You are on page 1of 6

Journal of Food Engineering 68 (2005) 303–308

www.elsevier.com/locate/jfoodeng

Production of fish-protein products (surimi) from small pelagic


fish (Sardinops pilchardusts), underutilized by the industry
Christos A. Bentis, Anastasioss Zotos *, Dimitrios Petridis
Thessaloniki Educational Institute (TEI), Department of Food Technology, School of Food Technology & Nutrition,
54101 Thessaloniki, P.O. Box 14561, Greece

Received 24 November 2003; accepted 9 June 2004

Abstract

A sardine surimi product was studied, based on three experimental factors: (a) control of pH-value (2 levels) (b) improvement of
protein solubility (2 levels) and (c) cryoprotectants (3 levels). Samples were frozen at 20 C and kept at this temperature for 25
days. All samples were then partially thawed, mixed with 2 g kg 1 sodium chloride and heated at 90 C for 90 min. The combination
of sorbitol (40 g kg 1) with the salt mixture (sodium chloride 0.45 g kg 1 calcium chloride 0.3 g kg 1 and ammonium chloride 1.25
g kg 1) led to the hardest and more elastic products. Protein loss during the processes was relatively small (6.9% on a dry weight
basis), and its solubility remained at high levels. The overall product recovery was 200 g kg 1. The use of different batches led in
statistically significant differences among the final products. The concentration of eicosapentaenoic and docosahexaenoic fatty acids
showed that under-utilized sardine could be an important source of polyunsaturated fatty acids and MaxEPA products.
 2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Surimi; Sardine; MaxEPA; Under-utilized fish

1. Introduction ity surimi, similar to that produced from the fore-


mentioned species (Trondsen, 1998).
An effort has begun to exploit some fish species that However, despite serious attempts to use species such
are either in abundance or underutilized. This effort as mackerel and sardine, the control of the factors that
has led in the production of frozen fish-protein products influence the large-scale production of such products re-
widely known as surimi mainly because access to the main difficult (Chen et al., 1997). These factors are the
Alaska pollock sources has been limited (Chen, Chiu, high lipid content, the water-soluble proteins, as well
& Huang, 1997). as the pigment and trimethylamine oxide (TMAO) in
Alaska pollock (Theragra chalcogramma) is the most dark-fleshed fish mince. Therefore adequate washing is
common fish for such product (Lanier, 1992; Suzuki, required to prepare high quality surimi (Shimizu, Toyo-
1981). Research has shown that besides Alaska pollock, hara, & Lanier, 1992).
and after the appliance of specific chemical methods, The colour of surimi can be improved by increasing
other species may also be used and produce a high qual- the washing cycles (Kim et al., 1996), washing time and
water quantity (Chen et al., 1997). Long period washing
would result in high hydration of mince and degradation
of myofibrillar proteins, making the subsequent dehy-
*
Corresponding author. Fax: +30 2310 791360. dration process more difficult and could repress the gel-
E-mail address: zotos@food.teithe.gr (A. Zotos). forming ability. The colour of dark-fleshed fish surimi

0260-8774/$ - see front matter  2004 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jfoodeng.2004.06.003
304 C.A. Bentis et al. / Journal of Food Engineering 68 (2005) 303–308

