2008 ,

,-.
.

,2008

,20 92186
2008, The Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies
The Hay Elyachar House
20 Radak St. 92186 Jerusalem
http://www.jiis.org.il

E-mail: machon@jiis.org.il


,
. ,
, .
: , , .
' "
. , ,
. - .
" .
.
, ,
, - .
.


, :
" ,
.
. '
.
' ' .
,
. , ,
- , , .
,
:' , , ,
.


9
..1 15
..2 21
..3 25
.3.1 25
.3.2 25
.3.3 27
..4 32
.4.1 32
.4.2 - 35
.4.3 - 44
.4.4
.. 49
.4.5 - 75
.4.6 88
.4.7 89
.4.8 -
.. 94
..5 107
.5.1 107
.5.2 111
- 117
119


,
. - ,
- ,
- .
,
, (// ,31// ,35//.)21/3/

,

.

- . ,
, ,
.

-
: (- ,- ,- ,- ) ,
( , ) ( ) .
:
, 199( 2007 67.2%
); - ,
1 - 97( 2007 32.8% ).
,
.
. -
.
1 ,
( ),
9


, :


, :
-
,
.
- , -
. ,

- .
, ,
, .
.
, ,
,
.

) -

- -
,
, .
- -
.
. -
,
" ( -)
.
10

 - - ,
, -
, .
( )
.
:
,
, -
-.
, - ,
, - ,
.

) -
- ,
- .
-

. -
, -
(") .
-
, , .

.
,
.
,
.
11

) -


, " " .
"
, " .
, -
- .
- ,
( -) ;
" .
,
. ,
.
,
.
- 54-45 -
; ( )44-23
( 55).
- (

)44-23 ( ,)55
.

)
- .
.

.
12

 , ,
, ,
- , () ,
, .

-
,
. ,-

.

(
) ,
- ,
.
"" ,
.
" : "
" - "
, -
, ,
- .
,
.
( , ') , .
,
-
. ,
13


.
- . -
, -
-
.

, ,
, .,
, ,
, - ( zoning
) ,
.

.
,
, - .
( -)
, , ,
.
.

14

 .1
,
. -
. -
,
. -
90- (- .)1998 ,
, , ,
,
( ;Kislev, Lerman and Zusman, 1991 ;Kimhi, 1998.)2004 ,
, ,
"-" ( , .,
. .)2007 , , ,
,
.

70- 20- ,
. ,

.
,

. ,- , ,
, (;Robinson, 2004
;Sofer, 2001; 2005 .)2007 ,
, - , (Roberts and Hall, 2001; Garrod et
;al., 2006 .)2007 ,
15

 , - ,
, - ,
( , .)2005 ,
.
, ,
- .
-
- . -
, ,
. - ( )2005
,
. " " ( ' )2004 ,
.
(" ")
. ,
, -
( , ') . ,- ,
, - , .

.

. -
. 1997-1996 36%
,
50% ) .(Sofer, 2001
- ,- ,
,- ,- , ' ,
.
-

- -
. , ,
16

 , ( ,)2004 ,
.
- :- ,
-
.- ,
,- , .
,
( .)2004 ,
,
( .)1995 ,

( .)Feitelson, 1999 // 31
" " . ,
(// )21/3 .
" ,35 , ,
,
." 35 " --"
, , .
, ,
. ,
- , (
) . ,
.
-
, ,
.
,
.

, ,
- ,
( ;2005 , ,
17

 ;2004 , , , ;2004 , ;2004 ,-;2002 ,

.)2005 ,

, ,
,
. :
( , ;)2005 ,

( ;)2004 ,

( ;)2007 , -

( , . , .)2007 ,
, ,
-
( .)2007 ,
(
,)2007 ,
- ,
, ,
- .
,
- .

- ,
.
, ,
, ,
-
( .)2007 ,
,
18

( .)1
.
( - ,
") ()

.
:1.1

19


:
)1 ,-
;
)2 ( ) -
- ,
" "" -;
)3 (,
) ,
.

20

 .2

.

.2

, ,
.
- , ,- ,-
. 31 , 19- ,
. - : ' ,5
' 6- . - :
, -
. .
- ,
: ,-
- , - (
) .
.

21,244 :
-6,188 :
95,063 :
2
- ,
.
3 :" ;2005 , , .2002-2001
21

 - : 7
: , ,- ,
: 47,800 -


,
. :4
- ,- (
, 30- ,)20-- ,- (
);
( , ,)30-
( ) .
.
: ""
1995 750- ,
,1981 1981- ,1988 15- ,
2005 240-.
( - , " ,
" ) . .

-
( ;2004 , , , .)2005 ,
- , -
-
- - ,
, . ,
,
.
4 .
22

 , , -
( , ,- ) , - (
) , ,
,
- . '
( ;)3-1
, " .
-
:
. , ,
.
- ,
- .
.
( , - ,- ,-)

;
. ( , )
.
,

.
,
,

. , - (
- , ,- ) ,- ,
,- ,
( , , ,-),
, ' ,
.
23

 , .
-
. , --
. ,
, - ,
'.
, ,
,
," .
,
-

.

24

 .3
3.1
,
.

.-
, ,
:
,:


;

;

.
,:

-
;
"" ,

, .

3.2
. ,
- ,

.
25

 .
, , ,
, "" ' . , ,
"" ( -,
- ) "" ( -).
, ,
.
,
- , - .
.
-
( , ) .
( , ) - , (
"-") ,
' .
.
,
- " , ,
.
.
:

. -
. ,
( , ) ( .)1
. ,
- ,
- .
-
.-
-
26

 .
.
.
, -
.
.

- , :
. -
; , .
,
.
,,
.

3.3
- ) (Pilot
- (
); - ,
, . ,Pilot-
, .
,
. " 296 .,
: -.
,
2007" 199 (67.2%
) ,
- .
:
27

:
-

18

56.3

14

43.7

"

32

100

15

16.3

17

18.5

--

13

14.1

--

15

16.3

32

34.8

"

92

100

41

54.7

30

40.0

- -

5.3

"

75

100

"

199

*67.2

* )199( 67.2% (.)296

,
.

28

 ,- ,
, 5 (- .)2007
: ( )
, ;
(
) ." 97
( 32.8% ) . ( 27% )
( 16%-) . :

44

45.4

23

23.7

30

30.9

"

97

100

- .JMP
- .
- , - - (
, , , ') ,
- .
.

