Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
6Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Among the Hagiographers-gandhi and his pathology, WSJ book review!!

Among the Hagiographers-gandhi and his pathology, WSJ book review!!

Ratings: (0)|Views: 57|Likes:
Published by Saint
In the aftermath of a Book Review by British Historian Andrew Roberts published recently in WSJ, the whole mafia gang of Indians, and foreigners gone all out far war of words with the reviewer, the WSJ and the author of the book Great Soul.

There are about 4.8Million hits on the internet on this topic and about 700 comments made under the WSJ book review article of Roberts, what is amazing is the Indians who post their messages obnoxiously spew venom on the author of the book though none of them read the books, not a single, nada read the books. Their comments totally based on the review that was published, based on the review without reading the book almost 90% of the people make judgement on the author. Some spared the reviewer, and most abused at him and WSJ, but pretty much every one started rubbing mud on the author.

Pretty hindu minded and pathological, so what if they both said gandhi was a gay or whatever, is there a sanity in interpreting without even knowing what is said?. Oh well that is what Indians known for and infact a state called Gujarat, run by hindu casteist Modi, banned the book already...

This is my review on the review in WSJ...!

In the aftermath of a Book Review by British Historian Andrew Roberts published recently in WSJ, the whole mafia gang of Indians, and foreigners gone all out far war of words with the reviewer, the WSJ and the author of the book Great Soul.

There are about 4.8Million hits on the internet on this topic and about 700 comments made under the WSJ book review article of Roberts, what is amazing is the Indians who post their messages obnoxiously spew venom on the author of the book though none of them read the books, not a single, nada read the books. Their comments totally based on the review that was published, based on the review without reading the book almost 90% of the people make judgement on the author. Some spared the reviewer, and most abused at him and WSJ, but pretty much every one started rubbing mud on the author.

Pretty hindu minded and pathological, so what if they both said gandhi was a gay or whatever, is there a sanity in interpreting without even knowing what is said?. Oh well that is what Indians known for and infact a state called Gujarat, run by hindu casteist Modi, banned the book already...

This is my review on the review in WSJ...!

More info:

Published by: Saint on Mar 30, 2011
Copyright:Public Domain

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as TXT, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

05/13/2012

pdf

text

original

 
WallStreetJournal-BritishHistorianAndrewRoberts&Hagiographers..!TheWheelofDhammaisTurningnow!AmongtheHagiographersEarlyonGandhiwasdubbeda'mortaldemi-god

andhehasbeenregardedthatwayeversinceEversincegandhibecamegandhi,thespreadofinformationandstoriesaboutgandhiwasthetoppriorityofthemostwealthyanddiehardhinduswhocompriseonly,merely10%orlessoutofthe1.3BillionstrongpopulationofIndia(but,thediehardsalsoincludesmiserableportionofothersthatincludesevenIndia'sdalitswhoarenotfollowersofhinduism).ThosewhoareonthetopofthefoodchainandpowerstructureofIndiarealizedthattheymusthavesomethingtotalkaboutandsomethingtoprojectIndiathatwillpleasethehinducrowdandtheworld.WhatstartedasaHooplagandhibecameanextravagantpublicity,gandhi,theterm,thenameandactivitiesbecamethepropagandamachineforever.Somuchsaidandwrittenaboutgandhithatitbecamesoreal,becamethesymbolofIndia,thesymbolnon-violenceandthesymbolofTruth.........soon.TheextraordinarypropagandamachineofIndiaandabroadkepttheboisterousnewspouringonpeoplelikearainstormandeventheBritishMoviemaker"stuporDickie"couldnotresistmakingamovieongandhi.WhatDickiedidwasaspectacular,epicproportionmoviethatwouldfurthershakeuptheworldandplacethesaintgandhiontopoftheworldasamodel.AlbeitpeoplelikeRichardAttenboroughareknownfordoingsomehomeworkandgatherbackgroundinformation,factcheckandrealitycheck,hehasrealizedthepotentialofreapingrevenuesfromthismovieifhetwiststhetruthfurtheranddramatizeit,howmuchfactisinvolvedinthescriptisamilliondollarquestion.Didhereallydoresearchongandhiisalsoamilliondollarquestion,leavingallthosebehind,ifwelookattheportrayofgandhiinhismovie,Dickiebutcheredthetruthinthismovie,itisnowaycloselyevenresemblegandhi'sreallifeactivities.Notjustthemoviemaker,biographiesafterbiographies,booksafterbookswrittenongandhibyvariousIndianwriters,historians,academicianscreatedanauraaboutgandhi.OncetheIndiansbecametiredofwritingongandhi,theinternationalwriter'spickedupfromwherethehindusleftanditcontinuedunabattedandunscruplousfordecadestilltoday.Notasingleoneofthewriterseverhadtheabilitytobeascrupulouswritersormoviemakers!.Or,weretheypartoftheconspiracytootomakeahagiography-calfigureoutofahalfnaked,dull,ordinary,belowaverageintellectlikegandhiisunfoldingintherecentpast.Forthefirsttimeinmydesperatesearchforonewriter,justonehonestwriterwhocantellmetherealstoryaboutgandhi,Inearlystumbledupon,thoughAmongtheHegiographersnowayasclosetotheTruthtoldin"gandhibehindthedivinityofmaskandgandhiundercrossexaminationbyG.B.Singh.IameuphoricwhenIreadtherecentwallstreetjournalbookreviewbyAndrewRoberts,IsaidThankYou,atlastIfoundonewriternowIcanlistentoaboutgandhi.AndrewRoberts,aBritishhistorianwritesaspectacularbookreviewwithcourage,dignityandutmosthonestythatweneverwitnessedinthisworldeversincegandhibecamegandhi,decadesaftergandhi'slifeanddeath,thereissomuchsaidanddoneinbooks,movies,novels,newspapers.WSJ:GreatSoul:MahatmaGandhiandHisStrugglewithIndiaHistorianAndrewRobertsappraisesanewbiographyofGandhi,challenginghagiographicaccountsof,asthebook'stitlehasit,the"GreatSoul."!).AndrewRoberts,inhisquesttoanswersomeofthemostsecretlykeptormaskedquestionsongandhi,thatmanywouldthinkrightawayitisascam,orthehinduswouldsayblasphemy,butforthosetruthseekers,thisisarevealation,aspectacularreveiwneverdonebeforeongandhi.ForeveryargumentAndrewRobert'smake,areallsupportedbygandhi'sreallifeevents.TheWallStreetJournalmadechoiceatlasttobeoutrightlyhonest,IamnotsureiftheywantedtobeaModeloftheglobalnewspaperindustryoritisjustaflukethistimeithaspublishedsuchareviewthatwouldsurelygoingtocauseamessamonghindus,who

Activity (6)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
Saint liked this
Saint liked this
Saint liked this
Saint liked this
Saint liked this

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->