You are on page 1of 29

c

c
c
c
c

c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c
c 
c 

 c

cc

 c c 
 c
cc

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
c

c cc
c c   c c
!
  c   c
c"c#
cc
$c
Vishnuprasad Nagadevara, Vasanthi Srinivasan & Reimara Valk

Abstract

Employee turnover is a serious concern in knowledge based organizations. When


employees leave an organization, they carry with them invaluable tacit knowledge which
is often the source of competitive advantage for the business. In a rapidly growing sector
like the Indian software industry employee turnover poses risk and challenges for
organizations. This research explores the relationship of withdrawal behaviors like
lateness and absenteeism, job content, tenure and demographics on employee turnover.
The unique aspect of this research has been the use of five predictive data mining
techniques on a sample data of 150 employees in a large software organization. The
results of the study clearly show a relationship between withdrawal behaviors and
employee turnover. Age and marital status emerged as key demographic variables. The
findings of this study have implications for both research and practice. There is a need to
expand the scope of this research to include multiple organizations and a large sample,
which will allow for more robust predictions. For practitioners, it emphasizes the need
for greater use of models and analytical tools in engaging with human resource strategies
and plans, and in particular that HR professionals will need to understand, appreciate
and apply such models in future to be able to perform their roles as strategic business
partners.

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
r %&#'(r& c
r c c  c  c  c   c 
c  c c  
 c c c c  c
c


c 
 c  c  
 c c  
c 
c 

c   c !" c 

c

# 
 c 
c  c  c c 
$  c c 
c  c   c c c   c c  
c
 c  c
cc
c

c   c%c&''(c) c c!  c&''*c)  c
c+
c&''c, c  c c c cc
 c c

 c c  ccccc
c  c
 c "c c c  c c
 c  
 c c c -
 c
  .c
/c  
c

c

c c
 
c c cc

 c  c
 c
c c c" c
# 
 c

/c   c c c c r 


c  c
 c
c c  c 0 c c 0c c
 1  c*crc
c 
 c cc
 ccc2cr/c
  c c&(c

 c
)%3c  c"c&c/c4
 cc5 
c  
c
 c$ 

c c

c
"

c
c

c
c c   "

c cc  c 
"ccc ccr 
c c c
c r/c 
 c  
c  

 c ¯ c 6c 0 c c  c c  c 
  c

 c 
c c

c  
c   c
c c  c
 c " c c 
 c +
c c
 
c  c
 c "  c cc cc   c  c c r 
c  c  
 c
 c c c c


 c r/c 
 c  c  c c c 0c c 
c  c  c c
 c
c c
 c  c
cc
 c0c c c 
 cc c c
c  c
 c
cr 
cc"c
c 
c c 2c c 6c c  c  
c c    c c + c r/c 
  c  c c

# 
 c c  c c  c c c 
 "c c
  c c 1c "c c 
  c
  c  c  c 

#c 
 c  
c  c c    
c c 

c "
 c
 
 c c
 
 c   c
cc7c c)ccr c 

 c c c
c c

c c
c
c
c c c
c  c cc
 cc
  c ccc
cccr c c
  c c "

c c c 
 c c    c c 

 c   c  c
c "
c c c
$
 c

/ c   c  c c 


c c

c  
"c c
 
"c   c c c  cc 
c  
 c

c  c
 c 
# 
 c  c 8 c c  c &c /c  
"c   c c "c c  cc


c c  c c 
 c c 
 c   c 1  c 
c 
"c c  c

c $ 
c " c   c c  c  c  c  c 7c 9 :; c c +

 c
(c c  c c  c 

c c  c c  c  c c c  c c c 

 c 

c
  c
c c 
 "c  c
c c   c*c<c c

c 


 c c c
c
c c  c  c  c c  c 
c c c 
 c "c  c  c
 
c c c c 
# 
 c 7
 c &c !
 c c   c c c c r 
c  c

 cc c  c c   c
c
c
 c c 
# 
 cc   c 
c c  c
c  c /c  c c  

 c  c c    c  c   c c " c
 c
c c  c  4c 0
 
 c c   c 

c 
$ c c " 
 c
 c  c " c
  "
c"cc  c  c&'''c¯    c(cc

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
/c cc
c c
cc  c c  cc c
c"
cc
cc c

cc  c
 c
cr 
c
c  c

c
$ cr cc  cc
c
 
 
 c
 c 
c c  c  

c c    
c c   c  c  c  c c  c c



  c 
# 
 c 
  c <
c 

c  c 
c  c " c  c c    c c
   c c   c  c c c /c  c c  c  c
c 
c c


 c
 
"c c "c    c c    c c  c c  c   c c 

 c c

  c c  c  c  c 
c   c  c c  c c  c  c 
c 
 c
"c
c

"&' %)c'% &"%c&*c+&)c

5c  c


c c 
c   c    c /c  c " c c  c "c c 
 c
  c 8c = 
c c ! c &''c c  c 
c  c 
c "1c 7c 9 c ; c c
+

 c(c,cc
c c
 c c  cccc cc c9c
c 7
c &''(c )c c , c *c  c  c  "c  c
c  c c c  
c c
 
   c  c c
# 
 c  c c c cc c  c 
c c

c c c c

c cc cc c c c" c c  "c
 c c c c"

c 
 
 c ccc1"c 
 
 c5c c

c c  
 c c  c 
 c  
 c   c

c 1"c 

 
 c 7"c &'**c /c c
7c &''>c  c c 
# 
 c 
 c %c ; 
 c c 
c &'*6c /c c 7c &''>c
c 
 "

c c  
c 1" c 79 
c &''&c )#c ) c c =c &''(c   c
 c "c ; 
c *c  c  c c    c c  c
c c r 
c  c
 c c
   
c c  
   c  c 
c  c 

c  c c  c 
 c


 c  c c c   
c  c  
c  
 c    c 1"c 

 c
 c c 
cc  c"cc
 cr c  c c cc-1"c

.c c" c c
 c"cc c c  c 

  c

9 "c  c  
" c ?
  " c c 7 :¯
c &'''c 
# 
 c c  
 c
 c 

 c c  
 c   c 7 :¯
c &c c $
c 0$
c
!
c 0 c c ,c &''*c c   c c  c
c   c  c +
  c " 
 c 
c
   c c "  
c c  cc"c c" 
 cc  c c
c