could be improved by leaching of mince with hydroper- sodium tripolyphosphate was added to all sugar solu-
oxide or sodium percarbonate or by adding some fat/ tions in order to optimise the cryoprotection of the pro-
casein material to mask the colour (Chen et al., 1997). tein matrix (Suzuki, 1981; Lanier, 1992). Surimi was
In Greece fish (mainly small fish) are processed by packed into polyethylene bags (350 g), frozen down to
salting, drying, smoking, canning, etc. However, the fish 25 C and stored at the same temperature for 25 days.
are often too small for processing and thus have no com-
mercial value and are usually dumped. Thus in Greece 2.2. Surimi gel preparation
the lack of utilization of small fish may also have an ad-
verse effect on the environment. The 350 g surimi sample was partially thawed at
Thus, the aim of this investigation is to introduce an room temperature, cut into small pieces and chopped
application for the Greek industry to use such fish spe- with an ordinary domestic cutter for 4 min with 20
cies. Therefore, the possibility of producing surimi prod- g kg 1 sodium chloride. The paste was stuffed in stain-
ucts from small pelagic fish, such as sardine, was studied less steel tubes, 2.5 cm in diameter and 10 cm in length
by leaching the fish flesh-mince, modifying the pH- and was heated at 90 C for 60 min.
value, enhancing the gel forming ability and finally
stabilising the product using sugar solutions as cryopro-
2.3. Moisture
tectant agents during freezing and frozen storage.
Moisture content was determined by the CEC (Com-
mission of European Communities) recommended
2. Materials and methods
method ISOR 1442 (CEC, 1979).
Approximately 21 kg (three batches, 7 kg at three dif-
ferent times) of fresh sardines (Sardinops pilchardus) 2.4. Protein analysis
were purchased, 2–3 h after catching, from the local fish
market of Thessaloniki. All fish had an average length of The method used for salt soluble protein (SSP) was
13 ± 2.13 cm. They were iced for up to 6 h before that of Cowie and Mackie (1968). In the procedure
processing (immediately after purchase). The whole adopted, salt soluble nitrogen, non-protein nitrogen
process was performed by hand (due to the lack of the (NPN), and total nitrogen (TN) were determined. SSP
necessary equipment) at the laboratories of the Thes- was calculated as follows (SSN-NPN/TN-NPN · 100).
saloniki Institute of Technology, Department of Food
Technology.
2.5. Lipid extraction and analysis
2.1. Frozen surimi
The lipid content was determined by the Bligh and
Dyer (1959) method as modified by Hanson and Olley
Samples of raw sardine from each batch, were
(1963). The fatty acid profile was performed according
washed, gutted, head and bones removed, minced and
to a simple and quick method of Humberside Polytech-
then split into two parts (A & B). Part A was washed
nic as described in Zotos (1991). Peroxide value (PV)
with water (0–5 C) while part B was washed with a 5
was determined according to the method of AOAC
g kg 1 solution of sodium bicarbonate in order to stabi-
(1984).
lize the pH value of the mince (Suzuki, 1981; Lanier,
1992). The duration of both washings was 30 min. After
adequately dewatering the mince, both parts were 2.6. Instrumental analysis
washed with a 100 g kg 1 solution of hydrogen peroxide
for 5 min at 0–5 C. Then, parts A & B were split in half The instrumental analysis was performed using an In-
(A1–A2 & B1–B2). A1–B1 were washed with a 2 g kg 1 stron UTM analyser, model 1140 (Instron Ltd. UK)
sodium chloride solution while A2–B2 was washed with with a flat probe of 6 cm diameter. The 12 different sam-
2 g kg 1 salt-mixture solution (consisting from 0.45 ples of surimi were cut in a cylinder form with an ana-
g kg 1 NaCl, 0.3 g kg 1 CaCl2 and 1.25 g kg 1 NH4Cl) logue device (2.25 cm in height and diameter).
to investigate the interaction of a transglutaminase en- Firmness, elasticity and juiciness were measured by a
hancer (CaCl2) and inhibitor (NH4Cl) (Morales, Rami- compression test using a 10 kg weight, at 10 mm/min
rez, Vivanco, & Vazquez, 2001). After dewatering the speed and a compression limit of 70%. Juiciness was
mince again, all four fore-mentioned parts were once measured by placing the samples on a dried and pre-
again split into three parts (C, D, E). Each part was weighed filter paper. A pressure of 10 kg was then
washed with a 40 g kg 1 sorbitol solution, 40 g kg 1 mal- applied for 1 min. After accurately re-weighing the fil-
tose solution and 40 g kg 1 sorbitol-maltose (1:1) solu- ter paper, the loss of water from each sample was
tion, respectively. A small amount 0.2 g kg 1 of calculated.
C.A. Bentis et al. / Journal of Food Engineering 68 (2005) 303–308 305

