You are on page 1of 6

JOURNAL OF COMPUTING, VOLUME 3, ISSUE 1, JANUARY 2011, ISSN 2151-9617

HTTPS://SITES.GOOGLE.COM/SITE/JOURNALOFCOMPUTING/
WWW.JOURNALOFCOMPUTING.ORG 76

Using RFID Technology for Chronic Care


Management and Improvement in Jordanian
Public Hospitals
Bassam Al-Mahadeen

Abstract— There is no precise statistics of people with chronic illnesses in Jordan. As a result, the current delivery system
of the monthly medications for chronic conditions has many deficiencies in current management of diseases such as
diabetes, heart disease, depression, asthma and others. Lack of active follow-up to ensure the best service for patients with
chronic diseases is the main problem. An RFID model for managing the monthly medications for chronic conditions in
Jordanian public hospitals was proposed. This research, which is based on an observational study of mediations for chronic
conditions given to patients with chronic diseases in four public hospitals located in southern part of Jordan, extended over a
period of 20 months, and is expected to help the decision makers to draw the right policies regarding the request of these
medicines. The statistics yielded from the proposed RFID model is of particular importance to help fulfill this need. The
proposed chronic disease management system is expected to control the health care cost, improve the chronic illness care
quality, and provide a comprehensive strategy for restructuring chronic illness care delivery system.

Index Terms— RFID technology, chronic Conditions, RFID reader, RFID tag.

——————————  ——————————

1 INTRODUCTION

C HRONIC diseases are a global challenge. They ac-


count for about 75 per cent of global healthcare costs
and 85 per cent of all deaths. Managing populations
eases is high. The most common include chronic fatigue
syndrome, chronic osteoarticular diseases (rheumatoid
arthritis, osteoarthritis), chronic respiratory diseases
with chronic diseases is a major challenge for developed (chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, asthma), chronic
as well as developing countries. renal failure, diabetes mellitus, chronic hepatitis, cardi-
Jordan, a developing country located in the Middle East, ovascular diseases (heart failure, ischemic cardiopathy,
has one of the fastest growing populations in the world. cerebrovascular disease) and others. These patients re-
Between the two censuses in 1979 and 1994, the popula- ceive the prescriptions of their medications every month
tion grew from 2.1 to 5.1 million people, an average in- on a regular basis. This process of prescribing or request-
crease of 2.7 percent annually. At this rate, the population ing such medications is not accurate, as there is no accu-
of Jordan will double in 25 years. The Government of Jor- rate number of patients to estimate their needs of each
dan (GOJ) has recognized that this will place tremendous medicine. The quantity of drugs is, therefore, less likely to
strain on Jordan’s health services. Jordan faces several satisfy the actual needs, causing several patients with
issues including less than fully functional public health chronic disease conditions not to receive their medica-
systems, a significant unmet demand for high quality tions in time. This process of controlling the distribution
health care services and information, and a significant of medications for chronic conditions is usually accom-
increase in the prevalence of chronic diseases. plished by fixing a monthly note on the patient’s record
There are three sectors in the provision of health-care once he/she receives his/her medications as shown in
services in Jordan: the public, the private and the interna- Figure 1. This note details the date of receiving the avail-
tional sectors. The public sector is composed of the Minis- able medicines besides the patient’s currently missing
try of Health, the Royal Medical Services, the University medicines. The patients have to revisit the pharmacy to
of Jordan and the Social Security Organisation. Most hos- check if their missing medicines are in hand or not. There
pitals provide primary and secondary health services are no electronic patient records in the public hospitals, or
with referrals of some patients to the tertiary hospitals computer system to manage the process of requesting and
located in the capital city of Jordan, Amman. Primary distributing these medicines.
Health Centres provide health-care services that include Improving the health of people with chronic illness
maternal and child health services, school health services, requires transforming the system that is essentially reac-
and health education [1]. tive – responding mainly when a person is sick – to the
The percentage of Jordanian people with chronic dis- one that is proactive and focused on keeping a person as
healthy as possible. That requires not only determining
————————————————
what care is needed, but also spelling out roles and tasks
 Bassam AL-Mahadeen is with the Department of Maths & Information to guarantee that the patient, using structured and
Technology, Tafila Technical University, Jordan.

© 2011 Journal of Computing Press, NY, USA, ISSN 2151-9617


http://sites.google.com/site/journalofcomputing/
JOURNAL OF COMPUTING, VOLUME 3, ISSUE 1, JANUARY 2011, ISSN 2151-9617
HTTPS://SITES.GOOGLE.COM/SITE/JOURNALOFCOMPUTING/
WWW.JOURNALOFCOMPUTING.ORG 77

planned interactions, receives the necessary care. The tion and optimisation of resources while improving accu-
proactive system also requires the existence of follow-up racy and minimising patients’ transition, hence improv-
procedure to ensure the follow-up care, and this means ing the services presented to patients with chronic diseas-
that patients are not left on their own once in home [2]. es.