5 ,
.
29

 :1 -

:2 -

30

 :3 -

31

 .4

.

- - - ,-
- . -
.
,
.

4.1
4.1 - .
" " .
.
:4.1 - -

32

127

100

92

100

75

100

34-23
44-35
54-45
64-55
+65

16
21
28
42
20

12.6
16.5
22.1
33.1
15.7

24
23
17
22
6

26.1
25.0
18.5
23.9
6.5

13
30
23
8
1

17.3
40.0
30.7
10.7
1.3

 :4.1 - -
()

'

'

128

100

92

100

75

100

8


' /"

' /"

27
35

21.1
27.3

1
27
17

3.3
29.3
18.5

1
11
9

1.3
14.7
12.0

55

43.0

28

30.4

39

52.0

11

8.6

17

18.5

20.0

128

100

92

100

75

100

/
/

99

77.3

69

75.0

65

86.7

29

22.7

23

25.0

10

13.3

116

100

92

100

75

100

2-1
+3

61
33
22

52.6
28.4
19.0

40
25
27

43.5
27.2
29.3

7
39
29

9.3
52.0
38.7

127

100

92

100

75

100

,,
"

"

113
6

89.0
4.7

80
9

87.0
9.8

65
5

86.7
6.7

2
6

1.6
4.7

2
1

2.2
1.1

4
1

5.3
1.3

128

100

92

100

75

100

28
68
32

21.9
53.1
25.0

2
22
68

2.2
23.9
73.9

3
10
62

4.0
13.3
82.7
33

 ,
. ,
:
. ,
( ) ( .)72%- ,

- -
.

, .
,
- - , 87%- .
.
, , .
- ( ,)89% -
. ,
,
.
-
,
2003- ( .)2004 ,
4.2 .

34

 :4.2

116

100

92

100

75

100

5.2

19

20.6

16

21.3

10-6

2.6

10

10.9

27

36.0

20-11

10

8.6

11

12.0

29

38.7

30-21

26

22.4

16

17.4

1.3

40-31

22

19.0

12

13.0

1.3

50-41

13

11.2

9.8

50-

36

31.0

15

16.3

1.3

"

,
.
- .
. 60%-
30- , 39% .
, "" 10 ,
( 31.5% 7.8%) .
.

4.2 -
,
. ,
35

 :
.
4.3 /.

:4.3

"

129

100

92

100

75

100

112

86.8

3.1

1.6

9.8

6.7

35

38.0

70

93.3

47

51.1

1.1

11

8.5

,
- 38% . - 10%- .
87%- , 3%--
; 1.6% . 93%-
- , 7% - .
4.4
.

36

 :4.4

"
/*
:
-

125

100

92

100

75

100

63

50.4

5.4

42

33.6

40

43.5

53

70.7

7.2

35

38.0

15

20.0

3.2

4.3

1.3

5.6

8.8

8.0

"

126

100

92

100

75

100

:
-

76

60.3

30

32.6

9.3

4.8

6.5

9.3

28

22.2

46

50.0

54

72.0

16

12.7

10

10.9

9.4

* ,
, .

, ,
34%- 7%- ; 60%-
, 5%- 22%- . 5%-
.
37

- ( ,)2004 , 21%-
;
- ( .)2007 , 43%-
- , 38% .
( 33% ,)60%
- ( 59% .)22%

( ,)4.1 -
( )72%
.
(.)71%-

:4.1
-
9.3% ,

6.7% ,

2.7% ,

81.3% ,

4.2
.
38

 :4.2 /
96.0

100
89.8

72.8

90
80
70
60

40
30
12.0

10.9
2.2

5.5

0.8 2.2

50%-

2.7

50%

20

1.3

10

3.9

50%-

. 27%- , ,
15%- 50% . ,
90%- . 5.5%-
.

- ( ;2007 , .)2005 ,
.
4.3 73%- " " . 4%
, 50%- (
.)4.2 - . 5%-
, 17%--
.
39

50

 :4.3
4.0% ,
13.3% ,

, 5.3% ,

4.0% ,

73.3% ,

, ,
, .
4.4 .
:4.4
80

76.0
68.5
63.0

70

60
50

30
17.4

15.0 15.2 14.7

2.7

4.4

7.9

20
8.7

6.7

10
0

40

40

 ,
( .)4.2 ,
63% 68% . ,
, (
, ;)4.1
- . ,

( 17% .)9%
"" ,
, .33%- , .
: 96%
( ,)4.2
76% . -
, , 21%-
. ,
.
,
. ,
, 10%-
.
.16%-
, - (
) " " :
. - 7%-
. ,
- . - ,
( 13 17- ) .
.
.

,
. 4.5 .
41

 :4.5
70

66.7

62.5

60

52.2

47.8

50

26.6

26.6

40
30
20
10.9

10

6.7

, , ,

:
,
( ,)4.4 .,
( )4.4 ( )4.5

. , 48%-
- .
( )26%- .
,
,
- ( .)1 4.5
.
42

 :4.5 ()

14

15.2

18

19.6

15

16.3

24

26.1

20

21.7

7.6

"

*106.7

* " ( 100% )92

.

,
, ,
. " :
"" , "" , "
.
- ,
: 33 ,
55%-
. , 24%- ,
. 12%- .
.
( 20),

( .)65% " "
43

 . 7%-
.
" " . ,
- . ,
- ,
, .

.

4 .3 -

-
, ( ) , ,
,
- .
) .Cross-Tab (Chi-Square Test
.

:
- ( ).

44

 :4.6 :

"

- -

26.3%
34.2%
39.5%

16.7%
16.7%
66.6%

7.10%
17.9%
75.0%

)23( 20.9%
)32( 29.1%
)55( 50.0%

"

100%

100%

100%

100%

pv=0.051

34-23
44-35
54-45
+55

5.3%
17.3%
21.3%
56.1%

0.0%
16.7%
33.3%
50.0%

32.1%
21.4%
14.3%
32.2%

)13( 11.9%
)20( 18.4%
)22( 20.2%
)54( 49.5%

"

100%

100%

100%

100%

pv=0.019

:4.7 :

"

- -

30.2%
27.0%
42.8%

10.3%
20.5%
69.2%

11.1%
55.6%
33.3%

)24( 21.6%
)30( 27.0%
)57( 51.4%

"

100%

100%

100%

100%

pv=0.018
45

 - ,
. , -
- ( " ).
:4.8 :

"

50.0%
23.3%
26.7%

50.0%
50.0%
0.0%

8.7%
15.2%
76.1%

)23( 20.9%
)32( 29.1%
)55( 50.0%

"

100%

100%

100%

100%

pv<0.0001

, -
:- -
, .
4.9 ,
.

