Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Undertaken
At
“The Co – operative Bank of Rajkot Ltd.”
i.e. Raj Bank
“Ratio Analysis Based on CAMEL Model of RBI”
1
PREFACE
As we enter the 21st Century with new hope and new expectations, it is
imperative that we appreciate the world around us is changing rapidly,
throwing open great challenges and innumerable opportunities. Driven by the
growing trend of globalization, the revolutionary developments in Information
Technology and the emergence of the digital era, we are witnessing
phenomenal changes in the world of finance. In the emerging scenario, finance
will be operating in a totally new financial landscape of atoms and electrons.
Ratio are exceptionally useful tools with the finance manager to infer the
financial performance of the enterprise over a period of time, with the help of
ratio analysis conclusion can be drawn regarding several aspects such as
financial health profitability and operational efficiency of the undertaking.
2
INDEX
PAGE
SR. NO. PARTICULARS
NO.
1. Introduction
2. Brief profile of Banking Sector in general
3. Brief profile of Co-operative Banks
4. History & Development of Raj Bank
5. Organisation Structure
6. Organisation Chart
Concept of Ratio Analysis its measurement and its
7.
analysis
8. Research Methodology
9. Ratio Analysis of Raj Bank
10.
Conclusion & Finding
11.
Bibliography
3
INTRODUCTION
The firm’s financial information is contained in three basic financial
statements – The Balance Sheet, Profit & Loss Account and Profit and Loss
Appropriation Account. These statements are very useful to different parties
concerned such as management, investor, creditors and other to form
judgement about the operational efficiency and financial position of the firm.
These statements may be more fruitfully used if they are analysed and
interpreted to have an insight into the strengths and weaknesses of the firm.
The success of the firm’s financial plans is based on the financial analysis
which is the starting point for making plans, before using and sophisticated
forecasting and budgeting procedures.
Comparative Statements
Common Size Statements
Trend Analysis
Fund Flow Analysis
Cash Flow Analysis
Value Added Analysis
Ratio Analysis
Ahead of all is Ratio Analysis which is a very powerful analytical tool for
measuring performance of an organisation. The Ratio Analysis concentrates on
the inter-relationship among the figures appearing in the aforementioned
financial statements. The Ratio Analysis helps the management to analyse the
past performance of the firm and to make further projections.
4
extremely helpful in providing valuable insight into a firm’s financial picture.
Ratios normally pinpoint a business strengths and weakness in two ways:
5
BRIEF PROFILE OF BANKING INDUSTRY IN
GENERAL
If there is one industry that has the stigma of being old and boring, it
would have to be banking; however, a global trend of deregulation has opened
up many new businesses to the banks. Coupling that with technological
developments like Internet banking and ATMs, the banking industry is
obviously trying its hardest to shed its lacklustre image.
There is no question that bank stocks are among the hardest to analyze.
Many hold several assets and have several subsidiaries in different industries.
A perfect example of what makes analyzing a bank stock so difficult is the
length of their financials. While it would take us an entire textbook to explain
all the ins and outs of the banking industry, this point will hopefully shed some
light on the more important areas to look at when analyzing a bank as an
investment.
Could you imagine a world without banks? At first this might sound like
a great thought! Banks (and financial institutions) have, however, for several
reasons, become cornerstones of our economic growth and steer the wheels of
the economy towards its goal of “Self reliance in all fields”. They transfer risk,
provide liquidity, facilitate both major and minor transactions, and provide
financial information for both individuals and businesses.
6
Perhaps the banking industry's largest distinction is the government's
heavy involvement in it. Besides setting restrictions on borrowing limits and
the amount of deposits that the bank must hold in their vault, the government
has a huge influence on banks profitability.
In present age in India there are many banks including foreign banks,
public sector, private sectors, commercial banks and co-operative banks. The
structure of Indian Banking System is as under:
7
Structure of Indian Banking
System
Unorganised Organised
Co-operative
Commercial
Unlicensed Reserve Bank Banks
Licensed Banks
Indigenous of India
Creditors
Money Lenders
8
BRIEF PROFILE OF CO – OPERATIVE BANKS
Once the Mahatma Gandhiji has remarked that,” There is sweetness in
co-operation; there is no one who weak or strong among those who co-operate.
Each is equal to other”.
Also today’s co-operative sector has grown in all over the world, with
globalization. They have also started to implement new technologies and
various management tools. Now, they are competing in same market with all
the other types of banks. In this way the Co-operative Banks holds the key
position in the economy.
