Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • (Death of Dialogue)

    Uploaded by

    Debaprasad Bandyopadhyay
    4K views76 pages
    2011. “kathaar Entekaal” ( The End Of Dialogue) Unpublished Manuscript. Bangla Translation of English Papers related to “Crippled Creativity Hypothesis”. Author of this book did not have chance to recheck the second proof for some unavoidable reasons. It is a book on the end of linguistic creativity, which is being disrupted by the violent other. The de facto publisher, raghab Bandyopadhyay, a veteran journalist, had bound me to withdraw this manuscript for the following reasons: (1) he alleged that i was "too creative" in my presentation despite his caution; (2) the heterographic North Kolkatan spelling has violated the norms of his institution, viz. Charyapada. [ his allegations over phone were recorded] Paradoxically enough, this book is against the institutional control that disrupts the human creativity. Moreover, he was then too busy with his felicitation volume, i.e. he was publishing his own felicitation volume (raghob smarane) by appointing a puppet editor. Strange!!!! Author will be grateful/obliged/thankful, if readers would comment on the content of this abandoned manuscript.

    Original Title

    কথার এন্তেকাল (Death of Dialogue)

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    2011. “kathaar Entekaal” ( The End Of Dialogue) Unpublished Manuscript. Bangla Translation of English Papers related to “Crippled Creativity Hypothesis”. Author of this book did not have chance to recheck the second proof for some unavoidable reasons. It is a book on the end of linguistic creativity, which is being disrupted by the violent other. The de facto publisher, raghab Bandyopadhyay, a veteran journalist, had bound me to withdraw this manuscript for the following reasons: (1) he alleged that i was "too creative" in my presentation despite his caution; (2) the heterographic North Kolkatan spelling has violated the norms of his institution, viz. Charyapada. [ his allegations over phone were recorded] Paradoxically enough, this book is against the institutional control that disrupts the human creativity. Moreover, he was then too busy with his felicitation volume, i.e. he was publishing his own felicitation volume (raghob smarane) by appointing a puppet editor. Strange!!!! Author will be grateful/obliged/thankful, if readers would comment on the content of this abandoned manuscript.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Flag for inappropriate content
    4K views76 pages

    (Death of Dialogue)

    Uploaded by

    Debaprasad Bandyopadhyay
    2011. “kathaar Entekaal” ( The End Of Dialogue) Unpublished Manuscript. Bangla Translation of English Papers related to “Crippled Creativity Hypothesis”. Author of this book did not have chance to recheck the second proof for some unavoidable reasons. It is a book on the end of linguistic creativity, which is being disrupted by the violent other. The de facto publisher, raghab Bandyopadhyay, a veteran journalist, had bound me to withdraw this manuscript for the following reasons: (1) he alleged that i was "too creative" in my presentation despite his caution; (2) the heterographic North Kolkatan spelling has violated the norms of his institution, viz. Charyapada. [ his allegations over phone were recorded] Paradoxically enough, this book is against the institutional control that disrupts the human creativity. Moreover, he was then too busy with his felicitation volume, i.e. he was publishing his own felicitation volume (raghob smarane) by appointing a puppet editor. Strange!!!! Author will be grateful/obliged/thankful, if readers would comment on the content of this abandoned manuscript.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 76

    "

    fi'h:'~ HI:~" K/:M"i:'V_ ~~~~~t'nJ.td P~q~~i·~ J

    Kathar
    l>y Dcbprasad

    E?!e7al

    ..

    ~}

    BtndYOPlldhl'iUY

    ~r!:hl

    1'~@l~1
    ~ 9}<f----<!l<1$
    ~ - ~\!)(.'G ~.

    '- F {;<jl%j<i<1'

    ~~~
    cs: 1<>I~("'i~

    ;:£"Sj.q~<i

    ./

    ~.J:l11(.<i

    r-...

    ?\<i-~
    '!l.

    ()"1f.i~ ',x'$<Ol ~~
    ~

    : f<\'831C<>F?1

    '6(4(-::1

    C~

    8.

    \!J{'G'?l "5j~j("115'il :

    M'G3lt<'F.'l

    <n~ G5f
    <1~

    t?rt<l>

    9lwt%
    9]i1i4'g

    : 0<': ~<JWJ f9i~U;<1 : ~


    :~

    ~/~.e 1

    ({. ~Gf<rrR-fu~

    m~

    "{3

    /lZ7fi9f

    9j<f-----,~

    :'<01r,.-(\.'j .~~
    ~~.

    >J"R ~ ;;n~i{\:Itt<r ~"'"4J


    ~ttvt
    I

    '<lS[' 'l@,

    "'''1-l
    .~~

    c~ ~~
    l'fl~~~ i ~1~

    ..",

    <i'lC811 .......

    ®~~'f1

    ~---rn
    d]';{_

    ~·(.$1Ci?:"~ \5l*fn~~

    \Qctt~'"'~1f

    :F1'z.G119f' b"PflC"!;) ~~?'t 9j1~ l ~(.'111 ·!lSf4itfP1. ~


    -,
    ~~ ~ ~. ~

    ~
    ~.~

    2f9tSJ ~
    <'{$j($i

    tt~'J1ir~~ <f.(.SlC~~
    ~_

    \5nOi<f: .~.~
    <t1~) ~
    ~
    _

    ~_
    I ~.~

    'iQ~_

    'C~'7'if\G ~~~ ~.C1 ·f.i1z~~ ~


    \5i~@til ~.'~

    ~tt;qi$i¢! ~()1*l 'P~ffi\Sl' ~:~FiH


    <>,.

    :liz~~'8 ·-;~I1~l~ \;~~

    «$1c.~?F<1I·(~
    .J,

    ;fjSl~~~$lfrb_ .:.

    'J{('~~'11~ ~OiC!:;j. \Qt{l1"V:!~ ~~~

    ~9flWrn.~ ..~.
    ~~ ~~..,~

    ~tqii

    ~~G~ns{; ~1f ~ _;..y~_

    ~~~

    ltR#1t
    ~=----"~

    ~4t~1 ~~~
    4~rn,
    ~~

    f\5~' ,~~ ~. \$~'G1 ~


    ~'.:.~~1I_
    a~<p~]~

    ~_.<;

    'i:~!
    ~m\t;

    {~~if:i~'\C1i'
    '5f-~~ ~~

    '.d1~ P1~t"%J ~~

    .~

    ~'\!)\M\!l1

    $ii~,

    Zy~

    'JI~i6~~~ ~~
    t,

    ~~~ -~~
    ___'.~_.'
    ,;._ .....

    E7lN~1~ , ~~ ..•.
    . .' '.
    . ~ I

    ';q,'S1 ~ .""-l,~.I"...~ "Wi

    W- .~

    ~Fl
    ~,
    ~

    m?J '§ffi?r· ~.
    •

    l8tI~j

    .' ~.'._ _ _ .",--_.


    II, _..' . ,', -

    m€~ 0".

    '13". ?t~ ...>il~'tOC.:i.. ~.:. f~1J($1 ..;r.~";i~~.", ..... ,~._ . ~~IL213~~~ ~o/(.ht~ '€ \5f;;m'~.,~ ~I .~

    Gl~9j~

    ~t"4!<?' t.;fjL

    '$l ~

    ..
    __

    ./..

    ~~.,._

    1ii~G1~~~'

    =.

    ~.

    ··~.~t.'~J" .. :
    ~1.~

    ~r~lR_ .~

    "111-'") ...L_~":_~ .
    .._.......

    ~C*G!l ;!;5ij':l'~~1iCi~:I~.~ !

    '_6i;t"r::--

    ~~

    F~I
    ~
    \)1~~

    \5fr~ ~:tf
    ~
    _.£"-.

    \bfRi~ ~
    '6 ,~

    ~~V't$! ~ Mt~<j''<!)

    ~Pfj~Jf\~f.b-1f

    tq~'\.f~! ~?f ~~
    ~4'f~
    ,

    ?Jl-j< b~~-q&!1- ~9f


    ~Q'~

    ~m'$b~ Gl~~
    it.:-_
    "V.

    ~.1t~~~ i'!D);M' 'q1C~~


    \!ii~~l1j~ i
    .,;'0...

    '?5i1~
    J-jr.3f
    i._

    0i1;_

    i~"ltlI~T~ . ~j~

    ~G;'jC'b

    ~l:'t)~(?r1

    1i~X:<lIT'~fSi

    ~;r'\..!}IM\;!)f ~

    .i'C&

    ~~-.fi1i
    qj'~~'

    ~'~'f]-

    :q~ '8 ~~O~~ "l[~

    .it~

    ~~1~~

    ::lSi\!) _~~~

    ~~~~
    \8'

    {~~~ ~'~~~
    ·~R{~~~lC1

    -m~, ~~

    ~r9n,~mJ.:rn9jf-n~l

    m~~>J61\!) )l\Bj?~qr$1

    01~

    \b(~~11

    '5Tt~ ~
    ~

    ffi'>1l ~~t~
    -

    .~
    <qG~ ~~

    C9fC~·-~[r~n(.4~N?(\!l
    ~t.vt·S!· ~{\!)r.U:P-::l ~
    ~§

    F',(t&f R;g'1t~~·~C~~~\!}· .' ~~)-<J..?,~H't)'1 t~~"t.C9 Tr·r~~r7"C"" i 1~(3J{~


    . e

    ~R ~-..El~
    ~1'3'j

    1!1~ <l~t;r

    ~2R\¢' 9!1:':1!i1! J-fffiQ Ji. q1r~,~.-jJ .

    [;",m tFl"~~
    0'1~

    "iTRf.1"

    GVlVTI 'C"l'd!R'l" 'C-qhl1f.'1'1"

    <n~~~<J
    <!)"l'

    ~~m
    RGl,

    ~'1f<i(<11 GTl<w '611J<l(}'i

    <.!~~.:ffi! D'R
    ~.

    ~M1'
    c<:!

    q;{ff

    :Zr1,

    Q1 ~~

    G'B'Ti ~ 'M '~"f'-',£[~


    ~C:<>8i
    'i3 \t?1*lm

    M<lz, ~

    \'jP'!'@<i' I t?f(~

    f<l'v<i<J
    ~

    <n~ ~

    Gi~
    0M '&~
    ("P(.Jl

    <n

    i5M"1~ ~

    M®!ij-

    ">iC;Q<:(Q-"i::I~\') '~H~j<Hj : '1cG';U~,r1, <f.'<'Ii-<ri~


    '~"N,I<1<jh1

    I >j~It!'Hj'<1 'lt1zC\5H CJf.(.c£]\S


    tfl"l..j~1(;<l

    ~"'t'5C'i''1

    \5TR"i <Jf
    ~:,
    1)f9lfG5

    >ji\i;, i '9iT"i5!c\9)"1

    \')(".;1

    NC'114M'1lfu ~I

    ~'i~"i "<!~ (~

    ''1:\9''1 ~

    ~~

    ~rt'
    <i'J\'5f ~

    ffil,,"~ '&?f1'?l~ ~
    CS1i9j'~~
    <!)(';'i"'(.<Q'

    fl<r;y
    .re'
    ~
    '1C~ 15l~

    ~~ <l>~

    (,q""lhJ

    ~(,\s.,-jj)Iz.,'i' 'Sil~

    <f.:?lf~
    ~

    \5'<1J-

    '1ilt"1'q_

    "'<1RG'f!.<1 0"!~, ~iiJ"1 >m"fl~


    '0~1 '~

    ~f(:'1i~

    15i~1<!~:zq<1>"11

    ~W

    c<P"l"

    ~'11$i <.£Jt!w

    <.!TI'9i'f'.l I ~-)'j~ZR ~<Ji

    ~i9G1 ~
    :((:1' I ~, <ff'>j

    C'o!I"H

    2!lM01f.i4 '!l.;jVJ'

    '\5]<n
    q;ql

    ~T.C1 c<J ~"<Tm

    f.rc<n~
    'rg:l'fl~

    q;fu, ~i<-1"1 W.
    t/1"1 <M \5'f<i!1J .~~

    -m

    ~,

    t/1 '\5]'Tffi WI':(,r;q

    <11 ('

    C<f.lVli

    2!iit<>;)1j]Fl> <rj;:G'fi1! ~6'<,"l tFl"'<il


    <iG'iC~
    Q..{.G1~

    (G'l"<!1 ~

    <TI?
    <.£J"l:Ri 2l~

    <IT "'i ~{:<! C'l'? ''5li~ifu'-''! ~i

    ~,

    ~'-:?f<1' ~'<!T.\5 ~ ~l ~ <!lC~""iC11


    'j.jC'Sgl' \5i<fi1J, \50/-1

    'f.%.0 ''1[;;1;;:'' C"f"l"f V',:!~'G~ <nPR"1C'1<l


    <!i~~>j<i ><1'\5-9-;1"5 ~\t?(<:

    <1~"d~ ~~'i'!
    ~G1l01-~~

    {'~C-1 0f~rGf;r~~~ '\5I1F1'i', <irq15 ..!!Z

    .£:~'"i'-5~

    (.~~!v~ 'YIIB ~~~

    ~m

    M>'~'~ F:,,~

    <fj'<.[Pi

    f'

    ~~

    ~~)!)k<f
    ~~

    -q;'~

    :i.[~i-:.1~9t1~t;,
    I,

    C~

    re.;rtt~'w.]G

    _'~

    ~4'4

    «$!t~ ~M~~ : '-5lq~~(.~b~€I$!M~<J

    \5l<m~ .'S1~ ~ ~q\, lT~~~ 1l$l~~


    ~ ~~ '"4~fPi~<r

    ~f5~C1I'-!l 'i5H.~ l!i~

    ._d

    '-.

    <:m~

    \5fh"§'C.q~i:'15

    '-, -"

    11)

    '<ID3,

    ~r:<l, ~.(h1(.r-jQ<p.l(,'Gl'~
    i

    $~J

    Cl1 oyj~"l\5

    r=__

    '<tJ<J~11~~t
    ,

    Q31.
    "~

    ~lr.9$ :q;ij1 '~

    plurirnethod

    ~~Gf"."fl~
    •

    ~~. tkt(Jj' ~~
    ~~
    '..Q~

    'm"1{,~'$i

    ~ \5l1~nH:'ii~ '.iJ~

    p1Mrjmet11od-~ \5fI~~l \5ij~~~ J=f~-~


    ~{.ft

    ~n:\5
    's

    9f@ ~ "9<11% "'¢~Cil41~'l


    -.

    -'2i~J"~ '9k;-;:J: ~It;, ~~T1:1J! "C{jL~~'f~~ ZUf~ ''&~


    ~~f1'l~'11 Ji~i.Si
    ~
    'G

    'E<i\$3if~1'f

    W1~,~I'r~ '~
    ~~9f~

    r~\<i,&<qJ J
    ~

    \Sl~f\5G~
    .2j"Q,~

    .~trl41~

    X'r"¥jl,·j ";(j"!J. 1';~'!$1~\(..q

    ~tit>i!-;1~

    ·~t~ '-4f8i~M) ~'5l!?.18i

    )5J~S!

    <iJl~

    ~ ~mOj~f

    'l~~

    I c<J

    0\'rb~~m ~~
    9j\4l:f\!;,~

    \5filmt ~f¥r~~\
    T~C>K~
    ~\$

    ~~\!)

    ~t~'
    1~~¢'

    \51~,~'t~

    "$ttl""':

    ~$i~~
    '~(?l-~

    '<l"~l~Qj(:~

    \5h'J1<r.J;-l
    C'>;>(,!l

    9j~~

    ~®:?l, ~<mn M~lC~$l ~f~ .~~~0t\tJ ~~ ~",~.

    '10\!I_R<l I ?J'~<{S 4?f'~ "\5l('i~I~'

    ~~Mf~ ~'Gl1~

    ~1t ~1Sift;,~

    ,,~"'t<1'0j .Ql. <>I<f


    ~l.
    ~ ~~~~
    ~->.!l~.

    2j~R><>t<f ~~
    ('>t~-j "!;1''i1!
    \~~ qRGil5~]' ~

    ~~01;;

    ~lf~~j-~G,tf-Frrn~
    4~1 <f.N3~r ~0/~ I ~
    ~.

    l({it" Pi"Co;>ll-'fr';c-l>1i'
    ~ '~fi{r~
    is

    @<'I<>i''''~t

    ': ~-)
    '8

    J tit1.11f'
    .

    '~'~"1C-!l· q_iC:-:1.~ I

    Wi~

    ~~~

    C<i~"i ~~~

    "~~~<!'~~lb:R'<F

    f%~$! '1lt4~~
    ~'
    ~~ ~~~($!

    ZC'b, ~' 8! 4~ CZl<:C'l <fSQfi~% ~" Wg'"X «~~~\5T'~'~i<P~1 ~'~'1 ~c.~<T'~~ ·~w ~ ~ ii I ~'P.'9j1~C,q;~)j(~

    ,,-

    '~~

    ,~

    '(/ ~' t!lq.>61·~ <'ltG1f~('G1~


    -_ Q,

    -n

    'style

    plural.'!
    10.

    ~-r~
    f\b~J1~~9j
    ;.!]~
    '-,. ~

    l~~~ ~' ~ 1l~7lJ:I9i. Dl~t~i c~'C\!) ~~ ~~' ,,~ ~®.~ 9fZ(~ ~~' ~~ '~i1JjUJ
    \!lQfl

    ~,.

    ~'~

    ~'~'Gl

    (\5{1%~ ~
    ~.._

    \5i~)

    ?!G<f~l\5~ft; \5i<m~ 5~f~~ ~C?f ~t)C~K~ ~ ~G1<ri?n.~ :tQ~I(,~'~


    \!i~~~.

    GTiL;~~' 9ff~~C~: jOj~lC.G11t1-lf; l!G1~


    (1f~""

    lfi:vi(~ll '\5l~=1'~R ~zCnt$..1


    ~ ",

    c'Q:n:~ ~{f>B1 ,~(~

    1':4~"(1 ~'

    .(}Pi':1
    .

    \!l'

    (~

    I~C~~
    a

    ~QjI .~Jjc.~,

    ~lD~,~.!j\bi'I)J B1']1I~11~ ~,

    ,.s::,.__

    r;~Fr

    <i'~it\961~riJ'?J ifl~"!I~ '<tt<¥ ~lyT\b~M:@31rj

    ~Gr1f

    <{i '~6

    ct1~'-9f1

    b~ G~~~~

    =1{~W ~"

    9!'!Mi

    ~~
    (.~~'"

    '31\!JJ~~
    i

    (:~R,,~~('5lt0.: t\!li~,R ~1f~-?n'f~'~~Tf~4 ~~\!3~ (institutionalised -orgsnised ~ science) \~~{. ~f ~41 (J. Q_1! \5'f\G m~TIJ m~l. ~UJ C~EI .~®$J\!l : D\Z~ ~~}ITJr .sl'=Z ,iG1~~ .~~1~('~' '~~::;i;:;r(.Ujlt5'fii ?C,?r~; ~~~<r C~
    j

    'bl@il Cb<r=t'22, -;n (~~

    \5.Ff.4J

    :>pBI- Sh:G1l

    ~'"o).... ~S'j~S1
    11~~
    ~~'6

    AA ~if$lUl
    ~

    ~f<f
    ~~

    ftv/
    ~"

    ~o<f

    t) )!~!1J}J6i''''~

    ~~~~~11 c"'1rrn·"fl~~l~~ ~t~~


    ~~
    ~

    ~"5;;rt~~r
    1§fffi,~'-p,!}t"
    ~

    ~(JH).{
    Z(3.!~)
    ,

    >St;~q
    ~_ ,"'~'

    -Gt'~~
    ,,-....

    fhK ~, ~tc.~I!)'1[$T
    _

    ~
    r"-'

    c\t)f-1
    ~

    i,'~<~~~
    ~~
    "

    r:(" ,.,.,

    ~:9fJ

    r'1~~-2l11ff8~4_:iS11<f1.~~J4~~"~ ~~

    <H~ ~ ~'3Il~~<;p' "Jf\r.:'il'7f t~C~,~.

    'M~.~5f~~
    ,

    ,<{jFf)n.~1;! r;Q,~
    -

    lJ11J, ~,~~
    ~~,(.;Ji"il
    ,~, \.

    ~~~~
    '(.\51 ~~

    Z'8Sfi
    ~{c1!

    0"3i cl(q,~ ~
    <it""1J f9(1'mrn

    ~~~i~ Clt:~~t~f

    .Z:~~_,~~ '~'Wfi~

    ;!

    ~fci
    "

    '~:1~e31'fi'-?l-~~ ~~~- "I~'~P

    -fi!-j

    ~~j~,C-::l'-~ ~<f5'fH
    .L:::':~

    01<P::(19fl~ lil~~- ~'

    i \51('~?1

    ~2J~'-q-

    ~~
    'i~<l~?4,

    ~<nl~r-<ifTQ?J1~!
    ,
    ''It)

    '>-11

    4f1R1

    ~H!(-.,;n';Tm :Q1~~I!i\"i
    9.iL
    j)"~

    C\!Jj ~~
    (.~<H~
    $j{5it
    ~~
    ())t;.i

    :9ft~ Wi~
    ~(}f~T

    q_, qQ;rr"'1'@;~\01i)l~

    v,-,·

    \S

    \&~ ~CG'i

    loll ij

    ~,

    '~,~~ ?1:(;<f~ ,?G1~ 9j~~' (~'f~~ ~~)V..fI2;?l ~~~~"Wm ~~ (.¢isco~rse) ~~R"1 ~


    ~K1R_ ~~
    ~lb

    li'Zqt?[ '~t~r?r

    ~~n

    ~r~ \3if(FTInti'!i ,~3j(.§~ : -<))


    \§9t{)3$l

    i, ~<1~ 'S1lf74~ :>j ~"1~


    lf~if~ig, 01t~

    ~~Ql~'l:"
    <1'zylt-

    ~~
    ~~

    ~lf1

    ~>Yj ~1~~~f?af:1?1

    ~~-.q;

    ~~1
    '(

    '~ t!t~,LIffl'

    1'&1-~~~?

    (~)'

    It?;t~

    f6-

    lfl~

    ~/

    ~~~OK<l,

    C'¥t~~ \(~'$J ~~mwt~1


    \§i~,.\~~ ~

    \s '5~'~ ~~ C~(\;l .cq~J ">j);Pi51~~ 1i~l:;qJ >t~l~ .u~~ ,~l.~ ~~~ ?n~t:'$~ ~ <i:l"~ '9fl\!llG:i~;,~'\!flf9Jm'~~ f~,~re
    f¢~
    "1~':Q11f~ '~'

    t<'.J·~;O~l~)1 ~

    ~>~l~ljK]l~-C~~

    \6jt~r"-~

    &]~I

    ,r.--

    ~'I

    d!~ oJ ~~ ~";;"rt:1~1~?' ~.

    €~t

    ('<P>1t~1 ~<p"Giltfj~N<f.l ::'1.ptn~

    ~.o.

    .DI. ~~
    1~7
    <flW~'8 ~

    ~~~~

    ~~
    c~, ~ <fl"1~ <fl ~

    ~?'

    <fl~ ~ ~

    ~ c~ ~

    ~ ~

    <fl"1~ ~ '~1~1\!)~' <flU! ~ ~

    ~'>f~ ~
    '~,

    'fI

    'M~~~'
    ~
    ~ ~

    ~MerlM ~
    .~
    ~"f

    ~ '!iffi:"i ~

    : '~,
    9fT@f

    ~ 0m ~?'

    CI5f ~
    '~~ ~ ~

    '5Mi ~?'
    I ~,

    W~9ffu
    ~?' ~/

    \3(
    '-';

    m Of'8~
    ~
    ~

    ~~"*t jj¥'~
    ~1?,jl\!)IWJ4' ~ ~~'Bf~~'Bf~

    i5!B1" <l~~!~IMOf
    ~"f~~~~;

    (9fM~)

    '5<ff1 ~I

    ~1?,j1\!)INJ4' (M~~~) ~; ~

    ~-~~
    ~ <fl f,;t~ ~

    ~~
    \5f<l~

    \!)1f\?J<l>?I1 ~,

    ~~"'..·W~9ffu~ <m~~ <m~~ ~ ~ ~-~


    'Tt, ~ ~~

    ~ ~
    <fl~ ~

    ~ <m9fR I
    ~"!

    "Tf~ ~

    <1'I.?IffirG1<i, ~M 81

    ~1~~

    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~ C~I,*il4I~

    N8lRtil4'i (Nil4il4f%t) ~, ~ ~

    0m <:rn I \!)!!i:CG1
    ~?

    :: ~ J

    ~
    ~
    ~ ~

    'li~9ffu ~ ~
    ~ <fl~

    mc<1 c<rn

    <l'@

    ~!?,jl\!)~

    <m9fR...~"f
    ~ ~, ~

    m~
    ~ ~

    '1

    <}

    <!l"1~ ~

    <!l~ ~ ~

    ~9f C<l"f

    'Ttl
    <!l<n~ ~ ~ ~I'~ <!l4' Cil4fGw~il4'8~ ~ ~?'-..!l~ "1Cil4 ?fm 151~, ~ ~? ~,

    <mr~<mr~
    ~ ~ ~

    ~
    81 ~
    ~,

    ~
    '.!1~~

    'i~~9f
    <!l~

    'M~~~'

    9fI<i"
    '8~

    c~I.<lR"'Pl, ~

    ~'I'i?lcil41<1'

    QJ <!l~ ~

    \!)It\!) ~

    ~ ''8~<!l~

    (,~I!?r.'i<lIil4i

    m~
    '8~
    <'F.,,?!

    I~

    Th?lC<i'Cil4 ~

    'Tt

    <l'@

    mc<1 ~
    <1'~

    f"lm

    ~-~"f<!ll ~, ~~

    <1'~

    m
    <!lllff

    <1'~ <1''8 I <!l~

    15lW-<l'1Iff mc<1 ~-~~~-<!l~

    "U'f?fm <:rn ("it


    (}f1.I~

    oWl! ~' ~,
    ~ ~

    '8~511 <1'~ <;t'1!

    Mt~ (A'8Jff

    rJ.. ~

    6.") r:

    ()if'<.'G'F ;n

    \5Tf~'fu i <!l~"f ~ft, '<1'~

    81 @:;; C57.9f ~. 11-';' <zil4 ~~

    ~~

    <fCG

    <1'1Iff C\51
    i

    <1'~1 ~

    ('\!)ljJl~

    "9Q)0

    'ff"l

    (,\5'f ~,

    .~

    "9Q.f1 "918

    on I

    \5f!@

    <W!i
    (,\5'f

    ~>j~"Ilt~ ~~j~j

    ~~~ ~PH\!)'IJ ~ ~

    C9f9f!~ ~? '1l~C<l;{Gj ~ D~N:Cf"l1 ~ I ~ ~? .~ ~ 'l~'%f~ ~j~l\!)'IJ-~ ~ \5li~ ~ ~ ~

    ~MJ if!
    ~

    r: \51~1\!)'IJ ~~1,

    \5l'<fl) 'l~~9f

    ~ '1l~~

    9frtm ,~
    ~
    '11f'11

    fj;y/
    ~'lf
    tiTl~~! -!l<l> <l>Q.f1U1IDS51 <

    WfD ~ G1t~~,
    ~151! ~
    I

    '&l
    ~ ~

    (A>'11 ~ c<r"M ~ ~

    -!l"M ~ -!l<l'!i ~ ~~~ ~

    .... ~
    ~

    ~9f1V<! ~ ~
    i <£l~

    m \5lJrOOt
    ~~ 6'{f I.~
    ~ ~

    '1lQ.f1,"9Q.f1\5l0"9Q.f1 "J!<r ~tC1<1'Ii~'1l ~

    "9Q.I'f <?U1.

    15!0 ~

    ~ ~

    c<r

    \5l0

    <:<M <l>Q.f1 ~~

    on,
    ~..

    <l>Q.f1

    ~!,~~,
    ~'lf
    6'{f1 ~
    \5l~

    -\5lJ1-~-~, -!l~ '5!@! ~

    orfm OM' ~~
    I -!lUr ~

    i5fc'U ~j~I\!)'IJ ~

    .'6 ~
    ~ ~ -!l~ ~ ~ ~

    \51f'lf1Jf ~
    ~ ; ~j'il\!)<lU(~

    ~
    ~ ~ ~

    '~
    ~"Irn
    <lj~'l~t'1l ~

    B9fmIf~-~
    ~
    -!l~ ~'

    cm~'
    OiIJ '<l\Ff ~
    'fl18~ \5l0 ~?

    ~
    ~?

    <lItC~ ~'lfV'f~"M

    'ft'6~

    C'f81ffi!

    ®Q(-<mrffi ~
    C~I ~

    ~
    ~1"Ilt"lGq
    ~tjJ

    m8 ~

    w.lJ \5lW'ffG'i01 ~,
    ~ ~ ~ ~9f

    ~~

    ~m ~ ~
    'W!i'lf ~

    9fWfrn ~j~-C<l\;ij(j1m

    -cm~ ~ cm~;rn,
    ~

    O51~-<fii"I ~
    ~9fIV'f
    ~~, \5l~

    m~ ~
    '~~'

    ~
    I ~ ~,
    .~.I

    >jl;jlf6!%IC<l~ll.!Jl~~~ ~<!l<l~

    B9f@ 9fj'6crt,~ ~
    "9'<.'! ~,

    <!l~ @t;\!)~

    'l"111J ~9f1"I -!l~ ~

    ~
    'ill

    <f!E® ~
    <l>Q.f1 ~ ~ -!l"M I ~ ~

    Nc\5 ~
    ~~<f1
    (,\5'f?

    ; m 'ff"l 00
    cUG'f·cWs ~
    'bll~. _' ,~:

    6'{f1 ~!C<I" ~

    ~,
    \5l'<fl) ~
    ~~<i'~~

    .::.9...A
    lL JL
    :.'" ~'

    '<l\Ff ~.~
    -!lUr \!)~<l>\51 ~

    ~
    ~ \5l~ ~

    "il18 ©-~ ~ ~

    W.f

    <fCi \5l~

    J~

    .-/

    ,-._ ('\m~ ~ I
    ~I
    ._~ ~.<Jffi ~ ~

    "1GJ3
    ~

    ~~4.f ~
    9(1l8m C~ I~

    \5lTI"I~,
    'l,~9j ~ '-!l~

    'S'ti'ilCC4M'i -!l~ '1_"1' C~ I~ ~

    Z~J

    ...., _"

    OJ! -!l<l'!i
    -!l~ ~

    'G~CC4('(;~ ~ ~ ~

    ~?1t\!)~

    m~ ~---wr ~ ~ ~
    '>j~~9f Cl ~ 'fl'lf1 C~I ~ ~ ~ ~? ~

    '6lJl~1H~j I ~

    2ffjj~/ vl
    ~ /
    r-.

    BJ "'"' ".

    :_~A~
    ~1'ill ~

    ... I

    mEl ~
    <?f~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    ~
    I \5f~ ~,

    ~ Wr
    ~

    ~~.

    '5!@! ~~ ~

    o:rr ...

    '5!@! ~
    ~

    ~
    <ril8m

    ~
    ~~~

    ttr(ffl ~
    .....

    .4r'1f.l~,
    ~ ~ ~

    *~ ~ ~
    ~ ~ ~
    \5IWoi1
    C9fUl ~ ~ ~ ~I ~

    \50 mt"I c!:j"J!<r ~Q.f1


    ~. ~

    -!l ~'ti'!tl(pll'1l I

    \5l1f.! ~
    \5li~

    ~ "i~

    "1~

    ~,

    i' .

    ~~~~oni
    ~'ti~CC4f<f. <!l~ m:01 ~

    SQ35, '~
    ~~~

    m ~"1V? ~
    f<rrJTJ-~~-'fo'1l5 -!l"M ~ ~ ~ ~-~-~

    I~

    f1
    -!l~, ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

    ~9f519f I ~~
    C~\!)C?1 ~~,

    -e~\!)J I -!l~

    C<l'fOn

    C~

    ~m ~
    ~

    I t<l' ~

    "Tl¥ ~
    ~

    ~
    ~.
    ~ ~ I ~~

    ~
    "C'

    om! ~
    ~

    C<l>"I c<r ~~

    "11! \5li@ <q1'1_,'fl'lf1

    C"'!fJJ "9Q.f1~ ~ff"1'~-~-~9f\;i

    crt ~

    ~~
    ~

    ~1rq,GlC~.

    9fffir on!
    ~ ~1~I\!)t~~
    ~ ~

    ~ ~

    C~

    \5I1D1, ~ C\51 ~

    <TIm ~
    "<IN ~
    <TI~
    ~

    ~lZ~-W:~ ~~C'j'[9f
    ~ ... l'

    ~
    <rf18, ~

    ~,

    iSM}

    ~"<lN
    ~ ~

    on

    on ~,
    ~ ~
    C9f~

    ~
    ~181 ~

    1fi<Wr '9(J1'~~

    M~ I
    L

    ~~:Q.f1Ur.~
    'l~~9f

    'fl r~

    ~R'1l1

    '-41'{3jl8 ~f\;i1'6! \5llC<;i .. ~ CX1~

    '51~
    ~i

    ~
    ~

    ~ ~
    ~~~

    ~1\!)-'1l'f9f\;i

    <fi";jR\5 9fWff

    on,

    -n ~

    '>jZ~9f-~~ ~

    'm~
    ~

    ~Q.f1

    ~I

    '5!@! ~
    ~1<!I\!)C~?!~
    ~,

    'l,0'f[9f-~~ ~

    rFf r:J

    ..-

    O'I"'!o9f1f.'l ~ -!l<f8
    ~, '~

    c<r1~ ~
    ~ <ll@

    on

    MC\!) ~ <f1<l'!i ~~~

    ~
    ~

    '?li"l ~ ~
    ~G'1? 9fT~ ~

    J;r/~'ti~t"'1!<f' <!l~ ~ ~ ~

    I~
    ~!'

    fXf~
    C"f~"C\5? ~
    ~ ~

    -C\51

    'S'j<ffiJ ~~ !:RZ~
    <f'@

    wi
    -i'r I
    _

    r-

    ~
    ~!

    "[<ff~~
    ~

    m ~I'

    <l>@?

    -~(,\5'f~Y!o~~~~~Wl'I~xr'~

    \5l@r ~<r~t"'!

    \\!)<j('G ~

    f<r~

    <f'Q.f1~

    I~

    1M'1lj~"('>T"1C\51~

    0i~,"IT:\5 "'!~?

    (}f18$I1 ~

    Wi

    \5ll9J~

    ~"I'C<!"I

    '1lQ.f1?

    -~ ~-~~'8~~~1 -~
    xj~

    ~~ ~~

    on! ~ '89f?;i" ~
    <I'@, ~

    <;f'!(ff f.RJl \5!f~Q,1;qj ~ <!)~ ~~, ~

    ~-<il. ~cr~,

    C~

    ~i

    ~,~@l-<il.~

    ~ C~I

    C~

    ~ ~

    ~ ~

    <!)<f~

    CX1<1~~~M
    ~@,

    ~~
    I <!) ~~'i ~ ~ ~

    <l1 NGiG4fet

    cWr-~

    ~
    ~

    ~1~1\!)(.'G~

    m<1iT!

    -~,

    D"I~<'llM ~cr

    ~ ~,
    ~I c<i'~?

    ~ ~
    ~ ~

    ~'Pft\!)c'G~

    ~~9~1

    -<1iT
    -~
    ~ ~

    ~"'l ~

    <u1~ CG'1"«1 ~
    ~

    em
    ~
    '8~

    CJiiJt?
    ~-'8~
    <:rf(;<ll

    '-"
    ~

    "!i it.
    "

    J111>{l;~~ ---...£l~ ~

    In

    c'>1ffi: I
    ~

    <u1<9frW1

    <l1 ~'(.~f5f?l~ttiiJ1
    ~ ~?

    fi1<u
    4t~Jli~1

    I\.

    <l1

    -moo~?~~~~~1

    <ITP!
    ~

    'VJI'='I";~"I

    <l1 ?f'1<1tiZbm "lI"'1"'l~(jl~ ~

    011 ~?
    <!)~ ~ ~I ~~

    ~~

    ~~cr'i'f\5
    <!)~ <!)~ ~t~~ ~ ~

    ~
    <I'@ ~

    ~cr
    ~

    'Bl, '& ~t~t\!lt~<;f'

    011 Jj~?

    011 ~?

    ~~-~

    ~"f
    8J '5l1~

    9f'ro! C9fUT <mi ...

    ---...£l'iJi <!)~

    c~c1fbc& ~~,

    ~
    ~~I ~. ~ ~,
    <!)~

    ~
    ~~~~~~ ~
    ~

    ~gp

    -~~
    -'8~

    om<9frWI
    ~
    ~ ~

    'B~
    ~ 011 ~, ~~ I
    ~£l~

    arM I
    I
    <!)~ ~ ~

    f.f>~~~
    ~, \!l~

    ~
    '8~ ~ ~I~
    @, ~

    '©-~' ~

    ~
    '8~

    ~
    'ff'8

    ? c<T
    ~ ~
    ~

    I <!)~ ~

    ~ ~1~1\!)~

    ~-~
    '~'-<!)

    <I'@

    ~9frn
    ~
    ~~
    ~ <!)~

    ~
    ~

    <l(Plffix;G4<1 011 ~-<il.~-~~ ~ I c<T ~ <1f I ~


    ~

    ~~:sf5 ---...£l~

    ~~'~?

    i5"M' 011 ~
    \5IBf ThW.\!) ~
    ~

    <!)~ ~'i
    ~ ~

    ~,
    ~i;f

    .~~

    'Jf ~, ~
    ~ ~~

    \!l1r\5 '8~ <Tf ~ ~, <Tf-~-~

    <mI ~
    ~

    ~1

    Ff;;rr '5l1~
    ~ ~ ~

    <I'@

    <l1 \5l1?lRlltB11

    ~m ~~
    ......
    (<:i~

    ~
    ~

    "IG4J <l1 ~
    ~

    ~9f

    I \5R1<1 <Tf-~-~

    ~1CG4t-.:pq

    "IG4J 9fffi I
    ~ ~

    9fffi

    CJiiJt ~(7! ~

    ~~,*fi?: OC<i \5i'P'i~l<j(}1t~iJ I c<T '5f<11-~~w,t '@9f-' ~9f-' ~

    -<!)~

    r:

    ~I

    >jf~lfet~~IC<l
    ~I

    ~ <!)~

    ~~~

    f.IDJ
    '~'>[
    ~i;f! ~

    '5l1~

    \51tG'i1 ~

    C9fGi,

    <1iT!)-~~
    ~

    ~
    ~Q,f

    011 ~r"f,

    \51 m ~1~1\!)~~ ~ ~ ~ m '&1'4l~\!)I~ ~


    <!)T)r ~-~'8tiifet4'fGi

    ~~

    ~'V!1

    CJiiJt 9fi¥1";

    orrn
    <!i~

    ~':

    ~ ~ ~

    I <!)~

    '~~' I '5l1~

    <l1 ~1~4
    2fV!:j

    (~~<!)<'ll~~~~m~~<!)~),~<!)~ '8~ ~ <!)~ ~ ~ ~~~<!)D'f ~ I-~


    -<!)~ ~

    ~;

    \5im ~
    -.:rm ~
    ~ ~
    $l0,

    ~~
    ~ ~

    ~
    ~~

    C9fG'1.""I~

    '£i5
    ~

    WoTt
    <!)~ ~

    '8~

    <l(;tii : I5Bl1 ~ ~'>l~

    W~ ~
    <WiT
    W1-~1 ~?
    \5J~

    9flm <mi... ' I

    ""I~

    ~lc"1fbCJlJ'i1

    -~t 011 ~
    ~,

    ~I

    '@9f'-~ f<l; ~~-~~


    ~ ~ <!)~

    ~ ~
    <!)~

    'r~ om9fBWr1 <.WI <rt-~ ~


    ~i;f ~

    ~
    ~ ~

    ~ I
    <!)~

    ~
    ~,

    I~ c>fGr'8 C<;fG'j I <!)~

    <l1

    ~i;f

    -~
    -~,
    ~ ~ i

    m~~ ~9fi-t
    ~

    ~
    ~-~

    <!)~ ~ ~ ~ <!)<l'1<f[ fG4T ~ < ~

    .C<'ll1'4T C~

    CJiiJt
    ~I

    c<i'! ~1<1t\5C't1~ ~

    f.mr ~.~
    ~
    ~ <!)f~ <!)~ ~ c<ro'Ml ~ <!i~ ~ ~ ~~~

    m~~
    '_;1~1 ~ ~ ~
    <I'@ ~~

    <Jf.T

    ~t<!I\t{~'!1

    ~
    ~

    \!)l~C<:1 ~l

    ;qj~G'f1I51<frn. <!)<'ll!(ff~1P'ff
    ~

    <!)<;f'~/~ <!)~~~

    <ITP! ~
    <I'@

    c<T <!)~ '8~

    ~cr i5ff@19f <I'@ ~I


    ~

    ~I

    ~'{<!)~

    \5Jl~~,

    15ff~

    ~
    -~ -~~

    c<fG4"C\!l ~
    <;f'!(ff ~ <;f'Qj1<1f ~~ C<;fG'j~,

    ... o:nf<j;? ~
    ~
    9!@,

    m~ <!i<f~ ~~
    ~t~
    ~ ~
    ~j~~

    c:<Bi @~

    ClJf.<:1

    I \!l@9f?;i" ~

    Jj~G'ff9f ~! ""I~,

    '1W
    ~

    Wr"<.~

    <J~ ...

    i~

    ~ ~

    1<:1(;<:1 ..., ~i

    'sTtil1 .~
    CJj~~ ~

    ~
    ~

    <1iT ~?
    ~ ~,

    (;<jl\!)r-; ;q'f(.'_;'{l<:1F<1fb \5IV ~ f.ir.<:1~ C\5i

    M~ ~
    ~-~,

    C<Jr.\!) 9I'ffu ~? i GilG'1-'>i~-~-?(G)'1

    m~ ~
    \51~ \5R1i;f ~

    ~9

    d'~
    ~i

    <rr1<9frW1 <!)~ C~"lI'0 ~

    C*F!

    \5IBf

    (,~~~

    ~lert...04 ~ f

    ~I'

    Proof) i2

    -~
    ~
    ~

    ~,
    ~
    ~ ~

    ~~
    C~
    <l'@?

    ~-~
    1(3~
    ~

    mr-=l
    C~
    ~

    CI5f
    ~

    ~<W! ~
    ~I ~

    ~ ~

    c>

    :;]

    ~~~ ~~ m
    ~"f/~
    1(3~ '5I<f'f~ ~ ~9f"f\5\5 ~~ ~ ~ 1 ~~ 1~

    DWr ~
    "fI1 ~
    ~

    ~
    ~
    C~

    ~ dVW~ ~
    ~

    -~
    ~ '~' 2j~ "J'!!(f1 ~
    ~

    ~
    ~ ~ ~

    <r0'f ~1<l11!l1R1<1', \51m ~~


    <I'{f.k<fllj Ff~ ~9flj"f X;f(.4"' ~ "fI, "J'!!(f1 ~ ~ ~

    o@j ~ ~

    <fi ~

    <!!~ ~,

    colft~

    C\51? ~!
    ~
    ~ 'm'-<.!j~

    ~~1{ <I'!(f1
    <fi ~
    I Ifl~ ~

    ~
    ~
    ~I

    \5l<fi~ ~

    ~
    1flG'f C<'1"!!(f1

    ~W~ ~
    ~

    ~<f~ ~

    ~t~ ~~
    ~ ~' Ff~-C>iPjJC~j:l

    ~~

    ~
    ~

    ~~~I ~)

    f.trn
    C~?

    f.w.J
    ~ ~

    ~I

    ~~, ~

    '~'~C@
    ~ ~ I~
    I

    (<!0 1(3~

    ~9f

    ~ aojJl(),\IC{(iS!

    9fTC"t ~

    '!fiR! ~
    C~ ~~ ~

    '5jlff <fi ~~I~IC1~'t ~~

    ~m
    <I''<Jt ~

    C'<ft<Il ~ aojJ1t'lIWiSi C<I'l'<Jt

    21k ~ """ \~
    11r;( ~
    ~
    -~, -~,

    <I'<'1DA'6CG4~"IC\5l1

    Ifl~

    mi~, ~
    C'<ft<Il \!il1D1 ~ ~~-i~0I;1~

    N®~

    'OI1'=J~~"1 '5jlff <fi ~4)I~"'ilaojl~'6 ~ ~


    ~ : ~'1<fI11

    m
    ~

    ~"i1~~ C'f"f ~
    ~

    ~
    ~~ C~Caoj~Caoj"'l1 ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~!

    ~I

    f<r"f ~
    1(3 ~ ~ ~-~

    ~~ mrn

    ~m
    ~ ~

    ~ ffi, ~
    ~

    "",,,.Ji!lr<I ~ 15"@ ~ ml
    1(3~ ~

    "'-WI' 0/11 "" <>,tt1>l,," '""'~


    ~~/~t<1ill!ll!,l,
    ~

    .. ~-~

    m-t I ~tlll~{O~=?1
    C\51 ~

    ~ ~

    ~ Ifl">j"<f

    0Ttf<Is?
    ~ ~ <wfC\5 9f@<f "fI1 ~ Ifl~ c<J ~'-~

    9fWf 1 \5~
    ~~

    ~
    ~

    <nm

    m ~~

    m ~ ~ ~, Ifl~
    ~ ~·~I

    ~I

    $1"19 ~
    ~

    <1lt ~

    C~Caoj~(Fi"'l \5l"'lJ~IC<l ~9f<I' 1(3">j"<f ~

    <fi f<I(Af\b'Ol'i1~iSi~

    <fi9J.?
    ---<.!j~ ~ ~ ~ ff@

    I!ll!,l

    <fl'm ~~
    "J~

    9fC\!?

    ~"'l~l!,lf<ll1.~11 ~9f<I'-~I\!lRr~I~

    C>i '~' C~ C>i Ifl~ <!l<fm

    X;I~I ~

    iq>'i1~aoj"'l,
    i ~~

    <f1WI1 ~

    ~~,

    01 ~

    c<J ~~,
    i ~~
    ~

    ~G'f, ~~

    i;ytaoj"'f1(3 ~ I' <I'~~ ~ ~

    ~fJF~l~
    I c.cr<f~ f.kil1<lf"f1 ~ ~~I ~

    \5lTW1

    '5I<f'f~ 4'Sft5I~!G4tl
    ~ <I'@ ~,

    rr~~
    C>i Ifl~

    <l'@ <Q~ ~

    co:rn

    ~~~
    ~

    m <fi
    "0'f ~ ~
    Ifl~
    ~;

    C>i~

    ~~lkU I
    <fi
    ~

    <fi
    i~

    ~il'fIGF
    Jffi;~

    "fI I· <f>~ 2j1\!l<'1~ ~

    ~"ff.'!~-<.!j~
    "P'1~-<.!j~

    <m9fR
    ~ 9f!~G"f~
    ~i
    ~

    <ft<I'J ~
    ~?f ~

    i <!/}M ~ ~I C<'1"!!(f1 C~?

    w-mr,
    ~)
    ~

    ~*~f®
    lJT ~
    ~

    <rf ~?f

    <!/}M <ff<iPJ ~,

    -~1'911(3
    9J~

    <fi'1,
    ~-<.!j~

    <m9fr~'l'ijl ~

    C\51 ~
    C~!

    ~
    Ifl<fm
    <l'@

    ~! Ifl~ ~
    ~

    ~-<.!j~ ~ :

    >@t ~
    1(3

    C\51 ~~ ~~
    C~~
    ~<l' ~!

    ~ MC~fi6I!i/i1 $1

    ~/~

    't"~.
    V.~

    ~
    ~

    ¥ Ff.
    ~~~

    .~~

    ~ M(Af\6\!5jBl>{;!

    <IN mJ-~'1
    ~~~I

    (~

    ~
    ~<fm

    m: ~
    I

    <ft<I'J-~

    ~
    ~~

    CiSim

    ~ ~<W! ~~, 1<f~ ~i ~ <n '~'


    ~ ~? ~ ~ ~I

    ~~
    ~~~~~<fi
    ~~ ..

    1(3~

    VI ~
    ~

    -~, ~ <1lt

    0i!!elf.2l~
    • ~~7/l ~~ '~' c£!~
    ~

    <1lt ~~~
    ~ ~ ~I ~ ~.~

    ~~f<ls<n,
    \51' >i<l<1~ ~~

    ~t
    ~

    fi1f~ ~~ ~ <1lt~? ~~
    ~!

    ft-j/

    ~I

    -~9tf.2I f<f>
    ~ (A@ <!l'<Jt~?

    ~ ~~! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

    ~?

    1fl\5 ~ ~ ~

    Ifl~

    ~9ffrl
    C\51
    <Q~

    ~">j"<f "0'f

    9ffc'1i'G ~

    <nv:T?
    1 ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~? <I'~'i'tJi

    -\51Ifl~

    -~9Jf.t ~
    9fl\5C'riS
    ~ ~
    9(fi@~-?:.

    ~
    ~ ~

    !(f1<1'C\5 ~ ~

    PP: ~~
    ~i

    C9fCG'l ~1(3

    <fi,~
    '>1~

    C>i~

    ~I

    ~~ ~~

    %5 ~
    I

    ~/

    ~I ~
    ~ ~

    ~ tl!ll"l~
    i ~,

    mr-=l 'l1'~I!lI<'1f.j ~
    ~

    ~-~ ~ 1(3~ "fI, ~

    c<J ~
    ...

    \5foTI/\5l~

    ~!<lII!lCl!,l~

    1fl\5 "i\5 ;qJ19frn ~

    <I'!(f1 i <!!~ ~"ti'KG41<1' ~

    <m~ ~
    C\51 '~'?

    'f~ ~,

    Mc~f\b\5lBl>{;!.q?1 -.q:f~f<1 Ifl~

    rr,~~~
    ---<.!j~ ~

    ~'~' ~

    '1('G"1R I c>iI>jJ@?1 ~
    9'~ : ~,

    rr~~~ ~
    ~,~~<;fo'!

    <fi ~

    ~1'<!l1)1'i1IM~ Ifl<r~ '5iIC;:M<jlf i

    ~o;jBl

    Qm] Pri'l,;,f}

    ~:,

    ·\gr~r~~"Z
    ~fffg.

    R.01(.4~"<f~

    '~~r .€~
    ~

    ~\9~r.{-~

    ~I
    <n~.(5~

    ~~ ~~-

    ~i-~"lf4 .~___;~~ ~~'"R J4'jLz<t~fQ.e('3l ~~(.c,,~ f~{.~~~Wl~1


    Clif~t<P ~~ i~
    ~Vj
    ,r,[?i'l

    ,%~G1 ~~

    qy~~~. i ~,~~q
    '" ;;Q~
    ~'(.~,(lt1

    ~<1~'Gi1TI~

    '~

    ~J-:;~~~G1-! ..
    ~'Jf~~ ~'\;'Jt~<;1· ~~

    :w"?n~
    ..,..

    ~~CGi~ m1~
    ..._

    \5f1"m~ c4c~ 8f.1


    ~ "-.
    ~

    ~t"l
    .._

    9-~'

    -Q'ill ~~~.
    ~?il'~ ~Si

    f~~:kj9f
    \g\$?l ~

    *tG1~,~~
    ~Sll~

    '~Q1.q. ~<fE1 tf!~

    \!)qJ ~

    <J:l1J 1 ~
    :q_tr6,
    ,___

    .. CX1'~";i
    ..-.~'

    C<4~'ii ~'9fr&:\f) ~~
    ~ ~
    ."./

    Gl1'?1i'?ijiB~i
    ~'Q]<fl

    Ol:rJJ~(,~I

    <HB? fS~ qs?;.(Ptil

    "'1\!l~~::111~ 0

    ;~

    ~~ni3{C~~ ~'(
    §t:~l' 411(.\5~
    .~ 9R~

    -4'-

    ·'--'.t ~ '~ ~14·~rn ~'~li9i?Jn ~.~ ~t.q~,~


    _
    <.0

    m®t4if~

    'fGQ'. ~
    'Q~

    I ~~l'~'Q[J

    c~:t<Jr~ ~~. ~~;:_l~~rI-~<P~-\b\8'!1 {<1e3i?~i .


    C3J 1.
    ~!P{;=4S {,~~~

    Gf'ij_''61(}~ ,¥{5'f .

    SU:£iI(fj ~
    ~

    \;t?j<n~'§(~

    ~\5T$1 ~~,~~

    i"'--'

    ~?'!ft~\!)m ~
    ':'j'I' ,~"--', .. ' 'J

    ':5~ ~c.G1rn

    (.9i9W1Q 4l~ ~C:~1C.SlC\5Tf flJt'O'f'rn'


    -q~1f

    1l17li~~11

    ,.-....,r-...

    ;(:.Cw.z~~

    ~<;ptH ~

    ~:

    ~,~(G1~~~!G1

    'G1~if;1r.?ir;_~ ·~~51'51-3i'5l~rn l~tOl~· ~5{<l: \5i?Ji\3C'G~ ~.ffi4f ~~ eJR~ ,<!J~lJ'f S1<R .~ \5j (~.1i1~ (A'8;m '<JW~ C<n~ ~·Pb";:iJ10rl~ ~;~fIi \5t

    .;_:ftJ. ~a~R 'f4f0t;~ " ".~ ~%lof l!1~

    1.'''~~ ' ...--. ~....,,....._,.


    ~'j
    .

    Gl~ ... "


    .

    1,\;1.

    Mt1C11Xf" ~M fiifw W!011 ~\$. <rt R4~$i~ ~4i;Gi ~'~~-~ 051' ~-t1fu ~ '~]~~?lf?f
    .~
    ~

    h_
    .

    --r~~~<lt~l~~'1
    'l(~>j
    ~'~

    .t!1~ ,,*,5~i)lG~('>i '1Qj {'\'fO'l~


    ~!~ .•

    ,~tfii~ :~~ ~
    -,;:: ~ -rr::t~

    ~.
    ~

    '~~P?.~
    :::rit

    ~1t;Gt

    f.iUN3 f.1;- ''fil'-01''


    ~. ~.r-~

    ~~v&i ~ ~
    ~'I~""d.·'\l!-QI
    ~

    <w(<1

    co@~ C'f<11
    ---'St - ~

    I ,~'~J;(;"iP"f::;o;.~;-I·:"'!h..ti2(-I'ijt\tllG1~~L~ '

    :...,1("",,;0<.., ,·';n

    '~J""'~? l~~'~~
    q~t1{

    W1Z~ ,zr>b <P'1 'I .'

    W-l'' '.;p
    ;

    ~·~R ~~G] ~~
    (.I7jC~:
    .

    ,: ~~~ ~~"Fl~

    tl
    1'"'\

    -~Flll.<rnll8
    (;;1~~.qr4" ~

    ~~.
    ~·%Ni'il'

    <Q~

    <i'~~C'ii;<i\Il j
    ~~ ,'i (~

    ~'

    <lIPR~~~IFf-~~Pll'5(~!l

    IL rji.·¥j~;C~4&1f5i'K~
    -''Dt~~

    ~iC~ ~~

    \S"W1.tJV-;{~
    ~i~
    Yf'~~ ~

    r:1''iS ~'<1lB ~:~l>!J't'1 <m"lB' ~ r:ornwi '~,'Ul

    .~
    .'';

    Ci~T.~J~~1~

    ~~M,.o:p\5i4ffl \!i7.~~
    I ~.
    '5]'
    ~'- _

    (?fu:::nt:~H

    ~.\5{Q.I<n

    :,!ZSJ{5!Jl ·~C· S4R q~.t-'2;i'~ ~~


    '".

    .. '

    ~,!J,jJ ~

    C~~~
    •

    ~',.~:'

    Ft·

    ~(~~

    '~<"'1~.9i'Yt~.~
    ,<;_

    ·fCTC?J ~~,~ ~~~


    .r'-. -:.___.

    ttr1.7;t;'0

    \?fi~~1~'l @)5{.tzt ...

    r4~J3~t!1J ~m
    \5l1~i\!J'-,!)

    <N

    .~l9ft~Mrn

    1r<t1lf
    -.~

    >l~.~ ~

    f.)'~.

    ·r-

    ..

    '1'&(~?{

    \!}\~!)_t

    ~~~ ~ ~
    "iSf-'{l t?ft~

    ~R?!<f"i1 ~I

    \tjj~Pt~

    ~~-a~
    tA1('~?

    ~(.'9 ~Rif-~"

    T~h.{1

    <75T

    Vi~

    \5TR.~~

    ~(.~·W ~iSF15L911

    ~~

    rq<:?i- c<i

    _.., ~~, T1GJ~~1I ~~.


    .--~ "f6~9;
    ~

    .q;~~ <nfu~'~1lJm
    ·~·~?jfG~

    e:"'iJ 1~?

    '~';M .$l1i~t l

    ~C9i.C~r~i ''5l1'i(~ <P11!_,'6fR1'~!9i~?Yf1'~

    "'~~8Jl

    .. ~t~'b'1!

    ~,'I5i, ~~l"?,f (.J{Grn: ~~?"lj~~~~t\!)"5


    ~~~,

    (<i1t~ <ff.G1f\b1i~~)

    ~:~Ob'8
    (~~1?I ~
    ~,

    rq·~,~~\5R'1~";;f!Ct1rn~O'f.
    ~fqf~if~~'(?)
    ~fq)\5l~

    ~6J
    -~
    ·1~';:~:J;;o-...

    \!illfii
    ,

    ~'~~\3

    ,.qG1C~ 05'1' '....


    I, "".

    <u:~,.t ~'~lc" .
    \b:'-",'}j
    r-

    ~!
    Ai OJ'. ~ """'t.J oib.. ~'l
    !~.' \,,~ --i
    ~~_.j.'~

    ~~"""=...

    ~C;:<'I

    .~--

    ? ...

    '>!1<f1'9[9-(9]li~',? . mt~~~WGj ~

    ~fM ~~.
    -''3fi~llC::

    -n'9"'"?lC\!l

    ?jJm,~ ~.
    ,,~(~
    -

    -~~ ~
    ~

    ~19i'Qrq ~r:n'?f
    <r.~. ~ .~~ ~.

    ~~~.
    ~?

    ~9f

    c<P1~ ~'.~ .... t1, v£.;"_""t_


    ·\!}t~$l·

    ~1{ )'f

    1Z<9f4 C?l\)('~

    'Z1,~. ,~'V1t

    -=,~,
    -_

    '4MM

    ,,~,-tf·c~11
    ~'--oi~~

    ~r{

    ,q7.t?r

    m~
    ...

    ~t9r;~l'~ l ~@!. ~ .. t1n~j@1 ~~ ~ ~Grf'


    C~·

    ~~

    \5{~1~' \5'f<fl~6(,dJ

    j),~f~ ~
    """ .

    :'~\$?mf,!;i T;~(Jj,€
    ~~~'<tS
    ._ ~.

    ;:PQP,

    i~I;{@Hl~l'~~~trR .
    'B

    fB:Gk?"~

    <l}r~

    ~{.C7!l'

    \!??H\!5:f~ r~:(.Ji{''1, ~
    itz.?'K<l,~ 1~1"1 051 ~
    Q.A,

    ;y cSRl\!lC:~ ~H.1i~~~, \~F:tt\Vt'J"$~ q~ ~€ir<1>j 1\!):<p<H~~J-a(<p


    ._' -

    ·$jl\§i{~F~,.~ \5uj~;f\;~

    \51<Jl~m

    c~.

    ~or1?1<51~~~~

    3>j'$i'~~~(~(~

    (,&~,ce,

    iN&i~ 'A:~{'<l}J
    ~~Mt?i@.

    011:;;;JJC~31:q~:~=ru~l~i' ~

    ~r;$f.?f ~~~
    ~9j~

    ffk.?1,'~ I

    ,.-...... 1~-71 ! \5l-;t~

    -~~

    rn'l]p~1l 1i~?J
    <l~li' ~~"

    ~....__.,:oar., ~"'ir-4~ \8!(

    ~',? '1~ru4

    L_
    .

    .L
    ._

    ~~,.q'~

    ~ Ml\5C(i1 \51~ _.-.

    ~c~ tQ,~~
    9f$l ~~

    ~~T J

    ~f4.~' nq~?~

    ~1<fi~~

    1~9jf~G<1pl~$l9
    _ ~

    ~(.Q"n~1t6f -~~

    1TI~«;1Gl 01~ ~C<P

    :0:;~rn

    15'i9,

    ~~

    ~~
    1 r-.

    -~,~
    -C-'1l;t

    ~~~ ~~l~

    rt~('4~
    l

    ~?

    ~qR

    r~t\$f.~, <F,~

    ~~;{.Gtj(.'~~

    I '€~ (?:! ·~~~.(;<i~(,G1~

    ;n.~ tf!~01C<q£
    '5ij.'?l~

    GrT":2l>j~j.

    ~~l~~

    -M~mrn-

    '~~'Ii~ \5~~
    001 ~1
    r'

    'r,@141 H~C..q~ ~.
    G~t~c ·~~oo Ji1G~ i ~9f?l
    ~«i ~

    '9]

    tl,,-q.m ~qrG'f?:.~~! C""i[:>f9

    tA.

    '\&r<ij-~Vr:t'~

    \D~,

    .CWi" .~<JS ~l<qSU;'1~6 <i~(.~


    ~C9'Gl

    ·C'm:~
    (;8~(q1

    \5j~~~~~~~r::t';;J~ \ffi~'

    ~ (')i~.

    ;tifZ$m~(.G1~ ~<!f ~9'G1

    f<H:fJ~~;'i' ~~

    ~<F'G~ ~~

    ~c~ ~

    I ~r\::lCG1fJ

    ~~:~

    ·~~tf*? fi-~I ~rR ci.i=i1I~


    '-\!)lZ
    G1B"
    1~Z.Ji'}~ Cl..:91
    ~.

    NC<l c.~~tq(~",~ I

    ¢'l~<fi~'? ~~~
    b}Oj~~~
    ~ =: .;:::;,. j4~~

    ~(~r.rj~9f 1 \0Q_CGJ

    ,;d~Y7f ~@~ ..
    '=

    <i"'-'i<n
    <A~G1~
    C;::.__

    ~'?

    rz:.... TiF~ /. .'

    .:Yj;o,j\h

    czrt~i'iTIf9j(.~·F '~GTO{-

    1"'l(,'H.~-:.~

    \~,1\5f~l

    'MS '~-;1~tc.~!~~

    r-.

    41~ ~"t&W

    C~~

    11~"'1~~

    '-~I
    =~--";C\!'l""'' '--='' Sii

    "t1PiC,l7i.~

    0fH'.~.~."~~~Oi'f{

    ~\;5

    '6j~! 4St1(.§'t ifi~1<."iS1!


    '~(.<1"

    f1r;;t~ ~

    C>irq~ ~t';:75"O{,}~
    ~9J~

    ~'~($1

    c<F',]"

    '&1tF~~1~ 'iJ.ct(.~9R5 <~jT~tbtG1fu1' ~~

    "'1~t<p~ .'~ \5fBi .,~~

    i .~t?1 {Af'<l1ff ~
    I 'W1'~~~:;'~~$l

    ~~ qf.'1~
    ~.
    9\ .,.-,...

    ~~.~

    t\!}f~ ~~

    r,mW-l,~ ~iI$I
    .-cqf~

    ~~~1G4f8¥'-~\5t~w

    'Y®~R~jr'<l ~~'tf~

    ~t~ '4t9{G1t 9nwK-11~]Jrn

    1..·.·...~T?9'if
    ~

    '4($ 1Jl1J' i ~~ wmnrn

    ';n- 1·'W8~1.'4! ~:t<i '<t.% ~


    <ij1"'11~br
    1\!)~
    c-,.

    .""~"

    ~'~I

    ',~~j~M .~TilC4

    ~t ~.~~
    .

    ~~

    ~~ ~~

    HcsI ~~

    D1MQ.J

    V~C\[) .~'!

    ~~

    ~~i~~11CiP1, ~
    \!j~

    ~~H-c<ffli '~'€$il~ ·~~Sl1D<f.

    <lJl9fhiBrc~
    ~c.~-1<P (~'

    ~~H1 Ff~"<i!

    Ro-n:'1ar~l

    'P1·~C1f~·$1~>l
    ~}J~ ~

    . G1\Gm

    <1:~

    C~ I '~I.

    o;;ttSiGil;l
    ~~~?

    ~ftf~ U1~'G11:' t${Gf]? '~c~<plH "bJ


    C.:.i'El ~.

    ~R) \5D~
    l'j").jlJ;iJ

    ~;1'i~ ~~
    -I~

    ~1f1iiJ

    if..~(.Gi~ '8f tw1~01~\5T~

    \SJC>!l ..-:fI~t.~~ ~'I ~~ ~<jl'~(."3'$l .~ ·sijt! ZJ~ r.£t~"·i'el-C~ ~jt<pfYj~t»\,I} <r-t:#C~ \5l1~u."'t-~ ~im~t,;qs OJ ~ ~'fD~t~~ -~fB~~~~{;G1t <Q~ 'qP;rt01~' ~ ..;$G~.';ij \!i4l1i i \!)~ '<11 tiGi'fliilf$l
    -Q~'€ .~~\;

    ilJ·?p J1,~~. ~

    ~ ,,¥M
    ~
    ~~,.~

    'Ti? '~-qQ.~®\!)' .
    ......

    ,<P'~(A

    ill'? ~;,{~,
    ~.I

    ~1(}iQ ~

    ~'~

    ?f1t~1~j~f

    '5G1<'§~ ~~.-.j<?BF '~~I\5t~·-~1Jl'5lt:'<P

    .~

    ,'-

    ,r-..

    ~\$~~

    ,.

    ~l

    '- .

    lfibl .¢I~

    .~

    r'M

    'tfT~ 'N1Y! ·<p~tf~R;qs ,~1i~-~~

    ~}<l~fU-~

    <ffi9j<p

    ~?JJ. C9ff?1l ~Ct7t!:


    I~ ~~

    ~~c.$i i
    ~I ,

    ~~.

    '\!)~-{~ ~~.t;:f~.~· ~-

    '<J"f1f!<f> -<P1~lUt
    L~f?t~i?

    <p~0'f~ li,ffi'1f
    ,

    ~'em <U~

    '.frj

    ¥A:~Vl f<pce_V1

    ~fV+~

    '\51<n~\"Ol. c<f&lH:'>i ~

    ~Pt- ~~

    '. ~

    9J1~R~ <l'1f~'t>1 ~? -~t Ql~' ~t?j~9fF$1tifm6T~:l ~~ 91l~t-i i -i~. ~~1Wr ~~~~~\S ~ ~C~ :"ijt9!lsiGt ~~i~ 9j";:.~ c?'~qj~ (~fC~ \b'~) ~t ~lJl~' ~,; ffi0:h:r\!)';
    Oi >r;ij)-n@ C~

    -\~~~m ~C'G ~9f~


    ~~
    ~9I~

    <J$C1~r.;! ~~!

    '~~.

    ~~-i

    ;;n~~<iJi,(.~
    ~C~ ~~

    GT~ er~qlT.U =9~?Ul1fr


    ~~C<!I ~. ''i](.~~G,ITs>t~

    ~Cq ~'rt{~ '9frnt~~

    c.'~~f4-{,\!);

    01,*- f.2rl~~J; )"~l~'~ '&:~~ >i'~P'iJ~M~'i~G:l

    '9,~VT~' .~
    ~. ~1(~f \..~l!!'t......

    f9~1-(,}j'bi~ MC<1I)"li
    ,r-{ ~
    ~

    ~(,~ ~~1W ~~1"9.i:~~


    '~~ ~r.{-'·1.J11~ 9j~~•. ,._

    ~W!
    ~

    ~'9 ll~'-

    , --®~.~.
    -~ ~

    ~7:~

    ~pn '<q)~C\5
    ""~

    91' ~rtt£ ';0;1 ~9t~~ G~

    C911~~'11 ~
    i \5fi~,~t

    tj~r%~ 11Si~:nC1 ~~;i~Gff1-~~m~ ::Ii"tifrl


    ''---'

    ~'"1~ -;:rt .. i;;:ql~i"t3cG11 «< l«ie~ ~


    9fl~

    ~Hb~<Pt t1fr:al-~FPf} O}r{IJ'i$! ~

    '¢[h~ ~.C'1~
    ;n, -~.% ~~

    ~~
    (~"1

    ~(;\!)

    ?jjf~

    m! ~

    \5ftSfl13i Gfi'Gi ~~41ru\!l ~.qr~·~


    !tttt!

    "\st.P~· \~~t.;1 <m~

    "G1~9j~ '~fia' CliLo::l. ~~.

    ~~ oot· fDfb'?!lQ:(,st('~f'1;

    'ftn'?r -£V1·...Q~Br ~~

    ~.ic~\5l'T~i1J

    C911jjj<M~ .Ci~~ ! "G~ ~~~tG'iJ;qs


    ';:P:~~15(.~

    <ri

    ·f&1r.~c~~·:

    \¥"jO'{"lflT-q
    ~J.I"'""iF,

    .•:-:"':

    .~~

    ·~i""~1

    lfj~
    ...--,. ~~',.)~.

    ~'~

    ~~

    -fiP~
    f-.,~

    (~211?i L.QI'&?1G1~~~
    ~

    c~R~i;{.~'iQ ~tm}tl.1
    I \5@9@
    '.

    ~1(;$! ~

    f:<1\§si1~j'~ -'6'l~:.q ~-;q:n9l;~t!!~

    ~;}l~ib~·

    'ijb~
    c"__

    ~1jC6·t ~

    ~~"41"\5
    ./

    ' ' 'J!:-i:l~ ~9jl'~~i:C~~


    ~.~,. 'G:PlJot:R:t;j?!~OHr i
    <'.q@3,~.~
    ,:z;'.....

    c>tll71UY ~

    ~ 'il~

    ,..,,__

    "1Bt~r ·~"'ilf~~ ~

    r,."""...._

    :~~lJl '5f8f:~~@flb.~

    ..Q'~~

    ~t

    ~i:~
    tQ.,~

    ~nf:2;'~':R~M~ ~ WE.~~ !
    ~
    '~t\!)4"~

    2fllG®l~9

    ~Z~M'\9

    '~L~ ,.,~

    ~)~TI1 ~Mi.!J7ifWJllt~ -~~W"1~';f


    9!~~

    13t"~rijr.~I~ifiOl1

    f2=tG%'Gt~'~I~~\5
    ~ f

    ~i21[~~ 9~, \5ffi'9fQ'

    'f¢s"@ .";f?f ~.