46

 :4.9 :
50%

50%-

"

- -

57.1%
7.2%
35.7%

28.2%
20.5%
51.3%

)30( 32.6%
)17( 18.5%
)45( 48.9%

P=0.091
:
34-23
44-35
54-45
+55

14.2%
0.0%
42.9%
42.9%

28.2%
29.5%
14.1%
28.2%

)24( 26.1%
)23( 25.0%
)17( 18.5%
)28( 30.4%

"

100%

100%

100%

pv=0.003

:4.10 :

"

- -

45.5%
20.4%
34.1%

20.8%
16.7%
62.5%

)30( 32.6%
)17( 18.5%
)45( 48.9%

"

100%

100%

100%

pv=0.014
47

 :4.11 : ,

- -

54.1%
21.6%
24.3%

20.0%
14.3%
65.7%

22.2%
11.1%
66.7%

)23( 20.9%
)32( 29.1%
)55( 50.0%

"

100%

100%

100%

1005

pv=0.004
:
34-23
44-35
54-45
+55

16.2%
8.1%
27.0%
48.7%

17.1%
42.9%
14.3%
25.7%

55.6%
33.3%
11.1%
0.0%

)13( 11.9%
)20( 18.4%
)22( 20.2%
)54( 49.5%

"

100%

100%

100%

100

pv=0.0004
:

62.5%
9.4%
28.1%

19.4%
0.0%
80.6%

11.1%
11.1%
77.8%

)27( 37.5%
)4( 5.6%
)41( 56.9%

"

100%

100%

100%

100

pv<0.0001
:

( , , )

43.2%
56.8%

82.9%
17.1%

77.9%
22.1%

)52( 64.2%
)29( 35.8%

"

100%

100%

100%

100

pv=0.001

:

73.0%
27.0%

25.7%
74.3%

22.2%
77.8%

)38( 46.9%
)43( 53.1%

"

100%

100%

100%

100

pv<0.0001
48

 ( )4.11 ,
( -) -

. - ,
.
- ,
- (.)2007
, ,

, :-
,
.
, -
.

4 .4


,
,
- .
, ,
.
- ( , ') ,
- ( ,- ,- ')
(- , ,- ') , ,
(
) .

. , 5 (
49

) , 1 ( - )
( .)1
1( 2- )2
- . ,
- ,
, - "" ( )4 " " ( )5
, " " ( )1 "
" ( )2 .
- . :
" " "" , "" " "
. 3 "" " ,
" - .
,
4.14-4.12 ( 4.8-4.6 ,
() - )
( 4.13
) .

, ( , ),
(,
, 4.12 )4.6 . ,
-
( , - -;
, ,
) . , 4.13
- .
,
- -
- - . ,
- ,
, -,
50

 .
.

-

- ( )
- ,
(T-test) T
.
, ,
. (
) ,4.14-4.12
4.8-4.6 .


- .
4.12 4.6 .

51

 :4.12 -
-

/- ( :)


()1

()2

()3

- ( ,-)*

4.24

3.74

-*

4.22

3.81

3.94

4.07

-*

2.69

3.77

3.22

:-,
, , '**

2.70

3.99

3.99

,
*

2.32

3.85

3.48

/ ,:
, ,- ,'**

2.93

4.09

4.12

2.30

3.82

3.07

- ***

2.76

3.99

-*

1.99

3.60

3.08

3.92

4.03

3.75

* 5%.
** ( )2 ( )3 ,
5%.
*** 10%.

52

 :4.6
-
3.74

4.24

3.81

4.22

4.07
3.94
4.03
3.92

3.75

4.12
4.09

2.93

3.99

2.7
3.22

3.77
3.85

3.48

2.32
3.07

2.3
3.08

3.6

2.69

3.82

4.5

2.76

3.99
3.99

1.99

3.5

2.5

1.5

,
- , - . :
. -
- .
.
, , :
:-,

, (
.)4 , ( )3
53

 ,

,
, .
, (
)3-- .
, , ,- ',
, - , , ' ,
,
.
-

, .
-

.
-
, , ,
, 5%
( .)4.12 , ,
.

4.13 4.7 .

54

 :4.13 -
/- ( :)


()1

()2

()3

- ( ,-)***

4.30

4.04

-*

4.30

3.91

4.21

3.95

-**

2.88

3.35

3.26

:-,
, , '**

2.68

3.52

3.46

,
*

2.27

3.14

2.82

/ ,:
, ,- ,'*

3.18

3.71

3.95

2.31

3.02

2.67

- *

2.42

3.09

( 3.91-

'
)

-*

1.54

2.70

2.35

3.85

3.93

3.77

* , 5%.
** ( )2 ( )3 .
5%.
*** 10%.

55

 :4.7
-
4.3
4.3
4.21

4.04

3.91

3.95

3.77
3.93
3.85

3.95

3.71

3.18
3.26
3.35

2.88

3.46
3.52

3.91

4.5

3.09

3.14

2.42
2.67

2.31
2.82

2.27
2.7

2.68

3.02

3
3.5

2.35

1.54

2.5

1.5

" , /"
- , .
.

,
.

, , ,- ' ,
- . , ,
.
( 5% .)4.13
56

 ( - , , ')
,
( 4.12.)4.13-
,

( 3.09 3.99).
-

( ,1 );
( )3.91 -
( .)4.7
,- , ,

( 3.35 3.77) . ,
, ,
, ;
, , (
4.12.)4.13-
- , ,
, . ,
- .
- ,
.

4.14 4.8 .

57

 :4.14 -

/- ( :)


()1

()2

()3

- ( ,-)****

4.38

4.03

4.17

4.12

4.29

4.17

- ()**

2.57

3.43

3.64

:-,
, , '*

2.63

3.67

4.07

,
*

1.89

3.05

3.44

/ ,:
, ,- ,'*

2.23

3.20

3.81

**

1.43

2.47

2.64

- *

1.75

2.96

( 3.81-

'
)

-**

1.30

2.31

2.64

***

3.11

3.27

3.72

5%.
*
** ( )2 ( )3 .
5%.
*** ( )1 ( )2 .
5%.
**** 10%.
58

 :4.8
-
4.38

4.03

4.17
4.29

4.12
4.17

3.72

4.07

3.27

3.11

3.67
3.64

3.43

2.57
3.2

3.44
3.81

3.05

1.89

2.96

2.64

1.75
2.64
2.47

3.5

2.23

4.5

2.63

3.81

1.43

2.31

2.5

1.3

1.5

,
- - ,- -
. : ,
. ,-
" "
- . 4.14 :
( , ,)
, .
,
. ,
59

 - .
,
.