è 
  





/c c 

 c c  c "  
c c    c  c " c c c c

  c" 
 c c c" c 
c"cc 
 c/ c
c@Ac

 cc c



 . c  c " 
c 
c c 
# 
 Bc 9c &''*C'*c  
 c  c  c 
c
"  
c cc @A
cc c c cBc = c &''2C&cc @A c


 . c  c c

 c   c c c 
 c  
 c c 
c  c c
c c 
c 4 
 c c 
c c c c "c
Bc7 
c c, 
 c&''>Cc2'c9   c
c
c cc@Ac  cc ccc

c c c c c c  
c 
Bc 0c c ! c &'&C2((c /c 
  c " c c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
c 
 cc
  c " 
 c c " cc
 c c    cr c 
 c c 
 c
 
c  c 
  c 
c  c c 
c  c 
 c  c c c 
 c    c c
c 
 c  c c c "  c c
c c= c&''2c c
c
 c9 

c

 c "c +
c )c ?  #c c <
" c &'c c  c &'c  c c    : "  c

 c c 0c c ! c &'&c c ?  #c ?  c c 5
c &''c 
c c ) c
&''(c c c  cc

c
c   c c c 
c
c c "  c

cc
c&c c
c  c 
 c c c
 cc "  cc c; "c c) c
&'c c&'c?  #cc c&''crcc
 c c
c4
 c c  

 c
cc
4cc 
 
c" c   c c "  
c "  
c c cc"c  c c
c  
 
c " c    c c  c /c  c 
c 
 c c 
c  
 c
?# c c  c &''*c c c c  
 cc(c " c    c c "  c c
7
 cc c&''cc cc 
 cc>>c" c "  c c c?# c c
 c &''*c  
 c c  c  
 c " c    c c  c  c c "c *c c  c
" c   c c c   c
cc  c c c c
 
 cc"c*c= c
&''2c


   



  
%  c 
c 
" c c" c
cc c "  c
 c<c
 c 
 c c
  c c c c c;c&'>c c 
 cc, c9  c c  c&'&c c
 c c 

c c 
 c c "  
c/c 
 c c c
 cc  
c  
" c

c c c c c 
 c c
  c" 
 c c" c "
 c c 
 c c
c c

c 
 
c" c "  
c c 
 cc c c c c  c
&''2c r c c 
c c 
 c  c  c  c  c 
  c 9 c %    c 8 
c c
5
c&'*cc c  c c  c  

 cc c 
c cc c
 c
c

 c  
 
c c  c
c c . c c 3c  c c  c 
c c  c c

# 
 c c c c c 
 c cc$ 
 
c
 c c c  c
c
c


 c
cc  c cr cc c c
 c
c
 
 cc1
c
 c c c 
c  c c  c c 
# 
 c r c 
c   c  c c r/c
 c
c r 
c
01 c;" c? c7
c c!c*c c c c c c"c


 cc c
 c
 
 c ! c c  
 c   c  c 
c c c  c
 
 c ,c  
 c
  cc"c c
 c 
"c
cc 4cccr 
c  c
 c0c "cc
 c c c
c c c c c  
c c c
c   c c1" cc
 c c c 

 c ; c c
c 
c
c 4 

c c  
 
c " c  
c
 
" c
c c c 
 c   c c c
cc 4cccr 
c  c
 c




/c 
 
c" c c c c
c
# 
 c
c c c  "
c,c c
   c7"c&'**c
c cc"cc" c
c
cc c/ c   c
 c
c  c   c "c  c 4 
 c c 
 
 c c c  
 c   c
54 
 cc"c  c c c
 cc  

c+  c&''c/
cc"c"  c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
c c c
c  c1"c4
  c
c c1"c4
  c
cc
# 
 c9
c
&'c, c
cc4
 c  cc
 cc c
c c c c c
c c1"c
4
  c c c c 4 
 c  c
c 
c /
c    c
c  c c "c c


 c  c c c
ccr/c
 c
cr 
c 
c>c
c

  

/c  c 
 c
 c
cr 
c
c  
#c"cc4
 cc c  c  c1 c
c " c 
  c / c  c 1 c c c c  c c  
c $
c
   
c c c 
 c 4 
 c / 

 c r 
c 
 c  c " c   c  c
c
c c  c 
 c c c 
c c 

c   
#c 
 c 8
c c  c  c
 c  c r 
c 
# 
 c  c c c c  c 
c ¯ c 6c "c 

c 
c
 c 
 c c c
c c 
 c$
c cc  c cc c
cc
 
 c c  c c c c 
c  c /c c c c c c c  c "c c
c
cc
# 
 c c c
 c c cr c c

 c ccc c
c
cr/c
 c
cr 
c 
c>c
 

cc
ccc c ccc  cc c
 
c c 
# 
 c / c 
# 
 c
c
c 

 c  c 
c c  
 c
c  ccc c
c c c
cc4
 cc  cc c
c

·

  ! 

r c
 c  4 c 
c c 4
 
c 
c   c c c c  c c c c 
c
 "c  c c r c c  c cc  c
 c
c r 
c c   c  c 

ccc c
 c c c
 
 c
c


 c c  c  c c  c  
 c  c 
c 1"c
 c/c  
c 4
c "c c
c c 1"c 
c
 c 
c  
c
c c
# 
 c
/
c c
c c
cc c
 c,c
c
c c1 cc c"cc$ c
c

c c  c
c  c
 c c
c
c 
c  c c c 4 c   c c  c 
c c


 c 
c c c  cc c c  

c c 
 c
c c c
 
c
c 
# 
 c
c 
c c c 
c c "c c r c   c c  c c  c

# 
 c cc
c c c
  c
c
cc 
c
cc  c 
 c
cc
 c c
c  c 
 c c  c c  c c c 


c
c c


cc c
cc 
" c
c c
 c  c c1"c   c c


c  c c 
 c  
 c , c c 0c c  
 c 1
c c 
# 
 c c
- 
c .ccc  cc4
 c
  c
c 
ccc
# 
 c c
cc 4c
c  
c c c  c " c c  c c "
c 
c
c
c 
c  c c 
 c  c

c c
c
ccc1"c c c
c  c
c/c c4 
 c c"
c
cc
- 
c .cc 
c c
c c c$ cc1"c  c
c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c
Figure 1
A Model Framework on the Relationship between Attrition and Behavioral Variables