We shall now enumerate the recent changes that have occurred in the
Co-operative Banking Scene, subsequent to the reform measures initiated by
the Government.
9
During 1993-94 the National Co-operative Bank of India (NCBI) was
registered on 5th August 1993 as a Multi-State Co-operative Society.
For the first time Scheduled Urban Co-operative Banks were permitted
to invest their surplus funds in Certificate of Deposits and Commercial
Papers of those Institutions / Corporate with credit rating P1 / A1 from
CRISIL / ICRA.
During 1995-96, all Scheduled PCBs were brought under the purview of
the provisions of the Banking Ombudsman Scheme, 1995.
10
HISTORY & DEVELOPMENT OF RAJ BANK
It is well said that “In the emerging competitive business environment
co-operative banks who adhere to strict financial discipline only will survive”.
The bank was started in small premises and converted into a large and
most popular bank having its Area of Operation in the entire Rajkot, Junagadh
and Jamnagar District. In years to come the bank will expand its business in the
entire Gujarat State.
The Co-operative Bank of Rajkot Ltd, have been at the forerunner of the
change taking place in the Co-operative Banking sector over the years. Their
strategic initiatives have led their position today as the first Co-operative bank
in Saurashtra to provide ATM facility. Their pioneering new approaches to
banking and their focus on extending the availability of tech-driven
convenience to large customer base resulted into rapid business growth.
A critical constituent of their growth has been the quality of their people.
The single minded application and understanding of the challenges of the
market place by their managers. They have built today stable business that will
deliver sustainable value to their stakeholders; there are more exciting
opportunities to grow. These include the whole gamut of financial products
ranging from agriculture credit to consumer credit, liability product and
insurance especially in Rural India.
At last it can be said that The Co-operative Bank of Rajkot Ltd is well
placed to capitalize on emerging competitive business environment
opportunities as it reaches out to new markets in Gujarat.
11
12
ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE
An organization Structure is the mechanism through which management
try’s to achieve its objectives. Various jobs are divided among units of the
enterprise and are integrated into an effective operation system to achieve an
organizational goal.
From the chart shown below it can be easily understood that Line &
Staff Organisation Structure is followed by Raj Bank.
ORGANIZATION CHART
13
14
CONCEPT OF RATIO ANALSIS ITS
MEASUREMENT & ITS ANALYSIS
Financial ratio analysis is a fascinating topic to study because it can
teach us so much about accounts and businesses. When we use ratio analysis
we can work out how profitable a business is, we can tell if it has enough
money to pay its bills and we can even tell whether its shareholders should be
happy!
Once we have discovered all of the ratios that we can use we need to
know how to use them, who might use them and what for and how will it help
them to answer the question we asked at the beginning?
At this stage we will have an overall picture of what ratio analysis is,
who uses it and the ratios they need to be able to use it. All that's left to do then
is to use the ratios; and we will do that step- by-step, one by one.
The three important questions we have asked at the beginning they are
describe in brief as under: That questions are;
15
What do we want ratio analysis to tell us?
The key question in ratio analysis isn't only to get the right answer: for
example, to be able to say that a business's profit is 10% of turnover. We have
to start working on ratio analysis with the following question in our heads:
Isn't this just blether, won't the exam just ask me to tell them that profit is 10%
of turnover? Well, yes, but then they want to know that we are a good student
who understands what it means to say that profit is 10% of turnover.
1.is profitable
2.has enough money to pay its bills
3.could be paying its employees higher wages
4.is paying its share of tax
5.is using its assets efficiently
6.has a gearing problem
7.is a candidate for being bought by another company or investor
And more, once we have decided what we want to know then we can decide
which ratios we need to use to answer the question or solve the problem facing
us.
The Ratios
We can simply make a list of the ratios we can use here but it's much better to
put them into different categories. If we look at the questions in the previous
section, we can see that we talked about profits, having enough cash, efficiently
using assets - we can put our ratios into categories that are designed exactly to
help us to answer these questions. The categories we want to use, section by
section, are:
16
1.Profitability: has the business made a good profit compared to its
turnover?
2.Return Ratios: compared to its assets and capital employed, has the
business made a good profit?
3.Liquidity: does the business have enough money to pay its bills?
4.Asset Usage or Activity: how has the business used its fixed and current
assets?