2 CURRENT SYSTEM
Figure 2 shows the flow chart for the current process of
distributing the monthly medications for chronic condi-
tions. When a doctor realises that a patient suffers from a
chronic disease, he prescribes the necessary monthly me-
dications for chronic conditions. The monthly chronic
medicine prescriptions could be given by more than one
doctor, so the patient may have more than one monthly
prescription from different doctors according to their
fields of specialties. A doctor may write the same course
of medication for each month, as shown in Figure 3, and
only one prescription is dealt with by the pharmacist at
the beginning of each month. This process implies that
patients need not visit doctors every month, and this is
likely to avoid them any difficulties that might arise every
month. In addition, some doctors like to see their patients
every six months. This being the case, this process is high-
Fig. 1. Multiple medical files for the same patient.
ly likely to save doctors and patients time and effort.
When a patient goes to the pharmacy to collect his
Effective chronic illness care would be impossible monthly medications for chronic conditions, he gets the
without information systems that assure ready access to available medicines only. As for the missing medicines
key data on individual patients as well as populations of from the pharmacy counter, the patient is kindly re-
patients. A comprehensive clinical information system quested to return to the doctor for a replacement prescrip-
can enhance the care of individual patients by providing tion of the missing medicines. The patient then presents
timely reminders for needed services, with the summa- it to the pharmacist in order to fix a new date to collect
rised data helping to track and plan care. At the practice the currently missing medicines. Re-writing a new pre-
population level, an information system can identify scription for the missing medicines is time-consuming for
groups of patients who are in need of additional care as both doctors and patients. More importantly, the patient
well as facilitate performance monitoring and quality im- needs to repeatedly visit the pharmacy to check if the
provement efforts [3]. missing medicines have become available. Repeated visit-
Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) technology is an ing could prevent patients from taking their medicines in
emerging technology that has been successfully applied a timely manner. Added to this issue is the high cost of
in supply chain management, manufacturing, health, en- transportation if patients come from distant areas.
terprise feedback control, food safety warranties etc. [4]. Due to the unavailability of precise statistics about the
RFID technology in healthcare has been used to enhance number of people who suffer from chronic diseases, their
patient safety and improve medicine-inventory manage- needs of each medicine, and the amount of medicines that
ment capabilities [15]. Many hospitals [5], [6], [7] are us- are available at pharmacies in hospitals, many patients
ing RFID-enabled wrist bands to identify, locate, and ob- may not receive part of their medications for chronic con-
tain status updates on their patients. RFID is also used for ditions in time, and this could result in more complica-
tagging medical devices and placing readers in doorways tions for patients. The absence of a computerised system
at hospitals to minimise time spent looking for these de- to manage and control the distribution of such medicines,
vices and increase their utilisation as a way to improve and the failure to keep the pharmacists informed of the
the overall efficiency of the hospital. required amount of each drug – so that they order the
This paper proposes a cost effective solution for the right quantity of each drug in a timely manner – are the
management of chronic disease medicines to increase main contributors to this problem, timely access to medi-
patient satisfaction and health-related quality of life, have cines for people with chronic illnesses.
better disease control and improve clinical process of Due to the absence of electronic medical records in pub-
care. The solution is based on using the RFID technology lic hospitals, some patients may retain more than one pre-
to build a new model for monitoring the distribution of scription for the same month, and keep more than one
the monthly medications for chronic conditions and pro- personal medical record. Driven by the fear of having no
vide the policymakers with online statistics about the ac- medicines left in the following months, many patients
tual needs of the medications of chronic conditions. This may replace more than one prescription in the same
solution is of use in that it makes sure that the monthly month from the pharmacy. Patient stockpiling of medi-
medications for chronic conditions will be given to autho- cines will very likely deprive other patients from having
rised patients only. The system should enable the integra- their medicines at the scheduled time.
JOURNAL OF COMPUTING, VOLUME 3, ISSUE 1, JANUARY 2011, ISSN 2151-9617
HTTPS://SITES.GOOGLE.COM/SITE/JOURNALOFCOMPUTING/
WWW.JOURNALOFCOMPUTING.ORG 78

The cost of medicines for chronic conditions covered by


the government is very high and constitutes a high ratio
of Jordan’s national expenditure As well, the delay in the
distribution of such medicines potentially cause compli-
cations for patients with chronic conditions. Thus we
propose a system to manage the distribution of such me-
dicines more effectively and to ensure that medicines are
administered only to those patients requiring them and
avoid stockpiling.