<
c&c
 c cc c
c
 c"c  c 4 c c  c 
" cr c
 
c  c  
" c  c "c " 
 c   c c c c  4c c  c c 1"c   c


 c c c c c  
 c c c 1"c c 3 c c c c 
c  
" c c
 c
c
  c" 
c
c
c

 c"c "  
c c   c/c1"c  c
 c
ccc

 c ccc
 c
cc
# 
 c cccc
c4
c/c

 c 
c  

 c c c c c 
 c   c/
c  cc
c c
c  "
cc
 c" c c c
  c" 
c c c
  c cc  c
 c c
c c c c
 c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c
c
c c
,&#&&-)c

  
"
 
 
/c c
cc cc ccc c
cc cc  c cc c c
c c 
c 
c c  c c c 
c c 
c c c 0 c c c  c
c c
ccc c ccc c cc cc c 
 c/c c c
c
 c*cc c3 c c
ccc c c 
c cc    cc 
c c

c c>cc c c "cc  c/c  c cc4
 c c 
c c c
c
  c 
c c  c 4
 c 

c c  c 
c c  c c   c /c  c
4
 c

cc c c c 
cc c&c  c
c
c  c c cc
  c c
c c
 c /c  c 
c
c c  c 

 c  c  c  c &c   c /
c
 

 c

  c c
 cc"c 
c cc 
c
c c"
cc
 c
1"cc "c c
ccc    c c  c c c c c
c1"c

 c c
r c  c
c   c  c c  c
c c c c  c c
c c  
c 
c
 c c 

c
cc c cc c  "c c
c

# 


/c c c c
c   c  c 
 "c
cc 
 ccc
# 
 c/c  c c
c cc"
cc c  c c c c cc&2c c c4 c
cc ccc c/c  cc 
 

cc
 
 cc  c cc
  c 
 c c c  c c c c c   c r c c c  

 c  
 
 c c c
 c ccc c
 c c
$c
 

 
 c "c

0cc4
 c c 
" cc 
#crc c" c c$
:c"

c/c ccc
c c 
c c c  cc "
c /c c 
c   c c   c  c 

c  c c

c 
 c 
 c c  c c
 
c   c
c c   c 
c c  c
4c   c /c

c c
 
c
c c
 
c  ccc c c

 cc

cc
c
c c  c
4c   c + c c c  c c c  c c   c c
4c   c 
c c
 
c c  c  c  c

 c 
c c  c c
 
c   c
c   c
c 
 c

 c cc

/c  c 


c
c 
c  c

c
$ c
cc

cc  c
c

c c 
c
  c  c c


 c
c  c c c c"
c/c c c
c
cc

c  c
c c  c c c  c c
c  c 
c c  
c   c /c 
c "1
c c c
  
 cc

c c 
c   c
cc c c cc cc
c c"c 

c
cc 
c  c
c c 
 c  c c c   
 cc"c
"ccc "cc
"  
 c
c  c  c c c c c 4c r c c   c  c c c   c  c c c


c cc cc 
c"  cc  c 
c c c

c "cc"  
 c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c



 

/c
c  cc"
cccc Cc

3c 8 cc"
c

3c ! c

3c 7 
 c   c

3c / c  ccc4


 c
cc 
 c

3c 7  cc4
 c
cc  c c
cc 
 c

3c 7  cc4
 c
cc c c
cc 
 c

3c 7  cc4
 c
cc c

 c
cc 
 c

3c /cc

 c
c c
cc c
c
4c 
 c

3c /cc  c


c4
c

3c <$ cc1"c c


c1

cc  c c
cc 
 c

3c 7 c
c cc  c c
cc 
 c

3c 7 c
c cc

c c
cc 
 c

3c 7 c
c  c c 
 c
c cc
cc 
 c

 
<
c
 c

 c cc c c  cc
c c c cc/cc
c 
 
 cc 
 c  c

c
$ cc
cc c/c c c c



c  c  c 

c 
 c 

 
 c c 
 c  c 

 
 c  c
;2c c


c 
c
0


c¯ c¯ c0¯¯c

/c0¯¯ c c  c" c cc  ccc cc"



 c  c c

cc
 c 
c c
 c "c c 
c   c /c 0¯¯ c c  c c c 
c
 c cc  c cc
 c/c  c  ccc  c cc
 c  c
cc
 c" c  c/c0¯¯c  cc  cc
 c
c c c c
c  c/
c
c c  c
c  c c c c c
c  c / c
c   c c  c 

c "c c c c
" c  c c c
 c c c c
cc
 c/ c  c c

 
 c c c
cc"c
 ccc cc  c c ccc
ccc
c  c/
c cc  c
c
  ccc cc
 c c7 c0¯¯ c 
c
c
 c  c c
c
cc
4c c<
cc  cc c
 c c cc
c cc cc c 
c 
c
c 
c 
 c
c 
c cc 
c "c
c ccc

 c

/c0¯¯c
c c"c  
cc c
c
 cc c c cc
c  c
  c <c 4 c c   c  c c
c c  
 c c c 
 c c 
 c c c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c

c
c c
c  c / c   c c c
c c 
 c  c c c 
c "c
"