    «1,1.10f ~tq

    ~1-~{;G~ ~C~Jrq'l~?f
    ~f)C?t

    Lflq. Ci1~'lPl$ .~m1~~~ ;fRl';:f

    ~rff~~
    (,,~~, '~r&l
    ~"')t.(ij

    ~rm~
    .......

    :-m_'!>.f 'S~~7?i~h~\5l~~wt~
    -='"-..

    C>n~t~J i 'tc..~l~

    Of~_
    .~

    c~~ro
    01t~

    'j4;\g

    'BWlH~' ~9;'l$!7t
    ~?

    .~ '( 'bm

    ifl1~1$1 ,~rISl~ ~.?

    'l~CbC¥4~t~i

    ~~.

    Jr{.....

    '~C<J1Mi'H'~" 9\%~.

    ~~.g(.~ -<}~il
    ~.9\ ~

    ~~ I '~lG1~i_-M lQ~lt~ .~

    W1")-M ~~rn =11~Q:fifc ~miMlf~l1; W1~ ~,~ <4~.~. "'~fb1 ~r.ffi .'J5!1$. -,<11<1<!'
    R47fr.
    \!)~~

    ~,;:j6~"<1' ~iGf (~~t

    ·~"91l~.c~''e?f-~~~! ._
    '~~
    ~,

    '~~~'
    ::r~
    ~

    f~-c~~\5[?f~4
    '\SjjGl ~-::-~~
    •

    ;~i)'l.~.j ~

    .~
    ~>jSl
    (""'I

    ~t1P.'<i ~~(.~
    ~~~

    z~~ 9fl~~<m ~;
    ~H.!i\1i&:t
    ,~.

    --~ro'W t;~~m~r~~€Mfir~' PhF4


    ~~~~
    :

    ''jf.6.%

    ~:~i~'

    ~:rol._~~.(
    ~r?1~

    ~~

    .'

    tP1~

    ;~~

    -\5lit~

    ,j

    ~f! <M9J197 ~'fDfT.rfrn ~qc-1\9 ,I ~W

    C11\M:Pt9~(

    f)' ~0<$R~iijl?J \!)G1iil ~.


    'Yf@ Q.6.!)·
    I

    J'<fil.ts7:\!1
    •

    .~~('G1

    f.F?~;;m-r.~fS ~~~~
    ~'Kf.1",.. ~. J1 IJ~'

    ''v.~.

    '?!~C~f' ., _

    ~'~I' ~1i~"'[1

    rQ.[l.;<p \.,".II1. '

    iGf~~lf (~
    . ~.'\. ~-~

    ........ }

    ..

    ~J~Wf.~~Rr R<Q'!) ~~I6f'l~ ~'J~ ~"';~~If'i" '{,':<PG1Q~~~~~ ~~. ~ . L'" ... I.::!: ~ ." ~·l~f~
    II.

    ~-

    ·\jr

    >lRt{.DJ'Ai~i.q'51·~·!(jl

    '¢j1~f~ 2l'Rs~,
    ·;_£ml.1ffl '~'";:r'H"
    ::1"'i" rr'l

    ~r~5firsr~~~
    '\:~~i

    '""ll-J.;_ ~

    ~~';"'''<':)

    ......'

    ~ .~~I

    .... t7>7$'t ~~~J \""~?'<P,.+I """'"- . ..." ' ....,;'i« '4'''''''i v \}]:.o( .' 1 """,,J'~:1
    '~1~ry5

    '~~

    Wl1f

    «~~~~\~.QJf

    [ e;~~7.Sl"f-c<1·¥L;·t
    '.
    .'

    -WfY5 ~. I ~. ~~%(J!) .~
    ',;,! .",'V" "

    "~m,,~j ~'' ' ';CI ~ion ....

    '?i~l\b~ '~f<l1 ~:i


    .......,

    ~. r ,;"';'~~ ... ,-hV"'-:;IA""""· L,'"'I


    ~
    1i).j~r

    ~:;'*t;t>1 '?l~Y<!, ~.
    }.i~l~·Sl

    \;,9ii$1 ~

    .. 311~~1 "\~~.'~'~

    ~r%

    ~~C4 ~~\S

    <rt9t~~

    .~

    \5ff~ V~.t:~;:'~~l~, '·+~1! ~it.~ ,ifiGq

    ~;q'#iC'f?r

    ·\t)~l I$:rC61 ..
    '4~:

    'P:m-~ 0'i1&lC7i13r"1~_:ftkt}jt<r
    ~~R f~~~r~
    'f'~ ~.
    ~~~;' -qV'j' ~'

    A:«r~~'@~

    ;ro' (i11~. ·CJf

    \5f1'-"'n"8,~kt,.~.~ "~f.tt'-;) j .rf!)i~


    C~~~ .~~ ~~~

    ~t?r, \5119 'f.tr<1?j~"ip1-ffl#r~ ~~~~~


    sq'j~t;<l ~!Yr""'<fC?l'

    f~'q-(rry& C9iit'$£R I ~
    ~~io~i{

    qJ17:f~(-18iJ8.)~C1j~.iPi~·1 '4;,~r'\5!f<J\93R!I~~-C~tFt~l{3t<~PK~ .~
    3fM'G1br~T~l~ "~~ ~ ~. ~C~il'l ~~ ~~9~
    ~
    '........ :::;,. ,'-" ,. ,'" c~·............!'

    ~~~.
    ~f:::;."

    ~~r

    ·~5G~19j19i:

    tiWfnJ'

    (A

    !'71I~il~?i( ~~'lVS~

    T ~1G~~I~;!)I~-i

    '"

    ~~'~1""
    ~9j~

    ~1ff1}3i ~'fl'~ 4f m~:{1M p~·C~.~~'~~~ .t'llf1 r.oi~I <!10'l fll1l?I C~~~ "f1<f1!l 08'0 ~ ~~

    ~~
    ~

    >l~Hi ,~~

    ~'i~
    India:
    W4f:
    ~

    ~~(JH7i ~C::nS'l C\5l1:'3i Rf01 ~1?J


    1fiQij \5!<lC~.~1C~

    r--'--':
    .9j"f\5t
    .

    ~I ..

    ~!r;~f~~ m~~~ {;2r'G!i'Ar:.~ ~'~~fdt~l ~i


    ~~.

    f~iFb\B~G1i1

    ~'l8~

    tYfi11 C>i~ ~~t~t:G1~


    \51~' ~~':<f9
    .::;, ('~'

    ·'GJ.~~,;;H ~Gqs ct;J'(;>i I


    '9f~"f\b
    r-

    .qU1 <ft?1

    .~~~~

    f;t..-Q51.,

    ',C'l~:~'tlOj~
    '4C~

    A Wounded ~Jviliz,ation".~~'J'i?f.1 1~C\5 C!)ti,<p~~.GJ.;t ~?\r.~,t?i ~:


    ./
    ~;-:...

    ;j/

    "$j"~r~f~~
    \5j1'PrG3\!)1~
    ~.

    .-.. .""

    -'"""'. .\"'\.G,.;...1!--=-

    ·w (~1"~;1!?l'~wt) ;0l'R~rn~:-Zc1\51~~'e.)
    ~~

    cnf.q (iii

    ~.1Jr ~1JJ .' {,~~bn~~! "5r~


    ,
    ~ j

    ,~t~· ~~f

    ~$l'

    Jj(,*~

    C<!~

    N<Rl

    ~'5it~f<q5~C~{ ~~~~<:'$1-~tf7l1~~i i
    r

    ~~ ..~~

    "'~HT"'~~?;jd!¥Gt '~\!)-F1":if\!) )1~J~L; ..<11~.~'<f'~' CG1i~e1';01~ XS~


    """,,_"'..,....,.....

    ~U!G§t 0fl~H:oir-c;n[)~l('ti1 . ~~ ~1?l\b .~f(."'~t~


    ~~.\!i

    ~tj·l~l~L~

    .Si.._

    r=«

    ipr~
    -~ ~,.

    ~9

    ~:

    ~~rrrf'{ -wr~
    e.~

    C1tt> ~I~

    ",

    ~i<r I '\5!*,t~ ~'~1J~


    (1:f{Pl~L9'~";J'

    <:;~r~~i (>i~).' ~~~~R--.,q ~1'B~

    vr~t<1o{ ;in"iL~~

    ~~~lL1~ ~<ij

    L:fk~H:i,n~ W:~211r:iF. 11 ~~$lr:,<{l' liR$i.~~tb

    R4W-e 'P9·r;b~i7ir~FtE~.·2t~n·«?l~ ':l'p;g~!)f(:<f~


    ~'6'm
    ,!(_~

    '~~~l~~
    ~~

    '~~<p

    '1,~~G~ @,<v.,~S'1 '>i!t~ ">T-mJ ~P"1C4 t~C<l


    v.

    '~'3;!j'i ?!~:c.'!l

    ~~0i ~PiR\5' e1,*,~J?l '~<,i1ti~\~


    :~~

    \5fF~~~~A
    .'5Tj".C1(."6j

    ~~~
    G~~t

    'lJfr:t<:i'G1 '<!f(»! ~ ~
    "t({.if74 CJf >i~g~~~

    ·ti;Gi '("ij"t~a-i 1 ~'4,i"{, ~':Q

    (<1

    ~)j¥i ~

    ~~J''5f1~~~~ t~.qu~

    '~J:;~

    ~~0ri.oi~ l1~~iQ~ '~c9@ <lWt<l,'~r-~' cl~!)1 ~~·Rt\5M~


    ~·I.

    ~~1l
    ~. ~~

    f;'R~/~~<q ~ ~4q!
    ~.ffi\§F·~fDC6J~
    .~

    c-~

    ~f

    m41 :z~ ~

    ~i~;!.~.

    QJ1(~<f>.1 ~

    \5n~101·~'8 .~~~

    ~~~i

    <fc<J UPb1
    .".__

    ~fB\ ~te1Wi

    -.

    ~~~
    ~~

    ('31~.iBiii')
    t!JC\9 ~

    ;.!j\!)~1q "1~' (~:q1';~i)

    ~r.~ crlf.:1i
    ~"1.~~'1,@~ <:iHJ ~~

    ,~'{j
    ~~;l (\5RJ

    C~

    l ~~ ~~ ~~

    'ilf1_l] ~ ~

    (:<l'&31~:c.~ N\§gR-~~

    *'~~«~

    1Y1t~ ~t4?

    xv·pil~ ·oil~~.

    ~f!
    ~~

    ~/
    ~.

    ,~m'1:.r.)I .~
    ,~-ijj: .;...~ ..~

    ~~" r.<I

    '"JiGrC.o1$1 '4'uPl'P1$ ~'i.{\5l~ <JSqJt\51~

    -r
    ~;;4
    .•

    '11CG1 4t~ C~~Gfjtiil-1~~


    iS1~J ~
    ~QJ<4'>c.4 v .li"l''';,I'1
    <I

    Xi~P1C~
    'iFf
    ;;;:r~~t:~l'~ '~I-

    ~~I~ ~~
    It-..
    t.,,,,

    '<rr4J
    VTQ.,[q

    'f$\"S ~"i(.~'i1

    f<lt4~~~\!)Qj'1<ff~~ .•

    ~'IM'$3R."i?

    TI{c."'J ~...--..."~ ~ "11":t' ~<p''i1(.\!}

    .I,'

    !'

    ;;rt -~'I

    .(:7l ~'''''

    <r"
    ''''"'II

    ~I': '~J,t,!ll

    9t~~ .l'~=-<IJ."l''''1

    9Rl ~ "'~'~'?

    (\t4~tlSl~fiJ~E<P~)

    'f1~'

    \~14(18f%' C~~ '<Wn

    ~1c<1~ (1l~
    ..,;.:, .'

    <4C;G1

    ~rort JTI1-J9rClWi)
    \~'~1Jf~~ •

    ~l-f~(~~'1
    ~(;\!"i ~
    ~,~ (,.-H.rUIII"'\Y:'i

    ~
    ~'.d!;>,~ .~ -~"'

    (~

    \S-r~?tfW
    I
    o;;;:r~ ""I~,~,

    111<t(}$itl~";t/t~~) @3"1,. (/~~-<'.


    Ctrl4
    .

    2ft ~~
    ~r.<t.~.
    ~

    ~n6~'S.~

    118 I

    '~i.·'_~.~) ~.
    Jt!l,*~1

    '~"

    .,~!~

    c~·t~

    '$1

    ~~

    !j-f~l<Hi(;1 (~~~t\Sr*.') '-...!!~ - ~'ZM'~(ij

    ..

    t~(/-loi'

    ll~-(?fif~~
    UR~ I

    srj(l~ Zlt"b
    '1

    I ,~V3 <rI' ~C'1., \Om "~

    I ~.11?! ~

    ~a:. .

    ~~

    ~
    ~~

    ~t

    -e \5;Fbes\!)r<i1~h

    :;qft~~
    '51C& ',.....

    00'i!) I.!l~ ~'1. 7ft ~\S@


    - '~Ii'='l:""(~.

    \5.1~\!)~i

    ?if....b:in .~

    "I~~.':'I:

    ;'*4W -."
    Ie'

    ~i'7.S"1~ ....j~. \!)

    ",;'<.,1

    ~-1fA?I ,'........

    )(

    _ fBu.rl $1
    ~~~

    ~~

    .~~'4,~'IS?1\:!)"Jll.{~·;n~
    '~('G1-1 ~~~\t;1i1 G1~'6' Cu~
    ~";q'1 ~

    <m~~q
    ~?

    \5fltti ~
    ~.~

    I
    ~i.I'~~f<fi
    \Sft;~=C,;gJj

    19

    Rr~ M~l~ ~~(~~~?,~, ~1'~ ~R¥Gl


    ~,~t<p
    I~~<:,p~

    f~fil 0,'*l'\~f'*1t~'ii
    ~~lt C'5'f1~ ~

    ~~'\.*j~

    (:rrl·<i?%i'4;·"[.~) ~~4\t)l$1 ~

    \:!!Q[1

    ~11i~'DtG?i~~t -"(GcOvernmentality)

    ~'~':;::P1\B1-<j)t"'?

    -tf L...

    t~~ ~
    <!l

    c,~fib"p\!) ~
    .. ~

    "I>f\'!J 0m
    .~~. '~,

    ~('<l'1. ~

    ~~

    ,~~'<

    ·\!}.lS1:i,~1~

    ~'$!

    (,~:~:I::~"-.
    ~_:~

    <K."1~"i>l1 7<ji§!llH4 ~ 'f<!il,:t,"'I1r.~ "It"1it '<lf~f ,~'<n'"?! ~ 'i5l1(.~ro~-:r~'1'f 9jiijl\&~ ~~.


    ~,"~(~j 9jj&~ ~rmG1 ~

    ~CtlFDfir.~·
    ."~~
    '~.~
    \fl~

    m~m~'~ ~
    {?f~
    • Ci~ ""'"I<...(~l;N

    \'j.;..\....

    ["--101.

    ~:g~!)
    ~C~· 01-n

    '1!(gi~

    I 'J1Jh1 .. r ~ ...". ~'.\S~T~

    ~~;I'> rS.J ~;I


    ('1\~'i

    '~rnw'm\;'G~,
    \5i ?h1t

    m I ~P$~, {01t~l?C~' ~~Ot$l

    ~r ~111

    m' W?
    ~~f.;.\5JN'~?H)o{Y ~

    1fl1~::iI~ ~i1}6J$l
    ~'~l/l

    q..1$l~ .... . ~

    ~ ~ (31 q~~; ~

    C~~, ~ C~~,...
    '~+~.

    'f)' fdf.-I
    -

    -d1-~n1 CWl"& -M"'lJ~ 'j::;~~[


    ~~.

    Wrt~ft1.Gt1~·Oxford

    English

    ( 1986) ·11~~G1t., f

    ~i?j"W;

    '?j~-MV;~
    C~~ i Ot-"F{

    ~'PliM~?11115
    ~' .... --ZQv.

    ~Wt 'qi~lt, ,~~ ~~~{.~~'-~lJi ~ -~ "iff! .~ ~¢t1'


    ",,¥,~.

    '",,.,<;).1'1' ,- (?> ~<'iI.~ 'V ·'9 ... ,.,~..."-'i

    v,~"":t)"

    C·

    o~ [~ .' '-.!",;-..,'' ' ... "'(1"1

    -~·W

    r;rl~~l

    ~C.4 '<!1
    .~

    ~"~ ''''.j

    'fi<~ i!j"'"l(\;1ion~ 'Y'", l:] I.. I 'Y::-!!

    ''<.:~'"

    Xr'!H

    .-,~,

    "V

    @
    .,.

    (",?!';\~ ,,""'1.'\ ..... "1 I

    ........ .. ~ -~
    ,-.~.<p~

    ~L[ r
    ,..,

    <.;;j@

    U1<1' '1\:; ~·N 9j ~N>. ~ ~<1'!\Si

    (.>wit <?

    '1'[- <>I "l.

    R>

    <l<'1rn. <mil
    ~

    ~t1.1:;1. f<i@
    ~!<l ~

    ~~j

    I~, ~.<JS1l1 ('~&~~) '<l~u;lfC';!) 9j(~w -. r

    ~ffiw

    <1!O11 ~ t~

    <(..1 '~

    ~.

    C$.1.~

    ~1I <f$r.~i

    '*QO'i-

    lf1<p~f?I ii'~
    ~~ ~
    ~-~~~

    'i~ qiff~~~{'L14 ~<r


    ~ ~$J'iiji11

    99i~·{

    <l'ftq .)l~

    ~Ri~
    ~i{(iFl
    ~OYPi

    Ib1?
    ~

    a"'St c.--;t~~:qs '~~~aJ ~ ~t-i~ ~

    Qi1~W<?~0:5
    $'j'1(\?1

    i '~~'_2i~

    ~"?r1

    \51{_,~?l_ ~~~
    .qfb'5'lOH

    rqt~
    ~
    ~fPi~

    'Fr~~};n~~t;::f
    J ~ ~.

    ..QGQ"i~> ,~~
    ~ ~.~ '~~

    <n
    ~'1

    qt~'3fl~
    ~

    '~rt~\51jf\51":'J (q~iH<p~r
    !Q<i"~

    N
    ~:~fi,

    tfI~;q

    C~
    /

    ~~

    <P'$l1;'14i' ?

    ~.r<r
    ~~
    r

    fifB~l .Q~r~.),
    ~(\!l

    9[~J\~"l \!lj"

    ';rn!

    ~~I$H \5fP! .~

    C?i{'b.'G

    "·PK~~·!~1¥
    '('6~
    9~~ ~

    ~-mtt
    "'l~<Aii;r ~9~
    \5l)~ ~~

    c~~tR· ~<p
    m'TC;:R ~

    o/OT <ltG'l C~(7jt)i~, '~l~~

    '5i.l~*I~ 8i i6f11fSj'RJ
    ?f(:oJ

    m~
    2l~-

    ~.

    'FP~ ~
    ~9
    '.

    (.~f<'{.\!) GTI~
    ;q;~
    ~LP'i"~
    .

    <A18f eJ~~ ~~
    iQ~[
    .

    ~) ~ GiIl01)· \51"n.~P'iC'!l.

    r»; Ct1:I-:4'~o.:tt,~J

    ~~

    'i? ~ 1. ~-$7~.t'

    ~V1
    .~

    «'1, ~ -oql~ -,~ ~1\b41?jll1tG"(~ ;,


    {~~(;~

    \5l~$l
    t

    ~{.a;H

    ~<;pM-?rr.q ~~
    D'RtV1iti

    C:01'GQ'j.i\S~!\ ~1.§.)'<14€ ~l?l" ~ J11~.~'?1 ~


    ,-... ./ .

    ~~'

    ··~C-G! ~
    .-.. .".._ ----

    gp?tC2:[~
    r',.....,,_____,,_

    c0~A .~~
    ~'9iJi
    ~

    'f>l~ ~
    ~.l

    C9j~

    -};\fj ~~9 {.'ol ~'itt\!J

    ~t'1. ~G~€'rrr-{) i \5.l~~Wl~

    ~R,®5!)F11-m?;!1'>11i$jC1j('~G11
    . """"Si=>::p~j7::;C~=; ,=~, 'tJi~'Si ~:q:1L.t~i

    \5rm
    ~~

    01-:<j(;\!)

    I Cl'j'Gl Cq~n '<1_iI:1 ~~?i?

    Jf4~

    ~r~~ JfW3'1f 001~


    ~',,~~ '<;!)iiil1;;r
    ~b

    \5R"7f1 C'i'Q}
    ;n"Sf
    <M\§f I

    ..Q';;l~

    ~''O''f\3 ~

    )~C~ ";{I""'I1I,l'vP ~t'$''!1

    1i~~?Jl?i9f1txt

    ~-

    ~,(''fl~bt \!)8n0f'41 <rf1:<r' ~~'I


    b1~¥<l '<)~-!)
    ---~ -=--...

    "5'l~

    ~ \8:Z C<f.,:qWi'~t.t4$f:@1R<f..~
    '

    '1~'<1

    'i6f1(;~~

    '91~~:1

    '1~1r~~' '~

    Fr<B1~ ~'ifll

    -=mr...~~

    -m(,\!)5j

    P,r."N~~. ~1i:.z~~i : 12Ft<r~'G1l~~~~


    <Sc~·~,

    f¢~i ~11FltC$~

    ~H .~~ ~.
    :

    r~p; 'I&G-~~?l;
    \$j<QftJ_~
    .

    I C~\5ii.i 'O;::r 1.Q~ b~~~SR. ~$~t~t'M~~~"'l

    (Jl\~tr~

    c9Tt&~ f
    ,-...."'"""":".

    '~<l'~' ~.

    r ~B
    ~,,?!;'j
    "-..

    '<11' ~Q"]'lf~

    i:.~~!f~ \5n~('~~ \5l11PlJbJ 'b~F<$~~' ~ ~<H',,~~ ~,~f~~~MNt .~. ~~N,~~~ C~Mj..~~ 11 .q~<n~ xl41it ~~1.~ firC?'l'<I·~(.~ '<1J<i~,~ <p~$ll "tBJ r (.~~1C~~ . ,,_
    '~"i9:~~l1r ~[01 ~,
    ~

    @ ~Zt'5l~tii
    ~,r.

    ~~~~Wi~ i
    r£l~
    ,~"~~.

    remainderl
    jGil~~

    ;-:;;0i{~,-i~~1li ~.R!fl-f~
    ¢i~~' C'-I..

    W{
    ...... ,

    remind ~l~~
    ~.

    \51~ \5fr~~l
    '<.

    '__'1

    t,.q

    rerruajinder I

    ~~~ <.

    \!IG1rR

    \!i.&m\31.~

    ·~Wi.q ~~4

    qz$it<1

    'bJ~r.t.--r~\~3lt;:"'l?l'

    \i;~'?f ~I{!t~~~

    .._

    "'-",,...,...

    '(j;'lI"~'63'~l .~Sj~ ~ZBfl~

    .. ~j;~

    f~-I.:

    ::.rnc;fj~~

    . (2iiG' Pr;,h~fl :..,

    ~1fij~~1'-6~.~~~l:<{

    _.c--

    . r-

    «<

    ~~~

    \5.t1~·xt?j· I·<q~~

    I"'"'-

    .....'

    '

    . ./.

    (b~t~·4S
    ~rt~~1'5J

    .,__

    _,.-... .. 0

    ~li~~I$l

    ~l~.rf(J~ ~t'ffl·;

    .. _

    . _"

    \m)~'-S ''-'i._H.''''i··

    x--"\oi'; --j"""

    .(-I),%~ ~~ l.'. "'1'\"'_'<1 :<'l\1:')4~' ~r-4" ''6l<1.'l§lf%''t"= ''II!>,"-",,,,,'>I ' • f...- .. 6, ...... 1'>nT :?;:'<?;J'!7 ""' ... ~ ~ "';-.!)

    ~~i!I..~"'"

    -::-rt ~..,..-;j-;"'l

    I ~'?l'~ - 1-..-:'._

    '~40TI I -Q'5J C9)~m ~.

    ~ffi~.}4~~ if1~~$i f
    i ;n~l~ C}.j~ C~

    ~Y1\!)f-)tQ~ ~~~I'

    ~R

    ~~'<H$i ~'~~~(£['~:i%' fqiM~i9~01~ I~C51 ~.<a~\Jr ~!/f ~

    c: le:.f~!~~~~~~ l
    ~'~.9j.;q

    f~\;~Sl,9(t~

    ~J6 ~~TIi
    ~(;~j

    0R_~ j
    ~.Q;l

    ~t"-it1Jl ~--~4

    ;o-\5frf4 ·'~'@"~?if '\!Ii~J~' '<;fffi I ~'l~ ':tj\!);~'" -s


    ,~.j

    ~.

    ~c~: ~ (~iiL~t~
    .

    X5ffi\b \5ij~l.~f~~.c;j) fr)~~ ~~L9 ,

    ~QJi;~(.(i11~~~1i'

    <p~.ri.z(.~ 9t~'I U9~ ~


    '1t'G'l i'4i:J11._ -,
    <p--~
    :C~

    ~9bl
    '::"~.Q__ j
    ~

    VSC~~_'~oq1 ~

    t~~ ~'""Pn1r
    ~f1'fil?l "~'~''<Ji

    ~tri1:r
    -

    _,.

    19!'W c>qsC'1..5 ~~
    -- .. - to

    :.

    1!j.,;p.l;f

    '-

    tJ'?i~

    ~tc~. 't7~~>'I"bJ

    \"j·~<?t? ~"G11:-:mI1~ ~:qt.~ '?i\!lf-'4~~

    f=(j~11taf.~ . '~1(~'" ~.~


    ~~\llJl
    . t~"

    (.:1i~ ;n"Xjl~q:.·~t~~~
    ~
    >

    '\5U~ "'11r$(J.J<ILGj~,

    ·9j~"X]1~m ~.'
    ~~.

    C<.i1W· ~~

    r~(,~.1 '~'~~'!'~,!

    '.

    , '. >_ G~-~~ ~<EZ'!>.~. tq{,JtG"l?1 9-C0Al-~1iJ

    rrrn .",

    '<1tG1"-i).!~

    ~~

    ~~m~~
    1Ji9ji~t71

    "._,,~
    ~

    I
    I

    I!l~~ ~~~

    ·<jG1G,crpr

    ~s§f~'iJ~$i~

    fq.eaWl'"?i>1"\!!J.;fijC~~1

    ffi"tn:~

    ~'~'~-i'~r~

    ct~'2 <rt 'P1~I_~$l~ '6{'1C~l-;iG~Jft~ '~'~m

    « ~~

    ~'~~~I~~

    ~l~_~mf;fG~1) <:1 \£I~4$~t4t~~


    ~L~ ~n~
    Ji\!)J~~ ~

    •.~

    '4~<p1\5l4l~ ('4~

    fitl~~~' '~~.;r~l~

    ~ll"i '~. '?J~

    '>i"4 <"Bl~~· )"1\tl}-Mt~1R91r ;q.=?¥~ C~~1 ~J'~


    '11I"mG1o;i~:~1 ~
    .~~

    ~ I' '~4'

    q~at~

    l~~'~I \5i~t!7t c~

    .i\5fR~?

    ,t'""'!

    '!)

    .'t~~ '(~rnlM<$ ~Cif14~ 'R~ ~'<i ~"l1<fl, .~~~'


    MA~' wr<~
    ~~
    Q_1]

    . Cin~
    'P{.~

    <Jlt9jmt/~~ ~fit m ~4C\Si% q_?\

    P'-

    ~.8.

    "4i' m·:1i'm-;;l

    ',*<~--;£i"\')1'i'';F.! 'l>I'l!1'~~ 1'~ l:>«!C'" ;r, I ~;n-'~!rr~t-.~ "il1 '~'t;'6t(.~~ '~rC~H9I'Kg' G'<IT'7l>-rt <p~O(],!O')t~ ~ 1 ~ {fq~H~ m

    *~U?J) .01 ~~
    ~~~4?
    ~ 'j;~'(;~

    (~l·:(
    ""

    $to-~t~\f·~: ~~t7j8f. ;n
    l<':~\S ~
    _r~

    (~~ !
    ~

    ~ ~.jwf*:.-il~~"!~;l\~~ ~.-. ,'~~ If


    ~'1

    ._
    .

    ~/\!)1
    T

    \5Ni:f43l~~

    '.'.~~~., ~~- ~~:;1 '~~~

    ~PR?J .~~
    ~

    '~'-N

    'Y.J~~tP"i"

    d~.:>f\5.~j-:<lL'll~ \5i@!~, .. ·
    . .;pf<l~ \QB1~'~1~
    ..... -·1 ",.., .
    OJ .-~ ".

    ,<p~~~

    ~, ~~J~
    1

    \5f1f~'

    -~\!)J I ~lQj~<; ~
    ~I" :~\J!~.~-I

    ~1,~~~ .~~~,~, '31 ~

    ~>,;

    ':,$1'

    <f1~(~c*'\VtGj)
    .

    ~:{(.q'Sl'

    Pll~ '1~~
    '.;,.._"'"'L. ~ ~

    ,tb~N~~;.GW~~
    '4t?l
    -", ~ j

    15lI~"
    3.~.
    '. ~'J!I"

    ~~
    ..

    14"%'; ~.~~~
    "9~@'-:1 ~~

    \5Ti'f~i~ ~~~T9f

    7fl·i~'1(~f.ii~l· ~,~.

    C'<ltiif.. '~~~'L:~'fk -~.

    _,......., .

    &t '!>t~t~~
    rq~
    ~I'1~
    '1","*"l
    '-'

    "JJ~~~ $'ilQiGr: ~t:;;:~. b<W~:,<M~'bfr.q q1~i~'Gr l11}iLG:10k~ ! '~F1' @~r;Dt;r r.q~~~~. fii f~Q~'~}!?f1qtl e:j<p~ 1N..v.:r ~ {~tI·gt 4~ i '~' ~. (!i~tit <~7f;f (~~, ~. ?")-..Q<t1$f ~~ ~filir.~·~ C~~'<l\!)~lffl'~
    (;'f<fr.'f>-'<,l. ' Oi5-"DiGi.\') ··~34'.q

    ~Kt~

    "{.:(j.(;~

    <91jR~"i 1 ~'19

    ':<.i"'b" ~~j~ .

    b=.,....,..

    ;rn

    V5fj'~'(AS
    '\¢t'\i
    'Jr'~

    ~':rJ;!.
    ,~

    ~ ''''~VJ..

    ..,~Q..:::::.. ''1{G.1. L~'IC!1" ~,,;~


    ._,_~.~' o,Jl{(:9

    ~77. \....~

    (~(~f~ .' ~

    <llbl?;<J>ffi, , ......"t _ .... ,.


    ..t2.___, '-'.

    ;lj~-cW!(;<'j·-I:mrGi(;%'$l ~~. ;li'~r-Vfl'"M; <i:jV51


    ---=--,
    ~;t I C~.f~,f~, ~·1~G"~,: ~'
    '
    <:f1r~"'lj~[~~
    t7::::r-::.~,.

    '~1,~-~1
    ~'~ ~

    ~<Pm: (~.ld1<1'rLi'l
    <P~I ~

    ~~

    '-'.

    ')'

    ,_

    ·~:n~01 ~~~"

    . '=
    ..

    ~t(7'[F~l\f8,?!}
    ...,....

    ~~P1~'i't
    o.rr-.

    :Z~.l~l~
    .~

    <"lit

    ~ttJ

    &~Z
    . r-.~

    .-

    .•~

    "1·~~.P':ti
    '"""

    C~L.~~p{~]~

    . ... ,

    C\9 .~
    -;:;-'U-q;

    ~h\?t$l;9f,I,-? ~
    ~

    .G--

    ~! ~

    <tfttp''ji

    (~i(.~"

    t.f}:r.pr. ~~11L. ~QJn9)


    ,-...

    , IS~ (9Jt~,

    >3<;>C\!)

    ~ft&,~ ~F~\$\5'l?i

    "'1m I fuf8r~

    'i5lJ19j1w.~{;~i"l:t:"<"'!~·

    ~wi{ ~,

    l!l<4'~ C4'<1 \t{1 ~

    '1~-'\5ri~i:tGt~
    .i" . ~

    tr{~?j~;

    <£~

    ~1f;~W1!~ ~~~l~ \5fll;{f~~


    ,'r-~

    ~iil'5T

    ~. "(I"lt.m;

    1'lf3p,

    -c~'!)?t ~\5<;~ ~

    i ~~~ ~~%v;!>r,

    =.

    CXJ."V1 ~~Jfl-(~Gi:Q '\5J'1>j~ ~. ~~ 1 if @~~ ~ ;S'! /" '" ~:; \!)H~q.I~~~t"i~Ji'\!)j-iK~ \5'7\'<fl~-M\S3rC~?l {>*'l~jht<p\!ll~

    "<1M .~df; - fl::~f;Gr'Sl~~ ~


    ~,9('~"?t

    ~~

    <IT>!

    '&R~~(.'G"
    ~~ rr: i1Tt '-=7'911~

    ~(,~ 5i<; C<je3rffi~;1t ~~,;; J,,'!Jj:"l11fi1q·1\G$l11l


    ~.~'¢lfl:'

    f~ ~C~~-----<.Q~,.,fb
    ~,~

    c-

    ;rl

    (~()9lfl 1~r~lJtW,~,41fphysics .is to be 'believed'), S5k<JP'1 ~"1

    ~1i"S~~ J1~~c

    Th.~

    ~t<; '€~$i.q.

    .~{,~ '<R#~. C~i(rtt 9i?f"f L~~I <qJ~~-m '1,t~r'\f3Gi G1\S~


    ~
    --.~.

    ~Rl~ '·>-:\!;lJ-12r~t'9·'>qf

    '~!f3411&'"(?f1 ~~.

    <m?i}x, l

    \5T1~

    Me(.~_~

    ~t'®t)-r~:~X1l~'T~11J f~~ 'ZlJl1l'~~j c:qs~~i.~ ~

    QUJ

    '1..;.>;;d,~'t'1~

    ~'"::"rl:<~'

    ~r' . \;~~jl~'('$"fl:.

    'iJt,.

    "~('~F'flDt''11~~\;1~!z~9" '~t~ C~MJ)~

    <ffi",T.<im

    f~

    ~~

    ~~

    ~'~nfiJ~~
    <~G'l~

    0"<:: l '~H '~~mt~~f~~l;~{~)lr~


    t~:~·d6f! 1F,;iT{.$~
    ,~.~Ij~ '...........: '.Ii' ~

    ~H;~~.•

    o~~i~ 'Gfi"9~";ij:?l~
    '1[,",

    ~R&
    ~
    \.._

    ~I

    '~"I ";i~

    <ri-':~

    ?1\5~-~~ I ~T~'I? ~~

    .;Q90'i~
    <1(',0']

    ·m(_>iG": ~ ~-....::
    I

    Yr1~,
    ''!J~

    • ~ .)......

    <)G'"ll ::;-),~:.0 ..j'!..l!I""";;""

    f.;;ffi':( f'i''i .. ....


    .!to"

    f.:{ ler'~
    , ' .. ,...

    >:;7~
    ~ ......

    ,.

    t71ii79!~' 1
    _.JI. ~

    '. I
    '

    f.'?1il!<I~ f"'l/

    ('<it'? !l!<il
    <Q~
    ' •

    ~i4r
    ... "
    ~ ..1

    -'i'" ''<I'm. ~-'Jj~'<il~

    <5l1lit'lM'[
    ~ ",
    .

    .;~

    '~.

    ()i

    <.t~.

    I",

    R).L,:-.;..;.. ---r
    ~

    ,~.. ' ....


    . . I

    <\~·~lr\r~t~,~~Jl

    6t4., .

    rx

    'Yj~C~i<~3~,::i.~!

    ,.-. c,

    S;;:.

    ~JD~?}Sil~

    ~-"'-

    ~~-

    ,........

    '1<R
    C~C"f

    ('1"'! ~

    )il'~J-'lq~'",~

    '5111,111

    (.151'';
    •••

    ,~

    (.~r~·(QJi;;P:HG1 (

    (a~ffj~ ~

    ~m ;;n
    ,~ .

    Cor'1 I<t>'-lj

    ~
    I

    0b1

    r~"",~~

    i r{:1,.v-,.
    I!

    F!>

    ~I
    !

    fOr

    epy-{f1V.:),: ~~

    ~~

    "

    ~?:' <JN~1IT$!

    "fP'1'f.'r<{'~~
    ?i~

    ~"i~~~

    <l>'<Ji<E"<t1'8 -!!~

    '3'(01

    011 ~

    '?~

    "lf~-~
    '5l~:5fe.:<.mtl~

    (<NK~/<{05i'

    "«)1\!))

    ~
    '~,f;:;<j>ll;

    7,'3f-'<1(.'>1'5: <l>~
    ~'-$l

    "'ll~?

    <.Q"1m

    ~"

    f-ic\!) ~

    ~'1'1
    :5f'3j-'iJ'1'

    t~\!}(;~1

    ~1f1fu>it<N."l1 ~
    <Q~

    "',,"I [ 'Vidi1

    \5[jfu
    1~

    1!3M} '\5fIG<Il't'il'

    R<lC~1

    \5ff<l

    :.«8m! ~ ~,
    \5l~ ~

    <(}7',<1,

    0J\k~ "Ti1_U'i1 ~"!<'~'1"1"'ii (\5f!["1 ~

    \5liG'n'fi' J'['c'i'llVM
    lQ~\ <Ti~ ~9[~

    ~-~ c~c~ ''1\!lJ'

    fu~

    I ~"R";'t"fZ'l ~,
    \5[jG'j)1tl \5ll~

    1b0'Q. <fic"'18I:<4'l,
    I

    '>if~-l5'&l

    14-F_p:i"
    <:>l£?

    vflf f~
    1)...

    \b1ff~~ <r:c~c~I), fi8rI4~trn (~~ ~-~~ ~~) ~) 'J! ~rP'J ~ <m1 I ~ <f.'Ifz '(j'ffi ') ~ + ') = ') 8! 21111"1' <j>'>1<j
    '.Q~

    <lJ19n~YJI~

    y,0J-C"l~'1"G1 <ll19J'BW!'B <tf.;!R ~"'!Bi

    c;fi",'2i'''11fu0~1C''l

    «~R<1'r~<i> m~

    )jl<f\Sl~)I"!

    <ID1 rq,"'f"" "ii'B1TI ~


    '<n%1W1' ;n"1:J0

    ;::rj I
    '1'~

    <~ 'T:<?
    <r! ~
    «>, ','

    '1'5l-<m

    A"n'G1
    f(

    \Ql(}ii_l

    C'r;"'<f1r.<T M<.J'(.l; (<.Ie\!) zr.<l'

    ~+~ "'1m
    =rn '6"11'>'!

    1(.131 '5ffiqlG(~:;:;
    ';)8

    mR 'Ji1'!
    ~'"?i

    ~(<i~tFli
    ~ l,'<I'6,~

    ~
    ~ "'"

    <fl"Z ~,

    \5ii'n~
    IilVo! c€1~ <Jtq; 1

    ~"'l1
    ~_ <.'b\.:{11

    \'i.fIC'!i_I <E0

    JUBf f.k~ :5ff\5-1i75 \!:)j<ic:~


    i55"'l1ff-05 0~
    I

    n'Vl

    I7T"'R ~

    ~f;tC"1C"ll
    C$,-<,~'

    <l>'<li!
    \5';~

    0f<I~

    ;'i7J-'eJ ~

    <rr~

    '1:c~
    $(;"1'1

    19j~18l1-I7PBl'l.3~

    ')~ ~1

    Q'l

    . =" (.<$j.,."

    ~~

    <:ff~ffi1<l ~

    '>i'1'ii "'l'<11(\b f.m; JW5-/iC\5(.i'1f \5ll9ff.'1 ~ 9J~~


    ~ ~

    YJil1
    ')'!J ';> ~

    ;::rj ! ~i«J

    c:;;; lSii"!::\!) 9J'M01 c€1Z ~-'5!TI"'11bC~C::;:;1


    I~ ':>'<-<1: 9['11 ;;, 8 '1'<11 ~1l

    <fJ~
    ~~

    9ft\5!
    ~
    ~? ~
    ~

    :5fZ'<ffi'tt \Q9ffi1

    '1J%1j;rc'<fi [%lC~5j ~,'1j'<fR.',


    ~~ \5!1~ t'1V1"'l?' '9j~-:5f'f(>~'f.'-

    <1"1~~ ~ \5.l~Jj11~

    ~;Q<J: <E~

    + ';>

    = ':>8 i

    'lli91
    f~(,<;'()-mtl'6 '&1l:Ml (IIT;~~I

    C'>fl'tt 9j~

    '5li~m
    ~'11

    f5"'1'(?Rl C5i'Gf!2, ~

    ('7f\5JA,J(31<1) '6 ~ ~! 8 ~'i1

    ':jiq ~
    .<?1 ~

    ;n.:r I c!j<r>

    'Dn-

    <!lm

    ~0>i,

    ~C"'.,;,

    ~?
    '-'l~.

    c%1 ~,

    *
    :>

    \'i.fJ~~

    \'lIl ..l(,~
    "1Dl

    18R1 ~

    ~,'-!:l1!irp1
    ~.~

    4>' c~'0
    i <E<{>~
    .('i;?t.JJ \5il~

    \5Rr "11c1s

    'BW 1 \'')l$i '1"',I"4'4-ThZ- ~:r<Rf1 <l"11


    mcJl~:?i<:J
    .S '6~

    ~--n-M ~ ~

    '6~ It1<:1 ~
    '"t.8

    1'1 \5ft'<5<f\sv:i3: '6'5Bl <wi 01311.\2."1 <jf~15 \5fi'lJ, ~


    <Q~ ~(,~

    ;n,
    ~R'-'IJfGI
    ~,

    'BZ
    '-Q~

    ~mfu ~
    >fGj-'<@

    -!!<l> 1il4'1'4S1

    \£"'ii

    m
    0t1

    ..El f

    Rf"!)'~~
    \S'3'$l

    RtG
    \5ll1! <fl~

    '1~~

    C4''''1C~" I '&l"li<'{ 'C'f1"<j YJ'lC.Ili<j>'Ui<j>~


    <E<1Z ~
    '1~.

    <wi I c!j~ ,,8 <fl'i1 \5.ljvr(,'\5 ~

    '11 .l1/~ ~

    'I)"i~?8l f~>i.l'!) (.<''"1111

    ~ j !L
    ~
    ~

    ~ "% .'4«1 r» ~'V!q4\!)j'1.3 ~


    c!.1~ ~

    zr.~,

    J:1"R~ 'Sj!<li ~ <Tj

    ~tn?fl~
    1

    011~ \5f!~1 "l'1~

    2)

    0tiI ~mmSi
    1§!Q,'qj

    1 \5i~ 11;1'(01 -!!~ ') "1'"


    >m1"1<iHl

    '$'i11 ~~

    RQoC.0G C"fG'iFi'
    ~

    ~ ~ 'S ~

    ':>l (~,

    \5I<1Jl11 t1:) ~

    0fBf
    ~

    (~'iG11
    ~
    4"""1,

    m"1~ :g<11 c~
    ~~
    I
    (.'5j

    0'fI1

    '''''<11, ~ ZQ

    'El-t;n"'1-L;nfC1t"''''l
    cQ~

    "l?!0i ,>\\!?<J:: 'i1C-i ?;'R,

    'Z \ W"'-~
    ~
    c€1<:.jj~
    ~-'<f@ <Q~

    ;::k~ ~'3
    'ilC.9~ 4!Pf~"Ml

    <r>'<Jl ,*1(%~~! ''Q'J1:n~ ~

    q~~<n;
    1<FBiGiC9 ~

    '{i"Si,-n 9~ ~:l:l10

    ~/

    f.TI'<o\5 WJ-~
    a%1 ~c<M

    ~"'I<rrq'r

    ;on I ~H

    'OO'-<Q~~

    ifl'lC<.j<{\ ~-'6'II:!-'5'i)"1';;::i

    m qiQJi
    «"1~

    <!J~I
    104(,"1~,

    \5j~:'t

    Uf''''Fl ~~,
    ~"1~

    ~
    ~

    ~'i)m-M"Bl4>

    ~m
    l5\Fj

    Flm

    m~ ~
    <1C"1l§" ~"'i:N1

    ~m ~
    ~'1'?i ~

    c?i
    :'l'tN; ~,

    m I FrR
    ~q

    0Q,'rn

    .~

    <1it~ ~

    iibf-i

    \5i "<Pff

    &~ ~

    ~
    $)11

    I V'H<il,
    .gK~1

    \5IjI5~ \5.TJ~

    fQ(1)W1iB@

    4U1fu-.jj~J<t

    I '3l~

    G'fft"i on i <!J\.'31Jl~ _<n~V«i eW."il ~~


    01 ~ \5[]"<1H',

    "Ii, ~)

    ~
    ~:('1 i

    <!l<f.b!C<1'<.f ~~ ~i9JI~~
    ('1

    <nnn~ ~/~'<J11-'<Rf ~. '5I'l>nm '5\~ <n ift'1fut1tC~l; "!p,R!foi1l; r~('Sit<1 ~ ~,


    111~ Qi1"l'(."l '11!
    ~-<l@ <.Q~

    B1, ~

    ~
    , ~-

    0R.

    <J!~I

    '-lr.~<1 ~

    "'i(rii'6!C11 '&1~ 01

    ~"'f
    '1('6",

    ';<1\;

    f~f.'r<i ~1::J' 4>"lim ~


    "i"iJ "1''"m B-1 "i! ~
    I

    ¢1<>;t"i, ~j\!l'$.-f~j(.'i~

    \5MJf>k<Ji,
    _./

    \5ll"'1'Ti5
    \5!11.~" c<1

    '5li~

    ~'R; \'i.fJ~
    1'<11
    m"./'j~ lQ~
    ~::-.-.

    4ffi
    .~

    ~1::J

    ~,

    ~'I

    C4"i?

    '\511~
    ./

    'ij~<j'<11\5i );L~05
    <J>'<)i

    G'R ~/m"D
    '<W(.«

    ~
    -

    \5.TJ~ lJ1i'j\b-8~"i
    '1.3~

    ~<li

    CQJ1?! ~lni9i<!J'F,
    \5n7,2\~

    "1<1?

    <QZ ~~
    01l"'ii 0tiI
    ~

    1.qi@1'VE< ff.«fG ~-~


    <E<!,Q,'l'Vr
    '(1~

    c-11,,1'1

    )ni.'~:9f1
    "fJR~-'.!J"?r

    ~.._ 41

    0l' ~IG

    I ~,

    c!.1~ ~

    c<J

    :z.~.~
    "1~

    ><-:i'-'f8 \5[]7Jl~

    <'t1 (0W·Z('?l~ ~ 05'C'1

    '51(.<""9~ ~ fuI%1'6G'lRit""~-'<N

    01171[<1,
    <r)~

    f~

    "1~

    '61";'C$i

    ~c.~'!'

    01~

    "IS:;':'-!:l«I14C~ C4"i ~~
    (/frP'1''6~

    F;>R;,01'"'1
    Qil<i>i

    'Clll'TI:3i-:";c,j\3ISi

    <;;'<11 YJ~? 010';~0'1.

    :;:,lC~1

    "0","" 1.'Of, ~'"".


    (''''(.''1<;1 ~-'iJ("1<1

    C<>1t\'?IS_,,")_i.l, '51<11 "l1tYJ"Cl7 C"1Jk1t.16G1 0>1V!1 ~"'O:jz


    ~~

    "'"
    '~<{'

    'Fl."

    15l'0'<f~

    't,~1

    f*

    ~"'''J~ ~
    <ii. ztr1(.f.f

    <TfDl' <ii9

    '>i0'14j?

    '1f ~

    \:J..'wlFrr ~

    ~:st"'1"1;;s,~

    ;:Z.11:.

    ~,
    \!)j>j'&'!'l!\5t, <l>Ff&1.'l-:l ~ ~.r[t~C<f ~"1"<11~ \!)ji~L<l' <>'1C~I~, :£:!Q;""l (;':jij'i'i!<i
    \5\"V((.<;~ ~;-:t,~i'6,

    \5f@l 81 iSfG'j-"0IG1T1<.!c<rCi$@b~~,
    ~(. ... s ~'fo'j
    ~;

    81 'flffi

    151<r1'."'?I"L;C<1"11 ( C!ifC<i' s~
    (/j

    '5f@l« ~""i<
    ~1<":"<'iI;:;;'~<J'
    <..S'>~<1~

    '~'-~ ~<'.1"(Xj

    \5.f.i'<il?i"<;,

    0~(':L"l, <j'j9{ ~

    ~1".'3

    01 Bt"~

    f<.~ 0fu,
    0@TIJ

    '5fm

    {,1Ei31H9

    '~'

    ;:;'1~
    \5fB1'6. ~<1I~ "UI\!J('<1C<J') ~-

    <rtlft ~~~ I 2j~ ~ I ~-

    '(.\5g '&I~

    g>tif-l
    ~

    lO11"tf4"5l! ~"lG(<l'
    <Q~ '5";fj

    m1i ~~
    <n~
    I

    ~~

    ~w

    ~~,

    CG1~I""i<])a'j
    I "5M :5i'Sffi

    ~E..

    <rj,,0'i! \Si1"-;:filfj

    ;UI~R~

    41T.f1Z~
    <!14>-----t1

    <m?n~iiJfl".'4 <.Q~

    "i?i_ (-@"I!~)

    <i'@ Wr<ft\5

    ~-----<il1:R

    '1':F1"fV'i \5~1

    CBIT9fl-i! ~,

    ~~<;fl!i~ 0~"'1;<q

    (>i1C-<.V:Bl '$fC"li'fil 0161JT<.f 9lS~


    \5-QjJ

    ~a ~
    ~ ~

    4tL

    bl<>i Q)JTII

    \5i1~
    <.Q~

    R; ~
    . f"",._

    <fi~i7f1 '5l<n"TI ftt4'3<i'I.~j


    _

    -f«vo-w<i<ff-1l<:i >li !B!J"'i'1 1


    C9;'1""?r;
    \5ij~

    2j'j~

    C~.f7:<:> L4(~ I

    I~

    ?j;:z"V(~IRr-¢ ~(.\!?(,C4 \!)q)

    "Zr$J ~

    <m":>'t, ~
    (O".gcQ

    '<~

    s(

    ~'l'i;--1J'6H ,-.

    05i9ft~ C<f'"1r-Ti ~q
    C;;jti~'..._j.PC:,,? tJT'i'i,
    /i"1rjj! <1m

    0Z I

    ~Cj"1

    -<'1~'6~

    "Pi'? ~

    <!i(.$<lrt~

    "J'fti.:ZI« t'<i'i~---<!!'?i
    {15J1t9{ ~

    ,..__.I,

    <i'i\:W. <1fi¥.C'-i1 <p<'J:SbF?I.!!

    :zo.? <ElM
    c r-

    c<if'<f
    ~111:.;:Z
    -

    ,..__

    1'i~'i<t'I'1r{
    MCil

    2l!i,t('A ~

    RW,
    ~~
    <:!~

    \5"F':l9f<:l

    f?tViG"'1Dm ~
    "<i'lC8f<.r '>!f."i ~ ~IG <J1
    !.1($i

    '"1.Pill \5fl"B: i firC"i<1'6 '~I'fr0<J"

    ReJ~
    '3N3

    "Jj"3]-'<j@

    I }jD<1fi)<:f ~ '2ti'f~<l>'

    .2ffff~'<1'
    ~

    (:<1 ,~ _~

    \5BI '111-q'1 <!1"lZ ~ (<Q"-.!>"''''<i ~ ~~~

    ~
    \5l1m! ~

    \!)4'/J

    8! '<'Gl,

    6 ~'itm"f'ij<;> M®iH;1 <!!~ c<l


    ..c._, ~~,

    ~1ISf7.<1G"ll1T \5l!ift.-jt\91' ~ "'


    ~',
    -~~

    <gi HGi"lkll

    ?j'4;f0

    <i>!iI! <l>CSl8i.f.9l"><i~

    \5frP'J ~1:l
    0IGm

    '\5llij(.<if04
    "-"""'_ ...

    CI51 ~"1
    ~-'<M
    ~

    ~
    ~"1{
    ~ __

    'f"!~) ~

    -~

    C'1'"ig~jifi.11 ~i~-qi'.'6<j

    '5[o4iRi'<i'

    1~1.>j(:',1 ~ "'I'~ 2i1'!-.!>....._J


    \Q7f~~j~'6

    .:;:,_t<~(.'iti ~ "f~,
    %,?"'~P"cC.Gt·,.,Q-<.

    5191"'l~i~fb('Z'?1
    ~. {

    (F1_<1C'"l'i«I gISi'm
    s

    I \5li"<11~ "l'llli':'i<:l ~_

    1'0-11

    f.ID:r

    <i'l'6f "1'.,;01., '3'<R ~ <!1~ '1011 f.9l'f\0


    0'6-<1''U(ft1"i"l'b C.! GYi(;:zI

    2t1'f-l~<P

    -<Q i!ITi~

    ..!J~

    'i<f~'4,
    ~

    I"

    <n1;G1~ '"1Ui\: ~~ <!1~<f-!iI! ~ <!1~


    ¢~

    \5<fIft"i
    ~
    <Q~

    l:lf<k$lM-<'G<j<-l I C9f1~-C;:~ -~ "fV'j<r~

    <!1<P

    1:iR1"11

    ~.~ ~!D G11 .,<_~-<.

    "/

    '@!<'r~!fu~
    '!l<h1' ~~
    ~ J -

    ~mi~

    -- "" CWBm ' ~/~ I .1.........-,,__~. ~ ...,\~"'l! ~ 1"1'61$1"'ll:<! l"lUj D{i1F0


    '! C<F(

    &;?il'G m

    ~lGm

    '<.,"'-1

    c<1 ~

    "fj'{ <l'&-~-(JR/"(~
    ~<i

    IbM:'r21'fG'i Ph. D. <f>1I~ ~


    'f"l~
    ~

    ~ ~<i1'i, r-:

    '3i1,,!j'1i

    "'------;1

    "("C~~ ~

    _ "~_ 1fl'i:J : '5l<ri-'5iT'Wf. e ojr<\,>


    0?? ~m

    <lilSrt«!\s<i'

    ~:4J<J'@

    tl...fus

    '311"<1"'fi'8f(,<iI'6<!'
    ~j'1

    ~~

    K:SifG

    :u··~
    @T1C<l'<l!z ~

    ~-

    ~\"iM
    I~

    --,

    Ph. D. ~

    \5f!r;'l{

    C9i~

    r-i('6 ~'?i

    ~~I~

    ~l'0

    '-'l>'M .,.~~?<.
    1'~b<j

    ,.... ~(:-.!>i <i']11""1 "'S.< '1»l


    ~
    (.~i'6i

    i \5/'<1'5

    '-'l

    \5l1U( Ph. 0

    ~>S1lBf

    i <!i'<l1"<14t'm_ "1F.i}~~A~K<i'i
    '5!~<;i

    Fr<l'~

    i '5!!i;'<ji

    ~~I>lj>C-,!> <Q'1i \5l<:!jj?i'0 \5li'1j'j1) ~"'1i

    <i'Bl (Gwes;, <;,:c~8J.Cf'i, 1?fJll15 C"i'.!.h':>""'tet,


    <f.2. Ph. D.

    (P1'-'''Ii"-.!><," IT~~! "liiff~ '5!~

    'i~lcn 'i1-m<pi "']


    <l'<i

    ?:h<i~rf#iI
    \5'<il~'<Ri
    <f)~!

    N>1{3 Qj6(.~l!?jf¢l-~"lTf<1~~
    C"li~~<fi ~ <l>'<.'1

    \5l~~

    ~sm ~~
    't''!<ffi_, ~~

    %! ifNI
    <i'@

    \5fl10

    $I?'

    '5i!i,$

    R>I-i ~"
    cQ~

    f~:ZVWZHJ

    ~~~1 (.~~C<ifGc&~~
    C1<fC<r-1, \.!)1Jl ~ (Fl'<fi-'fl~("11'?! 'ti)~(k~

    \5!~1J
    ~~

    fG1~J ~
    2j1ff'~ ~:
    i

    ~,-~
    '8~,

    ?:~

    c~
    ~
    ~
    I '-'l"-.!>'''P''!

    ~'<;1 ~ 511):'1 '5fl~


    -il~ ~

    ~ ~

    '11(~-<lCkr~~
    .!lqwr~

    m ~\li(.<.]

    ·-.!>-E;(~R i '5!1i1G'1 ~

    -!i~ V<~<4 \5l!~ \5l~~~

    C"i'[:-(€1flC~1

    ifCl51 <:l)i"'l'Bl ~

    -~'fJ:Z<l
    1'-G ~R

    QTf~ 7fj 1

    m, u?f£<>i
    ./

    ~~_ 'C<l'831M'Q>'

    -~

    I~

    ("1m _Wr<:iC'6~

    ?jffi

    ~
    r-;

    C"1~
    ..._,

    cf.V:I G'fZ~
    <j\@ ~

    '1i!i,1'fl' <Qi'.'0¢lo
    »<,

    .!l~
    ~

    '1r.~:\5ft~G'j ;q>]'GBl ~i
    <i'Q[f-<l>IG~ '1i'<J1

    'JiW'i)K "'1''<,;"1

    C"'lC",G.C"!'-;'1~ti!.d~

    ~f3<nf.t
    \5fl~

    R~ '<i\).,m "l~'@';€

    -:--1{)?Jcl"8) (9jl~<l

    '6e)i.jI'21m
    1::1

    ~f4'1>f~ 1
    ~

    t\9f'l

    '"l:!2J<t>Pl1CB1°ill),f-ql;;p;
    'Fl/@~Jj-<ml.,C.4
    1\1<-1(<.]

    ~
    ~

    <Q't'G,C<1j?l ~
    <i'«; \5l!1"1 Gl <rj
    "

    MCG<j<-l i \51~"'1~ C!ifC<i'

    '5!1-B1

    \5fRl~ <m',"\ <!10<iG1]


    -:rpj"

    I cm'i-~

    -,-.._..,.,.......

    r-«; 9'~L-\5TI15S1

    m'i'ill)'j<:(-~, .,-...

    .f;r-i
    ('

    ~w

    \Q~,~.~,<rl 1'<l'6!$! "'!~


    jJl~"'l?fL;
    ~)1(,,~

    ttr.::I

    4<::;('1! ~,

    F,\51'Ol
    4(:'l.!tf\';

    "'il."<f

    '¢ISm ~
    ~

    V)">l<-l Co/llC'w,;$i

    ~1-~'j'j"i"J"Vi~"-~~Vl
    \5f1~ 4~<l
    ~.q
    ~{3

    ZJ~"S
    MLA

    <l>qj >icQ~.-j\!?it<i-.~

    c~,
    ~

    cmq'::'i"f~

    N-&f~
    V1jC<:J;J

    "'l7.<f ~~

    'Ti 1
    ~f[i3
    ~

    Stylesheet <1~1 r,B"l !i!iIT- ?"'i€

    <i<1..~
    ~
    ~.

    Z::;, ~6
    ~,
    -,....,....

    C6ii

    (,;:j~ I

    -'il{'~<i-cmk?i: 1T.;~~
    1~,q1!.'Q,:

    ''mJ' 'Ti-:!JFj
    \"!-~¢l!G'1Gn~"l z,
    ...... Co

    -il~~"i'o,!1i~

    9~'1

    q;~1m
    -

    c&tt

    l<1]il''8 I

    l)"'l'¢1"81

    \5D1:fi<; '1i9il(G'f ~
    -~-

    ~ ...I~·IIQj81

    ",~G~

    tf

    5jc~ ~-.. -""",,1 ,-..,-. \9!~ ~~·rl.: i\bi~

    \O""'~<;<iH1 '2jfG"-' f~:)'K< '1f~


    ~~

    \5"C'ii ~iY;<~-S ~ =rrrr=:

    ~,-.

    .c-

    !,,(_:,s-'C<l' ~

    -=--,-. ~,\(~<1E7\§"~,

    "¢@,

    G'fZ @~tK~
    '\5fil~ ~
    ,-R-

    ~"'f~
    r;

    '5fifi:l€ I

    i~_\.0

    ,0. ~ -

    ':31 ~~
    I

    3{ ~~,
    :ZV.-.!>'>i ~

    \5(fqi'~

    5ffr0-5?r<il\R

    ----

    ·'>fl-Z-'f.1G
    '( ~l~~
    ~-Bs-

    .2i~ ~.,G',

    m >'.11.01 +rc~<f>i---<!!~ <f;~


    "8JZ '11c!@1
    ?i'<1I'~'6~

    :n~"1 «>"3"1}J ~
    C'./f
    D";J;lUl

    «:plG1'8 \§)1~ ~

    ~I

    <.--

    C\5I ~~\5i'<i}-R~t~i'l C"'Ui:? ~~

    <QZ1t1 1:'11\ ;fw. ~!

    <fuh ~ <N.O""Jlf~'>i

    '5\T,?i!(,fk1J

    ~B\S

    .' K a1:];~'E 6~lc:~na! t2 ..... P {m:) JO ::l

    •.t?\

    ,~IP·~··

    l'
    114~~ (~
    .\:!)~

    ~~~

    '1t9t~ ~~
    310'~'79j7. !"'v. ~ ~.~. .;..;:

    h::~~~F~~ ~9fRf'~Wlri1t:~ M'C{"Jt~~l'~~~

    ~9)~
    ~\93~ ~~;

    ;n0 .~

    Ff\S.f'~ @-e;"9fl?:
    ~
    ...
    T

    ~b(;e1 ~C\!5~cr;;;
    ~.i")'::' ot;-'N\~:v

    ·~~-C~10l~ ft~

    ~w
    Ol. ."j< a.1.'"h:.t""\

    ~<ffG<TIC~1.?Ji1i ~_I
    ';TT I .~,~~.

    ih~

    ~m~

    ~{5ro' 9tt:-f' {;?i'~ (.<fGl,t :W, i


    t~~ ~ ~~
    1

    ~'i'1ft-p~<n'tq'l-;1 9fW~~ f~*'iitn


    ~~~~..:~ -\J.--;;,.("""

    ~'~~~~t7ji'

    t"i#IIQ~I'ojP ~·rv~ r ~~~""'"-.I

    "I-··-!"",{'j.

    ~·i.q ;Ir~ I ..

    ..c.....

    ,~~,,t.
    ,\io< /'

    r~;~J~t'~

    '{!j~

    ~I$l(\5 .. 19f(fi

    .-.

    \!ffi'1i~ "'6PjJ.~tl:J1T
    ~"

    9j\~'~iJ

    I ~~. ~~.

    Jt~I~~lQj

    '.~

    ~CI(3~ .!!~l?t ,asQ,j1" I ~~-~~fil'~1I

    ,~~
    ~

    ~~~¢9~

    -c-tl

    F~M ~
    ~~~ $

    ~~~%
    '~$l

    ,9jf0,~ 9l~31littrei!d'>i'~J'
    ~0~ ~~.~
    ~ •

    ~~I~~~'

    fA .~~H"

    9f'R3r.sf!'~-:1r ~M·"¢2 '6f105lo;'! U';tIQrc~'J '~*i?M Mbst(l1,4!: il{.4i~~~~' ~'5f9fB;T~ ~

    \5jfb~~
    (~,~fft~~
    'I ~ .
    •

    C:~tkl~
    -

    tfll.<;j~I;n'V\8> ~~i'}jc.~g CL1l(\:!)J


    . '. ~o:f..._'. .. •

    f
    ~-~'Q;<:
    :..

    :-.n'fsfi1}~:ittt:9'
    ~9.r\r,'ii"--'_l'~~
    ~ ~.I!yt ••

    '<!~03'1:,;f1~ l,~ __ ...

    "'l~:oTtii1 ~~ ""-.~~~...,..!,...,~
    r--.
    c· -

    ........::

    a;51: -~(i~ ;JCOi.~

    ,<p'Br_~ ,prir.1 .;n ~'t,C;"".,'ti~ W('0 '''~~L~9i(O~11\i§~----t5i,'{-\5fI~(;1? <wn! ~'}l~ \!}~~<¥ \5Fl ,~i?l' ~
    m 'G#4i
    ~
    I ,'_ -

    ~¢fl :z1l~ ~"<;~c~~


    ,r--._

    C'&1' ~~
    j.

    '~'-"If

    ,,;:l,..;

    (:::

    ..."_

    .;:;:::::--.,

    ~r~l'Jr~~
    i:Q).jc'f -)1<4

    ~$l1V~'1~~ ~-~<.~
    m(;itC~
    ~l?1t~ '<J<C7>i~l ~ :J4~.t1J:'1 ~'~
    gp"
    r'~

    tQ<ji ~(.~
    <l!~.

    ~(~<{LKJ' ·~Jt<?f. ~-rn $l


    4l,<?t51?

    lK<rJ ~(.;(~ '~~~


    ~~<j;'

    ;n

    -~~mJ m 1_ <$l:C\;!l c~ Dl~~'


    i~ ''1_~~~

    aN1E
    A

    WI

    ~G.1~';{HH31 9lt!'Ifj~m ~~ ?Z8f;--,-~p <t4C~ ~', ~~{~fi ,~~~$i'"1Q


    .,_,{ ''i-!:-'''-''_;;'''-'''''-';~
    1

    r &_.

    k:~H,~18i~~ d:l:~
    ~~;

    ~t5.i~1'H"0
    L.b'WJ'
    ~:r<."l';?," . l\.ii,~"'"

    ~~AJT'Z t>'4f~~

    'i{Jf~

    Yj'6t'4citl

    :n~~
    '" --....
    I

    I~CNC~~ l
    <i~ ..

    0f'"~ ~~"~\5'~11~1~'~ i <Wi~ <Qqif~{~' 8J ~Qj1 bltq~


    'Oi.fA1:4' rl"!t>tl m9~·""4..-l4 ... ""'.? ~. .... IV ~-':U,;'1. ...... -""
    --...;! _.,

    ~~j17

    43:~-I~' "ia;:R..-;,· I
    ~ ]~

    i.;~"';'".!'~'

    ~((1fi

    :F.)-:.;~r~ ;!~. I;r~'

    f,ft ~

    ~\5l~ \5!<tml
    b~f¥-::1
    \!l.a.
    ('"'0 .

    "tlC~~ ~~

    : Ne'3R:r1':1 ~

    G~

    ~'5f$-11.~~
    .] ~'j~ ~

    f~q
    ~

    \~rcmu:r.l-<rRffi1.~1·~1
    ~
    1~ ~,

    ~@:Fj(~m c!1<f.G1,,~
    1

    c!1<lm
    ~

    ~ ~

    "l'?lf8:!

    9fWlm

    fl'i''Pl'ilhi

    m ~/' 'l'QjJ
    ~ ~
    ~

    g9J'D19f

    C'ffi~"'I
    ~

    '6fi~
    ~
    1

    <l]'&{O'{"!\

    '51@"'I

    "11~i7ji.t;"5l c<fI<f'irn 1 \51~

    C~18<f C'tJ\!li.<1 +."<.8 I ~'>l~

    \5['j"'J)« .~~
    CFIT.:?f
    ~

    ~nr -8

    0~

    ~'fj

    1 ~~

    ~m1!

    $~~ ~, .<ij\!)
    ff"..;>}I? ~~

    @\1'"1<Ji~
    C~ c<n"<f ~

    '"'1(.5'( ~

    ~I~!Q ~~
    (~j

    f~rqt~~
    "R;\5l'~'

    @l;Q.,ii>E:'5'13 ~
    ~9[~

    ~\5'f\?i
    <f!~

    'publish

    .or per.jsh'-<f1~
    <V,01

    ID

    DFi-~m ~
    C<li<fc:j:8j, ~

    'BJ\5

    ~t"1

    ~ \5I'iMC'l'

    9t~C\!l

    m...
    ?j1~C"{G ~
    ~ ~

    'm!9j4W't"1 I'

    '1'ffi:~
    ~!

    <1""1~"

    (;l)@

    fim!-f~1:rrF.1<:j ~
    ~? ~

    ~ ~
    <fil~ 9@

    "1 ~

    '''1~ f-';(?1'ii<l-'5!~\!l'13 ~

    ~8f"t

    ?jMi.<i~i'Wt

    <lC"]V"-<-t <:!l8 <i~

    'IOl1<l)G1H\!l 1>1%:"l '<itii."ZI ~I'i~ -<-<114 '5!1~

    ('fX1~' <l'0!)<:!l~

    8f

    9ff~

    'fP1

    '1<1>;[>

    (.t;"l'Ri.ql~ 1>1ffi1'M

    Nrn ~
    05f ~

    <>IMU1'''1f<iI1}H ~
    I::f\!l~
    <l'@ ~

    ~'ij ~

    '5!TIl, ro

    "iV'1 <il1>1<m:l i

    ~'91~1

    m-G
    Uiit"?

    I5ilWij,

    ~'G

    ;@i'1<1i'Pll<ilHl 2i!\bH{J\!l1

    <Wf.:T-~l<it'1~
    'Cj1i1I'ijM9l1GiG-~

    "5I~a

    C\51 91~-~ i1U'1'13 Wi~


    9<i~j>iC<1r:'ij

    ~
    ~? r,j\!lIM\!l'ij
    r-.