.
(- , , ') ,
/ ( , ')
( )
.
.5%
, -
, - ,
- .
-
, - , -.
, -
, -
.

-
, .
( ,)1
" . ,
:- , - ( ),
( ) , , ,- '.
, -
, - . -
:6

6 .
60

 ,-
" ".
- ,-

,+40 " ,-" , ,-
- , . ,
- ,-
, ' , ,
"".
: ,
- , ,- ,-,
" " ,-
" ".

4.14-4.12 ,4.8-4.6

( )
. ,

, 4.9 4.10- .7

:
.

7
, 4.16 ,
- .
61

 :4.9
- -
5

0
inres

halls

ofce

store

fbld

attrc

cmrc

zmr

sprt

edc-
cltr-
sprt-
zmr- ()
cmrc ( ,- , , ")
attrc "
fbld /
store
office-
halls-
inres

62

cltr

edu

 :4.10
-
5

0
halls outres

ofce

store

fbld

attrc

cmrc

zmr

sprt

cltr

edu

edc-
cltr-
sprt-
zmr- ()
cmrc ( ,- , , ")
attrc , "
fbld /
store
office-
halls-
outres

63

 -
- , :
- , (
) ( , : ,-,
')
.
-
, - .
,- ,
( ) ,
, ,- , -,
- .
- - , -
, .
,
- - .

:
-

,
.
, -
.
,
.

- -
.
64

 , - -
,
. ,
- ( ),
- ,
.
- -
,
- .

-
,
( )
, -
, ,
( ) - ( , ') ,
. 4.13-4.11
( ) -
( 5 .)4- ( 2 .)2
4.11 , ,
- .

65

 4.11

100.0
88.0

91.2

90.2
86.4
80.0

76.0

77.2

79.2

80.0

75.6

70.0

70.7

67.7
59.3

60.0

59.2

72.8

70.0
62.7
57.0

48.0

55.6

60.0
50.0

47.0
37.2

40.0

33.3

30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0

),
,

'(

:
,
(- ) ,
.
,
, ,
- , ,
, .
- . :
- ( , )
66

55.4

90.0

 .
- .
-
.
(-) .

( ,)4.1

(
.)2007 , ,
" " , /
,
. ,
- , .
.
, -
- , -
.
(- )
, -
.

-
- , .
,
- , .
, ,
.

4.12 , ,
, .
67

 :4.12 ,

100.0

94.7
90.7

87.1

88.5
82.4

78.3

72.0

68.5

62.6

90.0
80.0

68.0

70.0
62.1

44.4

46.4

50.0
40.0

33.1

30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0

,

/,

"

)(

:
,
, , ,
.
-
( ,)4.11
.
68

52.7

54.7

55.6

58.7

60.0

 :
- ,
.
:
.
4.13 - ,
- , .
:4.13

100.0

78.7

77.6

90.0
80.0

68.0 67.4
64.0

70.0

58.8

60.0

40.8

24.0

22.0

27.6
24.0

40.0
29.3

33.3

22.0

32.0
27.2
21.3

30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0

,:
,

"

,
:

"

)
,

'(

69

48.8

50.0

 :
, -
,
. - .

.
( ,- , )
,
,
.
,
.
( , )
,
(
) ( 22% ).
( , ')

, .

, :
- , ( ,)4.13

- ( , ,)4.11
( .)4.12
,

- ( .)2007 ,
,
( )
-.
70

 .
( )
-
. , , -
- ,
,
.

,
- ,
( 4.14 - )( 4.15 ,
-) ( 4.16- - - , ).
( 3 .)2
:
.

71

 :4.14

5

0
fbld

fresrv

fanimls

pstr

grnhs

sgrnhs

fcrops

plants

plants ,
fcrops-
sgrnhs (-)
grnhs
pstr
fanimls - ( , , , ,)
fresrv-
fbld / ( , ')

72

 :4.15

5

0
attrc

rurattrc

zmr

rlakes

tlands

nlands

nlands
tlands , / , -
rlakes
zmr- ()
rurattrc , -
attrc

73

 :4.16

5

0
envbld

bld

halls

cmrc

store

mincmrc

mincmrc ( ,- , , ')
store
cmrc (- )
halls-
bld
envbld ( , ')

74

 -
, :
,
( , ),
/ ,
- -
- .
- ,
-
, . ,
, -
.
,
;
.
, ,
- , ,
( 4.9
4.10 - 4.15.)4.16-

4 .5 -

-
,
, -
.

75


,8

.
- ,
-
. , 5
1 - . 4.16 ,4.15 4.18-
.
, - ,
: "" ( )4 " "
( )5 , "
" ( )1 " " ( )2 .
4.19-4.17
( 4 )5- - .

.
, .
- , ,
, .

4.15 4.17 -
.

8 (
, ,)1
.
76

 :4.15

"

"

"

*

125

100

92

100

75

100

113
11
1

90.4
8.8
0.8

83
7
2

90.2
7.6
2.2

68
3
4

90.7
4.0
5.3

125

100

92

100

75

100

61
30
34

48.8
24.0
27.2

46
18
28

50.0
19.6
30.4

46
15
14

61.3
20.0
18.7

126

100

92

100

75

100

111
12
3

88.1
9.5
2.4

74
13
5

80.4
14.1
5.5

49
17
9

65.3
22.7
12.0

75

100

21
12
42

28.0
16.0
56.0

"

* - , .1%

77

 :4.17
100.0

90.7

88.1

90.4 90.2

80.4

65.3

90.0
80.0
70.0

61.3

60.0

40.0
28.0

30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0

4.15 ,4.17
: 90%-
.
.

,
,
. ,
, "" .
,

).(p=0.004
78

50.0

48.8

50.0

 ,

( , ) , . 28%
, 56%- .

