Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Save to My Library
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion to Dismiss

Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion to Dismiss

Ratings: (0)|Views: 867 |Likes:
Published by GothamSchools.org

More info:

Published by: GothamSchools.org on Apr 26, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

04/26/2011

pdf

text

original

 
SUPREMECOURTOFTHESTATEOFNEWYORKCOUNTYOFNEWYORKLISASTEGLlCH,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofALEXANDERHERLllIY,infant,RICCHERWIN,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofMARLEYCHERWIN,infant,CAROLBARKER,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofOMARIBROWN,infant,GINADEMETRIUS,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofSEBASTIANDEMETRIUS,KIMBERLYJARNOT,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofMARGARETTHOMAS,infant,NYDIAJORDAN,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofHARRYD.JORDAN,infant,KAVERYKAUL,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofASHOKKAUL,infant,RUBENandGERALDINELOPEZ,individuallyandasparentsandnaturalguardiansofSHANELOPEZ,infant,MADELINEOLMEDA,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofCRISTINAJULLIACRUZ,infant,LAZARAQUINONES,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofDORISALCANTARA,infant,andMARILYNNSARJEANT,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofALIYACLUNIE,infant,Petitioners,-against-THEBOARDOFEDUCATIONOFTHECITYSCHOOLDISTRICTOFTHECITYOFNEWYORKaJkIaTHEPANELFOREDUCATIONALPOLICY,THEDEPARTMENTOFEDUCATIONOFTHECITYOFNEWYORK,andDENNISM.WALCOTT,asChancellor-DesignateoftheCitySchoolDistrictoftheCityofNewYork,Respondents,-and-UPPERWESTSUCCESSACADEMYCHARTERSCHOOLa/k/aSUCCESSACADEMYCHARTERSCHOOL,MATTHEWMOREY,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantsTHOMASMOREYandCLAIREMOREY,MARTINAARES,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantSABINEBALOU-AARES,GABRIELBAEZ,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantCHRISTOPHERBAEZ,LISBETHDELOSSANTOS,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantMIYAHMUZO,ELANAKILKENNY,individuallyandasarentandnaturalguardianofinfantLIAMKILKENNY,IndexNo.1
04300/11
lASPart29(Torres,J.)
MEMORANDUMOFLAWINSUPPORTOFMOTIONTODISMISSARTICLE78PETITION
ARNOLD
&
PORTERLLPStewartD.AaronEmily
A.
KimNatalieWalkerGracePickeringDanielleMiller399ParkAvenueNewYork,NewYork10022(212)715-1000
AttorneysforProposedIntervenor-Respondents
 
ELISSAKLEIN,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantAVAKLEIN,REBECCAKUHAR,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantROBERTMAXWELLKUHAR,LATISHASINGLETARY,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantRANIYAGARRETT-WELLS,MICHAELSUCHANEK,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantsSALLYSUCHANEKandAMELIASUCHANEK,andDAVIDTURNOFF,individuallyandasparentandnaturalguardianofinfantHUNTERKIM-TURNOFF,ProposedIntervenor-Respondents.
 
TABLEOFCONTENTS
TABLEOFAUTHORITIESiiPRELIMINARYSTATEMENT1FACTS3A.SuccessAcademy3B.Co-locationintheBrandeisCampus7C.Petitioners'LawsuitandProposedParentandInfantIntervenors9D.CommunitySupportforSuccessAcademy10ARGUMENT11I.THECOMMISSIONERHASEXCLUSIVEORIGINALJURISDICTIONOVERTHISMATTER11II.THECOURTSHOULDDISMISSTHISPROCEEDINGFORFAILURETOEXHAUST12
A.
PetitionersFailedtoExhaustUnderCPLRArticle78'sExplicitExhaustionRequirement13B.PetitionersFailedtoExhaustbyNotAppealingWithintheAllottedTime18C.TheAbsenceofanExhaustionRequirementWouldDefeatthePurposeofCPLR2853(3)(a-5)'sExpeditedAppealsProcessforCo-locationDisputes20III.INTHEALTERNATIVE,THECOURTSHOULDDISMISSTHISPROCEEDINGUNDERTHEDOCTRINEOFPRIMARYJURISDICTION21IV.EVENIFTHECOURTWERETOREACHTHEMERITS;THEPETITIONMUSTFAIL,ASTHEEDUCATIONALIMPACTSTATEMENTANDTHEBUILDINGUSAGEPLANCOMPLYWITHSTATUTORYREQUIREMENTS22A.TheProperStandardofReviewisSubstantialCompliance23B.TheDOEProperlyDeterminedthattheBrandeisCampusWasUnder-Utilized,26C.TheEISandtheBUPComplywithStatutoryRequirements27CONCLUSION30
-1-

Activity (3)

You've already reviewed this. Edit your review.
1 hundred reads
1 thousand reads

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->