Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Foreclosed Homeowners Go to Court on Their Own NYTimes

Foreclosed Homeowners Go to Court on Their Own NYTimes

Ratings: (0)|Views: 9 |Likes:
Published by Esquire

More info:

Categories:Types, Business/Law
Published by: Esquire on Feb 03, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial


Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less





This copy is for your personal, noncommercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customershereor use the "Reprints" tool that appears next to anyarticle. Visitwww.nytreprints.comfor samples and additional information.Order a reprint of this article now. February 2, 2011
Foreclosed Homeowners Go to Court onTheir Own
 ALBUQUERQUE — Saving your home from foreclosure is increasingly a do-it-yourself project.Lawyers are scarce and free legal assistance is overwhelmed in New Mexico, so a community center here is offering an hourlong class in how to download the correct forms, decipher thelingo and mount a defense, however tentative and primitive, against a multibillion-dollar bank.“I don’t see success for someone like me who doesn’t understand the law,” said Skylar Perea, asenior care aide who fell behind on her payments during the eight months she was out of a job.“But it’s better than nothing.”In New Mexico, New York, Florida and the 20 other states where foreclosures require a judge’sapproval, homeowners in default have traditionally surrendered their homes without evercoming to court to defend themselves. (In the 27 other states, including California, Nevada and Arizona, homeowners have a much harder time contesting a foreclosure even if they want to.)That passivity has begun to recede. While many foreclosures are still unopposed, courts areseeing a sharp rise in cases where defendants show up representing themselves.One factor driving the increase is the changing nature of foreclosure. When people went into default in 2008, it was generally because of the exploding cost of asubprime loan. Unable or unwilling to handle sharply higher payments, the homeowner walkedaway with little protest.Now many defaults are prompted by stretches of unemployment like Ms. Perea’s. Theseowners do not have the resources to come up with all their missed payments at once. But if they can persuade their lender to restructure the loan instead of seizing the house, they have achance of staying put.In New Mexico, this is where the hourlong workshops come in. “When you cannot pay, this iscalled ‘a breach of contract,’ ” Angelica Anaya Allen, director of the nonprofit Fair Lending
2/3/2011Foreclosed Homeowners Go to Court on nytimes.com/2011/02/03//03class.html1/4
Center, explained to a small but diverse group one recent morning. Young and old, solo and in couples, the homeowners in Ms. Anaya Allen’s class were all in breach, clutching special-delivery packages from their lenders announcing that the machinery  was now engaged to evict them. They took notes, asked questions — is the courthouse the building on Fourth Street with the blue roof? — and were resolute if not quite eager for battle.“I’m not sure where I stand, but I just don’t want to let the house go,” said Ms. Perea.The legal challenges that she and the other students will make are slowing the foreclosureprocess. Over the last year, the average delinquency for a foreclosed loan rose to 499 days from406 days, according to the data firm LPS Applied Analytics. But they are also straining thecourts and often encouraging unreal expectations.Louis McDonald, the chief judge for New Mexico’s 13th Judicial District, welcomes the influx of homeowners defending themselves, known as pro se defendants.“They really want to stay in their houses,” he said. “Some of them have fairly legitimatedefenses.”But the law grows more complex as the cases proceed, and foreclosure still looms for those whodo not grasp its intricacies. “The system is failing those who can’t afford representation,” Mr.McDonald said.The 13th District surrounds Albuquerque on three sides and includes Sandoval County, whichhas the highest foreclosure rate in the state. Nearly half of the 100 new foreclosure defendantsflooding the court every month are there on their own. There are so many of these defendants,and they need so much help understanding the law in a small, overburdened court, that last year Mr. McDonald instituted regular meetings overseen by himself and the district’s two other judges. Volunteer lawyers were on hand to advise the defendants, and the bank lawyers wererequired to attend.It was, in effect, a court within the court. But the program used a lot of resources for anuncertain result, so it is being replaced by a less comprehensive clinic. The real solution, Mr.McDonald said, would be “more legal aid.”That is a common refrain in court systems that have been successful in reaching out to theforeclosed. Before 2008 in New York, for instance, about 90 percent of foreclosure defendantsnever appeared before a judge. It was,a recent reportby the court system said, a “paperprocess” and not a people process.
2/3/2011Foreclosed Homeowners Go to Court on nytimes.com/2011/02/03//03class.html2/4
Then the state legislature directed that the court system hold mandatory settlementconferences to encourage the bank and the homeowner to reach a resolution. More than three-quarters of defendants now come to court, about 32,000 in the first 10 months of last year. Butonly 12,000 had a lawyer. The rest were in charge of their own fate.“We’re getting the people in here, getting them to the table with the bank, but I don’t kno what happens to these cases long term,” said Paul Lewis, chief of staff to New York’s chief administrative judge. “Many of the homeowners would do much better with an attorney.”The courts would be better off as well. In Suffolk County, foreclosure cases are 40 percent of the civil caseload. Upstate, in Schenectady and Wyoming counties, they are about half. The New  York State Unified Court System is asking for an additional $25 million a year to pay forlawyers to represent the poor in civil cases, including foreclosure. The legislature has yet toapprove the request.In Albuquerque, the three lawyers for the Fair Lending Center — a legal aid group that is paidfor by the state — would be happy to see their financing merely remain the same. But even if itdoes, they will not be able to handle all the demand.Ms. Anaya Allen started offering the foreclosure workshops last spring, at a point when she andher colleagues simply could not take on any new cases.“It was the only alternative: give people the tools to help themselves,” she said.Other legal aid groups across the country have been forced to consider do-it-yourself classes.For theLegal Aid Society of Southwest Ohio, demand for foreclosure help rose 51 percent between May and November last year. “People realized they could fight back,” said Mark Lawson, a senior lawyer with the nonprofit.Financing has not kept pace. At any moment, Mr. Lawson has a dozen or so files on his desk —people who qualify for help but will not get it from him. When he calls and says his lawyers aretoo busy to take on another case, some homeowners get angry. Others are grateful that at leastsomeone cared.Mr. Lawson is skeptical that self-help clinics are a solution. “We have overwhelmed judges andimpossible lenders,” he said. “It’s hard enough for lawyers to deal with them.”In the Albuquerque class, Ms. Anaya Allen does not promise a happy ending. “At the end of theday, unless you have major defenses, it’s likely the court will make a finding of foreclosure,” shesaid.
2/3/2011Foreclosed Homeowners Go to Court on nytimes.com/2011/02/03//03class.html3/4

Activity (2)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 hundred reads

You're Reading a Free Preview

/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->