$M$EE"<7C3( "8#$?E \$<$ :' #'F$<8 @$85 8$B:;$< $]:$<8"? 8'< B8:$<8"?M'8:<'?E '8 #'F$<8@$8: \'=?9 6$ 8$M$EE"<7C 38 (<"@B8# "#'F$<8@$8: \;BM; BE :' 6$ "9@B8BE:$<$9 67 @$8 'F$<@$85 :;$ #<$": 9B((BM=?:7 ?B$E B8 :;BEI 7'= @=E: (B<E: $8"6?$:;$ #'F$<8@$8: :' M'8:<'? :;$ #'F$<8$9D "89 B8 :;$ 8$]:^?"M$ '6?B#$ B: :' M'8:<'? B:E$?(C,;$ 0$9$<"?BE: H'C [&5 ": JX* YHCdC S$<B:"#$ !<$EE $9C5 &NX[Z YV,;$ 0$9$<"?BE:WZC
U
38 $E:"6?BE;B8# '=< #'F$<8@$8:5 :;$ 0'=89$<E $89$"F'<$9 :' <$E'?F$ Q"9BE'8eEB9$8:B(B$9 V#<$": 9B((BM=?:7W 67 M<$":B8# " E7E:$@ '( 9="? E'F$<$B#8:7 =89$< \;BM;Vf:g;$ ^'\$<E 9$?$#":$9 67 :;$ ^<'^'E$9 G'8E:B:=:B'8 :' :;$ ($9$<"? #'F$<8@$8:"<$ ($\ "89 9$(B8$9C ,;'E$ \;BM; "<$ :' <$@"B8 B8 :;$ +:":$ #'F$<8@$8:E "<$8=@$<'=E "89 B89$(B8B:$CW ,;$ 0$9$<"?BE: H'C X[5 ": J&& YQ"9BE'8ZD E$$ "?E' RC+CG'8E:C "<:C 35 h & YE$::B8# ('<:; :;$ E^$MB(BM ?$#BE?":BF$ ^'\$<E V;$<$B8 #<"8:$9W :'G'8#<$EEZC b;$8 :;$ AB?? '( 2B#;:E \"E ?":$< "99$9 :' :;$ G'8E:B:=:B'8 B8 &)N&5 :;$,$8:; -@$89@$8: <$"((B<@$9 :;": <$?":B'8E;B^I V,;$ ^'\$<E 8': 9$?$#":$9 :' :;$R8B:$9 +:":$E 67 :;$ G'8E:B:=:B'85 8'< ^<';B6B:$9 67 B: :' :;$ +:":$E5 "<$ <$E$<F$9 :'
U
,;$ 0$9$<"?BE: M'8EBE:E '( *[ "<:BM?$E '< $EE"7E \<B::$8 67 c"@$E Q"9BE'85-?$]"89$< S"@B?:'85 "89 c';8 c"75 "9F'M":B8# ('< <":B(BM":B'8 '( :;$ G'8E:B:=:B'8CV,;$ '^B8B'8 '( :;$ 0$9$<"?BE: ;"E "?\"7E 6$$8 M'8EB9$<$9 "E '( #<$": "=:;'<B:7C 3:BE " M'@^?$:$ M'@@$8:"<7 '8 '=< M'8E:B:=:B'8D "89 BE "^^$"?$9 :' 67 "?? ^"<:B$E B8:;$ i=$E:B'8E :' \;BM; :;": B8E:<=@$8: ;"E #BF$8 6B<:;C 3:E B8:<B8EBM @$<B: $8:B:?$E B::' :;BE ;B#; <"8`CW G';$8E FC OB<#B8B"5 &N RC+C Yj b;$":Z UjX5 X&*5 [ 1C .9C U[)Y&*U&Z YQ"<E;"??5 GCcCZC 3: \B?? 6$ MB:$9 :'5 "89 <$?B$9 '85 E$F$<"? :B@$E :;<'=#;'=::;$ M'=<E$ '( :;BE '^B8B'8C
!"#$ &'() *)+,-./-0+-123456
Case 3:10-cv-00091-RV -EMT Document 150 Filed 01/31/11 Page 2 of 78
!"#$ J '( )*
:;$ +:":$E <$E^$M:BF$?75 '< :' :;$ ^$'^?$CW,;$ 0<"@$<E 6$?B$F$9 :;": ?B@B:B8# ($9$<"? ^'\$<5 "89 "??'\B8# :;$ V<$EB9="?W^'\$< :' <$@"B8 B8 :;$ ;"89E '( :;$ E:":$E Y"89 '( :;$ ^$'^?$Z5 \'=?9 ;$?^ V$8E=<$^<':$M:B'8 '( '=< (=89"@$8:"? ?B6$<:B$EW "89 V<$9=M$ :;$ <BE` '( :7<"887 "89 "6=E$CW+$$ ><$#'<7 FC -E;M<'(:5 [K& RC+C X[U5 X[*5 &&& +C G:C UJN[5 &&[ 1C .9C U9 X&KY&NN&Z YMB:":B'8 '@B::$9ZC O$<7 $"<?75 :;$ #<$": G;B$( c=E:BM$ c';8 Q"<E;"?? 