2.7. Experimental design treatment, b = 13 panellists and k = 4 treatments per


panellist (k < t). Adjusted sensory mean scores were de-
The factors studied in this investigation were the duced for the 13 treatments and at that point, the pur-
washing of the mince with water or sodium bicarbonate chased surimi was excluded from further investigation.
solution (2 levels), the washing with different salt solu- All surimi products, as handled at the various levels
tions (2 levels: sodium chloride 2 g kg 1 and a mixture of the three factors under investigation, with all varia-
of sodium chloride, calcium chloride and ammonium bles considered, were statistically analyzed using two
chloride, 0.45, 0.3 and 1.25 g kg 1, respectively) and fi- different approaches: (a) A 3-way analysis of variance
nally the washing with cryoprotectants for product sta- (ANOVA) with no replicates for the factors and their
bilization (3 levels: 40 g kg 1 sorbitol, 40 g kg 1 maltose interaction terms on the whole set of sensory and physic-
and 40 g kg 1 mixture of sorbitol and maltose 1:1). The ochemical variables. Statistically significant differences
combination of every level, which represents a different were tested using the SNK (Student-Newman–Keuls)
treatment, is shown in Table 1. test for comparison of level mean values (Zar, 1984).
(b) The ANOVA procedure was further enhanced by
2.8. Sensory evaluation the appliance of Principal Component Analysis (PCA)
in order to investigate the combined effects of all four
Sensory evaluation was performed using 13 experi- factors (including the raw material studied afterwards
enced members of the academic staff for testing the 12 as a factor) on the profile of the final product (Dunt-
(2 · 2 · 3) treatments of the experiment and the design eman, 1989; Jollife, 1986).
was increased with a crab-like surimi sample from All statistical analysis was carried out on Minitab
Atlantic Pollock purchased from the market, in order Statistical Software Package (Ver. 13.1) and Statistica
to conform to the particular Plan 13.17a described by Software Package (Ver. 6.0).
Cochran and Cox (1957). The panellistsÕ experience on
sensory assessment was acquired through regular partic-
ipation for at least 4–5 years in similar kinds of projects 3. Results and discussion
concerning fish and meat products. Four sensory varia-
bles were examined: firmness, elasticity, juiciness and 3.1. Proximate analysis
surface colour. The intensity of the four variables was
recorded in a 15 cm unstructured scale. The lineÕs left Both lipid and protein concentrations were quite low
end was marked at 0 cm for all variables as extremely while moisture, inversely related to the lipid content,
non-firm, non-elastic, dry and gray, whereas the right was quite high (Table 2). It is well known that moisture
end was marked at 15 cm as extremely firm, elastic, juicy and lipid are highly dependent in a fatty fish such as sar-
and white. Samples were presented to the panellists dine, the higher the moisture the lower the lipid and vice
through a particular precedence, carried out by the use versa. It can be observed from Table 2 that both moisture
of Minitab Statistical Software Package (Ver. 13.1). and proteins were maintained at significantly high levels
After the samples (coded with 3-digit random numbers) (836 and 134 g kg 1, respectively), indicating a non-
were left for 30 min at room temperature, 4 segments of significant loss of proteins (6.9% on a dry weight basis,
5 cm diameter were placed in an odourless plastic con- probably due to some loss of the sarcoplasmic fraction).
tainer, covered with a watch glass, and served to the It was also observed that proteins were exhibited high
panellists. The evaluation occurred in individual booths functionality since they retained a significant amount
equipped with white lights. De-ionized water and crack- of water (836 g kg 1). The mean salt soluble protein
ers with unsalted tops were provided to clean the palate (SSP) of the raw material was 79.8% ± 3.8% (±95% Con-
between samples. fidence Intervals) while that of the final product was
61.7% ± 11.7%. Indicating a high solubility even after
2.9. Statistical analysis the whole process. The flesh yield after removing skin,
head, gut and bones was, as expected, quite low (286
A balanced incomplete block design (BIBD) was ap- g kg 1), while a 700 g kg 1 product yield was observed
plied including t = 13 treatments, n = 4 replicates per due to processing, with an overall recovery of 200 g kg 1.

Table 1
Encoding and analysis of the three experimental factors
Water (P1) Sodium bicarbonate (P2)
Sodium chloride (L1) S1 S2 S3 S1 S2 S3
Salt mixture (NaCl, Ca2Cl & NH4Cl) (L2) S1 S2 S3 S1 S2 S3
Code S1 stands for washing the mince with 4% sorbitol solution, S2 with 4% maltose and S3 with 4% sorbitol:maltose 1:1 mixture. A 0.02% sodium
tripolyphosphate solution was also included in every treatment.
306 C.A. Bentis et al. / Journal of Food Engineering 68 (2005) 303–308

Table 2
Proximate analysis of sardine flesh and surimi found in this investigation as well as results from other study
Raw material-product Species Moisture Protein Protein Lipid Lipid
g kg 1 g kg 1 g kg 1 (on dry weight basis) g kg 1 g kg 1 (on dry
weight basis)
Sardine Sardinops pilchardus 833.0 (23.0) 147.0 (22.7) 880.0 (102.0) 19.7 (4.0) 118.0 (21.1)
(present investigation)
Sardine surimi Sardinops pilchardus 836.0 (23.1) 134.4 (23.2) 819.5 (138.1) 17.7 (2.8) 107.9 (25.9)
(present investigation)
Sardine Sardinops ocellata 760–800 160 12
surimi (Morales et al., 2001)
Values are means of triplicate determinations. Standard deviations are shown in parenthesis.