    'l'Q[{

    (:>jJ.14i<i

    '~v

    _Qc. r"

    'iy-

    r:

    G'fll'iP

    r'

    <!J~

    '11'<1<;1<:1 ~

    C;;~

    \5lI"r.i ~
    cfliij

    f.¥:'

    \5P1" ~ 051, ~ ~-<i>fG1 051 ~~ r.9J~!

    m, '¢ij0)

    "'I'V!? i '5!1~ ~~

    ·;q;nH
    r-:

    <Q~

    >! .. t.<.i~

    m'<lw
    9';11

    '5!1'1:!Br ~

    \5ffi1 ~

    CF.11'<''8i''l(lf~/~"C.191<:j
    Cfl1<1Nl
    '("j~'

    "l""?z J1FlJ~
    4-". "'"

    ~J1(.~f~ ~
    ~.,G

    M <.ft~
    '1'.<''& 1, 1

    <f.<1I-<i''4ivi '5!l"<f
    <f!i)j 19
    ~. ~,

    <1'~'1Oj,

    C<1'<i~l ..._ ~,

    'Cjl'lt~ ~i'1'i\0)J~ ~!'i'<10'l'8:ql jj';>jl<l ,


    1<J<1' o~ ~
    \'j()()~

    C0Rtt
    ~

    (ql)"<TG1
    2'j1~
    r-.,

    t?J

    Jt'<:?I\!l

    ?fll'>l

    '111 "1~ G1 ~

    '"

    ..Q~

    -<f'1"l 'ijl~

    <ul?j)"<f?

    .£<i' ~

    (<il~, ~)

    ~q

    'lR"11'tlN

    '<!@1'<Ti )J60mesticated)

    I K~lt·(1i!" E~~Ee~~a:. L ;~rl P·:.un~1 :2~.

    qs'1{.~~r

    ~(,-:1

    '5rl7jC~? ~~

    ~'5H~

    '~7~<lS'~ lJi:~ ;rt ~?

    n,

    'J1t~'f-F11'/? ~~~.
    CiJT"C<P,
    ~"Di

    ~1l''l1
    tJj~

    H can therefore be stated : under a wide range <of circumstances, bodies rhast fall in the actual atmosphere behave as if they are falling in a vacuum, ·in the language so. common in Economics this would be rapidly translated into : the

    ~'~l~~~: ~ (~$ittbR9t ~
    ~~.

    "~'R1f{\D~) '{'~i~~'~~
    ">j~-'4C?,f '~ ~

    C~Pi~ C'(j:~!'tblI~ ~~
    .~

    "'i,'{,t)1!bf CG1 '1~nG1 m?

    \.iT~/~~'f~
    i:!~-'1~ ~~

    \~~

    C>J.k

    ~tGTI:9t~
    RJ '~N1

    ~'<1' ~)

    f4l~ I '~

    ~. I~H.,.,~

    <rm ~? \!)1~,ii4 ~4r1 dl~'DsiM~\5lfitJ·~ ·FP·r ~<:1. ~~ ~ ~~:tf~lF3~ ~.~ QjUi \S~~ rw~l:. ~J1'SiJti,t <:j~ Z0R ~.~ Q!1(.4i 'b.~~·
    qj''l<p.'\!J

    Plt~Gf
    ~~\~C$

    ?C./
    ~mVJ~

    formula assumes a vaGlll·nn. Yet it dearly does no such thing .." the formula is accepted because it works, not because we live in appro:.fimate vacum-whatever that means. (1953: t'S) ,
    atmosphere'
    \t)~\5fl~~
    il ~

    ~ctua]

    '5fl~ 'vacuum'
    .~~ ~

    t511:~~' ~

    ·~'~\{f

    eli1f\b~ M&3r.;T
    1J~1q)tQ~\5f<l'~'8
    ..... M ,

    ~T~~,

    ."......., __ '-,' ,.

    ~~-~(]1
    .~~

    C~

    ;;P$l~@·S:R~11
    ~<p~
    ~

    'as jf"
    A.

    ~<J\' CS"r.'l ~K9f ~1(&1(I


    ~

    >jt'1\QJ~'$L~

    : ~'~~ ~.4M-i{lt \5f1'~ ~T~n\!}C'G'4

    '5HtUe tP'W'qKl

    (.~'!

    '~C.\!}'S,~~~

    '~C~
    {jiN'g G~

    ~~.~

    ~'?f
    .... ,

    ~q
    ~(<l~

    ~m'
    ~~Gci1'~

    ~(.$it.~~'~ ~~

    ~.;r~

    ti1t~'"fil ~$
    i~'.

    <rJVf@1~~'ZPt;<p>i 1 ~-~.~
    \3l~(17j ~
    .

    '~-;~koq
    ,

    'i1

    \!)fi~ ~'fz,f¢~' ~{9!1t${i{~


    ~~q} ~~,
    (.311;$ ~
    ~?i(,\!)

    !?l~ "Z\:)mtr

    ~Mf~

    Siio111 1

    0'?1~. ~-~1

    ~{?fI

    C~ .. ~·

    .~?

    ~'G1

    9SL.q~

    -=n:,

    '8J ~~

    \5ll~

    X1~l~t;'.l Lfi'l{.~ 1'6(~


    ~~
    ~~

    ~~~

    ~~. ~"? '\!ifQf<f! '1fH.~

    ~~'

    dl~

    fu~!~?
    ~ ~

    <ID?11'1Ui ~5f!zi.§. q{~ ··~t'Pl$_t~«'j·~~,! Qr(~d;~ >ii4~<p19; ~Qffl l.B'~(-'~ ';JOjfbq£~Pl~k\!SSl 0i1C~ \:~FP1H >j<:Pt:!.S~·4J4,<J~ ~~~ti~~ I <.iQ1

    ~OlO~~1l"~

    \$'$Jp.S~fq

    ~
    ~'I

    .. ~

    \Wl~~ (~1.C\St'?1 .Q5N)

    .~~'<{$(>'45~t'i ~
    l' ~ 11 -~

    ~U.Ji~J1t'1'§l'

    '39{;'1.~

    z'Vf
    '{3.

    <i:j"~' ~~
    ~l
    ~I 1.,)''--'

    '9-~

    9l1~
    ,;-'11

    ~,

    ',~t>~7::1 I..:..IT! .....

    "'='~-.~.."ij

    ;qqm:?i~. ~~ il..~· '.P., " ',.' '\51";ij''1l,t,~~' ~~

    'izy'j~'87.'1~ '61(~.~~ -...... -. ~ ,Il.;~1 .,


    ~~~

    ~(~1f4'I"·("~ _---Il:;{
    ~. ~

    ~~l-Qt'l

    ~
    ~?ti(,& ~?

    "'f~GlS! ~~jiM"9J~~·'ii

    ~,<pp"1i9i~-9m'l5f~

    *C-:1'!1 ~~

    '181? ~.~
    ~j;1
    'd._

    -~

    ;n'~~~4f FJ;.9:11($i ~
    ~~?r

    ~mCq

    ~1i-9'n~3r~1

    C'<lc:~l
    ~:bt<;
    To

    ~t$1t ~iMl"5l

    ~ ~~b1.,
    fatL.

    ~)}'<!l

    ~f

    '>i~11ri(f~-M \5fi'~\!)i~~'

    ("~''!)'~''1~~9l'ft+'.~
    'q~"!))

    ~~~

    n. ~~iR~.
    ~ ~
    ~

    .~

    '~H>5~ ~~ }:nffi~ 'c;rnJl Xt5)~ :~.P4J ~. ~


    $ l!j~~k$1<' ~
    41t<l

    $~\$!~. ~~~ ~

    '9fTI~,. ~\S~T?r
    ~'OjtN

    :"_:>i'Grt~~l .:n~L'l1~f.i16P1:! ~ ~
    unt~~~lJ~msr-...:..fl~"i
    ;:n' t:<lS-;q.
    .<:iS~i~~~ C'91~f1~~(;'1~
    ~jFfl~~lG1
    ~

    '9j~)

    'RP\~

    cq51, (.}'!}i~~l ,.~~,

    :::
    .<p~

    'in
    '\5f1~
    j

    '~mri' ,-i C~"';·J;~.I

    ~1i
    ~~

    ~.

    ~r ~ ~
    ~.~

    ~Q,ffTI ,1''i'{i"''4;

    C4i ~L1G3U~~ (. '1~

    r
    C~
    ~

    '~ r.fl·m~~'(,9~1).!

    '\5J~15 (iSi4-\5)··~.ih~C~ ~ ~~

    <n~

    ~~

    ·:(f~~ read ~~ to

    'cr:

    \Si'<rt

    1$l'i ~(3l

    I (?~~il~ ~

    \5ffitC;~1;F.w'51l~ j'

    ~(t'~YI~j"'i

    <f.rn I
    "i~ \hfI(.~
    ~<l<r
    , .. < ._ r

    \5l-n 1TrUf 'C\!lib~~'fl

    '~~-9i'8~UC419i' .f~:~c~"as
    \91C-1'5l ~

    1f' ~
    .

    ·~m'

    ·~C~

    ~.~.
    '9j~"'l~~""1~i~~
    ,g~ -';''':'<llt..~

    ~~~'$

    1!I~'i;l'

    ~# ~ y~i
    (~~1~~t . t.~I'Cl:1
    (."it<;S'~
    '. "

    :S
    (ti)
    '9!\!;'t\!:l

    Y2 gtz ~ .;' .f'1:l/


    S

    ooWl~ ~. 7fl'€m GPk-il*,f~"u~ C$f1c"'{t:z ~, .~ t~~ ~f\bt(P1 c~t, ~Sf-J1~ll\b t"i~, ~-~\fjm/;U-~l'G~l t~~l f4'>Pi (~~ I M~~ !.!!~ ~J\6~, I~yetit clearly
    't~~'~~ ~<Pbli
    '~jl'4'Git(J(~ "lfC'(fJ ~I ~
    .

    does

    no such -thing' t
    >i\:!l$_;~

    ~,~~~..:,p

    'I4i9?3K"'i-:t~
    '~I

    -.qj'

    c.~

    C~
    1

    "'l~ "·::,r~·I),1 ~""" ~"'1II'""I ..... )1

    .~.G:.i\8~ "':'-ll ~ 1 ~~ ~l ..;-'; ~.~1 '''Z..~I91~t~'Sl

    ~'b·od·'·:"'mo..tF-> .. y 'Y~Jl)'1
    \5Thl
    C\!l
    ~~1(..q;"

    \£i~-1,xtol;fRJ'~

    ~q
    ~~

    ~<$l(,\!)~,

    Rouget

    ~cXj\5(?:p~

    ql<i5J?J ~(,'iiii)
    >j'igl~GI
    1(>

    "!ilJrffib11 (.$l4~
    "..:Si__

    g~
    9t'm

    §a~ '~~~bK9 ~. .~

    ~t. <P C>6l IOMffiR (~Co;p

    .~S! 't9f:~ C~1'~t~~ ~~H~1\!)~~1"§


    ~',

    (.~\S

    'l'51nI t i ~<n51 ·~h~j~


    ,-,

    X!): ~

    [<.pI):

    '9j~

    "~"FrR51;p=' r~iiSi81~ I ~~
    EGonophysics<:'jtGi
    ~e1<f~

    ~<jSfG11211l'ysic:s

    \511~ EconomiL.--t.fj~ ~\!?4-"1(W


    r-.. '=' &.:l(,$l I~t~< ~~

    ~.-.

    lf1~f9
    ~"J..~

    "J"j\!tJ

    t!!~ ""llt(H~ iG1~·!(C?l.c.~! $.El~~ ~':5iPJ !

    l:;-G~ ~~
    ~~'f1

    ~f~~J~i9T

    ~~1 ~C~ I (.~\!) ~~


    d~

    <q11S1R,~,?r

    ~{;~ t f{("l

    <U1 "'11dG1 :

    f~§,~ ~~<pf1l?

    F$ .~VfT~~

    ~~?

    '1-1~~T l!t~

    4~{~~~.?

    :full hoofJO: 1 ~

    R ~m~t ~~t(n.s:f,

    ·"Itl·

    em, ~
    ~~
    -e-,

    ~lii*MG~~~;;(
    ~~Vf'*"l

    'j:;j~1C",f~r~c~1~~
    G1

    q~~

    ~\5J1~'~ ''7jq~f5I ~t,<j'


    ~,f~*I;~
    "

    ~ ,~ .."p.',...
    ~

    R~7ii''1~~ Ti4ifi'df~ ~q
    AAt$l ,?,
    '-,.

    ;n C\f)l~~~C~(:f1\@'i~~
    :pJ;~ ~,~(~\.t}\R(/ll '

    ,W

    ~«1{],j14

    dl)l"l~ ~rr~t;'jll ~1 ~~~


    /.......

    f:.'~"-«t
    vn.....-;. _I

    ,r-,

    ~1J;

    rar-~*U1~ £P\V-G\5
    ~'~b
    ._

    ~ ~1b(\t) C~l; K

    ,-'.-.. ~m~ 1~~1~~


    ~
    r>-.

    \5flt'9], ~.>iQ" ')~0:O

    ~.

    ~.

    .,.., Heredia. r.£J"~l)i

    M€!1t1 ~$~li: ffi:;G1


    (At~:Sl; ,Q11~N~·tlll
    ·~u~
    ~.

    :' ~oii-sttc ;HeG1Jtru

    I ~.
    ~

    ':9'Z~~~- lit~ ~~
    ,~
    .r»

    ~~~.l1'
    ,,=--.

    ~}

    ~'~"';)1"'~'€m I
    ~:l1I~ C?H;;GjK~ D'l\~c.l.~
    .0~

    ~,q>Ui ~. :~~
    ~lQ~'

    '1t;Ji~ '~\!)l':~$f~'Z1'N1
    ~Il~
    ~~

    ~Bt ~tn~
    'rr-','_"

    ~~1i'f)-{;:1G1""'"'r.31~·· ! 'M--:-i"4
    '"

    ~~b'
    S\

    §l'Sli~1
    ~..

    ~l~()j'Sl
    ..' ~.

    \5l~@

    :C<! ~~}Si~~,·~

    91F' CGft(~, ~

    !)~¥i1J ~C(} '5l~:~fqtJr't!'l'11f

    ''':':'..,. ~~ " - ... ~, ._._... .


    ~<Hji \t1C·+4HY'j

    ~.

    €j~I\!Y f~'~ 1.

    \!l~~'

    .-- , ~{;~

    .~

    \f;i.oij
    \r--

    t.Q(}9.Oi1~
    . " .

    ~ti'1'~'R,:t$l}'f1
    d

    ''''-

    ~Tf"'-!!~
    .

    ~$t

    : DNA~-~i:rii~L~ Gf4'4llFl 'i'"'l*,~<Bl31*~)-r~~ l


    ~~ ,'-'. .~

    ."-"'''_''§

    '-,...,.,

    ~r~E.~-It¢Eiij

    Q-.

    ~fBflvTl-C~iil~i'Sr4i ~ GTC~

    ~~:.:

    ~vn
    ~

    u~~Jn7f
    Or--.

    cm~~·~Wf1 L ,r:!l~~
    ~r.:.r ~~(.~
    ~,.I'
    ~

    I AQl'C1 ~O1.~~/

    r<s~"l~ ~
    ~~

    ''__'

    ~~ i AGT~ M..A,
    tlt1:1 ~:i~'QJ.~
    ~

    ~tffi{itl

    ~\S

    ~
    _~'

    (~m~, <If;..j
    ~ ,~ ~

    &h1 ~~.

    ~~.
    _ ~_.__

    ~t~i
    _

    (~Gi.~·tG1:~~~'(Y)

    (:,~p{pr\~

    ~:

    >P:H~°t.t,'Wt:'E 1ilT~LI ~
    'C'":'Z.z;~c1C6~~,) ~

    ~.~. :1;~~f;$-"'1i,~'

    t~!~14k8Zl~4

    ~---~
    -"t:l'-:VT"Nfl;:"l"'R

    Bnl\m ~~

    ;Peat~P1(~~
    ,

    C*1~' >?vv~ ~icG1,: "~4i;:Wt~ 1'f\~bfrll 41' '~f"l~.~41


    ''4L~ WfiSf '~. ~

    '\t)r~;n~~~~
    ~14,~
    ,

    Yf6i~~ ~, DNA ~~.

    ~G~ I

    ,-.
    ~'

    ~/

    ~q ,)~b-~;;IR.Gtj:'$ll
    '5.F'?tfft1.~ Abiwrmat
    (~;9t '~,' ,~ 'quilt.€ rOJ'ltrary T<p~,,, ;Z~'~,'i11! ...~~~iP!J~i~(.!jQ: .~ t
    .~.~ ~~C>D ~~'¥~}(f--4
    ~ . ..__,

    '~q~t

    ~q~1t~

    ~~{,~ ~ C,arson

    .3llL:~
    ~N,

    p.~y'cWJvl(JfSY !~~, G}!;II '~


    ~1$f1P49~~' \51~t~

    nr \:3~f ~~tf.Rl1,

    17ff!~~'

    ~,'(~M -. of exeeu ..

    t:o_' fo~k1o{fe:~ordy ,11 small number

    ,~a-11<, ~~_, ~l

    ,''_,

    ~(\!l

    '~n~ I .~<?~?
    Mr--,.

    ~,~'_

    "l@l~c.

    'q;~}

    ~'

    ~~~~~~1~ ~(~?r

    ~?,~q

    ,~~ ~ "1t\l'¥\[) "M4f~l~ ~Fi;,~'>?~~t;'ffi' -'~"X-fs;1~h~x ~ ~-~*lR :fP~C~~? ~:{Fn t~R ''T-<;1G~ {9JEr' )1e.~'
    "j-~ ~!;.,,_.

    (Locus) ~~ '~' €fi!}F~t1S'1711 f$' db;'l~


    ~<J:\:Ql'Dl

    rives cl-ev.elop~ pepUc .uleersc In fuet' blue-collar wO'r.ker:s who are' d~SS@l:ti:s;fled wifhfhei:r Jo:bQ are more likely 'to.,' de¥clop ulcersthan successful business executives 'who .are rnoving. u'p en ,the o~i~tfp'ational Iad(f,er.'A~rld whiJe hE-ack people
    l'nour society ;$hQw~ ·tdgh;ef .incidence R of h3fp'e11~.~1lS'ion by different
    than 'white .people, this finding isconfounded

    ;nf$, ~~' tfktiii~ 4tN\ df~' ~l~~~ 'H~iG4~'


    tQ~ ~

    ~.I

    ~@f(,~~,

    .~

    (~~

    {~.iet,.iry -i'Jj~tbits', indlH.ting' the -exeessiveuse


    blackeieizens. ~(Carson
    '~
    i4:\ll ":

    of s-alt "by ';m~"y


    ~I ~~~"
    <Q~',

    ¥1:r;~,,~CX!l9fiS1li:,~'?~(~-<,'~~l~D:·).~1 \t).fij' <ff:q ::1:~;>W~?i'~I',I-:::r .-=-<. ~ .FM I_'~~~~ <:l%?$G6 9.~I' '~.::n <"1~ .• U~ 9;~-~
    L &,.
    !co.

    ~~I
    9:l~' U~~

    ~Z14
    ~;! ~'i"TJ I ....
    ..'.

    tQ'~6t~'\§~ ,~:,
    • ,-.
    J',

    et

    ':111989 : 273}

    ~.7'ffi~V!5

    ~~ :-"1f~'f~~"'1~ I

    ,&~'

    ~,9jqs;ti ~

    ~~~rf3rJ1 ~
    .~~~

    ~~

    ~~~

    ~<1(1{

    q(;~-(~!

    ~L~1

    ~,

    ~,~~~~

    ~9t~\5ff~'l\!)'"

    ~0.tl$t l1"9t,i?';1 ~~

    '\SH

    '\!i1tqnP~f.Q'j'~~1;;FqXj,~~~~ "ff ~ ~·($ifin' l. ~~.

    i4xn~
    '~0r
    ~q"'0~
    ~

    \D\!),,*C~ ~

    ~~~ 'G'ID~ ;~

    c~Pt~t'41)1-1

    cognit ive dorna in ~ fb\1B:~-t~lp(Jj:-:1 '9M'! ~·'t1'~'<f'G1~ ~~ ~jft'if


    ~

    ,~t~~
    .~~

    ~~R',*rr~~ 11Ji'~~
    lfJt.l.!l ~
    _-

    ~~5{.$ C~st:~
    r-..

    ~~ r~~C~~'¥4
    ......
    ...!. ~...--....

    q,'ZT:'t~ .000~~r~~j

    Ib;~:W*~

    ~,tt};!M'

    P4':;i~I:~(;~1t

    'physical organ'; ;n~ (IT'SSJl ~


    Device! ~'1TIV'l~ ~
    }-pgf

    ~~

    ~~~~,
    ~J~'G~V[

    ?~,~~~~

    'i0ffi\g

    ~"j~~~

    4'(':1 ~

    ,~r~~" ~ ~

    ~~:t~j; ~ O1m'

    LAD 41' Language

    Acquistion

    f~f.'\:3,·~
    31,@,~' ~'~

    ~~m

    WM-bn~

    'l.,:-..!l

    ~ \5f@! ~, (CO~ltex;rt~.~e)~. .
    \5l1"<Jfj':i4

    <il~

    LAD ;:~

    ph~sical '1"l1 ~?
    ~

    organ

    <n (,;::~~
    ~\~

    <rP.

    Q~

    ~ '¢@C'Tf"i
    0l19i
    JI1b,~"t<j

    \3Bl 9n'fu'11~
    0V1 'i\l>(;'f.'.'1 ~,

    :q;pf zjl;(.>j1: 0lt~


    '5i<1)IIt('<1'

    i <>j@ ~

    ~~'lfi?f
    ~

    \5l1'-::J'<I!l\!:' r<!"105 <fIll, ~ ~-·<.It<Ff1 .~

    J<f'

    <:[II; 2lR-'(,.q,,~~

    CI'R <!lWt (i)~'Gj~"1~L.(I


    \5Bi~

    os@! Z"(]J

    '3lQ ~fWf.-YiN;qj~

    2Bl~~ ;q>~'1-~m~ ~<!)1<i.~, ~ ~~~ 2!N,0"1 1i<~ (context-sensitive) \!)j1"<iJ1'1I

    ~'lj0DC'l"

    <rm ~
    <f1~

    <ri 'f)i"1"<1
    IS
    @1~

    I <Q<ri<l 'Y..:;'I<J t>K!2l 1STI-<.!l1i' ;q>Q)j<i'~ I 1!3?i ~'1i "'l!\4qrm'1'


    ~
    ~

    ~tJ
    \5f;R
    ~~
    '.B~

    "'tr<P11P'if. ~11
    ~

    !<l1M1C"l-i4
    ~
    'f~'1

    L'IJ~~

    (~~

    f ~.

    <!1~"1 I '5\<l01?l

    01~
    "f03 'm~

    .:rc~ ~
    ;q>'<J1-~m

    I 'TIN ~ ~

    ~m
    c<r<[~l J:l~

    ~
    ~ ~

    11'1~ ~ CBIT:"i
    ~Q) ~,

    1
    ,
    I

    :?;~~i~1
    <;j':'~Q
    ,.?

    ~
    9',Gt}{l ~

    9f(~'m <Q~

    <Q~
    ~

    m9f

    ~
    ,.,c.
    '4'I"'i
    ~
    ~

    CBfl:9j ~

    <i>"ffi1 ~
    ~NC?1

    ~~<n'8m
    <l>1lwi
    '<1@ ~

    «j$)V!1
    <Q1TfIT."';~

    ~
    <Q~

    "l~G'J1~
    '<lJi'">1 ~
    I~

    ~'--« FiC"1~
    ~

    (,9Jl:\? ~

    ,=j=,,~
    ~I~,

    df1J1\(3~
    'li.J'1L>i

    ~. l)::i~~

    Mn;~~
    9f1">1c.~f1, <!1.,sL>i <j~\:JI'<
    !?, ~

    (:'1'-'1011,
    ~,
    ~,_~

    r;;W

    CQ;~'"

    I~"~

    <i'i'l{'b

    ;\51$'lIt>:.t<{$l

    f1~ <i<1~<j

    <j~c.'1'!1

    C<ri:"1:!. ~I

    5jl\3'4Qi

    <i@

    <!17"i~

    ..£jT,'i:\T03,.n"<1<l -

    ~R-'ZiV1?i ''If.Ti'i
    <Q~

    "';~YF'1ll<i'

    ~('7l, ~,

    M>1f8

    (R)1»(;"l<q

    1JW

    C~

    JZVf'

    1T.!iJ.fBr

    -1V1~ <Q<W! <1f~>p.ufu '<1GG"1

    JlVf.i ®,sr ~ I

    d~:l?'P

    tWF.t!2. Labor··~
    f;~

    Rd~~
    '5tl"BR'1 ~ "WU~ \5!~

    ~~~~ij'il ~

    ",R30'C'1 I C<.l)j~i,<Q~
    c!l~ 'J'f'l

    l1l'0Dl$1C.U'<3lf11'?l 'l<fJ
    ~~"'T
    <Q ~
    r-.... /

    0'1<f '5l-~~T.<1

    (""GV1 ~~!
    ).),

    -<n'd~ "1{;i; +.1


    ~ ~fu>DruoiJ,€."1' C<M

    ~"'iJ<i>
    \51'G ~

    ,*I~RA Mf4~
    i
    ~

    =;

    'l""IR

    <g;,

    "J:ft..q~
    5j~

    C"'ltG
    ~!

    'M ~

    viZ

    rn I

    Laborit

    r-..

    1~ ~

    r-._'-'5il'(.''ii:<1I'''''~<1·''Ill1 /" ~
    <Q~

    f.1",;~<f& 9"1l(;~,
    ~q

    \5ff<l' q]t~

    .2l1'-'<l~1..!l'~1~

    ,-,(''tJ I i

    ~ ~~

    ~
    >£((}j';1
    ........

    '15fI';qFl \5ff"l1Br :5f!!J Z$l "I0fi \5Bf ~


    1
    __

    <n. I

    ?)tGI~

    ~1

    ~~

    ~'1~

    ()l%J~~
    '51(.'lJj>j ~

    '\5TBi H

    >n'OO' ~
    '61"'1"l'1
    '5i~

    ~'<jBl <mN
    ~

    r.k~C"l!<J!
    ~"lF!~!

    'mf<i1~<:l

    "'f?it~ ~

    r--.,-.....".-.....

    Oqf:;)

    <TI <rlFl

    '"lJVi ~i.G~

    v{

    \5(.'G"l, <m:<P ~

    'lfif.¥.f.'j \5f1~'l"If1 iX~


    f.!f;~

    ff. I f<r~~f.kGill Gl"l1V1 "'i,$l1i'I<:J \5fP.1 "i1f>0 ~, ~~<>\<p


    \5Tl1ftV11l '<.,~"<l

    QrfGq; ~

    C'IJ'b"C'1<H~ \51'1'9. 2!1~\&M?i

    '5iJl:@f

    G"1f0:? \51f<lT?i""l~
    '&j.riT.9' ~

    '8

    Til <!1

    R' ;:m;~ 2i1~<j\!J RRffi1!"i<l"0<:J CW~J~"i\ 'J:~ ~ ?)fi]X'ii"l felH>i'<3T.G'rt

    /r-..~,.......,.,.

    ~~/

    (,li1>mi.<i' f.'m~9 ~~

    '1'''lCIb Fro, Laborit V1<ilvl c>t~


    01~ ~-~~~<:;Jt<?
    ~

    f.Tm&"Rl
    1:i'tC<;l

    '1l";:fFl; \5f"'l :':<W'l ~~

    S1;,W~~1

    C~j(",.{ i

    'J'f1'1t
    ~

    ~t?lt<i' C~~~lN~

    ~
    <Q;q;ijl ~ ~

    \3l'rS'1 <l>'Gr ~~ ~!
    ",!(~j

    \51~

    (Jf'Bm

    <!1%1

    f~'-j

    % \5f8j'

    ~"1fl ~
    ~ ~

    f\b"fo<:z ;q{ ~";1""~ ~rcm~ I i1OOK!'1'i "1:<."?i H'f18 HC~' <'fD1 '-'1~ <Q<l"3r ~ ~"051
    I \5fl"1~
    I

    \51'1l5'?l{;"!,
    ~~I

    "'l.[;1 \5j~J'(ij C'R '">111.4(.<1' ~~P'{ "'ITI'''1\i5 ~

    <!.C-,<_

    ~'<?) e"im'S1:

    ~~

    ~ ~[-<ji'4!~(1~ "~"il ~ ~ I

    superimpcsaion-aa ~ I ~~!

    q>1~~0 (Ai~~105 15j]<>Ji2tC'i1 ("1% (."lC<l~ ~ ~\3D'fi


    ~~(>l~

    :;m:-"'f1 ~j1.f.'<Hl
    c!l.,s ~'Z~

    ~'Gr ~
    .

    ':ICG'lffi.!"Fl"1 ~ 1}ct; m

    @:<i "';~
    'O~ --~-.....
    91l'1."! ~

    «NMi
    ~

    0'fl~

    I CD 1)1 My Ameri-

    ~'81lif~

    0lfi~ri~ <r@ oil(jlfilJ


    ",\70)

    ,::9]1>'-'1}t"i) "'i"'lt -.:n-l(<j<;J

    can Uncle {;, ~.RiGII / 5',f;;'G8l "i~ <Ft? f.>j1l'¢~ j. I~Q[ -<.;
    C9~
    ~,

    \\
    . r.;..t,'l<1 I

    "i.~ ~

    W:Bi I

    %~

    ..£j('!il \S9-rnr<l
    ~,

    ~ 1~ H(.IS'W'lS ~"11 0f'1~


    <ij'l"l&,"i '5il"1Jj1("l~ <m'1T<;! ~~ (,'f""<!t\5 '6R'B!
    \5f~

    ~?"<.>j~-<.Q~

    ~'T1m i ~

    "J.'<! ':.tVl <m:ll \5l'fi~~


    8M'
    <Q~

    -2iN-01'9t 1\->l.:?.v"I~\51 ~ \5!'i<lrnT "'i~'1\"'l

    113t?i~ ~ 14"81

    Qli"-'i'M f:"~"1X5

    ~<i'(;i
    (J0ii'iT

    fubl'l.! '1G1I
    &m,_s I

    ~';;fi/~

    "1'&,

    rewind ~

    ~
    oil~
    <.Q~

    C\51 \5l1?i ..£j<1Y81nl fiMsH'!1 ~.u


    ~

    Evolutionary

    Psychology-a

    'bi<i,j'b;;:j ei<l'&l
    ~~,

    Henri Laborit

    (}f'<.~

    ep\(»CG'l'$i ~

    9jin.
    <.>j~

    C~

    ~?j"P': ~
    ('<if:+' c!1~'1<l 0M

    R-~(.i.11

    • oil'b",

    ]\bioi ~PG<i>

    <Q~

    f~{Wi,..,-(/fW 1f0C"1!

    "'10\3

    <:r1~

    srit<f~ ZtTI

    "1'1i\?~~I '5!1~\{3 iQl'W1"1X5

    '<rr~ I

    ~r~1

    19

    ~!'<)7j ~C"1 c!1!."'(.~,'"


    c!l<f.f<:rBr <;)11! ~

    l>lZJ[<l ~ ~'¢

    ~fjj4C"i'.'1 ~"'T

    "R.¥ \3[jQ~Q c51<l~"lt.~i~

    ">1'& 0f.Iqr,J "1'1'J_"l-<fjF'Ml

    ;;'%1
    ~?

    NU'w':ll

    '5ir-::iV::1i ~:""("N

    .q0

    !2.TI <rI$[ ~

    ..

    .t\;!
    ~ .I

    ..!l~ . dCS1

    Carson ~~~~
    .

    til

    ·tr;ll~ '.;(1~y.~~. ~.
    \5l1\;~\!li P)G"{(.ttf .~.
    ,<:(1,
    ,!

    Nrn$_i1:~~~
    9j~~f
    ,<l>~(,\!)

    '~
    ;n

    ~~'~f '~?!'I~Pi~

    ......

    ".....

    r-

    ~!
    '5]119

    .'

    01 ?l1-:1>i1l: ,(.~,~

    tC"'-

    '?
    l~(~ (\Sf" ~

    C\51
    ~:~~

    (f}~ C't

    \5iF;~~t"~ (~~ c.~'?l ~~.

    ~,,~

    ~,.
    9)"rn(<q.

    n;wH'-(3C~1~~cl9 ~t'l~
    '<t>Q!t :
    ..:r!.,

    ·.~m,q;mS1T~l? (?JQ~\9k~X9

    \.515fl .~~

    jL.

    ~t1y
    ~

    1J~~J~·~c~o~:G9~~~ I
    \5fi~IfC~r
    (.~<p;;::"7(,=?'j--~,

    ~o;. {..q~1~ 1-, .~~ Wi~lh)dom~ ~ ~BnM?~' t?1tH


    C?!i~1 ~ ;qs(;~?

    \51<5{~~fu?r ·)<J~i~
    ......,..._

    ~~-t-~ .t.:

    'P!rQj

    ~~Z{\5

    (sjtalker

    ~P17fl' .~(,'N~

    .~ 't..--o

    ~1J Q1i41~~ .

    \-9tID~ ~~W\sI,I;'~, \5fi'P1-S ~ ~? ~~ ~~~t Laborit ~~ti ~()rM @'5bj~~ ~

    ~i:f:I19f;qs(~'-S, ~.~

    ~'~XP"1\S ~ ~.

    \5T1fil

    QJf.C6 ~~?f ~1<I 'I{3~Wis(h)dom~Qjff ~ ~

    "'\Ve .are others'


    ~<!l'41"!Jl. 81 "j<:;'
    ~C911t5oi1 ~~

    ~~

    '34~j_c~?

    'iffloM ~'<i3r.oii
    <p<;q{.<trf;

    '5fI'lnG'1i'!iMlli> interiorized '

    4C!< ~~Dl

    \6~119f \5ff~r~

    ~H:}tM<f4 I Q8tf;l ~~

    Fb$AA~ ..

    \5j '~G1 ",ijl'ternaIizati,(Hl'·-*I.t~~ ~~

    ~~~ l)-\5fj~?H c;j~7f1f' <J~ 1 ~ 9j]fu, $i'G1-~l$m1J "11~Qjt~?l·~~\f ~ 'GiRg<l~ ~ . '''':r .~'?rt d~~ I<.!P~I~ ~~. . .i'l~,h~ ~ !~\tl"ll!) '~<f 1~;;?iE:~ ~ ~l$J ~I~f~~! ~E<r-'';·Il$l~t\.!)
    'V.

    '~rP1

    .~~ ~~~JiG3{. lived there. ~


    ~\!i<il<P '!R§ ~ ,..

    f1M«G')~, ~ _'. America


    0fV'j~ ~ :.,'~ .~.

    does nnt -exisr really. We

    ~~~8:r ~~
    ~""ir.~
    j,

    'O.~@'I' ·~i.rt$Rl1 fR:n~Uc~'~ ~~


    <P~, ~
    "

    <R~C~i4 ~rl)'"?i''1-A?!~(~'

    T<Pt~

    I' Gf[~~CP1~Fl'.

    ~~"

    ~;n~ \!)@

    \5l~tP.!)~

    '~G1i~'\":ICMtm't,<[$j' C1;j~-1 .\g\(:l~


    ~~I \!l.8·~
    WiG1~

    ''5:j~

    'l~

    ~!

    ·Nt.~·.9l111lM

    f m:'8'i1 fl1t\5 ''1h~~~ ~t

    csiM \50~' ~ .~~

    '~\5l)'" '9;f~ ,'"Yit~f:CI7j \s-~ .

    ?if~

    "Q,€-m "'ll1:r?~ ~C'Dl"

    'Yl'WnQ:5 1511T (.~

    .~~\~

    'Jj_~ "11\891' ;~9f.1

    Q1'~

    :54;q~

    ~'81J~~ \SO~ ~

    .... "All that is solid 'melts into air...~'

    FW ~
    <;ts~ij :

    ~l\5m ~.

    "~1G~n ?~(.~
    ~t(~q (~ti

    9\,¥~

    \5li\r..~~P·~l~C~?f '(.G1<!i '~4b;1·f4\!).1C~·1


    "

    1)1%1

    i-H ~\g!

    '5lI~t'6t~>GliRr1:

    '~~'?

    1.!1)3 R~"1q\S"

    <;n~?~0G1~P~:;1~~' ~'8?lm~il
    ~;1i(.~~ 1K~

    ~t9

    ~4'3

    15~J~CG1~ I W19f~~~ C~
    .

    '.:~~~ ~~.

    '~~\ii ~

    ~j1~'

    ~~~,I'ij

    ~(i?1 c<fR-l1W ~~t,¥.<lG!i(:~ ~'1


    ~(9Cl ~ ~

    $ ·N~t~~~·~ ~~ ~.
    ~~: .~~~~~ ~:~.~
    :

    .~
    0-...

    C'61~9j1'fG1*·~

    C~~ 9fFi1.C'iW~·~

    "11~itc~tr?J~~j<l~

    ~ ~<,,-~!VI

    ~l;3

    9jlJ1l~ I ~.~Gi xt~,,'r!C<P (q~~m On~! <, ">':-. ,"".

    ~'G1~fVSf~, ~~

    1L<pr~~D:,
    . 5~~

    ''''fN;mr ~.
    ~''<!~;[lj~~
    :~

    ~'>19n(Hr~ >i~jsii::~ I ·CtD.G4~~~ ~\fi , .


    .~
    '~->i~~~1-~!~~
    i{5f~

    ~~I-·qi\S~i! 01·j;ft
    I .

    ~'<Jm-'
    .

    ~~j

    \!)1~

    of' ,..,J..C ~ . ~ ~'!tAl.\5jf'~h1 ~!9j~~,


    t

    <p~~;"<P\Sml0tl~~~Hfi;I-~-~~-

    Jr,,~YtJ
    ,.)1

    ..

    I~
    ~
    ~~'{;;f

    ~l:,~.~C~\5·1
    ~~~.·§:-i..S""":"'1t-,<i:J.-(.-~--:-,jj-Q1

    <Q~'-·~--·-~--:·"~6~~~.-.

    -='~~1~-"~...... --'.:'."-~

    r-

    Laberit i1t~
    ~~

    5(;~"'l~. ~-3N.;~·@ln~(~~ ·

    ~tf)'I6G~~ ~~'!

    '()f~rV1.~. ~"'t~
    ''5f'<~~
    '$f.'Q

    (_

    C~~'i.f, ~~

    "151i4i~F,bSl~1t~~ f~,>j.q~f.tc~X!!

    '1,~%rrsr~~ ~~

    "~9fT~1r

    >qt~;lj.q
    ~
    ~'

    . ~,'l~ ..~,.

    ~i*,~ ~:-~~
    ~!. ~~

    ~"

    ' .?'2J"~

    q~
    ._~.

    . .q0; .• ~

    ~~"~SJ~·I ~~l"'l1 ~.

    I~~ .~~

    ~~~ '01' ~.~ ~,~~ ~.~


    ~
    -

    >J:~~'~
    ~

    'i5fl~-S
    .•,Wl
    ~

    ,~t'j)·, ~\S<J:W~
    "Jfl~~
    r-.Y
    _

    G,l~j{:¢l~j~.-;~<p~V3
    .'¢lf~

    'ifl' G,9'i?3i <M(j6ft~\5ff~~'

    ~1J~

    'Pl~1>~~,
    o.'7;"T";'!
    T~~~

    Rt~ ~:m~rJ'~.~
    .
    -~'

    W0 ~
    .....

    ~.'\.~ :~~:t~.~IU1~ '5j~ 9i~~ "~i'.~ ~jcat I,\5{~ .~


    . /h, ~

    umler.:;ti' .. ~ \5fi~@ c:~:rl~'·


    .......A...,..

    erase.:.-. 041W1~.~{~~...~.f., \5imll


    ~.-.,. _

    S··· .......,",B'..I.~l ,'~" I

    .~. ~ftJlFi ~~~~~

    .......

    Il<jj'l

    ~~-r:::::...,
    ~1"1i~

    ~n~'~1~"':'Sj;~~,G'!
    :;;:l"""""'"

    .__,

    ~
    ~~~

    11'~"9fII

    '1~·~rn 11~'CfBr1n~ ~~
    ~

    'l'''lT I ~
    ~~
    ~\."'I~

    ",/.il
    ~

    .~

    ''&1~ !~~."1

    ~--B
    ~~

    ~~,

    .~ ~li~

    14i!ii<l'~
    (.4ifq

    ""'('""''1,
    -

    ~F
    (.'!ll

    I)

    .:q~C111f ~~<I '1~~.afH:.~·Sl<ff·'ib ~.

    'I'~'~~

    ~'~Gi-~ri·~llill5"Rl... I
    0
    '-..~

    t!i·~"9i.i~[Gf"fI''' ..QQ_ ~.~


    '-.

    ~~C® T~{S ~~

    I""'-""'_

    'I5i,'i~i1

    ~$~ '~I<fl
    ~~4TI:~
    '~'.'.

    ~m
    ~M

    05i 'G4Q. '{'~T~~r-~qill$t ~f:f~{.~1 t~(!4


    '(j~

    -~
    QJ

    ~j_04;;_(~' ~1~. \5t,HCi5fe '~M ~!


    ..
    "....

    . .,...-..,

    ~-

    \5fi~1 ~~lG1~,

    11?l~\!i ...
    ~)!;..,.

    9:~'?~

    !iJ?!1! !~(,~~
    Q,'\;1 'I ,;:
    II;

    Laborit

    Gf1'.1. <R;G')

    ~')~

    CQ.j(~ '9jTG'1lt~! ~ ~~&>'~a,I~F!S ~~T?J

    ~·i~t~'6

    .,,';r\!)
    .---...; .......... '-..1;

    &:.p;
    ;- .....

    ~<f.l)t ~:
    9:!'1·~RJ II 1-

    '~l1€\l_(AX;~ ~(>3f--' ~(,qrl"'1f~

    '-..q~'!"

    ~01·?f 9<~ ''".:i~ <. -....: ~'L....

    \5fl1."0i

    91rr~

    \5lT("l<;;J ~
    j

    '\5f1(:?/G1' ~jl:j<j> ~?f<1>

    c>R'<! ~ C'>l~ \5ll~!

    :!'f1~~ ~

    2lfhRrm
    ~~ :

    ~IGjiM'& ~i

    \5T~~

    D1 ~ (S)

    f~ '&tt:'>io'1
    ----7

    %~h~
    ~
    <fi, ~'>l~

    . ZlR>Rrm \5f11:"0i

    (R)

    \5fR.<>;'<>1 0f<il ~'Jf1' 41 ~ C'1 \5ll~' ~9j0

    9f1\S1

    <WI ~

    C'f.' '1G'Ri, lfIY-'i ~

    eif\bf~m ~
    .~

    'BIZ

    (<>f05

    \51~ .. r <Qz M9'<l

    c<!\5 i .!l'
    ~9j<fi

    f4«>'X

    2l1\!J.h!rm'Q. ~

    2l1\!J.fJr$lj ~?j"<i' ~ ¢l~q

    <1>-\

    (S) -7 ~
    -7 ~QJl' S

    zif3f$TI! (s) ..:~::~~9j<fi o/.1i

    (r) -7 ~

    {R)

    \5f1C:<>Wl~

    ... ~~1 C"'r'R1


    \5flB'11

    ~"'1G1 ?fl\¥i
    <I>'<J1

    1!l'Z
    <{l1! t ~

    <Q"1

    f.1~"1 ~ f<i.
    ~n.

    wm"fit'rZ ~ <.ff\'ifl '<l-R


    R>f.;

    c!l1.<l' f.Br~"i <'f5iffi ~,<1q"1R'ii

    '<111.«>'1, C<1~
    ~'>;~

    ~CG'f1ji1d}t;C"l"l
    ~

    w.'?A C'<l'f@ ~~

    ?fl~ <n~T~ 'T-"b1j~! ~.


    2lf~f.1r<:j@ C~

    i.!!~.

    Bvn'"?1"
    \5flB"1~
    ~<p

    "'.!RJ\ <f.IVrn ~ ~ .~

    C~C<K~ <{'''ii.\!)

    .!l<i>. ~,

    ~t<lJ ~

    2lfbRrm

    f.i~:l\q
    "9 11~

    fl-~NI!3
    ?J1'il(Pjr; .c!I:<f ~

    ~9j'-.q;

    11<f1i.!!1Jt

    ;n i ~<n \5flB~ !:f@ r '3'[1 2lN~


    <f.Qjj...
    ~-)_,_Q ~,

    f.'mr.~ ~
    \5j~9

    -&m

    f.br ~

    <f.QJ1, \5f1~ ~1
    ~

    ~
    !;zCP!<_ ~

    "l\S1fiG'l

    '1'$1(P1., ~-;,-

    -.:r"1tQ:

    ~~(9j'<i:>4':;~(.~~

    9j"i~~

    'W"'R, "-... )~Z ~M(.\!)


    ~I

    I \!il"<19ffi <1''1'1, ~

    C~Mi1 ?fi'<l~ 00 ~

    cd1

    ~t3lJ;;:J C<lG'flI' ~"'f1'1R kc:rrG<1 ~ ~, ~,


    <QJj<I

    ~,

    ~"
    '5ff<1 "'11 "-I~ l:f11 <l1<P, ~ <iB!
    <Q~>j'1

    ~
    ~

    <f.'<fr ''1G1(%>, ~

    0'f"f<f. :

    <p

    '<I, ~-~ ~.~ ('"P'1G'fl', '~', '~' ...)\S6i)H"f


    I

    ~N

    ~"

    ~'>fl11Vm ~.9ll~ ft9~1 '5fl<f "<{, C«"l-i I/i

    ~&N:>
    ~~n ~iMst'1:f1f.'r;::r
    ~ ~<p

    <R'<It"i>f1'~ ~
    ..Q~

    'l)r'\~'1 ><j-,3l 4-:<f ~,


    Q;'iJ1 ~<,.>j{.<{

    ~
    <fiO.fi i

    H<.! '141"1<'1 '6\'lqfTItA.~"11~


    BI<i11 GlG'fl'B '!1VH.~1 ~
    '41~~R'r'il~
    0--:S4

    m~

    I5jlo1l.~ 1T1~ I

    '5N"1J

    <Q"<118

    ~~'6\fb
    ~f<:;i~
    r---

    R~~

    < <Q~V1

    m'&
    i"
    .

    f.i~

    ~J>:il
    ~

    iiilG4{.?i
    .c.

    -:1(~(.'ii

    '5lC~'1'
    .__.

    .\!)j(."~9

    C<fo'fL

    "'1'(3RI? "<lll

    <l>'11 \5f1<.i1~ "<J-c!l.;::r <!'lY-'i F1u

    m'<li1! (~~~

    vm'.9<,['

    \5flD'!1cj"liLfll:J\51~~l>f

    "Jr::r <>;~

    I '6H~\S3~j'!1

    \5fi~
    ~9fTI;l,

    "-I~(?r

    ~ "<ll'<ll <wlt~ "<ll ~~!

    '?>n
    ~I \5l ~

    '1lVl

    <fi'1! $11

    :>F'1-R>

    ~F-$<i' jfj<lfJ1<i>

    f.1~
    ~ ~
    '-.

    c<! ~f<iI~M"i-"-I"<llQJ1
    I ~'1<j'im
    y/"-

    ><fl$i'11~il\G9 "<ll~tj ~

    2Ih!r"i1i
    ~ Langue

    ~[q>

    ~
    '1'~(!i!_

    c<! ~'lf\!i

    \!)I.~~ ~j"1i1 i ~,
    \

    '4'w-!li i.!!~

    Langue

    I i.5jj<1" <Q~ i~T'1"-r;::r'5"j\!j

    I >l<'l ~

    f\bf,l lffi:<R I 'i3"1-;q 4"l-~ <W'i '~I01Mi ~ <f%fl <IN ~"lf.'Fl; ~\;fj ~, ~l,z<,Gj C\51 <fi~ '-!l!r:1i1 IlSf.>jm~ <n~ ~ <Q~ ~9j0r-."""" .......

    Pl$l~'1'I'l(,'l-;J'f!~,

    c<! "-I~ ~

    c<! "<llQJ1 1"110..,

    c>R

    Act

    of speaking
    fact-e ~

    Parole

    I~
    c!I~lZ:1 <l

    ~q

    ~
    1'1l<1 ~

    c!1~ Langue
    ~ ~~I 'Tl~

    C1' Social

    eilliJRrm1i ~"V1J <Q'lliii Wi-1_ <V ~ "fiVl.


    D'TI% ~~
    r--. --.

    <Q<fi

    "'1Fb<~ ~
    :=i

    <?(3! C'1'i3'i!1 ~,
    &. ~

    \5B!1
    '1"1(P1~,

    \5(@

    <rrn I \5f!!)-;Jc)<fl1TI <m"fl~n


    ~?j<f;

    \5ll~'1

    Wfrf

    : ~P1L"'1 <i' c<! ~QJ1

    >lliii-.!!

    '5!~:<!'J~ "1<11 ~ ~ ~~
    r~"-'"

    ~~

    ~'l'fr«~
    ~I{.'!J

    oR
    ~

    m~
    ~

    <P1t<7i"l

    <fl!? \5fll5<1<f<ll'11 '-!l~L<fi li~l"1 f.f;;fj'1 ~


    '<11
    ..

    ~l':l<i
    <il:<f

    <rf<i'J
    i5i<l1
    ~"1 ~

    <>;1"[<1 'i3 -r:"09


    ~ ~I i7-:~-" "-1",,- ~

    '>lIB!

    ~"f(<i'

    tQfbQ,;?!I
    <!l'1, ~ m_-\5l'<fj"

    <wDFr
    <i~

    <fi"'19"l:l <Q<i' ~<;>f<f-21~~ ~ C'<!"C1' ~'11 CWtBi'~

    (~~

    lfI';Q I <lJj·?!h:jll!{.9

    'iToi'
    'BI<l1'

    C!!l.t.~ 7Ti

    C'1:~·n
    c!I~

    ~<>;~
    p

    2lf\bi&.gj

    00, ~

    c!1ll1C'1'

    ~~11 <::'131 <i"1(;-.!! ("'10':, ~ C<>;C'1, ::f!Y-'i \5g

    m, <l>'5f1~
    go

    V'R11~ ':...!J/ ~'¥. "-I<iL>f -:;'3" j

    \5ffi12F1"f19

    --Ill..-

    6MJ
    ~

    4"l!~P0i.¥'"
    C::......L..-

    :.wJ.HI'f'(; ll1<!<fr>i1 <


    _...

    <ll M{1'1 "1,ziS1j'!JI 'i\~


    ~Ft-p"!iSl<i

    ~r"'I<>Ri'-:!':I'!Jt&f!1

    1'l~1

    Z~-\5!,zl"1

    ~ ~ "1"1

    i'i1'1 \5jl1il!iiP;l91 C'1>s<TI I

    ~
    <Q~

    11'B

    m<rr."1~ lfI<jJD.l
    \5l1V,-<{ ~-~\51
    4"l1

    ~R<i1 <!l~ <fi1<hl."'1{'<l' r 4' \5l~'<:fj <l <lJj"'~~

    fu-)
    ~~

    >S '<!

    Jt>1i-<

    >t>1"i1 <l_,_Q?i:,~

    ?:H'4"'I~'!5~

    I\...~

    <l ?j1~R~ D'-?t~ c!l4"l .,,-...<>;Iq\!)~; ~011 <: ~"S:IT;i'i

    &<1 ~ <{]'B cQ'fi. \5f111"1 q&fC"~I\5l

    <!l"1''\ '<! Q11)t <38 '1<:~(.\5 9f~ ,zGj competence


    ";iRil(}$~

    i '0 >S '<I .!l~


    I

    ~~

    cQ'bi~

    K~~ti,H EF!'I~mill

    (:.&nd Prod) ?~

    \!l101$l Internalized
    Genetic

    ,!L)

    \!'trm~

    {''S~t~~~">;'~iSif\5 ~

    ~"&iifi~:"" <j}!<f~'"~
    ~~-,
    (.!l~~-

    ~~l <1lSl~ '41 ..

    0S~ !1~lt~~~>i~
    <l#~(,~ ~,~

    1 _'.!l~ ~'G1,a;1

    ~Z'>b

    ~Vl
    ~~

    f~\tj~lS!1
    ~zG4
    ~
    .~l

    ~i6i(<p.3f~cmf~

    €ndowmyntei

    i~A"jl'~~2il~

    riJl<?&l ('1lZ{~~'n ~

    ~<rj'?f

    Ni$
    1~

    ~\5

    ~~§1,t:<;!p. ~'~~

    f;ijtJ1~\!) <J;l·llC\!) '~J1~Hi9f·

    N'~l~
    ;::r

    ~rn <!l~l
    l~j\5
    ~.-,_"=

    'Q_Fbftt.M

    Ml.~J?Jbl_
    .....
    -

    Language -(EL) I up.:p~l ~~ <Q'T-

    \b~r~f\~fip;p
    <~(j:Ir.Q1'1'~,

    ~
    ~-

    ~~09G~"tGij"~ ~
    J4.~<l1
    'i'{$! ~

    c.~f~· ~ ~
    ~f~
    ,"

    1:(,~1J:l?jft) :~

    9rf9\5N!<t ~.
    CRJ{.<P ~~

    i5i~l:(,] CZI' CRt


    C~R"'H
    'lK~ . 1f1' ~'\.~

    ~lli

    J_ ~

    ~1)1
    7i1t~ ,~G1 ~
    I L.S~
    ~ij

    e.!J.t ~_.~
    ....--. _ Q-."

    " I ~1()§iffi1 i-<l%'3R Wi~~ti$ ~~ ~


    ~......

    :th3>i«;) ~<KPi

    C~'cG-9f~(;~~

    I ~!f?l

    f~ateC4 f.k~ <irn 0I>rift>4 ~<JP'J~~ j ~~NHnet~~ ~~~ \S1<!~f0~ ~'~ ~~ 8! ~~ ,~rm'd1~ ;n c.~ ~h~~C1 <?{.~ ~ l1~'c:B'~ '(f.ft~1\!)1t~· 1f1V1 ~'1~ <r~tst ~,B-1 ~,~~ ,~,§~ :!l~~r;!~IG1i I'~~"H
    "' ' , ~

    law

    r--<

    '6lM" ~1\5;zPi C~

    ~"..-,... -

    ~L~ ~-

    ~~
    <!"I,",

    'fi)r:i ! \5fPn~ ~t~~~~. ~';{ ~'9fb'Q1(ttf


    - ':1'lRl ~

    Jitfi.9l;;!l 1$W-11 ~
    -~E::lt~i (~C~
    ~

    ~
    ~~~-l\~$['j

    1lt~ ~
    ~

    '~--

    (l~ '(5RP1' c\[)

    ~lt
    ~~~

    ._~i$l ('<1(.'9

    c14r~(.ti~ ~
    ~

    ~\'? 9frn
    r-

    WTf j ~9

    ~~

    ~~

    ~~~~c~
    '.~

    il1PfC~ll:

    ~~t7fI- .. I~
    ._,

    t~~l\$ll'1ytt

    ~~

    -.

    c<rJ9! IYfGi1~1!~i~~d'!(G1:;r,

    ~,

    \!I'\St~J~ {.r§1 'Olj~Of1i

    >!l'~~5Htdj1~'~C;@
    L/\D~(!4 ~~, ,OO1®l~~ LAD-~?i6-:1~. ~~)
    ,_ • ,_.

    f1~tr~

    ~'1~1L~if'Sm C<t~l~i1S
    ~,~
    ~'~iil
    _ , . '_

    ~4i1l <p?rtq~
    ('~>l~

    1>.Gl-~)'~~f~ .~~ 4! ~~
    l)'~~lII\!)'~l
    .,' _', ' _ '_

    ?1rnC71~ I \!)C~ ~~t ~·~UA.~ ~

    <Jifth .;G!F1~.~f.~ ~ ~,c~t~c~ fiut,io .. io ]~)gy-'?li "~~l!1i~l'Gf ~ ~~,,02fS b \5{~t~~ '{3 ~ ~~t:i. '<p~,~ l 'U1'~r<Di:q"f(l~ i6fi~ ~~ ~Q.lla;'~. ~

    lQ~l}f ~'Zlj-1~
    ~$J]

    ~~
    ~
    . ,

    lf4c;"

    l'

    ~~

    fif.~~~' t5tP1",
    '~;;;1
    j

    ~'

    ~1%~
    ~ii,M~~

    ~~

    <P~~

    ~--->Q~

    ~~~

    C3~I~

    bG1t\!5
    :;,;vj~t~,

    .~~ ~qj'-<p~~l

    R<lWn
    .

    {'9flPl~ ~
    !.fJ4b~ ~~~~
    ""='- • '. --:_

    '051 <lJ'4(~q' ~1' G<ll"D '9f1~


    ~,

    <fl1A -=tfl ~~

    C''JIm D1 -qr~

    "Jr/ c-:

    r=

    '~~1'~· ~,~<,;p~pcr ~'


    ~'7'

    ~.,~~n~m~
    ~~

    :~m;n

    ~ij(;~

    Horizontal mutual aid~~ ~~l~f~ \S1~ ~t~, ~'~~~l~

    i
    ..

    ~~

    '61'<.tGrl

    ~ti(Gj

    ~1RJ ~
    ~(tj'~

    '~~
    ~Ji

    c.. ........ . .

    1~~"$im~Sl

    -=-{_

    (~:(.\!l ~,

    ~<,fiT;i ~Pfrn'

    :q1~'trnti

    t ..c~'!" .

    '~
    ~~~ \51~

    so<ci~iO~ogy.. '5i~
    ~~~ ~~~l)'l

    '-m:~ ~'lR11' ~Git~· ~'I..


    ~ ~~

    ~O{~

    ~iG1lti1?1C~'- iCiijf C~
    . C~""'t(..1 i

    '~'1~1J9'~H~ ~p.ln~n~men~~(~l.st)~
    ~t1.tij~

    ~.~<.~~:~ 'b)lN
    '5fl~

    fb.J!-~ ~

    ~)'.'4rH~~' ~~-~m'~~1J~l:;t

    LAD-1f

    ~lRti ~

    'C~c~ '~~4~tG1
    ~\Sit.,{~

    ~T(JJJ: ''¢f~,~
    «<: ~

    ~~~
    _~~

    ',K1 . -:1

    ~~

    (:<l~ <P-::11

    ~~,~1,

    :m.t!]

    ~1\S1{~f.1~ ~
    ~Qj1'

    ~f\bq1}f <ip~lp)~ I ~'

    ~~

    t.q'G3i~"if.' '~"'1\'5~rn

    '~It.~~

    ._

    \5R~~~.'~ l \!ifQffi

    Dasein

    ~tG1r5J.,i \5l;.1f1(A ~
    (-;(l.1<r)-~~ ~"

    ~t'i~t~>£l4i6t

    ~ITl~(.~TI:ffi

    t>r;f.{;

    f4(Jj

    CCfl'5i~
    ~

    ~CfiZif I <n'G~'S1 ~'

    c~~t~~ I lQ'4fdft4 ~ ~4 9'&1Q"ajc~ ~1WI ·'5ftii (.<Pf!q1'8"11\8·m <rltA i{1 i


    ~if4~01~
    C~G1~
    4l1f ;:?JPt':,l tQ~1{

    ~'i",<l 81
    Wh:.<;p
    ~~~;:i~ ~""~J;t.,~.

    \!5(C;fil~ 'e?ffi

    ' ._" . . ",,"~'-ro ,-. <q]'1<f i'1\'~~j~1f"'~~! ~rrq(;~;noPt~ t\S1~ ~'4t~,~ ~ H:nf¥~' ,~~~ b,~r"$ ~'6~.
    ~

    <¥2ff ~~~ f.fj~·/edti-ction

    c7j(~~ I ~5fI~(.~
    \Sij~iG1

    ·t:ri~~tBf,~'lw;'PjKQi~fG4M~~lf4\&1~'~'
    ,~~
    (q~.. '.-~~":'(.

    ~~U~-l~

    {'-~'ffit:~~

    ~:n(:~ f4R,~

    tJ~(:<P

    '.~\8g1f44'
    ~

    of~tFr, \Bu.\!! ~1
    ~~
    ~~".o'J I,;"'(.~

    ~.

    Dasei:n~"IT .~
    t?i l,:~.

    ~~;>{:m·:f5i16 ~.
    ~~-(P1
    '. I "

    ~1?1't'1iRi{

    ~-1~Z<P ~~ ~~~)i(.~ ('~G1t~ ] 't;i'jmjML-~·€1 ~i<1ff89 ~~lJ9~.M ~~:Zl~ ~1>ici\!):ii~~ "'i,W~


    ¢l.>!4

    .~~.a~ ~1~t<1~~'~T@

    (falling)
    (J1~r'S ~

    <JiLtiii~~.liPiz
    \5t'-:I?i?{Ci . ".
    1

    '\ST~-l
    [...-q.......?HC.-.ll 1oJI,""'t!
    ,-1.

    CD\!)'~i >J.'8i~~Q'{\!Jf
    ~<l,,,, l:L-~~

    "<P~~-

    4~! ~.I
    .,-:.\..1.

    ~;()ti -'4:.'·"'t...lR

    b~''''''''''~ '~~~
    I

    ~~' 14tee~·~~.c~
    15'~! \5i~,

    ~Qji w.t~ Hal


    9~t~

    'b!1Df{C>~

    MU~Ci5 Gtr.~~kj%::O (
    ~~G~1. <p
    C<r-l
    ~"

    \5l.(:i{)"Q

    ~~Cft)C:~ I~

    <liF:.b§j~-)

    '~

    '<fI ~ C~s:tG 'ift' ~

    vn~,
    .

    ~~~c.~~~1.ji''flR~~ <l:vr(?1 m2:n~: >1~r$:rrf\b'?l~


    r.15~ ~_. ~ffl -~ ~G'1{51~
    ~9<l~~~

    c%

    -;rt C~iQ'~
    ~

    ~.
    '~~

    'iL~51 <p:~rr~f6t?r t>i<jwt.<f.~ R


    Btm~1i!
    .r-... _,

    ~i1'§ ~ ~. ~ ~
    .~~

    '~

    ,......., 11i4'~~B"P.T~.-;;
    :/

    ~L<l ~

    ,!C4t ~(.\!)

    m-= Gf"'t~'$' ''Jir.I!F13-hC:~'?~>t(§rGt)i':l


    ./ ~

    ~<r '~~~

    'ii54r?B~~
    G! ~.~ \5ff\ZC{~~

    'b!<l\!"iP'Pl1~G4l. ~~-P"f.~q ~(~ ~.

    ~~W]i~"

    .,~,

    "~~i?~~ ~tll1 f..SiVFi 'C;;'!;;'K'1 ;n' ~~


    <1tb
    1 ~' ~
    ~~~

    «st~-~~~

    J~~Z ~

    ~~j-~\!I_:'J1\81\3 ~QJ:~l?f
    >

    ';m ~ ':s:tjC~1 ~\!i<w

    l1\G1K9'i <fS~ '~t.\tIl ~


    \5D~' ~

    ~\S~t9~,

    l-~' ~~~'. zur'


    ~{.o~ ~~

    '~'~~<p~~~

    t""i.<- ~,~fwr~:Wt~~ ~05.

    ~c..t'~1.?)1~RTI '"0~1-~1-

    ~-~.

    l!j'$l

    ),[l?'~ ~.~

    {.J·{Gl 'f-4.Dl~ kfC<l'~l


    ~~P1H~ ;:j~-. 'iDlZI

    ~1

    ~clfieT""! [

    ~,l
    <fj

    ~-:1~<;~

    (f]S1~

    -m"1t~~~-~@~

    c ~ ~'M=S:P1m?11f1~<nOf

    ~Rt1
    0C~ ''1;

    <l~;t$f

    ~'~.'pmG1~~r~ ~Qk~'?1
    <pqr ~' ~

    ~1?i%1.'~
    ~'

    ·$1!~I~"l}.J;\$r~-tJ!~'PbH

    ~<ri~ QJ191 'fviCV;f.j \5'Bi~'n' I ~~

    I -~

    ~l~

    2:'9~if, '~'l\Bt~i{J4'<f12:

    2nd P~f1of;}g

    '. [(~.tii;:;;t I"ltcm:r;J E

    .~Q.,tR1I~'<f-l"fi;j~ ~
    ~~4~ .. ~~ ~93f ~

    ~.~

    &$:
    ~.

    <l!~ 1{~

    'c~n~ ~.~ \51

    ·*tRn"Y'f 9j~1 ~
    'q~
    .~t;I '6l~

    <ff~

    ~".\!)~

    C~~~l

    ~U1
    j;j~""'f

    ~0.n~

    \5fRrn ~

    ,,·il
    (?if

    Q4~~,'.q'<@'m'Vf ~l
    ~dI

    :9fP.J~ \5D~
    ~~
    <f!~'-

    ~"I'

    ~>mlC"i1"1f ~.
    ~~
    <p~ ~.

    ~">f.l '~

    ~171'~\!i:G:illi--~'~~ (fj'??:CG1 '~


    '~ \§1~(Gi ~

    -~C41lS :Jj_~~%~' ~QfI ~ ~


    <1qjf.'\b ~.~

    ~')<K". .qLG1 \5fm


    fj~

    ':r1<ll(\ft1>iI;"i i
    '\!)~

    .",Q(1

    .~1t1~ ~.

    ~.) ~,
    '<P~

    i
    '\5fJ~

    ~\!).~

    -;T:j I ~-'), .£l~'

    ~~·ti'

    ~M' '~'~\!)M

    ?ir~~~f(.<p'Jfit~
    I~ ~.
    r..

    <p~'C~ I

    ~?t
    '~
    ",.

    ~1

    ~Citrn<Fl~.
    ~.

    ~~.q

    i\/
    'ci~ I Ri$ft~01?I '>1C5f .~

    Z
    "-

    ~".;D

    ~:t~..Q\tt ~l%it~'f!iR\5t
    .;r[
    g-, . ~

    ,~C1-' -~q

    C~~?f\:st,~

    (J)·¢f4~ 4i lU1f~~G~ ~
    l1'~~

    I
    <fiQIBi

    ~if

    \5X'3?n:Q .~

    L!l<p

    ~~.c~·''1tG1,
    wrnJ:1
    qc,

    'i<$~t(~G~~

    '~~~'&J§{<:V?

    «TIl ~(~'~

    ~l~<l~f~

    C$n110'1?l ~

    14\g "~H:~J
    '~
    '?]~

    ';f\ .~

    rl~

    ~'fl'l'iU

    ?i\$j(fH1

    ~~111'

    fikSl ~(.~'i1'
    R'il\$'

    f1lirn ~

    ~1);j,€H 9l;R ~~

    <:5r"ijRq{1

    i .~~.~~'$l~

    .;,f¢l'6~.

    '~

    ,~t~Flift· ~~
    c1GW5'f~ ~~

    ~!8l,

    ,~@

    ~~4i!7l'

    ,'ij~H<P ~M~It~?r
    \5fl\1ffl '~R1

    '61t"'1f ~
    %~j ~.

    ~Pn1i
    ~~~

    ~?1<q

    f9J~ ~~'61(,~'q.{~ urn~ ~.~ \S~


    ;~(;.~, '~H!(Cdi ~'i
    '\!l~

    (.\!)nrID
    -~f1'~ff

    -n, ~dij·[fl?i ·~9jl{s t<Jt~ .~Pi(.~ ~(yt~ ! ~~f1«:P ~~

    .~~\~"W~~

    ~'Msri ~_
    ~'~

    t~~-~~(}11l Jft"5f 4>i'<IlVl?1

    HC~ ~fGlC~t
    ~~
    <Ni('~

    '~'{~~i'

    .~,

    R~

    .~'~-' ~~

    ~,
    ~

    'fi~.,\tll '!JmQ$] >Jffll

    ~~\!iflTIi

    'N' {:;i~:y\!l. ~~ I,

    '~tfif~ ~
    'QJ'I'2ff!
    .'&~,

    I .. i~,~rc<rfj1~ f j

    *
    (~ktlr

    >iG~

    "IRl"K'J ~ ~I¥~~'~
    (~

    l-eifi~
    qr~i ~,
    ~l~1.l!C~~

    ert~~..""r~(.<l~ ~~ ~m 1~~r :rn~,


    :!'i1ijJ\&, \Y:i"?lfl
    ~<

    '~\!l

    ,.;;n:~,~· ':C~,

    .~\!)

    -~

    '\5\5

    ~Z'1 ~~f~Ul

    ~C'i 9j~tJ.

    c:l~.. ~(3J

    .r
    ~

    , ~<:~~ 9Kf
    ~
    ~

    ~t~

    ~~I

    .~<rffi' -~~G~:@
    ~.~

    i' 'i75i1t& '5f~


    '.~11'@.

    M~ tif~tttkt
    ~~4~

    '\5Dlr' ~

    ~-qJG1'~(<i

    {?1 (.~{j1~. ~~

    ~'ij\511 LAD
    z:;\!)~,

    06t

    ~1'Q<P~~{Plib,~r,

    ~'W

    6""~~G4 <f~,

    l)l

    7J8r ljC~i ~C~


    C>.~

    ~F1 ~,
    \5[~

    ~'~"c1(fffi~'14~

    i4'~'~'I' Oi~r\S :{'1f\!i


    ~~

    ~(-<11 .~

    ~Pf ~

    '<m'~ 'NC1J
    \ST\§1~R1l ~
    .~ tor$!
    ~ I~~

    <fj~41

    ~,~

    $~~C<';l~

    ,~<f? m9J9l
    ;0, ~~
    ~'.i!~'"
    <,

    '>11;ZC~~iJl£1l' <ltG1~' 'I'1t~t~i1) ~


    '-{Q\!l ~~-;;1
    ~ "").r .~r_~ -"1
    ~I'~''''

    ~Mt,r~ ~'~ ~T~.·'l.~ ....


    j,

    . ~~H·"?r
    t.:tt..n!;
    0'

    1 01, ~
    .~ ~

    .~t3~~ ~
    .~, VfJ\.~
    ,I.'

    IlL

    \!iIl~(F1' ~~f~

    '~Q,.~ 4Cil~

    '9'frn f'

    ~1~. Cl~'1 -~l~l~i~t >i~FH~l; ~~


    ~~"&.-c<U~
    ~?'i.(PI
    '~'::1ZJ;-' ..q'~

    fkst~·

    '21't~ Gr~OfSl

    'O.I1~Cqr",!