8':$9V:;": :;'E$ ?B@B:E @"7 8': 6$ @BE:"`$85 '< ('<#'::$85 :;$ M'8E:B:=:B'8 BE \<B::$8CWQ"<6=<7 FC Q"9BE'85 [ RC+C Y& G<"8M;Z &J)5 &)j5 U 1C .9C jK Y&*KJZC /F$< :\'M$8:=<B$E ?":$<5 :;BE 9$?BM":$ 6"?"8MB8# "M: M'8:B8=$EC 2":;$< :;"8 6$B8# :;$ @$<$;BE:'<BM <$?BM '( " 67#'8$ $<"5 :;$ ^<B8MB^?$ 6$;B89 " M$8:<"? #'F$<8@$8: \B:; ?B@B:$9^'\$< ;"E V8$F$< 6$$8 @'<$ <$?$F"8: :;"8 B8 :;BE 9"75 \;$8 "MM<$:B'85 B( 8': "M:="?"MM$EEB'85 '( ^'\$< :' :;$ ($9$<"? #'F$<8@$8: E$$@E 8': '8?7 =8"F'B9"6?$5 6=:$F$8 $]^$9B$8:CW A<_'8`"?" FC OB<#B8B" !'?7:$M;8BM 38E:B:=:$5 &jN 0CJ9 *UK5 *Uj YX
:;
GB<C &NNNZ Y$8 6"8MZ5 "((e9 E=6 8'@5 R8B:$9 +:":$E FC Q'<<BE'85 [UN RC+C [N*5 &UK+C G:C &)XK5 &Xj 1C .9C U9 j[* YUKKKZC
J
,' E"7 :;": :;$ ($9$<"? #'F$<8@$8: ;"E ?B@B:$9 "89 $8=@$<":$9 ^'\$< 9'$E8': #$: '8$ ("<5 ;'\$F$<5 ('< :;": E:":$@$8: BE " ?'8#L<$M'#8B_$9 "89 \$??LE$::?$9
J
38 R8B:$9 +:":$E FC 1'^$_5 [&X RC+C [XN5 &&[ +C G:C &jUX5 &J& 1C .9C U9jUj Y&NN[Z5 " \":$<E;$9 9$MBEB'8 :;": \B?? 6$ 9BEM=EE$9 B8(<"5 :;$ +=^<$@$ G'=<:6$#"8 B:E "8"?7EBE 67 <$($<<B8# :' :;$E$ ?B@B:E '8 ($9$<"? ^'\$< "E V(B<E: ^<B8MB^?$ECW38 " @"88$< '( E^$"`B8#5 :;$7 @"7 6$ E"B9 :' 6$ V?"E: ^<B8MB^?$EW "E \$??5 ('< :;$1'^$_ G'=<: 9$$@$9 :;$@ :' 6$ E' B@^'<:"8: :;": B: "?E' $89$9 B:E '^B8B'8 \B:; "(=?? 9BEM=EEB'8 '( :;$@C +$$ B9C ": [j)Lj*C +;'<:?7 :;$<$"(:$<5 B8 R8B:$9 +:":$E FCQ'<<BE'85 [UN RC+C [N*5 &UK +C G:C &)XK5 &Xj 1C .9C U9 j[* YUKKKZ5 \;BM; \B??"?E' 6$ 9BEM=EE$9 B8(<"5 :;$ +=^<$@$ G'=<: <$($<<$9 :' :;$ 9BFBEB'8 '( "=:;'<B:7 "89?B@B:E '8 ($9$<"? ^'\$< "E :;$ VM$8:<"? ^<B8MB^?$ '( '=< M'8E:B:=:B'8"? E7E:$@CW +$$B9C ": j&j 8C)C G?$"<?75 B( :;$ @'9$<8 +=^<$@$ G'=<: <$#"<9E :;$ ?B@B:E '( ($9$<"?^'\$< "E (B<E:5 M$8:<"?5 "89 ?"E: ^<B8MB^?$E5 :;'E$ ^<B8MB^?$E "<$ ^<'('=89?7 B@^'<:"8:LLL $F$8 B8 :;BE 9"7 "89 "#$ LLL "89 :;$7 @=E: 6$ :<$":$9 "MM'<9B8#?7 B8 9$MB9B8# :;BEM"E$C
!"#$ &'() *)+,-./-0+-123456
Case 3:10-cv-00091-RV -EMT Document 150 Filed 01/31/11 Page 3 of 78
Reward Your Curiosity
Everything you want to read.
Anytime. Anywhere. Any device.
No Commitment. Cancel anytime.