4.16 4.18
.
:4.16

"

* ( )

"

*

"
*

"


-

124

100

92

100

75

100

110
14
-

88.7
11.3
-

78
9
4

85.7
9.9
4.4

53
10
12

70.7
13.3
16.0

122

100

91

100

75

100

104
12
6

85.2
9.9
4.9

59
26
6

64.8
28.6
6.6

49
16
10

65.4
21.3
13.3

125

100

92

100

75

100

111
12
2

88.8
9.6
1.6

67
17
8

72.8
18.5
8.7

55
12
8

73.3
16.0
10.7

118

100

92

100

75

100

76
26
16

64.4
22.0
13.6

51
25
16

55.4
27.2
17.4

* - , .1%
79

 :4.18
100.0

88.8

85.7

85.2

88.7

90.0
80.0

72.8 73.3

70.7
65.4

64.4

64.8

70.0
60.0
50.0

55.4

40.0
30.0
20.0
10.0
0.0
:

4.16 4.18 :
, ,
-
.
,
.

.

80

 :
,

- ,
).(<0.0001
- , (
)

.

;
).(p=0.001
,
, . 73%-
,
,
, ).(p=0.01

( ,-,
) .,
, - .
, .

,
. 4.17
.

81

 :4.17

*16

*6

/ /

" *

/-

* ,
.

,
. ,
. ,
.
( .)4.11 ,

( .)4.5 , ,
" " " ".

-
4.18 4.19 -
.

82

 :4.18 -

"
"*

"
"*

"


-

"
"



,

"
"

"
"

127

100

92

100

75

100

109
14
4

85.8
11.0
3.2

56
14
22

60.9
15.2
23.9

43
18
14

57.3
24.0
18.7

126

100

92

100

75

100

89
21
16

70.6
16.7
12.7

44
25
25

45.6
27.2
27.2

35
21
19

46.7
28.0
25.3

126

100

92

100

75

100

24
21
83

18.8
16.4
64.8

14
19
59

15.2
20.6
64.2

22
12
41

29.3
16.0
54.7

127

100

92

100

75

100

116
9
2

91.3
7.1
1.6

77
10
5

83.7
10.9
5.4

70
3
2

93.3
4.0
2.7

122

100

92

100

75

100

71
26
25

58.2
21.3
20.5

57
18
17

62.0
19.6
18.4

47
16
12

62.7
21.3
16.7

122

100

92

100

75

100

58
21
48

45.7
16.5
37.8

46
20
26

50.0
21.7
28.3

44
12
19

58.7
16.0
25.3

* , .1%
83

 :4.19 -
100.0
93.3

91.3
85.8

83.7

80.0
70.6

62.0 62.7

58.7

90.0

58.2

70.0
57.3

50.0

45.6 46.7

45.7

40.0
29.3

30.0
15.2

18.8

20.0
10.0
0.0

"

"

"

"

"

"

4.18 4.19 :
-
. , -
, -
;
-
, ;
);(p<0.0001
-
:
84

50.0

60.9

60.0

 ,
;(p=0.001) 1%
:
- .
-
;
-
,
.
, ;
- ,
- .
, "
, .
,
.
,
( 3) . "" )1 :
; )2 3
; ,
- - ( )4.18
"" ( , )
.
, "
-" ( ,)4.16 .
, " ( )4.18
( ,)4.15
.
4.20 ,

85

 .
:
.
:4.20
5

0
10 11 12

:
1 " .
2 .
3 " .
4 - .
5 .
6 : (-).
7 : .
8 : .
9" .
10 .
11 "
, .
12" .
86

 , :
( ) ;
, -
( ' 2.)9-
, "
( ' .)11 ,
( ' .)2
-
, - -
( ' .)1
,
, ( ' 7 ,6.)8-


-
( ' .)12
. ,

( ' .)5

. ,
- .

,

, ( , ,
') . ) Cross-Tab (Chi-Square Test
- -
, . : -
87

 "" .

- , .
, : 55%-
- ; 37%-
10%- ( 10% ,60% 30%- ,);
51%- " , 37%-
12%- ( %17% ,43% 40%- ,).

4.6
,
-; ,
. 4.19 .

. ,
.
, . ,
30%- ,
18%- .

, . 40%
.

88

 :4.19

127

100

92

100

75

100

35

27.6

24

26.1

9.3

38

29.9

45

48.9

28

37.3

1.6

6.7

23

18.1

1.1

2.7

24

18.9

18

19.6

31

41.3

3.9

4.3

2.7

4.7
,
, ; ,
, ""
(- , , ').
-
,
(-
" ") .
( )1
.

;
. " :
/ /
89

 ?" .
.
, ,
"".
-
.
( 4.21 ) 9
.4.20

9 ,
.
90

 4.20

"
-

"

"

"

"

118

100

24

100

5
32
28
42
11

4.2
27.1
23.8
35.6
9.3

2
3
12
7

8.3
12.5
50.0
29.2

125

100

24

100

3
56
26
30
10

2.4
44.8
20.8
24.0
6.0

7
5
7
5

29.2
20.8
29.2
20.8

123

100

24

100

3
51
33
26
10

2.4
41.6
26.8
21.1
8.1

6
5
7
6

25.0
20.8
29.2
25.0

121

100

24

100

3
57
27
22
12

2.4
47.2
22.3
18.2
9.9

5
5
8
6

20.8
20.8
33.4
25.0

122

100

24

100

2
51
37
20
12

1.6
41.8
30.4
16.4
9.8

8
2
9
5

33.4
8.3
37.5
20.8
91

1.6

2.4

2.4

2.4

4.2

:4.21

0.0

30.4

41.8

22.3

47.2

26.8

41.6

20.8

44.8

27.1
20.0

16.4

9.8

18.2

9.9

21.1

8.1

24.0

9.3

35.6

23.8
40.0

60.0

8.0

80.0

100.0

120.0

,
. )1 :
,

; )2
; )3
, ,
.
, 27%-
,

.
"" , ,
, .
92

 24 , ( 26% ) ,
. ,
( .)4.20
, ,

" "
("" "").
" " ,
- .
()
,- 75 .
( 60% ) . 4.21
, - .
:4.21

"
.1
.2 ,
.3

.4
,
.5
.6
,
.7
.8 ,
.8
.10

*75
24
19
13

32.0
25.3
17.3

10

13.3

8
6

10.7
8.0

5
5
3
3

6.7
6.7
4.0
4.0

* " ,100% .
93

 4.21 -
,
( ,)1 (,)3
( ,)4 -
( .)5- , ""
( ,) ( )2 "" ( )
( .)8 , "
" ( ,)7 ,
.
, , .
,
- . , 8% -
" " " "
.
,
20 .
24 ,
. ,
,
( 8) . (
) . , -
, , .
" ".

