Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
1Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
gov.uscourts.vaed.262289.29.0

gov.uscourts.vaed.262289.29.0

Ratings: (0)|Views: 7|Likes:
Published by Griffin Boyce

More info:

Published by: Griffin Boyce on Mar 27, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

03/27/2011

pdf

text

original

 
TILED
UNITEDSTATESDISTRICT
COURT
FOR
THE
EASTERN
DISTRICTOFVIRGINIA
AlexandriaDivision
2011
FES
10P
U--U2
CLERK
US
DISTRICT
COURT
ALEXANDRIA.
VIRC
'
IN
REAPPLICATION
OF
THE
UNITED
STATESOFAMERICA
FOR
AN
ORDER
PURSUANT
TO
18U.S.C.§2703(d)
Misc.
No.
10GJ3793
No.1:11DM3(Mag.Buchanan)
Hearing:February15,2011
10:30a.m.
UNDER
SEAL
REPLY
IN
SUPPORTOF
MOTION
OF
REAL
PARTIES
IN
INTEREST
JACOBAPPELBAUM,ROPGONGGRIJP,AND
BIRGITTA
JONSDOTTIR
FOR
UNSEALING
OFSEALED
COURT
RECORDS
tGINUL-
c#
Case 1:11-dm-00003-TCB Document 29 Filed 02/10/11 Page 1 of 25
 
TABLE
OF
CONTENTS
TABLE
OF
AUTHORITIES
ii
INTRODUCTION
1
ARGUMENT
2
I.
MOVANTSHAVE
STANDING
TO
BRING
THISMOTION
2
II.
THEGOVERNMENT'SGENERIC
INTERESTS
INSECRECYDO
NOT
JUSTIFYKEEPINGTHESESEALEDDOCUMENTSUNDERSEAL
5
III.
THEGOVERNMENT
HAS
NOTMET
ITS
BURDEN
TOOVERCOME
THE
PRESUMPTION
OF
ACCESS
10
IV.
THEABSENCE
OF
A
PUBLICDOCKETFOR
THE
SEALEDMATERIALS
IS
NOT
PERMISSIBLE
16
CONCLUSION
18
Case 1:11-dm-00003-TCB Document 29 Filed 02/10/11 Page 2 of 25
 
TABLE
OF
AUTHORITIES
Cases
BaltimoreSunCo.
v.
Goetz,
886F.2d60(4thCir.1989)passim
Eastlandv.U.S.Servicemen'sFund,
421U.S.491(1975)
2,4,5
Grandbouche
v.
UnitedStates(InreFirstNat
7
Bank),
701F.2d115(10thCir.1983)3
InreGrandJurySubpoena
for
N.
Y.
StateIncomeTaxRecords,
607F.2d566(2dCir.1979)3
InreKnightPubl'gCo.,
743
F.2d231
(4thCir.1984)9
InreSwearingenAviationCorp.,
605F.2d125
(4th
Cir.1979)4
Leucadia.Inc.
v.
AppliedExtrusion
Techs..
Inc.,
998F.2d157(3dCir.1993)5
Local1814,Int
7
LongshoremensAss
'n,
AFL-CIOv.
Waterfront
Comm'n
ofN.Y.Harbor,
667F.2d267(2dCir.1981)3
Nixonv.
Warner
Commc'ns.Inc..
435U.S.589(1978)
5,12
Perlmanv.UnitedStates,
247U.S.7(1918)2,3
Pollard
v.
Roberts,
283F.Supp.248(E.D.Ark.1968)
(three-judgecourt),
affdper
curiam,
393U.S.14(1968)2
Press-EnterpriseCo.
v.
Super.
Ct.
ofCal,
478U.S.1(1986)
(Press-EnterpriseII)
9,12
Rushfordv.
New
Yorker
Magazine.
Inc.,
846F.2d249
(4th
Cir.1988)10
Stone
v.
Univ.
ofMd.
Med.Sys.
Corp.,
855F.2d
178(4thCir.1988)
9,15,
16,17
United
States
v.
Klepfer
(In
re
The
Herald
Co.),
734F.2d93(2dCir.1984)7
UnitedStates
v.
Mentzos,
462F.3d830(8thCir.2006)14
UnitedStatesv.Moussaoui,
65F.App'x881(4thCir.2003)12
United
States
v.
Myers,
593F.3d338(4thCir.2010)3
United
States
v.
Rosen,
487F.Supp.2d703(E.D.Va.2007)14
Case 1:11-dm-00003-TCB Document 29 Filed 02/10/11 Page 3 of 25

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->