3.2. Factor effects analysis 3.3. Effect of different batches

The results of the ANOVA (Table 3) revealed that During the surimi production process it was observed
washing the mince with sodium bicarbonate (P2) re- that fish originated from various batches, differentiated
duced the weight loss during the heating process (208 in size and spawning period. This observation was con-
g kg 1) with a simultaneous reduction of sensory (5.7 firmed by the proximate analysis of the three different
cm), instrumental firmness (0.45 Nt), increase of pH- batches used in this investigation. The particular inter-
value (7.57) and moisture content (853 g kg 1) of the fi- batch differentiation (as in moisture, protein and lipid
nal product. The salt mixture solution (L2) increased the content, Table 4) had an important effect on the forma-
weight loss during the heating process (331 g kg 1), the tion and the quality of the final product. Sardines from
pH-value from its initial level to 7.5 as well as the PV batches 1 and 2 were probably captured during the pre-
to 10.7 meq O2/kg lipid. Samples treated with sorbitol spawning period, while those from batch 3 were fished
solution (S1) (cryoprotecting agent) were firmer prod- during the post-spawning period, considering that
ucts than all others as assessed by the panellists (8.4 they were caught 1 week after the first two batches.
cm). A similar result has also been reported by Suzuki Kurokawa (1983) has found that sardine muscle origi-
(1981). Furthermore, a synergistic effect was observed nating from samples during the post-spawning period
between sorbitol (S1) and the mixture of salts (L2) lead- had a lower gel forming ability than the pre-spawning
ing to even firmer surimi products (10.8 cm). The inter- ones, an event that was also confirmed in this investiga-
action of the salt mixture (L2) and sodium bicarbonate tion. Samples produced from samples of the 3rd batch,
(P2) also indicated a synergistic effect on the pH-value, showed (a) low levels of sensory firmness: 2nd batch
the PV and moisture. These variables presented their 0.76 Nt = 1st batch 0.58 Nt > 3rd batch 0.37 Nt, (b)
maximum values at that particular combined level higher pH-values 3rd pH 8.03>1st pH 7.08=2nd pH
(P2L2). 6.93, (c) low levels of SSP 1st 71.30%=2nd

Table 3
ANOVAÕs statistically significant results of factors on the variables under study
Factor Affected variable F-Value p-Value Levels
1 2 3
Washing (P) Weight loss (WL) (g kg 1) 59.70 0.016 309.5 207.9
PH 37.29 0.026 7.00 7.57
Moisture (g kg 1) 61.49 0.016 818.6 853.4
Sensory firmness (cm) 63.38 0.015 9.0 5.7
Instrumental firmness (Nt) 6.38 0.030 0.69 0.45
Salt (L) WL (g kg 1) 121.47 0.008 186.3 331.2
PH 48.58 0.049 7.08 7.48
PV (meq O2/kg lipid) 37.91 0.025 4.67 10.73
Sugar (S) Sensory firmness (cm) 21.48 0.044 8.4 5.7 8.2
Combined levels Combined levels
Salt · sugar (L2 · S1) Sensory firmness (cm) 28.57 0.034 10.8
Washing · salt (P1 · L2) WL (g kg 1) 103.8 0.009 449
Washing · salt (P2 · L2) pH 33.03 0.029 8.03
Moisture (g kg 1) 26.47 0.036 868.9
PV (meq O2/kg lipid) 41.69 0.023 15.94
C.A. Bentis et al. / Journal of Food Engineering 68 (2005) 303–308 307

Table 4
Proximate analysis of sardines from the three batches
1 1 1 1
Batch Species Moisture g kg Protein g kg Protein g kg (on dry weight basis) Lipid g kg Lipid g kg 1
(on dry weight basis)
1st Sardinops pilchardus 825.9 (10.9) 154.5 (11.5) 887.9 19.4 (5.3) 111.5
2nd Sardinops pilchardus 812.5 (6.1) 165.8 (6.2) 883.8 21.5 (0.8) 116.2
3rd Sardinops pilchardus 867.5 (6.5) 113.1 (7.2) 860.7 18.3 (2.6) 139.3
Values are means of triplicate determinations, except from 1st batch which is six fold. Standard deviations are shown in parenthesis.