    ~"

    rt$l<pf~ I 1-5~'Q:5 ~ :?J?,';'-~


    . ~"'-~~-

    ~m' ·~¢tBi·"'ft<Ji
    Q~

    ~$l?~~~
    ~.

    &Q{iR~} I tF~, <~~:sJ-~ ~,

    '~i~r~
    ":.

    II~' 'wi.

    '}jf~tk
    I~. I...;

    t.."\.Jj

    ""'' " ~·lt"L<r~ I''-...·llI'

    i""!":f"?~..

    ~Qjt~'S:. '.<nY1 \S.bC~l~, ~C\ti1~?ti C~If"P1'\~~()1 tll~~'i ;r ~\~~z~


    I '~~c" ,~~-

    _~.~. .t~~

    ~t~fJ c~?+ ~~ I
    ,~<fi

    (.<;p\g

    :qsQ!1 ;;JG1c.~ ~?'

    ~~.,*'1' "(:~'f~ltL.r_'Q 'cij!t~1G1t~~ 0PK~t ~V1 ~


    <l¢i-:

    Ihal
    if.\.QJt

    ~1J~'z

    ~lf!"1Nt RC<P ?jC~~~


    qJ

    f~~'

    1C~~, ''§}~1~H
    I
    ('li<1,

    '3fI~:~ff~~
    r."ll t<I fII f.i,
    ~~
    ~I, ...

    ~("l:1tW1~~
    ~~

    -:tn~~ICi

    '-t5r~,rmf!.~· ~~

    '-;;n'

    ~1t~

    05i~
    \5fl~(~$1

    ·{?Pltiilrrr~<p~1
    ~~

    lococentri c

    ~'G1 ;n?
    • ."

    "i~foii~41 "
    ~~t;.y~,

    '{ii>t '11'<1
    ~\5Si~
    '..

    <1'q[ ~

    t~~. 1i\;~j:9\5 ..
    ~-~;~

    I.._ '~

    ~(~- \5t1{tt.rl~~ -4~4 ~l$f ·;n·1 .~ '-'.'


    Otf.'~

    <}t1\S~~ • ~t ~~
    {\511 ~ ~

    (;<l'it![ ~r:9

    <'P~<n\51
    '?~

    '~~'4~~1~~

    b01(.~ 1031

    ~'!iiC~ - :i3I:0J6
    ~\!)~.

    ';:O~ ~"f.'n1 M~fij ~~"i~f0 I ~~'Ff.;


    "1,fGi51u~ffir;<qS \5f~?i~~
    : • ~(,\!j

    ~G ,~';j'1~

    C~J~
    ~~~
    ~ :~

    .;p~~a:G'1f1i '"i{'j?

    "5Ti"1~

    .Q~

    '9fj(~

    ~f<q!)1~

    ·"1,~~~,Q.r~- ~

    <F'tl(.~ ~R~ri,

    ~'Gt

    ~~

    ~,.q
    .__

    .~ tm . "'11\!)-~i"!'~'i1
    "f.k51
    ~ 's:rl""""_/~$l' n·~ ;>i lio§riC,,:r.

    >i'1~ '~

    ej'R,.qjq <P[~ ~~G1 I ~$


    \5n,~'!(.h~~;,;,i'
    ~~

    ;qt~ C3fG1'Gi (~~


    ~_/

    ·;rt('\'ry-;hl:..·'l

    ~'~1"ii"iI7:::r

    ""'..~"71::;::;;:; t~!2.,! "5lf--i~l....·l~

    ~l'9i.('i
    -::::n t'
    ~I.

    ~~. lA~(."1~:..r...! ~

    jqsfhn (8N~G1\$IM(.~c.-~S1,¥fil<J)1
    \8'''T';i

    <:iq,~ {H)~e-revers.an~?K'4
    ~,~

    (pPif1~1k·'i ·.<:,C~ ?il~ 1 \5l~' 'S{lIS

    C.<p~1

    ~iT-?ll_<;"'C<l~?

    ~~

    9nG11'·~-~C1~"'Fi·~~
    ~\$rt~~<r~1 ~

    on~ ~

    ~l'P:l$l~C~~)f,C~: ~Vll~~
    'B~~@ii(..oi~
    ~

    Ji<.;!'~ W_~\f) "V'11~t,<q~?'

    : ~~R~~

    ~
    4"::

    At?! i 'lGl:
    ~2;(.N :q.~~;

    \(®~

    '15.l'

    'L~~ Et
    1fl~~~

    .~:m'~\!)'i
    ~

    ~f<1~:m~P!:~~~
    ~;§)~
    ~ '~
    ._

    _.

    ~~Wl~'05.ll~,~, '~'< ~ ~~
    .nt-:;.: ~ . I~\.'?=l
    I' -

    1;"';'1~ '~"':"n"H$l! -t'lll'~\'~"~~i~."'-I,

    r:;r::;;
    ~\."'i

    I '31~
    ~

    ~M~'~ ~G1
    ~
    ~ .' ~

    ;.Q~
    .

    ~Jl~rn <$q'j
    .•

    I L~~~

    ~(J~
    -

    9fP\G1 ~
    i .,;-;
    L~".

    '~I"
    ...."

    ,<t~059Ji~G'ntl.!'li~t'i --J.... ' '.


    I
    '5fl~

    : 'Ut~~
    I

    1 .~ •

    fv~l c-

    Jozhfl ,:.,._

    '5l9i~ ~

    ~.

    ~~

    ~
    t ~,

    ~-Z<rt9S1R4S ~

    ~ffll?i ~~ ~'~~ q.~c-!)~

    ~trJ

    Sj7f1

    '~Ffl'-:::: '{3~1:r "5l19;'B


    '9jf.'i5;;1f,~

    1r.-r~W'-( I

    ~6Pi(~ q:n(.~,TC% ~f;U~ -. I \5ll~,

    '-S?iC::1, ~t~t(.l1"C~A.

    iL.-

    ()!1fil'f1iB~tf~-::i ~(;~.,
    ~~:>f'<f

    ("Or M<@n;~~~!~
    ;n' [

    ·zr~-' -

    ~04(.0fi1t'1~~.~~

    9~' ·q"Gi.tl7i '(\31 ~G1c.<l

    :sl~·'.ff(!1~ ~ ~-

    \5f1~C®

    ~~1l

    ~~1 ·;q.G1C~· -111"$- (

    \51"J1G'j"1~

    {9j~ ~

    9i<l<Q>'>1) ~ i!§"~1'011j9j) <!'@


    ~

    Q)'j'N ..~

    "l1"Ff.

    \3"j""i1

    'R11J

    '<n~'-~

    2lB1"<1

    ~~

    \51-'»11'

    <n ~
    ~

    \511<r ~,

    ~1G'1

    '5\~T.'6 ~
    ')

    \;h(.\!) ~, '8~x1t?( 9l\?ll.'3 ~ ...


    \5fiiSf~ 91'11(.<1\05

    c:<!05 ~,
    (}A~,

    QI:<f1m

    1i?J ~
    GfMlIGJ? ~
    ~

    ZD! <m:I1 ~
    00 ~

    wr

    :C;"';'7 n

    ,..,

    cJtFfl~?~~

    '8Z sense datum'"'"'1"1 "lt~\ ~?

    ~1f
    ,

    \511"P1 W-f4"'lfi1

    C'1~111)<i' N1'li~

    \2f."i
    ~

    ~'tt'Gf.4 r.~ ?iNMi GSRff0 ~ '''jj7)'V5i«'1.::i<f@' "1i9j1"Rl'"?j \Sfffi9i"i I ?ll~ BFnlf"1' ~


    ~j

    c<rF! ~ ·~lr.~ I ~"'i<71

    ~'JrrJ:/ ~
    <'l IfJ

    >i:z~ ~~ H(,?'J 0l<fi <rj.q> i <1-';\"1i ~ '~-~~'5IT"iR'sr '411>'181<1 ~ .r,~1\!J GIT:<l f.Q.m ~,9)>(301i ~ '4V:lt;_l'j~-'1'(.'?1(}'~:"i I' <!!~ ~ f.tr~ ~ *tc1 .2fl1'l\b«> i{(,"i~ ~'6IN'1' ~-.nq? ""!~ ~ ~~
    ~1
    ~

    2i I"'''~ u, '-I'

    m<TI

    <fi@, \3Bl ">iVf Sj j 1\SlJ GR~ ~

    ...,..,~

    "If"llb ~

    ~rv

    ~(3'fC~?

    '" "-

    <f.@ "I'lJ'6i Ci:fl"'1\~~

    "-l~1

    QRflB ~,

    l.f@

    0Mt1GJ?, M~
    ~'8 \51l~

    ~0

    <i'R? <fi@1
    l.f@ ~

    m
    I

    <Q'"Q:. ~1XB

    ?j"j'><fi9flM V
    I~

    <i1~
    ~

    ~ ~9f

    ~ ~ ~!')

    ~;R,

    <i1Z ~,,~

    ff.. ~~
    :;"Jf®j'X;1>>l
    ~"Zf, ~

    ""!i ~
    .(9\£ ~

    ","'i("l<Mffi
    ~

    (cQ<11""8
    I 2:l1~

    v'8J ~
    iM

    C>:J.ri<l ~-FW

    ..!!~ (<iG<ljl)<i> m.<it·~1'1

    'i1"Q '61~H~co~:z<+l1<71:::" ~ ~

    GmT01 ~ (~?
    1 Wi '>fi'b~ "l~ '8 11~

    "

    '-13~ Pink
    ~

    F19yd-<i1

    'Brick

    C\5T.~ ~
    <i1<Wi l:1~\!)~

    : 'We do no) ~>!v.n9j ~


    I

    in the WaLl' <Q$f r~@ri411> ~ nor need no education.' <Q~


    ~jE._ ~

    ~
    <Bl"~

    9ji~(.~"!1

    ~~~
    ~<:i"i! 9ffu\5'8

    ~'(_~f-.6
    \51'6

    03rn ~ ~
    ~?
    (}P(Fl

    <fl@?)i

    'It.G1

    \5li'<3V1"

    N"

    l:if.'jG'j

    "<F1'foT!;'5)~~'
    9fful3-Q<fi

    \5Wfl"<l

    :ili*l1>nCl'(l ;y.i''l'R'''il:? I
    <!i'8"f!1 i <!l ~ 2iV.l1~

    (,"'f~1 (not ~ C<;l~ I c-m~?( 1'~N'l." 'Yi'$f~

    RH1\!)':z ~
    ~<{

    ~~ ;rn, ~
    ~

    ,,¥<71<i1?! '14P'i'Ib'

    f1ni ~

    ~?jt
    ~1~

    CQ)~

    '<iB ~'(fi ~Vl

    m~
    ~Q>

    01'i
    ~<F'T

    9f?iG'i ~

    <fiYi

    ~-(9fl1G'1
    ~'i"f8l
    £It\3

    , 01l ~i<;.{

    <flfm":11 '8 ~t<1


    ~ '~

    f~:::~i ~
    ! I!) 1'1{.1b

    9~\51
    ·4'f-

    Wt ~

    \511~."'f ~
    ~ :

    -;n, ~

    211m 0"f11151!1mc\!)

    ~.fb9j'i) ~~

    ~~ <'l11 ~

    C'f1 ~~

    . '''fW1'-<.Q iSf1"'ff -"l1 ~


    (= '-;;;!\:?lrn'
    ~

    81 ~f0\!)
    'WRl'$f

    \5fi~,

    '5f

    f.1v.J ~
    C>Rl?

    'rJf<l -?jte~

    <qq<f! ~

    <.!l~

    '5)~ ¥t"Q C<iR;~


    ''1j~'"I1\:>j:

    Ff.

    C1'YC'11 ~<mj9

    m-m ~\!)

    ZSi CiSf01<:f11m 1 ~ ~..>j0"<!J ~~ ~1J


    '?Z'"'./~"1~ '5l(oi

    oTI~
    ~
    ~

    Boo ~
    drI~
    '\5~
    ~

    'lJ1
    ~Q

    \5R1'<t'1"~'-<.Q"Q <!I~ <J'<l'vi ~

    J'lZG'ft?J ~
    ~I<l<i', '~

    '¢l -n't-n??r ~Pl' ff. <.!l~ ~"'\'@, fil'W Wt Z'5":.l! "lb-'ll? (<Q<l''<tfw \5fif.4 \511~ <1<l~k9j'$f ~ ~Q) flijR~t<!' ~'i <P?3f "I01"l~ I) ljjt (,<i!\b <Q;q~ '1? C<i~~ ~~J[1 "Q.!Q:,~ ~'*'i
    ~, ''lC.(;i "liB',

    W<i<ij

    ~'V1

    ~'R' I

    ,"?lJ ?if! C1<JZJ"1


    \j --

    "'~G'j2i1~~ ~i<Wft-\Q% C"1i4(f. C<1Zj~-~ f.f;TI'1'-~"1~il1


    \5fQ,'<lj ~"~
    ;q)~

    ~FTI

    (,<71I(,<i> \Qj9fR-l)f9';)<{

    ;'1'¥R01<"l, \3'<t"! 1'Q,'<P <!of.Ti ~, 1"j9j\5 ~.


    'Yilt! ~ {.~

    <i1 "ITP1 ~ ~

    <!?Fi>l('<I'!Ef.i" I

    <R"1'\5D519j\5 . . ~1f?i>... I' ~


    ~

    ~[
    §I
    ;;;:-1
    r>.

    <rri9j'T~ I ~

    t>l@f.'l <!l"l'1, C9fl"iK-<i>~ ~

    'R>
    1-.6'1

    .<.£I1'? '5l~'j\?Tf9)1 ~~? <lj<i>J ~t<"j f<1;" LAO-<.Q$f <Ql\5 qf~


    '5[~

    f.i':z '\5fI'9ff.1-~-~'_:51'~~

    <i1"1'1 \5l-0m~"M>

    <fl'i<f~ "W'r"1
    <!lZ ~ 2)~<l
    ;::r'4~

    ffi~
    9)(\1(.'1) ~

    <i1<lZ ~l{ ~

    ;n:!, ~-~"lQ

    2)1i'l\!Jq;

    '1,_?l~
    ~, ~ ~,~/~

    m~;q~

    ~m~,'5)i%
    i

    <£lZ "51~1;:jr.1b''iZ>'"11

    ~9fl~j~U~11-;_~ >rj<i l~ ~
    05Tl> ~
    <Q"Q '<!1<i><l(""1~

    ~' ~ '~
    "i'1\!)J!~
    \Q~

    \3'<11 ~'iJPi{;.3lfl

    NGl
    ~,

    \5l-','i1Fl'f-.61>'
    \5lI~ 1 "TIQ,IBJ

    ~'8

    "!1?

    C'6!iJ ~'l ~

    1'1(,1l't_,

    C<rR,1<r
    <l",'~~\5B1

    ~
    \5l1~

    ~,
    ~

    ~
    'fiC?'l"11:<i> <i1<rGi

    W1V1
    : "11'"1(:11

    8I\5K<!

    W, ~ if'''ij, \5l~~ ~

    c<R'i '8Z y,,9]ft-~

    ~-;qR'l"!1!
    c'11<71(,\!) cifm

    f.k>1 B"j<l(.\!)
    <j1\Sm

    $1\!?1C"'i G'j~ '"Q:8::L0<:! ~

    'f-@ ~

    m<,~ <ntfRf
    <!<R <lR{,~ll ~

    i \5l1<l!-"1 ~

    ~, ~
    1>'<111 ~ C"i'GQ "<f~ ~~
    ~ \;:.6(.<1,

    l<rWrHl1\St~l\!J?1 "f~h-9]1~~
    t'lj>~<Q ~~

    l"flGf-

    ':;']jl'~?'

    <l1~C<.'1~ ~ ~
    \3~

    'oo~'/
    ~\5

    ~$f&~q\5l<l \51"~! J:f~


    -=<-..'

    "ifxH"'l'ifxl
    '8
    w'<1I51

    ~Gf-"1'fa,tlb~
    ~/~

    '~'R'f'~~'/'m'j''8''jj'
    '6 ~{,e3~ ~-\5J'~ ~

    \3Qj1f9l

    <fl object <rBi"

    C'<lUt-Z <ll1J
    '<i1~'

    sense datum
    ~ ~; ~~

    ~~
    ~~

    ~
    2l\5l<l

    fi:iv<'i ~

    rn

    '5lT'1B! ~
    1''<!i \511~

    <li':ztl<1
    <i1%1

    ~5fzl\!)C?jJ1

    <Wf1 <11'<<711 ~

    i~

    W~'1
    I

    ('1111 C"1j~

    1'ffl:lC11"l\5 ->1j~
    ~~,
    '"=m'

    ""!i I
    "!1 ~

    o/i'>l10-C<:l"ffi'i-mrr-Bl'

    <'h!

    =~ ~\:?r,\!)~

    ~~

    <f'M'"l \5!l7.9j ~ '\5fI'Vi -1% ~q


    ~\3
    ,~,

    <!l"f'ffl
    ~'11'R>

    JL

    .it..

    ~ !l<"i ,1

    Tt:~,"®ll

    ~~ "®1l" C9'1? q,1?i1!;'

    .,

    .q;'lI;Wf
    ~~>C~$f

    f~

    C'~C~t1·-r. d!9Br ·~er?

    ..!!-q~>8

    or'q-_ ~~'3~<1TI9fBf. :Ji~"6f-'4~lC~


    C~\!5(,$l~' (n?)~~ ~~">jr~rf,§~<p?

    r-

    ~~<

    w'i1.G1rrH

    <Q~

    ~-:1€v.J~~/~tu&hr
    -~f~h~'@t<f.O f

    .~.

    \$l~

    f~$l~ ~-c.~ ?{~'OZ"~<!t. ~~.9i1?j'~ QG1 .: ~~. ~,1?5 ~~f ->-}~6n\5 -:~,n\§"fR'<?'~;n'Fl'S
    ~(~~(~ ciJ ;~~')~-

    Ji1fhc.~ 1 ::eJ~'
    :, psyche-0l'

    ?'ffj
    ,/'

    '7~W111MK~~i>U<f!>{' ~"'~1~<p'-f1IOOR~il

    C-;li~ ~
    J

    ~~-rq f~frJ$;~~~\!l

    7ft~ ,~:~,&t~
    (~~

    ->r~r~M~·t~ Dl~K7i ~1\5K1·Uf~ I


    ~~~
    .

    ~crJ~h!

    ~.

    ~1:ft~?

    ,~;n*"'4{fl,S. ~. internalized 111t9f'(Jl?

    4G11it 'JfI~ {~l)-i5~


    ·~tw{

    ~~~

    .......

    ·=9Jll1J9G1;.Q¢I(;.
    -

    <>-.,

    .~.

    f~(~.~

    •.

    society

    'fif <r-~?_.~' f1«3:In:F{~ ~ 9Jwi o·a",<i'~ -';f\! \!if@{ '5fl~4' '~' 4l~ -"17ig_____;~· ""l ,.' V"'ll','-"' :,;--,~~~ ,f}?l' oli7'""'~ ~:nt_~,:-:ffi~ ~ . \.. •. Z ·..... ,iI". ,'Ci:stm'K.Qt~2, ----.c9j~;;>! ~ ... I ~(];7, .... "'U '?W:f{ ''-''LV~,,{) ~-;<: ;II....':'-IW "V'l ·,,-,,!"I'n:;,.~ ~."""·T"i
    ~"'P ~~

    r.pi,~~

    9.0"Ji.,z ~,~

    ·psli-;~~

    -;rn 0 II

    [l]ingoUIstks becomes a social science when weface the faor that speaker S of alangua~e L has in 'S~Sbrain'constructed-as-a-mind not only J -'an internaJ representaextemal representation, -",;fiich-enli){)\j,-

    <? t.~r{

    seni'Ste-datum~~~

    fil~~ ~

    I!i~. cil<p f,niG111

    ¥4~t~ <tS~

    tion ofL

    that enables S to use L~ hut also something

    <!S~ ~~1~~ ~. ~t.~


    (~t\tl

    '~t~

    ~:~(C'1

    tQ&t~ ,~

    ~,

    1fl~

    amouraing to E~~ L as represented

    ~~15'1ffl9f .

    9.ftc.'i11· I

    iesS's awareoess of~the community's joint possession .of

    In t My. 1988 paper proposes that for

    \5f!fit 'b11f4 31'4!'6N3~ ~G~ ~ C<i ~1l~~' ~G1~ ~ '4'Qij <;f-~:m. ~~·~n ~H4~~ \;MXl1 ~-it"lfol "I>if1';;Iii1<11:crJllJ~'5!<r ~ ~

    .;r-\

    Qi~1'J

    C'1@3'M<:fS:A b(

    m-m ~,~ :9ll~~~'~

    ~m ~ ~
    5f~~

    ~~. ~

    .~~~ ~, .,'frJ t'l~m -

    .d-/
    (l

    format reasons. S cannot consauct Of store a. viable 'soci. . "_ ety function' .capable:. of mapping l onto an il:nagin;eQ set of paral lel l-representanons; non-formal ii:llag~ of course tmhodyfng (Dasgupta;
    ~1lI~,
    ~\&

    .and that instead .S allows a

    4, an external representation of ·dis~

    l [51' Wi
    '\5f~

    ~~.CJ)~. '?j["@i

    MC'1~(M~l <ri specilaizatien-

    L) to' serveE, ~Thu5E. is U~esite where _5'1)

    '<fl~ <m9j'1~ \5ffi:rf~, ,~!


    \5f~$l~~.

    ~7;~~~,m

    >9.~

    ~C?lr*,tP1.~). \5l~~~}~

    -a psycho-socially veal image of L is posited and imagined."


    199J: G'1['lbl~V'r ~~&:~ ,'tZ~- ~~fr
    ~~FPrn~

    ~11, L~\§M~;1tiJ:si ~~. c<l' 4f!~' ~~~'e't9i ~7A" C>j~;n~Vf ~9jR~i1";srnM(;({r<i~§t ~~1~ "5f@ \.srq)$-Cf;{·~ ~ '~~1 ~~C:\!) -9]'tt:~. -;:rr~
    ~~r;l

    -:zc.~.~ '3i~-~C~
    •

    \b~~(;$S

    ~~~I

    ~11t~
    7iTi?
    1•

    ~~'i ~~C\!)'q)1:5R 'i1ll 'w{l:~.~ ~,~<3~f; ~C'{~~ ~:'1f1 ~,IM~Ml~!1f ~'<ptH.~ C\!)~ ~~C~. Ct)Z:fl~t'l7j~- : ~(.~~ ~t 't:;r@Jf4?? ~<n. i ~~9 (~1?rR>~) ~ ~c.'5f ~<P1f QJ1<?61 '!>ffi I ui111xs f~ \!It<J '~1Jf \£:2J'~
    .\P1W~':ijf&l~~J~1!9 'W~C'$1~
    :~U~~5j

    1'fC~,

    ~9l;1 ~t~·~~ l'ir;:tiR\5l~~c-5l ~


    ~lu:";O"'A .., ~ ~ ~.\.,~
    -~""'I

    C4"i~:' .
    t!l'~
    ';:;:I~'O

    -e'C6 ~-:>i~~1Gf·~9j'fi11 ,~ ,

    -m:,9j: tQ,$.1)'!

    ~~*~ • '<iP4tJl
    \'5IlD''$l'~~

    21~.~

    P4·~~_x,~I·~,""~~
    .;. - ~ -" ~"
    I ".

    \5lRS.,,~~rrvi
    '''8 ~1§;'.~ '~', G'JI
    ,,..~

    N~\~
    ,,,-.,,'

    i=-

    -~"""'4"">i,,-fr''i-'--\)t tQ~~.

    \51~C~'

    ,~m··.·,
    ~~9
    D'iif~
    -:pQ:,tm
    ~.......

    . ._,..,._~

    G1i
    I

    'S1C~ I'

    ~''l..~~J~ l/l~
    <}(ji1

    '--..

    x(~k'1~ (organism ~ ',0) J

    c:r4i ~(~ ~~
    ':')1.<t· ~~

    rql\.. ~''''-j.

    ~Kt {,..,q""l: 1 -~i"i


    ..--, .

    C<1eg'i~I~"1S ~~11~-&rnt1"~'1t~at I
    ,,,--,

    ,co·

    ."'.

    ...___

    ~
    ~J~.
    G:

    ¥~Cf\5~.
    ~

    m
    D---J:l"

    P'l~'1' b::.?it ~(~f

    C*GE (CQgn·iti·v.e
    ~

    Domain ~. D) t
    (£I. \!I~

    (Learning
    (<1~-l~

    Theo-ry ~ L T) Q;~ {O, q)!

    ~~

    ~'~.t~Q·
    ,~

    ~htC:~~'\')Jlf.<lf-~'5j.Sij dl~'
    f,~. ~'

    ~f.ijj I ~~~t:~{?j

    ~~'>i<J >i~Pfn~CG11t~'Of11~ ~51'$(,Sl(.Gfj?1 JiiiPi)t i

    "ff1~ n~'~ input (OR~


    D
    \Q~'
    ··''''''~I'''~''_;;:'...J 'V! ..... ~~¥'~~~1

    m-m

    \~~'-u.'8<J

    vr~9)
    r--

    ~~

    ~~\ ~~i~

    <;p'i1i <n1! \5i'{JS!


    r....

    !~b

    .t=:A,:

    >i~JiH~

    <p~n <QCG1·t~i~~G~

    COlt 61 ~

    Pt?6% out pur:


    ,Ji'l1=9H ~.

    '~,~Grj~

    ft;~'il ~~

    ~tA [_.~.~
    ~

    -o~ <!M ~t¥ ~


    \~H ~~'€.

    {r-O ~, ~~
    LT -(H, L) i
    -:i'l~ ..~.::.I ;.~~\
    ,(J~ "-!;~

    ~~M
    ~~

    \5f<ri' (1,) -~\!)1<:('0


    H
    ~t*-.\+"""'i-\:..JI (}.-~~.•• !I!~

    ·!4~3i~Rf.f~f ~~Sl ,~t4

    () ~{r~) C~t'i)rnypPi1l;n"4<Pi\8I(,,?~$i~.

    viGl ~
    "'n!

    >.;;.I·I'·-.lI'$l)

    di 'we must .nscover

    lffi>lUi€-t>P,P'{fr! ~

    ~~~f;H~ ~'5t~~~ ~~-. -t?1\&:i ~t~G4 <t YC~J(,~'iil' ;;-(;p-nl t7~l%.'H


    \50
    I

    ~r lTI1?,~~"\P~1 "Q~1·<_'tW~. ~~'1

    71051

    1::...." the rnsntunonat

    d 1 l' an·' omer iactors

    ! t1a{-

    bliOC.~ k
    '{j~

    ~~ ~.

    .. \;~~ ~ .•

    J->l j:P'fH-

    ~1:>i1c:s

    ~'R: ~~ro-,~~'1If'~_ ~
    .~~

    'Sl

    ~1~ H
    i\3l~;:;~t~"

    ins~gi:1tand. ~l;l.flders.tanding in crucial areas ofonr


    are effective." (ChOI:11S-,J)..')',

    lives and ask why they

    >i};;~-:>'I~~tb-~QAl~~m®ml\h~iR 6~-ldr?H-~~Slt
    f«i?l~q

    ,~t31.

    1986~ xxvii)'

    q;SiC\5"i''q( ~16s~

    ~t~ I '1}~\!)

    H_ ~~<p

    I r <IT Sli!

    \_.HU.

    q~",' p'

    .;~~~~J .. ~

    ..&~,.,. ... r

    ~H

    ~'1211L~\5fi14m
    \5J~~

    s.t~>;[~rnct·:

    LT (SH~, l)'1 ·L;.

    rQ{.~.$t;jJ ?BJ(.\!)i ':qf Of<fl


    .

    Pluralistic

    Methodology) tp'!zl~rt<f3
    ~~1,'"\1 ~ "-"I

    I ~t~(\Q

    ~qre
    ~
    ~

    ~Q,~'

    '6.i~@3\!)1~ ~<i4Ci
    ~~<JS ~ ~~:

    \!tfX}5J

    ~~ ~i%-<;p~

    L ~.'

    <n f$··;n9f.;f~~· ~
    (~
    ~()!)j~f1e31c-;«pe

    .~~

    ~9:j_~

    R~'~" ,~d}t-01~$1 '~~<f~~" .~ b1~~1H ~~r-r "'1$11'8~~1~~ \5fq;mf\bQ

    '>r~4f~(·~.iMTUl 9fl~ ,~~~.

    .orsm

    t~rn,~

    'a<eFb~~~~j'~$i'
    ~';ff~:.

    :/

    >rc5'l

    \!)t~~'1~i-2ii%":"{?G1~t

    f)G"JG<r I
    \!)~,

    ~f%('<H~
    '~

    ~9j<p(,~'!:l

    ~
    Vi~mSf
    ;:rt I ''11

    '~c.~;~'
    ~~~

    ~?pr~~!i:~' '~~
    '~~MVilj$f

    C~l~liBrl ~1.C2J
    ):ff)~7..::i ' ,I " • I
    !

    ~~'

    ~.'<tr ';rf'fflt?!

    b'G1C:\5'~(:~~,\51-::1 '~~t~PitJcf'S)'<r~~,<?C:W"3 <P-:1C"",~~:q) ...

    ~ t.:"'l~~ ~ ~~l":l

    "Linguistics
    familiarJesson

    would perhaps profit by taking to heart

    a.
    ~

    l))1;@.U

    \!l'\~

    T/Jfi1Jl(};ll,<n
    !?91.' D/

    D/ C*(~ :!i81j'G1J lfi9&!~ \s51.q€irCllill


    15~~
    ~i<pj~~

    ?JM~f~
    ~l~t

    <ul4ff
    ~

    of the natural .sciences. Apparent counter phenomena should be, carefully

    1 ~'Xf~t'

    Cli5Jlro ~

    '~

    ~tG~~'

    example's and unexplained

    'ij5:ij~rn ~<fiSt41,~ <Ul<p$l''rM¥t9'4"flCG 9j~{~~jCto1~ (F)


    ~(}if-t~ 6fm-~~

    'DiSJ T./I T/-'?f J9t5f

    ~fii'!)
    ~
    ~
    M~:si

    lfZm
    1~

    nosed, but it is often rational to put them aside pending ;):({


    ~o~ -, '1i1~

    FwfI{3,'
    ~'

    9jf"8,m
    (M) m

    <rrn

    ~'1l1~

    further !study when principles of a certain degree of exp lanatory adequacy hare at stake." (')'~ovO ~t\!'i' ~ eJ~1F?D<q5 ~~ ~K~ .,' ~"*

    ~~'~C\!) '9fii@ I \£l~'


    ~~C" '~' F
    1

    M..-p>t~~>i"*,t?Jl
    (£j~

    T/ ~~
    ~.~
    Boti-'

    r'1('~i~~~(,<F \5W;)f$1t ~
    A~

    ,~f~t~ ~<f'~
    ~~
    ~

    . ~\J;·~t:?Ji9" $lOi':1'

    F1~\4l tgqt~9?
    ,.....,

    ;n~ ~Hflr,' ;~ <il~r.".l'!l?


    ~
    ~?f5ij1,

    r.m;~ ~ii~, <.Q~Vi ~9f9f1tU, <fm'91fG t5:'1Ht~.~ ~,~,


    C"~(~ ~

    m '.tum."" ~"'l.d ~", ~


    ~~~\!l
    tQ. •.

    til '

    " ".~~~",
    .,

    -, ~

    '1,'

    ~'9j~C$bl,

    :tc.q orr I
    ,

    ~Gf!

    ,',

    "

    ei~419 ~

    'w!
    ~.

    (c!l~ ~~ 9t~('1~'1 6Gir\5 Pj~ ~ ~ VI:!)! ~~~ ..;;\... t'/. ~ '~C\.!)l !'= rwT:-t ·:2.fZ"'j(.;---..n"lj ~ ~
    ~-1-1i'1~Pi
    . cY'

    \§;li G\!;!' 9ij ' ."

    I)

    ~\!)~,<r '~
    I17:;;r-

    ~~
    T/~a::;;r~~,c;(

    \51-;qJ~tt&Z
    II'"l"ru'!l

    I\'~

    ~";;!"

    \!)i~~

    k.·~ , ~':-.\ "1'".i~

    -=<1t~:<P="i

    f,{}-"'" ~=~ I

    b~~?4 '11:[;; error

    ~Sn "Jil@1
    ~~

    ".,'

    , ~(\!l ~j,@~

    ?JJ~IU

    ~'Rt~

    "'r 1= L

    11 ~

    I
    (H,. L)] i.Q~

    'r

    C~~J! M.~

    ~~"i~'9jF8~ ~'~t<f I F C~~~"·:WH!tm,

    'lR~.
    <e(p'j

    ·~tf\bfu"P'6t"i?ltvi

    ~~ .. "- -.A/

    ~1.lfbJip-!)"
    ~
    l '-;,

    11414~L f{G1(k

    &111~~"~ ~."'P.r"c~~~,*(~~ ~ ~I;"~, ~T!(j~<p ~'9f9"j1~Jire'$lC?'?1.~ I ~:...R,*,~


    '(J.fi1'

    '5fH!\!)' (GlobaJ)f.1,¥%i\g~l:e_<;1''1 \J;~i:z~'i ~9j·.9n'1J(.<i5 ~<.; ~~C:~ ~I':B,


    ~!
    ~

    'f4>~
    ( 'C;~"

    J'l"'rt<S;1 f;!ijl),~ ';11<>1 C'l"ltt:O! ~


    <1G'li(;\!)
    ',~,

    "'IB!f.i J '<!l~'W -(~

    ,,+I,'~

    "il~

    '

    <iG1I,

    "

    ~~

    ."t

    ~.

    ~J1L~

    tm) ~'~ :z\!)J~,:-';'-l '~I\!?J~~19

    perfontlance
    9.

    ;n '~ ,l;)i:n~~fi~Wf <fi

    ~'Wf(<t~~ ~
    ~":~~

    ~~

    ~:$~l®1t1~~~

    :~~,~

    '6l1?i1it;:;j'

    ~ ~ EL

    )=FPi~~~
    :;rI.!

    :{1~1~,'\51' (~Tlq,~ ,s!~~J.Uf.


    .:"\1",<'
    ,"

    m-eFilo;f\!)~ \51~rit~

    f~
    ~

    F¥~, \51
    ~',

    , - ~~-\£~~!z~'~'G{,(7jk.~:G1f ~
    0'Rt'f

    m~

    ~'il§f(~ Cb(;G'J
    ~:.(jiH(l$

    C14? C<rp1'~

    '<~'>~';~~. ~
    '.?

    {$lM~ ~~~~6'~1~\5ff~

    Y' ,
    ,

    .r ~"?i
    ~~
    .

    performance

    f1t~t~1' H'<P~ t\!)f~, <PC~ IV1~~


    '~Br~'~M~~
    ~'Ib ~

    ~JG ~~-\51b~

    '«fi~ C'1t:;'Q ..;' /' ~"?f ~C~ iompeten ce '<fi IL f~'\5i9f I, ~~


    ~~l
    L'T \!il~ ~, (SH" F" ~

    r!l<f~

    't, t ~

    L) G4''1G1~1~ ,QJ

    F (~
    @'{3~

    ~'~J)->Q'~ ~
    ~'

    '14Bi'Q, "( ~
    1~

    'm-<l1'64~1tr

    "1t~ ~

    ~ wmn ~-~~q,
    ",',

    ~q1~~
    \~i\8'N{,'f$t
    ;-;-.

    ~~~'\!)
    ':' ~5fi
    ,,-

    <m:<r ~
    '~~?J1~){}f.,

    ~Bf
    \5I~QtI

    (/'-¥{.~~

    ~~R<qS

    ~~

    <i~'~?J
    "

    ~"<f ~~k1'~ 41~~S1 (<n'f.J~~)

    'Olc;t>11f3f

    '1-' ~~~fit?J

    <p~~1041

    c~"q;,t~~ ~?tqm'U?-i 2Ji1~fi!~ '1l)ilC<p


    ~?i?jIZ~J?1' ~'~~
    '<ll)~i' ~-~

    mi:t~

    ~~~I

    '~9jl;~'\!}', ~q
    L.!1~

    ~iii'13If7l~\!irr?r

    ......

    :>t.fBi:t1 ~
    '~Jf(3-1

    %t<p:?r'1 :( Unl versal


    ~
    <I~'

    G rammar ) ~
    1

    Rm'l<p:~{J:5 19f~
    6tft1 ~
    ~~'

    }t'eBI ~~~
    ~V1

    ,'.~ ':{(;'01~I

    ~~ r'
    '91~~~~\~im
    i@9r-q'(}1)~

    \!Fi~(p'l eJ~'

    \g,bC\!i ~~
    ,

    C:.5j

    ?~J~h:~ ·~~~-i2\;""~dlr='!t-=~,q \5fjJ1tct


    1\51~(.0

    ~w~~

    fi1;~ ~'t;'"j ~1?:l ,~ .


    ~<r~~

    ~
    ~(~

    Pi~tt\!)t <rt ~"i~t <U


    ~ ~'

    @C1l<f ,~~

    (»~;~ (<:l~

    ~~i!-QI bricoleur-elf ~~-"0/8mt~l-~~l~


    '{3~

    '~

    \!.)'~~'
    ~'1JF&c;1

    :!tlf\b~<:f;..·[)m ':>JiB 'i~G1\!),m

    ~1;r:w~€1
    ~

    j\;,~1il
    ~

    I '~

    ~"~i{O<,p'~ltYj

    ~'i(.~

    'i5'9f9flTff-'~~9' T31'~1C\@<i~ Gf~-~t'it


    Qb'~14{~~, ~~ ~~~

    <n' 'l!(iilMf~'
    ~~~?i('~

    1J~Cft~\~fH"Yf

    ml
    ~

    ~i1tGifrk,
    ~~@

    1!P'fi1l.~WF?H .9f1' ~'~r~


    Q1~'8,~~1""1 1

    ~~

    ~,

    )lQj~1U t'1~ '¢~t ~~ ";ft'l '~Fprm:G'~j~,t:\5Pl a~q '~ ~


    "-'~~l'q

    ~G"11~~~ '~ ,~9jrrn~Fr~'C'~~'1il:c$1~


    C~I~;H~l J4lW1c:~t ~C<l
    (.~

    ~'~ ef·~.1

    \li)i911Ff ~
    1)1~i<11 ~
    ~~'

    ~f~-;1

    ~~tGrt~m~~L1\G @~?~~$l
    <U Plurimethod-srs

    Di~~~ 'F\~19f

    ~t/'irsr cD.'i&r
    '-q(~C~~ ':

    ~~br;(f\5 ~'iJ-j~~

    f'hf~~
    (~~

    ~t<V f~(.'~\5f1)j'$ll ttft~9.l~

    ~'\~itC"'191xp,9f~f\b

    ~l

    ;v-ni-ff>t

    9'tl~""l«

    _'

    ~QJ ~~

    .,1"':7

    ~.

    r-. 't:QVil:~(?lL&:~~ '\51 ~r;r

    l-iJ,q· '0!!(~

    4~(.'¢
    ••

    911BH:l'l @M '~~B

    '2J(:Q~, ~

    ;~Rt,&1.~.
    C~j,
    ''--'

    c~
    F

    "5ftz?l
    y

    ~'~~(J;,

    -!

    [)?!~ /~~rn
    "...

    'isH~'?f1 C~
    ~~ .,...........

    ~~
    .'

    ~
    (;<fi"~~i.,

    Xj~-:2fl~C~?l \!l<:<f
    .

    CQ{¢<p,. ~

    ~~~li1

    ~'9f,

    M€6ic~·?r ~
    '8.0.

    C~

    f5~f¥?1 ~C~·~ ~

    Fr~GJ..~<;Zi~r>.5 .~.~
    ~
    ,,-.-

    ~',>\1'~,~ 2!t-I''!J.; ~

    ";flf'JJ<i51 ·~f~c~~jl'~u$~
    ~1;q<A q,~
    < '. ~

    ~'1ffit?j-1
    ,., .. '

    .qf~.f~~ C~ • ,~ ~ <P~C\!l 9jT~~ ;u'-~,!'rS~-ire:~~. '1~ ! _~'fil:~n:.r~:~;q'~1


    . ~ .;r...

    rn i

    .srm ~~
    ~ " ,

    ~~-~1ri1t\bt
    ~<f~'~~
    .

    "0iw\!)ffl\£($l'if~
    ....., -

    _'-.

    ~.~ \bJ<l¥f;;;iJ:::_ ~,~

    '<P!<t!

    ~'-c~vr
    ~~(\5)

    t/i\$, ~f~~
    ~~~~(.~<Q'

    ~G1

    ~,

    "Ms?'<f\'

    "q7.?-M

    <{Vi' ~~.~ G<?!""c;;il =9~<l


    ~ ~

    ~]~-:;j.

    R-~,@ \1t1~r~G~~ t"f&C!i I


    :~~(9iPlJi!'
    2fl'\~-1.!i~
    ~

    t~@t~ff>l>j .~1
    t~f.G~fij \5i)~

    ~~c~ 9flB1 Jil~ UI~,.q~'f t~C~Q141


    ~~,--,__ :>41~t'~K; 1'!i11"f'i\8, ~l71:

    fJ~

    ccn.~
    '""Jt1lt(71=:,'.....,~· ......

    ~MC<:\1') <Ji1~ ·~U


    \t):~~

    ~,~

    ~~P.tCl;1Gfft ·11' ~~~C:iEl

    ~~.
    D~P~~l
    Uif:{,

    (.!i~ (~ru~O.
    \?!)tf4

    C'JfRf"<-C<t~

    (em' + i,Q~c:-n) ;~('5l'{3

    '-;n
    \~Th.GI

    ~<)5'
    ... -;-

    -J...Sl~" ;n<J-1<ql.tt·r~01·
    ..:0:..

    '<l'~1-~'StC~

    .Il)if~,

    C<l.Sl(;q·<!R4$) ~'r1~filt3{"ifll

    \511:3 '<.~~ ~ ~~nm5{'

    ~'1·~cf
    fiqsz~~~: :~R~j$i

    ~.t4}k~: (~
    lt{·ro ;
    ~
    ~J

    CY.fi;r~f.'1·'i1, ,o;pOfr--4.qrfhl ~
    <1t~ (''''')2" 9M
    ~ofC~·~

    mq ~ ~.11J
    .~

    Jflf~o.l

    ~CG'iI1)~rn!
    ~~ ~(JI~

    ~1,5l ~(.<l;.q:~;;tl;r ~

    \!)\G -~
    ~
    ~

    ·~fzt~1\5lJ~-lQ"?!
    • •

    GYf\!)4"*('~'?J"
    <C'-.".

    ijjz_,

    .¥ti)~'; .t;@ ~,' ~~


    $fi~

    ~ijl: .oq'r:.'1R.\9\t3
    ;:rj' I '~9j

    !01.I<P~~~

    ~'Qij

    W~

    :m.~

    C~lfTI\Q~i

    tb~'C})~.

    ~ICn$l
    fqR~' .~~~
    ~

    ? ,"5fi'11yt.F~.

    f~<2i~ir

    1519)1 :"'1\G1I9l, ~41~ iD"'l)f% ~,@ ~


    .

    ~~t;(
    '~~fh:P1\Sr3'f

    we'!)·~ '~~~11m
    ~~~,1
    '31~

    "'f1

    well-formed sentences l ~
    ~'11 Qiis C~l~'
    .;::-.,.

    .';~rWFf\ "~~}~:,
    ~"-b~~~1f"
    ~..--....__

    ~)~~~',,;;g:f .

    ··zm:f 0tf l W~ 0 <Jl~~ ~~ Ci5i r.;0r~. ~6i(.~~ C~ ~; (;>It,t


    . . .

    Q..c.~c 7!f~! ~~.::p?l(t;ij

    ~tt<i)
    ~\f8

    t_Q~ ~-~.G1-<n'Si(14
    ~

    Si
    7p:~Ji f.41C?f

    (essence)PhfI'9 I
    q~1'0
    G,'

    rEl'<ji5·1' ~~:n~;\;!)1
    (J®1~ <FQ{1'

    :'~.'

    use-value,

    W)zqt ..'~

    ~Flr<rC~l'~

    bG1t~

    ~5f

    \"5'~'

    (~'~l~t'1bJ ~?R\!)

    RSr_ r

    0;- ·~~1-~'

    .~

    jjj1~\sii1' ~'"11Rft

    ~
    rei

    .~~1ij~ ~~
    ....., ." ~.

    ~~J1i~~-Imt:91

    C;n~·:H~X.'1~flfS:?r '~;.~
    :'l~-::l

    ~
    ".,;:.j

    .~
    ~ctij

    ~w ~
    .

    ·:~fZi~ '9~ b0c~ . ·V., " ~UJi0~.5TIS1 \5niit ~ \ f~?1~ ,~


    ,~~
    ...._._,

    q..y]

    ·r

    "il3(~~

    ~r,;~'4-~,-~
    ~\$'

    '''1~~q:' (greetin,gs-business,-fareweH)-tQsr

    ·~m I

    "lF~

    I...J;""'-.!l~ ..

    C)~"i'
    -~.-

    il
    -:

    -~~7if
    .l.9\3
    ~.

    '6!\tl-"'l~
    '--

    ~.

    q-;':i)r,.\5 ·%?I ~~.~ ..-..


    j

    ~ "'<:.~,V-~ 'I' ....

    ~~%1J1J ~
    ~.

    Gl«i '~(!i '~(;'"j=911~:


    ~.~\St.i{

    ~~.

    ~~~
    '4)~

    ~
    JN~~

    ~~~t)S-4
    (Vt~ ~
    ~

    Jff:1l~ '?i7219~1-<F·'2m ~ ~r-{ ~~ ~,iU. ~QsJ <p'Sm MH~'~ ~ ~V[r;:r ..jj:r~f<f.G'T?r "4MI~1U1 c~St ~C~ (~~
    ~
    ~I

    t3~:OR~rc?j!
    ~"-{l~

    %1..<:J C~ ~ \!fi :00 9ftq1?r'8f~TY


    '<iGGi~ \5D~ ~} ~
    <lGj('~4;, ~~

    ~.

    .0bt v~1vH ~~~1~1'':-{


    ~ I d4'l
    ~'~(at

    ~{$l

    dl"W1). and ~~

    ·q.~l 1i'tt~m
    ~~ ~
    .'

    C<j:'if'l

    ~!.

    ~V1'. \5fB{ ~<f16r4~


    I .

    {~~~~ .~~ '8CZ


    ~1lr<;;~~ qJ"P1ti ~~ ZC~
    ~5j{;~"
    ..--...

    '?feu

    <.;tlf[, ~'\§;G1CL;

    @~W 7:fP.GmiJ1
    \5il~

    (41(.~1?' <piQfii;r

    \n~~? -;qft). ~.~~ ~1


    ~Q'
    , r">

    fq'G"J;~ "S:f<1f.ij)~!. \5ft-;;;n~ ~~ .~2f-tir ~


    c..... ,..,...,:;;:...

    Jft~. ~i:_411-~
    ~.Qtt I

    .a,. rime

    perciptable

    ~1 {.Tfl{Jm·~:>i~~.'.~"'i

    ~'~~$SW1, '5f1t~ CPr~ 91"3' (}1~ ~.


    <1(Q)
    ~~04~,t;<~'~

    imperciptable'
    ~

    l :;rrr.l!!1i7!1Q'f .: DJic~t~~?H.~1 r~C:~I~Gj'Wi


    r.~I'I6'!

    c~~~ ~<p,Q!t":?lRb-iJrSli5r
    <n\§ ~\3,*9~:;;"

    lil':~;frc~~. 9f9J$li\br~"'?lrn~~'
    ;,qPi

    '?j1\fit<l~ I ~

    ~(?5J'

    ~it~<P~

    (JB131 ~U~Tsr
    ~~t5f.

    ...qm ~~?t,.Gfi~\$~~~1t ~ y'~'<{ ~fp:r~~ 'C~. I ~«r ~~1 ~<F-t1~8c~ :;z~~ ~(~G<.$~ "y!C5t>i~G11?j '"51~
    ~ ~

    \~mfilit;~l>jIl(.lf:f~, {~4t5.i
    C:?!'~·~

    \5Tf1fr~0~1

    i@:~~.

    <f'~'iP. 9'<Jl~·

    'Bf~~

    9~r

    dl~li~nll CJ4G1 ms(~


    C1~i-:;;rr-G1~ OM! ~,
    _

    9f® I M~~~
    o.!1~'1>li
    <P1~,
    t~Gi~\:!)

    ~ft'''-\.>'!;; ~
    \'<u1'Y)1-~t;1 ~

    J1\~'9'1

    ;r.mt9fib ~
    I ~~V1 ~. ~

    ;n~lf'

    0'i"'l1
    ~Fl,

    ;Z~. \5@l;;

    <>tft<l o£DI
    :;qf~.e( C~~~ internalize-

    ef'n/

    ~~~";{ir~I>;Phf

    'if~[~)j~~~ q1~ '{]~ ~~ l


    >;??{.

    ~t~4,
    ~'!

    ;i5rt~

    -"1'icii

    fi1'~'~~~
    01 '~1<n~
    ~

    >t~1: ~.

    "OJl<iiRB,,<i) at a tirrie true and unreal [ 01

    '1G1(.~'~

    ~~CG11

    (~'\fTI

    ~(.~ ~~,

    ~tr4

    9('?l f~C?i.fJi)," ci:I~'>l~J;


    ~ . r·...

    ~~~'4), D.~f~Q

    ~!~C~ ;n, Q1\~r01r t~~G?1~


    8J 1J19tl~'tt

    fi1E;~

    lion~

    '~tL<
    .

    ~(.<p~

    ~\!)'~ -<

    ~\5fI~r.'C~\3" ''£~jlW
    ;&(

    1tc~ ~

    i ~~~~(i1$j

    (.<p~~1 3f'iW

    <p~t~·
    ~'i"'~

    ~~
    -..'_'

    \h;&jGu. <Ji:<r 1G1 ~?


    . ,', "

    \5'1 t£GjQ;' <n1r!


    ~~~
    r-.o, ~
    =rt ~

    '~~MC?:!

    ~~.~~
    ~

    <i?~1~..: ~<nqs.,.
    '~tf[
    ~'~7l7;'

    Oi ..s9 (.'ip15ttU'i '8':?lf-r"1' \f3_.z '0j\f)~,


    \b~{.t;.
    '_"

    '5i.~C$k:~ ~:<P
    ~i~jl(,"i

    v.lq$j

    \8\)1'

    (,9j~

    3:11fit"'l'~Hr.j~~\-e!-".~J)!)j~

    "&.--,

    "

    '<f:\?<l"'-cQ <!i~. ~ 'Vl:UZ"l?',

    fii~ I

    ~<>l~

    \'il1'<lTR
    phatic C9f"1 ~

    ~i?,u""!)~ ~<1i
    ()Wfi~!%;

    c<i <f.Q_f'( ~ "l"1C<l"'i ~V1t<:j d;q ~1l8l

    \5'i<f

    'l>1'Z"PiP.<m:<? ~~
    Q:r;r;:l ~

    '~L ~', .~

    \5Tlw.'.,.1.!l~:>j<'l C"9r.n-~

    cO:~ie:
    ~"U
    .' I I If"'I-~) I \5Tl~

    "Jf\5J 1tJJ, ~

    ~~

    I \5f!~

    'JjZ<lTI~
    <Q~ ~

    "f1~

    \5Tl~4'Ft' 1519fl'i5i'A
    I '6I<1J'e

    (f)V7i M(;kl

    :"iC'Oli'67'1+'6IMm'e

    ($:I

    MCb?I:!
    ~~

    C~t<i' <m!
    'cq..~'i
    ~ \'if@

    ~1 We,,!, ~
    ~rC~<>l ?', ~ ~ftf?f9lO1
    <l$ll1<i

    ~:fL>1 c-~
    ~l:jJ

    M~

    ~1"1~11

    <Q~?i' <!!~ \5fI'1T"iM'

    ($:I '5f@

    <rfiT

    ''E'iJ'
    "ft,
    ~

    (value)

    '1'R ~ ~9f1\5 ~, <m"'li~ I </Wi "l]'\& ~


    ~

    \!llz!."1 <i1 c<!@ffi '31 Z"I


    ~' ~

    f9fV:!
    1

    ft;{,~ ~
    I
    <Q~ ~

    <.jj~

    ';f'"fl1

    I Cl'f~G'fIT.~ ~ '~)~ ~~

    <mUI

    <:fi9fN' C~
    ~

    ~~-~~
    = ~~,

    Ci511 '<Jl1l 'UWlL?l, ~ \5'<1'<1 ~~t'1' 1'lfik<1'1 ~ I oil"!' ~ ;.Q~ I


    'f.@ (~>~

    'tM>n ~

    1J<f"'I ~ \5'>R8-

    ;:n <'1''<Ji-<w!t1

    '<l1\5-\:>j~r\5,

    r.;1h:/'ii~ $1t.w'Gri I \3"f<'j T\.. <rn, 't-R'iRD I '5'i<n-~,


    ~~ '5fP:nm :q;~ <Q(.<7]~ ~
    ~ Q5i,

    fl ~"'i<f~~
    <Q~

    ~f¥nl

    (QlGIRr-ler'5ii)-c<f'

    ¥~
    '~'

    Hrn '1,~-'5!1f.! CiTi?l


    <m"il
    c!l~

    c<M1 .. ,_

    i51<n-~,
    f.rn3l"! ~
    <Q'f-8

    '51<f1-~~
    ;F~?lqIM ~ ~011 "l'<@l1F81

    civilr-ized)

    ~, ®-'5ffu ~
    <r0 ('Jj1"1C~C"I,

    '<Ii'C'f' "1-.;( ~
    ~<1}

    '5Wl <rr19frnt1
    S1{,\!l1 <rrI"lU,

    I <Q"f<'j ~

    ov.<R ;:n
    Ij

    erIGt;'j'rIG"1 f~r?r~
    ~H~"1\!i<i -.v.<1} ~

    (om( <ltG'R

    'miC?I1fM~')

    G~n';i<1'

    \5V;j ~,

    ~'ifC\5. Gl \5fIn
    'f.qrn

    "'l~~1
    ~

    ~
    ~~

    \5fliil ~q'j ~

    \5Bl ~ '5T@l ~ 0f~i;;pl,\3V§ :q.~ <J~


    q.~(;G'fj\3

    M(,~f?i: Encnatic
    <Q~ >SV§

    'm'?i ~1l ~'<Ii<f


    <l~-<l<J>

    language; .~~ \5~

    ox;?f ~
    1

    C<Jij

    ~
    'f.@

    ~"i\5il~
    ~VJ!.~

    Yormal)
    ~
    ~, ~? 2!~ ~

    '-"1<il\!lC'{}?I Jllfl:jJ
    \3?J~

    %' ~
    I
    \3~

    m"! ~-~?flfS~
    ~
    ~ ~

    f?rc:3

    ~
    FlU!

    GJPJ"iVJ ~
    "lVl~ "It''U

    '1f~ ~
    ::R
    (}fl:I

    ~,
    1J'ffi, ~

    <Q~

    f.k"l
    ~

    <rfiT \5fP:n'?i ~t1 ~fi"lR> ~

    :)'j<:C'ffi:"'l~
    ~

    ~I
    Jtl

    c;G.! I ~

    f%1'<li,'J\i ,

    ~,?G

    '<Jlm, \5lZI11 ~ "ffil TI ~

    c<rr
    "'l~

    'f1\3 I 'TiQ,tTI!~
    I '3lw,

    "iTG11?JJl'Ji I ;.Q~

    ~Bl-<Rfl-~
    c~\~)~

    ~
    ~'<Jl-~\3m
    l)Ji~ ~ ..fi~ ~~~~?

    ~
    '5fl~

    9l'fu!jl;~ ~
    ~ 'f'~<i>, "1'i"iC<J>

    I "iTG1'<JWj<Q1J
    ~I ~ ~

    "Q;fS<llb"t' 11\51 'f.i-GJ


    -C1~

    \5TlUl:.I <!!~ ~~

    2!i'i3vnfj'j'31?! ~ ~

    ~Wr,
    C'<i~

    r:<:><n1<lDl<f ~'ifC\5 <mJ, \5fl~


    ~

    "q@j'
    ~ Gl'il

    c<f' C'1'1Q)TIl ~

    :<'''1 C\5'f \5fP:n'?i ~? ~-~


    i '!51';';;ffi1

    --

    ~1

    \3

    1.Gi"l~

    <JfiT
    <Q1J

    (,S1C~ ~ '<Ki-\5fPBIT '6Il41~

    w.?I C"fC1'-1 '<i1! <11'l1~-"l9i~ C~

    <r;1J I ~,

    , «l>-;j <!!~ ~a! :qf3v:r!f'>R5l".!.,<@

    ~rer?

    ;.Q~'-"IC<11. >:!\iJU11 ~ ~

    N(.'1' <Q\511Z ~,

    '<m?ji~ \5lH <Q~ \5ffi;"i C'<lc:<P~ C\5I 01f<J I Gllf"'I ~ ~~9fI~-'1r<f~\ C'!)~~ ~~?jI1M~ 1 ~~9f1'R ~ <rfiT '6J'i)C<1' <If'%l\5 0@, ~ 11~0:> ~ ~ ~~ c<Tc:D ~ <lC"'li1'iZ Qjj(;<i', \5'[~ ~~~
    :(lC<l"l~Pi ~, ~~ C.ri?l4~ ZC"l1 .£!<mr <p~
    'f'C?I'[ I' ~~9f[qij

    m~'i ~

    r~O'lJ-~1fut

    I ~~?fI'1(,..j'1 '£!<l:~

    ~,

    1J'[?j'f. '6Il~,)<{

    051cPi

    '151?8l-~~J1<f. :?JJ! ("t'~-i0~~) '"


    ~Cf

    \:>ffif :q;q'j~'f'\3m~R<l1ttL1?I
    -~

    ~ffi

    '3l~ m?f 9l~ I i0r::."If1iI ~

    ~lm~
    ~~

    <rlZ 1 ~
    ~
    w.?I, 1'i<fBI"! '1i'T
    P, /

    f.'nft'1 <fl'1,- ~¢.j'1'i

    ~-0~-~'6<n Jo"'ii ,-,


    '5fi'PLf<lI~4

    ~, ,

    '1'~-l51"1iDifc1~R~

    :)'j~G119f '<If(;15 ~11."\'ox;9f <:J11!~~

    fuc:rr ~
    <m"'ll~

    'f'C?I ... 'f.1<1-'f.f?I"l ~~

    ~'i1l:l? c<TI::;f <mJ C'1f<r


    N@I?J";:j
    1

    I <i] l1\SftGr 'f'Q,1T'1"iJ Z51-~ <i]>i'!)j",zj'Ol

    C1I<:!fl?i <1'?I(~1

    C5'm q;fu
    ~~WBl

    I~ ~
    ;.Q~

    ib~9fi'1ij
    ~

    "IT:~ \5fIw. ~j ~ ?Ii? ~~ <J>~(kl

    ~-~ '-"I1K\!l I
    ~?

    I 5IP'1~<ll

    <j>Q.B "fl'T ~
    ~!

    ') 9]'1P1111 qw[ W'1 7,81

    S11'1i.l
    ¢~R"I~

    "'lfu'T

    @'ifij-'f'l"l\ft-~~? tltG'i m
    ~'3~

    ;.Q~*~.<£? ~
    .~

    ~nnm

    'l'\!l~*? BRl ~

    l11f.l

    '~'Z!)~

    '1'f"'1' ~
    C"1~!

    '5f1fii

    'f'~~ D1'G11~Pi>

    I<1C'8r-;! 'I5i"'IJ \:>ffif 2!C?lI61:'ih! ~ I ~

    fXi~-\5f'~-~

    'f'q'j

    05i

    \;"1();

    ~]t~ ~Rlt'1''-''IT:1
    ~ \5@'>f1

    I \51~?j~ 'TWt-(.:$I'1i-9iT~P4<7]C~ '1! I ~1 ~ 8.}.


    <Q

    ~i

    ~-'1'm<;!

    f~'!6
    ~~

    '6f1j<ii~JI"I('0IzfG10 <lT~ I >i<1L;RWll-~!

    ZV'l ~I

    \51I<W! ~dl"lNlz"l

    'il'f' ~~ 1.;"I~l>

    'l1l'.q3;q >n~

    l1f1;Ul 'Vl1i0, '61117 I <fl~ ~"11~


    01~1 I <f.'<."i <)<7]!. C"l\FI ~ \!l ... i
    <Q~

    ,-,,"lj~i7.l1 1;:J<l<:~9;

    '5f1fii
    <5fi"m1 ~

    .£!~ ooi>iITBI¢'-"I"0

    ~v:r~

    w.?I C"RJ <!Wi '-"ii.ll\!l'l;j

    m ~'ft<{

    ('f'ivn~ ~
    ~

    "1m

    iff <!G1t <ffiI 'f'~j,

    ;:n CC'i '<II <.l-nJ

    fo'1~

    ("lF1

    ">j7j

    '111 ~uw'ii
    ~,

    'f'1i

    <rm, Wi~

    C?fU.9\'3 ~

    '1"l'Q, I \5i?l ~

    P1wE

    G' <Q~ ~~ iV1' <:J<l~>1<i''"<iG'l

    "l'I13F[C<i>? '(>'1C1]'1, iBf1'i"11>i

    (71

    <:J<l~'Jj

    <f.('.<'i(.'!<. Vi >q1~$l"f'M

    131<iJ~ <!l~

    «'C."lQ?i..i i5!'<!l~ ,c<i'<jG1~i~ ~


    <f."@

    c~J<rG'J '2(."1
    ~l.m.6j, I\tC'1'(.iJ\ fiT(,\!l '>fIB I
    ~"'i ~

    01'"5f
    ~\!)"f-!

    <'<:<(.\!l C'i)~

    Jfi?jt1-~

    Gf1f.1 ft<ltrc<f.'3 \5~


    ;n, \5Pl <!l~
    0l<f
    <f.@

    &:'L

    <:3'{ \5j)~

    ~~'1,

    f1'1;:;~1R:i<P ~~, Gj_~ I ~ ~

    \'5ffo/~, \5B! C~n;e,4 "f19j C~


    ~

    $rn I ~.>f'1~L
    <r1 ~,

    '>ftt1<l,.,._'5l'0f.'f1k~
    ~ f.1~<j<j'§{3

    \3I~"'I'<f ~ .~ ~~ ~

    "l1<p1~ ~
    ~

    '&Pi 1 ~q
    Q.fjt<f. "ff ~

    C'<1"f:4 I<N31 J4i9j i Jfi9f'5j ~ <!l~ '6fI<i(.\!)

    <!l<!'i!'5 ~

    N~
    '~'?

    Vi AOSiI!3 GfiJfl'0 ~
    >i1'>fti

    ?fl"@-'1'0 \5l'G>'3 -::mz ~


    m <TI
    1 "l>1~"i

    <i''if?

    -;ffil ~

    c<li<1 <f.<1('~

    9f1TIr (}:f!1.!

    "ff, ~. : minitruthful

    >i~

    .><t~
    '531' 0f<I1'S,

    Vi '¥(.G1 C'l)'ViE

    CI)\D.,m ~

    '\'5I~1<l(,11<1' ~

    ~-~ '~' ~J

    ><t~ ~
    ~

    f.Q~'c~ ~9 ~ m,

    I i5fi3c!l<r, >W:'9fm ~ '5l?j'?K0

    (~\.4Th"<'i ~

    ~'8
    <f.@f ... I

    N~11'1'@i'1 GJ 1<;) '6l\5 <T~ <n1! minitrue, minipeaceful

    <Kfl~ 2iTIRnBP (~\!)Gi'l

    ~
    <j)~

    ~
    <fI?j'l

    ~,
    ~

    f*~ \5fI{'Xg
    ~->jiQ't1 ~

    & Cl;(.;iJ
    ~, 0l<f ~

    (IS1)i~ «'('ii,
    ~(j{J

    B1i 9jT(;<!-

    zrn

    m <l"rn

    "1~ m

    <>f1Gr ~ I ~1:zC01 <:3'1 h>i~<1'@i'1 \3I~'l.fZ

    <.!1m

    <rn,
    ~

    ~I

    '5f<' ~
    c!l~

    <:n~ ~
    ~ ~,

    R!'{3 f<f.

    <Q~ W;>rf~?

    minpax! ><f>f ~

    cW (<pI» (.OZzt&t
    c!l<!>t1 '.'Ji"1f<l <{l'<il

    "11~ c~~$l1>1
    <n~i

    iSM \5n'$!l!3 C'<ftG1i I \5!Bi W,UN.:JM'


    '\0 %

    '1CG1'lH

    "The political party which works for the defence and is cailed r''Socialist", and a despotic government
    m<J~ ~

    ~-\58l1 I <J1l.\5 'mf ~


    -:ifl'8 ~

    z<1! ~
    '11m

    growth of capitalism "democratic", 1f~ ~~

    \3<',1.! filTh

    il~

    z;;r/

    '~' "original all."

    0'<11(;1'1 meaning"

    ~ f<f. ~

    <rwsil>!
    "If there has neither of nothing at
    Jf(51 ~

    and a rigged election "free" ..."? ..15j~ \

    \5l~"'(?1? ~

    ~,

    \5TiPflB "Soviet invasion in Afganistan" ~


    ~
    ~ '9jfu\3',
    (R'<j!

    <Tf~ "Soviet

    are wars, and neuclear threat, it is because "deterence" and transgression,


    '0%!'@01', '~'-c!l~

    nor measure. Its "logic" is the logic of deviation. it is a rhetorical-strategic : 29, 1S'1!~ ~, \!ii11/l <=iim (9ji1lw ~ ;n"ij ~ Zl'A 9JW '5f<' ><fi'f
    "l'(31'
    '.Q~
    _,-..

    fiYj <Q'/J(}fft ~
    'ifi<rj' ~ ~',
    '\'5jQ)<j'j ~ ~

    defence in Afganistan ", \5<!'i! <!l'Q: BG'JC'G <r1'{3~Tf;q :!'lQr,m'5i


    <!:l<fiVl

    9f1Th j
    ~"''1~', Y<n~-:iflVi ~'?jC\D~

    escalation
    )~\T'\. : )~'t)

    'c<li<rl'

    0!51 ~ 'J'fi'{',

    '~'4l'<n'
    '«j)<Jl1' ~

    (No Appocalypse

    '-nt' \5!M ~<;f ~


    ~

    '5l'9fm<1'.1
    "(I'IT(;%i '5fI01<i'1~(,G1<l ~

    l'fi'\'l m~, 0~
    t1:"1C~ ~
    r--.I'"

    R~z

    c<J'iSf,

    '51~~ ~ C'<lt<f. ~ c~ 9'<111 ~ ~

    ~t;j~

    : D1

    \5B' "f91~"'In"---<!1l1"'~-::l

    ~~1!i 0i<1 ~ ~ ~,

    ~' ~ ~

    ~ ~

    <ri ~' '1'P1f9\"11 "l~


    @~~i<lq fl

    <rGG'J is/'i'j,,,,

    I <!l~ ~

    <J<R
    \5~

    ~Fz.;1"1jl'0<f.01J19

    <>iliSiro~
    "1~-1OR'\!l(<P
    '~9'~'''''f1Q ~

    11\5, ~,
    -

    Q,,'Tl.<f.l
    \5()~
    ~"""""Q

    ~
    •

    <!1m C'111l~~
    <!:l<TI

    ;n
    "f1:<l1

    :Z\:?j<-j<iF<i'

    <rt ~

    *7
    ~

    '5l1G'J<i'I)\;:,I.ii1Q~9j'51 c!l~ t, ~ .. D'2'{!\Sf ~

    <rrn,

    ><t'<:f<A<Fi

    <n1! '~

    G5i-:n1! ~KG11<i1'Pl'!
    <J"<[.1 ~t<r<i 'f-R,\5<!'i!
    Q1~ ~ ~~

    <>iM\D)I\SfJ!

    '&Q/1) -n~U1'1 ~
    J'j\~~

    fim!

    0T!~

    OM c!l~
    ~I

    T<1
    fb~\D

    i'>19j1
    ~

    ~m
    <!l~ ~ I

    ~
    ~

    MG1

    ~\SVJD'f1 <>It'\5 <l"rn


    ~ 9j8~i<fl<1

    )",\T8-~

    \5ft~G'j

    ~~m ~Wm~
    "'l1t
    \5j

    ;;;tsf""-ic<pi'1 ><t~n

    T4~~
    ~
    ~~ 9i~"1 ~

    ~11S1'E"'IN>4 \5jl~r:q<::<!~-JiI

    f'l; ~
    ~\F'!i

    5)ocq-; I 9\'1"'if!~

    h@3i"lii '&1~ \5fI~


    c!lV'! i5!i7<fi;6l ~RHlt "1~0!5

    1S:-;{lC."'I~ 2l¥'0
    (RJ<P

    ~C~ ~

    <TI f<i>; c<l'R

    ><t~ ~
    '10"ij',
    9jCj} 1!3~; ~ l!3oi\)($l, '<!:l~'

    <if G>'l \5nG1[.ll',

    "i"'Jl<l',
    c<l,

    'NH@',
    C"f<f'>f<m
    fi)~\D<'<f.

    ~
    ~i
    !<l)t<f. ~

    ~
    ~
    r,

    <n ~If!
    ~

    ~Jf9!31 m
    <!~'i?Gj
    ~~~~

    c!l~~~<;j~("i '>lfu'l"3 ~

    ''@9j~Ij0~j<!l'---<!1~

    1!3-3J ~1! I <!l1,>1'1 ~(3J1


    '-'11"<. <!1~ ~

    ~*~
    ~

    11j\;,~ f.!Fm1
    C~

    "'I~

    ;n? ~

    tribe

    <n fOlk?