4.8 -

,
- . - ,
, -
94

 ,
- .

. 11 ,
, ( .)4.5
. , ,
.
, ( 11)
"" .
- .,
,
- " " .
,
1- ,5 .
() ,
.
:
: , ( 1 )2 ,

( ) , ( 3 );
-

23 : ( ,
,/ ,)1 ,
( 1- ) ( 5 );
-
20 : ( ,/
)1 , ( 1- )
( 5 );
: 1 50%-

, 0 50%-
;
95

 : 1 ""
"" , 0 "" " ";
: 1
2 ,
, 3
;
: 1
2 , , 3
;
: : 2 ,)34-23( 1
( )54-45( 3 ,)44-35 ( 4 55 );
: ( 1 )( 2 ,
" ) 3 ;
: ( 1 / ) , 2

();
- : 1 , 0 .

.
(
.)10%
10% ) .(pv<0.1 ( )b ,
.

( ) , (
) . :
,
.
,
-
96

 ( )4.22 -
( .)4.23
4.22
" -
" ( 70.7%- ).
:4.22 -
)(b

)(pv

)(x
-

0.430

0.043

<.0001

"

-0.139

0.041

0.0009

"

-0.145

0.039

0.0002

0.153

0.043

0.0005

- :
( ,,)

0.116

0.040

0.0045

-0.115

0.046

0.0124

--

0.193

0.055

0.0005

- :
-

0.078

0.038

0.0409

- ,

-0.080

0.036

0.0254

--

0.085

0.0350

0.0157

- , '

0.070

0.032

0.0288

:
44-23 54-45 - 54-45 +55

0.335
-0.260

R2

0.121
0.114

0.0061
0.0233

0.64

N = 270

97

 4.22 5%
64%- .
-
:
- ;
" ; (
) ;
"

( );
,
;

, ( ); ,-
;
,
( ); ( ) -
( -);
- ,
- ) (NIMBY

;
,54-45 , -
, ( 44-
)23 ( 55).

4.23
" -
" ( 56.6% - ).

98

 :4.23 -
)(b

)(pv

)(x
-

0.564

0.056

<.0001

"

-0.117

0.050

0.0206

-0.088

0.049

0.0712

-
:-

0.133

0.044

0.0026

-
: ,

0.064

0.036

0.0815

:
44-23 54-45 54-45 +55 R2

-0.375
0.395

0.143
0.132

0.0091
0.0030

0.52

N = 277

, - .10%
.5% .52%-
4.23 4.22 -
-
- ,
. , -
, - .
, - ,
" , :
(
);
-
;
99

 , ,

, " ( .)4.22
" - "

: - ,
( )44-23 ( ,)55
; "
( .)4.22
4.24
" " (
90.4%- ).
:4.24
)(b

)(pv

)(x

0.121

0.052

0.0211

0.120

0.042

0.0051

0.070

0.041

0.0887

:
(-)

0.129

0.052

0.0142

- :
- --

0.121
-0.159

0.040
0.043

0.0026
0.0003

:
- 45

0.359

0.119

0.0029

R2

0.29

N = 254

4.24 ,5%
;10% 29%- .
100


:
,
-
;
- - ;
- ;

45 .

4.25
" " ( 79.9%-
).
:4.25
)(b

)(pv

)(x

0.214

0.064

0.0010

0.163

0.043

0.0002

:
(-)

0.201

0.060

0.0009

- :
- ( , , ') -

0.117
0.109

0.039
0.051

0.0030
0.0337

" :
".

-0.195

0.077

0.0124

:
R2

-0.162
0.159

0.077
0.066

0.0361
0.0162

0.34

N = 255

101

 , .5%
34%- .
,
,
. , ,
"
" . "" " "

(""" ," " ") . ,
( -0.162 ,)0.159-
, "
" .
, -:
,

. , ,
, -.
,
- ;
- - ;

,
- , .

4.26
" -
" ( 50.3% - ).

102

 :4.26"
)(b

)(pv

)(x
-

-0.190

0.055

0.0007

0.162

0.073

0.0279

0.181

0.056

0.0014

0.474

0.053

<.0001

-
:

-0.065

0.038

0.0856

0.382

0.187

0.0418

: 50%-
, 50%- ,

R2

0.50

N = 278

4.26 ,10%
.5%
50%- .

- :
- ;

" ; ,
.

;
,
;
:" -
.
103

 4.27
" " ( 52.4%-
).
:4.27
)(b

)(pv

)(x

0.214

0.074

0.0040

-0.119

0.054

0.0303

0.208

0.052

<.0001

0.182

0.059

0.0024

"
,

0.134

0.068

0.0516

0.174

0.059

0.0033

-0.153

0.046

0.0009

-
:

-0.079

0.045

0.0792

" :" ""

"" " "

0.375

0.119

0.0017

R2

0.49

N = 275

,10%
.5% 49%- . :


" , " . ,
, -
, "
. ,
104

 , "" -
( ,4.4 )4.19 -
.
, :
,
,
( ,4.5
.)4.8-4.6
,
.

,
"
- " (
73.6% - ) .
. 4.28 .
:4.28
)(x

)(b

)(pv

:
--

0.347

0.055

<.0001

0.520

0.052

<.0001

: 50%-
, 50%-

0.348

0.141

0.0140

0.072

0.032

0.0274

R2

0.58

N = 280

105

 ,5% 58%-
. :
;

;
-.

,
,
. , ""
, . ,
:
"" ,
;
" : "

" - "
, -
, ,
- .

106

 .5
, ,
,
, :
- , -
.
-
. ,
-
.

5.1

,
,
;

. ,
. :
.
;
: ,

;

. , ,
107

- , -"
" " ;
,

;
- :
- .
.

-

-
,
. ,
- -
;
-
;
, "
. ,
- (
) - ,
;

, ;

,
;
108

 ,
;
- -
,
- , .

(- ) ,
. ,
, ;
-
- . ,
- ;
- ,
- . ,
;
:
,
( ,
( ,-) ,
-
-;
( )
;

.

109




,
, ;
"
;
,
. ,

, .