66.70% > 3rd 37.70% and (d) higher susceptibility to li- plains 61.4% of the total variance, the 2nd axis explains
pid oxidation PV: 3rd 15.94 meq/kg lipid > 2nd 5.51 16.5% and the 3rd one 13.8%, summing to a total of
meq/kg lipid=1st 4.69 meq/kg lipid. 90.7%. Variable effects are represented with arrows in
It was also observed that the samples produced from Fig. 1, commencing from the centre of the three-dimen-
sardines of batch 2 lost the greater amount of water dur- sional space. Variable correlations are represented by an-
ing heating: water loss: 2nd 157.17 g kg 1 > 3rd 74.70 gles formed between each couple of arrows. An oblique
g kg 1=1st 65.20 g kg 1. angle between two variables reflects a positive action,
an obtuse angle shows a negative (opposing) effect and
3.4. Correlation of sensory and instrumental variables a vertical angle shows no correlation. Treatments that
are close to a variable exert a strong influence on it.
Sensory and instrumental firmness correlated fairly PCA (Fig. 1) reveals that raw material (three different
(Pearson correlation r = 0.74, p = 0.006) while sensory batches) is a very important parameter on the profile
and instrumental elasticity correlated sufficiently formation of the product, as also noticed by other scien-
(r = 0.85, p < 0.001). A strong correlation was observed tists (Okada, 1992; Suzuki, 1981). Treatments 10, 11 and
between instrumental elasticity and firmness (r > 0.97, 12 from the 3rd batch are characterized by high mois-
p < 0.001). ture content, pH-value and peroxide value (PV), and
low values of total protein (TP), salt soluble protein
3.5. Principal component analysis (PCA) (SSP), weight loss (WL) and functional properties (such
as instrumental firmness –IF and elasticity –IE) (Fig. 1).
Variables that showed statistically significant differ- Treatments of that particular batch were produced with
ences from the ANOVA, as well as those, which mostly the combination of factor levels L2 and P2 (Table 1).
contributed to the formation of the first three major The 2nd batch (treatments 7, 8 & 9) revealed high
component axes were studied. The 1st major axis ex- functional properties (apart from treatment 8) and low

Fig. 1. Principal component analysis showing the first three major axes.
308 C.A. Bentis et al. / Journal of Food Engineering 68 (2005) 303–308

Table 5 Lipid content of sardine-flesh was highly rich in n-3


Fatty acid profile of sardine, surimi and cod-liver oil polyunsaturated fatty acids and especially in EPA and
Fatty acids % Fresh sardine Sardine surimi Cod-liver oil DHA. Thus it could lead to another direction of utiliza-
C20: 5x-3 (EPA) 11.3 9.8 22.1 tion of this fish.
C22: 6x-3 (DHA) 24.5 28.7 14.5
Saturated 40.1 38.9 21.0
Monounsaturated 13.9 11.1 9.9
Polyunsaturated 46.0 50.0 69.1 References