    'c@ <>fBl<rt' ,~T<n

    21$1;,

    \5f1~R."l<l 9j'iE~f\!J ~

    m'i
    I

    m ~~~
    ~ ~ ~ Of'5m

    <lCG1C<;Z<i, 9j~

    ~I
    I

    C._

    14'\8

    iS1'i)(;\5-\5~",.,Cj

    c!l~ "14!'iN>(,\D

    B"'f0 <n~
    C<;zC,,? <l''<iI ~

    ><fq

    I H~J<i'2<i

    OO~

    <f.~\51, <!l~

    CC1"<j'17.C1lS{-\5j)~~ ~

    9!"5f. ~
    C\3I ~

    1~

    W~-'{3
    "1~

    (.'!J~H

    c!l)1<1~~ 1!3~

    \Sf9i~

    c!l<fi ~

    f.~L <r1$G1<i ~

    ~'8JC1? 'il
    "'l4f

    )",b-8-1

    B/9\<e..-c!l 'forced

    labour camp'-<Q1 'i)101'.'J~j <=ii'"l


    \5@'B~

    Joycajl1p,~ \5j'.l.jqj '~«:'<f fiavery? c<n:M ~G1c.1) <m!, C~';jl<i \5fj~l1 '~:n<lV1 <l!1l "1~

    I:'';dom

    N. ~ HISF1'N-

    -#- ~ C>j~

    <rrn ~
    9J'DR

    %')~ 1It<1J fI:<f.


    2l'W1
    ~

    <P'i\?(

    9Jl-::l";jl~M<;> ~<{lC<1i?

    ;>;1'fG

    ~'<1l~

    1<1($1

    <f.'<I1 <;jG'Jt~ ?--Q~~ 1

    ~'Tl ~

    r~

    9f!\5l1! c!l<!>t1 C~

    ~~~

    \'5i'0f.'f1k\!l ~1!3

    i "'lC<>r'i

    (2nd Proof) 35

    "

    r·'EW
    Ir~m'.;::lllJnal 3fo~r

    WORDS

    ORDE1I

    <!l~ 'i'¥<i

    WORD

    ORDER

    !l3JC\")i <i,¥~

    WORD

    OR(}ER-<!1~

    Nc4>
    C\51 <llFl

    tc-

    oqL"r.:ot~n!Lat!QI'\ nd {}':stn...c!l0f).1r11l.e'mafl ra- M enace [0 F (1)0 a o Gred! A!:tsUrd("l on I ar lff5 ~rld trace PP-IVATILATION -(.es.p.e.ct ~(,'! Scverelg.rllY tl!'Terb!::y' '.. lueless a

    <ilBlD ~ sernioclasrn ''It<tBr. ~

    I ~~Jj l <!l~

    ~"i

    IbC<:,'1 <il~<?f\!iJ,
    ~ ~

    ZiW59J'ffl <Q~. I
    ~

    <1~ <l'C?i, '5lj-Q>i'Qi~

    <!lJj' \5(;1" ~

    Dev;J.Iua!.IIJ1l

    Oil ~i

    Ily IT'L?l<Ing

    wfc1 '1~ffl9f-~~jL;
    ~

    """"KE T FRIEWl Y
    Ma:l<lr1g ff~eoos tly'S.2nr~ McDorral.d B.agefS.

    mSTERITY
    RE DEPlOYMB.rr

    mm ~
    ~

    wm

    '611\&", C~ ~(!;'lF)'?I

    fSl"1C<l ~!
    I-~

    }¥\'il1<R-~~

    ~~k'- ~ [(/)~
    ~'?i I ~
    <Q~

    8.~.

    T I adc jreeucm

    FREE-mADE from dury:fJree ~;pICt.talron tly Tr~l"rS-N~roj CofOOraTIOIlS (T N Cs) GLOOALJSATIDN

    m
    9f1~

    <Q~

    q;'<fj'?l ~TG>

    rn 1<71(.<1"1 ~~-~
    Jj'~~'i

    \5i<n'?l ~ ;:rt ~ I <il~

    \5fi'-t>J~?flq

    B1<ffiJ, LAD--.il '5fI'I11l%,<ll ~C~~


    <j>@

    '<I"G<.~ Rs
    ~ ~
    <Q~ ~

    Frans-rancraez

    ancn of caora.

    cotonuafon

    of Laiour
    Wa1dof

    Beware orue Nev.,rw(t'Cls .hat ?_.lJ)ll)tt:1tH[1I1. PIJ'-'erty

    CAunON orders [he N~ & i'f'Iequ('!l'iw

    f<lGD;n

    ~+05
    I~
    <!)~

    :(WI

    ~T-'61Jl..j\~f>tV1'1
    ~~

    <f.~

    \5j'i?i J'fi~-\5ffi"'lIMRVi'1

    ~9jq

    ~43
    8.~.~. <!l~q ~ ~ ~ ~ ~?

    i%nl
    ~

    «~1""1!4'<nTIi~~(.<;>I¢i~,'1 ~
    ~,

    ~'Gi

    2ii\iJ0H, ~,
    <il1"

    <w121tm~~"1\5J

    1)j(;9j \;¢i(;L; ~'6m

    H'(f!#
    ~f1
    ~

    k'>ff& ~~rFl --n. ~


    ft; ~
    4>llC~ ~ <!l~~-n I \5Tj>TIVTI1

    ~'TII

    ~l£ln";!j
    ~
    ~

    'I1'l'0(;\i~

    1R~

    ~~~W-~
    '@~~\(.'l)~ 1R~

    ~
    <»Q_fjfvLSc. ~

    r-;..(
    '1 .

    {lZ~
    Dl~

    ~ fl

    q;Q_fj ~
    '5!"1~<j ~ (/j

    ~
    r

    ··fu~C1(<;l C~I <!l ~"ii'Sf1"q0 (~

    ~
    ~~

    0'f,:m <Tl1J? <!l~


    <!)<i>Gj

    .{l~
    ~ ~ ~

    ~
    ~,

    ~"Br \5ll~ ~

    Gf\5<Qifl ~
    ~'>1~~ Ck.Ul10', ~

    J? ~

    '6~

    ~
    CJj~7j

    t31 ~

    'l1J, JjRC'"!Ji"1(€;.C:~ cq'6~n ~

    <rm~-Kfl

    <!l?i ~ "'II'4@?! ~

    C<'f@ ~ "l~<m

    \5jf&<n'iflt'5I'?§ ~'?§

    "0>i

    1ikk

    fSB, \5j~H~'1 ~
    <!l~ ~

    'c~'(n
    ~'>l'

    m '5lf>{Y?i ~~
    ~

    <R;?i <!l

    "f11~~n14> <
    ~'B1
    2l~

    ~lffil
    <!l c<M
    ~-<Jj ~

    "")L :r:J ~ ./

    Z;~

    >?l1~~

    qQr$l1 (~~
    ~ ~ "5f~qjt<>rn 'R?f

    2Jl11'fGJi) '5lf!1C'fR4> '5l1'11¢iMCl!>l 'f~51 Thf.ic:rr 0'ffi 15"l<;<f-1<1t


    <!lll<f.lj ~9J~

    ~~~)

    "1C<71C~<i '~~<'i

    8M <il~ '2jPbru.Z-:rn Brhl~'


    ~, <!l~

    I5f<f<TI <l'<.fii 'm'<iro ~,

    '6~ '5lf<fi?i ~~"? (<!l~ ~

    \5lfu<:lT[oi f.rrF1 m I Win:! .~~


    C~Z4> ~~~,
    C~\5'<W!r

    ~jf!"lT~

    (~'" "'~ : ;;;({"') ~

    ~"f
    ~

    Dlfi\n:r \SZ"11 ~

    ~~

    ~'TT

    <F1'<,tBr ~ ~.'-_~
    "'!1~1«'~"1I~H

    <n-;n ~

    C'<fC0

    fii~1f3, 'TR1 ~
    <f\"@s ~ ~, ~

    f~w

    ~H}iGr~\5l9j<ff~\')j~ fu
    0'ffi I'

    2l'l:.fi"1 'R~ I ~

    Ql ~

    CtH'1t-~-~'?I :=J'

    q;Q_fj \5f<'!'<jIZ "'1l?IT:"1 OW! \5ffi)\'J) 1li~ ~~ "',-_ I 11<;l7l C~ \5jjG'l~ \5jf>f 'I;?\(3~II~-rn '6t?i I ~~ I.\")~r.:l 'j<1l~
    <!l~ ~1J <!l<ilii <!l~ Ib!1P;p1-Wf]";j<j>]-m ~(P1H (constituted) 'C1GIi ~ ~ ~
    ~

    BH ~

    .'fl~ '¥C<71(A<i '6 ~

    <f! \511~G'j
    <!l"4>W "11'11
    <@'i <!l~~"lfu

    ~'i)jC"Tfw

    fPmJ

    'J~

    \5fOl"1l"f C~
    '<'@

    fI1n:J

    B05lll
    '\;11><71

    ~
    ~"Jj

    T~, f\bf.;
    ~

    ,¥\i1<ll11 <!l~ ~

    Zi~~mm

    ~~~

    {l~~

    c<rof03?i
    <f..~

    <4ocat)-9J(;lj>-R9fClP
    ~im9j I \3\'?i c!i1"~ ~ <!l~ ffi"i ~

    '1jik,*~ ;:5IG"f@ 'l1 ~


    C'1'Bi C~ ~.fC\!i ~

    '6'9t'?l1 ~

    c-~ ~
    Hi.*l

    ~,

    <il"C111\5l1~

    ,_~ 'l)"&l?i I'

    f<rrn
    ~cf

    f~

    ;qi'iji?1 1Yit~

    <Q9Fr 'fPll
    ~
    "l<l1 2ffi-~ (~6f

    9fI<1101<ll WiW
    ~<l~ W, ~

    ~L9f?i (li1m') <i"J<i1~ ~ ""l'<>! ~

    <Q$
    ~
    I

    (human essence) cjLll1ction) ~~

    101<p[Plr>> I \5Im{l_~~:-,f<t

    c-:n,

    <Q~ 'l'f:<i 'I<3~

    "'¥3i:Wl

    C'1<1, '61<,j"TIi)~ ~

    \5l1"! <.Q<f.B"\\?1" ~?
    eDt9j

    *"""~~~
    "'11~
    '51~

    "U::1<-jI \5ll'l1!?l 2ffi ~

    <f1~.~ \51TlTlt:rM '"0-;,,,011 <!l~ m1?;'151 >K.3'f <!lq; ~1c.~p:j<f.


    f:Q~fi1:l ><J<4k1
    151111<!l~

    ~+~ ~ ~
    I {l~ ~"Ii"1{."1l<fi ~ ~<i<P'i\$\~ .~ ~ ~ 1<1<l~~"1~, "l~
    <Q~
    ._"

    <r<M ~51

    /~7.'S1

    ~J ~/_
    .If.....__
    _

    ~~'1i0l',
    <:fj1J ~"1<1

    ~C?l~(.<71<i,

    NATO-?i~-

    t.!l<t"!
    "l~"l~ ~
    r-...

    c.~ f,",~~'G\
    ~ I '!ifi,& <.Q1" ~!

    Rl~
    "l~

    'B 1lJm
    '5~

    M<i~<f. ~?ll<f.'-) \5l1~'& ~ ~<JJ\0"l\5 l41f~<»~i! f<i1".,r."1cG «'<I "4>f.<l: C'f(;l"ITl ~! (;E'f; <l~~R ~ ~({)
    2jj\bM~

    i?1f<lvJ C<lt\'l 15'1~ ~ 'YJ'1i"rn <1Jfu;~ ~


    <!l:z 9J~
    ~ ,

    C\SlC.;'1G"li ......-11_

    C<M '8!~,¥~
    "Jj)~'
    ._~ (

    '1 /

    C-.ffi1'G1 ~

    <QWi

    ·2..d p,{)oi')

    19

    . f Kathar Entemal

    ~\!l\'J)
    '~~f~R
    '~

    lQ~

    G9 ~c;tc.l,j~ ~
    ~

    ~G1

    Qf,14 \Sl1~C~ m~~I~~~


    ~'~~ ,(obj<cc.ti.fled) ~
    J'

    ~$fj~

    t , (./

    c: >1

    species hody-~

    ~rn~·f5G~
    ~ <l~' I ~~

    .~

    lpedes body~$f ~
    i ''3{lPt _.Q~
    C:(re;-r <l~1
    ~(;'1.1 \5fI~

    C1~*~~ ~
    ~. ~ ~'

    ~1J:

    I~

    ~
    ._fj.~

    \5I·~t'1

    m&.~,~c<P <1G1on
    Oti:g,

    lflm .~
    t·
    \5f1~

    (.~

    ~.~, lfl~

    ~~':?f

    bio-pol itics I ~,

    (J .~feL(/onQJu~d)
    I

    '~~

    ~<fJIt¥1'~'~€ ~q;;'iJ,~ -M~'1! real

    ~m

    1~

    ~
    \!)~.~~,

    ~.

    az1

    4i{.~

    t.Z01 .~

    ~dfCC}~;

    real-ised
    ~l.Q

    ~"

    01 'f;lp]';!)'
    .

    ~~.<i'~'J11·t1:l1\St?r ~.. '6I~t~ l<C~ 9t~

    ~m'

    ~-f4~<Jq

    I'

    ~R'1'~

    ~~;._.2j®4--<p'il;n

    tflfW1<))@

    4'm:~~T<11\!)~!
    :~' ~

    ~
    ~1W~

    ~~.~<JMr? ,
    '.

    \5fl'ffl ~.

    '~~.

    ~~-'5{q~~f

    ~Jf"@-"'l~G~~

    C~\!},&~<p{.t;t· ~~·Pi<i1

    ~~trn,
    ~\!)jtM-

    ;n~ :~

    '5fi$J,~i~

    _'t'~~'"11 F1~1?

    ~~

    anaeomo-politics
    ~~l
    ~~

    \51-m,\!)~~

    '";fl~<iRi~~

    ~i@if·:tlf\1
    ~~tGil
    '\!i\!l~

    ~~Z ~ ~rn! 1:~\bt~l~ ~'m~ ~ 'I~~


    ~ ~ ~ I ~'
    1,.~

    G~ I, 'OlBI~l ~m

    ~,

    ',",

    .~.

    ~~(.GC1~t<P·'2P1 ~
    '-44!~L;t;;jt~-~

    G"'1i\:~\5~,
    ~-c<fl~~ _~

    \Q~~h~ ~~ .~

    ~~

    .h.. vL

    '¢ij~R~q. af~{'}1H<P r4~~-~~~{;r~ ~~.

    ~
    .~~

    '~i1:~t\1:n f4¥~ ~4i~?H &,-~'Qtt ~~(P' ,~~~ \!)i()Hl. ·~tG, Q1"8m ~\!)- 1\§~ '~ ' .', ·OJtG10'f\2m ~ . ?1$l'~ (\!)011 ~. \5fi:~ ilf-~'~ L-'. -- . .N.. . ,.,. . ',. ... .
    :\5l{~<f.45P1~:i1;

    -4U~' j"
    I

    ~~
    &j\1pG1~ 8.. . S
    ~

    O«"? ~qr' <f3~tk


    <¥(:~

    mI

    \5{l~~

    "4fu~ ~;,
    ~"<tt ~ .~

    ~~\5

    ~'t7i<P\S
    ;n'¢l@ ...

    ~ if4
    c<f't .~ self),
    \!4Mt~<f.'

    .c<P'i £fi~ (.'9.


    c9j(JJ C~

    '~~1d1

    GJ:~, ~~
    c'YfGi ~~~1F~l?f

    1 .~.

    ~t~t ~{G1;j~ ",¥f~ ~


    01U1 ~~)z c~@
    ~'
    '~'8

    c:®.t~1G?4J !t,~nt~ '~:'~ JfjWtf'l ;utZW:1 ~. ~t2.:l~,


    ~~I[q ~

    'l!,~t~~

    I ~~

    .~~
    ~ ~

    -~~'51
    \Qf~
    ~~

    <fi'rt(~ (care of

    ~'{3.!

    .~~ ~(.~~
    ~

    c<fS'fBf

    ;2nWt, ~
    '<P%~~U1,

    1fi"S, \5W$'Yi~(' ~ l'

    ~'1iG~

    .~ I{)R ~ ~
    8.~.

    ~.crl tf~1

    !{'-S~

    ej$Ji'1 151~ I Oi~ 81


    ~, ~

    I~

    .•

    ~\5l;:Eft~K~.:q ~~:

    0"Iff.i' ~~'~V~,

    '<[t'(fm :qt ~
    . '~iJrC~~l

    ~N:rm ~.

    ~'.~
    iif(.iij~

    ~~

    I!I~ 9f<'i51'~"i1~~ ;n~

    'semjot[~ chota' I ~~~


    ~~,<:p ~,

    .~ '11 symbolic o.rdeN~ ~7ie.;rn : ~.q1(l ~<i~ ~tfil ~QJ1<P~J.~ ~. ·Ift ~ .~\& ;O~
    \5fl~

    ~.<R ~?tC'1Sl

    '~R~' '~<;?f)1M
    ~~

    ~.~ I ~'~
    A-

    <J~M' \t\!~~ ~~<fl~.61m


    ~~~",,~'; -~
    ((J1' -'SlI
    -

    9j'ifi(]

    (i{1~t\5f@ ~
    ~'c<P?F" ~ . '.
    . • .I

    ~\f<S ~31

    (Must~~ ~
    R1ill~ ~
    \!)'I}J

    <H3f 4~C,;f) '~1F ~'.:


    .....
    .

    C?1~ '?
    ,~,~Gt1~ ... ,. cl.
    .

    ._

    ~J7l:lti -~ -,.1l_\..!.""J"
    ~.

    .-;Jt [ "'11.

    ~7A;I' ~~"", f\St(%$!4~~1:~' ....•.. "":#Il1:"!-4"ll


    II ' ~'."

    ~~ l1li1 ~ ~ ~·I·\~

    fIT 4~

    ---~-.?

    , ·<tG4i ~~. ~
    ~<f

    ~{'im ,~ ~ ~
    "-J'.j,

    il'~ :·1 ;11

    "";f"

    t.;~r"1

    .. ~

    "'1 .-...; •

    HI
    >i;q'''l'&(,..Q''S:~'7fm(~~

    \!iifjilrn
    ,~\.

    ~'-~
    '(.ra' .....::;;;

    ~1U1

    ~.

    '?i,%t'1~
    ~ \5{~-~

    ;a~¥J

    ~1!
    ;.L

    '~7!!<f:91<m~1

    4a'11

    ,!ti,"'~

    \!:1~'f1l~ .....
    \!)G1,ij
    a:.,.'

    {.\!)i

    1bt.Q?$i mlir9-~\Bj«P$l 'ti~i$I r£l~ ~&t~\~C:W1ffl:~1i


    ~.~ ~l5j$';4 .~~

    '::qrpf ()'ro' <p@

    ~\5l'Pj' '-$i
    ....

    m
    ;.qntim'~:/·· "~I&xr._"'~C<{~Git~f

    .'.' lo:{(<P(!'j ~
    q -H"i
    ,Ci""~
    r(l~'

    «P' \5:lT~)1f

    fflt~ ~-~, Oi1f.G1, ~'I<fl--.m-~l~-8rR-fs11?i-~1~:'_1~~1-~ ''Z\!in~I \5{'9jC$l1j W.~~


    \5flWi1r

    '7Qj'~-~

    ~'H~~

    ,,.....'>11~'I)?l <flloe.ntity ..... -l'~


    ~~'A

    1.\!l'1':1

    ~II

    ~,!Fl~ I~i_

    '""f.l j~~sf

    (<nn1r~ '<n~' '-~; .


    ~~

    ~~rn
    ....... ~

    'tj,Gfj;n?J

    D~(~

    ~9ftr1~

    'Sjl1-~/~()1ijfm/Wl~-~BJ

    ~Rfi'I

    .<:Q'<R l til'%" \5l'~~ PHr~tq \5D~~


    I."<It.~·~,

    ~~<p1 .~?
    ~?'re1 ""l ..... 'Y1 ~~('$I' '-"1'1 "':

    .'
    -::::i
    ~ T9f~ir:1 ~. J' Y"3I,l/ :d'I~. ~.I"F,,:\!:l 'P..~ ",'",

    ~~~rn
    ~6f
    '<;p.~..q; ~

    <,j [Ctj

    'fr;R.G1 '"
    ~.~.
    I"

    f,.qRlt~ .• ~:.
    ~~'

    II~

    ""tl ~ I~

    ~§

    49 ~''4~ILt@

    ~~~1J:fl~~U-~

    ••

    ...

    I.

    '~c:<l

    '~7r!':::;r~ "-vi ~~.~r~

    .~c<
    ~t<:!

    \!>i~:'
    ~01~'

    :"t-~ '~'/~'
    "1~ 'l3Q> ~

    '~'

    '(<l~"li"l1"'

    :m~

    ~~
    <!i~

    2)f!r,<.ilQ "1<rfG
    'Jj)~ 'SlVi ~

    ~
    ~

    ~ 'c"lR"lP1'
    ("1~~)

    <1>('51~ ~

    .... '11)r ~<.il

    Rt'(i()j~l,

    (;'1',,"'\1 ~~T
    <I~

    \5f+f<l \'llBf ~ C<l <1>i~<1>1:1"f-

    C<l J'l1r':1

    Dl'W

    <il~

    C~

    <5l"B1 bl!(:1 ~

    '111 <!l~"f

    '~'j'~"r

    f<rt"'1<r ~
    : '5j<w~ ~"1

    ,~miotic

    C~

    c.".-pJ

    ~ R~~
    ~ ~<1J {~

    'ftA
    ~
    ";['!B!

    i5"1fu.'1.'1 ~IG <!i<!8 ~'ij\!) <¥efer) m~/~ ~I ~<i1 ~@FR-~ <li'ZC-:l<i J'f~~"l1C1 <m~ ~----<Q""l:R '11, ~ ~
    ~ ~

    t·

    symbolic-a

    I ~~9J~

    un?ft ~,
    \5SI, ~,

    ~
    cot?!
    <WW3

    ~
    <f.\!j~

    '6I1Pl
    ~

    ~G1(.'!l 9f1~

    <1>-:lG'!l ~ :~, ~
    'f.'@

    'TI '%n--.:rrr ~Fjl'

    "...,.

    "l{)W ~
    <@C'j

    ~jv;ntJ~
    <Q~ ~~

    ]111W<1> ~9fBr<!i"11

    f.2r;fiq, ~
    C~ I~

    <1>'!l'lftR '5!J.m'i

    1I(,,~ <n~«'"l-:l ~"1!

    <!i<M '5ll'ifP.r
    <Q~

    ".JJG'; I ~TI ~
    ~-\5t~

    U'tN'1i <!i'Q: (''{?I3?!-~1fur

    <Q<WG ~
    ~

    ~\';)1~1
    '1J1Ql-:ltll

    \5~

    MW ~-~~
    ~t<P<t
    8R I ~ <.£1*1

    00 :~~
    ~ :Jfl~

    <TI ~(?)-~

    Q0-' :Q®~i ~ '5i"l'1P1'!l nornena) <'l'>(~~

    (foi@i.1@pf)

    P_
    fiill1 ~

    ~?f

    "5f1fit' ;fi'}j~ ~/~ 'f.'fu-f.t:rli-"l~


    ~9fj<j ~

    'TI~ ~ (~

    0!1R
    <Q~

    M
    ~~

    c<Bfi <il~

    11<jIo1~ ..!l~ I

    m C?im om, ~J1G1)~c:<lIf.l-\5fol~ 1iJ~ ~

    'TI ~

    (rule-govemedr/Cphe'8l)<ji ~

    '21011>'!

    ffi ~
    ~

    I~

    \'5fj~ C<i'fvTI

    I <!i~ 2101(4 ~ ~

    '<lG.,j(4 ~ <IT~ C'lVl",


    ~ ~

    I}
    -""' ~~ J

    pllenotexy

    '-5:!Bl 1!lj"'\]NC1> ~

    C'Pf<l ~~ elements),
    f.iR''!l I

    ~ ~
    1'f1 ~_

    ~, ~ ~ c$i I~ ~ '5l1~-sem iotic cherat N~..;n I "1~ )]l'Q:-~<11"f11:'Bl ~ ~"1'\5tm ~i ~"1~


    '111 \'5f'<t11
    (.Q'<f

    <nm

    C"1m ~

    ~~IG

    I "Z/~

    fC:'fi <W1 '511-N:----<Q~

    1f1

    ~m CS'\C'i,
    :.-\5fiTI ~ ~

    ~ i¢~

    ~
    <!1~ ~~ZC"l"1

    \5lPT1"i1;q>'<I! ~ genotext I 01i~ ~

    115'" ~

    <W1 ~~ (disruptive \5f)?i '<m~' C0I ~


    \5fI:9J"lpf ~~ ~ ~<i

    <.1J1084
    ~
    ~I

    C<1I~~ I i¢~

    ~
    ~-@;~

    ~-~~

    m:,

    <lG'iBI

    I r.::'r!''0~i':1
    ~

    psi (,v)-properties "Within sequent articulation

    T~

    ~m 'Z'-~

    (~<E<1

    '~'IG

    ~ ~<1im

    I) \5l ~Vi

    ~
    ~

    ~Wrrn
    '{?j<.1C>b

    9J,?,C'!l~ .

    ~-<.j>pI"15j_Ji~I"

    ml$l'!l

    'f.'Qf!-~/C'11cT1 ~

    \5lT1

    ~\SM\')
    ~~ ~

    ~z.
    ~'I

    (transcendental Bi4t <:rrr:~ ~


    ~

    this process

    one might see the release of the drives as constrained system

    and subby the

    ego)->\.{ll 41C~;;n$i ~ ;rjl ~ '*1Cf4' .~'G


    '~'-?i ~

    (Qp(.'<3~m \5i<m:i thetic)

    ffi
    fiill1
    ~

    N<:ElG\ ~
    <.lJ19Jm

    ~
    '<!i~ ~

    ~I
    ~

    <!it"! Gfm."
    21ft ~ ~

    ~
    '1q;C'!l~
    \5j9fQ-

    social code a genotext itself to describ~e is indicated


    '1J19jTfWf «P'i 'U~(3:1 <E~ ~ C9j"~'!lllf~ f.if-.r\')/~ \5l ~
    BjS'j ~<-l'2:i1

    yet not reducible phenomenological in terms

    to the language system intuition

    as

    p 00 ~
    '5J1<rE1
    ~

    '~

    and as the signifying of structure,

    as it presents

    '<1GC~ OJ

    as a phenotext; or of competence! (1973 : 1250)

    2)1ffi ''1T'1"'~~

    C~

    .. :~:R1 'T1~~, 1'ii1~,¥'!l

    '3'1
    ~

    Q1

    WI

    'TI [~Q

    Q1 2)1~~(f.rp

    C1>~j.:jG<'13

    (reified)

    mz~"! ~, "1B"1\5 ~!

    perforrnance.i.The
    ~

    presence of gena/ex! within tile phenotexi


    <!i~?i qp.I C"$], phenotype

    <!i<:~

    <>f'<l'G1 ~ ~

    by. ..a semiotic disposition."

    <tJ<.1ZJRtl' ~ 4Qjl-9'G1lT"l"
    ~ G"')'J, ~, '<.~ 4'"1~? <.£I~ ~, 2)'11 ~ ~,

    c.,!\?J<i1W
    ~

    'G'liG, @' ..!l<'l~ C"~11bq;l3m ~~ I <.£I~ '{?l(<lZ fu.ZCi' 1@1 ~ 4C"lf~ ..!l<'lZ (.Q'<f
    '<5!<tU'P'l"" ~
    ~~q" ~

    c<rRJ1 03i
    ~

    111

    "STCi:fJ'G &,415! 0'ft"4f~J <!ii¢ C<-If';<tl"F1i '4V'n~"'f


    : «R ~
    $PT <!"<f.i "1~

    ~_!

    ~enotype

    '5f11 phenotype. ¢enotype

    '6j"'1C~-:1 C<Sl1...,W<1> «{>lIS, '51H

    xm,'$f?f
    ~
    ~

    ~t-'Z ~
    ~

    ~-;:ntJ~

    <mfuqi; <Ut11.TI-".l1J\91i<l1

    ..!l<ml"RrCi()j'{?l

    131$i
    ~

    !!7

    l·ci

    1'ii1"i",,":[;'rC4 c!1i¢ ~ ~-c"'\~~


    ~

    c<R? ~ C<1>'1G1? (.1>j("'l1

    ~fPi ~
    ~~~~? ..!l~ c!1w'

    01~

    W ~M' c-f:t? <n~


    ~I
    I

    I'ii1lPl ~,

    f<l> '5J1fit ~
    '11~

    ?jf<l~l~ t13Rt~
    ('51<n-1_'S!"Xl1"'1'!l\<r

    <m?j~
    zi'&i-~ ~ ~@1~)

    @"1(\;-c<R»

    Iv1C"1"l! >'fI~
    genetic

    R$l;l!r."1/1<"~~

    '~1<K'!l 10l<:j~'!l \5fi?i'G ~ <!'h'!)j~

    ;n I '5l<f'1 ~
    '311 <j~(;<i ~,
    ;?j~ ~'{'j~ ~

    \5i"<l1 !Gfl @b"1 fenotext.


    7Ji ;nf.il;

    \'3.TfSnm
    I

    I5lBi ~

    iTVi ~
    '51<11["11

    i!il)"flt 'f.'T?ll"!tGl c<r "11~,

    endowment,

    9I<f"1MQ¢

    (.\';)131.?!? '5l1<fI~ j;'!l('"1-q~ "I!ljj'!lj'%,!)


    oj(,<i"'l

    C"1G'l i!jj~\';)If>i<1>

    phenotext

    ffi

    "1'f'?'f?j

    ;rj \

    \51 '~

    ~X4'!lj?'

    C~~"I'ii11<l <.£I4G1 ~~

    (""11 ~

    '51<li'."'1t<i]

    "i'<i3~ .~

    I ~,

    \5~

    ~;

    ~~

    c71t~1f'1"l' ~

    f;;c.~ 'ifG<1' uk"t


    'l<!t~ <i1@f.11

    ~t

    ~ ~~
    [~ IS ~

    "My Ut <1 , '¥f.'l ~


    ~gftilj ~

    ~'{3/~'{3l

    ~(

    "1i\5

    ~-c<n9iM! -~ 7j:s:'U1 -~

    ~<:P '11 <Q'{I1f<f<P 2i~l

    <P{ ~

    :5'('~
    f.Hb~

    fo0.

    fi<fG! ~

    '1""iU:~rrC><l'~tG'fI\5j"11, 9:s:ti

    '

    t5dt<;j~4rn ~
    (.~,\R C~
    ~ ~

    \m ~ ~~ ~"o/l "t*frn
    ~19j' ~~,~
    ~ ~
    <it§' ~

    ~.r-~,(~"'I'<1i~

    ~
    ~.

    , /~ QIru,
    ~ ,,~
    ')'[D'f

    1.'<1<11: I ~, ~" ~ '{>d! iDI"t<r-l"


    I

    (IT<r<n~

    0' <t~9 I ~.

    I "1 ["i(01

    ~
    <!<jl~li

    ~1'G
    I

    "fiJ.
    \511~ ~

    II

    '5l@!
    I \5M"'jJ ~

    "Rlw
    ~

    Zl~

    m~.:5j<p \5l1P1 ~
    <BP1 ~~ ~
    L.\5f!~

    ~m~~

    ~'<'f

    11)';Q[<i'i!

    "3~t<l~

    "1~

    ~-?,T~

    ~~9
    ~,
    \50l
    \5[<1 ~,

    ~,

    ?\Wl1 ~
    I

    c\5fl1 ~
    <.jJjJj,

    I '11"Wi~'{3

    ~
    j

    F1:vl ~~~

    <.jJj~

    "'fi~

    <f1' <!N)-<>P!Bl ~
    11Ti7I
    \5Q,fj

    ~~'-t5i?i.£lIt~
    ~<R
    <'{>~

    Y<.11ffi"1l
    C?f"iI

    m.r"<I, \5j1\')0i>\')
    ~ ~

    ~@lDf<f :><fl9f filcG1'i <nlII\bG'f.


    ~Q> ~

    iSMl21Z Q\3T11"?! "119f! <J<Jli% <Q<rt'i'r ~,

    \5fifffi-N'l4 ~

    ~iQ>lt5lC«->1 "119f CG1 fuQij


    \5f!~ ~
    j

    9)'iD'r~,

    o.fl?G41Cl1(frj!-<Q~ 'Wi ~ ~ ~ o.fl<PGl 1i~ ~-~'11<tQ

    i5i1"lBr
    ~"i1

    C~

    ~1~{)f<?~~~~~~~<!I<r\~~

    <+>J'fG'n(;<l--<HPi \511:l4!P1 ~

    f.<i"¥<:P\')i l \5f.ffi!1

    01\A-9jjG1G19fi"il't
    4PlfR;

    WJ'<lt'3.·
    \511";ffi1 ~,

    ~-\5!'<fl5

    \5lPn1!

    fo1<j(.\5

    r;;c~

    <Fi"l1, 7jc<r<J"i1~~
    ~

    \5j'<ll) "1i~~rrA<l' ;IT <


    '\5!i~GG1li ~.

    <Mi~ -

    ~m
    1

    Qi&01 ~ I ~ I~

    "1'Mt~

    ;,Q

    "i1?f'<l19fi'0 ~

    M ;,Q~
    'QJ\si1'9 ~ ~ '8~

    M ~-~

    <ffi9fi@ ~

    ~
    C~C1 (.B19f ~

    "'fF

    ~-7fI
    <@1~ -~,
    \5T1~

    <n~

    ~"11~'"

    {t;C<E1

    <Tf I I!jMfil~ mB ;n
    0f',,<1(.\5 ~

    <pi'foT! ~

    '3mut

    17M \5iB1 \511~

    .. I6I'8'I'1<lf1<1

    m
    ~ ~

    ~ .

    'Bfm ~"1 ~ <.jJj9fiWl ~


    LQ'i/;f

    <:JD:l" i1C~<l'l

    G'fI5fiFR
    ('ifIq'j

    .$J>1':>j '11'

    csrol~ Nl5jQr-filc'1"1'lf@

    f'-1~w.o,* ~
    [L~"'~

    9f{;l 'TIl-9f$i

    \5lt~
    ~

    c.<Jij'i

    C<J .~

    '<fl zv.:r
    ~

    GlfXt ~

    ~
    <'{>'<11 ~

    ~'6 ~

    KhJjRrr;,'Vf"l~ 9f~, \5lt'<f a'P'l-C6n!:>1"$l-~ ;,Q"if.i ~9fill


    l)'j<'>f1 ~.
    ~?
    ~ ~ \5'j

    <r1<n~(.tll->1 C~\')$l«>11 7j~.--~ DTG'! \5jlc~...


    ,"l

    8W5 ?fIB-! "1.'<1 ~

    '11.. ~

    ~'t

    ~<PGi C'~(9)'i~ ~
    structured,
    ~ ~

    <n-.n~
    <l~,

    ~I

    m~
    .~

    <iSl'~M!~\')lIM

    fik:1l ~~

    r -._.''''-OJ ~
    ~
    ,""

    , ~ _'",

    I """

    ""~

    i\l
    ~"l
    :q'l!:j_ I

    '!Vi.

    ~U)j_., LQ'Z <i<J1~~j ,<Q~'6

    '81"PfS ~
    ~,

    "1l '-'-/)l', ~
    ~~

    \5li9)f.'j <!"l'l C\51 4->1"1 ~? iSNT<l cm<F!

    'Om ~

    :,f.M-;

    ''Jt ~H
    ".frn\ I Moses

    normal, academic,

    c<JQ:
    ~

    fo1~ ~
    ~
    ~

    \5~'lF"i1'<, ~

    'ffi4

    scientificj .'(,~

    f<JlQJ
    '5lfGi'.<1'

    -<QFr

    \Si'&j~<llt

    G'f\<j ~

    <lG'!1<i \5fPl ~ ... "l~

    ~
    9J@

    "<1'101(.<:] {.11«"1'i I 'l:4M>G1 UHC'f,


    \~j~(.iij \5'j

    and Monothe ism, ') (;J 8 eu--<Q<'f b- 9f1\5I ")~

    m:w:s ~ ,,"'1V'f' "'I"? R. "3~,


    in attaining

    ~~~

    ~-

    ~
    C2i~9f"'lm

    9)'iDl

    i5!l~ GWfj <n1! ~,

    .. One or the other son might succeed favoured

    a situ-

    <ffi! 1

    11 ~~ ~L

    ation similar to that of the father in the original horde. One

    C<Pf&t ~
    191el?Mll?
    ~ ~

    '?ji<WtN>@UR~'
    ';,Q~ ~

    <f.~'1ti~
    ~'i'i 1

    position came about in a natura! way : it was that son, who, protected by his mother's love, by his father's advancing years and replace
    ~
    'IBM)

    iji\')\')i

    ~c.G1 \5f\~
    ~

    ~<:><n~ ''5'Ff.1<."1r{,

    C<P?' ~ i51'&l~

    of the youngest

    -<MISc.«>
    :l4'T!R9f, \5fi'-1--nJ

    (,()C'i..J

    on

    \5lZWl 4$t

    1'1

    could

    profit

    :~J03 >r~<.1 ~.
    9t'T@:, ~~

    ~-c<J

    C<P@ ~~9f4
    ?fK~ LQ'<,tj?J1 ')

    <n~
    ~<jIS~

    ~
    "i~f'[;l

    him after his death.

    "fl ~
    0Um\5,

    ~I')\')<l'«(~<l
    ~'{3

    f<r.r"'lI<1C1<l

    ..-~5jfZ;5
    <1~

    ~i%

    -600

    '5ITI9f<r-{;C"lo{; MWVZ-l I '{3 ~,

    ~ '1~ .~

    <ic'¥l f<l~
    \5!~1
    C~

    ~~------:.Q_i7'!RlT0f

    C\51 1Sl~1
    Dn~

    ~"'ll"@->j-M~,

    <11<1\<1

    concerned

    ;p:J

    I ~1~R\5

    ~"'ln<'f

    4{;f,

    <!It! He?) f~

    -~

    <l'el(.~" i <1~<1l9fi

    \'5fA1<'; <i111'G ~

    '1''41 .<P?J 7f1-~f19f

    urnl

    "llr

    <Wlt-~

    B$l\<1'Q

    I <ff18 ~,
    b

    051~ '5fi'>1,.,
    .

    c<l'~
    3:L

    f.ic~ ?i1'0i" ~~
    ~q,.

    \5"'f.i I \5iI5c!1<l

    ~-ffiQJ .. S·F<
    ~

    @''1'8 ~ (reality ~'"1 ~"'f

    cfl C9fi\5T ~ principle),

    ~,¥J'.'1 ~

    "I't'.'1'i ~-m\5&!
    rB.

    13ft

    ~9jlfb1'

    0bI'\:<lS

    <!G'f1 ~

    '5ff1

    Pi> 11~
    (additional)

    C'31 c!I<i>cfl9
    1~ r;J(pj '8<Wf 1511<1(~
    '5lt<$1~!

    >t~)~Bl,

    <il"'8l"A c!I"I' <Q<f'-:<4}!-:Q1l«"f.

    -'OllfP.Zi, ~l~ \5fi9fR


    -~,

    <l>1cfljJ7j 1 'i':(<Ji151 <'J'iler"l'C'lli ~, '1<r.i '6<r.i

    QJ

    ~f<1.ml5
    Life

    <Q"0 <Q~ ~q education


    '¥j.

    cfl CF11

    >j~J~rn '51GDI1'§
    9-~1' ~
    <1'fjj1t(.~

    <1""";&(.<:""1<1

    '<J<nGDl1i \5l1~ ~.tc3 ~,


    \51-ifl-<l> ~

    \5l1<>;'<ffi'! ontogeny

    ~9f<il1 <f'Bl~(Pl'l

    CV Gf@1

    m~

    "'fi

    ~?

    ~
    I I'!ll~

    I mean, I

    \5l@!

    ~m

    \'XI\lXf 1 <!l~ style

    <m"9fl<Wi

    151'&1'1-<11'11 ~ f~"1lj I ~~M


    '51<'1®$l\

    /fl~-~ia1
    "{)jl~ ~

    ~ ~ m~
    ,¥G'!N'i 'C~~, ~? Cognitive

    \51-ifl-''l;,

    1"l ~ ~

    c!I<l>>j"lgl~

    f.R"""i'rn ~
    cfif0!ij ~
    0'f'Sm' ~I
    . ~? ~, ~?

    <!l~Zl~G>H
    mind-ns
    '<l@

    qSj"(:Gf.Ernr'l q;~

    'mind'-<.Q1 ~

    M'1
    \51TA ~

    ~nvrn"Zj'<f"l
    (.~
    primal directly

    C~-~-P<i'li't'!I

    '..

    <l>1ffi:CG1'i j0f.i 1

    1ftI1 '5fV

    C'R ~,

    '11, C9ff'>f.'!"<M1 ~I \5[qj~ f<R1 0R f<f.~ <:rTif\;5~ c!I'3 C<W<i "l~C?r?l" ~"i his
    "Sons from them ties with

    (Jf~m ~

    Cartesian

    construct

    RvI,
    ;n

    m ~9fQ.9f

    0fI'611R ..

    mind

    ~01~
    "The their nence

    ~,satisfying into absti= tendencies; into sexual ~! ~ could he forced emotional aim.

    psyche
    :>jGJ'ifim,

    Science-au

    ~"<)S\5J<:<r \51'<n ~
    ~ ~ •

    psychoc<J '6~

    father. had prevented sexual which

    analysis-<!l1

    "JjI5J 'iJt1 15[l~ c!lq;

    st<fj ~(J5'!zI st<fj ~ <1f"I'J ~

    f4.(iij
    ~

    159f"M1'1 C~
    •

    and consequently inhibited into in their <HIGV'i"1 ~


    I ~

    his and
    that so to

    "I'QJ"i-"iT!-1Gi11 ~~psyche

    ~
    ~<1I(g~tt

    <>j?f51"

    '&[)(?!

    em
    em
    "I'@':3 15[l~

    \'llBr society-a
    1

    Mt'Bl

    "R~

    ~~ ~C"I"1? "iT! ~?

    .. "

    one another were ~, speak,

    arise out of their

    tendencies them

    -~'1R ~1. •
    ~ mmBI
    cfl<l>L;l C~ i?fl)j C'31 C~ '5fl~-~<fi"8 +-surplus -~, basic

    m\1':lF" ~
    ~9fPl >R:<iJ
    ~
    "I'@

    \5l1WJ, ~ \51f~ ~10 '5lBi: c:qi@ Gl<:l1G'i ~


    ~

    031 ~

    He forced

    group

    psychology." c!I~

    (1949 : 117-18)

    <i'QJ1-~

    <l1'Sm1" <ilQJ"i ~1<jCtrz'1 '<Il~


    C1~:___~
    ?('[@?

    <.!f'Q
    ~

    <j\\O>:r~, ",\!p:r~----<il~ c9ff'>]';i c-<fo'ii~"f.'6fC:<ii1L;j ~


    ~

    <:rnR>i'1f ~
    <>;~
    "iT!I ~

    <!I~@I

    ~-

    05t
    \S1G'j

    "ll¥ ~~

    \5l19jf.'l
    QJ

    ('9f1~'6

    W, i?i~1:'Z
    I

    ~f0,

    ~
    ~

    cfl~@1Q
    \:ifl~

    ~'11 ~'<N1
    (~:

    ~
    ~'(j

    Ff.

    "iT! ~-~ <J.1"?[1 '\51~(:<f' C't<l~f-~

    "fJfBl ~
    f.ic~ 'fS'<f1 wm
    "l1l:'1 <Ai
    ~~
    ~U;i~ ..

    -"1w ~1

    "iT! ~ repression

    15!'&I"11"1"1., c:<fS1'1 <1'!\L'i""l \5i1E,"d~<f' ?f\9(~1


    ~ ~ I (Marcuse, ~ ~
    "zy:,,<j

    "R<:JJ ~

    <!ii';<r -;:;rr I <!I ~

    1:Z'11"'1"lJ:_'"01 ~
    fll
    9j~

    'l1'-:?,H:t;"'1

    surplus repression?

    ~
    QJ

    cW-) ~
    \5Q,'19f<R5 '~t?l0'I<j'
    "I'@,

    ~~,
    ~

    ~m'¥(.iil
    '6l~Fi<>;~
    ~

    ~~~"-'!:I8)1 ~~
    C'>f(F1

    9j~t1 1~ c~ ~

    bG'R.1 ~?

    repression

    c~
    ~

    ~-<ljl.';>f0 ~

    YMl~
    ~

    '!la-

    defer

    "J.."""1,¥M~

    c<l <{1'0<i~fb1

    2l1~

    ">i~B!, 151'"1 ~,
    15C<l" ~

    o,) 1 ""I'lf-c<!R"l$l" l'fj'6<n'Z


    labor
    \519]~ ~, \5\5

    11WJ

    c!I~ ~ @''-1:'8 ~'


    ~ 21\ifll

    surplus
    \51911~q '8

    c-:rn ~

    ~~~

    I~

    <ffi1
    o:f@

    <il'<fi ~ ~~41<iq"""1

    on

    I @'i'8

    <r<lif\S<1i 1 \5ffj'6

    C519f" 0'R,
    ~<j

    ... '!4i1

    RP! ~.

    ~" ~'-ii;~
    <fc1("q"ij, "ptf"l
    <j~

    ..!1'i31t<l ~

    'OIl?fRl ~

    \5f"ffi ~
    I "\'5j@l
    2j~

    ~
    ~ ~ ~~

    f\5R
    ~

    ::1'&"i>ff1 ~~C":<i"i'l ~! -<m9f1~i


    Wr~ reversal ~ ~ c<J Zll, add "iT! 1 Primal <J.1"1'~~ C'3l ~ horde-<Q~

    <1Ti5W

    '11 '1lI'1~il1'!)

    om,
    ~

    <P!~

    "f-'illi

    '@<!;lfiiG'1IIS'WSI? ")'l\0

    ~(;<1{~¢

    <n'11'6

    C<:i

    "fll?fl;'lf \5l~

    fu:1

    <1''<11 ~

    I c!!"lT'l ~1B!

    "l'ftl(.~<l ~ ~
    I ~(-flRn-"l">.!

    Wi '<'i'"i)' ~"
    ..!I"lT'l "l1'81VI

    ~~'bmf1~

    <i(... )(,'l?.~~ 1 c!I~ "

    'Wi D1&"1jl-q4~
    17l~

    >j;]' cm:<11 <'i'liiRi~

    RIm
    "Ff fBC<::1

    lml,"'!I"B!,

    lm!''lffi f.'ffii'i "1~

    ~
    '5flm

    ~~'

    fl>

    0i'X'1 ~

    ~'.'1"""1?

    <!if; \5l·Wl(A9~
    f.tc~i<j '~'

    G~!1 m,"'!l <'i'lJ ~ ~J

    ,-

    ~ ~
    ~m;;t<!

    <ffi:i5, bllQ_>1i ~""tOl..!1~ <'i'lJ ~

    CGB!?2.t 0'iiitl ~
    "B! I ~

    tI<1IT

    -<l><1G1 -<31!.~i, 'CT~'11 9i1G1 "iT!I cfl~

    C'3lI5i1<>R1~ <i>I~ \'lfPfl ~~I

    filf.hrGJ ~Pr<c

    r:{rr5fR

    OMm

    "1"!!i1"GEf <!1'S"'11~

    -<_'!) <[11

    i.5ffl.

    <!~~-\5l~-~

    m~

    Ii'1,~~~
    <11 ~,
    '

    i.GD

    -<_~ "11, l:il&<n "11

    i@'r4C'i1 case study-tl"


    C4C'G rn-~'iVPfJ415

    <l'@

    11Z

    15i1@
    <n~

    WK<I

    c<P"""l'i"fi <J.1~
    2l~ I "?[1

    C?j'>]'l~-

    21121"'1 mm Gft<l ~

    'i1I~ C<l>~'G '(9f"YiB'! ~


    (<1'():;

    151'&1<1<11<j" ~

    (<j@IH<.p

    <lifo'! "f'r~
    <!)fk"14'fu'ff'1l5

    <'I1">.!1 '/ui'!'M I

    'fS\f.4{G-:< 6f'JM

    ~ VL

    A"->.

    ~fu I
    );( (6A

    \5fl<l>11"i <£W1 z(0'5~ "11~


    9~<:j'i

    \5G1m ~

    <:r~
    <1<:j~

    'i319(,~ I

    <R1~

    <r~ CBf'i'f
    ~

    <ilC<:j~f, >jC~i"i

    - 1 -,

    &1 I Zr

    ~~il: 13f) .,.~;~


    \5~
    foT5l?]

    C~

    l1t<R

    -;:rj C<i 9~'f~J<81C\!l <!l\5 ~'q

    ~q3fr'::~I~}1

    'It-\!l~T*\!l

    Z'l,'\5fl~"'lII~

    1:Jl5 "fTb ~
    <@1'

    C:"i

    c<:r

    "{I""-~

    '3-Q thana;s I~ 'ii'\!l<l,,?\!l ~


    cQ\5

    2l'lFf9i Mt\!l ~

    .C\5t! {vt;f
    '>'j~

    9fR

    ;n

    {/j ~

    c:Wr
    <Q~

    '3lQ ~

    C"1~

    '1f~,

    11<f "1(;01 <!l~1 2l~

    <1"1<1 03P
    ~~

    P-'''''J!M'

    >!('@IT:"i ~

    N'0 <v;l.~
    ~"><]~

    ~(pl ~

    ~C\!l __ .~

    ?f'i?l~

    :?/

    C~r<fv8

    C2l1:zJ~ ~ <J'0~ ~ ~

    1TI~0"'1" 'Ci!'Jl~I""j:j'( ?) I \5lJ1G19jfttTsl

    fit
    '"

    C9<wI

    er"U, ~ \5!T~ ~

    ~~

    Iv[{'~

    c<T ~1:111..;o!
    <M(x)

    \iRK ~
    I\... "Ji-~
    r-.

    ~
    ~.-...
    ~

    mm~-~
    \5~~1
    @9j ~

    <QWI ~R.'1'1

    ~i
    C-9 ~"i

    1"'-I"'-I'I'<i\")

    '9'1l"<:f ~-'3~

    \5ftf.! :l'fTGWiC\5
    .=
    1<11\')"'<1

    CJW1
    ~

    m CZi<t,
    C~ <!l~

    -m-M<H1NZ '5ll~
    ~G1 ~~
    ~,.p._,..,

    <ri'<. ~ T"1T.Sl~
    r-.

    ;n C'M, '5flT-i: T9]'9(j:{i!B! C<i"l~1 0'l~1

    i5!PIT'1" C9/<'l (,YjI·j<1 ZG!


    C"1c.GI'i-\5ffi~·
    r-. ~

    f'-_

    'K?f,

    i3<Pj"iq ~~ ~

    ~, \'~I~~~

    1'"l¥ I(.1(fti, C<i-qlnl,


    \5['ffi

    fDW
    qj

    m111 e<rr:Q ~ I ">jrc~


    cQ<ffi\

    lii1<lt'.G1'1, 'You ~ ~ ~
    ',?{P1

    .,1«,,, j)R9f-<r<lrf~t1 ;:m~


    '5ll11T11J:§IID"1_";i:f-cQ<:[

    B"ti?,1T.liTm 'il<1> IWZ f.iCl1, k@(1~<.jj'l1 :ii~, f.t';$I \5ll'T~ ~ (!l't>! ~ I "1.>J<fUi

    are quite right about that' <li'TIVn1 C~, ~ <it


    ~~i 15ji&]"<:[

    <!l1'~ 1<71(<71';, ~I

    ~~\P'1i ~

    <1N~i"'i ~

    I \5l1~

    \5M~~~~1

    '9'<li ~~
    <il~
    ~

    <n I ~!~I
    <in1, ~

    "1'''1'1 C'3l ~?l

    ~i"r-<fil ~
    '5IC~

    (S9;;tO~011'normal'
    I

    <il'?llp1"'1 <!l~ C~"1C'1r®-{ ~ 'wellformed'

    \51<nG1 ~~G'!'it,
    ;ro, context ~
    (I:?C<1 9';j(.CI,jj_..j ;n

    <!llP1l~, ~ ~ ~~

    <!fit
    ~

    ~1.QOt$l

    L\5I ~1
    ~:wrl

    ?l1fm
    <f>j<{>j

    Hf;;f\5 paradigm PiRn, "fl"ff;?


    <1>('?l

    ~tBI
    '~~',

    ~
    \5l19j~ ~

    '3oWl(';\5

    ''5ll~'.JGf~-~,<t~r<fIl9j~ ""1"~<P1CCj~, ~1
    ~

    i7ll~,
    ~-::l>

    0fG1yf,lii1<K"1t1,

    'VI"1i<F11~<l"
    ~?'

    I <!l<lX \5l1"l~
    ~G'j~ ~

    0Tff>
    ~ -\5)~

    ""1"~
    <f(Pl

    Syntagmatic '1i
    ~'T :
    <1>Q{I-~

    paradigmatic

    aphasia?

    '&lR ~
    <!l~ ~

    'fDi.<P ~
    -'qll~

    : '\5Br<>\<:f, \5l1~

    ~1~

    z"l~Mvr
    1<71ffi: ~

    0~
    C?)~

    ~<n c<:r
    ~"R'Bf

    ~~G'jr~-.,

    \51 ~ "~
    <il1"1'J;n <P<:f'1?!

    I <1>Q{I f.Tv:r ~11

    "",iG<7I ~~ <1Mm1 C9l~

    ~ m <IBI,
    "';~ ~~

    '-'1~"t"fi
    qlf-ic~
    ~

    "l?! Gl ~<rRr~'1<:f
    ~\g

    m
    <q>qj '5!B1

    \!lC~

    ~~ 1'1"1"11 <5jJi<l'~

    I '5JJ1~
    ~'3

    nfZC"11 «1>@ \'5lTl"l'~

    ~
    ~
    ~

    f.TxQ'>l WJ
    ~
    ~ .. ~

    I '&1"18f ~ 't4JI<q>Ic'\§fit<il C~

    C'11: I '<1P1
    : . ~

    \51

    (}j

    ~~<IJ1<1:
    \5ll~

    ~-'3l

    'b(1'l1\ffi" ~ ~

    \5fi"l1~ m9fM CQJt<f.

    ~m :zv.:r
    SjJ.!1PSli
    ~~<i(,Gji1 ~

    C"i"Dfo11

    8frn <1>qj-<n-~1

    '¢l1C\i2. I '5ll<ilQJ1, pQ.)1, \5i"<l1 __'q"Qj<rl «1>l-;Wt

    C>!i"'iTi7lI~i\?{
    "?!15<TI ~ -\51Tm1

    <iJq r <5fN
    I '5ll1 <5fl~ \!:i~

    <l<i1(\;i11

    '9~if"1 'i'j~ \5l!~1


    'QTff9"l:?l<li',

    '-'1~

    ~<j

    P1F11

    '-'1k111~

    ~11l1
    ~1

    ~<1fiZ

    <P'1(,\") ~C<71 C'il~, ~'i,


    1'~9

    R11'1
    I ~

    \5liStm

    '5PPQff : «i'l~

    '"tlll:?lP1<il' BNf, C<Pl-;Ti)j ''6111I:?if4q;' I <!l~

    C>WLC>!~""VIl:?i1&i$l

    '&11
    ~

    C<:rit11)r '~9f\5l<1I' \39]1 meta-'11><1<p


    <l'~ .. :~q9ffu>j(Q

    '1.fiSl'rt '1i''1.t1J
    I ~\<ji\")'G
    \~1<fi<:[

    <!!<1> \!ilf@<q> C<fi9f-<>l"n0'1 \5!iCrn ~

    ~$~-(.mfu<P!
    _ I

    ~-yf

    \51<rr\!i'G
    "l~-\!l~c.1rm Gl ~

    9tr/
    <:;:

    ~9ff~ "11'8 ~ order-a

    051 <l>"<f1 ~

    \5Tt"m11 '&1~
    Si<fi\!i'l$t<P

    C9f"li' C\5l '\5i'tt'-\!i'G order-(0 ~


    <N.<71jf.i<l:

    cWi ~
    ~

    ~%," '!>Ti9j"R
    cQ~

    r:;:;.r/

    <Kli, symbolic ~
    ~,

    meta-symbolic ZG1 @f3 ~-

    N@TI"l\51 ~,
    ~ ~C41

    9j)i1fi.5~C'l1'1~mopG Dl~ 0f~ ~

    '0Ri '6119f"'111 ~

    '>'jT<l"j\5

    '-'1"1.,'Z
    ~
    cQ~

    \5I<rI !iJl, ~

    C1I<:r <!l~ G;R!QH I

    '1>ltlU{Y

    <rm C>!'f!1 ~"'fl C\51?

    '5lf<r"~'Zl <i1 super ego ~ '1W!/~/'Ul~ i ~,


    ~
    "'1Z....!!?: i.1:?\!l<'l '61lT-i: ~~ \!iff"lTl1

    ~
    '51~ i;5·r;n

    -'&@l

    C:1ll1 ~~,
    ~"1 <!l~ <!l<l"1l1ll'Q\ I "~
    "S~

    ._

    I\. bAA "0\5 ('1'31fl1 ~

    "

    ?l11Bl(.·Y"<p ~4r-."m9?K·n
    <i~

    ~fG~""_

    '-<lZ'1" D).z"1'1 paradigm shift ~

    Jm "'~

    CQ.'0ll

    \5l1l ~

    ""1"9i~iG1iZG1 ~o{."'\5Fn-"'~!
    M{'\")

    I ~"i

    ~,
    ~4 ')8"

    <:>@~, ~,
    8lC~,¥, ~ '1'iJH" '1~
    ">!~;S>j~

    c<nI 2lFlit}i'3

    i5'lt ~
    I 9f"~ <1JI-&'1 ~1~j&i

    9]M"11~ \3

    '<:f1W

    "'I'b,
    f.Bfi
    :~

    I 1Jl<p<'lCq<j" W;<>t <f?§f'0 ~ t1~1<l1:1l1 "Sfl~

    '61 ~(<i<71 <A~~

    '5fI~ f,8,~
    -;:rj: \5l1~ ~~,

    ?$\<;1~, '><)41' 9l0l> 1?;G1i ~?


    <!!?'1<71 '3ffl~c",ni<i'

    \5"i<nT0

    ',;nr

    m
    ~~

    ~lfil

    \5l~

    :>;~m1'1[

    9f~

    \5'41
    "l_"g ~

    q>'<.~

    <fl'Tl7:'iI1i

    6Mj

    <1)r:;"1J'@ I

    ('414

    c9f1i , 2lGk\~~(;q
    itl1~I'1'm,

    "Ii ~1l mit1"5!

    ~Hf.!)1

    9@

    ~,

    <il~i[;

    CSTf'<M ~-

    . 1lRi I (;r"i

    ~-.:rt,

    :>'lr~\6 ~

    ~'"?f ~

    ~~'1! ,ffif~

    QJ

    <rrn
    ""1''f-C~

    (.<P~ >i'&lil01~ ~~'

    'i51~1 Gt:~~ ~~

    .~~
    '~~'~~;

    \5f~~z : <!Q[j~{ff1
    \5l,~~

    !J1C4 ~it~ ~
    t:fffi

    ~m ~d:l r.r}

    '1f~ '~ ~rn


    ~·C ~

    @9f~

    :qs(3lw{?

    (}'P~

    Qi 'OI1~-;l]

    'il.3l&:E1\$\''i,!

    r-..L..:-.

    1i~'~ ~

    ')p~K~~ ~

    O1lBm' ~ ()
    is at the height no
    common

    "51~ "<Kiii

    <is'QJ1, 'When

    a love relationship

    11J~ J1~'~C4:9t9f,

    ""l?Urn

    R,~~~

    t room is' left for any surrounding world; the pair of lovers are sufficient
    unto themse lves, do not even need the ch ild they have in make them happy ..' (1930 : 79-8,0),
    ~~ ~ ~. <1Ff\!?l .10'

    ...
    ~~.~

    .~~ 11\iRbc~ 'T;fi1i


    .~
    ')~:~<!"Jfim ~<"'n~l
    ~~(5a

    :9'~ Ifi ~<p~1~~9.tBr<m:,~,rn,~~?


    ~f?r 4f1\'b~?
    ~! ~b--'

    ~~~~]~

    ,-Jt~I~rlrQ~ ~"<T<rr~

    ~
    ~

    9~1' tlG9( ~.;n C~C1


    F

    4~~r1J1' I ~
    "6t~\!i,

    -'

    lnf ~~c1~-~
    ,

    1~

    ~t

    (\5[.<t

    t~<~~~,~\5fi~~
    \5l$I'€

    '?!-:1!.q~

    ~1.I$l

    (f1'~

    r\5t~

    '\:!)Br ~1<)T
    I t,<N~(3t~4S
    ~·I

    ~l.11i%' ~

    ·lfj~tn '$r~\!)l ~
    05r.?f <.Ill~~?-1

    c9>lUf C~
    ~ r.,1il?f!<1u'i'!if

    ~lt'7l, ~~, -=,,~'bI4~""'"",~, rn~;

    C1' P.l~1Ui

    Wi~"
    ,~

    '~~~¥rnr ~~~
    tQ~ ~~

    %L
    I~ I"

    i4~@'$nr~~l1~~
    ~"111~

    ~-'

    9jh~1\!)f\l3" . ~k{}ifID59jt?1'fl

    ........ ~.........
    '~41'01~~

    ('~\!)G?N3 ~t<fS

    0'ltlt &i&~~~~~
    'Ol>r~,'~
    ,(,1J'~~

    '__ ~1<:~'<41 ~r.l ~'\';!W


    Ol15M' ~

    '9j~<lI\5l ejr.e.rC'ij-;:t ~' ~


    ;

    ~il"F

    (ASl~'

    ~&
    ~

    -. m~, ~~

    ~r

    ~/~

    ~'-'~'iS1~
    ?ffi]~-i [

    <Y~1!R.VJ;... I' '~R?t"t1(Q'['~


    \!I~'

    H~~ ~<t~
    {""""'"-..

    ~fflt~
    :
    .. G"j~,

    ~'M\5fG:rn

    ~<1t~r1~1!(l\!) ~3JH:~~~ ~
    I('~

    ~>f=r~ ~V1
    '{3~'~
    '"'t.....

    'ih~
    "

    ~Hi~~~'"
    FR11

    ~fBp1 <.glt;~,~~

    ~1R ~~'"
    ~

    Zli\D~rQl ,m
    ~

    ~.,-....

    \5l'f\;~
    !:.i]':qs

    cirlP~•

    '~lI~lql'itt.~ ~-~
    ~ '~~
    ~~I

    2iq~

    I'"
    ~4Bl~,1
    (Fj~ ~

    '~C~~ l1f{!§ji C-4iGit ,~


    ~

    ~
    \~Hiiii~f§

    ~{~'11:~nt,~ '~lSJ~TJR

    Ttt~:~ ~5rFtGf~
    '8 ~.

    ~f\3,

    ~j~Rf ~~~.t~
    I

    ('i"1t'"
    ~

    1M~ <[jF<i~~ ) ~

    eJ'?PI~!

    ~"'I

    'R>J:l

    X1~i1

    <TI'~t~ ~. N~
    $i(OQ'j \9~

    ,~
    ~~~',
    (~ 9f1~

    ~~

    \5JBr'

    c~

    ~R.;p ~
    ~Q'

    \51'1'Gt1~c;;j~:ii
    ,:,!j<p Ii'

    p. '9j'~
    ~~ ~

    llt"l ~

    ~~

    '1Ml
    ~~
    b~
    ~'~

    '~~~i$3ii4~~

    ~'R3t:?1 <f1% ~
    ~~tt~~
    \5~?f

    ~r~~~H~
    ~''1:\5f@-lil'~
    ~

    VlJ?JN·~r..~
    ~'~
    (jJ' ~

    ~J41H C:?11ffC?i
    qf$,~CSfl8

    ,~
    '~' ~'I

    <fD1

    \~~
    ~';{J.

    ~
    C~ om1 ~

    ~~~11~
    ~

    ~1\!}tG1'81

    1~j\Dm M~i~"$! \5t~


    ~1Ff ~

    ~9U? ~ ,~ ~'iV1 ;rj' ~) ~$~.~f¢1 'b1~ ~~, ~' ~~l~~~~'Rb


    ~C\!l .~-~~ ~
    ..~ '
    CYM)
    ~I'

    i5fj~c:w 151~t.~ ·ifi ~~' I ~~


    (flifi

    ~~<l1iSl~lSl
    ,~,*

    ~1" ~«~t
    ~~~t~
    'i:C~1 (<f$f:

    '~?

    \5fI'j;fi~ ~~
    f~Gl ~?l
    ~~

    '~
    ~\!),

    ~~'X'j19j, ''Ii1(3!f~fpi~I <rr11 r.;lG~$! ?11\5ti9'fij', ~-~~Jl~

    ~<v~ ~,

    "iM <v,~

    C\eJU4' '1GGll : C<P~ I

    ~1r '&~?l"'tftGf,~ ~C~

    ~~
    "J'f'i" ,~. cOl>i1 ~~
    )f'(g:l~

    I .fl~

    'b~~)

    ,t8<iFl, ~~~

    Xj'~~~m~

    ~~"R

    (.'i)~.~

    >!iii, @~wr~
    111f-'

    ~q

    m;
    ,""_'"

    fl.'.·9IBl.' i~ . .~~ ~~c>l1'$f *,,(.<l~ ~tm'5j~f?g I \5Bl'~


    \511.

    <n :<<lr~
    Gfi'Si~·

    ~.;' .. ~

    XJ~ .cm~)

    ~f~~1J~M,~~
    <l!C:~
    .~

    ,~~fq~, C~

    ~R,t"qK~
    (.4@lGr~rn ~~ p' ~~' '4~

    r6~

    C~~j~@

    fI1t45~
    C~'Cl\g:

    C~~~,~

    \5i~~

    I t)j~$l{,\1~ ~

    ~r;l. 11~.~

    ~$f

    .~

    (.~~

    M(~ iTt~l~
    't).~

    "~~

    ·\5f1nt ~~~:
    'GfIiir'1~,

    ~~ ~
    \!l.~ ~.~

    iJl~

    .~~

    ~@f1r
    X'ott"@ ~

    ~
    @~(G1

    ['f
    'e.

    ~r~r~n~ \&141~l~
    V\!lT~J~·~~

    '6{i\;~1J
    (X51~

    @i~.'

    ~?f
    Y1fi~ .tn!i
    \5l1~

    'I)ffi

    is'C1(b ,·fIit

    'tM, ~
    \~~:'6

    ~~(;~t

    ~fiI ~1!if~

    ~~C.q)

    ......

    -q~~100~
    ~L\ti~ I~
    ~<p

    ~q,'G1 ~

    ~~'lfii!? ~"1tm

    <w~~'fZ~'c7J$t ~~M ~Sf·~· ~"'t cm~~l5J ~~ \~~

    'rrJ
    ~

    ~C~Jj>~.!::11-~liC~

    C'511b{;51II/ @l~
    '~R\!I~U;1

    ~~-rn

    ~
    ~.

    1/ C~~<M~ '519f ~R ~Qj~ "~ 5~ ~m ~§~


    -fc1f1C'0Rr
    ~~t;(il

    C'JfG1II/~

    ~i/~b~),*

    oo~ ~

    ~,¥15!"

    V~~
    ~t<>1~

    ·~~~~SlL~~'9iJ

    fi;~c" :ztPi 1 "51~C~4M.

    '~~,

    ~~

    Kfi~~t9j~

    ~g ~;:lt~t C~~ 111~t91 Gr 'e'1"5l\B1iJ't>11:i I

    ~'"<,~?

    '511~ ~
    eif:1"19fQ ~1'i'1l< ...

    zrn '8f'1fI~
    ~,

    q"i1~
    ~ ~

    Bc!;"1ji.:2}1

    m, m

    I ~~

    ("1m 'lR~

    ~
    ~

    'SJ.'1 '5f'<l1!

    ~"5{

    11R'il'>l ~(g
    ~ ~

    "11SV~fi<rr'1~"5il~'-~
    ~

    "l1!i'(P'H

    ~-f.t9J~

    1 0?n'1@

    1ffi1Qj Ql ~

    I '5f'<R!

    "1f"<f ~
    ~
    ~

    't:l
    "if.....
    ~~.~
    .

    .,..__

    %1"1'1 ;rll \5R'~

    ~ '51I'li~
    ~
    9fj{><[

    erci~ ffif[<~,~ B19f


    <l'('!1 ~

    "i1l:'<J %"i ~
    1''<f1 "W1 ~,

    IJi I'

    ~
    ~(.D'!(_I

    ml~ <101(.\!) cm1'B! ~


    C~M<jI@ ~

    Q.ffC<f.,

    '\3~
    ~'111'

    ~~.q>R.'1'>l
    9['<f ~

    Zi~<F4

    ~-rn C9f@ '8?51


    ~

    ~·'Tli

    W 1f'~'<K01,
    f.iffi
    ~
    ~R\!)

    <jJfu;9j13 ~
    ~ ~

    '<fist ~~
    'T! <r01k.~'S, 11/1P ~ ~
    \!)8111/'ll
    9J~

    '\!)~pf-<.!j<[

    ~
    ~~ ~1

    I/~

    C'lI3l c!:l1' ~

    ~ I "l}~ ~

    <RFR, '~

    ~"R ~"i

    1/~~
    ~

    9/"1)l\.'b ~
    <j\5

    ~9j"i

    ~ ~

    'LJ"'1 ~
    1381~

    .m
    ~
    (~

    m~~ ~
    1.:<>11' ~"<r-~,

    '5IlJT1 <J1<:<! ~ ~? D1'1l'lfllS ~ "~

    il1 CI5\!

    J1\~1b(<i-:1.l!l<!' dfn:>

    ~lftk(i.G1<j I ~11Vl' ~
    ~

    m\

    00 'Sl1<A~

    "19f~ C-N?1j<'~<11 llt~C<P1'<f1

    ~l:f.i~
    (}fI~

    '1Q arf"i l:f.i~ 1/ ~ ~ 1/ C'5I'Tfr }jR_\!) <T1V1 <j\5


    ~
    051"TI ~'1 8!l'$l'Jf<:oo;
    ~

    c9Jli5<111/<m~ ~,
    ~

    l!l"<f. f.i~ <Fll~ c!l~

    ~
    C<>l~($1

    <m.<1 '{3~ ~iTill

    11/ ~
    11/1~V<t1 ~ ~ 11~~
    ('9J~,

    9f'<t,i'f.'3 <iiG1 ~ ~
    ~:rr;;!