c  c   c 
c 
c 
 c c 

 c
c  c c c c  c rc c


 c  c "cc 0¯¯c   c
cc  c   c   cc c c  c 
c c c
 cc c cc

 c
cc cc0¯¯c ccc 4ccrcc

 c
c
 c cc4 ccc4 c
c 
 c  c
c 
 c" c
cc
 c cc

 c  cr cc cc  ccc
 c c c
cc c c
cc
 c  c c


c " c  c c 4 c c c
c 

 c /
c  c
c c c c c "  c
  
 c/c 


c  c  c c cc"c
c
c
c   c 
 
 c
0¯¯ c  c " c 
c
c  c 
c
 
 c c c  c c
 
c c  c c  c c
 
 c4  c¯    c(c
c
 c c 
 
c; 
c&''c¯    cc

0c  c c &(c  


" c c  c c "
c c 0¯¯ c c 

c c c  c / c c
c


 ccc  c 
"c
c
c c 
c 
"c

 
cccc
c 
c

c c  c c  c c c  c 7 c  c c   
 c  
 
 c c $ 
 c
c"cc0¯¯ c c4c c c 
 "ccc c0 c c c c c c c" c
"4 c cc"c cc"
cc

 c  c¯ c
c
c
 cc cc 
c

 c c  c c c  
" c
c 

c c  
 c /c  c  c c "
c c 0¯¯ c

 cc 


ccc

 c
c cc ccc 
" c c
c c"c
c c c


 ccc 
c
 ccc 
" c
c$ 
 c

Logistic Regression

9

c
 c
c c 

#ccc
 c cc
c c4
c c 
 c  c
 
"c rc  c " c  c c   c  
"c
c c "
c  
 c  
"c /c 
 c
$ 
 c c
c c

 c c c 
c 
 c $ 
 c 
c 
 c 
c 

  c

c4
cc
 cc ccc
  c 
" c
c

cc ccc  c
 
"c 3 c 
c   c c 

c 
 c
c  c
c
c c  
c "c c  
c

 c
c
c c"
c 
 c
cc
 c 
c/
c
$c c  c  c
 c 
c  
" c c c 
c c  
 c  
" c "c 
c c
c c  
" c
0 c   cc

c
 c
c c
c
c
 cc" "

cc c c
c
r ccc c c cc  c 
"c
c
cc" "

c
c" c" c#c c
 cc

c
 c
 c c 
 
c" cc  c c
  c 
" c c
 " c c :  c c
c  c c
 
c  c c  
 c c - c 
.c  c c c


  c/
c  c
cc cc c-

.c 
 c
c

cc$ 
 c c c
cc
c c $  c  c c c 
 c 
c /c   c  
"c
c 
c c c - c
 
.c c c 

c "  
 c " 
c c c  
 c c c  c r c  c  c 

c

 c 
  cc" "

c
c

r ccccc" c

 c  ccc

c
 c
c
c
 cc c 
 c
 
" c c
  c 
" crc
c  c
 cc
cc 
c 
" c 
c c
 c c c  c
c c $
c "c c c  
" c / c c  c c  
#c
 
" c
cccc

c
"c
cc cc

c
 c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c
*lassification and Regression Trees (*ART)

;

 
 c c
 c/ c;0/c
c ccc c cc"

c

 
 c c
;0/c   c"
 c c"
cc"c 

cc"  
 c c c c" c c c
c 
"cc
 
"c ;0/c   c c  c  c !

c r 4c c
 

c c " c 
c rc c 
c  c c



 ccc

cc c
 c cc"c cc cc 

c
c c c
c c
c "c c c c c+ c cc  c"c c  ccc
cc c0cc
 ccc 
 cccc c cc"  
 c c" c
 cc c c c5 c c
 c c"c
 cc c 
 c c c c  
cc c/cc c cc c c
c

c"cc  cc


 
 c cc c c/cc ccc 
cc
cc

c cccc  cc cc c  c
;

 
 c/ c;2c

r c c  c c ;2c 



 
 c  c c 

c c c  c c  c c
c  c " c  c c

 
 c 
c 5 c
c  c c  c c
 
 c 
c c  c c /
c c  c
  c c
c 
"c "cc"  c c c c<c4 c c c
c 
"c
c
c c c 
"c c 

c c c "c  c " c c  c  c c c 
"c /c
 
 cccc 
 cc c  c c "
ccc c  c cc cc 
 
 cc
c  c cc

 ccc;0/cc

Discriminant Analysis

8


c 
c
c ccc c c  

 c
$ ccc  c 
"c
c
 
 cc 
c
c c cc
  c 
" c c
cc 
c 
" crc
 c


c c 
cc#: c
c
c c
 c"

 ccccc
  c 
" c c
c



c " c " c c c c 
 c  
 c c  c /c 


c 
c

 c  
c  c c c 


c  
 c c c c  4

c c  
c " c c
 
 c  
c c c  
c 
c c  
 c /c #:  c   c 
c c 


c
 
 cc"c cc 
 cc" "


 c c c 
 c"cc"  
 c"  cc c
 
 c  c rc
c
 c  c c
  c  
" c  c
c 


c 
c c
 
 cc 
c
c c0
cc  
" c  c
c  
 
cc 


c  
 c
cc

c 
" c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
%'c
/ "c&c  
 cc
 
 c
c cc ccc&(c 
" c cc"

cc0¯¯ c
/c 
 c  c c  c
c "

c c 0¯¯ c c c 
 "c c c  c 3 c c c  c c
 c cc"
cc0¯¯ c 
 cc c 


c 
c"c"
cc  cc ccc
 
" c c 
cc  c
 c cc  ccc

 c) c c
c 


c

cc 
c
 cc ccc 
" c c
ccc
c  c c  c
c
/ "c&c/ccc
c c
 c 
" c  cc"c" 
 c 
" c c

c c
 c c c 
 c cc
c
 c.c
%
 c 
c"c
c
ccc
c

c"c c

"  c %


 c 
c

Privilege leave used (Binned) 0.148577

Current position in the company (Binned) 0.146736

Current technical expertise 0.146736

Late arrival at the office (Binned) 0.144292

Experience in the company (Binned) 0.082996

Total experience (Binned) 0.078281

Domain experience 0.071921

Casual leave used (Binned) 0.069042

Total number of job changes 0.034097

Marital status 0.025611

Gender 0.014790

Age (Binned) 0.010350

Experience in the current position (Binned) 0.004343

Experience in the current team (Binned) 0.003620

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
 cc
"  cc
c$
c

"  c c /0 1c

Age (in years) .762 2.142

Gender -.770 .463

Marital status 1.699 5.470

Total experience in years -.984 .374

Experience at the company .263 1.300

Experience in the current Team -.461 .631

Experience in the current position -.334 .716

Total number of job changes -.459 .632

Casual leave used .410 1.506

Privilege leave used -.119 .888

Late arrival at the office -.262 .769

( 
c
c0 1c c c

Current position binned(1) -.828 .437

Current position binned(2) .623 1.865

Current position binned(3) -.409 .664

Current position binned(4) -2.318 .098

Current position binned(5) 3.612 37.035

Constant -14.489 .000

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
c

/c 
" c c
c"