Fig. 3. Scanned document of multiple monthly prescriptions for the


same patient.

3. RFID TECHNOLOGY
RFID stands for Radio Frequency Identification and it is
a term that describes a system of identification. RFID is
based on storing and remotely retrieving information or
data [8]. A typical RFID system consists of tags, readers,
application software, computer hardware, and middle-
ware [4]. RFID tags store unique identification informa-
tion of objects and communicate the tags so as to allow
remote retrieval of their ID. RFID technology depends on
the communication between the RFID tags and RFID
readers. The range of the reader is dependent upon its
Fig. 2. Current system of the monthly chronic system distribution. operational frequency [9] [10]. Usually the readers have
their own software running on their ROM, and they also
can communicate with other application software to ma-
The proposed solution to manage medicines for chronic nipulate these unique identified tags. Basically, the appli-
conditions is based on the employment of RFID technolo- cation which manipulates tag deduction information for
gy. The premise is to build a database of patients with the end user communicates with the RFID reader to get
chronic conditions to provide the latest statistical infor- the tag information through antennas [10]. RFID middle-
mation to policymakers and stake holders about the sta- ware that interprets tag information to communicate it to
tus of patients, each type of chronic condition and asso- the application software, and application software are
ciated medicines. This information would provide evi- integrated in a manner to form an RFID solution [9][11].
dence for appropriate medicine requirements over time. The main components of an RFID system are:
In the proposed system, each patient with chronic condi-
tions is given a tag with a unique ID to identify them and 3.1 Tags and antennae
their required medications. The patient’s tag can be used RFID tag consists of an integrated circuit with memory,
directly by the pharmacist to access the patient database which is essentially a microprocessor chip capable of
and retrieve the patient’s information and medicines holding stored information [4]. RFID tags can be active
without the need of using any prescription. For any miss- (with batteries) or passive (without batteries). The tag has
ing medicine, the patient will be able to come directly to an identity (ID) that can be broadcast to a reader that is
the pharmacy without returning to the doctor for a new operating on the same frequency and under the same tag
prescription This process will be of great significance, in protocol. RFID antennae collect data and are used as a
that it saves doctors’ and patient’s time and effort. medium for tag reading between the tag and the reader
[12]. As well, RFID antennae have a reading range both
sideways and in front of the antenna. The antennae draw
JOURNAL OF COMPUTING, VOLUME 3, ISSUE 1, JANUARY 2011, ISSN 2151-9617
HTTPS://SITES.GOOGLE.COM/SITE/JOURNALOFCOMPUTING/
WWW.JOURNALOFCOMPUTING.ORG 79

