SUMMARY OF THE CASE AND REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
This is a civil case for copyright infringement and other intellectual property
claims. The District Court granted summary judgment for plaintiff Warner Bros.
on its copyright claim and issued a permanent injunction based thereon.
Defendants AVELA, Inc., et al. appeal the injunction and the predicate summaryjudgment order.
Warner Bros. claims copyright ownership through chain of title of the 1939
films "The Wizard of Oz," "Gone With The Wind," and cartoons featuring "Tomand Jerry." AVELA has obtained and restored publicity materials relating to the
films, including movie posters, photo stills and theatre lobby cards, and haslicensed images and artwork from the publicity materials to third parties for use on
merchandise. The publicity materials used by AVELA are in the public domain,
and are not protected by copyright.
The District Court determined that AVELA’s use of the publicity materialviolated Warner Bros.’ copyright in the films, and found that Warner Bros. hadsufficiently proved ownership of the copyrights through chain of title. AVELA
submits that the District Court’s order is unsupported as a matter of law.
AVELA requests 20 minutes for oral argument, as the issues presentedunder the 1909 Copyright Act are complex and subtle. AVELA submits that oral
argument would be of assistance to the Court in dealing with the issues.
Appellate Case: 10-1743 Page: 2 Date Filed: 07/23/2010 Entry ID: 3686762