cc

c
 c cc  
c

  c c  c
c
/ "c c 0 c / "c c    c c  c c 
 c 

  c "c  c
 c 4  
c  c /c
 
c
 c c 
 c  
" c c c - c  
.c  c "c"
c 
c c/ "c c /c

: $ c 

"
 c
c  c c  c c  

 c


 c c c 

c 
 c c /c
  c cc
: $ cccc
c6&*'c
c&6c ccc

 
c cc
c



 c c /c 
c  
" c c $ 
 
c  
" c  c
c c 

c 
 c c
  c   c
c / "c c /c " 
 c  
"c c   c  c  c
c  c c c  c

 c 
" cc

c c

/c

 
 c c
 c cc" c
c 
cc"
c 
" c, cc  c c
c "
cc 

 
 c c 
 cc
c 
c
c c cc "
c  c c 
c   c /c
  cc
c  c
c<
ccrc c"c  cccc c4
 c
cc c c
c
 ccc
 c
 c¯c c
c   c cccccc"c
c  c  c
c cc
c c ccc"  c

 cc 
c
 cc
 c 
" cc"c  cc
cc" c c
c 
 c
ccc

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
Figure 2
*lassification and regression tree diagram

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
;

 
 c / c ;2c  c c " c 
c c 
c c "
c  
" c /c c  c

c c 

 
 c c ;2c c
c   c
c <
c >c 3 c  1c 
 c " c c
;0/c c c 

 
 c  c
c  c 

 
 c  c c 
c "  c c c 
 c c
c c;0/c  c c"
c 
 c/
c
c
 c c¯c(c9c>ccc

 
 ccr c
c  c c 

 
 c  c  c 4
 c
c c  c  c   c c "c  c c c
 c
  c
c

c c/c  cc c 
 c cc
c   cc"c ccc
 c

 c  c 

 
 c  c /c 

 c  c c c 

 
 c  c
c ((c c
 c 
c
c c

 c c  c c c ;0/c /c 

 c  c c c 

 
 c c
c
 
c"c
c cc cc ccc c c cc;0/c/c

 c
 
 c c "c ;0/c c ;

 
 c / c c c

 c /
c
c c  4c 

c
 c "c c 
$ c c  c

 c 

 c "c 
c  c
c  c c 
 c c


c

c c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c
Figure 3
*lassification tree diagram (*5.0)

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c
c
c c
0 c 

 
 c 
$c  c c 

c  c
c c 


c 
c 3 c c c
 c  c   c c  

 c


 c c  
c c 
  c c c 


c
 
 c
c+
 .c9 " c/c  cc cc+
 .c9 " cc"c
cc



c "

c
cc 
 cr c
c 
 c cc cc+
 c9 " c
c*(c/c  

 c


 cc
+
 .c 9 " c
c  c "c  
c
c
c c 4
 
 c c c 
: $ c 

"
 c /c
  c ccc
: $ c
c
c 
 c c
c>**>c
c&c ccc

 
c c
c
ccc  

 c


 c

/c 

 c  c c c  c " c  c 


c 
c  c 'c c  c /c


 c c c  c 
c  c c c  c c  c c c 
# 
 c /c


  ccc   
#c


c 
 c c  c
c/ "c>crc c"c  cc/ "c
>c cc   
#c

  c
c ccc 
" c c c4
 c
cc c
  c c c c c 
 c cc
c c  
c/c  c 
"c
c
c 
 c

cc c-.cc cccc c c c-&.cc cc
c
cc c/ c
c
 c "c  c  c  c  
" c 
c c  
c 

  c  c c 

c  
 
c 
c
 c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c
 c2c

 3c(  c#   
c*
c(""
c

"  c (""


c

Age (in years) -1.437

Total experience in years 1.815

Experience at the company -.832

Experience in the current team .629

Experience in the current position .615

Current technical expertise .002

Total number of job changes .197

Casual leave used -.306

Privilege leave used .204

Late arrival at the office -.073

0 c  c
c / "c (c c 

 c  c "
c 
c c 0¯¯ c
c &6>c c  c 
c
c c

c  c c c 

 c  cc  cc c c  c D22(c c  Ec c  c
c c ccc cD'2*cc Ec+
cc0¯¯ c c "cc
c cc
c

cc c
c c  cccc c'cc cc  ccc

 c
c c
2'cc c
c cc cccc cr cc cc0¯¯ c c4 c
c
c


 c 
c  c c  c c 
c 
c c  c /c  c
 c

 c c


 c
cc  cc cc%

c c/
c
cc"cc c

 c
cc c
 c
 c4
c cc  cc c 
 c cc
crc
c c 

c cccc
c  c
 c

  c c c   c
c c " 
 c   c c c  c
  
c c
c
  c" 
 c c  c

  cc c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c
 c4c
+ 
c  c"c"" 
c
$cc5c
+ 
c
+ 
cc 

c "
c
c 
c"
c
c 
c
  c   c
Left the
82.93 17.07 100.00
company
(c678c
Not left the
9.43 90.57 100.00
company
Left the
80.49 19.51 100.00
company
(%c
Not left the
6.60 93.40 100.00
company
Left the

c  c 75.00 25.00 100.00
company
Not left the
The cut value is 0.700 18.63 81.37 100.00
company
Left the
58.54 41.46 100.00

" c c company

 c Not left the
9.43 90.57 100.00
company
Left the
86.84 13.16 100.00
#   
c company
 c Not left the
19.79 80.21 100.00
company