, ;
-,


, .
-
- ,

- ;
- (
)
;
-
;
110

 -
,
;
- ,
- .
, "
, .

. ,
.
(
);
, .
,
;
, ,
, ,
- , () , ,
, .

5.2
,
, .,
" "
. , :
111

 ,
, - ( zoning ),
.

, , -
, ,
, - . ,
- ,
.
, ,
"" .
,
"" , .

.

, , ,
, - ,

.
:
,


.
- , ,
, ,
,
-.
,
- , - .

.
112

 ,
.
( , -
, , ,') .
.

(- , , , ') .
, , ,

. , ,
,
;
- . ,:

,
- ,
.

. , "" , ,
. , :
, ,
. - ,

.
-
( "-") - ,
.
( ," ,)35 -
" ,
.
113


: -
( )
, ,
.
,
,
( , )2007 ,
- , :
,
- - , -
;
-


()
;
-
.

- .- :
-
;
-

, ;
,
;

- ,
;
114


,
;
, , ,
.
:
- , ( ,
)
- . -
- - ,
,
.
.
- ,
- . ,
( - )
" "
(// .)21/3 /
( " , ") .
, -
- ( ,- ,,
) ,
. ,
- .
( , , )
-
. , :
,
: , , ;
115

() ;

,
, (""
" :" , , ').
- , ,
, ().

- .

,
- - ,
( ) - ( , .)2007 ,

, ,
-.

,
, .
-


. ( -) ,
,
. .

116

-
,. " ,2004 ,. " ,
, ,.
,. ,. " ,2005 ,.
" -" " ,
, ,
,. ,. ,. " ,2007 ,. -
: " ," , ".
- " ,2005 ,. - " ,
.
,. " ,1998 ,. " ,
,.
" ,2004 ,. " ,
,.
, .2005 ,
,. " ,2007 ,. :
" ,.94-123 :63 ,
,. " ,2005 ,. -
" , ,.
,2004 , ,2001-2002
.
,1995 ,. , 42-
.22-7 :43
,. " ,2007 ,. , :
" , .
,.' " ,2004 ,. " ,
.
117

 - " ,2005 ,
. , , ,"
- " ,2004 ,. ,. ,. ,. ,.
, , ,"
.6-5
"," " ,2004 ,. ,.
, . ,"
.
" ," " ,2002 ,. -
.) ( "
Feitelson E., 1999, Social norms, rationales and policies: reframing farmland
protection in Israel, Journal of Rural Studies, 15: 431-446.
Garrod B., R. Wornell and R. Youell, 2006, "Re-conceptualizing rural resources
as countryside capital: The case of rural tourism", Journal of Rural
Studies, 22 (1): 117-128.
Kimhi A., 1998, "Institutional environment, ideological commitment, and farmers'
time allocation: the Case of Israeli moshavim", Economic Development
and Cultural Change, 47: 27-44.
Kislev Y., Z. Lerman and P. Zusman, 1991, "Recent experience with cooperative
farm credit in Israel", Economic Development and Cultural Change,
39: 773-789.
Roberts L. and D. Hall, 2001, Rural Tourism and Recreation: Principles to
Practice. CABI, Wallingford.
Robinson G., 2004, Geographies of Agriculture: Globalization, Restructuring
and Sustainability. Pearson Education Limited, Harlow.
Sofer M., 2001, "Pluriactivity in the Moshav: family farming in Israel", Journal
of Rural Studies, 17: 363-375.
Sofer M., 2005, "The future of family farming in Israel: The second generation in
the Moshav", The Geographical Journal, 171: 357-368.

118

 1

.1 / / _________________
.2 ?
/ / - / , _______________________ .3 / / ?
50% - 50% 50%- .4 ?
.5 / ?
/ ( )______________________________________________ 119

 .6 - .
/ / (
).
-

:
- ( ,-) - - ( , ,)
- () ,- , , " , " / : , ,- ,'
- - :
- ( ,-) - - ( , ,)
- () ,- , , " , " / : , ,- ,'
- --



120

1
2
3
,

 .7 -
?
-

1
2
3
4
5

:
:
, - - ( , , ,,
)



/ : ,,
- ,'
, :
, /,
,
, " , " :
, :- ,"
, :
"
-
(
)
(
, ')
121

 .8 / - ?
_________________________________________________
_______________________________________
.9 ?

-




,:
( ) -
, ______________________ -

-

,
-

122

1
2
3
4
5

 / / ,/ , , . ,
/ .11
.10 / /
?
.
( : )

:
- , ________________

? ______________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
.11 ?
, _____________ .12 :
, ____________________123

 .13 / / ?
( / // _________) .14 / /?
34-23 .
44-35 .
54-45 .
64-55 .
+65 .
.15/
. ( 8 )
. ( 12-9 )
. /"
. /"
.
.16
./ /
.____________
.17 _______________
.18 ?
.
. / ______ ______
.19 ?
. ,' _______
.
124


.1 ?
( ____________) / / , _______________________ .2 / / ?
.3 ?
50% - 50% 50%- .4 ?
.5 / ?
) ________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
)
)

125

 .6 - .
/ / (
).

:
- ( ,-) - - ( , ,)
- () ,- , , " , " / : , ,- '
- - :
- ( ,-) - - ( , ,)
- () ,- , , " , " / : , ,- ,'
- -

126

1
2
3

 .7
?
-

1
2
3
4
5

:
:
, - - ( , , ,,
)


/ :,
,- ,'
, :
, / , ,
, " , "
:
, :- ,"
, : "
-
(
)
(
, ')
127

 .8 / - ?
____________________________________________________
_______________________________________
.9 ?

-




-


-




,:
()
-
, _________________________ -

-

,
-

128

1
2
3
4
5

 .10 , ,
(' ')?
.