energy from the reader’s signal to energise the tag and events could be prevented by building a safer healthcare
send the data that are received from the readers. system. Such technology could be used to reengineer the
inpatient medication process to improve the efficiency of
3.2 Reader hospital management and increase higher quality of pa-
RFID reader works as a central place for the RFID sys- tient care [16].
tem [12]. RFID reader can read data from and write data The RFID technology can facilitate the building of the
to compatible RFID tags. Upon receipt of the RFID read- u-healthcare (ubiquitous healthcare) environment, pro-
er’s radio signal, a tag sends information stored in its vide strategic services to patient-centered recording, use
memory back to the reader. The reader then converts the medical data for cooperative care, process integrated de-
data into digital information and forwards it to the ap- cision support through current medical knowledge and
propriate application. Communication between tag and comprehensively use patient data for research and
reader enables the location information of an item to be healthcare reporting [11]. The use of RFID technology
recorded and transferred to a server through a computer together with a wireless networking system allows medi-
network, thus allowing the movement of the item to be cal assets within the hospital to be managed and con-
tracked or traced [4]. trolled from a fix location. Medical assets can be tracked
and monitored to control the misplacement of resources
3.3 Communication infrastructure and reduce their loss, achieving an optimal use of re-
Communication infrastructure is a collection of wired source management. It provides direct and continuous
and wireless network communication that carries out a identification, position and tracking of patients, drugs
series of information transfer actions that deliver the data and assets at the right time all the time. A standardised
that are stored in a tag to the reader. RFID software network architecture is used to convert the
Using RFID in healthcare may have a great potential to data gathered by RFID into information. This information
reduce operating costs, and improve medical services and is then processed by the back-end system into useful
patient safety. RFID allows the wireless storage and au- knowledge that could be used in the organisation’s deci-
tomatic retrieval of data. Such a system has the potential sion-making process.
to help boost supply chain efficiency, improve security,
reduce theft and counterfeiting, increase asset visibility,
enhance inventory control, and automate stock reple-
5 THE PROPOSED SYSTEM
nishment processes [12].
Although tagging objects, such as medical equipment, In the proposed system (refer to Figure 4) each patient
drugs, etc., is a potential area for RFID in hospitals, the who is diagnosed with a chronic condition requiring
tagging of patients involves both more value and more monthly medications is given a RFID tag with a unique
challenges, data collected from tagged patients may help patient ID. All monthly medications for the chronic condi-
improve medical processes, decision making, and re- tions are documented on the dedicated database of pa-
source management. Equipment tagging may be easier in tients with chronic illnesses, with their patient informa-
that experience from manufacturing and retail is already tion. When a patient comes to the pharmacy for his
available. Tagging people is more challenging because it monthly medicine, the system’s database is accessed for
involves patients, physicians, medical know-how and validation using the patient’s tag, and the patient’s record
practices, and organisational issues [12]. is retrieved automatically. The available medicines are
given to the patient and a note is placed on the patient’s
record beside each medication. For missing medicines,
the patient comes later directly to the pharmacy without
4 RFID TECHNOLOGY IN HEALTHCARE the need to see the doctor again to write a new prescrip-
RFID technology can provide new capabilities and effi- tion for the missing medicines.
cient methods for several applications in healthcare. The Travelling from distant areas to check the availability of
RFID system should enable the integration and optimisa- the missing medicines is not cost effective and often pa-
tion of resources while improving accuracy and minimi- tients do not return for the missing medications, thus im-
sation of patients’ transition time (the time needed for a pacting on their health. A suggested solution is the use of
patient to get service), and this leads to improvements in mobile phones in rural communities as the majority of
patients’ services. The application of RFID in healthcare patients do use these devices. The system can use short
could save important resources that can further contri- messaging service (SMS) through mobile phones to com-
bute to better patient care [14]. Moreover, RFID applica- municate patients upon the arrival of the missing medi-
tions could reduce the number of errors by tagging medi- cines at the pharmacy counter, as in Figure 5. Therefore
cal objects in healthcare setting such as patients’ files and patients would no longer need to make frequent visits to
medical equipment tracking in a timely manner. Improv- a pharmacy to get the missing medicines. Patients’ visit to
ing the situation for patients care by integrating medical the pharmacy would be timed by the availability of the
objects involved throughout the patients’ care is also an missing medications via the SMS system. The flowchart in
advantage of RFID. Figure 6 summarizes the new process of the proposed
Adapting RFID technologies in hospitals has progressive- system.
ly become a trend. Medication errors and adverse drug
JOURNAL OF COMPUTING, VOLUME 3, ISSUE 1, JANUARY 2011, ISSN 2151-9617
HTTPS://SITES.GOOGLE.COM/SITE/JOURNALOFCOMPUTING/
WWW.JOURNALOFCOMPUTING.ORG 80

Fig. 5. Patient notification via SMS.

Fig. 4. RFID infrastructure of medications for chronic conditions


management.

The proposed RFID system will supersede the current pa-


per-based distribution and management of chronic medica-
tions, and will guarantee an optimal way for the manage-
ment of these medicines. The system will ensure that only
authorised patients are given their chronic medications,
achieving better health quality for patients with chronic
conditions. It is proposed that the system will also provide
on-line and immediate up-to-date statistics for stake hold-
ers and policymakers about patients, chronic illnesses, and
the extent of chronic conditions in the population. As well,
the system will provide more accurate predictions about
medication quantities required for the next coming
months. Thus it is hoped that patients will avoid illness
consequences due to medication shortages.
Fig. 6. Proposed System of the monthly chronic system
distribution.

6 CONCLUSION
This proposal is mainly concerned with demonstrating
the significance of introducing and integrating RFID
technology into Jordanian public hospitals. The author is
calling for the RFID technology to distribute medications
for chronic conditions to patients. To this end, a new
model is proposed to electronically regulate the distribu-
tion (on the part of pharmacies) and collection of medi-
cines (on the part of patients). The employment of this
model in Jordanian hospitals, which centres on replacing
paper-based records with electronic records, would be of
crucial significance, in that it would guarantee that only
eligible people would receive medications for chronic
conditions. Under the absence of dependable electronic
JOURNAL OF COMPUTING, VOLUME 3, ISSUE 1, JANUARY 2011, ISSN 2151-9617
HTTPS://SITES.GOOGLE.COM/SITE/JOURNALOFCOMPUTING/
WWW.JOURNALOFCOMPUTING.ORG 81