/ "c(c  c  cc



 c  c"
c"cc

c
 c
c*'2cc cr c

c

 c
 
 c c c 
 c 

 c
c c c c c  c c c  c 
 c
$ 
 c/c 4  
c  c c c 

 c
c 
c c "c c  c cc
 cc c
  
c
  c  
"c  c c - : 
.c /c   c

 c  c  
 c   c  c c

 c c c7 
cc c c
cc c c
 c

r c 

 c/ "c(c  cc

 c  ccc;

 
 c c
 c/c
c'cc
 c /c 

 c c c " c 
c  c c  c c  c c c c  c

 c


 ccc;

 
 c/ c;2c cc  c
c cc cc c ccc
 c3 cc

 c  
 ccc;

 
 c c
 c/ c c;

 
 c
/ c;2c cc

 cc cc

/ "c (c  
 c c 

 c  
 c c c c 
c 
$ c c c 

 cc 

 c
r  
c c c 
c 

 c 
$ c  c  c   "c  c  c 
c  c c
 c  c c 
c 
c c  c 3 c c c  c


c 
c c 
 c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c
c
 c  cc
c cc cc ccc c0


c  c  c c
c c c

c  c
c cc cc ccc c<cc . c
 
c
c
c
 cc
c cc c
cc cc cc  c c c
: 
c  
 c c "c


c c 


c c  c  c /c  c c "c
c c


 c c   c  c c c 
c c 
c c "c  
c c  c c
 
c c 
"c
  c c"cc c c cc
c

 c3 cccc

 
 c c c
;0/c  cc
cc" c  c
c cc

 c  c)c c
$ c c "cc

cc c
c c  ccc "ccc c0cc c
cc  c cc
 c
$ c
c cc cc
c
cc c c "c'cc c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
#r('r& c
/c 

 c c c 
c 

 c  c

 c  c "  
c c    c 1"c   c
 
 c c 4
 c
c c  c  c  c  c

 c c  c c  c 
 c c
 c /c c 
$c  4c 

c
 
 c c  c 

 c )c c 1"c   c


  c ccc

 c cccc
c4
cc
cc c c


 c
 
" c /c c c   c c 
c  
"c /c  c 
 c
 c
cr 
c   c c " c

  c
c c 
cc  c
c

c c" 
c 
 c  
c
c c 

c
/c  cc c

c  cc c
 c c   
#c   cr c c
  c c "c c c 
 c c


 c  c c 
c  c c 
c  c
 c   c
c r 
c /c  c  c r 
c c 

 c 
# 
 c c
c c
 
cc 
 c c
c/c  c
c c c c 
 c"
c
c
c  cc
$
c 4
 c  c c  
c c   c c 
c 

# 
 c
c  c c  c
/c1"c  c c c
c c c 
cc  cc
c c
c
c
"c c
c
c
# 
 c c c"c
cc c c
c
c  c  cc
# 
 c
 cc c  "c  c

 c
c
c c 
#c  c
c  
c c  
   c c  c c  c  c
 
 cc cc "c .c4 
 cc1" c cc
c/cc"c c cc
 c 4 
 c c c 1"c  c c   
c c c 
 c " c 
 c c 1"c   c
) 1c c  c  c c 
 c 
c  c   

c 4 
 c " c  c c
 c c c

# 
 c  c  c  c
c 


  c
c  c  
c  c c  c c 4 
 c
 
c c   
 c c c 

c c   c  c r c c  4c c r 
c  c

# 
 c c c  c "c c 1 c c 4c c   c 
  c c c "c c

 c" cc 
 c$
ccc1c cc4 
 cccc "cc
 c c"c c+ c c c1c c
cc cccc1 cc
c " c c
 c / c  c  c c  
c  c c
 c c c 

c c c
 cr c 
 c
cc1"c$
 c
c c c c cc c c c
4
c 9 c c  
c 4 
 c c c "c 

 c
c  c c  c   c   c c
4
 c c  c  cc c1"c   c cc  cc
# 
 c
cc c
 c cc c c c   
c 1"c 

c c  c r/c 
  c  c c  c  c
 c c c   
c 1"c c  c  c   c  
 c
c 

c 
c 1"c

 
 c  c c c /  c 6c !
 c c 
c " c  c c c   
c 1"c
 c  c 
c c c  c c
c  c c c 
c c " c " c 
c 
c
4
c c  c
 c c
ccc
c
cc c0   cc
/c c
c cc c c

 cc   
c1" c c 
cc
  c cc  c 
 c ccc c
c c
c 
 c

/c  
 c  
" c c c  
 c   c c  c 
 c c c  c /c
  c c  c  c  c c c 
c c  c  c c  c
c  c   c
/ c 

 c c
c 
c 
c c c  c   c  c   c  c "c ,
c c 0 
 c

c c c c    c   c c c   c
cc 
c"
 c c
 c
c1" c c c c
cc cc  c) 1cc/ccc c c c 
"c
c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
c r 
c  4c
c  
 c


 c/c r/c
 c  c " c

c c  c "c c c

  ccc  c7 cc c   c c
 c
cc   cc  cc
 c  

c4 
 ccc1"c cc
# 
 c/
c  

c4 
 cc
c
 
c c  "c 
 c c  
c  
 c  c c  
 c   "c c  crc
c
 c
c c c c  c
c c cc c4 
 c
c
c
 cc1" c54

c
  c c  c  c   c cc c
 c
c c c
c  c c c"c "cc
c c
c7 
 c   c c c

 c$
 c c 

 c4 
 c

/c cc  c


cc4
c
c

cr ccr 
c 4ccccc 
c
c
c c
 c c
  c c
c

 c
c c cc
cc cc
c
   c  c c c
c c c 
c+
c c

c "cc c c c c

c
c c c 


 c"
cc 

 c c"cc cc
c cr cc c
c  c  c c c  c c c c 

 c c 
c   c c 0c  c   c c
 
"cc 
 c   c
c c c


 c
c

0c  c
ccc4
c
c4
 c
cc c c/c
 c c%  :!c
c
%:!c 
c  
 c c
 c c c "c  c c    c c c  
"c c c
  . c  c
c c 
# 
 c ?
:) c F
 c c =  c 2c 5 c  c c

 c c  c
cc c c cc c
c c0 c


  .c 
 c c" 
 c
c
"c
 c "c c c c   c c -
.c " c


  c c
# 
 c 0
c &'2*c
%
c&''c
c
c
c c ccc ccc c
c
c
c
c c" c cc

cc c
  c" 
 c c  c cc
# 
 c/
c
c c"cc

 c
 c

 c  c c c c 
 cc"c  c   ccc c

/c$ cc1"c c c c


cc c c"c  c
cc c "c c
 

 ccc cc 
 c c 
 cc cr c c c 4c
c
c
"cc c
 c  
c c 
c 1"c c 
c + c - 
c .c  c
c  c  c  c c c c
c 
# 
 c 
c c c  c c 4c 
# 
 c
c 
c c "c "c c 1"c 
 c
c
 c
c  c   c
c  c c c  c c c  c c  c 
c c 
c  c   c