:
- , ____________________

, ,
? _________________________________________
___________________________________________________________
.11 ?
, _____________ .12 :
129

 .13 / / ?
( / // _________) .14 / /?
34-23 .
44-35 .
54-45 .
64-55 .
+65 .
.15/ :
. ( 8 )
. ( 12-9 )
. /"
. /"
.
.16
./ /
.____________
.17 _______________
.18 ?
.
. / ______ ______
.19 ?
. ,' _______
.
130


.1 / / / ? ______________
.2 ?
, _______________ .3 / / ?
/ / , / .4 ?
50%- 50% 50%- .5 ?
- , _______________________ .6 ?
131

 .7 ?
) ________________________________________________________
)
)
.8 - .
/ / (
)?
-

:
- ( ,-) - - ( , , ) - () ,- , , " , " / : , ,- ,'
- - :
- ( ,-) - - ( , , ) - () ,- , , " , " / : , ,- ,'
- --



132

1
2
3
4
5
,

 .9 -
?
( )
-

1
2
3
4
5

:
:
, - - ( , , ,,
)


/ :,
,- ,'
, :
, / , ,
, " , "
:
, :-, "
, : "
-
(
)
(
, ')
133

 .10 / - ?
________________________________________________
_______________________________________
.11 ?
1
2
3
4
5

-




-


-




,:
( )
, ______________________ -

(-
)
,

-



134

 .12 ?
, _____________ .13 :
, _________________________________ .14 / / ?
( / // _________) .15 / /?
34-23 .
44-35 .
54-45 .
64-55 .
+65 .
.16/
. ( 8 )
. ( 12-9 )
. /"
. /"
.
135

 .17
./ /
.____________
.18 _______________
.19 ?
.
. / ______ ______
.20 ?
. ,' _______
.

136

 2
:1 -
- ()

"
:
-- ( , )

- - ( , , ')
- () , , ,"
,
/ (,
')
-

--

129

92

*
75

83.2
8.0
8.8
80.8
11.2
8.0
70.2
11.3
18.5
26.2
23.8
50.0
27.4
23.4
49.2
17.2
16.4
66.4
36.6
15.4
48.0
14.9
20.7
64.5
27.9
26.2
45.9
10.7
17.3
71.9

85.2
9.9
4.9
82.7
8.6
8.7
82.7
8.6
8.7
32.6
25.0
42.4
31.5
17.4
51.1
21.7
14.1
64.2
50.0
17.4
32.6
20.6
22.8
56.6
25.0
20.8
54.2
3.7
7.4
87.9

84.8
6.1
7.5
77.3
4.5
16.7
80.3
7.6
10.6
21.3
30.7
48.0
26.7
17.3
53.3
8.0
10.7
81.3
16.0
18.7
65.3
2.7
4.0
83.3
2.7
14.7
80.0
3.0
97.0
137

 ( 1):

:
-- ( , )

62.7
15.3
22.0

70.4
22.2
7.4

77.3
4.5
18.2

--

64.5
16.9
18.6

63.0
25.9
11.1

78.8
9.1
12.1

- ( , , ')

75.6
14.3
10.1

69.1
21.0
9.9

81.8
6.1
12.1

-- ()

65.8
20.8
13.3

46.7
30.4
22.9

50.7
25.3
24.0

, , ,"

75.0
16.7
8.3

58.7
17.4
23.9

64.0
17.3
18.7

68.4
19.6
12.0

43.5
22.8
33.7

42.7
20.0
37.3

/ (,
')

81.0
14.9
4.1

65.2
17.4
17.4

46.7
25.3
28.0

64.5
23.1
12.4

42.4
19.6
38.0

29.3
17.3
52.0

--

71.4
21.0
7.6

43.5
21.7
34.8

42.7
16.0
40.0

59.2
17.5
23.3

32.6
17.4
50.0

24.0
10.7
64.0

138

 ( 1):

69.2
19.8
11.0

70.7
14.6
14.7

30.7
24.0
45.3

(
)

36.1
31.5
32.4

44.5
27.2
28.3

75.8
8.3
15.8

67.4
15.2
17.4

36.0
16.0
33.3

76.2
13.9
9.8

69.6
18.5
11.9

50.7
18.6
30.7

* " , " ,
( ,8 , .)1 ,
, .100-

139

 :2 -
()

"

129

92

75

:
- ,

86.4
8.8
4.8

90.2
6.5
3.3

80.0
16.0
4.0

--

91.2
6.4
2.4

88.0
7.6
4.4

76.0
17.3
6.7

57.0
29.8
13.2

72.8
13.1
14.1

62.7
24.0
13.3

59.2
25.2
15.6

70.7
16.3
13.0

60.0
22.7
17.3

37.2
23.1
39.7

55.6
17.3
27.1

47.0
21.2
31.8

- ( ,, ')

67.7
14.5
17.8

59.3
16.1
24.6

33.3
16.7
50.0

75.6
17.9
6.5

55.4
25.0
19.6

48.0
29.3
22.7

/ (,
')

79.2
17.6
3.2

77.2
14.1
8.7

70.0
18.7
10.7

140

 ( 2):

, :
-

87.1
10.5
2.4

78.3
6.5
15.2

90.7
5.3
4.0

, / ,

82.4
11.2
6.4

88.5
4.7
6.8

94.7
5.3
-

62.1
15.3
22.6

52.7
24.2
23.1

68.0
12.0
20.0

46.4
21.6
32.0

44.4
27.9
27.7

58.7
28.0
13.3

, "

68.5
16.9
14.6

62.6
20.9
16.5

72.0
17.3
10.7

, "

55.6
21.0
23.4

33.1
19.9
47.0

54.7
17.3
28.0

:
, :- , "

77.6
12.0
10.4

58.8
13.6
27.6

78.7
14.7
6.6

40.8
23.2
36.0

27.6
25.4
47.0

24.0
26.7
49.3

,: "

33.3
28.5
38.2

22.0
13.3
64.7

29.3
22.7
48.0

141

 ( 2):

48.8
16.0
35.2

68.0
16.0
16.0

67.4
18.5
14.1

( ,
')

32.0
19.2
48.8

27.2
20.6
47.8

142

22.0
20.1
57.9

24.0
28.0
48.0
64.0
24.0
12.0
21.3
14.7
64.0

 :3 -
( )

"

129

92

75

- ,

4.38

4.41

4.21

--

4.46

4.40

4.12

3.77

3.99

3.75

3.77

4.00

3.64

3.10

3.48

3.29

- - ( , , ')

3.77

3.51

2.77

4.06

3.64

3.41

/ ( , ')

4.09

3.95

3.81

,
-

4.41

4.11

4.56

, / ,

4.25

4.35

4.61

3.68

3.60

3.91

3.22

3.32

3.64

- , "

3.84

3.68

3.85

- , "

3.48

2.89

3.44

- , :- , "

3.99

3.52

4.07

3.07

2.74

2.64

, : "

2.95

2.34

2.77

3.08

2.42

2.64

3.75

3.77

3.72

( ,
)

2.71

2.54

2.36
143