Association of Official Analytical Chemists (AOAC) (1984). Official


moisture (Fig. 1), and was used to produce surimi with a methods of analysis, method 28:025 (14th ed.). Washington, DC,
combination of factor levels L2 and P1 (Table 1). Max- USA: AOAC.
imum percentage of SSP was observed for treatment 8 Bligh, E. G., & Dyer, W. J. (1959). A rapid method of total lipid
(S2L2P1). The latter product had a pH-value of 7.0. It oxidation and purification. Canadian Journal of Biochemistry and
is known that the solubility of proteins in solutions of Physiology, 37, 911.
Chen, H. H., Chiu, E. M., & Huang, J. R. (1997). Colour and gel
stable ionic strength increases along with the pH-value forming properties of horse mackerel (Trachurus japonicus) as
increase within the range of 5.0–7.5. related to washing conditions. Journal of Food Science, 62(5),
Finally, all treatments from 1st batch (treatments 1– 985–991.
6) occupy a central position in the figure, thus indicating Cochran, W. G., & Cox, G. M. (1957). Experimental designs (2nd ed.).
that there was little influence on the surrounding varia- Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
Commission of European Communities (CEC) (1979). Oven drying
ble pattern. The only common characteristic of these method. SQ 1442.
treatments is their washing with sodium chloride (L1). Cowie, W. P., & Mackie, I. M (1968). Examination of the protein
extractability method for determining cold storage protein dena-
3.6. Fatty acid methyl-esters turation in cod. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 19,
696–700.
Dunteman, G. H. (1989). Principal components analysis (p. 96).
The fatty acid profiles of sardine, surimi and cod-liver London: Sage Publications, Inc.
oil were also studied. As shown in Table 5, there were Hanson, S. W. F., & Olley, J. (1963). Application of the Bligh and
significant differences among the fatty acid profiles of Dyer method of lipid extraction to tissue homogenates. Biochem-
the raw material (fresh sardine) and that of purchased istry Journal, 89, 101–104.
pharmaceutical oil from cod (Gadus morrhua) liver. Pol- Jollife, I. T. (1986). Principal components analysis (p. 272). New York:
Springer-Verlag.
yunsaturated fatty acids contained in the cod liver oil Kim, J. M., Liu, C. H., Eun, J. B., Park, J. W., Oshimi, R., Hayashi,
reach 69% of the total amount of the fatty acids, while K., Ott, B., Aramaki, T., Sekine, M., Horikita, V., Fujimoto, K.,
those of sardine do not exceed 50%. Eicosapentaenoic Alkawa, T., Welch, L., & Long, R. (1996). Surimi from fillet
acid (EPA) is also found at 50% greater concentrations frames of channel of catfish. Journal of Food Science, 61, 428–431,
in cod liver oil than in the oil deriving from sardine flesh. 438.
Kurokawa, T. (1983). Kamaboko gel-forming ability of sardine caught
Even so, when taking under consideration that a signif- in the coast of Nagasaki Prefecture. Nipon Suisan Gakkaishi, 49,
icant portion of sardine was not used (such as head, tail 1057.
and internal organs), we can assume that under-utilized Lanier, C. T. (1992). New technologies in surimi manufacture. In C. T.
sardine could be used as a source of polyunsaturated Lanier & C. M Lee (Eds.), Surimi technology (pp. 167–207). New
fatty acids and they might be pharmaceutically utilized York: Marcel Dekker Inc.
Morales, O. G., Ramirez, J. A., Vivanco, D. I., & Vazquez, M. (2001).
in producing MaxEPA products. Surimi of fish species from the Gulf of Mexico: evaluation of the
setting phenomenon. Food Chemistry, 75, 43–48.
4. Conclusions Okada, M. (1992). History of surimi technology in Japan. In T. C.
Lanier & C. M. Lee (Eds.), Surimi technology (pp. 3–20). New
York: Marcel Dekker Inc.
The use of sorbitol, in this investigation as a cryopro- Shimizu, Y., Toyohara, H., & Lanier, T. C. (1992). Surimi production
tective agent along with washing the fish mince with a from fatty and dark flesh species. In T. C. Lanier & C. M. Lee
mixture of salts, resulted in a harder and more elastic (Eds.), Surimi technology (pp. 181–207). New York: Marcel Dekker
surimi gel. Inc.
Suzuki, T. (1981). What is frozen minced meat (surimi). In T. Suzuki
Maximum weight loss during cooking was observed
(Ed.), Fish and krill protein. Processing technology (pp. 45–51, 100–
for the treatments washed with water (without attempt- 103, 133–134). London: Applied Science Publishers Ltd.
ing to stabilize the pH-value). Washing the minced fish Trondsen, T. (1998). Blue whiting surimi: new perspectives on the
meat with the mixture of salts enhanced this event. market value. Fisheries Research, 34, 1–15.
Protein denaturation did not show any statistically Zar, J. H. (1984). Biostatistical analysis (p. 190) (2nd ed.). Englewood
Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall Inc.
significant difference from the ongoing procedure, but
Zotos, A. (1991). Investigation into the effect of prior frozen storage
it was influenced by the quality and condition of the ( 20 C) on the quality of hot-smoked cod (Gadus morrhua) and
raw samples. The condition of sardine samples influ- mackerel (Scomber scombrus). M.Phil. Thesis, Loughborough
enced the general profile of the final product. University of Technology, UK.

You might also like