records, medications for chronic conditions could be dis- [12] W. Shang-Wei, C. Wun-Hwa, O. Chorng-Shyong,L. Li, C. Yun-
tributed to non-entitled people, and this would be at the Wen, “RFID applications in hospitals: a case study on a demon-
expense of those who are really entitled. Equally impor- stration RFID project in a Taiwan hospital,” Proceedings of the
tantly, it would be financially and physically unbearable 39th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 1-10,
for patients with chronic diseases to frequently visit 2006.
pharmacies to inquire about the availability of the un- [13] Y. Meiller, S. Bureau, “Logistics Projects: How to Assess the
available medicines, bearing in mind that the recipients of Right System? The Case of RFID Solutions in Healthcare,”
medications for chronic conditions are assumed to be suf- Americas Conference on Information Systems (AMCIS) 2009
fering from never-ending diseases. With this in mind, Proceedings, Association for Information Systems Year 2009.
going repeatedly hence and forth between home and [14] K. Ahsan, H. Shah, P. Kingston, “Role of Enterprise Architec-
pharmacies to inquire about medicines would add insult ture in healthcare,” IT. Proceeding ITNG2009, IEEE, 2009.
to injury on their part. In order to avoid patients with [15] F. Wu, F. Kuo, L. Liu, “The Application of RFID on Drug Safety
chronic diseases disappointment and do all we can do for of Inpatient Nursing Healthcare,” ICEC’05, August 15–17,
the sake of their comfort, RFID technology was suggested Xi’an, China, 2005.
to be fruitfully employed in Jordanian hospitals. A tech- [16] C. Lai, S. Chien, S. Chen, K. Fang, “Enhancing medication safe-
nical explanation of how this model operates was pro- ty and reduce adverse drug events on inpatient medication
vided, though I strategically aimed to communicate the administration using RFID,” WSEAS Transactions on Communi-
technical details in a non-technical way as a way to guar- cations, vol. 7, no. 10, pp. 1045-1054, 2008.
antee the reception, on the part of non-specialists, of the
signal of this piece of research.

REFERENCES
[1] R., Khresheh, R. “Investigating the feasibility of introducing a
consolidated birth record: the first step in an information sys-
tem that identifies outcomes and enables improvements,” The-
sis, University of Technology, Sydeny, 2006.
[2] E.H.Wagner, B.T Austin, M. Von Korff, “Organizing care for
Patients with chronic illness,” Milbank Quarterly, 74, pp. 511–
544, 1996.
[3] E.H., Wagner, “Population-based management of diabetes
care,” Patient Education and Counselling, 16 , pp. 225-230, 1995.
[4] E. Ngai, K. Moon, F. Riggins, C. Yi, “RFID research: An aca-
demic literature review (1995–2005) and future research direc-
tions,” Int. J. Production Economics, 112, pp. 510–520, 2008.
[5] S. Tzeng, W. Chen, F. Pai, “Evaluating the business value of
RFID: Evidence from five case studies,” Int. J. Production Eco-
nomics, 112, pp. 601–613, 2008.
[6] C. Chaoa, J. Yangb, W. Jenc, “Determining technology trends
and forecasts of RFID by a historical review and bibliometric
analysis from 1991 to 2005,” Technovation, 27, pp. 268–279, 2007.
[7] S. Wanga, W. Chenb, C. Onga, L. Liuc, Y. Chuangb, “RFID
applications in hospitals: a case study on a demonstration RFID
project in a Taiwan hospital,” Proceedings of the 39th Hawaii
International Conference on System Sciences, 2006.
[8] J. Schwierenl, G. Vossen, “A Design and Development Metho-
dology for Mobile RFID Applications based on the ID-Services
Middleware Architecture,” IEEE Computer Society, Tenth Inter-
national Conference on Mobile Data Management: Systems,
Service and Middleware, 2009.
[9] K. Ahsan, H. Shah, P. Kingston, “RFID Applications: An Intro-
ductory and Exploratory Study,” IJCSI International Journal of
Computer Science Issues, vol. 7, issue 1, no. 3, 1-7, 2010.
[10] J. Bohn, “Prototypical implementation of location-aware servic-
es based on a middleware architecture for super-distributed
RFID tag infrastructures,” Pers Ubiquit computing, 12, pp. 155-
166, 2008.
[11] S. Tzeng, W. Chen, F. Pai, “Evaluating the business value of
RFID: Evidence from five case studies,” Int. J. Production Eco-
nomics, 112, pp. 601–613, 2008.

You might also like