Welcome to Scribd. Sign in or start your free trial to enjoy unlimited e-books, audiobooks & documents.Find out more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword or section
Like this
2Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
229 CO Space Case Neg

229 CO Space Case Neg

Ratings: (0)|Views: 731|Likes:
Published by Christian Jones

More info:

Categories:Types, Research
Published by: Christian Jones on Mar 15, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

02/03/2013

pdf

text

original

 
SPACE NEGDDI 2k8 Culpepper/OlsenG. Zhang
SPACE NEG:
Table of Contents
Space Colonization F/L:.............................................................................................................................4Space Militarization F/L (1/4):...................................................................................................................5Space Militarization F/L (2/4):...................................................................................................................6Space Militarization F/L (3/4):...................................................................................................................7Ext Space Mil F/L - US ahead now ...........................................................................................................81NC 1 Ext:.................................................................................................................................................9Space Militarization → Nuke War:..........................................................................................................10Space Militarization → Nuke War:..........................................................................................................11Space Mil → Arms Races:.......................................................................................................................12Space Mil → Arms Races (China/Russia):..............................................................................................13Space Mil → War w/ China:....................................................................................................................14AT Space Mil Inev:..................................................................................................................................15Turn: Space Mil Kills US leadership:......................................................................................................16Heg F/L (1/3):...........................................................................................................................................17Heg F/L (2/3):...........................................................................................................................................18Heg F/L (3/3):...........................................................................................................................................19Ext – Space Colonization → Militarization.............................................................................................20Space Exploration → Militarization:.......................................................................................................21Space Exploration
Militarization:.......................................................................................................22Diseases Turn:..........................................................................................................................................23Ext. – Space Colonization → diseases:....................................................................................................24Ext. – Space Colonization → diseases:....................................................................................................25Space Colonization – Costly:...................................................................................................................26Space Colonization – Uninhabitable:.......................................................................................................27Space Colonization – Lack of Funding....................................................................................................28Space Colonization – Microgravity Damage:..........................................................................................29Space Colonization – Not Inevitable:......................................................................................................30Space Colonization - Debris:...................................................................................................................31Space Colonization – Lack of Personnel:................................................................................................32Rescind Commercial Ban CP:..................................................................................................................33Rescind Commercial Ban CP Solvency:..................................................................................................34Rescind Commercial Ban CP Solvency:..................................................................................................35Rescind Commercial Ban CP Solvency:..................................................................................................36International Cooperation Key:................................................................................................................37Solvency – Economy...............................................................................................................................38China Cooperation Good:........................................................................................................................39US Heg Loss Inev:...................................................................................................................................40AT Space Mil Inev:..................................................................................................................................411
 
SPACE NEGDDI 2k8 Culpepper/OlsenG. ZhangSpace Mil → Wars:..................................................................................................................................42Space Mil → Preemptive Strikes:............................................................................................................43Space Debris Defense:.............................................................................................................................44Space Debris Defense – Humanity at risk:..............................................................................................45AT Space Solves Environmental Harms:.................................................................................................46Securitization K Links – Climate Change:...............................................................................................47.............................................................................................................................................................47Securitization K Links – Climate Change:...............................................................................................48Securitizing climate change spills over to military spheres................................................................48Securitization Mpx - Prolif:.....................................................................................................................49Securitization Mpx - Bare Life:...............................................................................................................50Solar Power – Popular:............................................................................................................................51Space Exploration – Unpopular:..............................................................................................................52Solar Power – Congress supports:...........................................................................................................53Solar Power – Reps support:....................................................................................................................54Solar Power – Congress Inaction Now:...................................................................................................55States CP Shell (1/2):...............................................................................................................................56States CP Shell (2/2):...............................................................................................................................57States CP Solvency - Generic:.................................................................................................................58States CP Solvency – Funding:................................................................................................................59NASA Spin-off Turn:...............................................................................................................................602
 
Clark-Martin Plan text.
Doesn't spec incentivesThus, the plan:The United States federal government should provide incentives to the National Aeronautics and SpaceAdministration for research, development, and implementation of space-based solar power satellites.We’ll clarify.NASA Trade-off DA. Maybe have the DOD do it. Consult Congress.
Kernoff-Olney Plan text.
Says monetary incentives. For development and deployment of SPSPlan:The United States Federal Government should substantially increase monetary incentives for development and deployment of Solar Power Satellites in the United States. We’ll clarify.Doesn't have a good fed key warrant – Their national security space office card doesn't say that theFEDERAL GOVERNMENT specifically should provide incentives, it just says incentives.Their Hamilton card doesn't have warrants why a NATIONALLY coordinated program would solve or why it would have to be led by the USFG. It just sounds like the states which make up the US could doit too.Their NewScientist card also doesn't even mention the USFG
States CP probably solves. Need to cut ptix links – pop, unpop, incr pcap, decr pcap,
Their Morring card doesn't say we can achieve the types of transformational changes indicated by the1ac advantages. It just says some change can happen within 10 years.They claim as their first advantage Information War and say that information solves prolif, but their evis talking in the context of surveillance systems in the military. They say that space solves surveillancewhich allows for a more effective military. This seems extra-T b/c it's not from alt energy incentives.
Links pretty hard to securitization K – surveillance links, militarism links, balancing, eco-managerialismgoogle scholar search on security and space and representations/discourse args. Copenhagenschool.USFG has to do it – Fisc Disc Net Benefit
– US probably has to send the satellites up there.3

Activity (2)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 thousand reads
1 hundred reads

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->