Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
3Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Summary Judgment Decision

Summary Judgment Decision

Ratings: (0)|Views: 2,242|Likes:
Published by Greg Saulmon

More info:

Published by: Greg Saulmon on Jun 10, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

06/10/2011

pdf

text

original

 
07-0S-201102:45PMFROM-HAMPDENSUPERIORCOURTCLERKSOFFICE4137371S11T-448P.002/017F-9S2
.~
...,'
~.
COMMONWEALTHOFMASSACHUSETISSUPERIORCOURTDEPARTMENTOFTHETRIALCOURT
HAMi:JDENCOU~¥IL
ACTIONNO.HDCV2010-0037-B
SUPERIORCOURT
FIL~D
DEC15)2010
)
.~,~o.~.
DEFENDANT,THOMASL.DUPRE'S
I
C'r.:~K'MAGIS;RA~OTIONFOR
)SUMMARYJUDGMENT)
))
------~-------------------)
HAMPDEN,ss.ANDREWNICASTRO,Plain.tiffvs.JOSEPHF.MAGUIRE,THOMASL.DUPREANDRICHARDS.SNIEZYK,DefendantsNowcomesthedefendantThomas
L.
DupreandrespectfullyrequeststhatthisHonorableCourtenterJudgmentinhisfavorpursuanttoMassachusettsRuleofCivilProcedure56againsttheplaintiffAndrewNicastro,Asgroundstherefore,Thomas
L.
Duprecontendsthatontheundisputedrecordofmaterialfacts,heisentitledtoJudgmentasamatteroflawagainstAndrewNicastro,andwithoutatrial.InsupportofthisMotion,ThomasL.'DupresubmitshisMemorandumofLawinSupportofMotionforSummaryJudgment
and
StatementofUndisputedMaterialFactsPursuanttoSuperiorCourtRule9Awithsupportingexhibits.WHEREFORE,ThomasL.DuprasherebymovesthatthisCourtenterJudgmentinhisfavor.Dated:November2,2010MichaelO.Jenin
880#
25134073ChestnutStreetSpringfield,MA01103
413-737-7349Fax413-731-1302
2-lfJ-1
D
CaHf.ri
in
01ultk.
u.c.
--
-
J&
 
07-06-201102:45PMFROM-HAMPDENSUPERIORCOURTCLERKSOFFICE4137371611T-448P.003/017F-962
COMMONWEALTHOFMASSACHUSETTSDEPARTMENT
OFTHETRIALCOURTHampden,
SS.
SUPERIORCOURTCIVILACTIONNO.I-IDCV2010-00037-B
)
)
)
)
)JOSEPHF.MAGUIRE,THOMAS)
L.
DUl'REANDRICHARDS.SNIEZYK,)
)
ANDREWF.NICASTRO,
Plaintiff
Defendants
HAMPDENCOUNTYSUPERIORCOURT
FILED
APR262011
~-:-.O?;:..
!
~~';:;:;.nlSTR.rE~
V.
PLAINTIFF'SEMERGENCYMOTIONTOIMPOUNDPROTECTEDPSYCHOLOGICALRECORDSANDREPORTThePlaintiff,byhisattorney,movesthisCourtforanorderdirectingtheClerktosealandimpoundtheexpertreportofDr.JohnDaignaultattachedtothePlaintiff'sOppositiontoDefendantsDupre'sandMaguire'sMotionforSummaryJudgment.ThePlaintiffalsomovestoimpoundthePlaintiffsconfidentialpsychologicalrecordswhichareincludedintheDefendants'ExhibitsconnectedwiththeirMotionsforSummaryJudgment.
In
supportofthisMotiontoImpound,theplaintiffsubmitsanAffidavit,attachedhereto.ThereasonandgroundsforthisMotionarethattheunderlyinglawsuitconcernsthesexualabuseoftheplaintiffwhenhewasaminor.Theexpertreportandpsychologicalrecordscontaindetailsofthesexualabuseaswellasintimateandpersonaldetailsoftheplaintiff'smentalandemotionalh'lstoryandcondition.Theplaintiff'sconfidentialpsychologicalrecordswereprovidedduringdiscoveryandwouldnotbepartofacourtrecordbutfortheMotionforSummaryJudgment.Similarly,theexpertpsychologistreportwaspreparedforpurposesofrespondingtotheMotionforSummaryJudgment.
 
07-06-201102:45PMFROM-HAMPDENSUPERIORCOURTCLERKSOFFICE4137371611T-448P.004/017F-962
COMMONWEALTHOFMASSACHUSETTSHAMP])EN,ss.SUPERIORCOURTHDCV2010-00037BANDREWNICASTRO
HAMPDENCOUNTY
supeRIORCOURT
FILED
JUN-
6
2011
JOSEPHF.MAGUIRE
&
others'MEMORANDUMOFDECISIONANDORDERONDEFENDANTTHOMAS
L.
DUPRE'SMOTIONFORSUMMARYIDDGMENTANDMOTIONOFDEFENDANTJOSEPHF.MAGUIREFORSUMMARYJUDGMENTINTRODUCTIONPlaintiffAndrewNicastrofiledthislawsuitagainstthedefendantchurchofficials,allegingthattheynegligentlyfailedtoprotecthimagainstpedophilepriestAlfredGraves.Thismatterisbeforethe
COUlt
ontwodefendants'smotionsforsummaryjudgmentpursuanttoMass.R-Civ.P.56onstatuteoflimitationsgrounds.Alsobeforethecourt:istheMotionofDefendantJoseph
MaguiretoStrikeAffidavitofExpert
WitnessDr.
JohnDaignault.For
thereasonsdiscussed
below,
Maguire'smotiontostrikeisDENIEDandMaguire'smotionforsununaryjudgmentisDENrED.Inaddition,defendantDupre'smotionforsummaryjudgmentisDENIED.BACKGROUNDViewedinthelightmostfavorabletotheplaintiffasthenon-movingparty,theundisputedfactsasrevealed
by
the
summary
judgmentrecordareasfollows.PlaintiffAndrewNicastro("Nicastro")
was
bornonApril4,1971.In1982,Nicastrowasanaltarboyandthepaperboyfor'ThomasL-Dupreand
RichardS_
Sniezyk
~'

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->