5.Gearing: does the company have a lot of debt or is it financed mainly by
shares?
6.Investor or Shareholder
Not everyone needs to use all of the ratios we can put in these categories
so the table that we present at the start of each section is in two columns: basic
and additional.
The basic ratios are those that everyone should use in these categories
whenever we are asked a question about them. We can use the additional ratios
when we have to analyse a business in more detail or when we want to show
someone that we have really thought carefully about a problem.
Now we know the kinds of questions we need to ask and we know the
ratios available to us, we need to know who might ask all of these questions!
This is an important issue because the person asking the question will normally
need to know something particular.
Of course, anyone can read and ask questions about the accounts of a
business; but in the same way that we can put the ratios into groups, we should
put readers and users of accounts into convenient groups, too: let's look at that
now.
• Investors &Lenders
17
• Managers of the organisation & Employees
• Suppliers and other trade creditors & Customers
• Governments and their agencies & Public
• Financial analysts
• Environmental groups
• Researchers: both academic and professional
18
What do the Users of Accounts Need to Know?
The users of accounts that we have listed will want to know the sorts of
things we can see in the table below: this is not necessarily everything they will
ever need to know, but it is a starting point for us to think about the different
needs and questions of different users.
20
Which ratios will each of these groups be interested in?
On this page we see the table which help different groups interested in
their ratio. In the left hand column there is a list of interest groups one by one
and in the right hand column there is a list of ratios they might be interested in.
21
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Research in common parlance refers to a search for knowledge. One can
also define research as a scientific and systematic search for pertinent
information on a specific topic. Research in academic activity and as such the
term should be used in a technical sense. Research is, thus, an original
contribution to the existing stock of knowledge making for its advancement.
22
RATIO ANALYSIS OF RAJ BANK
It's all very well being armed with a list of ratios and people who might
want to use them, but we need to know where to get all the figures to put into
those ratios, don't we?
Here are all the figures which are taken from profit and loss account and
balance sheet of “The Co-operative Bank of Rajkot Ltd.”
1) C – CAPITAL ADEQUACY
2) A – ASSET QUALITY
3) M – MANAGEMENT
4) E – EARNINGS QUALITY
5) L – LIQUIDITY
23
1) C – CAPITAL ADEQUACY
24
1) Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) or Capital to Risk Assets Ratio
(CRAR):
As per the latest RBI norms, banks in India should have a CAR of 9%. It is arrived at
by dividing the Tier I and Tier II capital by risk weighted assets. Tier I capital includes
equity capital and free reserves. Tier II capital comprises sub-ordinated debt of 5-7 year
tenure.
35.00
Interpretation of the Capital Adequacy Ratio
The minimum CAR as per RBI norms is 9 % at Present. In fact, Raj Bank has always
3
shown a healthy and improved margin of over 9 % which is stipulated by RBI, in the year
2002 – 2003 CAR is of 30.63 %. But from the year 2003 – 2004, it seems to decline in CAR
gradually to 29.25 % in 2003 - 2004 up to 21.17 % in 2005 – 2006. This is due to steady rise
25
30.00
in the Risk Weighted Assets. The main reason for the rise in Risk Weighted Assets and
decline in CAR is constant increase in advances over the last few years. Now, it’s looks to
improve as years passes.
26
2) Debt – Equity Ratio:
6.20
Interpretation of the Debt – Equity Ratio
Deposits form a major portion of liabilities for banks and are included in
the debt component of the debt – equity ratio. A debt – equity ratio of 50 times
is considered healthy for banks. Ratios of Raj Bank are below 50 times, which
is much below the acceptable limit and, therefore, has scope to increase the
debt component on their capital structure.
6.00 27
3) Advances to Assets:
20.00
Interpretation of the Advances to Assets
This ratio shows the total advances as a percentage of total assets, which
can give the capital adequacy of the firm. It shows the ability of firm to meet
18.00
capital need. Here, we see that Raj Bank has maintaining constant percentage
of advances to assets for last 4 years but in this year 2006 – 2007 it has
1
decrease by 1/3 almost.
28
16.00
4) G – Secs to Total Investments:
105.00
Interpretation of the G – Secs to Total Investments
investments.