 
 c c"1
 c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
(& ('r& c
/
c c
 
 cc 
 c" c 
 c c1"c  c$ cc1"c  c

  c " 
 c c c  c 
c   c 

c 
$ c /c 
 c  
 c
 c"c c<
 cc c  "
 cc ccc cc

 c cc
 
c c
c
  cc c
c
# 
 c+
cc c

c  c cc
c  c
c  c
c c  c c
c   c  c c " c 

 c  c 
"c 
c 


c

c  cc
 

 
 cccc 
" c c 
 c c1"c  c c

  c " 
 c
c c 


c 
c
c


 c c c   c  
c /
c

cc

c  
 c c 

ccc  c c
cc 
c ccc 

c c

cc c c  c c
c
c
"cc
ccc c c
 
c cc
 c c
 
 c c"cc c c
c
c

 cc c

/
c c
 c  c
 ccc  c<
 cc  cc4

cc  c c
 
c  
" c  c c  c c c 
# 
 c c 4 
c c  
 
c " c
 
c 
" c c c  c c  c  c c 
" c
cc c  
c  c

c  c c  
 
c 
c  c  c "c c  

c c c   c c 
c c c
c 
 c 
c c  c c 
c 

 c c /
c c  4c 

c  
" c c
c  c 
c c c 
c c c   c c c    
c c c
  c /c
c c c c c 

 c   c c
c  
 c  

c   c
c
  c 

c  
 c c 
c c c 9 c c   c  c c "c  c
c  
 c

 c  cc 
cc 
 
 ccc
 cc cc

 cc c
c

c c

/
c   c  c

 
 c c ,c 
  c c  

c   c /c
c c 
c


 c c c   c c c cc 

c   c c 
# 
 c
c c " c
 c? c c 
 cccc  ccc c c cc c c
c
 c"
  c/c c c c c  c   
c c

 cc c


c c" 
 c 
" c c"
c


 c cc 

  cr c c  c 
 c
 c  c c  c  c 
  c c  c c c c c  
c   c G
c c
)" c 2c G c c  c 

 c  c 
c c 4

c 
# 
 c   c
c 
c c
  cc
 c c
  ccc,c
  c c   c

/c cc c cc


c c  c
 cc c c 
 c  
 c
c c

c c  c  c c c  c 
c c 
# 
 c c  c  c c 4
c  c c
c  c c c /c 

 c  c   c   c 
"c c  c

 
 c cc   c c  c c  ccc crc  c
 c c
cc
  cc cc  c
 c

 c 
c
c
# 
 c cc c
 c
c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
',&%c
Vishnuprasad Nagadevarac
c c % c
c c  c c H 
 
c  c c r  
 c
  c c c r 
c r 
c c 7  c )  c ,
c  c c   c c 8  c 7

c

 
 cc 
 c  c
$ c c)
 c0 
 c

5
Cc  I

" 
c

Vasanthi Srinivasanc
c c 0 
c % c
c c  c c 3
# 
 c ) 
c c , c
 c7  c,c  cc
 c c  c+ c c/ cr  
 c, c
 c   c c 
 c c   
c c  c " c c  c c c  c 
c  c " c
  c
c c 5 c G
 c  c   c @575!5¯;5Bc  c    
c c " c c
 
 c c c4
c4
 c
ccr  
 c/ c c
cr 
c c
c  c
c
  "

c"

c  cc,c
  c
c c0
c

5
Cc 
I

" 
c

Reimara Valkc
c c 
c   c 0  c c 
c ,c " c c c r 
c r 
c c
7  c)  crr7)cr 
c,c  cc  c c: 
c"  cc c c c
r/c
  c
cr 
c c  
c  
 cc7¯;c
 c

5
Cc
   I

" 
c

(9 &!#- c

0 c  
c
 cc
c c c   c c cr  
 c?c ;  c c ?c3"c
*c/c  c cc 

  ccc   cc
c c  c cc c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
cc
c c
%*% (c

0c c c! c=c&'&c9   c c


  c" 
cJournal of Applied Psychologyc66c2((:22(c

01 c7c?c;" c?c7c c?  c;c=c7?


c8c,c c!c=c<c*cr/c c 
Cc
)  
c: 
c 
c1"c  c cc cc

 c c
 
 cMIS
Quarterlyc>&&c&:&*c

0$
c?c!
cc+c0 c8c!c c,c%c+c&''*cr  
c1 
c  c
cc
 c Cc0c cc c c

 ccAcademy of Management Journalc(2c&:
&*c

0   c¯ccc5c 



 Cc0c c
 ccc
# 
 cHRM Reviewc
7 c2':6>c

0
c;c&'2*c/c


 c c
# 
 Cc c" cc c 1  cAdministrative
Science quarterlyc&c(c

0 c0c c0c cc/c  c


 c cr 
. c 
c cInformation
Economics and Policyc&(c2>:*>c

) 1crcc0

 Cc<c c
 cc

c   cHRM Reviewc6:*c

)  c=c)c c+
c%c7c&''c3 c"
c c  
c  Cc/ccc c  c
c


c

c   cHuman Resource Managementc>*&c>&:(6c

) c;c0c c!  c c&''*c/cccc 


c  Cc c  c 
 cc c
  c California Management Reviewc(&c':&&6c

) c!c&''(c8
c c 
c 4 cc   c" 
cJournal of Applied Psychologyc
*'6c'2':'*c

)c c c, c?c*c9 "c c


cc
c
 Cc%

cccc


 c

# 
 c c 
   c  c "c c
cc
c
 cInternational Journal of
Retail & Distribution Managementc>2(c':>*c

)#cc8c) c=c+c c=c/c0c&''(c="c  c" 


ccc  cPersonnel
Psychologyc(*c*2:>&c

; 
c?c?c*c7 
c& c;c cPersonnel Todayc= :7 c&:&'c

; "c=cc c) c8c7c&'c0c c  c Cc0c$ 


 
c
cPersonnel
Psychologyc(c>>2:>(2c

;c;c&'>c% ccc   c "  c c cJournal of Applied Psychologyc


6&c:&&c

8 c!c8c c  c=c8c&c  c c 


c 
 c c
# 
 c
% cAcademy of Management Reviewc6>c((6:(26c

, c8c/ccCareers in and out of organizationsc CcG 0c

, c/c,c9  c=c c  cc¯c&'&c0"  


c c c c c
Cc/c cc
c  
 Journal of Applied Psychologyc662c26&:2*>c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c
= c!c&''2c0"  
cr c¯c¯
  c5cThe Blackwell Encyclopedic Dictionary of
Organizational Behaviorc&:>c34cG?Cc) c