    <ilfu I/~
    <Jf(;1 <:j\5

    ""Fl
    ~
    II'

    am:9~~\~

    -n, ~
    '1i)~

    mr 11/211"1~
    ~ <r,
    ~

    i51f?f@ 'ecJ
    (S1"[?f ~

    wn

    &~
    ~

    c~

    Rs["iT<r(Si)
    ~

    ~ ~

    ('bM 4im C'>l19f"l-~r:wz? r;<R. ~

    ~
    ~~

    I/~
    05i

    DR,
    -2l~

    ~~"&

    Di'1 <>11<1\;'1 ~? ~-~'>l1->i9f81


    '5f'<l<r\ ~-~lV1<r
    ~9J~

    .l!l<r>l\5.'<)ij ~ \5fI~

    l!l~

    '5f@l ~ f.ifi(~ l!l'Z ~


    ~?

    '!zt'ifl

    \5l'<l<r\ <'VoT"l1"Ji-

    s l!l'<)ij'{3!
    ~

    <fl1\m~~

    1>@

    \5fi-.:n17fi-~
    '~! ~

    "'l(\bi':'i3t
    ~

    fu~'Pi-~
    Co:>JVf.~~J1l'&5 ~ \5itt"if,

    '&"i1~W
    ~:?fJH 0m ~ (C~

    I C<nQf[

    <n~
    ~

    f9f\{l'Jf<:"B! ~~
    ~I
    t

    \5lI(9f ;rl ...~


    <fl<11~ il1?

    \51119f? c<l' f<l~~1 2i~


    <n1

    ~1/9f\5!1 ~ ~
    ~
    '1'j15i5:j'Z3Mi

    W1

    '5lM<>1(.'li

    Gffi"ii'DiI<m C"\<r ~ <PI,

    trRJ
    <i'@

    "l'ff"10i' \5f1~
    ~i.\!)i1r:

    ~"fif&1'b Wi~

    ~Fb'-l'ill1 <i>"Ii
    "$l <:H<J
    <J~

    ~ <ri, '5ff6-;j1)"-l

    \5fi"fil...'

    m~
    IS

    C4i 9!\3i? C4i er~

    \5mM9!~
    WoilI~

    fl_
    ~

    2?Z"i <1>il1 ~ <1',(1111 11t"f1 ~


    '~'

    '{3Q',

    f<is? '13, ~

    'L'%i
    '('JI?;, ~

    '<liW1 ~

    ~ \5~ ~ ~?

    M<-I~
    "11% ~

    <rf!'fG'j

    "PL ~

    "Pl, ~
    ~
    <>f'~

    <rm I ~ ..l!l~

    n"4 _.Ill
    '-

    er@J(.1' ~
    e.

    Dl'f "<lTFl~,
    ("1°"1(1

    '-'I11."if ~
    9fC\!:>~ '1?l"?l

    (9i111--y<

    ~J.
    4iC'1

    <TIl) ~"i

    ~ 1'<1."\1

    1'''I~"l1
    ~?

    ./ ~-~'1
    ~<5i'ffi\!)

    C<fl"m-<j"l1'

    Rvr ~
    ~

    '511~'1
    ~

    4i'!1IB:C<>1'l

    ~~? -2l~ '~

    ~9'Q

    fu ~
    C~

    t~G1-Gl"f1I'l1 <r:~ ~? ~n"?l~


    "I'1V'fi1? ><M'!1~l l!l<!' Dm

    19j~ 9f1ft <r! ~~


    1 \5Bf! l!l~ W1~
    CSI~

    ?fIi8l

    ~~

    (teleology)
    ~'ij

    I c2ilv (l<nf3~1 Fl> -M(l:iz


    r.BGlI'kr:<>1"l?

    FR3 ~
    ~'! <il~

    srf'€'

    +'.Iflt4i .::nk;

    'Wi? l!l~
    ~

    m~
    0

    <>iiC<1" CI31~? ~ ~-<lJ1f<i-"!,¥J'!1 ~ ~? ~

    ~
    'lR~

    ~ "fi\!i:tl:!'i1

    il1, ~ \5M cqfit ~

    \5l1("i' '5l'<Ri '(\!)<>1i<li'il ~

    \5ffV'l 'Tl

    .ft> ~iU1'!1 ><OO?


    '1("1'>l ~
    Uf.:I1' WC'1I4i'1

    l!l~

    <r!wlV'f'1 ~'1
    @'1~ ;ON:\!) 'ljt1~G1%G1 %~

    9JJiD ~

    "J? ~r;~1J{;q1
    01" ~

    r.b\Fl
    ~1J

    051
    ~

    M.

    C4i. ~1<ilfe(BI~ '1(GiIBJ.01il, C4i.-<[

    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    '511~ l!l13 ..~~


    (<1'''1(.01 \5fI'<[

    "'llfjj<!tCl
    ~"?l 05f ~:

    '''ffi''Ji em '1M'!11'J
    SRI

    f<is
    \5~

    ~'{3 I

    Fl> ~
    ~~ ~

    <f.t'<r!

    'Q17,,,,,

    *'l<i <i1M>(

    M.
    ~

    c~
    \;b(~
    Wf.j

    "i*,L~1~

    <f-'1t"-l ~rh!

    ~lIb<;lj I ti~

    f9r.
    ~

    C4i.-<[ ~ ~?

    13<R "T01 Blf.i,


    ~

    ~
    ~?

    "1iM"'Mf c~
    ~

    '5Il<rr<i '@ 9f@ ~


    O'f"'l1"<r BI'lfl t"1(\!)

    "The development of paternal domination into an increasingly powerful state system administered a continuance
    1929 : 94

    <rI ~.~

    'I3i
    "'1,~

    by man is thus

    "11S~"c"l'>l?
    QJl l!l~

    13j'{3 '51I'<i1"?l ~ >£L;<1G1 ~ I ~I"'fH1'

    C"iDJ l!l'f. 1'Ri~


    O<fG'lTIl!

    of the primal repression, which has as its Marcuse, 1956


    <Q ~'f-l~!

    '5f1<r l!l<!' COf"'R!n1 11V>1 ~,21I~

    <fl C<0'IT:P GW'f1 \'5f1'1 ~

    C\51

    purpose the ever wider exclusion of woman." (Otto Rank, .


    @'{I\!), : 68)

    ~9flf0~
    \!!lj;1I'il
    ZGl

    &~,

    '{3 l!l<l'~11V>1'5l-GiIre<l'
    ~'8~

    <R;G4, ~

    9iJlJ:i

    "i'fP1 <.ff1:Gr ~
    ~

    9JC1111 "<J1j.;-Wi

    "'iWt
    '<,t\5'lj

    <@\, 'fermination

    of biological mother

    '9

    l!l~\

    ~:>1 anni-.

    0W1 'Gffi~ C<ff'Sli1~<jK<l' 'Sft<r<r, ~ C'>fC\Z ~-~I<'l

    1I$l<1I' \!)\!)'l?c'1

    \5lfull1)?1
    l!l1'

    'L<Ji)j

    hilation of
    <i'~*1~

    1?-~?
    0m

    <rt ~

    'dH1P{;' ~C9J'<r ~~

    \5f1~I'<fi-®

    mw

    <Jl1l ~

    ~9

    '1\-~\Q''b1~ ~

    C4i1VTI

    C"i<f ~?

    <PJtft

    "

    . I K!ilthat E<!<·em!ll 2ml Proof} 4.1

    1 tf'f

    'W'1,

    0111 am!,ili~lation -rn,


    l]J~
    ",)&<1:0:

    castration «01! .~
    ~

    'I)"'0l ~"'~i:li
    1~qf9
    <j5~U1 ;;rf ~~'31t?

    ~~~C>6

    ~~(,~ll$ltlSi~tf\!)
    (Y"C~)

    \Ofi{J ~.~

    -;n'~
    t<M(or11 ~
    (-.p~~t

    '5ffDl .~ ~.~
    tfl~'6~~~~

    s(

    mffl~

    '1.~) MUl "Ff; ~

    ~it<f~Ai-\~~ ~. a.rem <rI1A ;n I R0i~ _...., ~~ '~ f~:, \5fl?'~ ~ ~ifl1% '~$->1lf~'~J9 MC~ ~~~i~l1\&~'S'8r 're~~~~~R\t)14;~t\§ '9jPFi ~~L .. ·~ ~ '?tC<1~C ~ (J.5tr C~~

    ~c.~t.~~!

    ~&1{/f~

    a~ C.1\M1M~
    .___

    Beyond the pleasure principle? ~~. {?j~~,. r-i,t.~ ~1;c~ .~ ~{,~<pUl . .,~ I ~ ~ ttl~' -\!Ill~ soc·Jiety-~· ·interfa.ce-r.fl~. ~
    ~ ~'~Z-Ql~ ~
    1

    ease study ~.

    quantification
    rr-...

    C~~ (ff5R~l~ test-'IS

    0rn <p{3it>{R
    ~

    '¢[f.~

    ·~rn(3J ~
    ~

    : psyche

    ~~

    ........

    <pQtl. <nFI Ilt~@1!? ~~?

    ~
    ~~
    \!}(.<l'

    ~~j(.I$!"J1

    (~~R~ C~
    ~~~~8;
    ~'8.

    <!Ill", ~f<l\!)Ng
    ""f?§1~<1~
    )

    ~'?Rt", ~
    "'"

    ,,"~'i11'fi ~

    ~
    it""'

    W iii<:<i>;~
    ~
    '<4~
    ...,;;;e¥l...."lj?1!""""~,..,..,.·~

    (Q~~~~...(fj~

    t!1:'6l$J ~ <P;1<;lfil<r H~R:~~~~ ~~.~~~ "


    ~Z-H(]!~
    ~
    ~~<l~'O

    \5fj'9fR\5l1m-"?f

    ~-<n"'i.~ '<iG'j;~ C\5JotFt,~?fi

    ;~ff&51~l~~,
    .:$\

    ~~I

    : lK~~'"1~

    ~ll~~ 411(qj- ~ ~i% ~'t~ <p'QJ:i! ~rn


    Q4l?]-'\5~

    ~~.'~~f4.'+l~ ~, ~-~1~

    .'2l~q

    q.;-;1{.~ ~

    'H~~ i\;,~
    '~'I

    \51,~~'ffll' <.fft1 ~.
    ~fiJ~·
    ~

    ~~ro?A m~~c~t
    liT·(.<p ~~.~

    i ~:W
    11

    '~~~·\Di
    .

    '<BJ51'0~; '? \5fm'~ qi~101$l

    <rt'9J

    I \!)+(~?l, l>i~~~

    ".

    GWt? ~~
    \!iBf~
    C~

    ~.~~

    ~~
    ~(£

    <pVfI,'C!~rn
    1 C9J~'
    '-

    ~<1>it~
    ..;:;:,.

    <nPi

    ~.-<) -.Q"<M
    ~-~'ffi:
    "ql~'
    ~

    ~rm'"'(i
    ~,I

    N"'lFfi1 ~
    9.0.

    ~i<f.\~f
    .~~

    '~

    <r~3J ~

    .-...

    ~~

    ~o ~

    exeension

    ~ .~. ~

    .~
    1.(;~ ~~~

    C4i®S! ~
    ~{.~
    '8~~' ~

    vr'fl;,
    ~:
    .. -

    (£j~

    '<nwt

    t·%{.G1t)4(.:Sj'~W11

    Qt&'¥ ~

    ~
    .~

    I
    :.~

    !.fl%1' ~C&ii
    ~

    <fS~1(i; ~.~

    9fi6

    ~.~~-;1(5~1

    \5ll~"?l11 ''sC~1j· ~'~iC~'G

    :>i~t-i1(~~ ~

    1 ~t~ ~C~

    ~~~

    e.tG1'ijii1 .~-

    v@r. ~.

    ~~-!r "ifCI!)j'-PF
    '~;rniY;9j~ ~'~~~
    ./

    Gratuity
    ~ ~ ,Q,.. ~U'~~ \Bi=1N'S
    .

    (:~~-~?i
    ~ I <!J'f.~
    .

    ~.

    ~.'<,!}m

    ..,

    Q3f~~
    .
    ..
    -

    '~C<l01-1 (~·f.i1'eJ&1~{~ .(l)1~~l1fl·~


    t\b\5(31m
    ~~ ~~
    '\!l
    .

    f9JY.$f

    G~~ I'
    G

    \5D~m ~.,.
    ~
    I

    ~
    ~ Ci,I~9~

    ;~I"!P~~l ?j?l~r~.C~
    ~ ~
    <pB'~

    >jl&lP{V1'~?
    ~
    .

    Me:~-i~""t~·~I.'%
    ~
    ~ Vl~~L~ ~
    "'.

    'l'1t~t~l9i 4'?K~ '~~~JI\!)*1

    -,,-,,,

    ;;j~<fS C9f~ ~l ~:NOji~~:~.), "5~ ~.,


    ~~\5 ~.
    {<!~
    ~(31

    \5fl~11

    ·f¥G.~ .~T'W
    ~.
    '="...

    M~BP

    'iR4k~ <gM~

    _~~
    '~~ .~
    ~

    ~~
    f4~

    ~~

    ~~"1~

    .t::i(~ 1l1~C'$$i ~rq~j'~R m~c-:q ~'.; &i1ibit!J~ bj~~


    ~ C~

    '1~~ffi .~~
    I

    N:.P>1 ~
    ~
    ~, t<p~

    ~C?l

    ;;rt ~~<4rn\f3,

    ~15J '5.1"'1>tG.Sl;51 ~

    -Q~>i1 ~~
    .~~

    8N3

    ~t..

    (W~¥l ~~i?lL1rn)

    ~
    .q~i!

    ;n '~TiIT ~
    ~

    i 'C4il dl~

    Jf<i PNnl~ ~

    1~~ IQ5i '? ~ '4., '~ ~

    null worker (~~"


    ~.
    ~'<

    ~ (9J"t<Jt ~ .~~

    ..~~
    'I ~~

    ~'4l<p

    ;rn") .~.
    '13'~

    "0J \5fI:"I1f~k\5? ~~,


    ~~

    ~
    ~Qf1,

    It .... >i~~" ~

    031'

    c.~~ ~~?t'~l$lR?~\!)Ci~

    "\(;"41'51 '~~

    (;ffi;~N:~~~.~

    <r~' ~tf<l"Pl ''q~


    ~"~
    ~

    ~~~rn- ~f1A

    ;rr ~~

    r.tR:~

    't:bC~\!.l-;;rr:x~l~
    •

    <N9fI,

    \Gm ~
    ~

    ~G1~<P«':~ ~

    01<g ~ f>i~j'\5R.~

    ~~d1RiSi{j.~m4tfCii· ~
    !Ii\!)~~f?f

    ;Q~ ~.

    "'.=t<t \S'l~~~?

    9l':@; ~<1~, .~~


    \5l~~J ~'~ 2t~.

    {{~1<.:<gli \5l13?1~~'~~

    ~~tG1lC~Pif&'~

    (\5li~ )~i\b.q.lNf.. ~~\, \5lC<UR;i6fC~ro~.iDi~~ ~ ... ~1Sf~Wt .~ \'5lj\1ffi\&,~"~


    ~

    2fI~131; ~4~\!)

    :ffl~
    ~
    I.f[~

    ~(j{lH~it~
    '~9f1G1

    4~tRs ·~~~t~
    ~·~C~

    i~t~l'f1,

    fW~~ '~

    >i'1lJRJ 8l<WR ~

    -\5[j'~~

    .~~~ 'OUi

    S:iS :(cm

    C~.i

    ~tt~ \!)~~-~
    ·-.\5fI~l 61<Fif~~~ .~

    jl<fffi'~ 1i4~'-1 C?tl~1!f

    II

    GllC§[f$fi(irii't) testosterone poisoning I ~f-J11~t~1-0f10'!~ .~

    (mnRb :
    f4~~ Ci1ic:~fijl~1@;i &TI~(.~~~~ F$ ~mr\51t~ ~mC3 ~ \~Hjlf !fM' (~~? f~~ 6tl(.~ JlHn-t:'11 .~
    ~;n,.
    ~"1 ~~. ~

    1J~rlt-ilQJ

    tro)

    dll: ~

    '~

    ~ I 1_Z ..Q~

    ct;PG;i=j! ~fiji-.~~

    .lQ~

    <f-QJ1 ~cerSi

    {.~~" ~~
    (JiGl~.

    c\~n?

    'OIrn~1
    I

    ~)
    ~

    <rnV6'~,GL;r-}j;J9

    'Fts

    M~Rf-'( '6lJR.s>W91UFl ~?1'1 .~ ~Ch'51 \'5r~M~


    ~~.
    .q(.~1 ~

    en ~~ st~t c;nt~t?· ~.~


    >j~~m~). \Sl~.G1 ~
    9!"~~ otl'1@i

    ~\!)'~9
    I 1fI~ ~,:,

    C\!)j 'O~ ~

    thanatos
    ~i

    ~'~1.~~~.
    (}]C-{ ~5t~

    ~Z'Ji1~4
    .2Jf.~lP~.
    I.

    .!i1fu
    ~~. li1~

    F~(;~
    ~tt.~

    '~'-~~J4-~\Q)<'~~

    '$fjf~~J'71ii' ~
    ~CfI~

    bG4(<l

    ;n I ~r.'<!

    ·~t
    .,~~

    1rn~~!
    fJ~.~

    ~·W~Gci4 -sl.

    ~~
    lQ~

    ~1l~ ~

    '5ft91M

    "Gl~{;~ti

    C<4Gslf~~

    ~~.:f4s"~

    ~-~

    trivial

    ~Q.,IM)~

    fb:4

    .1~~ '1M~-'bllll'1t

    ~.

    tli~.. '5fl'?f

    \!if~'

    Cl1! "111 <ii<iBl

    vi

    ~~ f-t'nmr
    '5l(,<l'~

    ;n, ~mJ ~, \3

    <Q<l'~ eros

    -;ql~(,<;'!~'1'qj I 00Pl

    W1'3<m1f, ::11"<E1 00 $ ...~, 'I


    c>:iG ~ f~l"lH
    '5fI';j @<T?
    (i.R

    <f'qj ~

    I~

    <ft<:P ~
    '3l?i ~
    8[ ~

    ~~
    : 'i5l1>n?i C'ii.C:"'~
    ~*;11>jC:<i ~,

    e;1~ ~

    <i!<ll0-n <w7l lbi'8'h1<lfl

    c-nb'1C<r> om<R, ~(lJ'H4

    ";jJ)~ ~

    \5fi
    ~I<l(.~

    m\3

    ~
    ~

    &PGR",
    <n~0'f( ~
    ~

    \3";jJ)~' I

    \5f<l9f<:!

    fifiJ@'f:l11f~

    ~Z

    OSf3jlj!CC1 ~ '5l"1l\5

    ~f;:;

    «l'I7j \39f@

    fifc;5 ~

    c<Vo1? ~

    m\3 ~'>jl~
    ~

    <1"fC<t><i.

    W[i1 C?j'>'fl1" ~

    '1,-<Q<:!

    f.1mq

    21[cloSlI, \5f<l ~ I <iJ~

    9]~i3iMZ RGl
    '5l<'1(,~~ 1m \3Dr"l

    13.:i~-~

    ("$Il"lIU1Q ~

    'lJ':"1G ;n Flfu

    <il%1 C31 ~

    1fJ""i1C'3 ~

    'I1fCftq> @r%frfC\!)

    f5R, ~
    <FQfi <>I1~(''1<i

    (,trl"lt~ ~

    ~->iO@I'>1

    ",(§1H

    f1; \5Tl9tf,l? \5fi9t';fIVTl" ~


    ~"V'I

    -"l<lBl pj; ~

    ~:H~-<Q<:!

    ~i1>?
    ~ "Cffil

    "1i<l(,i$iWGI

    , omn1 ::pf ~

    A
    ~ ~ OJ...~

    '~

    -t"!,
    ~<1f6f

    ~2iRi:";j

    ;;;rr'i"<F.: eros ~ JWlf


    I e;~
    'j~

    thanatos:
    ~

    <r<J1fG
    ~
    <F@

    \5tQ)<j1

    -'5liDi, ~](.>i, \519f 0:!@ ~


    ~

    \51"<11 '5li\?i I ~c(

    41'1(:11 (:~\!)C1'Q: .!I~

    .!I~

    1f~ ~I

    <Q~

    ;n I \5ffj:!M Wlm C<l

    ~/7fj-~
    'K~

    f<\"9f"l'P

    (,'1]:>1"$1

    '<ItVf. ~

    C31?
    7fj,1'l;"C"l?i ~ c'<l0l> 'TIJ, 1'8'-~ <lV'IN:Cq.-,: 'D!-<ft~<l

    I ?'j[61C~ '8c2i ~
    <Q~

    ~il
    1$~'1

    ~f1 zVr ~ I t%n : $ll8ii~ c~ .®s '5l9ffit<:v.<ii<:! I ~

    ~,

    "l~ ~ >j!JTt"l ~

    -R>"{~ ;n
    '5lBl
    ~, -~,
    ~-li1~ ~

    (..'.5l.!<i

    'm~ 'm'4n'br
    <il~

    <iTf09f\') ~
    ...

    J'f,'!i'~"'C"l?i '5lf'5'fCl'f ~

    2l1'*m:! I
    ~

    i5Tl~? ~

    c<WN

    Hm ~1C"I1<iPlBl
    <jlQJj <'1C1(~

    ;;n c;m
    ~ ~
    '5l~

    <>IMJJ"1? f.tg>#; '5j(P11'1[:>Ji'1 i5TlN!! \5QfiM

    9f11:1 9f1t1 C31 ~

    R~"1'.§ c<mi<l

    9tiBl ;;n

    CqQSi~'1~iSl ~

    m,
    ~!

    <Q1<q>~

    <>I""R:1 : .!I"T'1 <Fqj <w7l ~~ '1<:.fC13~ \5fi9ff.1 ~,


    c<Vo1 c!1~ 2l~"""1
    <q>(1<i?

    'f-li'tTIR ~~
    ~ andropause ~I ~ \5<R\3

    .!IZ "P1" '-'IT'i"<l' ~/<ll~

    ~tlt."J1I·<:!
    2J~

    ,zj-~-'11

    c"i'<f

    q
    ~

    <3H

    $ '0l'1t' ~ ~I Ci'l1'b ~(~ 1fl1i:~'1 : ~erJormance anxiety? fbf.; ~, ;;n, <il~, ':i''X \111 1, f.'r(jq f.1w. ~L<t>
    '11
    c<F{?

    -"\3"01 ~
    Q5l '5fi"tIIQ)<I<TI4 ~9f
    ~@f

    em

    S1C'liMC~l:j"i''C1i831P!"i"-._Q~ ~q? «riMif.i"i'ur'!i


    '11
    >'j\5J-'<Rl'"G~

    <il-;qj1! \3Z

    f.Tmr:q

    w»r

    ~'<JH

    fo

    CF'K<R rnidlife

    ~H

    blue ~ <IDSS! ~Z~ c'71W ~ ~


    ~

    ~~~

    0i~1 :
    2:i~ "l1<1; "1V1)'1 ~
    <t@

    C'<l0l> m

    fils? ~~

    supposed

    objectivity-u

    \51f"i"m

    self-reflection <n \5t1~-~ <!TI'! ~. '1i, .!IZ <111 <i1<i; ("l, i5f\9ff.1 ~ ~ <l"<r.:! <?qj 1"1 I§2JPioi, \5"<r.:! \5ff';rm 'S01 :(.1"'-<"1 \5fi9t'";:fffi 'K'1J om;"l '-"()(,'" <iJ<ll

    ,~

    .-fI-

    '8l19ft\3 ><R@ 2:i~ '>f1QBl

    <ri
    ~

    .!I-;q;fl~

    <@1-~
    \51k_t?J ~

    me ~
    ~'?t

    ~
    fi"W5

    -<ri, 'Ti 'lS1B"I?I"'lit ~


    ~~

    misandrous ('1Z-f1('<l~
    '5l~ ~-'<rn" -;rn I ~

    11I?i 1~-<Q<:! ~

    '<tt<t> I

    (,S1IC~ <il<pj'>1~ ~ c!1"M f<l;- chronological

    ~11l-m

    '11 \51'8'11'11"11 '5fI'P1 C\5I <:5f@j

    'Bflf.1 '1.' <ff ~


    <r1

    o:nf<l;- <Q "1<qk<1 <;J '>fIl.9f<l


    ~~~"i~~?
    \5l)~~~~
    ~ ~ ~ ~

    >i1<1Rt<t> 'TIJ, C<t>IRi universal

    m9

    <iJ~ <1 <lIFb, ~9t~


    <r>m):5 ~

    <rm

    '11 \51'8'[1<'1111

    age-<.!l~ ~

    -\!llitP.ii, \5fi"1f.:t ''If.~~i' 9f1G'M


    ~iC<i ~

    em ~
    ~i

    M>~:;i~\3
    ~

    eIT"1<t> RV1C<N ~ .!I"Grc<t><1T<f<i '111 \5fl<>lf.1 :>j<:1'1'@ DJ<f@ P'Rf.<!> I \5Tlq~ C31 \5fi9j'Ff ~ 7fi,&j9ft-~ ~ ~1i510f
    'If.'-l~l~ ~

    '.iJ@?

    ;n f1; _~ ~

    <Q

    2l'i~ ~

    ~?i
    j\;M('1

    ~.wpfijf.1
    ~ <Ji:51i
    9]~

    ",L"1"l?

    f.1; ~
    <j(G'1<i, ~ ~G:

    ~9f1"<:! \5~'\5
    ~ I

    C<t>1B! 2l~?

    V1S1<i
    ((0

    CI'rn ~ HUli<i
    ~?

    <t>1TIif1, <l'1lH>'';:i .~

    f~'\51, f<\"'l]'\5

    <Q<j~ "1~IC11

    C\519i ~
    CQJt<t>m

    ~~"<:!

    ;:nit I·

    f2lfi1fG~ ~
    ~<>Rll<i: ~~
    I

    ~
    \5R"""U ~

    Rf;

    .!I~

    ~~ m \5f!~

    '11 \' J1(~1C"11

    '5if~

    «A"VTl' '1'8'1)

    BTi9 ~
    <nZ"i ~ ~

    '5V'P

    «j>jQJjll

    VTI':<{?

    "i~? ~
    <Q~

    01"4\.'3 ~ on their
    S0l15

    ~ ~1 "1Bn?i?

    ~I<[f<fl, ~, ~ ~, <Q9 ~ ~, ~'

    "who ~

    111'8 ~ '1'0f\;) ~'?1

    W
    ~
    ~~
    1

    ride piggy-back
    '(~C\!)t

    throughout

    their lives:"
    ~

    l5l.G'l <QV9iW. ~I"l1<1 ~,

    c<J 1<11' ~"<lR! c<J

    "'f'Rf.l1 ~
    '9fl'Gl <Q~

    '!' " /

    <Q~ <;5j-~

    <Q: ~

    ~'8Ci1

    We must hand improved

    It [this planet]

    down

    41<.<1 ~ ~ to succeeding generations

    <jl<i,
    III

    f\1f.:1
    ~
    ~"'/

    '5ff-.rl"<1 ~

    ~C\!)"'l [' <Q't1 I5lmi

    an

    ~'

    (Fj<fi ~

    (}R

    f\1fol ~
    ~ ~ Libidinal "having
    c<J I~

    '1P'i

    J}
    ./"
    L--'

    ('

    condition."

    (" "'(['" .<il~ ~t:!Pl "J'f~'1,


    ~'1J '301)11
    1J1)~
    r=rr:=i

    ~01~ ~
    Q,f)~ ~

    ,q 'i(!:) 9f"RJj) ~
    ~

    ~IG> iSliRC{1C'0"\, \511 ~

    SjG19fl~ CClm~ ~\!)~"1<l ~-<r1/G1ivn '3ll~ ~1'01<l<lf1 '5~


    9[m'l:)~
    I,

    M\!JI<l '8<>M ~ d

    ~I

    _3!1.\')'!1
    ./

    1<J(.,,<1'

    ~ f.Tm"f <['(::Wi! ~~<!'8r!


    'have' "1~

    super-ego

    'r0

    'PlU:F:p<li"'l

    ffi@l4l' \.
    ~

    .tA J~i"'1;_ -)"'1'::1, ~ ,G1 ) '" ~''''~ t= I "'l") ,,,<i, "fill 'f.Jl<Wi"

    f.nfi'1 ~
    ~

    "K""h9 '::I,<l "J' G'fi9fl;<l" I <il<f~ 9rf"'f19fl'M, testosterone poisoning4'1:)'l_""""'7 ~

    =
    ~

    'TRI""<i"
    <010_ ~?

    ~,
    ~'<rj

    1S'il\!) ~
    ~

    Nv.J italics-a
    0f.'1 <Q't1have ~?

    C?lZ:~

    '""' l~ . ","' ~

    '5'l'S~
    ~

    ~ng
    ~? ~

    (father)-<Q<:f
    ~

    ~t

    (like to be) ~
    (qijQ[ffi?

    being

    '5l1"<f

    tie-<Q<:f having mother

    i.5f11f being father" ~ '8<:f 4''<11 ~ map ~

    <Q<:f ~
    ~,

    ~t~ ~
    ~ ~

    "£{l~
    ~ISG'fi

    Ph. D. ~

    Gjffi

    A. D.! "i'1if'1 ~
    ~ ........ ,_, r--,

    "f1Gl
    1'0«N.'2i1S
    ~!
    ..._

    C'5i 'l3iR1
    "l:'-f'jiS,i<l\5

    and being (lack)

    'i~ vl?l<.il~I"'l\!)i
    ~ ~

    <:f 'm~ <Q!i_ Acronym-elf ':!!i.>

    !i_G1 :

    'I'-'I~'-'I

    <Q~ ~
    <£!~

    ~ C~
    ~

    f9R>m
    ~
    IS

    (Jfi<J! ~'0

    '1~-<Q<:f ~

    <llM (X)f ~

    <n~

    \5[il?iFk:R>

    ~<r
    '<ff<fi I ~

    \"iF.P0 'have'-<Q\J1 <Wi? .2j~~


    @'8'?1 '5l1?iI\!)\')

    \SjfR1

    <.!l\J1 C~
    ~

    '" I Iil""" M8
    I ",,' iI
    \;
    i

    ~11

    "lVlf nirvana
    5fSm <1Th(j1l\!)i '5f1V'l ~

    principle ~ ~ "1~

    i<l($l 9'4"( "P4.(.\!) ~

    I IS"1l~

    ~~~-'Tt'~ ~

    \E-<.!l'foi ~""<i"~
    ~"i

    'lCli1Oc~1"",f""R
    ~
    I~ ~,

    f.;.; I
    ~11

    Vf~

    "",,,,r.;,,. "ltv>: '" "''8~I :' 11:


    ~Wl

    ~I

    ~,

    "GflW
    ~

    (X)f '3ll'fl"<1 ~

    I~

    some-psyche

    <r1 ~ 2i-4'A-;n'~

    body-mind (<it .~
    ~ '<"'-Ill ~

    dualism,

    '"'"'
    ~

    i%K"lP1
    0511:<l' ~

    <ll'?l"1'4,

    '~

    '5lim"!J <A;~

    m m~~
    f~

    ,>]~I

    \!)<i<l.

    ~
    C'j~

    --::.j
    1

    topography ~

    <Q"<fi topography-a
    ~-~ -

    anatcmo-clinical

    'Tt) <r1~

    I' "<lR! C1T."i

    ~
    ~"'I~(~:

    om

    ~~R'tC{l1
    ... ()1!t>(.'?l
    ~,

    Ql"'-l1Vl) 'i~t.1;'<'5t ~

    C"l~ ~,

    <rt

    \5It!;!',"I\!)'lib<'4\!)1i1

    \'l.Tj"1JR-$jSf~

    '3"'-1"<1 ~

    C'<it<ll c<K! ~ ~
    <£!~

    '5f1~

    \5ffi:'1"i : :~

    WI '1'fI'R ~
    <A"Ri ft; ~
    ~~

    MCJ.~ I'
    <fl~

    <Q<[~ ~

    ~9fl~,

    4'<lCJ.~ ;n 1

    ~
    ~

    mn
    ;qj ~ ~

    ~
    >

    <1ffiC4''::I8i
    ~"?l

    '{)1lfii "11%\::> (Gl"1, ~~

    'r0
    ~?

    -1C''11~

    ~1<f

    '>]\:5

    <W'l ~?
    ~i"'I~<l<i'ic\!)

    <fl<i1<:! ~'-f'n\!)

    "R> \5l0 <ffiJ ~


    event

    f<i; ~

    \5I\!l\!)

    cQ-9]~

    .2jl~
    <;5j~ ~

    ~
    ~

    r;5m ./.

    W!~,
    death was the great are
    110

    ~ of my life : it if is not the men There


    "'TIJ\ <J<fI~ ~H!.\!)

    ~;

    hean-Baptiste's returned

    "'1m:
    ~

    \')1 % f<l"!fI\5'fGi ~c:<R ~

    my mother

    to her chains and it gave me my freedom. good fathers; children, would bond which is rotten.

    ~~,

    ~9f<fC9

    mA

    ;r.J ~

    The rule is 'that there is nothing. better have some!


    i 964 \')Bl"li
    -e":

    it~,

    \5I<$g"1N, ~

    c$. ~

    who are at fault but the parental than to produce me. Fortunately
    ') 8-([)

    <ITC<fi «1'"i3 ~

    ooU> N~
    ~

    but what a sin to have lain down

    If I had lived, my father ') ~(!:)'1

    W!~~
    ~~<Q~~

    ;n ZGf,

    <If.1 ~

    ~'i
    :

    ~f\1

    '<fin> ~

    ~(.tnM~
    <.!If\i,C$l, ~

    ft;j, "<fi~I \'l.Tj?if\5'!J 2l'fllJ f9i,,?U'1(<l<l


    i11~k<!

    f~f~

    on me and crushed

    he died young; ... " (Sartre,

    ~. ~n- VS~<i It ~

    <l~(?

    CG1q[ <J~C:\')IS ~<[,C~<i

    ~n <fiffi:~"Wl Sif\S1

    CI'f<l\!)j ~

    't@ ~ ~
    ~ ~

    \5ff9fOi ~
    ~ <[(pi

    <['I<!i.'l

    "lIn,
    ~I

    9I ~

    "l'zy3

    4"
    ~

    I-L

    <1:.0. .

    \8f<n'~C;} c<M

    \5'm

    <fI~;;<fi

    R>'?f~"'I 4"1/ 'Discourse' KU1("1 O!"l ~ ~ (C~


    ~'
    cQ~ ~

    <!0'l cQ<f.TG ?jR\'bl<ll ~


    \~.!l

    <Q<1~

    'f3) ~

    >j<\r';

    (21'<11G'i ifI~~

    1'5) ~
    1TI9J~

    ~ \5"f
    I~

    <n~1 <Ji<l> I

    <Q~ ~-~

    <fit ~
    <11~1\!lHl -;j~
    ~

    ;f;T Qfw
    ~

    c-Mm
    I

    m
    fl

    'lNl 'ii '<flOO

    <m~ ~'
    ~ ~ ~

    <Q~

    Jf'0%1!?J'

    GTl~

    4I~.q'5!, ~

    'ih~<!\!lj$l

    "J'f~~q 0T'SQ1 c<M 1I~~


    <fiQj'f-<1G11/01'"FTt M<lITrCR'!l <fiQj'f (D(,9f,

    "<.i-R ~,
    \5lq<ff

    ~
    <Qd

    <fl~<i\!ll$l "'lfl~~ <!i '-II ~

    "'iTW

    ~<u
    ~

    \<i<im$l

    <fiQJ1<1l~

    <fi'<fG'l"

    f9fCl

    \?f?\

    \5l<1 11J l>R WJ, ;qj 'ii ~, ~I

    ~1
    .

    <l1<fiJ!<1dfl1 .-rr-4J, " ... " C~


    <::<T<'l ~~

    <Q"9 ~-<.Q"J'f<i~

    '38r "'l11Vi DllMt;-21"R3

    ~ffi''5 I~

    ~~Gif1"<fi1

    \1l.ff'lTill ~ Dffi I1i I


    : \'5B! ~
    Q

    <± ( ~ 0(

    '5i)~ ~

    i5Mlffi-~<r<i

    C<fi1"81
    ~./

    R>\("l''Q.

    \51'?r ~"0 \5['0~'(3'! . ~ r-.~ <Q<iBl \)~Pl'~ 6r<!1M" I<H,;j<l<1 ~ (~


    ~
    1'@

    1\!)"111)9J'<.Tl1Jl1 2l~ ~

    ~'?r
    C<J!.4Z

    ~<JJI'i)
    ~;

    ~'1J<l;;1 ~\FfI
    ~\5hl\!)
    ZY('''1

    i<k>Si1~'11

    (.~'51 '>Mi11l\bR3'f.

    : ~~
    c<l 'li-.pl"

    ;qj'f.J\!)C~~ : @l"'1'6IN.?'f. ~

    ~<u

    c<l

    <fi1<f~~~~
    'Jf~ ~ ~. ~

    <Q<1~ ~

    \5l'M 0114(.+1 ~q
    ~
    ~I

    cdfi ~
    11iS!<{))\bi§3

    Q1 f<Flc:~

    <!>'<11 ~;
    05'f_'8

    ~®~\!)

    ~?lVJ
    9j!14~1\"?l

    ~ZG'fl9f
    ~~"'l';f

    <.fl<r~,
    ~
    "'l~

    <w.r "l1~J, <Q~

    c~
    M<.l"'<i
    ~

    ~}jC\!)f (<1Gcn \1511~

    '5l"':<i1 ~9j'*1n

    c~
    ~I

    (<:@c~ ~
    Zi~
    9j~

    '>51"?l ~
    ~

    9'<11
    ~.2l~

    '51~~ ~

    ~-/"J'fc<Fn <!i'f.:

    <1:.~.

    fu~ \5!<m9j~
    \5l1"'l'R

    ~,

    <rl ~,

    \58 ('b\!)<'j C'<l~

    '5i)"1Bl ~9J4C"''$i ~

    ~~

    9(1'Sm

    (.<1(,0

    ?jT0-----<f!~ ~ '::l"q~ ~

    ~"

    m~

    :
    : "Of course one can design a that any more is
    (~

    (8) "There must be a continual struggle against authoritarian social forms that impose restrictions beyoll~ese
    : ';>,,"I'l:l, ';>~~)

    ('.»

    '5ff'1f.1

    set by The laws of nature"

    restricted environment demonstrated,

    in which such controls and such patterns .. can be by such methods than

    but there is no reason to suppose

    learned about the range of human potentialities

    m, <il~
    ~1~
    ?j~

    '%rt 1'~(>~4
    "l"B@

    ~,
    '5Tj~

    \f)lc:'1'1 ~>9lG1l!:lhl_

    <n ~
    <mM

    ~'?
    15[j~

    ~:im9f<f.
    \!J~ O(~ivl?!,

    'b\G?!

    '5ff"l1

    1'Bi '5ff<>f<TP1

    would be teamed by observing humans in prison or in many a classworn." ~


    \5fl~
    ~ ~

    ~
    p. ~

    ~
    ~

    'T~1~~ "li'i~ '1rf5Vl


    '8"~-~~"ifo1
    'G'i
    '3fi~ ~li$fr{I®C\f)
    =b';

    '5fi"CW.,

    f<ft.l
    ~
    ~ ~

    ('::l",'","

    : '::l';>8) ~,

    .\5l11.:S~'1!:l1 ,q;1<i'1.~,~ '5f!?j 1'1 <1,Pl"1 101 1<1>~~I

    ~
    ~ /

    <mi,

    Q1
    .,m"

    C\5i f0;"1b'l1 4'v".>j<1dl"i'i


    (\5\ ~
    (\51'

    <lfi1"1IG'fl, C>i"1J<n&ii1 <.ff ~m

    <Pl1?fl qiCi
    6i'Jj(}!l1 0

    9ft'61J! <J\V1 <il )1FFP1\GP1 i5Il9fi1 ~%'!11m!


    ~
    ~

    >i~j<1
    r-.

    m ~m

    1.~ m~ZFJ1G>--I5[Q$
    8l ~ '<lI~\5!jD<'lM
    ():f05 ~ ~

    m~
    ~ ~
    <Q~

    <il:t <1>,,?(\;:'1 '!<fCmT!:l\5I

    TII~

    'G¥
    ._/

    ~!'i<jS'{'Bj<1

    \5lWf ~ <Wi'!
    'S'{\f)) , 'B

    l'cFn I '3fi?j<® ~-~~1'


    \5l 051 <5lcdi1f<M>
    I

    "5Tl'lf'f'
    1'~,,___ ~'1
    <Q~

    ~' ~
    'il~,

    "BJ I 15ft1:MT <.rfC<.)i '<.fl'W1' <rf


    •
    <Q~ ~

    9fJ1'1-~Qj'~

    ?\~<i''91''1i ~ ~

    ~
    '"'

    ~-~
    --="r (."<'''''

    '1im
    ,~

    ~'Z<1'
    ~

    (\5jQ)<ff

    1""N{.9'~

    C1!:l1'!1 ~ ~ ~

    <l1"'1"ff0'11-QR C\5i ~
    <nJ? '3fi~

    ~9'''''-<.S1~ (1·<l>"II{.~~ I<1Q<1 15ft~ ~j+'Pj'i31(.<l>1

    9f<.:'lP "~J'¥!/l!'5'jJ'

    '8

    ~~~"iJ!)
    ;?fl~ ~~

    ~"'to1
    '5!C4 ~ ?/<.:QJfilN <m:! ~'
    ~(':q

    "lll¥ ~',
    1'Bi, ~

    'r1f'~'?)
    -..£l~~1T

    C\!J11 <Rfi ~
    ~

    '¥_(.'i1 ~

    'B~

    ~~j\;
    \f)'G

    <!1m ~',
    ~ I~ ~ ~'

    051 <l><R'B~ ~

    ~crn~
    ,;>",b-"I

    H?1~'1V'F "threat of
    : ';>b-';,)

    1'l1"1

    ~4'I<l
    ~~
    ~''-<Q~ I5[I$l '~'

    ~
    ~
    15ft~,

    :1TI J1l~

    ·<l'@_C'bf<.:G'f I <l>qj-"<1G11-

    '5i~I'1'm '1'C1'1A I '3fi~ "I!"11>i\G1<><1>~"i (~) \5f{<>[f.q- ~ ~


    I

    C"ff~(31C~'i, ~7.<f

    <1>~';J<U~<4> ~

    ~
    ~

    2:]'i1'-!)mij{?1
    ~ ~ <pqj!

    9fEl:"i'3

    ~"I

    violence or a pattern of deprivation and reward" (Peck, : "It is reasonable to suppose

    C:;i'-!1'!l(, \51~"
    '3l'Z ~

    \5lm '~'-<.S1"

    -m:<1 ~

    ~~

    'I5[jqxf that just as,


    C1> ~
    ~51I

    '''lii'Z1' ~

    '5iNV'1~ ~
    I"~

    '<1m1'<l'@ He\!J
    15['f~

    ~~!
    'BI3 '3fi~
    ~

    ~ '3fi9fi10

    C"fI\1<.("l?1-6 9fQJ ~ [11 ~ ~


    ~"

    intrinsic structures of mind underlie the development moral consciousness, expression )\!J~-\!JS ) ~
    ~? ~

    If cognitive strutin a
    :

    Authentic \5l11 lnauthentic'51l'&c.'{1 C"\W'f.lfo1 ~

    tures so a 'species character' provides the framework for the growth of cultural achievement, and even participation tree and just community ...human needs and capacities find their fullest in a society of free and creative non-"free
    ~1~PWj
    <Q~

    \!J'G ~
    ~

    'f'liq
    ~

    01'Z

    Wi-~

    <ii~

    "l(q3 ~

    f\k'3 *-\3lll1"f -.n~


    "li~

    \;"1@ <r\'31J!C<1l Of'"405

    procedures ..." ('::l );'''I'l:l


    <Q~ ~ ~

    m~
    ~

    '1~

    151'Z <Q1'~ ~

    m '3fi"'f'TR:! ~
    l5i9f ~

    ~c[;j

    CJffi6TI" <l'@ <Wi-~

    t¥J~ ~
    <il~

    ~
    (~

    * ~0r~
    I ~ I

    <!I<l> "K.$ ~

    C<1'<fl~ ~

    <l>qj c<!'<l1?Ji ~

    ~~~'<l

    ~~l"jm~I

    ~,

    and just"
    1>@

    ~
    '5lQjPl

    '3fi~ ~-)

    l'Bfi51'Pi <Fm

    m (~
    J'j~

    >f"tI
    'B

    '5f!'11'<T1"!1" ~~<!>'lTIl
    ~ <l>@

    '1'~

    "-.n~

    l:fPiCfi 15ft'T'iV;@

    <l>Qj'j-~-~ \5l'<fi~

    4l~\(O<1?"

    ~"m
    "'iBlG I

    1J'j9ji<Thl <fl<.fl?l' '51"lJMc<.)i ~ S'{'~O'fItq


    <!l1@ ~

    f.t01l 1'l"!1""1 <ilVi C5fG'l ~ I <!I <r.?i 81


    <Q

    ~"1~

    'G'1 '5fu \3'<lJ


    <il'<l1 ~
    :qj

    {If)

    "Suppose that the the social and material condition that prevent were relieved .. " <Jt
    (D"lf%: : ';, "'''I~, ';>~8)

    11 ~'iq-::iQ1"R 6iV51 ~
    Wi~'B

    <:rt~

    ~"
    '8

    <BJ;

    <r.?i ~M"lJC\!J <,rrr."'i <fIT."'i


    cQ~

    free intellectual development


    ~?j"!1"?f(;'lj>,
    ~ ~

    <#: ~
    <Q'D'i

    Jf'i "'1~~?FIT,

    "j'&'SJ-;a

    ~N

    <1'1"1i 0TIi, \51 ~ ~ ~

    (31. ~ ~ ftFic0 9fBj(Ff':Z ~ I 01~ -.ntoi A


    115;,1.<-1'1'5i9fJ'!Bl"i ~'8
    (.'l?(..Q ~~

    <5lJtG'l?]~ B-~ ~ <lJF&f.i';ii


    I~

    -.n~
    I
    cQ~

    "'l~

    '519f>IIQ"i, <ii~
    ~~G'j

    IR9f

    '1V1, 01~

    \'ilN!~

    ~1G1'bl'B

    ~ :

    9flB

    <TIl,

    ;:rr?

    8l

    2l"1j 'BO

    (:;,) ~

    "1'l~

    <n

    \5lJF'j"l~

    \511~ ~

    \5iJi"1~

    (f<iv<i<j~

    cQ~

    LAD "l~ \5lJlG1~)


    ~ <Q~ ~ ~ ">1)~ ~

    f.f; "l~? ~
    ~

    N~

    Jf<'! 1'f6f '5UPf~

    \5i~r'1IT3 ~? ~, ~ ~,

    \5lm~
    ~?j<'1'L~->i

    'TC?i ~
    ~? ~ ~ ~

    CI1'8m m?
    ~

    :m-'<1i
    'Z>:~
    ~' QJ;11

    <iI'1<i'~IT:<r ~

    c<! "l~ I \5T'?f ~

    ~8
    ~';j

    ~ ~

    9i%i-~

    f~rz;::j
    ?f1"1 ~

    ~~'?f

    @\'3i'l I--i('!> ~
    <1"1("1 ~ ?jRi<1~~! ~ ~

    0fuz ~,
    \5lJ1i7I~ ~

    C"I"'II
    ~

    Wi

    Sl<frn "I~
    'TII-~lf'1f';Q
    ~,

    ~CG1"i I <Q'Gl \5M'<iJ 1<r


    ?j~"l

    ~P'<''1,9
    "IT:<:lJ

    "i~ ~~~'Cft'1I "IT:l4J

    11<8 ~"i

    J'j>:~

    CDTIll~, ~
    Q.,()p..!_ I

    ~
    ~~~,
    :?j["):ffi

    .031 ~
    ~

    <Q'q_>!"l

    I\!JR
    ~j(.<1'

    <Q<iG1

    <1'4"1 ~

    ~
    ~

    ~ (-<)

    'Z~{P"GIb\;u\5("l:p (.G<r(AiqiRii{.~ "- \5lJ1G1"111'1t,'Jc<!-<'tjVi ~ ~

    '"

    <lli'l\i;~<ji I ~ \5l\!l<£1<j <£1<f.

    ~!
    2l~:

    \5f.i'Jj
    ,~

    E
    I

    ~
    c<!
    ?j~

    J'jz.~

    \5jft

    wq
    ~
    'B

    on ~, Frm"l

    f\fB:1,
    c<i'lt'TI

    '!>l~
    cQ ~

    ~:n
    cQ<iG1 15Q)J

    omJ ~

    f!WJ

    e~fBG'i'tlI<t\{l I

    <lG1i ~,

    \5ft<!l

    cQ<r~ \5Br "'IU zr~w.1 qn"ii'1 (X\'3m ~ (ji\31H ~ ~'I <!<R Schank-efst (.~1~f~ ~
    15"<1'1 i51"<11 ~ IQi

    cQ~~1~
    \5lWi~

    q;;~'tr(;~ ~ ~
    ~?!

    <fi118f ~?
    <£1\:"l Principles

    I5T~

    <ll<rJ~C~ '!>~

    <i1 "i\5

    cdll
    ~

    zrn

    ~,

    f5:t<T'5l~fm
    "~'$"

    "<lNHl1 <ITGl1
    0'C\5 ~ "21'\5j"l1" I
    ;pJ

    Parameter

    ~,~1\:1l cQq; ~,
    '!>1!(,\Fj

    'Y,tG{

    [Bc" ~I<jl
    \5UW!~
    ~I

    ;n
    ~

    .2)Nl~
    <rf\'31JBf ~ "IT:1:fl ~G{

    fQ5f.i ~
    \5jft "fCkj1

    ~~

    ~?

    1"5iQ{{~ Jt<l'''1'tlIC''I

    I)IWtC<l ~

    >iZ"l"lM "l<Tz. flbleiGI"1

    Fl>-~
    <l'~ ~ .:?.'iiZ ~

    ~z.~
    '~

    <r~
    ~ 1f0J~'G

    <IN
    ~e ~,

    (understandingj-e

    C6fC"l CGf8

    c<j'(;<iifu? ~,?

    <rfi1
    ~

    m~
    c~
    ~

    Ul~

    c<!

    <Q<t>l>1 <JS'<It€
    'J'[@

    '!>I~(ft'j Ul~' COI',<! m'<! ~

    ~~~7ff1
    <Q~ ~ ~

    <1'i'l{.~ ~ @\'31 ~

    N-, !%R
    FP:&'l'<f ~

    ~z \S'Z ~

    '<Pl

    f~TI ~
    I (\5N"IJ ~

    C'lj:(ft'j ~'

    ~IH0!>
    ~ ~

    T1rc~'~
    ?j~

    (G<rG"lWlf@ri'l ofPl ~~~ ,5.r<TZ m"1'!>

    <n

    "l1i1<1~C"li'l "5jZ~

    Ul<f. '!>~ I ~

    '5lt~ ~<rci

    \5lWTI ~

    P
    ~

    f.tc\!) ~
    ~f.1

    I <iI\SMJ ~ ~
    '\5f1~

    B1<n"<:f <ll<l'j-\5l'<f~W \58i1"1"IT:<:lJ \5li~ I \')~


    ~ @\'3?! ~ "l~,\5f1>nm

    m B)'<ff-'8fR1 '511~<tI'ft <lic~ \'3'<1iC<1<TI Q4'C~ ~ ~ m 'tl1<l1 ;n ~, m '5Wrn "l~ ~ 'WJ!'B \'3~
    C~1JIG'j m~c"1"l

    'tlm~<il>fl(?li

    \5lJ1G1~

    \'3~ <l'<h'<lCi'l ~

    9fiC?i!) ~
    \5(f\G'1~

    <fi\3'<li-R \5!riG1~ "11f-jR>,*, ? ;,'iiZ ~"i1


    ~
    ,-...

    (Q"!'f \S~(;q, ~

    <n<1'1~~

    -11~J~ \5\!5"1lf.1.~ '!>{.,<}'5lf6fu>i(Pt ~ ~

    ;qt

    f.1':ff'1 ~~PS?l ~ gence) "Fif.i1 <Jim <f.G ~, 'rHMl' ~'11Vr.<JS :!l~w.1:fl


    ~ \5lJ1G1'i1M'1~! >i1<.c1<;J
    <Q~

    ml ~
    ~

    1iJr'1 ~

    (Artificial

    Intelli~~Ht\ire\5 ~ '<WPT I

    ~"'li'T

    <iM '511?i'T, ~

    <:5!llfR 'TIl ";1l.'f'?1 <?1L'i.

    ,m ~'1'{31
    ~?(j'\5

    ~l£
    <Q~ 'B

    \5l'l"i <iI~
    \5ft~

    7i'41:<1>'B

    ~Ri ~"1
    ';2"1('!> i
    9j~

    M(;'!)

    11''t. ~"!'f

    9ljQ<j I

    <iI<rZ ~

    "'._,

    ""

    'lfG'
    'Jfl~ 2l~

    m~

    <fi;1t ~
    \5j<JQJlq' ~
    ~"?! ~'Oi
    '<l@

    <llfV~, ~
    (}f<l :

    '~
    !Q~

    ~$l

    \5f1~~' \5ft~
    '~

    \5l1~"1
    fl<n~(JW~. \S\9i'l <Q<l1?J1

    \5l1~z
    \5ft~

    ~11 "¥.(P1 \C;'{l1 C~


    I~ ~ \'3 \l;'B1

    "l .®i>i <'l"¥.<i <f.G ~n ~~


    ~!

    ~m ~
    l:j'[<;J"

    \5ff?j1~~

    'lfG'

    f<r~
    \5fft'Jj q \3m

    ~
    ':l 'B

    I ~1'fM4

    ~ ~ 01"l1 "l<ffi1l

    <!I~

    -<"lZ ~

    ~zrrrn
    'tlj1~11}f1(?li

    HI.:1lIf\§I'!>I ~~

    ~l£ ~

    \5fi?f1\5\3 C"l'<1 \51"<NR

    \:'i~1 ~

    '1G1
    ~

    2l"'):j

    <.SO :
    )'j]Q)?;<l}

    (e)
    Q.~.O

    >iI\!Ji~. N- <jv;ijJ't'W:?rn ~
    ~?

    '5i<I-pJ C<li'>f1(.<!1'ii '<WWfI"1 (.D'gj 0lV't ~ Processing (NLP) Machine


    ~~j~

    '41l"i'l
    'JflG'( ~~

    \S1<;J~<)C:(<;J ~,
    ~? 2l"'):j !-inl

    ~{.~I ~ Language

    >fP'rM"T'Zl'<rn

    cQ<rG1 :>flPID @"41"'l';j <t>lCG1<i I ~


    -

    ~JtBf
    ~

    \§fit"! 1''\!)~<J:?
    ~?

    Translation
    C'fi'tl<1jkj ~m
    <Q~

    Natural
    \5lI~

    <f.G ~

    Qift;
    ~

    ~'t. '3!rrG1"il<1q~ul'Z ~
    Language
    r;:;~

    QjjN,
    Pr,....,

    ;:n'f<!; ~'Br\'3
    (2IT~ (,'!>I~

    \?fiU ~ Sch~nk
    4(.~

    Natural
    ~-'1',</«11

    Processing
    ~l) ~.

    (NLP)
    'iI"%i
    I·i(.~

    4'01(.'!> f"l'VJ

    <1~, ~

    C~i1)

    p' ~C"1"i

    4~4~'Cft'11 I

    , >n?,

    ,?~?l

    \5ff9j'i'3\i5
    ~l{ ~

    '511<F111)<"Ij 9~

    '111 cQ~ :~H~<1' Jf1 ~

    1"1';21<1

    'm<f<r, cfl<1'~ ~

    '<IT4<r

    '!>C'lJi \5l1~
    ~?j~

    .~

    ~>:(.1f\S?(.'!> ~

    "1'%1 00 ~

    if;1'1('''1«1 I ~

    C"':ii~I'1

    f.:l(~I'k, \3fC15 \5ff"Pi1 "Ji"'iC\i5 Fr~1

    ~rl.~ c<! c<rf~ <nt<ll

    ~'

    ~Q'

    I c!l~ "5!i<I'1(;<M" <i'>i<J"l''I1 <ri '5!T?l'il~


    H(<lM'b
    cQ~ ~

    C"'Kf 'fB!Gr ~ <M1 ~ij~G'l1 C"l<J


    D(,G'[

    ~ 'ffi~

    <ii~

    Xj~ c!l'l1<i'b?[

    ~l5m
    '5I@b?j

    C'bN'?l:

    2i~

    c<R" 2lil'l'b<i'>

    ~
    C~d:q~I<i,

    .2f!"i I 2ltR>Mi2i.lj<"l! ~
    \5fI~ ~'iI~-~~

    z<3m ~
    ~~

    . ~1"1

    C"'i<i(3l1'$l(<1'

    ~ ?R:~
    <Q~

    dural

    'PI1i1rn ~
    !rocedural

    ~Q

    ~ pY? <fif~
    .~

    ~r.r ~

    1 ~1
    'R<jJ ~I

    "1\FR,

    11

    ~/roce<lC"1~<P1'1,
    ~ c!l~ G{'~1 :l'fil~

    {\5j ~

    \5fi(~

    I\!lPt
    ~

    'ijl~,
    r;;r;:{ I

    %I<lK§1<l ~
    j"j~

    'ff'<lIVJ
    c!l<i>il~

    (1M,

    m t3~
    ~tFI1

    <ii?t \5n~<1"1<f1i'b1<;J ~i~

    ~H1"1(<i

    ~.

    ~
    ~Q)j

    fonstitutive

    <n-\5Br <nJ
    I %l~

    ~
    ~
    ~

    \5f<l"1J ~
    '1T?5i7J'i"l
    1~ R\-<il?l ~, ~ \5fI~

    ..fr1\!>{.Qj'3 I ~

    R~ ~\
    ~

    ;;5)'1

    ~
    c!l~

    &m

    \5fI~

    ~
    -"<rj

    ~"iRB~
    ~ ~ ~l

    ~
    <11'3 (::'Ci>b-Ci»

    ;:n\lffiJ ~
    mechanizable 01T~

    0TIJ <ii'f.'l

    '1i(~,
    c!l~

    ?JW3 .-rvT
    "llF1<l1i8l<-l\G

    ?;JJ3 9J"\D1" ~

    computable,

    C<ri<r ~

    "We have no answer not yet succeeded results rules" unfettered even from random 1?j':lf5f ~~_

    at present in a small thinking by

    ~.,,!
    ,

    ~
    l'",C'b

    1'i'l1.7i"i ~
    <il<!!t'1 ~ 'bCIi,1'?l ~ ~~ I~' ~9f"'?l"

    1i :;j'bJ~M~16r<{C4
    9j~

    <!JFMrc~
    I I
    1:jQ)j"j\5

    '5<VB~'8'

    ~l"?l-El-$j ~
    ~

    ~'<Ii,

    "-

    <Ji'"'?J"1~

    ~'i
    fl'Z'11'

    '6~:z1.~~

    '5fC~<1

    '3jGi\')If\;l;fR~

    as all attempt-s allowing ac::pted


    <l~lij(\5 ~ '@9(~

    to do so have mind
    I?j~

    '6~01 ~-mc<m!
    ~
    'f't'b"1'>1>"i', \5fI~ ~'\f I c!l1)r ~

    ('3!'l + ~

    "fiB 9fc:1 <rIG' ''5ff<JJ1\3' <ri '~'


    <!>qj ~

    mea-sure. tr is believed the human knowledge

    that creativity to wonder "'lj'9fI'liS or conventional

    <ul<m <M1 <mi I) ~.~


    ,+ffi'b I I5fQl'i~ ~ ~

    1~

    Xfl11~

    by the .rig,tBitL_es of
    C9[JH0S1Pi'?l ~ ~ c<l ~~ ~ ~ ~'blt<t~'?lC'b

    ~/Ri~'&/"<I'{3-r.""1V1>
    '~'
    ~ -, + 'iZ +

    ~
    "l't'lBf ~"i

    '\5lt~'
    <ii~

    <n
    ~

    m~
    ~
    1

    <!bstraction) ;n ~,

    t. r.

    c<n<r
    ~Qjjl

    <.Q~

    c~rers

    ~"<I

    ~
    ~

    \5M '5fC~

    <£1'1'
    .....

    ~~:zru ~

    "'5IT:~

    roTI"i\5i
    <.!1"8:co11 ~·I '5l1~

    C'5i)ifw<:>'ij ~9f~

    C<liffiiH<f.C'l1 ~9fiG'l4'~\'5

    <ul?j!<l ~-~

    ~I)<il ~,

    f<mnf<t\5t
    ~~

    <t-UR, \5f<l1'b(~'?l~\5TI<Jl1V1 ~~<jl'r61C'N \5fi<1'1"i

    <!l'SI1<i C'6t@Q@ ><fGff~

    R"'fu

    <P<t'1\G~ (ft1)<1'1J<:j:!J-::tP1~ <nJ ~1\G


    ~-J=j~'~

    ~~:;z~

    -. ~
    <ii~

    G'fl'il'l11f1 I ~l<f"i 'TP.J

    ~m ~~
    ~ ~ ~ c!l~"t~i(.1 \5n~

    f"fD1
    <ri

    ,,"1{,G'1'i,

    ~<.<ffi"W3i

    \5lM~'6',

    ~"i"1-~"li
    '51<!I'bC~'?l ~ ~, ~.

    ~X:'-l(.~1
    <fi~

    <V4'1'S~ 'b)V1$l
    <il4~
    .2j~j<:f.<f

    f<f<rn

    ~"i
    <fi?j~ '3

    Jj.{-:;j'bj 'Ji ~,

    ~
    ~

    M~;j Sff(9( C\5fu ~

    9fi'3m

    m 'it
    11%1.4 ~

    <ff\Z<:j

    '8'f'ill'31 \'51\5cQ<l, ~-~"f'S


    C"f<HTI1 Xj'>fiq

    :
    ~

    Jfj?j

    KU1C<i ~
    ~,

    <ll'+J'b('~ \5fi~

    ~fu~ ~
    ~ i3Qjt
    2i~

    Of~fM i11~
    ~

    il\'t~
    1 c!l"'?J" ro1, < c!lV'j

    <1'C'?l'i, XjC"'1"1 ~ <nJ I "i<Ii ~

    \51Z ~
    I?j~ q;@

    ~I
    \5I9f"19j7;'R

    <i'\9J \511!O"(15 C"l'"<lTI! '5'il!OiD5BI1 ~'1 ~


    \5IQ)"<rj cQ~

    \5j<i~'b ~ ~lnC<;'1<1
    ~C.!J1

    ~
    ~
    '3
    ~,

    \5Iq
    ~ 2j'bJ~Ll'

    \5fi~H'1S ~\51fi(j('<1'1

    C1i"1C'b

    ~1r ~ ~.

    1'Q,fj

    i"!C\5l \51l7;9l "f!ifC1i<r ~


    1>C1C'eH "l~

    9f@ <l\'+JQb'1i

    1>Qt'b

    f~
    '3

    1 'FI1MCGi'?l ~

    "fr~n:r1 ~
    "51~'

    '5'i@RDI'"'?J"1 '51<n'1 ~ f;'l:!)l'lfV1 '2l'il'R;'1 9fQ)


    Sff~ ~ ~

    m 1 ~,

    \5.lJWi~

    'li':j, '3jt:;lQ,'bI@1i11 \5fIQ ~


    ~
    C'4'Q'j 214~ ,
    \5j~.~ ~

    ~<fl"l<.l)'11 ~

    05\:;;

    WI

    Elec-

    ~~ ~

    f1ftl?z~ ~

    tricity Xj<qj)i4 ~ (11 + (1) Z'bJ11q


    'SlV1 ? ~~-\5n~
    1

    m, "1\\bJ~
    :&~

    Electric + ity
    ~'f.'l

    (<il~ +t1), ~

    1:f11! ;n, i3l\}Ri ~

    :"<I'{3
    "l~~-<li~
    ~<1l~

    '5'i@TI:5)'"<f\ ~1J ~
    <'jO;'j
    ~?

    '5'i<lT 'Zn1'+ ~ ~, ~
    ~

    mr'~
    ~ ~

    ~l:9iTG'l 6flll9im

    ~
    ~<1''''
    <l'@
    r-

    \5fi("1

    o:JG'1tt\5 T'lf"GJ 1
    \5j ~
    "

    ~~

    ~
    Q1

    ~
    '<>i~-~

    f<@<r~ <j:rr~'''1''il:'+ <ri ffi@<1'


    c<l <ul<m

    \Slro"1i3Ie>+

    <wi ~,
    ~~

    ~~
    ~

    ~Qt <1'&113
    \5l<fl~

    <ii"W@lI5f~<1ifiJ;q>>i-..Q?l ~

    '1l-.n:~~'"'?J"1
    RMC<!
    S\<n~

    <iJl<r'1{'cj~

    'Pi

    /!J

    <n ~
    '5j:!fj ~

    f.$

    9J~

    ~
    ~

    ~,

    \5lt~

    'fi

    P'1"N

    <1'C'?l~ 'Ti I ~ ~<1 2l';lr&9fi5 P'l'Z-..Q"'?J""K\5i

    i1[;;,:j

    (C~j~)!
    ~

    \5l~fu<f.

    \'5!11 1bVB<19fi5 '5ff:?:l~ ~ ~ '5'i;;fQ5Bi1

    w-{

    15l~

    ~'1

    Z!<l"f\5!V{>\G 1<1(."11>~

    ~~

    C"'M'~ i t3'1 \5l?Z <ro, ~

    ~
    c!l~

    ~
    \3IQJ5 ~~

    <l1<J'iJ1tq~
    ~q Natural

    "'iMXJtt"l ~

    ~,
    <l)~~

    NvJ

    0R

    N>H
    ~
    ~

    I~

    (p)~,
    ~~

    \5Ml<!']'i \5.fI~

    f\SIH>it::<!' 1:<Il01?
    ~<l"l\51'C'+2fi.:u

    (<l'''1('\!)

    ~~

    '5'i%l"CblQt

    '+I.~<i 1

    f.Ti51

    ~"t

    <l)<1'Jt>"1~<i

    ~<f-1~"i iD!jj(';<:H'1"<f

    <n

    llC6lt'.l

    'b~

    '3 ~

    Language

    Processmg-ns

    '3f(?j1'<t!11

    \!)iq_(Pl

    ;q, ~
    ~

    ~
    ~ '8~

    ~
    '1'~1''<JWi

    ~
    ~~

    <1'1!'{j ~? Principles
    ~I

    \'3i<ik'1'
    '1 I<rJ

    I5Rtf'1r.~<J"I-<Q~~
    ~q'1~~
    ~-<Q~

    ~/'rinciPleS-<Q~ '5f'<l1
    C"~ G1~ ~ Sli.~i
    ;:p:j?

    Fv.n!
    ~

    'Bl'

    j\;,fG~~

    terU1

    f;ttG ~
    ~ ~

    (. c-j

    {.1/

    ~, <i0 ~ 13~ ~ <I:.>b. ::r.

    ~
    '5f~

    "ii'l<1'1("-F1 \1i1"'1fut~
    ~

    \5lf.l~
    \5lJIGi'»'fum

    C<frnp<fl~ ~

    c!l~ I

    \5f~~ ~,

    1 "l1r&<1' 2jiR:>R<1>~m

    8! 131~?\<{~'1J [.;~\!)

    131

    <l1<1>j'b0G1

    ~'W1

    "l"1R-"4

    <l1 ';rf I '<[ll'lilir

    <wi1 ~

    -;n,

    9J?31~
    <Q<i'

    ;:p:j

    I ~fim"1<:">11

    ~
    ~

    ~/:;n-~
    ~ "5["@

    '5'!JJ-H;11

    '¢fj'?l <Q~

    <1IC'1')1 ~

    <l1 '5lJl"1~-H';->11

    c<V!T-ii <re1 '5l'<1H ~ <JR-~ ~

    <Q"'F lararneter

    (~~
    <Q~

    !arameter-<Q

    (,el.
    1

    ~
    "l('i31

    "1'101"'~'~~
    ~I ~'1 ~

    ~'"11·>ti~Vli1
    \5IK~ ~
    ~

    ?!q<l~ ~

    ~-.n~,
    '<[F~' ~
    i1~+'li'qk<ll

    WM ~

    <ro'iZ

    '''''1~1 ~'~J!~ ~'1 ~'


    I

    ~'-<f!"i

    ....

    ~ I

    B1~<n ~ ~
    ~,
    '~

    ~1<p)~('<;l'1 (,'l.{'C..l1 <i\"",'i~1 ,arameter

    ~ ~ I '5!J1~-~ "iB1<1'-£C"li1 ¥'<!1 2:l1~ ~?