100.00 29
2) A – ASSET QUALITY
The prime motto behind measuring the asset quality is to ascertain the
quality of assets and majority of ratios in this segment are related to non-
performing assets i.e. NPA. A credit facility is treated as past due when it
remains outstanding for 30 days beyond the due date. An NPA is defined
generally as a credit facility in respect of which interest or instalment of
principal is in arrears for two quarter or more. This segment contain following
ratio
30
1) Gross NPAs to Total Assets:
Gross NPAs are gross provisions on NPAs and Total Assets considered
are net of revaluation reserves.
7.00
Interpretation of the Gross NPAs to Total Assets
The quality of loan is one of the crucial aspects of that decide the health
of banks. This ratio indicates the percentage of gross NPAs to total assets.
Ratio does not give any tolerable or desirable limit. But it should be below 10
%. Going by this norm, the Raj bank has their entire ratio below 10 % which
shows that it has the lowest gross NPAs in relation to their total assets.
sets
6.00 31
2) Gross NPAs to Net Advances:
Net Advances are net of bills rediscounted and specific loan loss
provision.
0.40
Interpretation of the Gross NPAs to Net Advances
advances continue to remain at “ZERO” level for the last 15 years and it
0.35
become one of the only bank across the nation which has lowest level of gross
32
NPAs. Hence from this ratio only we can say that asset quality of Raj Bank is
of high-quality.
33
3) Total Investments to Total Assets:
16.00
Interpretation of the Total Investments to Total Assets
indicates the lack of credit off-take in the market. The Raj Bank has higher
investments in risk free securities which shows the lack of credit off-take and
14.00
further confirms the aggressive strategy in the disbursal of advances.
34
4) Percentage Change in Gross NPAs:
% CHANGE IN
55.82 27.53 65.63 - 55.52 9.86
NPAs
80.00
Interpretation of the Percentage Change in Gross NPAs
60.00 35
5
s
indicate great sign and stand ahead in the lowest gross NPAs level which is
great sign of evolution.
36
3) M – MANAGEMENT
37
1) Total advances to Total Deposits:
60.00
Interpretation of the Total advances to Total Deposits
persistently convert deposits into advances, this can be analysed from the chart
shown above.
38
50.00
2) Gross Profit per Employee:
GROSS PROFIT
715,123.03 700,058.61 653,572.56 657,858.43 845,796.47
PER EMPLOYEE
900,000.00
Interpretation of the Gross Profit per Employee
The gross profit per employees of Raj Bank decreases during the year
2004 – 2005 i.e. of Rs.653,572.56 relates to the past couple of year i.e. 2003 –
2004 of Rs.700,058.61 and 2002 – 2003 of Rs.715,123.03 which increases
800,000.00
gradually in 2006 – 2007 to Rs.845,796.47. A picture that show’s us a high
efficiency of the management of the Raj Bank.
yee
39
3) Net Profit per Employee:
270,000.00
Interpretation of the Net Profit per Employee
The net profit per employee ratio of Raj Bank remains constant of the
last few years which show the effective management of the bank which can be
observe from the chart and the figures quoted above.
260,000.00
40
ee
4) Business per Employee:
BUSINESS PER
27,784,684.50 32,503,223.59 34,558,640.65 40,566,072.49 48,205,846.27
EMPLOYEE
60,000,000.00
Interpretation of the Business per Employee
41
50,000,000.00
e
42
5) Return on Net Worth (RONW):
7.00
6
Interpretation of the Return on Net Worth (RONW)
This ratio expresses the net profit in terms of net worth. This ratio is an
important yardstick of performance for equity shareholders since it indicates
the return on the funds employed by them. As we see that the net worth of the
Raj bank increases and the net profit averagely remain same, the RONW goes
down but than also Raj Bank maintained the dividend pay of 15 % for the last
15 years.
6.00
43
h
4) E – EARNINGS QUALITY
44
1) Operating Profit by Average Working Funds:
3.50
Interpretation of the Operating Profit by Average Working Funds
funds for Raj bank is 2.22 in 2005 – 2006 which is decreased continuously
from 2002 – 2003 i.e. of 3.30 and stable around 2.00 to 2.50 . This is an
45
3.00
encouraging trend. The income is fund based it comes from investments rather
than advances.
46
2) Net Interest Margin (NIM):
NET INTEREST
3.67 3.38 2.95 3.00 3.89
MARGIN (NIM)
4.50
Interpretation of the Net Interest Margin (NIM)
Net interest margin of Raj bank is also shows a steady decrease. The efficient
and prudent asset liability management enables the bank to maintain the interest
spread. The net interest margin in 2004 – 2005 is 2.95 from that of 3.67 in 2002 –
2003 which again taken the momentum and reach to 3.89 in 2006 -2007.