?
  " c0c c7 :¯
cc&'''cG 
c "c c

 cc@

 BCc/c
 ccc cHuman Relationsc2&c&>>:&22c

?# 
c c+c=c c  c5c&''*c0 c
# 
 c   c  ccc
  
 c c
 cc

cr c=c?c<c c+c=c?# 
c?c?
c5c  c c7c/ c
5 cImproving training effectiveness in work organizations(*:*c7  c¯=Cc5" c

?  #c7c?  c7c c5


c0c&''c8
 c c4
 c
  c c c
 
 c c

 
 Cc cc c
  c
 ccJournal of Vocational Behaviorc2&c2':*&c

?
:) c0c9cF
 cc8c c=  c5c;c2c; $  cc


  .c
c cCc
0c : 
cc  :1"c  :


 c  :c c  : 
c
cPersonnel
Psychologyc2c&:>(c

9c/c+c&''*c5c c
c9c,c% c;cc!c c c0cJ "c5 cThe blackwell
encyclopedic dictionary of human resource managementc'*:&c34c) c

9c/c+c c7
c/cc&''(c0 c  
c  Cc/c 
ccc  cc
 cAcademy of Management Reviewc&'&c2&:'c

9
c7c&'c 
c c  c 
Cc+ c  c4
 c
c 
c  

c

# 
 c 
  Administrative Science Quarterlyc2c6:2&c

9 c!c,c=c%    c0c8 


cc0c c5
c)c7c&'*c0 c

 c cc  c
 cJournal of Marketingc2&>c>(:2'c

7 :¯
cc&c0 c 
 c ccc "c c/c ccr  . c
 c
c  Journal of Management in Medicinec&2c&6:&(c

7 
c=c=c c, 
 c8c0c&''>c/c"ccc cc"cKcH 
 c
 c c c

c "  
c  cResearch in Personnel and Human Resources Managementc&&c2':>c

79 
c?c=c&''&c0ccc$
 c c  c
c

 c cJournal of Political Economyc
''&c&:'c

7
 c0c= 
c!c8c=c c! c¯c&''c0c7 : 
c
ccc 
 
c" c "  c
c Journal of Applied Psychologyc**6c*':'c

7"c+c,c&'**cr 
c
  c
c 
 
c" c1"c 
 
 c cc
 cJournal of Applied Psychologyc6c>*:(c

7
 c8c&cr 
. c  c
 cIEEE Softwarec= :<"c**:c

7c=c5c c)c9cc,cc c  c@ cBc


cr/cCommunications of the ACMc
(2&c*>:*c

7c?c9 :; c=c c+



 c0c(c/ccc  c
cc cBritish Journal
of Managementc&2>c>>2:>('c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c
c
c c
¯    cc(cApplication of neural prediction models in healthcarec% c  c cc
 cr  
 c;  c c:! c;"c 
c9  c

¯    cccr
cc
  cccc c  cc  c

cr cc
=  
c5Global causes on hospitality industryc¯cJCc/c, c% c

¯0 ;37c6c,c



 c,c" c 
 c
c" c 
cD3 
Ec¯0 ;37c¯ 
cr c
¯c2'c "c6c0
 "Cc
C  
¯    ¯ %  4K
L22cD*c7 c&Ec

%
c9c0c&''c%  c
 
 c
 
 Cc/c
cc c  c c c

 cc

 c Academy of Management Reviewc&(>c>2:>6c

%c&''(cCompetitive advantage through people: Unleashing the power of the work forcec)  Cc
,  c)
 c c% c

%c9c+c; 
 c+c=c c 
c<c=c&'*6c3
# 
 c
 c c 
c Cc
0c 

c Organizational Behavior and Human Performancec&2&c*:'c

 1  c?cJc*c/ 
c cc"
c cBusinessworldc>6:(c

 
ccc c   cGc¯cc7 
c 

 cc
c
# 
 cHRM Reviewc>>:
>c

 
c¯c c>c, c  c   c
cr 
c  c
 Cc0 c

 c cc
c c/
c%8cc 
 c=c7 c cc7  cr 
cr 
cc
/ c)" c

 c=c!c&'c 
 c  c   c "  c c Ccr cc c
 cc

  KcHuman Relationsc(&(c2&*:2>&c

  c c*c@,
c 

 c Cc0c"
c  BcD3 
Ec
C "

    

  :"
:   cD*c>&c7 Ec

 c=c8c8c=c5c= 
c!c8c c! c¯c&''c0 c
# 
 :c 
cc  c c

  c cAcademy of Management Reviewc(&2c2&&:22c

c9c0cc8c5c c/  c!c;c6c%  c 


 cc
 
 c c Cc
/ccc1" c c
 cc c c  cPersonnel and Human Resource
Managementc2>c>2:>*6c

 c7c=c&'''c0
 
 ccc  c c  
 ccc cc  cc
 cJournal of Applied Psychologyc(&c&**:&2c

cc%c c  c=cc&''2cr  cc 


 c  
 c cc c c

 cc
"  
cAcademy of Management Journalc2c&6&6:&6>(c

/cc%c c7c=c%c&''>c=": 
 
 c
# 
 c
 c c
 
 c c
 Cc% c   c" c c : 
c

 cPersonnel Psychologyc(6c2':'>c

+  c=c%c&''cOrganizational entryc 
c70Cc0
 :+ c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c
+
c=c)cc=c?  #c7c c<
" c¯c&'c9   c c "  
Cc0 c4 

 cc
c
 c
cCanadian Journal of Administrative Sciencesc2&c(':2(c
c

cc ¯    cc 

 cc c ccc
c c
c c

You might also like