    '<BM:!', '~MT~
    ~

    :fOOT"1>qrn l£'&Vf"1 \1-''<ll!1~G1~<fi3


    ?fBI '\SRi 9j~'
    @t<l

    \5ff?T i1"q;'i"1 ~)

    I \5fIC'>t '~',

    'm9fl"i1'iJ1 l~c<l
    <l1~"1I~lm
    q(~

    1r~Mt "1TI!9ffcf.ol~
    'Wn'
    \5q;:[

    >jf\bJ~ ~ ~ l5Ff? <lJ1?fBWr ~


    ~',
    '~

    -;ql'<fl~

    ~
    <jl@

    1i~
    mqj ~

    ~
    <Q1<ll~ ~

    f~~
    ~<>t

    ~
    ~

    <Wft <rffi-'5!1t'>t
    «iW c!lWl ~

    03t ~

    fl<I'M
    fl

    <T! I '''1"'1"f;' ~

    <J-<j'o:j -<jfii1 '~

    '~

    ~',
    ~f

    '9fn5<fR1 ~',

    <WI
    13<i;r

    Fr41~ 10;% ~
    ~
    ~'i

    ~~ ~
    "1~

    '5lHMB ~
    <>1i~' Itn ~
    ~ ~<Q~

    ~
    ~"";j ~~!Bf ~ ~

    <11V11 ~
    0fP'jf.h11 \5!<r~
    ~'>f ~ ~~
    ~

    '~'
    ~

    <f'fu
    '1'1(."1

    ~,

    <J~

    "6!<TI ~'
    '3Bi~ ~ I~ '<fl7.<-f> I fTt v:lb13~! 6fI'lr.~

    <1"[11 (Jl7.51~

    '9j1D'-<Q~ ~

    ?j.q~Pi'<ii~

    '<BM:! 9jl~',
    C"fl111 (eM,

    'c'>tff;1, 9fj('tJ<1> ~',

    wfij', ~<l

    ll141'

    c!l ~

    4'&12 '"li~
    C'l1J'8ml c!l~ ~ c!lm

    <m'9ffiTIi1 ~

    f.;t..(")~

    1J1, ~)
    '~<i"

    <rm I 'ltmT-ii "R"3 fulr<r '<JiG ~~~ ~~ ~V1


    c!l\?l <m?rr~TC'1' ~ cm-c1J'8 \3j
    ?fj@
    1

    Of<ft ~,
    '&@
    ~

    ~ ~

    "1~
    H~

    J'F"'if.f.<!)
    ~

    \5lq(~ <>1i""f5'6!Oi~ ~'


    f,'i';1

    <!Vi ~
    <jl@

    C4'fQ)l c'1\:l> C<J"l

    (?fro + <Q4)

    "ffi?Jl'0i1" ~ "1'3'<1\5

    ~?!\5J
    <fQ)l ~

    irc~'~
    ~ ~

    ~ ~,
    N<!1@41
    ~!

    131'~

    ~i~ q_"1, ~~
    C~<yt c!l1Yt +
    ':>

    '''!I<:>' f<1; +

    ± ':>?

    ;:p:j

    1 1Jfu,1.\!)-<1JF&c~

    ?f"Gn <Ti"C<l:------c!l~~ \5lW1"1M'T()l"l


    ~ c!l~13

    <Pm

    '<_.~
    1~

    'QJXi ~'i1

    ~~"-fM
    21<1~'b

    o:pm- ~~
    >ff''& ~ c!l~

    QJXi ~
    2t~ ~

    if'iC0"1 ~

    Jjf-1f.(i2; \5lJ1G1"if111l-l fiW.i luzzy logic>-<-Q~ 1_ d?2:


    '.Q'1'!

    ~G1 : <l14j''!l'<;l 13

    w.. <jfi;ri1
    "11~
    ~

    f~r.~:ri;!r.Cj<i
    P

    ~~

    151'i-'5UfG'j"1f.<i:!101<l' ~~~
    ~l3m-"(JiI.~; ~'\'f'3
    (11~ ~ ~

    c~
    "I<ibI ~

    <QI?3Wfi!LIZZY

    A>
    ~

    ("l-em I
    J'j~'>]~ <l>Ci1

    /f@%

    ~~

    fLlZZY

    ':>

    <l1,offi:{ \5[f<'N ~I

    1 '5fI'M1 <J"<M '0'fI~' -R-m-!?! ~ ~


    ~?

    \5"<M

    '5f'<M'i '1lF&1
    <ff<f. ~

    <~nR:>R<1>~

    \3j~.:YI«~'<;l? \5fl<l: c!l~

    ~R
    ~

    <Q'1'-<Q~ '8~

    <n'
    ~
    ~? ~

    <Q1i ~
    Q1~

    qk~

    <fi<T-.l\!)G'1J1 "0?!\5J ~

    _ 'r."114llr-~
    '0'fi<»--4~'-~ Q!.1

    SjC~1 "1t'IT 1 ~,
    4C'bi '05G1~~r,

    '<.'~G1L;t', ''6!qlll'-~
    ''0fG'l~<ibI'
    <Q~

    f1>
    9flB,

    ~w.
    '&f~

    \5fl~

    1f.'il

    <J1<l"

    ~'l'I".:>I(."-I

    "lF0Q

    f\.l

    m
    ~

    C'1f.<i
    ~'-_,-_/.5:l.

    C'1W1

    (51-q

    I <!l~ -<PCG1
    H!:frT'0iVfI

    0 <ffi-~

    ,2j~

    <Tl

    <1>\!) (Q)t4 i

    "J'fB <Q\?l \5f.1} c<I't'<1il3

    -n <n-;>~ 1
    -E-~

    -;n! m"ij~1MR <?fl <mJ <n I ~,


    qN~f"'li'.41 c!l~ c!lVf.'1 ~~

    c!l1i--@W:"'8i -;qlQ)l ''6fG1tt','~r-~

    r-,

    _"2iJs-!~
    ~,

    l:fI~CfI <I'&m ~

    f.j~
    ~(/i<l

    ~=-~
    <J~

    <@j

    'GP\'li c~

    ~
    ~ ~

    m '5fI1J'
    ~
    <jl@~ ~

    ~
    Ul-;ql~

    ~-~
    'ffi"'ll~--7_ c!lJ'j-~

    '3~

    cQ)t4

    <rm 1 c!l<» ~~
    ~ ~,

    'Ul'i'

    C"lI~"G'j '0fG'l'

    t~(P11 ;~

    Ul~

    Ul~Wfi

    -;n'(j <>ftG!
    c!lVf.'1 ~'

    9jWm"i7.4
    j

    'lif~

    <n~ ~<j
    ~~

    05'm 4ffi, ~
    B"11:f
    1

    '~-s1'i1)' (\'3"[<f ~ ~, ~ ~ '~'


    ~ '@H1-FM'

    ?fi'<l~

    C"l7.~~ <{'¥<l1 ~
    9]~~

    ~
    (PF)
    {LF)

    "1~

    ~#1

    <m1

    '1'1C'b

    ~""m
    411~ \5ff~m \5f\~

    ~1"M~(,1$11 <!i~
    9(j~

    ~ '~ ~'

    ~1

    <i:rNJ! <!i~
    cQ<{l]l~ @i~~

    O'f'Bm

    ~ 1

    ~?j

    9fr8m <:fiT<! I
    -"lCO""!:z ~ ~

    ('3'j\;'~

    \QlC'tft ~ 'blR:,@l~j\Ol

    "':\'Bm '_;R'1'51

    w.:n \51'
    1)<jiG'j ~

    <l>P,'1 \5l~~ 1 l5!'<ji~<!i~


    <Q~,t,~

    <!I ~
    "Tl~

    fun! <n~~<m1
    (semnatics)-~
    ~Cj'J'j\!i

    C<>i8l ~ 'WNl~

    FlQ'Q.
    ~\
    !?J,<J'B

    I \5l<P'lJ

    ''Qi9\fu ~
    <Q<:j

    \5fl~r\!)~ ~

    (Logical

    Form LF) 1 <!i~ ?j<f1c~


    ~'9~

    f.Trfu1~~

    '1.9 ~
    ~

    'ljf'fi3 <t1 ~'llfcjc~?1 <rG!'1l1 \5l'<l15, 1ituational


    'B >i1l1>fR
    ~(:\5f>i

    ~'1->i<f{f~I!
    ~,

    l)j4'i1<1 'B

    (interface)
    <!i

    (~8 ~
    6f<;j~'f

    f'~

    C''l'GQ

    6f<;]~'I-<!i~

    ~ffl <!i~
    ~

    1,t<1l

    r>W<1c;;pf ~

    'bll.q>:;·PF4'1\' 'Tt ~ QG1, ~!

    ''IN&Rb-f.i';l
    ~~
    ~ ~

    ~<.Q>(Sj

    logic <IT 9j';iTGfiPF~


    9(i'BTIi <m11
    fi1v:1,::~Q

    ~')

    ~~<>R ~

    -{?:'Bf

    "lJ?'1~
    >l'11>fR

    \5lW'ijj~
    <!1Ft
    <Q<r>

    <m~
    I ~'1
    <j<.f~

    <Vt?
    ~,

    .q>\5't1

    f.:ic;~ ~<$f.b(.<$ ~

    15lR:,~\!)t<jl'tll

    (Sentential
    ?ij9JR0[

    rn ~
    ~

    Calculus)
    1.!.1~~~

    m~ m::m
    ~

    '>f<fu" <Q~ ~OO? ~ <rl'&MtfJr1 qQj ~


    lR.<,JJ ~ ~~ ~

    '>jq ~

    >P1>iJ1C<J>5ll1R> '11 1 15ll1'm?f\.'7.;~

    '<lt~iMs<01'T'
    1

    ~
    11,-=>.~.

    ~.~

    ct<:lf

    ~I"

    <f-<>1&l11 2lVTI9f £:JNCm.'i!:<{

    fu-'~
    Qi9ft~

    'B <!i~-~<mVBr

    t~i1 <!S@
    q;:@

    {'~"lf.q ~

    '5lBr LF 1.!.1<1lR.~ r)J1r&<t>


    \QR:,iM'6i<l!'tll

    r?1Fl

    ~-~145j"@Q
    1.!.1 ~ ~I
    ~s

    <'i1<t>j<p¢j"f'i'f\5 'ZJf;Q,~j<:J

    ~ LF-\b~9f#1l_
    \5'q 'B ~

    mR>~c~1 <t>%f
    C<>i8l

    -it C~

    ~qiT

    1.!.1~

    <)1<f.j<J'''1C''1

    ~<i

    1'1Gr.1<l 1 f~"'1<l\5 LF ~
    <l'?l)" ~

    m ~'llt\5
    ~ cfl'<!17!1,

    ~
    ~_

    C:\::>(,1~C;G1"1, !14J\!)C~1 '11~ < c<J"'1 ~. He\!)


    ~

    <l'tWf ~9f<:~~ ~
    <Q~ ~
    ?l)~

    C:~SjI4 ~

    LF
    ~"1f4"1 ~
    •

    lR.<U

    f<i<:~ ~
    T<l@i~
    ~

    \51~~

    fu~

    C~N

    <r>@

    5l~j
    -S+

    j"1':"~-'''''' ~

    -"'- ..c

    mr~~
    0

    fiTG
    cQ~

    'lL

    ''2!~
    <!>@;

    2ffi1V1

    fu~

    ~<;j

    '1L

    ~t

    <!i">T-11.!.1'4 \5lf~

    ~ ~, ~ ~.
    ~<iJi&l
    ~ ~
    \5f1~

    ~91

    15l1'>ifu 'f!G1CCI:,{1 ~ <TI fuz>-~~~


    1Bf*,-\51<:j ~

    ~
    Gl'1~~B<fI '31 ~
    \5f1~

    ~?

    \!f;;m\!)v ~
    ~~
    ~-\!)1i:~'B

    81 m<M I~

    '€l'f\\!J'''l' \51'i>iitR ~
    ZfI~

    <n<PJ~<:(}~
    <!(OG'l

    <rIC1'

    \5'-<11 ~ ~~'fj\b1 'f[9f5!

    \::I~~II?j\5

    "PI ~?

    ~ <:fI~ ~1:z01
    ~ <Tj<:J

    (!!J'C<r>
    ~~

    C~rr~l' ~

    <rti1
    ~

    (5IJj~CIS(OG1fl ~

    '@<>f?ffrn:r" ~ ~'1
    9j~

    c~

    LF-<!i<1 ~
    ~~

    \5l~ ;rn, ~~~

    "1fu;, 'B ~it<i> )ji'Z'<lIk><t>


    ~ ~ 0C4 "f>f ~, "<!i \5f1~ <!I~

    ~qj

    1 C~
    ~

    ~
    I~

    ('llJj-5J(}SL<01~ @?f9f111J
    <r>'<r.N~ ~ 1.!.1<r> ~

    ~
    ':J'f1" ~

    <lit
    ~

    <l'Q(11

    ~'l)\5
    1

    1rfl'~"M ~ C\5t@ 13\~


    <!IC11

    \::)K"1 ~

    1¥1';'i1 <r>i<r'<B-~' 5j4_<{ ~ '<.~\.1S 0~~

    ?fl13 'if!

    <!I<l' <;j>j1{.!l"~'«:ll'i1 "11~ ~f


    <>fi@

    \5i~?f.!I R-m
    ?fiB 15lQ,)<fj

    1~

    'B <IT1')'-\5'I~?f<f

    '111 ~

    <f!<r>l

    15l14'SlH-6'5l 'i!R?i 1J1'<m ~ '4jl;~ ~


    ~'i'"@

    '111 <!i ~

    1I<r>J "?l1V'l01?j
    ~'

    l%:m~
    C~ ~

    t.t) (.e J ~

    ~?f'I'fR~<:¢i'iC1i
    ~'{3

    (components)
    cQ~

    ro~~ 1"'1,

    ~
    ~I

    ~"'-IDT "l~
    C<P'R lA1

    ~1.zCG1~ ~

    \5i~?f.!I ~
    ~
    ~

    (om positional function

    m, '?jf~'
    x~
    'B ~

    <jClC~

    '@R1-~',

    '(\!)<7Jl;r,-'~

    ml"S ~
    ~

    1 c<l'l"<11?l'Z63i'fu\5 '5Pr"fJ
    \5l '5f1~

    15ll~

    <ffi,I"? '~!' ~ x clW \5l)~ ~~JiMI cQ~


    ~ ~

    ~~1"1x 'i'ft'<:fl'BG11x~

    9ft'

    em QR91 cqz:<p
    I" C\51 >f<i ~

    '(1"Q>~

    ~C)l
    C~l~iDl

    Rv:r

    <Q~ifl'i!'i1 ~
    cQ~~

    <HI <!I<7H ~
    ~

    CBfBfl?Pl1 ~!f<f;
    1

    ('>,,"'b'!l)

    \51~'1<f ~<1
    '(11 ~,

    ~
    "~ <rn;\5

    C~-!i>C"l

    N>~,

    <!I~ QJ \5l(

    f<!;

    '51fu<ilrrt

    ~m
    ~ ",,'1<1'"1"1'

    (!!J'C<r>

    ~0
    '@9fIl1I'<i-

    ~i>J""il 1~' -?f1~?


    fflVTi <l'f!<l <1Bl'11
    ~?

    <!i~

    <!i~

    '41 <1.!l" '( ?) 4

    fi> -.rtB ~ t>'-l¥h1


    t ~

    cn~~it
    '""-

    "1~
    r--.,...,c~

    "1G1(O<.i<l, "15l1~
    ~ ,.4

    fi
    ~j<ii<l'1'

    6fl(JR,

    \!)~

    <!'S?

    c<rt4
    ~

    hi7/:~?
    ~~

    c"1~m 1

    ~-c<r>

    I5l1iir

    9flTIr ~

    1 '510

    <rt ~
    ~
    "?lie'll'?) ~!

    :Q0i41
    <!I ~
    ~

    'll"G19ff,:rrn .!l"JJI1"f( ;1'(1, 1~"C~IV'1i.'311<!i~ ~ ~'5t(."1(,4~


    'TIl, ~

    C~"?l

    4('1'c.:"
    <ilG1,

    '5ff119fi"1~-i<l~?1 I '5ff11"11"1~ GJS1T,<i ~ \.5Pfl-~~

    v-»

    r,"

    ~ "11~(,~

    Cill:'<1, '<1~.zlr:C'" i5fl~1 ~,

    ~(G1 T .• _ <!I ~

    "l'R<;N ~ '1"'i'<illRi'1'
    ~

    \5i'I<r>i1 o;n:r'Z ~'>i" (~


    ""l~
    <j'j

    : ,>;;o8lr)
    ~ '@?f1!fR~

    0'&.!l"Sl f.T;fi"1

    <!>@, ~

    \!)OQ'B \51~ WJ"'f


    <K~

    ~,
    1'1('\!)

    <nC"'h1

    'B~

    ~ct

    f.'IM~'Yn'tft, <h~1 ~

    <J]\S''l\%;;

    I~~

    ~<i'<jCl ~

    ?f"ID1?

    "l1"f1'lC"1 4"[<lM

    <ri ~

    @~<fm

    1Sii§:1\:51<l1

    . I :K.a:tbi!l eil!<e';l1,'!1

    [2nd f~roofl 52;

    (,~!'.d~ 'Or-~I ~.
    9LSI

    <8J~ ~ C~R

    qjf'~ ~<,pUi

    -m~4!

    'l!!? ceJ1~tl~'9f Sitf~ ~~


    9ff@: ~

    c:QrGG1ftf~
    ~~ ~

    ~o~a1 '}:jt-il~ ~~

    '~~"?J
    ~~

    ~<l[J.

    >t~E"@ (shift) \5r~~'i<1_,1

    .i.Q~~

    '~ii\;~·i~
    ~~~1'~1 l!!~

    -~

    l1lW'

    ~~C:'6 9j1~tG1~ ~t<t q;,Q[t-~

    H~~ .~q
    ('bM' ~ .. I
    '~<1&li

    w.~
    ~r[<q I
    ~
    ·'"n..

    ~·?j~~·'K.<P

    ~'i
    '-

    ~'Z.·3ij?it~·
    /
    "

    fDf::zo\p
    '~(P1~

    '~"~t\t)

    ~'t (G~tM'f'j'~~~13f ':~

    c~t~
    'C?R':i{ ~'I~' 1c.!1'~ SiCol

    ~1?f«1"£fC~L"5T'YJ1 ~
    <.?tiii ~,~~
    ~~'{f

    ,~. l~(.~Rr

    ~Ml~~'Af ~-~

    O:«»':s1 ~~T ~~
    ~ ~~t~lC)t

    9j'nf~

    ~:tz~ \"5Ii9I ~1J I G3i~ ('y{W-'S4 ~

    '\!)1<ij '5Pi~}f~·~t

    ~1t~
    .

    ;ql .~ 't8T1 ~~z·~~


    ~.~

    '\5.P"t1P1\{f-.5i?t· a~,(<::p

    41 @t?f1'fil ~,
    '51~.Q.G1f ~tS1
    '~

    ~lf'C~r-1f~ ~.
    ~;~ ~JJ?LI

    t~~ ~'~~ ,~'(~,~r ~~


    ~ "~~. ,~~ t,;ql<l~3l'~ '~~

    r~(;qbi;{t

    ¢~r~'
    ~!1'"
    ''9-~

    -;qfG1f~ ~~9j(~~
    _

    4
    ~

    r~t~\S@ ~

    e~I~,'~ .~ ~~' ~-~~,

    -m1J~ ('-!}'ilR ~

    .. ~~1t<1 l",,·'i(g~ ~

    trans-meaning, trans-sign I.·~ 'HOb ~j'/l, ';fI, 'i5~Rf;g


    ~ ~>j~\t)]' \5f]1~'

    <v-.ry"
    -~

    .~I'1lR:~ l1t1Y<S ~'#H ;;~m:mG1~~,lft~. iC\§f ,~t'1f ~~Ulir;;1r~ ''}jf~~ ;:rn~,. 1t61 ~ ."

    .~;vrrr-~~<lGi'K<t~,

    CtF~

    >jF~fij,~ ~~ ~

    \5K;EP-:5Ci1{,~(J1 tfl~1RiBl-

    \5tc.f)\!)~ ~G1f0SifCiffi4"i'Wr

    ~
    ~9]~

    C9nWr~K~{\!)rn

    :~:c~. I '\5ff~

    '~I

    'Yi£~"it~

    M~~~

    '<TIrn~

    ~Z11 ~'i1~,

    '~~'?it~ (l.8.
    .cqm:~l'?j~

    ~<l~'rn'~

    <f-'~--<J1~>loq

    :>ft~rer<f$ ~{t1l4~1t.~~ ~;zP1I~'

    1M ~~~~9f-'
    .~n~~l ~
    '8.

    4",xrFi~~;:qs~~
    ~\t\[)~?i~~$f~;~'
    .(.1$d-j{.\3'

    \brnMrM<P

    <W1
    wt~~

    (altG:Wt~~
    'ej(jb\!5il

    ~RlQ_1>i,(}'p.'8

    1f<~lR>~J3i~f'{ ~~ ~F6\B3\!}rn f~~q!


    <'$r~J~PTi <n ~~'~
    ~
    '

    ~~1 i ~«i~1i\W.¢''1 ~Qff

    t3i1t~

    ~Cr,j~(\!)-vtI~'

    C\2if?J;fw~,?t

    ~1Bf. '5ft~~t[{P{j;f ~ ~

    ~ (}p!lGGi~ I

    ~9ff?r I' lS'R

    \8

    ~4P'lf4:<F?l (~~~~J

    ~,

    rir*rq

    81 ~.

    !@jI.~G.'1f\b~?1
    I~

    ~~~.,fl;i1"«

    J1~rPX~}; % \~
    ~"'i

    CI'f:'8m ~ .2f~'8 ~-~

    _. ~~l1~f
    ~'QH?,

    .. ~

    ~--,~->t.

    9:)')"1 '{)lC6~trJ '(~~

    c~ ~ ~m ~m.
    ,1;1 if, t§f1~}05"

    "We assume that thy language (the generative ~procedure,


    the l-tanguage)

    computation system and a lexicon, The t1r'st .g,eOe!rate~s the' S[)s -(Stnlc,;,
    has two -componenta
    : a.

    ;n~I.ql'Vfl ~

    N(3i C~~~l
    ~
    ~

    W@~ffi

    :!!~,

    "\;q

    rural Descriptions), the. second, chracterizes the lexical items

    c~
    '~~

    8r,~t~back.

    to the future t ~C"i~~~. ~

    .8r ~,~~~..

    9f'l~~~ ~R<$ ~
    .~ (A"d1('\§'
    "II~
    ,

    ''1M8J! ~($iC~ ~~;{~"tf'{\51~"'Yj<f{,<p'qi<p$l~ I


    \S ~
    >.,;; ,,'

    ,9fR~Jj-{. ~f7gr:rr;;r
    \""-1'"1

    'f$)73i,. 1i~~l~m~J'!l'~
    {:>i5c~~1tii1
    :,~-'-·I
    _.. ;._SL_

    tB;~~, Wf'(~~P:U~ .@\5UJ"


    v' ,,'\
    ""I.:ii
    ,,:1".-1/

    "'ill·I f\~W<·"I"; "5:Ii ..


    "'I.h ··''-'>,t\-;o-:'!· ...
    '~'-' ~

    -.

    ~\.".:--I.

    ...-<...
    .-.

    "':;1"iT.:J
    -

    ~I'\.~·l \."'1'1.

    rrr;;:;j

    ~~. ~\~-,:,.",tft.9

    ~ ~.lli?J'I··~Cl"'· ~
    h·=i: .~.~,.
    .~

    ~t
    '1~

    ca' \S~i~,ft
    <fj~

    that appear in them, Mal~ycurciaI how these 'systems interact."


    '0fB$I@ .~:
    ~

    questions arise "as to ~W <P~1(.~~, '~~Of9fr3\'!ill

    O1:-rnqt'"+il'~~'
    ~f~?
    tQ:. Ji'~

    ~~,,~.

    compU!tati:qn-'~m ~,st

    ~~

    ~W

    Ff4iffi~? f';;'!M"f.' l.

    "'1$W5l"-0f~~

    ..-,..

    I~

    e.

    ~~";I.q,ltiit::r ~

    ~<.~~
    '-

    'l5f(J)\!l~

    "8

    ~l\!)~J?1

    (~.

    ~~~'Iil~

    ~OilRklfl~

    '1$~1%~ ~
    ~ ~.~~~-!.fl

    =9~~,~~li ~<p
    "6i";(J[~-~~\f:j

    t~wf1Wiz~II ~~1.z~@i
    'CF{jq-ii \5fl~~9(jffi<t1rn4

    C~

    ~\

    8T'~

    ~Cb",(jl

    ~,~

    II

    jogocentrie,
    ~ -<l'ri!rt~ii,

    ~~.

    ~,

    ~~~91fu'$i

    ~('~<1HC~~

    ~~

    Computation-cis

    !.lg9tentrk 7ft ~,~~ c~fG1~~?1f&~ \5tt?r'8 ~, ili~

    t.

    (.{V·, b)_

    ?~1 ~ "ifi"~ .~ '. if.~i Z\5, ~ ot<tf Q@P-5 ,llspLaCemfn[;~ .~ '~I''!?R<q ~etonym, X5f1~ fondensatioo-<!j:<i1 ~"CG1 ~ ~,etaphdtC\!)I?4 ~"I -~rt(~<H~:!1ii
    ~ ~11<1, ~~

    .'-

    cilC.~4jC;;1Z

    ~ ~ ~~ R ~!:~1
    ~~(j1~

    'Wl ''''.·Sl·~I·~m, 161::Z:\5q.$lt9~ ,code~~

    (~U G (Universal

    Grammar) must provide means.to prevent


    to

    ~r~

    an array of items i.n a form accessible

    the computational

    .~ ~l~"$,

    ~~T$@f~~G~~ d:l<h

    ~~')

    "o~f9fi8<11rnzr; '~~
    (~'1~

    '{3~;GG11'

    system, " ()~~ ~ :v)


    '~0<l1

    1_G1I ~E.\5 ~"?;<ll 'l~qt~ooA~ ~~i<!)

    ~m <;!l<J) M.~ transgression


    ~ I ~!A .<!Jtj i!l'8§~

    ~ ..~

    ~<PF1r:<P~C:~~ ':yF~9fTqC\!)~ ':1~~iI<f$


    ~'?i~r ibf~~¢~:q
    ~<f~ ~<fS~ ~ ~
    ''A,~

    I wfB:\!),~~(.~ '~1C$!rt~ C':iF(,c!1 ,lQ~

    '~~94ft:ci, Wj~Z~'~ '1J~J!I transgression

    f~~C:il~' ~fi

    ~«I..Q~ ~

    ~f~

    "5j'$~~ ~ '.!l<'i1V1 ~~1Cnn.~

    f4~'Qr~1

    d uVJrJ

    sign : a. t neory of language, that 'takes' a linguistic expression to be n-othing other than formal obj-ect that satisfies
    [he interfac-e conditions
    jn

    ·Hll ~<j

    "''(lGi~

    optimal

    \;I;,>~ay."(')~~~: '9;)

    1l\9<Jj

    A> ~
    \5l'l~-c<r~i1t'1

    <TI c'l'f.'Gl (~ l<t4:f c'lV'f ~ ~


    ~
    1

    ~?

    c:<l ~
    :gJ?

    "interface"
    <IT;C'i

    \5fl~

    "array" D"1Cr;z-~<j ~,

    ~IWl"1C~<:j ~1'f\1t'.'!> ~

    lategory-~ CII:?C'1 ~
    ~

    m+~
    ~
    '5«l~I\S ~

    "taxonomic M!Jt.~1'13
    MOVE,

    arrifacts'I-a

    9j§"j\5 ~

    1 c£]~
    ,2J~

    ,rnpty CG1"<l1 ~
    ~"1'q;

    t<? It"i 1 \!lfrG<1> ~~'{{ rNGEST

    ~
    ~

    <TI 1 <i1~ 9ff"ff?liR,

    ~'Z:q;f\b<:j ~2JWf ~~
    "r-r ~
    '<I~
    rrrt-srt

    :>jf\1J~ <ji'r.q> Zl1i'~<1>


    ~\!)

    ~fi1~
    ~ ~

    Schank-<i1~ c2li2:l1fil'Z C<i~It<T <,Q'lfIm


    (CONTROL, PART)

    \5l \5l'l~ 'G3j<{'!>lGG<1> ~

    f.'nIT"i I ~
    1I:?1"'l1" I "~ :?iFS<li"1 ~, HC$! ~

    \5l'\V<m ~

    ..flll:?fC<l-PR.OPLE,

    ~~ ..fl<?1b1<i),~YI<j>I"V \

    r.fz

    ~W.I <rf1) ~ ~WI ~


    . Technical
    ~? ~

    m9f<f. ~
    c'l'Z ·C2l'im\~

    ..fl'5 "11'1t '<frm<lT~ ~

    minimalist

    '!>1.

    ~9

    ~~

    ~"1cr;zrj, <fl{'.'5 0filB1"lFb\S3'!>I<l~ >i'1Ji"1$l1: ~',


    1

    "l1_Ji%lifl. \5lN
    ~"<f.1

    ~VT~ ~~
    ~

    ftR ~ ~
    ~ 'I3'i:\'?', ~~

    rn
    9f1t?j

    c;i(;)~

    8m:>Kf

    <lj'!>jSl ~?

    C<i ~
    '<!It~ffC~7j

    <Ti-'!f<l'>'1t ~

    ~/~~i)T~O<fI m 1 ~
    '5<1";{ \5Bl1 C<!

    <>\1M, ~

    <rt
    <l'i@'

    ~/

    ~ 'if

    ~ {z't~

    -:>jlf11SjN'@lAl ~,

    <>@fl:fC<l'

    '¥i

    "c'l~~
    'f'@

    1-1"
    ~

    lntelligentia-a Gouldner (~",,,o.)

    \5l<f!

    001)

    (<p~t:"1"i ~

    ..!f~ Tech-

    nical lntelligentia-s critique code ~o) ~

    <,Q~

    "Culture

    of Critical Discourse." to mount a


    ()~lvO :

    (ceo) '1"1C~<j I Gouldner


    of the dominant ~
    ~!"

    " ...his (Chomsky's) system depends

    vel)' capacity
    :

    ~ '1I:?1<:d~
    ~, ~

    :i1(.'!>1 ql@
    <j>@' ~

    <m~

    "<?Bl \5l 051 ;rn

    <jS~ZF1it<l>
    )",,,,8 :

    1'1. ~~

    m~
    1~

    R <f.t
    C~
    ~?

    in part on his using the very


    (:"",,,0.

    (CCO) normal ~

    to the new class."

    8,,)

    W
    ~
    ~

    (;.sl1$lllf.'f[ ~~

    Q}IC'!>i cD.-<l'>"1 ~ <lJr&9j\5


    ~I

    '1lC3i'T

    '1."ff'lj>@'13
    17i1~ <Jl~ C~'?r

    1i<l"j\!)C'G1 .2l1J%'~ '~, '!>(\ij1 ~~ fomputation


    ""11<{<Pt<.--l jfo1 ~ 9Jt'lf-..fl~ 'l3Q
    ~

    <1l1Sj(:<l~<f.

    G(.'-!;;:1(

    II:?INrjP\ I" (~, ~ C1~"1f~ ~1Jf<1


    LG'1'C"i~

    9j~I"1t?f I)

    "self-avowed"

    .2l~1\!3i'31 ~,V1TI'1l~ ><]'?r9i?fl1 ~


    ~-<v<fo'M

    \51<lC'!>'Q_\5l'<lI<1> iffiC"i ~
    ~:

    'G3liMif\G<1> N'G3j~1 c'l<1Bi @C"i ~, ~-~ C<il'>!1VJt"i ~


    ..fl<f QJ \!iilI ~ ·-51!.'19 ~ <,Q'f.'Gl ~
    C~-~

    '&t9f<T8l1 ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    ~f.q,~<iQ
    ~ ~

    <jS'<fI-<11 W"<fo'M
    {<R

    rn'

    \!limn ~ <rt
    ~'I

    "Mi

    <n<1>J~'G C<! ~

    ~7j-<Q~

    <f.'<fI <rr.G'i-~
    t"
    (.\5j

    :q>-<f.1\9 <rt ~'I

    Computation
    ~"<R

    'fir'!' ~
    ~<:G1 q;o·ff C<?(~

    m-~
    ~!-

    <jSm'13

    1 Government-Binding ~ ~ 2i~ (.'!>j(G''H, "'~


    ~,

    f.hpl::t1f\1

    <n !rinCiPle<l"!~'13

    l· (

    ,J

    t· l· /

    ~"1fSr'1 ~

    (/f.flgOcentric

    aI'Z<i><F1'lf.,cQ<f

    w."j.~ ~
    ~
    <r(f'fi1,

    <rib(A~ \5iWi"i0"T~ f.i';'1 'f"f<l '5l Si<l~


    I"

    m ~,

    i!3f<l1f.'T \5IfI

    '''5"<R 'fii ~

    '5lWZ!

    '5jJfo1~-m
    <:f1<J, ~

    cornputation-na

    ~?"
    ~<.j)

    Ct;<1>cr:IiN~, ~

    <rI~"i
    "~

    ~-.>jJqI"1
    <TI, \5[1

    "'1'>1 'f'Gl'1
    ~

    "~I"1<jI1M!CI$1

    \5l'l~9

    C<ri"iIi:<11"i 11'1tl

    ~
    ~

    ~ <IT"H ~ citM.'t1?lij '5l1~


    !lgocentricism

    T"ll"f1 ~

    $~~
    1<m;;5 ~
    ~

    <j1'1(OQ'\ <11\9111 Fi>~?

    $~
    '5lIZ\?i.
    '<:[i).if

    <ID9J'GTIlt ~
    ~

    c'l~

    ~~j'0 C<! ~

    m~

    Cejj~lDT~ ""~
    D?Yl1fMTIf 1

    \51 I,pr<g'!> I, <1l<1 ~~


    "l~

    ~f."<"

    "lV1 C5V1

    ~......,:;: .r;'-'l~'1'

    0filVTf ~
    ~"11

    ,....

    ~
    ~

    <n \51~ -:;rm<rR!


    ~

    <.!l<f ~<.j}

    ~<!
    ~

    "iflT 1 ..fl~
    ~,

    Si<rli ~

    "1",i

    "1"'' 'J ~}
    SATiSFY ~

    \5l@

    'if fui-1l11'DICMl

    C'¥Ccl 9"'<j<ro~ 1~1Sl f<rcx.{~

    '<!ill <TI

    "'ll>C<1 'if I "}']~~9j

    \5l~

    2luli61OlhJ'!>f I \51'<1 ~ <n1! PF~<f1


    "l~ ~
    cQ~ ~

    c'lq;{)j ~~
    OUT 2if~!Jm

    ~tm"8M~
    \5Rj'1l1l'/j

    .2l1<li\6<l'>412fm>i <nGl<l>II:?IL1 ~~

    05fu
    ~
    "l~

    'f'<10 \Sf"11?"

    - <i1.2lI&.Wl c'l'f.'Gl array f.;t1tW'!> Binding


    ~~,

    :gJ~PELL

    <V-fl
    ~
    1

    <l"1CQ'\'i, "C~
    "i<li"l :!l01<? ~ c'lV1

    \!lIC"i<f. \5llC~
    1 ~

    -.n~
    ~

    ()~",,,,)
    ~"i

    '!>C\ij ~ .l-jL3t ~

    c'ljfo1 <fl<jS 2iftrm,

    ~a <w.l

    COMMAND

    ~'i.5P1
    'f'@,

    MC$l~C"1«

    2:'~!Ji,

    CG1'<!1 ~

    ~1C~01 W"?C1

    '6l«'1<1>'G1 C~l~"@lZ "lj\;'Gw)I<:{I~1 (~, c41r&<1>,!>j<l

    f.pfrq 'f'C<1 :o:n \5lm \5[118<n1l 1 ..fl'Z \51Zf1<J:'3 ~


    I

    '9fV5

    'f'@1
    '6ll~
    I

    viZ

    0<mJ

    <,Qoq~

    m~

    i8fFTi~,

    <fl <Hit."1'>i :;:jf&!JG1

    \5l2i~ l3"1"1~
    <:fm

    '&11*11 \5l~

    \5lf~lI:?i<l1
    ~

    (Gfil ~
    C'M ~

    ~'<1"fi"i\!5 2f811\51C«-:.1 2i~

    i7R ~

    "1ii5

    m~

    M)[~rT"i, <rI c'l~


    Vl'l3$lB[

    a%l

    ~'13 ~

    I 'f'Rq ~ I c'l 051 <i1~

    ~\51N<1>'!>1 ";ffi ~ '4Jl'<1I01]>:,>l1

    .+ J

    :,,;,,~~ : ~b') M<'<1>-"5M

    <fl~.l-j"1 4~\FTI

    I-;v'i
    fi'i(.!J

    <f1<J

    ,'!)~?)\5

    c'l~ \5l.?iI'f'!>

    NIOJ.~108?l

    \5Pl~, N1\5ISlrj-ISlM'!>
    ::z[~'Z <rt<rll"

    R>t~ ~~

    7.Z'1M' )arameters

    <iTI<1Jf ~

    c'l"<R I

    "Tool

    using animal"-<Q~

    ~<ffi5

    .,
    ~
    1'@ ~ ~

    ~~
    I~

    ~,

    "<Q"'M 4Q)1 ~

    (.'i'j4Ci'1i(.iSt~ 1(3<:[

    '6~

    f.T;5~
    ~ <l>i19 ~ "

    ~01l

    ®l1'i'!llfGl' <f!<;J]1 \51~


    ~

    ~ MCl'

    ~?

    ~1:j<'1~~

    f<l;- ~

    ~z;3 "fI ~

    ~?

    C"'f~rr <n"f\51
    ~
    ~

    fu.s! ~
    ~'1 B'j'>l ~ I <Q'$T<f!"'M

    B'j'>l :q;:fu ~? 9f1B 'lI-\58


    c<! ~

    ~11.!:ru

    C'3'i

    0f<iz CJ'R
    <ffi1 ~
    ~
    '<Br

    >it:>'>IIM '51~ C~
    ((0 ~

    ~'1B1'>l ~"1C'!l 'lI "iBlBr '5fJ1'a19j~


    '<jCQ'>I"lK,\51 <f!<illI

    ~~')/~~~~.~ f~
    v(

    (.D1"<1 ~V1

    @Gt ~

    <Hi <1'11', <Q'Q:'~~

    GMJ, ~
    ~-:-\!)I~(Pi

    ~\3
    ~
    <wl@ 9l@

    vrn (rr.:M '>i1C'f~) ~ I~ c<n~


    ~

    1 ~, ~ '511~
    <Hi~1 \5fJ~ IflC{l ~

    N~~IG~I

    S1~ ~

    \58. ~~~ ~ 'bC~~ C<l ~~~ c<! ~h"1'G G!1V'i, ~ on~

    "iiyf"iT9C'!l<1

    05fu

    ~m

    <f!\5'liS<:[ oo;~
    Y[~~ ~~ Jj@ ~

    <114J'!lC~~

    '¥1 c<! ~

    (~
    GlI41~R~~'!lI51

    Jj'Z~

    I~"

    Vf'Bmf) , I~ '$;'lj ~

    DW'I
    ~

    c<J<1

    '51fbR'0

    ffi "-

    !erI£<3Pi
    ~, 2i~ ~'!ll>j

    <iC-H, "<Q'SfOl<l'Q)1 05l <WI8. \5Tl~'? '5I1"'Rtm ~ Ri'l'3j~1~1 I (fj~

    <if 'bIJI<71"1N't"l

    <Ql''1"4~ GT~ I ~ ~

    ~"!:l ~ c<J~
    ~

    \Wi \;(ytl"iJ c<iVf. <Q~

    /tgocentric
    '1j4')'!lW~

    I c<R <Q"foi ~.('I\.._

    €. C)

    <Q8 '-!?I('~I~

    ~"11f.1 S11:<f.l ~ ~'11l1ft ~


    ~ <n1r~? ~
    er'lj?R5 ~ <Q~ I"

    f<l;-? ~
    ~
    ~I ~ \5fJ~? ~.
    :

    ZI(:!:j"Q \;'{3"1 01'B~

    CG'$!tJ

    <Q>f'11"4fQtG'ii

    ~~~j\1i;Q.$Irn ~~,

    C6'1"Gf ~ "~ost

    : of these issues <)lniversal guage or Chomsky's Mental ist/ innateness

    dL c.

    m<r"tl ~
    ~~ ~"i'1'

    C"l"1l ~~, '!llc'!l f<l;- "l1"'1~~


    \5fJ"TI~ ~~

    011~

    <f!1~"4 ~<l' ~'l~ <ji~1

    characteristics

    of Ianare

    t·

    argument)

    2)i\!J&~I~ ~

    cL;<jif.<iIC-1ilC»'iCofj

    ~I <;"11 ~'1-(:;'","I'b,

    ~Gffl:9i\5

    matters of speculations and unlikely to be resolved in the near future. Moreover, they are not wholly relevant to innateness or linguistic theory and practice. [t is perfectly possible to be

    ~~~. "lJi;~
    'B1:rI~

    i'l'3i'i'!liGG<l> ~

    iJfil, ".?l~
    ~l ~

    ~13 '5$1 9fi'STIBf ~

    c~

    ~,

    )(;)b-'''1

    )",~-)",q)

    h.--

    follower of TG and still reject mentalism, them." (Palmer, 1983 : 194)

    1!"1'-!?I('~I"1

    \Q;~j\b ~was that human Influences


    ~,

    universals, or alternatively, to be a structuralist and accept. brain were, 'uncoupled' from "One word of caution should be added, however. That is, it is not necessary to accept Chomsky's views on innateness in order to go along with his views on the goals of linguistic theory.i.ln fact, it is perfectly possible to accept (Radford, 1986 : 28)
    <l1<t>j'!l('G51 <ii1~ ~

    "The .most extreme view, expressed by the members of the. audience, any genetic
    ~ ">1'01)

    whatsoever

    that, like computers


    <Q<!~ <Q~"im

    built to a standard design, by programming." "As scientific

    hypothesis,

    these as-

    sumptions, whieh are familiar from radical beheviorism as well, seem to me have little to recommend them. On these assumptions, it would be quite impossible to account for of their growth ..." the richness and complexity of human cognitive systems and the uniformity
    ~, \!)i!(G"'11: 1<:,(:\;5 "i~

    part or the whole of Chomsky'S Linguistics without accepting his Philosophy of Mind.." \5B! ~

    fiT; ~ "i'i'01fG¥ ffi 'lI ~ <:il"61TI ~Tj<J? ~C<: ~ ~v:m:"i fiT; ~ B'j'>l1\5l'FJ ~~ \5fr{ 2i';lY&<l ~B"'..~ 1)pn <rrn, ~ ~
    C~Cc!1'B ~
    'Jf&l<jJ

    m
    ~

    (9M

    I ~~

    <Q<f~ <lil'J'!l!.~<j

    2i>{l'0~ QG'i?

    '5fl'0i, \5TI"i'<:fPri Language and Mind {)N"I'!~,

    ~m Y[Vl1
    M>
    \5lH
    ~I

    Generative
    <l'@

    Enterprise
    "11c!11]Q)1

    <f!~ <Q~

    1510'< q~? ~ ~

    \5fAI"<1 ~
    ~'icU~ce!Mm1 f<,i'l'3I";;f~~ CtJ<t>f,;~!G'j

    <Q~ ~

    : .c<f><1 ~"foi ~~ CQ,~

    "1\bR

    '5ff9f'1l~

    ~qj

    G'$'>I~lFff

    ¥'>ICll>,'i l" ~~ "Kil ~

    <Q<t>II \5lIB

    'TI<fi, (»<t'Rl'i"'1
    ~'5j

    \5R<l, ""1j\1J~
    ~
    Gi~(il

    J'jR>J~ ~

    <f!~(,G'fi \5l~N"l
    «]~ ~

    (blind

    c<W'i ~~

    '5ff"!1 ~?
    ~~

    m~<j(PK~'i

    c~ 'f"I~

    \5lB[

    <lft
    I

    M?L'<il immuned

    spots)?

    '§"1~

    Aporia-n ? ''o/''Y'~'
    Ci,~ ~

    c?f\v!z Me'».
    iSr1iMC'!l

    <t>'Qj ~l

    C'G~f.1'1>fG'j ~,
    ~?-<Q"l'i\!)'>1

    CilRiG

    6ft'lI ~

    <f!'SfOl<Q9" <l"RI'ljjo:K'!l,

    'ffii "fI? ~

    f<l;-

    f.ID:r

    '-!?1l>iC<ii1 ~

    "lVTt<2if\!J<iJit;:>1 .?lqf{.,,'>1 6ITJ ~

    r:

    \5Ir~

    '?"1m
    :8: II ~
    ~

    exPI 11"l~

    I~

    'fi ~
    18f'1J?
    -Q~

    <Ml"Pl jl(,l'l1't-~
    B!7jii5"lT90 ~! ~ "51~, ~ \!i1 ~ ~

    5f'Gm'q

    C~I'&rn

    4'1Jtl<1J

    ~~ ~

    ~?Rm
    C\!l~

    ~?f\5

    ~ oW<!(F!,

    ~ ~

    ~ 'f-qrn
    ~

    ~
    1:f~

    '5l\1l~(%;1

    ~
    ~

    ~ rn
    '5lj\;,iM~I<n~
    -Qq.tj

    HR~~ f.'r41"i ~ <:5m


    ~C'G~
    '@9;~ ~

    ~~ "f"f"ll \5fI<r c<l

    '6C'Q'1 ~ \!5~I3l<.ff
    ~

    ~j;f,jP'J\Q<i
    ~

    ~::~-:i Diful l\!)M "BJ I 21m 2~hl_:_m'frn mm~ ~ I


    ~ \511

    ~H¢

    ~U

    ~
    'i37;'<jJQ

    'film ~
    'l5QjJ-'fRi1"<1 ~

    \5fP'R:G'j

    '!)(O'Q1 ?/l\fP.J, ('<tff.


    ~

    I \5i~

    C"IG'i~'f~I('1
    ~

    c<l ~PiU1,
    \')C'Q1 ~

    <ri'i I
    I *Pii <10c"I <l~

    I~

    '@~

    '5l<1e'li=\~ "'5l'8l <ll1')'!)(.'iJ1 \5l1~ cfJ'f- ~

    If!~ ~

    c<R

    11l"l"l ~; ~
    ~

    \Ell"l
    ~'-<il~

    '>l.f""!~-,?jRl~11T I <!l4]\!)C'GQ~

    iF! c<J ~<1 k-ittl\d1i.\Q~jj ~

    em
    I

    for;:m:'f ~ ~
    "i~.

    ~,

    <lTGY \'51 ~
    ~

    {~I

    <!1(';\5(G4R<1'fG'i

    .-n';f<j ~

    m ~ fils <lmn ~
    ~ ~ (Jffi~
    <l\PI ~ c<l ~ ~

    I 1J0<1 ~

    <li<t>j'!)C'!,Ii"l~

    fi:fGr ~">{~ <mr (~?


    1R.'3i

    c<l ~ Ibjl~I'1\!l'l

    ;n~?), ~
    "iJM>K'i"1

    ~~ ~
    ~~(!"l1Sl

    (.9;'"0

    (9fG1-~
    I~

    ~
    ~{j

    <m~
    7j\!5 ~

    ~.
    (,Q)V:i>

    <1Jf&7jG
    ~1$]1~{j
    '1"1~ ~)

    (?j'VJ m"!·1 ~

    ~
    "l~ I

    <T1";fi~

    <lJi<f.$l"i Program-a

    <!l~

    11"l<1>

    ~
    <Q <!1~

    <Q:q:fG ~{,\5

    ~1<1~'1C(
    \')('Q1 If!~

    Minimalist
    ({.S.).
    -Q~

    <>@""i\!J !iJI.5 ~p ~

    ¥G'f
    ~

    ~i!"l'3m~ ~

    <rt 'Samizdat' ~"R


    'M1 ~ ~
    : )'60

    Gultung
    ~ '¥"I<iIl';1 <p'<Il<fi\5i DG1I5:"I <1"<./<1 =\W~{Fl"'11 <!1~"<1~~ (cfJ~ ~ <Q1>

    <l>H~

    ~ \5l1~

    ~ I cfJirn::tJ.~

    'f.T'1~<.r
    1" (~~~,

    q;~-~
    :;,,,,170

    0BJ I
    (g~'!)

    @?fRN"i<ffI1-f<mn~
    I 'l5r~~

    <!1~

    -Q~

    ~, ~~,

    W? ~?H~
    )"''''..>_

    ;rn-<ITi'i'fPlti ~

    ;rn-"This

    <iZ?f '7i~
    '~

    Rbf~ ~
    ~9f

    ~
    1(.<lt f.'r-ll

    ml:9f~ "11> ~

    m "BJ, 7f1~ "l~\5r:

    parallel

    is not a Joke,
    : ([9.)

    it is a structure

    .~ ~FG:
    <Q~

    ~N

    \5l<jl~IR?<1'), <Q~

    <.£l~J:m'11''1'
    -QT\<12j)~

    ~XZl<f ()"'%

    '69.),

    <Q<1''3i<i

    "1~%!Rl<1' ~

    ~
    ~ ~

    <rim «'$1 )j"l5'jI~G¢ ~?j1>ivf. <rm\5


    ~ ~ \5.lQJ<fl

    ?f1Br
    ~
    ~

    ~~'1I5G'f8!-~?!
    ~ ~

    :'i'111 "l1"11"l~lf'Q'1' G!i'F1~C"l


    ~ \5l~ B!"i
    9@

    0:5f<l: ~,

    \5l1'1:frn ~

    >PPli'4fil<f. TIl~

    C<l, D'i'l,~

    1v\1l<i(''P..Q!GCf., \5f1'TR.,,!Q \5Qf){3\FftN

    "l~1f.1~1

    '4<1'\'S'Qc4

    1«'11

    0'8111

    <n,
    cfJB

    \!lh'll ~~

    m?fvi

    PH:$j~

    ~'2

    I ~TI

    ~
    <Q~'<IL;<1j

    ~~
    ~I"

    <rf1:"11 <Q"<fl8 Rf6l1


    (marked) ~? M[T-(,\5
    Yj~}{ffi

    JTI<tSi01l<i (unmarked)
    I~
    15\~

    -s <lJI\!><Q"li1
    "iZ~

    ;q@-?j'1P!1

    ;ffi ~-c!l'<rrc<1'6

    Co'l'Sm ~
    ~

    'I5~\FWf

    '<3~ <Q~
    If!<q ~

    ~TiR~ ~

    cq;jQjj1!?

    ({.({,

    '$l"l c<J ~

    t7i'l>T ml\!>~(X\j
    (;\!l~ =\"1 ~

    C<liM1R<t> ~1Y:I\QJ<Jl'1! 2l!C.fi\1 'l5Q.,1pf~~1=\<1''11 ~ I

    ~ ~

    ~-~9 C~ ~

    f1N,n ~
    <:f.04

    rn >0'1 ~
    t<t>U:±1:,
    ~

    <l1<t>1~C.'iJ1fWPl ~

    <:5m
    1<Q"lBl,
    o.Q~

    m~
    mi81't<1G¢

    -Q~

    "<flm~

    ~
    ~,

    C'iWl1 ~

    OO~ rtJ"RJ<nlTI ~!~\~~C<f. I <r'1! 9f<MI~f8<'1> "i>~C\D I \5f1<;f1~ ~

    ~
    cfJ~r~'l2:j~

    ~
    ~ I

    \5Pl)'1

    '3~'p!;V'11

    'S~

    (;~~

    «l':l;H'il\3 C¢(~

    ~'<j51

    r:Wi

    m
    {j

    f<tt1t<J'1 '1'-:i(O'!) ~~
    C~ ~ cfJrrtJ~-:zw.g

    ffiI<t> '1..\7Gft
    ~"'1<'
    '1'@

    <:f.04

    ~I

    ~
    c'<tff.

    '11 ~?

    fQN3f?r
    <'!1iil(~f\b4~j

    <.£l~ '1t'1 ~
    ~ ~

    1til<l"Q:i<1C<'1> mqrn

    13m ~ R>
    ~qI

    fW

    ~1

    '5fBl ~
    '<'1><:q1 ~

    GflG'fltff \50? Gfl"Rr C31 -Q~q

    '1(.\.I(;iz ~C<1lSjjBmlG1

    <Q<l>f<Iv<l'<f
    .;>-['&1

    ~7.'Tf.R\5 ~

    'l5Qf) ~

    :!'JVWl~ ~

    11i<rl1'1 ~

    B!<ml
    ~
    <i')~

    f"iD1'e D';l~'1
    NI58!C<i'1

    Gultung ~,
    o.Q;q; "1"1~

    c<l'm ::;;r<J "ImJ

    ¥l~

    Jil'>lj>'ful 00
    If!~ ~

    ~"ll";f~

    ~
    ftc4~

    HS"?Ri1
    ~
    ~ ~
    <Q~

    'eMlm
    I~

    \5lT~fi«ii <ITl:lJ ~
    ~

    Fff~ \5RBl <f>'1!


    ~7ffiJ

    ¥i'>lj>~
    <;flWl?!

    f.iprn
    ~

    iWG1 ~
    C"l~ I

    '7i":5fCstG1-\5IB

    \'5TI1 m~'f.Tf

    2i1F?d
    (~
    lTlVi

    'Z~

    ?f0<r> ~
    ~.

    ",'J1(?irn ~)

    "iI~I1fKi ~Wj "1 \5'<J~ ~1 ~~?ffi


    ~

    tJ/

    \'0"11'1

    'i'iii&f1 ~,

    4~Dib~

    ~{jm

    yPinished

    producer

    -t.. ~
    <1 C5Dl

    B!"lll5l'Bi

    R> \5[<f~<S1:q19

    C?/?f8f, ~G1

    .. ) <!l1Sfi73 ~

    ~~ I ~'G <fI\Sf1"<:J ?fi~ I ~!i.\!J<:i

    --

    ("i"lRi."'11 BPn1!

    IblM f<l\@\i.~ Bl<iW?

    '5lM ~? <!1"fi1 2i:0rn Ib'ei'l ~

    11i~'i

    <rD"l '1t'1 ~

    Un:'! Proof} 56 -, ~I,

    \.. ~

    ~i W;!
    ( _

    j\;,,- ~

    \!ii~

    <l~%<1 ')

    <'1"'i<1

    ~G-rn
    <.9~

    qi'Q)'j I ~

    ~,
    9j~ ~

    c!I~

    'I6M

    lfo'U ~, ~
    . ~.

    ~
    ~R:1<1 ~

    Flf
    <R:iii
    (,\5j

    Jjj~
    ~ ~

    ~----<.fl"M \5f!~fiDPi

    ~<1.f'i C\!51 <lG'TI ~! ~ ~~ <:f.C'IT ~

    <{i0j-Q!f1~T~ ~ I~

    \5if~q}i0
    ~~1

    c!I<m! l€i@l~

    ffi <r1 \5JIlIM ~_


    ~

    j¥'?
    ~

    ~m ~
    ')cv-~8-~ ~

    1Jj\&~
    <!>@

    V.J'id,1
    '15lf~9' (c!I"l_ c<J

    c<J,

    C"JG'fffi ~b ~
    1

    ,,;C'!.)

    QJl,

    c!I~

    2Jff3M;q-qi'

    ~(}Bl

    'Ti ~

    ~iC\Si'" i2if9f<;:, "m>:! '4Ji:r;!L'Vl~-1


    'S~ ~

    1:<1lxif(;@t

    \5Pr ct<1'C"ll"1fui
    ~
    'Smcs

    C'? 'W'i ~ GP'I ~


    <!.~

    ;n?
    c;<q>@ ~
    ~

    cfI"f.l

    -M'D

    <n~

    c<J <lC1 c!I"f.l

    "1,,"1'1

    C<l ~1i'Il

    W)
    9t~

    C'<[[<'lS <Q'Q- €l~

    9i'D!? <:n~"ll

    <.9~ ~

    111BWJ'flSl(?) ~

    4<;q(_'!.)~ ~ }1C'!.)i ~

    I~

    \!51 QlIt1'i~ c!I~

    : <Q~

    Zj~01<i!ti'1 ~

    ~~b"lJi'1
    ~

    \5liV'R,

    \5f1V'R ;n \ C'1f"l ~

    c;<q>@ c<JiM
    '5llPfi ~:
    '-S \5~'1~~

    ~
    '"

    I \5!f<i<;ft~

    \5l<l}i"i<l> I

    G0l<:J ~~

    ~
    1 t4l.oif<;

    ~
    I MIT ~~

    office of the

    'OII\?R ~ ~1iSi)<'11"l, ~

    ZC4-~
    ~ "fi~

    '~;

    ~,

    l\bP1
    2!~

    - A~ I

    _ 1

    Strategi~_S~'Vi~ <~SS)~~I<jJ'!.)"l ~ -Q1:lU 1\59i1G!'~C't>1 9niiif>1


    9j'("y~ ~(.~<j '5l]ll>i;H.>Ji'tl

    ~""Ul:

    <!l<T-_ ~

    1\5i::?.J1i6E'1

    *~ ~
    <.....-'

    f)1fo1<1'R
    ~

    ~tnR~-c:ri'l' ~l;fR ~ 0f.W ~j\;f1x


    I ~ ~~ ~

    ~-mt

    '5IP1 6fo/l~

    (lbf.i
    CIA-cil?f ('5R3i5

    C~<vt1:R", -&~4~i~

    <uf&<;'j\5 '{fui'\1 'Sf&

    l\0c.,.ilC1i'1

    M~N."1; :
    '?l~

    Rlf.1~t4

    D'lIWfV-'i" 1"'<11 <lC"1il I

    Rbf.i
    ";IC1

    ~-,.Q"'9f~R><-l

    ~n:r ~
    ~ MIT-CIA-~

    <lim<'! \5IJRl~

    9JN1 OM 'Ti ~1<1'!.)~

    ~'TIl
    '5l'<tl)

    <il?l9f'?l 'S~

    C2_, iI\, 1

    PmRi\'!.)

    \5l'<Pf! ~

    >i'"lliSi'b~~

    Rlf.1-

    ~f.q

    F1f.i ~
    <Q~Q)'j

    '~I'!.)lG'!.)i'1 "i*ll ~'J -C\5t<i 0, ~~ 15t!('.i'F1',bt ?ll~-D'l 15t'<Pf! 05l:%fuFr


    '>1~?l c!I ~ JfJ~-'<3~
    9j~

    "l1<irM]1?l!<1''!.)ffi
    ~

    <1''1'9'4 ~~, lm'Wf! ~


    (,\5j

    "itt'5! ~ ~ ~ Rro"% @31<j'!.)C~1


    03i ~'3W
    'JfJ'VJ:<l i '>11ffi'{3~ ~

    ~
    6f<;j~- ~

    c!I~ c!I~

    ~ ~H ~,
    <1ZPi ~,

    C?f1t"i"l--1t

    "lJPi~~(;>j ~<>jffif(;\SG ~~{;'N,i1

    t<i1Rit

    '7

    (~I"'1

    '11 ~
    4Q)'j

    :",.::z 'K~'<i~i'l~)j~~~G11 ~~"'i)@ ~, \5)~ 'W3, CWI'<l1 c~~


    4<1.f'i1' " ~.

    ~
    ~~'Smo:S

    ~9ft

    ''§j;:::b /

    c7')_.,

    i7fGi ~

    ZfJ! BT%?;"3 ~'¥ ~,_. ~


    ~ G5l~

    <rn-~ <t-1@: Ql'ijy "l'I?


    o.Qll9j~ ~ 'CIA-MIT

    '5i1t~!
    (Wi
    ~

    -2!r<l11SMt I

    ~-"fi9fj~

    c<rf'4 '»~ffi
    ~l:jJ

    <nt; "PL; I
    'i'i,

    @{l'

    'Yf<l" ~ q;@ fqQ Rf.'l i1:q'I"1


    7l1P1C"11$

    ~ ~) s1~~
    ~~ ~

    Pi. ~.
    ~

    c!I_-C%!"i"l-c:r"l.

    m.-QJ'ii§

    <m1t:

    c<J1"?n~~

    '}j~Vm5I$1' c!I~

    ~t"<:i-~GlSI~
    ~

    ~~ilJ1
    <:fG1-~?
    ~'S ~ ~

    0M 1 ~

    <1G"!C'!.)~ 9j"f@r1,

    fi1vi ~ ~ ~ '5If\6v:m'?j~ ~fqC'!.) <mf~~'1 ~ ~

    :
    C~9f

    f'if8[ '~~'
    'l:lMJ

    I c;<q>@ l'fGl'Rlil

    '<-.IG1'-~1
    c!I'"M

    '~' 1_~

    m
    <f6'r

    ~ ?lh1«
    ~~

    \5ff~"f

    '11, <W1~
    r-»; ,.... ~

    ~ ~ ~

    031 ~1:<!'

    r>
    ,~

    CWlqjl$ ~~ o.Q<rZ c!l1$ ~~


    "i'0}j<'{f ~

    I ~'1_ iM ~'"5ff

    ; c<R ~
    , ~ ~

    c!I<.f1'V{? MIT-ClA C6f1~4G'!1VJ

    <Ii ~

    C4<l? 'O!'<R1, \51"11 "l« 1'4 ~"fT1iZ_ 9fj~[>j[<q>~~ 9j3l?l1V!~~m? 4WHs{;(Yf~ ~ ~ D~I~' ~ cfI~ 1iC:>t ~ c!lG'1 cfI~ 1~C~ I '3B! ~

    '5R'<l1 ~
    (/!<.f1'V{?

    @ ~~1l1f -n!)"Pbl<'l
    M<j;:j<i' ~ <ilm~ll

    ' Tlfr ~
    '5l~><j <il~

    '-T;Pl

    Pi. ~.
    ~

    m'11 ~

    9fl'C<1<lII31~ ~ 1:&1R-l~ 21'4i4 ~ c<J PI. \5JI~. o.Q-"i'J' 7cQrr:p·j<lJ"1e"i

    <n'G"?
    o.Q~ cQ?l ~l:jJ

    c!I-{?{?'i17?:1

    1<!1'C"1; C~ffWPl 9'<l1 ~,


    c!I~ '<11<>liii1~ ~-tlrn'b

    -'

    C<1>tAT '<I1~'i7fI ~! (l<i~)7P'f


    c!I'l'5 cQ\5"'41'F!

    15R9f'll'1 01'-1 c!I~, 2lF6~tC:"li'1 C~ ~

    \~)-lfu4

    <m~'

    '5f@! '<I1\0i 'T'~ <i~ I c<l ~,


    '<:3<;<"':j ~

    <'pQj) ~

    91lS1<1'C>1'1 '-G'Yf<l"

    \5lf~q
    ~R"1}1
    ~
    '~

    (1''10191\5'i11 \5JI':>IT'19fQ (.::zoo:;,)

    ~
    Jjj~'-f1~

    1'''141'!.)1~ ~

    zm'r"?1 9f%11l,
    ~ 1Bf1~
    ~l5j<il~

    ~\'5)'?l ~

    ~GG"!
    bl!t'>'1'G'j ~

    i-h"l ~
    ~m

    DWr ~
    C1~
    4@ ~

    G'Sm
    3t''GG1i~ 'Exactly reaction

    <iD1,R>Pi ~
    ~ ~C:'!.)rl, ~ ~

    "1C:G1~CG"!rl c!I<n~
    ~

    ~'1~
    l"qj

    lSI'ij->~ I D"l1% ~

    o.Q'T <Q~ (~<i1'f) \5f!"'1f.1 ~ ~oO»)

    \'Jll'>fiJf

    '1CG1WtC"1<-l ') D'lt<\l"1Ji.11 '>

    1~?3[I ~~ 'SVi,

    '\5jj9fR ~
    ~<ftq

    sm~~!l';f, ~
    ~ 'OII~ ~ ~ C'i)'N_, ~

    o.Q~

    :r;T~n5Imr

    0W'iii <n't21l1i<T

    'T'11.'!.)"l?' Bush.

    ;n

    ~i1'R
    C1():!)

    {-<jC"1<iM I '3105 ~ <lCiZ

    <mJ 'Ti, \5fi~

    iJt.C<1'C.b<i ~
    \5JI~

    "!l~>(C"11

    ~(( 9fR51 c.'<ll:4 ('1 ~, the same thing as president

    ts'4m5l \SIB?) ~ It is an would

    (~~CL'fi'l?) "l~ ~,

    iSiG"!Zf'Gm-<:! <:31-m <r4C'il' 9t~~ \5f<l'<lJ "iV1

    !'z<1f.'; I
    B)m\'OII'm'(m.1

    ~j'l:1,

    George

    G1'Vn
    2!~<'''1<1

    <n1-lf.i,

    '5f'TJ ~
    ~

    institutioal

    and I had been the President,

    the reaction

    ~RG11

    \'5l1~1C"l~

    C<lcrC'!.) ~~

    I c<J ~

    €l~-m c!lV1

    have been the same.'

    <!l"1. '5fl~.

    fG'

    "Ii ~<f.

    :Ql%0IT:<'M<!ii'01"'1'<P (9fq;,.",";j C~ (.<!G~ 9jlC~",

    t!~
    ~ ;::n 9
    \!:Ij~~

    C?fG!\3 "l:&"4.-{i ;::n~


    2j~~1('<-i1

    ~, ~ ~

    c<T"ifil "'\<P1C:\')]>1 ~ ~, ~ Di"',fiI'i'<3

    C<i'~rHC:<i"-" I C<dl~L"l'0 ~ (?it\'?


    (.0(."1"1

    <T"<fi'l Against Method <i'Z(}{I'"1 }j\§I<I"1111 (~:~

    '<i19C~ ""li~,
    2j"{!<l

    'f.i~\S1~' <rll;f ~
    CSiNri

    ZGl ~

    "'lJr&5'i'<3iC9 R> \5fl?i ItR>C~


    <jj~G'l1 ~~

    m~

    <rm

    ~~

    "l9
    <f!'i1ft) ~ ~

    ~~
    ~

    (Pluralistic
    <.fl~ c<! (<!l~

    Methodology) 'fi Gna,<:H'ill 1V'f) ""li~O'jf


    ~

    <rf~

    Y,Vlf

    ~9]'Vf~
    <TIl ~~ ~
    ~_

    \5.f!~i<P "lT1V{
    ,"'II"",.SU<{

    <!l 01~~'1':z c<r(~ 71KDl'l0i ~

    :lf5i'<J@, 2i"!;->i·.l?r..1"!)
    ~

    Nei'I~~~~1 ~~~
    ~
    .5>

    <1'11;: <"""<i<T'e~ ~

    ~\B1(:"S~ iKl6\1mm 9
    mT.~
    I <Q~ ~r0:f'1 '6!'iJ<R~ GiT9]';fI"J
    ~ ~

    'Bf1~1T1 q'@\3 Zl,,!;· C\5!(.G'1'i ~,

    "5!1<>Rm ~ji3!Z'1S<>
    <!l~

    '51<m:r

    "tii9J"R-\;i'.\')@ ~ ~
    ,-,

    ;r.<f1':z?' 1)"41%. "'i<i~'~ ~ \5fi~'i1"?l 2]~t-r

    ffi?l1ll
    '~?i~
    ,G.,......

    Jffu:n
    (]J

    <PI? 9:(, ~

    ,=,-'-'

    051

    CBfi"1 ~ "'i11 ~

    "J..!",I<i I '51:>iC"""l,

    ~"1

    .'-

    <!l~,
    ~

    <!i\.').<]i:5 ~~

    l>iN'i ~
    (~

    ~?i @,'8(.<1i'1
    'l.~ ~)

    '1[('$ ~
    2]~j'0"i1

    <!l"4i ~, ~ ~

    f.TI.~C:'li>'i

    "WIT<i13 ~,
    ....i'11fGi'1

    <fl'<J1 <i(."l<"l
    =

    mi$r~I~ R<\~<>
    <>"Ii 9f!O~"i,
    ~

    0'l<f1 9f\G@, ~
    (>j

    \5l111'R ~

    >i151"l"'iW1 9'<ii-fl-~ ~ ~0..-j~i"'1


    ~ ("0

    8M "R Jfi"jj11"Bf<;f'~mi3t
    I \5fjQ'R
    <!i"l1'3
    .

    IF! rj\!l$
    ~~

    0'f'<3"?ffi1 P'i) <>?llm'<3

    <TIl \511

    '<3""11 <.fl~ ~

    ~,<q\')1
    r-»;

    <.£1\5 ~

    ®
    ~

    0)1$i(.a,1 <fii0'J. "4'51<'M~ ~'if?!


    '11'><]'<3~'<:j ~ ~ ~

    {with zero h istory) <!l<> ~


    .

    Ft.

    \5:119f<m!

    B't<fjD~F't

    9T'1"f ZGi qlR>(.#~a,!

    r.'1<f ~
    ~vnTI
    ~-

    'l'il1<"l\')(:~ 'fI8r(<"l1\')~~10 <l(''''~t, '(.<j(':(,,£

    l11'14C.q>

    ?i'1~ ~"'iI1
    '"",

    21'Vm1 '-"~"il

    W~
    Jf51 \:?1t§\.\5
    ,2j~

    I ~"?l ~
    ~

    <!1"Z
    "5fVl'f ~

    om ~
    i c<Tl~\')'l
    ~

    m<1 ~

    ~ 'fi"1~- ~

    ~ ~~

    I \5T?l9f?f

    ~ ~

    ~ ~

    fl

    C4\T.'11 Jff"4'Rffl"f,

    ('nothing general to say'),

    -:($Jf.i

    ViL~,¥ <!l ~ <Q<:j "R<1}

    <>Q[i fl ~
    i.",PK~ ~ ~

    "'ill'

    ,£G1<il <f.c:~G_I.G1'-{ ~

    ~ c\')f4l ~ I~

    '¢l~\')

    q"r6'll?i ~
    T9!l<I].G"1

    <!lz \5!"1~, "\Bfl~

    ~H\9~~I \4'\:3
    c<1<i <siT ~

    "11'"<1<1 If-l

    RzC:q<i <.fl"4'i'f1~

    ~<1i:Z-ZlRAJ1(."1?l ~"?i
    '<j@ ~

    mrffiift

    I ~'B9f?f <:f1VKa,"1

    0'1 <11··1'11'"'1
    \5!"1L~1 ~·I

    M'li/''''

    <TI '"41'1(,<11

    B'1:(..-r"t!r;(\')
    '>iV'1~. '5fl'<:)' ~'i)i~\')I!

