Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more ➡
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Add note
Save to My Library
Sync to mobile
Look up keyword
Like this
2Activity
×
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Aclu Circumcision

Aclu Circumcision

Ratings: (0)|Views: 1,023|Likes:
Published by christina_jewett

More info:

Published by: christina_jewett on Jul 15, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See More
See less

04/14/2014

pdf

text

original

 
CROWELL
&
MORING
LLP
ATTORNEYSATLAW
SUPERIORCOURTOFCALIFORNIACOUNTYOFSANFRANCISCOUNLIMITEDJURISDICTION
1
SFACTIVE-099401.0002187\902339146.2
2
3
4
CROWELL
&
MORINGLLPEthanP.Schulman
(CSBNo.112466,eschulman@crowell.com)
TrinaD.McAlister
(CSBNo.253139,tmcalister@crowell.com)
275BatteryStreet,23rdFloorSanFrancisco,CA94111Telephone:415.986.2800Facsimile:415.986.2827
5
6
7
8
9AMERICANCIVILLIBERTIESUNIONFOUNDATIONOFNORTHERNCALIFORNIA,INC.MargaretC.Crosby
(CSBNo.56812,mcrosby@aclunc.org)
JorySteele
(CSBNo.206944,jsteele@aclunc.org)
39DrummStreetSanFrancisco,CA94111Telephone:415.621.2493Facsimile:415.255.8437Attorneysfor
AmicusCuriae
10AmericanCivilLibertiesUnionofNorthernCalifornia1112131415JEWISHCOMMUNITYRELATIONSCOUNCIL16OFSANFRANCISCO,THEPENINSULA,MARIN,SONOMA,ALAMEDAANDCONTRA17COSTACOUNTIES;ANTI-DEFAMATIONLEAGUE;JEREMYBENJAMIN;JENNY18BENJAMIN;LEOFUCHS;JONATHANJAFFE;YAELFRENKEL-JAFFE;SHEILABARI;19LETICIAPREZA;KASHIFABDULLAH;BRIANMCBETH;andERICTABAS,2021
22
PetitionerslPlaintiffs,v.JOHNARNTZ,inhiscapacityasDirectorof23ElectionsoftheCityandCountyofSanFrancisco,andCITYANDCOUNTYOFSANFRANCISCO,242526LLOYDSCHOFIELD,Respondents/Defendants.27RealPartyinInterest.28
[PROPOSED]BRIEFOF
AMICUSCURIAE
ACLU-NCINSUPPORTOFPET.FORWRITOFMANDATE;CASENO.CPF-II-511370
CaseNo.CPF-11-511370DateActionFiled:June22,2011[PROPOSED]BRIEFOF
AMICUSCURIAE
AMERICANCIVILLIBERTIESUNIONOFNORTHERNCALIFORNIAINSUPPORTOFVERIFIEDPETITIONFORWRITOFMANDATEANDCOMPLAINTFORINJUNCTIVERELIEFDate:Time:Dept:Judge:July28,20119:30a.m.302Hon.LorettaM.Giorgi
 
CROWELL
&
MORING
LLP
ATTORNEYSAT
LAW
10
11
12
13
14151617
18
192021
22
23242526
27
28
2
34
5
[PROPOSED]BRIEFOF
AMICUSCURIAE
ACLU-NCINSUPPORTOFPET.FORWRITOFMANDATE;CASENO.CPF-11-511370
TABLEOFCONTENTSPage
INTRODUCTION1ARGUMENT1
1.
CALIFORNIALAWPROHIBITSTHEPROPOSEDORDINANCE1
6
BusinessandProfessionsCodeSection460(b)ExpresslyPreemptsTheProposedOrdinance1TheLegislativeHistoryOfSection460(b)ConfirmsThatTheLegislatureIntendedToPreventCitiesandCountiesFromInterferingWithTheRegulationOfMedicalServices,WhichIsAMatterOfStatewideConcern3PREELECTIONRELIEFISAPPROPRIATE
8
A.
B.
7
8
9
II.
A.
TheOrdinanceIsClearlyInvalidAndThereforeMayNotBeSubmittedToTheVoters
8
TheOrdinanceCannotBeSavedBySeverance9TheInitiativeThreatensToDepriveSanFranciscoVotersOfFundamentalRightsAndHoldingAnElectionOnThisInitiativeWouldFomentReligiousDivisiveness101.TheInitiativeThreatensTheRightOfParentsToDirectTheirChildren'sReligiousUpbringingAndMedicalCare10
B.C.
TheInitiativeThreatensTheRightOfMatureTeenageBoysToMakeDecisionsAboutTheirBodies12TheInitiativeThreatensReligiousFreedom
13
TheLawSupportsRemovingAnInvalidInitiativeFromTheBallot,ParticularlyWhereTheCampaignFostersReligiousDivisiveness14CONCLUSION152.
3.
4.
-1-
 
CROWELL
&
MORING
LLP
ATTORNEYSATLAW
8910
11
12
13
1415161718192021
22
232425262728
1
[PROPOSED]BRIEFOF
AMICUSCURIAE
ACLU-NCINSUPPORTOFPET.FORWRITOFMANDATE;CASENO.CPF-II-SI1370
TABLEOFAUTHORITIES
2
Page(s)
34
CASES
Am.Acad.ofPediatrics
v.
Lungren,
16Cal.4th307(1997)13
5
6
Am.Fed'nofLabor
v.
Eu,
36Cal.3d687(1984)8,9,107
Bighorn-DesertViewWaterAgency
v.
Verjil,
39Cal.4th205(2006)8
CaliforniaVeterinaryMedicalAss'n
v.
CityofWestHollywood,
152Cal.App.4th536(2007)3,4
CitizensforResponsibleBehavior
v.
SuperiorCourt,
1Cal.App.4th1013(1991)10,14,15
CityandCountyofSanFrancisco
v.
Patterson,
202Cal.App.3d95(1988)9,10
CityofAtascadero
v.
Daly,
135Cal.App.3d466(1982)10
CityofSanDiego
v.
Dunkl,
86Cal.App.4th384(2001)8,9
CityofWatsonville
v.
StateDep
't
ofHealthSvcs.,
133Cal.App.4th216(2005)2
Comm.ofSevenThousand
v.
SuperiorCourt,
45Cal.3d491(1988)2,8
Debottari
v.
CityCouncil,
171Cal.App.3d1204(1985)9
NorthernCal.PsychiatricSoc
y
v.
CityofBerkeley,
178Cal.App.3d90(1986)2,5,12
Parham
v.
JR.,
442U.S.584(1979)11,12
PlannedParenthood
v.
Danforth,
428U.S.52(1976)13
SantaFeIndependentSchoolDistrict
v.
Doe,
530U.S.290(2000)"14
-11-
SFACTIVE-099401.0002187\902339146.2

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->