4.00 47
3
3) Net Profit to Average Assets:
50.00
Interpretation of the Net Profit to Average Assets
45.00
utilisation of assets in generating revenue. The Raj Bank over the last couple of
48
4
ts
years not able to utilise their assets as effectively as they where in the past
years, which can be seen from the chart and figures arrived on.
49
4) Percentage Growth in Net Profit:
% GROWTH IN
10.80 10.13 2.31 1.20 15.84
NET PROFIT
18.00
Interpretation of the Percentage Growth in Net Profit
The percentage growth in net profit for Raj Bank in 2005 – 2006 is only
of 1.20 relates to the other preceding years i.e. of 10.13 in 2003 – 2004 and of
10.80 in 2002 – 2003. This shows that the net profit is decreases comparatively
16.00 50
very highly but it has U –turn in 2006 – 2007 reaches 15.84 which give the
enormous quality of earnings of the bank.
51
5) Non – Interest Income / Total Income:
16.00
Interpretation of the Non – Interest Income / Total Income
14.00
amount of deposits with RBI and advances.
tal
52
6) Interest Income / Total Income:
96.00
Interpretation of the Interest Income / Total Income
94.00 53
5) L – LIQUIDITY
54
1) Liquid Assets / Demand Deposits:
This ratio measures the ability of a bank to meet demand from demand
deposits in a particular year. Liquid assets include cash in hand, balance with
RBI, balance with other banks (both in India and abroad), and money at call
and short notice.
7.00
Interpretation of the Liquid Assets / Demand Deposits
osits
6.00
55
5
Bank, the ratios indicate that liquid assets are able to meet demand for demand
deposits. Thus it indicates better liquidity situation.
56
2) Liquid Assets / Total Deposits:
60.00
Interpretation of the Liquid Assets / Total Deposits
57
liquidity situation of Raj Bank is quite good, they can cope up with the total
deposits which can be seen from the above chart and figures.
58
3) Liquid Assets / Total Assets:
20.00
1
Interpretation of the Liquid Assets / Total Assets
18.00
that liquidity situation of Raj Bank is quite good; that’s why they are able to
meet with the total assets shown in the above chart.
ssets
59
16.00
4) G – Secs / Total Deposits:
This ratio measures the proportion of risk free liquid assets invested in
G-Secs as a percentage of the assets held by a bank and is arrived at by
dividing investment in government securities by total assets.
16.00
Interpretation of the G – Secs / Total Deposits
14.00
suddenly decrease almost half i.e. to 6.59 in 2006 – 2007.
60
ts
5) Approved Securities / Total Assets:
35.00
Interpretation of the Approved Securities / Total Assets
30.00 61
gradually decrease as shown in the figures stated above and reach to NIL for
the past couple of year.
62
CONCLUSION & FINDINGS
1. Capital Adequacy
Raj Bank has always maintained the healthy and stable margin of ratios
in this segment. Then also they are not increasing the debt components in their
capital structure. Although the bank is able to taps the market and went ahead
with their equity offering. This inherent strength of the bank is evident in their
capital structure.
2. Asset Quality
Raj Bank has continue to maintain the “Zero” level in Net NPAs to Net
Advances for last 15 years and it become the only bank having the lowest
Gross NPAs level across the nation, these shows that the asset quality of the
bank is too much sound.
3. Management
From the ratio it can be observed that the management of the Raj Bank
varies widely. Even though there is a decrease in their gross profit per
employee with the increase in the employee but than also there is great
combined effort of employee which has shown the effective and efficient
management of Raj Bank which can be noted from their dividend declaration
of 15 % for last 15 years to their equity shareholders.
63
4. Earning Quality
Raj Bank has increased their investment in total SLR and Non-SLR as
per RBI norms. This also shows that effective utilisation of investment is their,
as their investment is in risk free securities which help them to concentrate over
their lending.
5. Liquidity
Liquidity shows the ability of the firm to meet its current obligation
when they become due for payment. The liquidity position of Raj Bank is too
strong to meet their obligations. Raj Bank has efficiently maintained their
liquidity position for last few years.
Perhaps, more important is the innovative spirit of Raj Bank that turns
challenges into opportunities over the last 25 year of their performance. These
gives the competent and willingness to scale the new height in the years to
come.
64
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Books:
65