    ~rfu.
    '¢l",\')

    ".I?l ~
    :

    <l\!? ~

    <siT

    <nro~""li
    0l~,

    ~'ifrn

    i5T1~

    ·~.J~'qk; ?l'IV;i~

    (triviality)

    <j>@? ~

    "jj<i

    f<l; <£1"1"\ <l>Th1 ~ l~:r'1Z ~.:Q~I"ffi


    \5~

    ~
    ~,

    \5!100?
    ~

    ~
    <!ii~

    *!:iJ"Ji, f.l@,(.~if(;9
    ~?i ~"i

    @9]~

    051 "fI'i) <{\)lJ), ~


    <r19J1iS1"1<'!m

    c::BI <!llf-l ~Df ~-~ <>'<11 <l\F1 D"1l%'<3

    \5fI?r <i'\') ~
    F4\')I~

    '<!i1:l>?
    <i'41I,!)i'.~

    As

    'i1~'fi~

    <n~'"4 I\bPirn"1i5 <!l~ 1'41 '"'5.Uj~d~M>i'.>{;<'.l ~ <!l"<'ffl (!) ,...._ .~. A ~ _~~ (?l'0<ff?l) 2i I\')V ~ 'Offii"l'3J 0'fl.'"<lcoq><i ~kq 1'( Cfj"l091 ~ ""I $l1·"Pt-I'" 11-;.,,,rn ~ G51 <.fl~ '\5n"l11' i JflTh<Jf ~ ~ 1'o/\')ii'1 01<1;""0'<11:'1 ~?i <!1<rG1 ~¥{j'1c:{ R~~

    om-m1
    Jfz<l\5 ~ ~

    M('~ ~
    ~"1
    ~,

    qm
    0

    <TI .fi~c<Br ~'<Tf'l ~ri~I~?

    <!l'"l:i'1 6l1'1J9!i C'<;(9Z

    '51"1('~~
    \')'{j<fi'''Pffi? <Q'"l:i'1 ii'l~~ \5lro"'i<:jl~ <!l""!G".z
    _. _"=

    @'cbffi:", <li~O'fj ~ WJ9-~"'i [':;(.<.J As <lJr&N<fTI!


    :Q'>!)'W

    n
    ~ I "11~

    ~!iGt-:{ ~

    11 ~
    "'i1 <1("11.

    ./

    W-/

    (""It\'?

    «:n<18:t"'~ i ~ R>

    1"1~ \5i<.fllJ
    9fD? <n?
    ~

    '5l<1Jj'-"l<ll >i1<i'i<'1 I~
    1-31<{q'I"1

    1""1<1 ~

    <>!!Ji

    <1<;102:(."1"1 : \5'R\~

    ~1""1'TIS4 ~ 'Ti Ji"lTl"i3!"-"'1l~

    c<1

    m~

    ~
    -.orr-1J17l
    Vlji1,?IT.'i1

    \5T?l

    t::<1lIT.'i1 Q1"'i ~"?l Em~ ~

    C<i'<Wl ·~!i"'"l11riJt1'\')

    «'f("il

    "jjzr~rn-<iJR '11~
    r.

    <n~B; <nt<i

    MH

    1(1)'1, '5Pl" 1\S1-i~

    ""i",,¥N G'fi."<i ~

    0r:G

    fQl\2

    ><f'i"5l1lf.T! 15IG1~!l ~
    ,..._, r-~

    C:iJiD,?iVTI

    bie , \5j~
    cQ~

    BM f<f;

    <:jl~~ <rrFl"l ;::n? ",,1."''1 ;n 0


    ~i7iC:<,j

    \51

    "i$[

    K@I{+il Ir1.{C\4i? 'B[,0 ""I~d~"1\5


    ~ ~
    r-»:

    ~1 ~
    -14-'1)1! Jj\5l1<j@ C<1I'1<i ""l-<al~-~ .:Q"!t ~e"1,

    iSM1f.iC~ <P\')<i'~i'Pi1 ~~C:"llilit9t'Jj


    ">J\!J<iJ

    1:51~

    D"iiR: \NR1"1, '<511 ~

    '>'1'41r~ WiB

    <m~
    (]J 0@,

    I 'i1~'11-';hf\b

    m <!l"jj,
    ~

    <mIVii
    ~

    'tij'\[3i'.?l ~fGC?l 0'f'<3TIi

    'btICSi.1

    0'Pl<I ~ "1R~

    '¥(a,

    ~lf1'1 ~

    ib~
    ~

    )"'"2>81...~ ~
    m~
    ~ qU, 0l~

    ~"'lJ)1:'1

    <Ffifly

    Gfll~3FIR~ :£j-9~-11

    NC~i\Si<1<lrm ~-

    ~,

    -: ~J.:. ttI~

    1'5_

    (X5

    "1TQ,~ Xfl''l'l"!l "i1 i


    ~

    ~'0:'l

    C1"i
    ~ "f'<l~

    ~ i<lDI"'\')
    9'~

    <Jl<:i: ~(\')I ~IGl1\')'i


    <K"1(.'!Z<i

    ?BI ~'1i
    c' L

    t>lfo1e~ <rt1i I
    ~

    (reducricnist) "'&i'."i

    ;:q@~
    ?j3j,_~j

    2i'cl'TI C1TII <M~_

    \5ff'I<l ~

    ~D1

    C'1"'i<it, 1<l@iC"1<:j '1"1"'1 '<3 \5'~::'i'<IM'6


    \5{~-"lf.'{~

    <>'<11;:;-j C~t<'l, <lIZc.<l"l "J1S!Ii3! ~

    ?fl~i~<i'$
    C~i'.<l ~
    <Q~

    ~?ll;il$i I '5lL<i9

    ~';-i!'>'1'41G

    '51:"i1I"?l ~

    C~"[<f. i}f<i\F'i; \1:.JJFTi<"1R>v'3~@"'f0"3' <P'<l'~ \5lJH<{R>)G<{[ ~~

    cQ~

    \5f'N! ~
    ~

    '<JCG

    M i7W1
    ~.

    -<000

    =: <.fli * ~ r_..pI
    ...
    ~

    R>\?J ~
    <lt~

    ~ ~i

    ~ ~"Jl

    -;::;1'>1i'1, <Q<>5f"lT%?

    "M 0K.rr9]~1
    <f.Qjf

    \5ii~"lt:<P"'5:f4

    f.t@

    ""l~~'>1\3

    ~-;n f-iGJ

    fi\0i'i<l1111C.'1<; 5ii.~

    ~G1lblF1

    "f~)

    ;::n"'jj

    m : Psi

    (\5f1'f\') ~ ~
    @'>li"fR

    ('fi

    Psycho-social
    \~::/i5jL\')~ \5fi-.n~

    ~9f111l'l)
    ~'G1Fjl'1

    m ~,

    "1~

    ~ ~'<:>,

    )"'tr8f~

    [t;iJc\') ~~

    ~~<1Il)'q>

    (;\81 OM I 1""5r-1 ~

    "1<1' \Sfrn'>!M TG'I~,

    ... for

    ~,

    almost 40 years now I've been writing about how 'empty organism' malJeabilty absurdity." \.5!'<J<l1
    )",,,,8

    and

    Theories
    \5l<lI\!)'G""~ C~ ~

    of human nature have served for coercive to intellectuals,


    <Q~

    purposes,
    ~?

    '+'
    ~

    Discourse 1 ~
    {<Vo'j ~

    :>lHc"1'i ""l1
    <[(Fj"

    '1P'fl'111 '5{[-.rm ~
    "normal C1l17JTI, ~
    <1'~ qr~
    "(l~

    ()~
    science"
    <!1z ~

    ~-rn,
    ~
    ~

    )"'M-<.Q<[

    V'i'''1{'C1<i, ~

    -~

    ~'8,

    "'1<%1 <iN "leads to error as this one constantly has, then drop.
    C1C1t ~ C"'lT8
    ~ ~"11 ~~ I

    it."

    ;:rj; l5l'i"fI""1"

    and why they are so attractive


    ~ ~IS ~

    despite
    <1'Q.~

    the manifest

    f1-::J"!l ~

    y01$l ~
    ~

    H:;.qs( ~

    '>fiB ;n ~~~

    ~ 2jQj:Sl ~

    ""l1 n
    ~ .....

    r?1'i101 "J'lZ'lD<jI?l
    :';_I!J ~,

    rF ~

    '5I<D"!l(.'G1 ''''~~~C\!)

    1t><-lrn"l~

    <i>'<J1 '1(o<7i{'~<-l fit> function designed production


    >j';7C-i<"1~ ~ ~, ~

    «l'jQ.tj\S?

    ~f';

    m~~
    1!:ifJ~,

    ~"'~'0<l>(3jC"!'8m
    C<J \5'G
    m,.j\5C'G<"1 ~~ "'l§<i~'14tGi ~)

    <11 '1.nrt <i"1(.C1'S ~

    yQ~l-<rOll
    ~

    <~\j' ~
    ~ ~ \"5ffi

    ;:rj, ~Q)<rt

    \5f?:¢

    l:1G1iG<1M

    <i'@
    1

    'S ~ 1S<>81(oil~

    cR~)
    ~

    '5{['PT ~
    1 \5ffi'!

    •
    ~

    <f.?:m ;rn-, \5fi"fl'ClBi:*

    '3Q)j~Z~~

    " ...You are quite right about crippling of 'education' a technique


    N<j~ll '@~ ~ ~Fs1f<l1931"1 ~ ~
    <Q~

    creativity.

    In fact, much of the was, after all, tools of of that."


    I D"li1J;

    2lQj:Sl ~

    is to do just that. Mass education to mold


    ~ JJ"lI'8l\')7J

    H~1 <l>(3j,
    <mJ"i ~ \5!1q3ffl ~~
    ~03'S ",1(.1'1

    ~-\5!;pll-m
    ~ ~ ~

    <rH'J"!lC'G-::J f.'rn'3 ~ ~~

    \5!Tl1rn \'l~

    independent

    farmers

    to docile
    ~ ~~

    ~~I'&@i<W1~m~<Q~<11~~'S~~ ~ "!l~

    and was bittertly revisted by many in full awareness


    Q!Lrl 1<10)'",,"1 D"lf{;i;! ~ IS <'l1iQ<f1N>1 "1<'!>W ~

    ~,
    (~

    '<iOlt ~

    'J'[<[

    <Pl~

    Co'l'Z~
    ~f.i ~H
    ~IS

    '?~~ ~
    1<1 L"1'1 ,

    m~
    <ffi! ~
    C~

    ~, ~if"'~1

    9'1\')1:"1) ~
    <iC"1kCfrH
    1

    'com-

    ~.f.
    eGG'
    ~ ~ ~"<'j

    '5!1-.n"V'f1: ~@3"!lR1l

    ~ "J'lZ"1"<J~ ~ "lTIX5, ~€f ~ <'l1"N ~ 0l?j~9f1f.1 fiID"J 1 <Jf.l1S ft"R ~


    <i'Q.tj

    putation' \5l1<>l<1B!i
    !!_?l!.\')! <!1~

    "'1'<lfW~"1:

    ~I
    ~
    ~W

    ~
    ~

    ~,

    '3lQ]F! ~
    ~IQ1\')h'l \':>i<l[\5t$

    ~~ 'J'f1~

    ~ ~I;j, Of] <;i <\\')1 ?f1G1"l 1l¥<l,


    I~

    m ~m,
    l{'\ij(.'{I-::J ~9¢{'~U

    eml ,!(.<!>[1 ~

    \51Tf;n"Wi0fi-<11('~19M\t~-<.£l<:r
    ~

    <:~

    CqC<7iV'..(<1 15~ Jj"1\')<l~(3j <Q~ ~ '1"ZC<7iC\51 '@~

    \!ifi?il"!l"!l

    <Q~

    M>'@
    ~'iCl{\I1'i

    ("It§: <Qq;;r\s---<!1~ ~

    "<iR W ~

    cs»

    N"1.Sl

    C<1>11:'i1~

    ":Bl-f.:'l
    ~'1,

    Nj<j"!lL'G I ~ ~""1" '11<ll""1" ~

    <l>11i: C~
    ~,

    ~
    ~

    <>t'r8r 0R:1 on i ~
    <!1<11""1" <:rCj'ft~

    (;<1 '5!plf'T'G

    -mfB1··dC1

    \5!Tl11<:r ~""1" !Z8l ~


    <Q~ ~

    <Q<f.T1SI \51\5<Q<r,

    ~1~r"1, ~ ~

    <1''<l1~

    \5!1~"i

    <!1<11""1" ~,

    ,(£§'C<\$\,:>!

    Nrn ~
    (?) <Q~ ~
    \5<[

    ~
    ~

    ~~
    tTk<11GG I

    ~
    (G1qj ~

    ')L_.
    ~
    \'l<f.T ~ ~<1u'(i<j ~ <;fC"<:[<j"~
    ~ ~'<{i,

    .~

    ~w

    ~I ~?

    '?~# ~
    ~
    <{i~

    ~'

    \5i8 ~-<rf

    m ~~~ ~

    D%:"i

    <ff0

    4l1>WJ'b
    I~

    <l>(3j ~~

    <l'<R

    "'0g-~

    \'5Qj"j '1'1g-'@~?f.;l~.
    '<J@

    P)
    \5!1~m

    R\5I~
    <Q~ ~

    \5i8 <Q~

    C9fC\?~04I~ I 171 <rri"'lm l{1"'1<ll1(;'F! ~

    81"'f 6ijlfSl~<p

    <1:J1~1Iw -G'P't :ZG! 'Gt~~<n<l1


    ~"fI';Q ~<jJ

    -sr'lm I
    00
    81 ~

    c<M W1'HllJj04, GffilG"i <!>-::J%<O'jI~:;.. 1%11 <il¢j~'G ~ (


    oR'fI(X5

    IS~ \':>~L'" . \':>It<1~ ~ '5flf.f:ST<l" '<JG"1 \'5l1"SlBI .I\..~ ~ ~ 1\? "!llfu<1'0l'!'1 ~!lf 9~ ~ "l1'! '<lJ1'1 ~
    ~ <Q~

    I <!1 \5ftiTI~

    <fI?l ~-~

    <T1~

    ~~I

    B~
    ~
    ~

    q;~ <1"1&"'1

    \5[1""1" ~<fR,

    158! ~

    ~'i
    "lH1~i.<1~ I ~Irl

    M!.~ \5[1~
    ~""f

    m,~
    C'R3[

    f'>lm

    «1:>-;:r<i

    rn

    m.1 ~'FTI-~t\
    ~
    ~

    ..!l<rZ \5!\5g<>l"<1

    ~
    '!If!

    ~
    01'<.(1

    ..!l "1<1> U"fIf41,


    ~ ~

    ''SID

    P1"
    1

    ~-<Q~

    Western

    \5!19ffu 811r.;C~~G'"j~I ~
    "fI"Vl ~

    Economists and Western Societies ()"'tr~) University


    9Q)1 ~

    Zl4>l"l'<{iThe Johns Hopkins : C\'lI


    ('i5]'11""1"

    "1:'HlfbRH
    ~
    l'1M'rI,

    <f.l<fo!t'"100

    c<fG'fI :

    Press 1 ~

    D2?7l ~ "1'1\'l81 ~

    <!>-::JC"1~,"~

    OM fiID"J
    .znG,zill-11S

    "'f'Ffl~ C9j~\';)

    f.j\~-::J ~

    <!1~

    i Dl.1I¥-::J oil?!. '5fm<'[~

    ~m

    'Jj"]~

    '3"0 : ~>

    "1,1"1 "1?!. ~

    '11"1: 00

    ~]

    o::rR M04j~ : Algocentric

    '5!f~"i

    \5li"i ~!iil->1 2ir:!)0I'i ~1l

    C9j~"1'";j-fiwt-lS~

    ~-c<J'Il5

    ZYI\;(''0~k<i?1

    Ji~Vl1"i-~
    <JIB 1 ~

    m
    ~ ~ <!>'"%l ~

    0T 0T q.:qr I.!l~ ~
    \5f1"fi~

    \5f1~ ~ ~

    '3l~ "'91tl~ 03l"lffi 'Gfl"TI ~

    -n

    031"ffi! ~

    :,'jfG"0rt-@ ~
    ~

    0i<J

    ~81
    ~

    ~mrn <ri

    ?!fm~
    ~ G!T~ ~~

    ~
    y\!)]

    "i~

    ~ ~ ~

    f<rr;mij!
    'IT%e;Wftli
    ~

    \51"'1~-c'l~ I
    ~ 'ip"1\!)n

    R>f.l

    i5l19f1\')'1fP;(,\!)
    1 ~ ~~,

    '5lt9j1'\5

    ~~.

    ;:n

    ~'13

    >j.{<fl<.]J[Qj') ~?M:
    ~

    <JI~

    <ri ~ <.!1£,Lll

    \5'Pfm '"r1C1t"1'

    1 I.!l~ "IT:<iJ C~

    CG1 \'5.l1~-~ mTPi


    ~·I

    ~<1C'j ~,
    ~

    f.lct~
    '5lt>'l'lTR~

    <ffi9fl<.!, ~
    <fiQf[ "<ltG'! ~ '1i:>iDIDI(1l 05V!

    i7WI :
    (1979,

    tual and the state)

    I ("f1'~;::1l~

    0'@ I'5PP'iJ 9fl\5f) I


    <Q~

    F-lm ~

    1W1

    (~%<il Intellec~1"lF"1\!)I$l<fi t<J'''1('.!l Gl'0'R 1 ..... ~~

    ~
    ISIfilv1
    ~l\!)

    C5ti <l@, ~
    -''5ltm<.)-0300~'

    39-43

    \51~ C~ <'P'<Jl C~

    1l'<l1t1 <.!1';fol "f'@ <1'~V1v1 <ill i5l1"1~ ~-cm;rr ~ l5{'f1 <iI! ~ '13 C<Wl ~ ~'Gl f.ki51~'<J\iT C~ ~ <!i~?
    Q1<! <iI ~ ~m
    ~<f\5
    1

    ZTI G!TC5f <M1 '<li"1'G'ffi)m ~'<fi I ~

    \5f1:«.j1 <.]I(.~, <J"<[.1

    @I Ji1v:M ~

    -("}{ <l>~M ~
    "1(~ C"1~ I 031~

    ~if

    c~\!)(.,.

    ct;<::lfMG
    ~

    l5li<=r~9
    Rl{[R\!) ~

    9@

    C"I'<! ~

    i!R11'5!f~
    ~!M>n:.5II("1I"1Cv1i1

    'ij'G'frn

    'GQ 1'51'M111~ "Di :


    ~!

    fiillR

    ,Q~(kj'1

    C~\!)<.j (Q![<f. lIm ~ \!)'{?<p~

    (~ tran-

    ""'N<jJ~
    '1j\bj~ ~
    ~?

    I.!l~~

    2l~, '13~ 0 ~ ~4iR ~

    <fi'<Jl

    fik:?J

    C"t<i ~

    : through

    scendental
    Jj<l

    ego <ri
    ~I

    WF
    -~

    <1("fu
    9'3m 9'3\1Bl

    m~
    ~

    ~~-c'l~

    ~~

    ~~-

    "it was life more than the low that became the issue of

    \':'i1<'!~?J Vf"1~

    :ffif?;~

    ~
    q;qr "l''<Ji
    Jj<l

    political struggles, affirmations beyond

    even if the latter were formulated

    <f}Qf[ ~

    'Ti?
    C?!OO'13

    9f'I@, ("l~»
    ~

    <Q~

    0T 0071 0091 <l>'<Ji wm '!fil?


    ~ '13 ~V! ~31C.\!)f ~

    (~» ~
    <Q<Wr

    ~. ~
    '1<f1~ ~
    '9j'><1"J®' 1 Q1

    concerning

    rights. TIle 'right' to life, the one's or 'alienations', the 'right'to re-

    body, to health to happiness, to the satisfaction of.needs, and all the oppressions discover what one is and all that one can be, this 'right-which the classical juridical system was utterly incapable of comprehending was the political response light of soverignity"
    v1';lv1 "I 11C-';-1 01 $I 1'l~

    '<PI
    ~

    f.'mm
    I ~

    (~(\ij)

    <ri ~-9'3~
    '111 ~

    ...~
    ~

    'Gfl"R <it, ~
    ~

    0fe1T1 ~
    '~' 1

    C"ii~VN

    <Q~

    "~'G'l1q
    i5l19ff.t
    C~

    '5ltR! ~
    9fq-~~I,

    .iX51 '<iJif1' ~
    ~
    <)iqj

    ~
    1 i5l19j'<n~

    r'31
    "l<Gm

    ~/

    '5ff9fR

    rnrm

    C'MilC~<'!

    to all these new proce-

    dures of power which did not drive, either, from traditional (History of sexuality, -SQJS:I ~ ~
    1

    f.:jC?l I'5rilpl1Fn"i{;Qj c<l \51~<Q>R6<l1 Gi8M\!)

    \5T~S-c'l~ w'<i1 ~
    ~

    I3TC\!i \5f1ii1

    c>R
    <1:.~. \!)'l'13

    9j~~

    ~m
    f1,~C\!)~

    "*' :
    <P@'

    ':>8<i ~)
    (/j

    0T

    ~9ji!

    9f1i3l~ 'ffin'l; \5f1~', C":1l1(.>1 "1

    \!JR! I'5!1'Si 'YffZ1 f1,~, q;~

    ~Ti!;i ~$lKll

    ","<[.1'13 l't)~:L~

    9f1fu on 1

    C<J ~

    ~'I3m-fumf<l\!)I?9'

    ~
    ~

    "IT:<iJ ~ ~ ~ GLOCAL!

    -n <fiM<r.'Gi '1!3f f.Wr


    1

    ~5f

    co::rn-<.'l~
    qlG1]~ ~?

    \3t~
    cQ~~

    C~{'i3i"1r.;i1 'fl9j1)

    <fl"1'.!li1:![i'll ~~

    <mI, I'5!@! <Pm


    I'5!M 1Ffl~

    "':1f.i C"<.iG1Uz'l iX51! ~

    filCG1iSf(.¢j

    '1Jt"l1%l ~
    i'f"'9fl11oTI
    <i>@

    c.W1 ~
    ~

    ~
    ~v1J

    ~1'l1 <t>@ c9fTl:<J? 2l~Tll ~


    Q1 <f}'<Jl~01l~ I

    : <fl~ 2i~ c<!"i '~1:'f<.j'(?) ~ ~MC4l1(--1 <fl~ cQ<Wr ~ MI.?J~'1jj


    1'5f!~ GI'1
    <t>@
    1

    ~<.]~UI
    I

    '~FnQ)q>
    !i3J I<li:.'!:JI~
    ~, ~ ~R"1I-~'9 MC"1 \5Gi
    \'5["'I~ 9-~

    <l1 <fl<1'<.]'1"'1
    j;;'.!l"il 8J"i

    ~-~"'[<1>

    fiW:5

    ~t~~-rh:'f
    9j~

    'Gfl~
    ~

    : ~'13 ~

    fiW:5
    ~1Ji
    ~

    ZTI mTI<i\581
    Q1 9fl

    f%<:mm

    1'5!9j!'l(/?'13 (/j 15)";f


    <i>@

    cl~ 1'5!~ ~ ~

    ~ ~(C'jffi et<iJ~ ~ ~

    <N-<lS'<Jl 1Jf&<ij13
    ~

    ~"'l'ifG

    (~

    ';lCG1 n81

    fiiGffi:

    w~
    I

    '1Gl

    c-:r.:r----<!l<f~ <fl~B

    'f"frn,
    ~

    (/j

    \5f~
    "fl91tr

    fi1c?J I
    ZGJ ~

    <.!1~ f<lT.<.!Tfi.i\!)](1l

    m.. ;:n

    2l\2J'8'!1 Mf.~~GC1'l ~,

    \3t
    ~

    ..Q~

    "'If.W<J-a

    ~ 'TI<TR

    ('1€\1Bl

    fG(1l '1l<l'1
    ~ ~

    'r'1~-~~'<!9
    cQ~ ~

    C~
    ~<f,

    Ji,~<;ffl
    ~~

    '61I1J",T?] ~

    <.!1V'i

    0i"l'i ~"'Il

    foic\!)- ,

    W:fMTIr 1'5!?'11 ~

    fiiGl:>i I ~

    'HI ~~011
    ~<t

    <.!1~ '5T<m'VT<f

    on ~

    KASS~CHU$~S

    INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY

    :!OD-219 Department of Linguistics and Philosophy C~mbridge, Massachu$et~s 02139

    200-419 De-partment. .of t..-inquiatics and Philoooph'y Cambrid9~j M~~6a~huae~t6 02139


    De-ar Mr. Bandy opaclhy ay ,

    Jun@

    23, 1994

    Dear P~of. Sandyopadhy8y, The queac Lcna you raise ar-e i.nt.er,est.lng, and merit a mot'"e considered response than I Can pq~aibly give h~r~~ qiven Cu~rent pressu~e6. Henc~ only B te~ WO~d8, r'm afraid.
    that. there, is anythin~ general to say; it depends en th~' cone e.re Lrrte , end t.he cepec Lcy of the pere.on't·o resist t.hem. JIo.5' for the <cacxeoem boya , t.hey are the people who are ma.king no effort; to resistj rathe:t:"., tl"1I?Y a.~-e the- conants aaz-s, the onee ..... chose to no conform r to ser-ve power, wh.a.tellei t.ne consequences. In brief, the normeL z un of intel~_ectuals·r· 1& doubt.

    I thlnk you 2.L-e -quLce right about CI:"ippling c r-eat.Lv Lt.y , In fact, much of the .funct.ion of "education" is to do just. t'hat~ Mass eouce tLon was, a eue.r all, designed as a t ectmf que to !::\Old Lnnependent; fat'"i'ners t o docile t.cc r e of pr-oduct.Lon _- and was bitterly resi9ted by. ~,any in full awareness of that.
    As for a ne .....type of s.oci.o.Li nqu Lec Lc s , rne ybe , but. .I eho'u Ld say 11m in general ra;t,h8-.t' skeptical a.bOll~ social sciences. We simply don~t know enough and it~s a~fully tew~ting to dr@ss ~p ignorance in big words and empty phr-as@$. Take HabeJ::'lflas, whom you m@ntion·. He seems to be a decent human being~ but is he sayLng anything that couldn't b~ put in monoey Lj ab Leaz hnd that wouldn' t. look like t::uisms i.t- it. were? .Mayber but I wonder.
    I

    the

    natu~e-of

    2.
    3. non-"it:"ee

    Agreed.

    Again, m- not. .eu.re e nd ju~t community"

    r't

    ~ ll~

    not

    a~r~ l!!see

    your

    pc Lnt;,

    Since.r-eiy

    >yOU~B,

    !, e ee your _f!~lnt _ "rhus the. c aae of '"i.~~·not "t'hef corrt r exv " of what 1· am· quoted

    /1;-'<0,<"Noam

    f/:.r~\,,_/"1

    ae s.ayi.nq ueue ,

    humans.
    general and just n.ame Ly , for how

    whic;::h is a apE'.cF.,.l:~at.i_on about.. t.he "epee Lea character" of if i:nde.ed ebe e-e api:!Cteh:::character Ls e.s I apecu Lat;e (in· a libertarian tradit.ion. -o(~ Len t -vintage) t then in a non-" free anc c~.:nunit,.y""': rUnQarneflt2l ·fju(nan rights a.c e being infI:"ing@d.-~ the .right. clev'elop one~s species che eec e ec- t.o the f.ulfost_ A~ the- co["",c.:e-pt. 0'£ human na(lit:"e has functioned in our aoc Letiy , that.

    Chom-sky

    !,,:rj

    to

    is a fine quee c t.on , which has no~l"'.ing special also d i.s cu a e ed it,. h:om a v·ffey d:tfferent point. '!'hU9/. for almost 40 yee c s no"",, I ~:~e: been writing

    to 00 ·~it.h FotH::a~itL of view, to ~ !BQ;t"-@ .abou t.. how -empcy

    !·'ve
    ~

    organism" and "malleabili~ylll the-ories cf human nature have aez-ved for ccecc rve purpoaes, and why they .ar-e so a1:t.ract;l.ve to intellec·tuale,
    despite tJ"'leiz:- 'manifest. ab su cd Lt.y ,

    200-219 O~pa.rtmant of Lin<,ll.O.ia:tlcs a.od PhilosOPI1Y Cambri1ge, HaSgaC~u5etto 02139

    4. Again ~ I max be miss ing yo-u point. orprevent


    thE

    but

    if 1:.hi!. -onstrC!; Lnt;e that. c


    or removed.

    flo ..... ering

    of

    111JI'olOlJl

    c ce ar.Lv Lcy ace

    eere ecc

    February

    lJ~ 1995

    presumably
    s.

    LL will flower~
    as l}. It depande on t.he per-sen. arid thE:! n&ture of

    SaW€' anewe r

    De",,,..Dr.

    Bandyop,,<ihay,

    the conditione.

    I don't think th~re is anything general to 5ay~

    ?..bout, the use of gGn.~ra-t:.i"e grammar in Mr.?., I'd et.rongly Buggest that. you contact my cc f J eaque Robert Barwick_,. at the: Compu=tQ~ aeaence d@partw.:ent. h~:-e (.in tl!e Electrical En9ineerinq Dept.}. He r'...1:C1.!!! the maLn
    pz-oj ecc e,
    !;"thO<'"5

    and

    k.nows much. more about

    tn.e

    topic

    tha.n I

    do ,

    He's

    the

    one

    has

    doing tha ...... "ork: on Principles-Parameters oeen qu :5.te auc.ce s az'u 1 r it aeeme .

    .appL"ca.chee;and NiPo,

    ""'hi.,ct..

    The Sca:rle-Penrose arqumenc.s see-ffit.o me very uncor..vincing, fOL reasons that we r-e bri&fly l11entiot'i.e.d· by Turing in his clas,siC' 1"950 pepee-. i];,a he po.i..need cuc , it is l'i.\ea.niogles$ to a:sk ~·he"t.het"esectn.nee think. Si.mi.la.c!y, it w-ou!d be meanin.glesa t.o ask ""hetheJ; br-ains think. ?eople !thlnk, maybe o r.ae r l.iving thio5Js; that's Ute way t he. ~'o....~ is usect , It.'s E ilLke aak Lnq whe-ther ·ai..:epl-anes ~'o:'e~ll.y" f Ly , os: subn\acines .awiM( etc. Theae- are questi.coz aboc e- choi-';t! ·Qt tot'!'f!inology! ebour adopt:ing cert.ain U"!etaphot's. There are no emp i r Lc a L, que s.t Lone
    i..

    ,.

    , I.:,

    Kaibfli!

    wteJnal

    {21::.9 F'r'ooJ) <S i

    ~ ..'. ,~ , , The S€=,&'t".le,~'tpe arqume,nit:;:9 ~ihiow T.lothil'uj'. Su~·se.that. in t.aiCt: '~pia do, lo:r~9 d i"d. $i!>~ 161:' aJ!1 .i;l,lq-Pf: i t1>~~ t;ruQ!Y l!..e.1.\,l.-ned ii:")o$.chool., T.. heir ,pra1o.5 ca.r:ry· out "the ,ai9,ori~.hm",bU!t. :t.nt%.1; bralins oon't do .lonQ divi.sion. fio!:" ·th,!;:':t:.r·ivial. r.~ason~ noted by' T"u::.Fng}., "F'urt'he't:'!RGt,re'f one oane.a,~i.1J ~,t, 'U:!:? 'a~~ ~w:'i.tn.'!let;i.,"c. rOO;"t\, '';' anal,bg6u,s· t,O,' s~.ar:le·· 9, ·Ch.l!'09-se room .. and. u~e ; ~, . .
    n

    :;',

    1-'" j

    ,-

    )..

    ~\ I'5l ~J

    r.!l~

    ~~

    .~ .i'~' ;-. .•.q

    ~'~<f~~t ~'~::f~(/n~. , ,~
    ~ ~

    fifrn ~
    ~,~dF1W;

    '-"' ,,...__

    (}4~vrl'f«;"'t<f
    (r"<:

    lIf(~.fm ~.

    :;pri~7.C1i

    '11,:;. t.o ft'~Q"'e" {i.e: •• c,t;.!l;l!clude- :t,atse-ly~ tn<'!'.t",.t.h,e.""!::';it"'!;i"fj ,£l.lgori:t;hm,. t':~9'h' ,i.t do~:~~ Ml o.f t:h."ls, i'~; besi.d~<tlle· contlJ.soion ... itf my :o.pir.iolfll..

    "

    ,joe~n.'t

    U9p

    the
    90

    ·poLn't.,

    b;aa'ed
    .< v ,

    ?1!4lSt;r'''1 .<t4~~~
    ~~ '<p(3f

    'i(}~~

    <m:~ I

    <:j.... . S""<""";R;1..-::..···

    ~.

    '~'5K\!) C5{~'~t:di~; ~ 'fqcr.J1 ~.

    ~'J1~l"{IH~

    'QJiG11 ~~~

    ·'tllW~· <pl$lf.:!"f- .~~ '~j'@~ ~l

    ~'MZ<JQ?J~'
    ~:~

    FenrOE'@ tB.~8-. tll,i"g E>er"ioltlsl.Y <c. wtli~h J :thi.nk '15$ mi.,s:_t,a«e;.but. then adds a:n'Clth~r rn,is-ta.ke.. He.... , ,S1iia'lP~Y 3 w.rong- ~l?9;J.t Cbede-i,···.s theo.!!"e'ID51· as <1nurnh"B;: ot l09icLa.iu;\l·ha ..... et.~iad_ ·to ~B'zp.l~in" :Ho,s!. recer;itl.Y~. Hi.L~ry. :P~tn.am, £0 'the t~~ ¥or'k. "ti!lr~$9OQ.l;;_ Rlevi,e:l>O.
    !!Oa fC';c Sp-,a1l::'·1e-"''I'I .. prC)p{l3a-~t..tiat·th:ii'lkil1!g

    '-.~
    .'

    5ji~Rm ~~~t'1&!1i J'f~::l1Jf''-~ 1;J1,ij~tt:1 '5f<1mmT-m I ~l;(<f d1~' llR1'Z" ~~ 1ft. 1iiu ~ ~.<f<f ~~11j0 ~'~ .~~'§ (.~~.<rrn 1.~
    'I'"-""L

    1~:r.~tr¥f
    1.."...:, ',_

    ~4f«.liji1

    ~.-

    brains, . .qt.

    that' B .vtl;.ue.• i-t.";.g not: the · .! can 9JEH!I:~th~,r@ is: r.o-l;.h.in:g here' th<itw.ol~r:I·t
    CO~Oi1le
    ".

    i.s: j'U1a1t 4 pr.Qpolt'"t;y~f ,fOOd~ :a.e~!3r all,. .. ,l;g f·a~ as t . s:aid by J03e.ph pt'_j.egt.ley ,:t
    Sot:

    <u1'9.f@

    __

    ..

    ~Q'j.

    ~jr1R ~

    .~.

    -,

    ~.'~

    ,~

    ",

    ~-:-

    ~~
    (q~

    ••

    ;;;rl .pk~~
    '_'

    ~..

    ,~
    ~

    ~ { t!l~
    __

    ~'Rt &.t

    ~C~CriH C~i1dlWif I
    \5fl~ ,_Q~

    ~x

    CbY.iJ
    ~

    ~@

    lQ~

    \5rIW1~ Mt).D ~ ~

    ceir\t~r ieiB .ago. Y'O'll .~$k

    :'i'h:e 'qu.eS:t:.i.On

    i\.S> lfat- 8.9 'r. A coorp:uta;:- p.coq:;"am.


    "l.H;>t~t1c.n,

    ;?'f ,adi'llpta:bU-i.t;y <t:1Dmp-.rte,t'G· i.s ot !lei, theot'at: leal il'lter,e$t:; Qo;:,n 5,e;B. and 1 ·~a· 'rleV'er p,a.td th~ sliqhte.st ,a.~t·,~ntion to:;, "it:".

    ·"'.<.i'I-H"'t,her my ~rk

    ·i:a;

    t.o.

    ".Comput:e!:,,~tde.t.ldly

    p-Br,tic~l.ar·ly·.

    ,~'tirn ~ ~~k~?4
    ~-s11
    ~ '*11
    ;::h~

    ~hl~ ~-.
    '41'~1$P ~ ~!W.~~~

    ~lit·~)1H:~~.~
    ~~ ~~ .~ ~

    ~.
    ~~'~(\!)

    "1Bff1f?t ~.
    .71t ~

    i~

    ,att.@:i= 'allo(

    .hr

    jUi:1ft:. <I,'t.tleory

    wt"it-t"e/l

    ~.n: ar*

    \'5n'f;1·~'qjq'f
    ~ ~
    .~

    odd

    beC'a'~;m:e o'f~ ~~~lB.Ll :pr;(1"9cer-·t;ie'S o.ft:he. de\/' i.C1;;! >"lind- i.t,.,e, ao:('.tw,arec .• W-h.p ·c-O'!r-,G~? 'fh-'i! minima·H,st. l?,~o9!,,;l;t"1) i;e =l1!O'tiv.at.ed:;",.1 t.orl;:,al.l·Y diffeE"e:lt: .cOnoeorn-B ,I' ·thO'lla o-f. '1'i~:PlIla .~t.: i,~nc,rt. 1 '0(;, my' hole~ pretty serlO1;/.l;fly..
    tH;;iI'M~.l ate~ U5~

    (¢1~1jj1~Rf-·~ ~~~.

    ~m~

    .mt1~(~

    ~j,Rl~ ~1PG'9Jt"i ~~

    ~MG1'1f.$' .q-~'
    .•
    11'4";;i
    "l..~~

    ~·1!~1.1?l~(Jbt~'111 ~.ft,

    'fm~

    <i£G1'

    ra:xe do .. and l'v-e ~x"p) i,cit· letf waxt.iL!1i.9th'3t the' ~'I'!t:3.p!;Q:t:' ,isn""t; . t.e. be 't<!koo too .. 'L,Ut-a; ,any· mat.aiphor, ~t i.the'iLpB o-ict.l.:E-lt'li'"t,;n¢cu.gh;!;: and .
    i.f i,t.

    of '~OI'tI~;t'ets

    as a. m$t~.pho.r ~ 1 <!ctuaU.y

    """ii,I"\! I'U

    J.."""'~'"I

    .~

    I"'H.\:;!:

    'oQ,~

    ;m

    ~ 1,.;v I

    ·'IZI~I ~11,-.J..:;:tJ •.

    \!ifT~

    ~."iifi
    ';9f~~

    !Fll~ ("~4ft ~

    war:! ..~"
    ~~

    ~~~tt1
    ..~

    .~
    ~(S

    m~
    ~.

    nl1,~ ~'~
    :~~IL$f~

    Ff .~.
    .~ u+!

    04l> ~'6~rf:1
    ~

    n .1f1~' ~
    ~~·,\!'il~Q'1,

    01'

    '~fPSCTn. f4~

    ~ma:~,.lna:tt9:;:, fine;: con ILrt~~nt._ly h a ,81 t·:he;n d.t'Q? 1, (.' " ,

    J.'~-9cl"·s to

    -£t-rl;"¢t:.

    «1'.0:

    t.hi:$ one

    f$

    '01 '0;1~~

    4t.~~~ ~I

    ;rt, ~lt4l

    M>y' O~f"l v·i,~· f,'00:r m.ii.~wy'ear~ til, t;h~t,. ....,i3' o~t)' Il.a.;';·'i!;! 'U\+J tirF;i.e~t .. ..... · i.ntiOll<ol of IJ'Mi.e:rsJt:iln-d i.nq tinriq: t.,he .nature 01: U~{i1 ml.rtd.; and t.tl.a.t. H: f;f W'or.,kir+,qG j1;<Jj}' W0.U 't.Ul:fi. ,out t.p, b-ea: 'ffliJ"B"t,·e; l·-Y- fo·.e-i1~):t't\a(Hl, l~~ the t~hF:Ii.©'.\li 1 'a~.ne¢· I' diiEH.;'_H"1"l ed atlout lv'" l~alZ"il' ~go. .-~ ~j~ b~ie-f. beyo.t.\d ta.Hil'l.an c®pi:sternid bOiJ't'.d:Dl. ! t so, t.l::la; would be ·ilI...... lnd:!,,;"!;',l!::ViC>I\ot ii vml:",~.~!"H'l f ~d~tea·i.~nc o t:n{)%.H]ht:r one thltt De6cdt"t.e6 nJcmf.leU .wo;».qd· pe.rt;~p;a: ka>l'(i! diBI:ili'.ed.a. l:o'.(thou.gh·,9t ~(]me :timQG he s,~.Ld ~d.atd;t.t!ir thLrH}st.

    'r~~01'?'iBt".[flli i4'!l-?l' ~.

    Ji~~'orc;>j

    Ctfr.11 ~

    \5fl'9fR ~

    ~qlf

    1t:01rl,.. i¢lm ~~

    ,fUZZYI'~

    ~mrn~, '~'5"j9fK1rt'?ij.
    .~.~
    9f~\!l)W:ij '?

    ~.~'~'::~\BOlr<il(iij~~·,,!<:q$1~~J~~1

    \tlI~i4'~rnt r.QJfj:I~~ !uzzy=


    ..' ;:n~ ~s-

    t~ L /

    ;S0gk-Jl~ ~~

    covery '(~c~ ~~~l'Rb<{1. G1~ ~ I ;~~t::t' ~ mrn ll1t>.jtPl~ '~\!l i.Jt~: HA "a priori' proposition; ... is Olle ¥ihkh, though ~t'ffiJay;be ehdted by experience, j.s se~n, when known ,to have a bas~s other than ,experience. A fhild leall1ing adthrnetic ulay be "helped by experiencing two rnarbles and two other marbles' and observ:i.llg that altogether he (sic) is 'experiencing foul' lnarb~e·s.)But when he bas
    .grasped the general propositiml longer requires
    rtwo

    '111~c~~ ~

    ~ ~ ~Pi~,'?

    '~i'

    ~T,~F invention F

    and' two 'are four! hellO

    c;onfirmadon

    by :insta.n,ces.; the

    ptbpOST{ion has a
    I'

    .certainity which induction ,can never give to a general taw.. AU the propositions of pure Mathematics .are in this !?ense a priori.
    (Russen~ 1946 ~-~".~ }?!n~~ . 9ji15~>}-..Q~~-, ~~~

    ;1~1.;5f>i~<:pt1if~'Ff~f'i~t
    .

    ·c?]f1Z·AA_ ~ ~
    ~"l1f$! ~ ~

    .~

    (?') '~-Wlq <P1! ~ff

    \5fIt?i ~
    8. ~

    'm"'ff<:f

    '1iG1 '<iv.TI

    9ft"l19f1M

    «11r41

    "For my part, I belive that; partly by means of the study of 'syntax, we can arrive at considerable knowledge conceming the structure of the world." (1950 : 347) .Q ~ ~
    J1~V1 ~ 1::'<IT.<f. LF-<Q
    I

    fc1~,

    f~
    ~?f:'!
    }j(t>~.j

    0IT."T'ft ~
    :

    (,'i)~

    I~

    <'P"!fl ~

    I.!]~

    '5!'<l15 ~

    ml~
    )11) I

    <HX~'1~1'i)~

    "llll<"i(I!lI~"1~1 C~-"l?!
    'R;<:ijQ

    ~~

    ~CC4<-]11 : ) \'il~ 0 (

    11. iE:"1<lfG~ ~
    ~{.>:lli1

    ftmfk?< ~

    ~
    ~1"i'Rl1

    '5!1'<fi\5 ~
    ~.~

    WiXi C'ii18i Gll<f."?f~

    ~,
    I.!]~

    <il~ '" "1~

    Gl"1WU Gl~<ll'fl f\ill!~9~ ~<ff.1 <M1 <m:r ;n, ~G'f1R ~ c<ro~ e<r<R>i '8~ ~ >IT.<iJ 2fll1'1 fl <ITll <=IT I (~ ~ ~ pending ~ ~I 11' ~-<!l"?! .1) ~ffi 'c?jJ~ <fI5"l'-<rI f.1g~ ~c~ ~ <>!JBl1~ C'<IT.<f.1

    ~'P>~ ~

    '5!?f'>ftIV I <W-!'1

    ~m~

    '1'1:3'('1]':1 \5lV!<Pt~ I
    <Q~

    15m'il:

    JfC!)[

    ~?j\D

    <>Rl1"119f (,~

    {)\'il",s)

    Gl~

    9f~

    ~: 1

    <r3'5l~ ~
    PnC'flf
    ;n~
    15V&, '5fi?fR. ~

    J1\G1i9f : ~
    ~
    '$fffi ~ ~

    ~9f;T
    ~ ~? "

    ~~
    ~ I~

    <@l '5fi9jf.'!

    Plffi
    ;n~

    ~
    \5)~

    *
    ~

    '5fi"1f.'! '<:>k1 ~.

    ~Jt ~ '!Z'.fi ~ 'Z"!, ~ <!i~ msIT ~!A ~ "l'C<f.1, ~


    'ffil<l? ~C5f

    "'f'f~

    \!)~

    'Pr.Nl~ <nJ I

    <J~

    <Qt1\ '3!?fU@

    \Wf.

    '~\g

    'Z"!,
    I

    'i!)~

    ~1D-!

    '6

    ~~
    <Q~

    'BI, C'l~

    ~'13

    ?j'li' oq:;<RI8~ GfC'iJ ~

    'TIl

    ~1Jf
    ~~~

    f<j\!)4 BJ ~

    ~~~~~?

    o:rt~

    mzMm!f, ~
    <Q~

    ~ mn~ ~.
    ~, ~

    ~
    ~

    >ro.! ~ 'ffil<ll, ~

    QJ

    <ffi'l

    "1tRg C~

    'BII ~

    B?j~~ ~, <1r.of.:1, "'<3(;"l5 "llfu:


    C"~ ~

    (;q !fI'I31"

    '1~~

    <;@T~

    '5I1?fR ~ ~l)1 :~ (~
    ~? <f(\1bm

    11"f',
    ~-cfl()j

    "!~
    ~

    '1f\1b~

    'fife

    blood!

    ~,

    PrC"fV't '5fi?fR ~
    ~

    miss <i'(3Wii,<j 1 invention~


    '5f!\%l-c<iGl

    ~tC>jI:Z<1 $1@f1 ~~:


    <;@1';j

    \7W1
    \5f1I551 ~~

    monopoly-~ 'lV!
    \5{j\55f,

    <n\1b~

    <''<:>(1) lPIT'iflm?
    !,6 ?i~

    <fIT3l \5!1\%l, ~

    11\1b~

    \SRi ~

    BJ ~! ~-Made
    you Mr. Rakshit-(
    \5[1\;'ij

    in Bengal!Q'ff<f1 C'4C'l> ~)
    'QfGf

    '1[Vm.>jI~<j : Allow me to contradict C'<fC<i' \5l1~1~ ~


    nasium ?
    <.j@j~

    'Wl ~

    \5ff~

    g_.,

    mlr.R?

    Gym-

    '13~

    ffi Wrn 1<l.. :?


    <nJ-Juvenal-<!J~ ~l'1l-Mens

    ~:

    ':31 ~
    ~

    1'51\&

    C\51 ~-~ sano-

    <!1.~

    sana incorpore <!1.'l, ~

    A sound mind in a sound body! Right-'I3<[jlf! <r...r.-1 eEl ~~

    ><1m

    fl'

    'jJ.t11~

    ott

    :[C\5t I ~

    c$f.l)1 ~

    ~
    Q1

    Gymnasium-us

    'K'11-Athens-cQ$1 '5l1<l15ffi

    'l!.'ij<;j

    <m:!j

    ~iI ~~91-~"f,

    C~,
    .

    \5U1~"1~Jj

    o
    ~

    ~ ~C~-ciP1<r
    ~ ~

    \5!0 ~ ~ I .Q~

    'i"lc-6'l m;~

    ~ ~
    ~.

    .Q<l\ \'5fRF\lD<TI

    Wi' <fiR) '-'1<1, o/)~ ~,

    '5(j(FIl5"lIQ fIT<l-DiaIogue-<l1 <i~?

    '5l1?fR

    ~'$

    <W121VTl'5'f (~"Z9f1>M

    RPm == ~(''VJ''1Jl£''1l' ctrlF&<l> ~?!I)


    \S'8~Rcrn 91$1 ~ )'11'l1l%r1' ~
    ~ <;>ffBl, ~ '.5lK"11b;mr %j{'<I~q

    <1''<fi<11~f'Q0'i1l.<f. ~

    <I'm ~ ~

    I oil~

    c!I~ I~

    '511\!?)'0~19 m~· ~

    ~~

    '5l1"'fR ~
    <;j@j~

    'R31 Ievel-"t'!lH'111 <r01) ~ <TIl, '>t~

    '-'1~

    '-'11''1<j>}j \51~-

    "lWGn~ : But at the highest q'i/"Z ;rn! (~'3

    ;rn-w:~

    ~,

    ro ~ ~ :>f<l .:n~ <iN ~~


    <rN

    M!2)~ \'5ffVl1 '5l'3<!l<f, ~ \5fj"q'<f-<!'&i-~

    I
    9f1@,

    <IT~tffi ~ \5I1f.l <JIRwl ~ <jj-Productive \"if1~ ~qlz~'i cQ"<tTG'N3 ~-i~l~ <;sjf<f"1>lZXj ~ <n ~ ~ ~v:Bf ~ <n ~'-' I <!1"<f.'l (.'0j ~ f.t!1~ Twaddle ~ ~~ <wIi <rm ~ I <n~ ~ <WI C,-,"'l..f G5">R ~ C'31
    ~q'$ ~~_:_

    1F&~jj
    ~

    ~i
    ~~

    I5ffGl1 \5lmt
    ~ <:fG1 ~-

    '<!v"11c."lS1Jj'<lJl ~
    C'lRiJi <.!1<i>G1

    '@"Z9f'1LM ~

    <fi I5!I"Sc<fl4rnl' I ~"i


    ~ <l'&1'-C$5t

    :>f~G'fK~

    9@r<ri.r~
    ~Ht\5 'Communicative

    9fl'0f,

    131 @~9i~2!fh>~l?:\!S'8
    cQ\)iVf> ~

    1I<tJ <P1C11 \5f~«:' \5fft'P'( "<fi I L <fi ~qJ Competence' f<!mlU'Hl (Pragmatics)

    b)1I%-<ilfQJ\57ompetence
    I~

    ~
    <q1

    L· L'

    1"'ifG I ~V1Q"Ti':>j

    ~"1i9ifoi\5
    ~ ~.o.
    cQ
    @1~ ~

    <r'lfI-c~rr\58" <!l~ Jjfl11f\0i~ ~~ Universal',


    (.~f0<f."I9 ~ ~

    f'1foi

    'Dialogue
    \3~

    Constitutive
    '-'1~ ~

    <n. ~
    ~

    :>fC51 ~I '1~C\5
    >iCJ:fiIG>iC.9

    ~~qj?;?j<j

    1<!l'YiRi WR;:q
    ~,

    (5i~!

    mm
    ... ?
    ~

    <l'1B1 "l1V1 ~
    Qi@

    ?fJ?:?l ~'lt
    ~'5'f'5

    <ffi!
    EL ~

    C"R ~

    MgJ"!)

    <w!~'5'f

    :>f~G'fi~

    ~C?l

    itTG! I ~

    8Mi ~,

    0Pf ~

    I cq; ~

    "Emancipation

    from the compulsion

    of internal nature suebased on force are reThis does not occur


    (:;,,,,q~ : 1'-')

    ~?~,~
    cQ~ cQ;q> ~

    9fl~I"1I%('\5, <111~\5 ~
    \5I1Br~ 15!~ \'5f~ ~~I

    ~.

    fazxt ~

    ceeds to the degree that institutions ~I


    Qf

    C1M ~~ ~mrtvrn ~
    "fl ~
    C~I

    C?]~ C~I ~'


    <if I ~

    placed by organization to communication

    of social relations that is bound only activity of struggling class. (includ~ ~

    ~
    ~"l

    free from domination.

    E L'-'1<1 ~<>R1

    'DlC'iJ1 ~?;\'l

    diretly through productive 17FR, ~,

    ing the critical activity of reflective sciences)"


    ~

    I5!<iJM("lS \'5iIil1"<1~\5
    '8~'8

    '51%<101 ~ 151'1 ~
    ~ ~ <!l~

    I L -'$ 15!1"<1 "lSi"" ~


    "l1V1 ~

    "\3j~

    ~~

    \5li'i~~l'

    ~ 9f@'1\5 <f.?l05
    q>'<fll" q>«h1J1 ~

    ~'?l

    I '\5RJ' '5 ~

    I '5n'{!;H<lrn<f'

    ;q>'<I1 <1C«1[i;:«1j';jI :!jj\;)01(<i1

    ffi ~
    ~ ~, ~

    <.Q"<ll"8 '511'i~~<f' ~
    ~ :>f'ZG'fi9f <IT ~'1?!

    :>f~G'fiC9f

    wj
    ~"G'j

    'if! ~
    ~~

    m<rf.fi ~,
    ~

    <mr I ~

    <rrn?
    ;n~ I51Bi I

    ZC11 ~~r>i

    ZC1 Sociobiology-a ~ "The

    F1;:(1 ~
    ;q>q:m

    f<rett%i
    ~~ c!I<!> ~

    ~Q)

    f'ilBJ
    ... ~

    i@1<1\5\!\b1' C<li!!i3im
    <1t«1'iN-<!l~ \5Io;>ffi <!l~ ~

    "NRJ\5 c<fii ~ i5if.ffi:~,

    ~r?l1

    '@~9fi'R ~~

    >f<fG1 <TI <!1m '@~5im

    oil"<f.t1 ~9f

    c!I:>f'1 1"'<I1<n"Gn:l1

    zlt<Bf.ifP1~ <!l~ I5!B! <j>QllQ


    ~

    ""f1\ffi <TI ~
    ~ '@~~

    ti~PR\!p
    t7W1

    'Cw. ~

    '5f!t'lt ~

    nature

    of western

    sysnot of

    f~

    9~

    15I"ti'T, "~
    ~-:>j<l

    ~"RtPm1? ~iTI
    <!I"l' I ~~
    9jQ) ~

    ~
    <1l@

    ~'Si\!)jj~

    %(RrA~WI ~~
    "'lfiJ ~
    ~ ~

    mZ ~
    <fiG

    i;ffWlil~

    mTrEl

    tems of indoctrinations understood ganda official sion,


    1lFIV'~

    was not perceived stance

    by orwell and its typically the basic assumptions authentic


    ~'<q

    by dictator-Cwho and thereby

    fail to comprehend that incorporates marginalizes


    :>f~G'J1~

    the utility of propaand critical


    '-'1~ <1\5"1 ~ ~

    \S::Fn<i1

    I <!l~
    <W\av.:rt'5'f

    of a critical doctrine which 1511ft;, must

    @<;"'1'f'R ~

    <!l~ ~J'1..«1<f.

    ctrll'&q;; flrm
    f.'H':\5 ~,
    \3i1~

    "<fi G~"'1I"R

    '<M1 c<l"05 "'1'1t?l1 @<;"'1'fi'R ~ ~ ~~<l,%\l;Jrn


    ~

    SF""Im

    <li ~

    1Jj"'1~ '5lj\I;J]i!BQI'1

    be blocked."
    ~

    em, )",Ire.
    ~

    discus1"Q(j

    : -'Z1r)

    I GI'<1Wf~

    '51I'07..{<lml' ~

    <n~"i D1"<llB'5

    ~:l'j~Ra-jT5-;n"l«1.q>

    <?\2iUm51"<1 'ij(;<{l'Gt <f8JVZi ~

    '51j'-:!lh<ll1lqs ~~G'fi'1

    <n ~

    l~ ~(QVTl~

    iSfFTI ~

    ;n I

    t' K8t~JaI

    8met'il~I,

    ·C~IJ.dProof) '6~5

    '

    ~t<Hi~'10l"$lRi?h'),n l.!l~' ~~

    '5l1~\2C"j(P'Ff"'j

    'e(3J~l4V:~:1 l(fj~

    9j'jZ~~ '~

    \5l@

    Gl1'~:1C'1~ ~

    H~

    :m1i ,I ~\!)H1 li''lifi\!Vi ~,<po~l"4fN@1'~~~'


    eAi3TliGltll tci~ I ~,

    q'~fb
    ~4~Cqmf.1C\!)
    ~~
    ...,""I r

    ~ffi·~ -qZG1i-q' ~C\!l~


    .. wm,~td) '~,',' Vf~,·""rt8.~", ,~,~ ~
    r ~

    '~i:tGt&il;

    ~<R "68r ~

    ~'(~,.i~'fe
    '~ ~

    t~m4'('~,., ~r;«1.;p1it '~P4>~)6bjtat-~}"~1 ;;g-\8ffi\6 <1\§i-C~tp1~ '~t


    \!}4.4t~4,

    ~'<J\5

    ;n~,tHtat'~~~~~ ?l~1ttGj ~

    \9f*~~M,"m,·· ·..

    ~~nm~~
    ~~

    fif(~'l

    '~-

    ~~I~~"'2nN$I'$j(~~
    \s,

    "=1'oq"; ~~'
    >i~J(AS

    ~~~t'1~,m~,~ ~. C~~

    \9@,i:1G ~~i I{3G~¢'j'~'rn

    , t.. .f' t

    ,(. - c- IY11'1~ ~~ 'l!j~ f~nh-,_;rarnmar"<lPi",,,"·'I'r'9'~'H'~'\'~'~'~' ""'- 1. .' 1 ~7.u~ ~II£


    ,G ram mEr.!

    Xil'1"ij

    C"1ffi;CS1 If!V9

    (}Erc~ 9f~' I ~~. Pk~1 \"JPfR1'~,'<!1 <wrc'6 '1GiC~


    '1t<V
    ~(;. Pi
    .~

    Cff6m

    f4f\b~ ,~~rtP\!)
    ~
    ~~

    ()tim' ~
    ~1-t';-.rIIG1·

    ~~Q':~

    "The concept of )1n [deal community of communications


    in favour of a '~rans.c.en-

    4Jl~

    ~'~ t&iit' J1I9(O"i4 ,'~~,

    ~Q'l ~

    ~~,~M~~~l?(
    ~

    cancels the constitutive, plurality of sign-users

    dental-subject whieh now also understand tical sense.' (l\§~>f~ -;,~b-'9t : :~:~\!i)
    '~<~~1~
    ~(,.Lr~
    ~ '.Q~

    itself in a practical-hermeneu-

    fi;:J
    --

    FHq2;, :91~rn c~<lJ


    If!~~'\!)'1 ~~

    "."

    ~,?,C\!5I<q~D<!i

    tir~~ ~ ~
    ~~

    ~Jt ·;n.1 ~,~~-.


    i.Bf5f~~\5f~

    ... ~

    ;n ~

    \5ifq·% Xf41-\51~~'$1' \5ft'~1(J1?l


    ~~,

    \tijK~ >:541~:P~~%rn '~f


    51~~ 't?aHiFi~llq;l1?f'1

    ~1l419\f1~ ~(.<tstft~'

    ''Jl~;~$~<.~~,

    ~<fl~ 1@~~

    ~tG1!-1, "~";f-~l{\!)@

    JfZC1lt~
    Zl~'~~ ~
    ~
    \t'j~

    05t '~~\!)B1'
    \;:Sll''1t\5m
    ~~

    c~ '*let~
    c~
    C~Gi1

    ~ ~' ~;f\@ DF1 ~;t"


    'qC&' I ~'~'
    1.Q~,

    Polemic
    ~

    G~G\!l'@bC3 ?fM,1 lfl ~

    ~~4fl1l~<p

    t. t .J

    '~~ ~ ~r-~ ~'rj)0~


    '"' "I'">~ ~~"'l') .""~~ (.r{$! I."A·<:P <m' ~Ju:~$l'

    9ftq:tw)~ <p~

    ~~Mul
    ~

    lll('~~i4 ~,~.
    ~g-f<j~'b

    ~~.

    Ub·~ \!l~

    ~TiS~:~\~1
    '~

    R<st">1 ~rn,

    !Oly!ogUe-<!Rf
    .. 1\""; 1"1: ~{}~~ 4

    \S ~ "ij~lqj?l ~'S

    <leG I

    ~:

    8Ji ~~

    "Y'fitb§.,~, tI~~

    '-~

    C'!i$.i <n
    J'

    qjl'[~1R'f-1
    I ""I'~i
    '('j';;j)~

    ~ it.;'~ ~ rVi:-..t: ''=<"lit~' / ~ .. "ClH ·'i~~.I"':\!:l{;'G::i'

    m~Jc-q~I <l4'?Wnnm~'?ltitj
    ;n r"
    1:hl¢1i(}6; ~C$l
    (JFT

    ~l

    ~ffl~Q '<f:~r ~ I
    ~4S'jW?l~,

    '<P~~'?!~%1
    ~'11..G1'1~ D~f~'·I~~
    <pQ(f

    ~Vi ~-.~
    .

    ~':>,~ ~
    CW1

    ~tG· ~\Sf ~

    Culture 'of .~ critical Discourse '(CCD)~~


    ~;;H:[;fqoat'~J.Bf
    ,C~ I~

    ~
    ~c;?f~ 1fl~

    '~ .

    ~ffi9f \!)~¢14~~ ~J.~ ~/ mQl1 '1ff~tW: ·RiJ, ~~ \311lHl1 ~, ~M '~11 ~.U~"C!I ~'11 ... ~: -s ~ I' ~~'~ ,C1.fi1CiQl. 'SYiil1\!i~~ ~~ "1i4S)('<fS '6G1' <m~' ~""'m _ ~ _.'
    :~,-,~Rb"4'~~'9
    .:0-..

    «firf; ~

    "-11'~e:o(.

    (l

    <1(Pi4 ~~<f'~>ne

    (t;~R~'JG1
    ~

    ~,b(J?~

    ~Rb,41ifiI ~

    C~"}GQ ~J<p~
    ,~ ~.

    ~
    (Ni .~~

    •
    ~)llt:9\!)'Q ,~

    <l\&,C1Bl
    ~

    Mtfltf~ .~

    ~'>

    C;.:r<fj~4!

    1c~f ~@{~ 9.j~(§tI4~rn

    rt~~

    disem-

    <fflI' ~
    ~

    '<fm I ~I~~

    m~ ~'<t-1ffl
    .~~

    bodied

    c<tt,~
    ~

    !t<.5i <rr~~ tt'P'l~~}ii,~~ ?fOS"(~r ~?l'tf{~~?r CCD ~.~ \51'~CG€'<1P11 I~ ,X3(31G1~'l~ leq f'h.lraHty of sign-users-as ~q:r <1?P1C~~~ '()1Gr
    t!fC~'~~4i~:m\15\~fQ

    i@;F&-~re.~ .~
    ~,

    ~<;;PC~ ~~'f@r\!)dj~ "~(.$ll?f ~!

    «11 '~ I ~~t~<p~ ~1J iHpl~

    '6 '~:ji%Q

    'c<r~

    'D¥Jm~"

    $li-(}9¥\5ffi

    ~.:?jF~t\!)
    ~
    I.,

    ~<4CI.D' ~(<i 1~'~<f5G4f&<p


    ~ ~~; \5f~
    "

    ~l\bC6 ~~
    ~
    ¢OH()-

    ttl

    1Q;11bM~\5l1f .81" S;'c:~Ml~.~·

    '~~r C~~
    c~~-'"
    ~.

    050 ~, ~. c~
    ~

    lozne, <fi ! WaloS!ue~ ,"_" ~


    ~

    ;rn:l' \61t~'~~9j'Yl<t~~I'1~<:%i~ ~"\...:.;jrJ..!..,


    <r?r'~ ~ .~ ~.

    (13!~, ):~"1~)
    ~'~l '~

    L·

    (ulylogue .~

    ~mf.t*1~~
    ~ ~

    s. r.)

    lJ

    (.<rl~ e?N '~

    (~.c:~1ltl.tJi~ ,\5PTrn·"fation~1 problem

    solving discourse')') 'Wi(~iir ~~ ~ttw.I"

    \51 ~.
    ,~~~

    (<frll'l '1!l05 ~
    1~-;1~-4.!1~ ~-~',-~ <frtfiif, '~~

    ,~i~;[;i;t\5fB1 \!)~:-;;~ro.n >i~. ~~

    ;;pj~llBl· <f111-~(>~~ l~Gtt


    '-.

    C41~

    ,my:&1~ ~
    Vl-em ~.

    ~C\!)
    ~\S~~"8

    "'1'1"@'141'&<r~rn
    ~,

    "11f<f'iQ~

    cq§'{;fl~

    ~ i<:l"4~'
    .~

    e1'¥J,&,

    fi:........... \5fGq

    C\5t~

    1~1i(j
    r-.

    <nfil'~ ~f&~ ~~
    Qt~
    ~~~~

    ()1'r.:lMsGl
    10;;1 ;I';"i~ ~l~
    II ~\Q ,ft$!' I'

    2j]~<lI(}'isr ~n\l§~~~

    '11"'ln':1

    \Q5l '~~

    ~"ijt"ij\!)

    \5FM(:rmq ,5i7iCG ,~

    ~~

    \51"RPlmQ ~

    (~~1!' ~~

    \b<:~

    ~J]

    tr.lc1)fiSi,

    i.!l$6r ~9~ 'c!l~~\$1l

    I -CJ;~ ~c{~~?YBf
    <:ij

    ~51(~~ ,~i@'2lt<1

    <IN-

    fOIYIO~,
    9fl<i .r
    \5[~ '<1GlL'.:!>
    ~,(.~_~

    I <§!«C'1~~<l1 <pQjj "4t.'61 '1'<~C4~~I~t B1C~ ~ ~2J~9f \!)"<M 1TI~0 9J~ ~ >9[~f.)~t~lfG,~ ~1I~~1iWJ {rHl\!l~l1i ~~.'~ ~ 1(;~

    ~Nl,qrVf'~~ 1tC~f

    qr'ftS

    binary

    00 ,"

    ~~9R~5r
    ~4<i ;' ~~ ...~

    fitc"~ ?f@

    I \!)'~:;?3lC\!)l
    Jj'lj\"j$ ~

    ~.~.
    I

    1!:IG'Ern ~(~~CC'j~!0'ro1:
    ~,

    Q%<n®'~if3i~
    ~ (~~

    ~M <lfG1~ :;:p,~:~
    r-«

    5tG4i~/~Q.ll
    "11~~)

    <1'~: ~t?I

    ;:'~'fi1 ~RJ~\;€_Jflffi\$ '~UO~1~ ~"1'<1 (

    (~~~~
    '5ic~<p

    ~l\5-4111?' 98i. r_{$'t\fii

    <rM. ~f\!;,:<n~; ~r'Q%fI.j9ffu~


    ~r~<lltT,~~l':'T~
    or' ~~~

    : ej.F!>1fCf

    ~?'

    Zi::,,~e(iS!i'{ 'bHil<p~i<lW.:q~~,Q,fj~CR

    '9j~~~

    ~ m R'9

    ql\:!)-<'H~'f?'r·t.~ll1:

    ~~lf?'
    <QGt;~

    ~ <iN

    (l.

    ~R>,"lj'lC¢!

    W~ <IJ1<>11::ii;!

    <TI

    ~r? ~
    "if"f"?

    <!l~

    i:j~

    ~1!1-~~
    f<l-9JN? iFfl~ ~ ~
    <i'l~

    <!lG'fi~ ~

    c<i'Z ~
    '~

    GfINt? '&~

    <liV'f ~

    ~ 'fI\S I' r:
    ~

    <l~

    2i~:qi'i? ~

    ~/~-?!(;'l'P

    or<n'
    ~ ~,

    mI
    (55C@

    ')

    : <!l~

    Zf\5

    'fI\S, -ti~
    ~, ~ c;rGJ ~?
    1

    'f'\.fOF, '<i>l'ifii' <0 "fi~l?j :


    (black
    ~ ""Ii"!"',

    ~,

    mail) ~I -05) ~
    (}IV:! i:j)~

    ~
    '-

    F!? <?11F\1
    ~ 'lIv"'"'i,,, --o=:t

    mv? ~
    f<l-f.'v.m'>f

    1m

    k/

    !R~?~,
    ~~'?
    <Q~

    <lC1i ~,

    '~

    1R " ~.

    '&1'~

    'l~ '5fl'1R

    on~
    ~
    ~<Q~

    C~

    '5!PfI~
    '1~?

    c~

    \5i<f.rn ~

    <11m

    vrc"43~ ftk"l' : '~


    '31C"('?1C<1>?'~ ~

    'W1 ~

    <!l<r\ ~~

    <!!dic~(%'1, '~~,

    ~l\!c)d7f~l'

    '5fi"i:j)lJ ~ ~

    <!lr-l 111\6, .0 ~

    I' iSffi
    1

    i:!1
    ~

    m, ~
    0W'1 ~
    1

    J~ "1,,<1> <1(Pl ,-.. t>.Gll1, ~"'" "111.'11


    "P1

    ~ 4t~

    CBfl<i~ <fl:61'i('1' wR ~
    ~~~
    151<0 ~
    'B~,'

    m1
    ~
    lfRT
    ~

    ~ : 15f1~

    f4%!~
    ~

    ft~ 4 ~ ~ 'B~ 'f'@


    ~ ~

    0W'1 ~
    ?i~f)'jc~

    <1>i'K~ \SRI ~

    Di~ 1!r-l(!jfCq
    N.HGlt'i'(

    ..=j
    »:

    1'T ~
    ~1r

    * ~~,
    1'T ~, ~ ~
    ~.

    $jPi(~ ~,
    -q><j ~

    \5!B1"

    '<fI ~,~
    ~ ~',

    NC\31

    GZf'Ti----<ilm
    'BGi~ <Xli ~ -~ ~ '5fi~ ~ \5j«:'~ ~

    ~c.Wi" ~
    01"\-~
    ~ 2i~

    ~
    ".iiL'?B'I ~
    9'F!'
    <Q"fo1 ~ ~
    \5{~ <Q~

    ~
    : '~m"1'1101~

    ~~I
    ~
    ~

    m '~"i'

    ~ : '\5l1F\1

    !!:'Bm' 15!0 '~9\

    !Z'S1{t' ~

    y(
    !ZBl

    ~?

    !ZBl C"FT 'lTV! c<Fi ~

    I5fBf '~"i

    ~'
    \5~

    'I5lm! ~

    C'>JG'f' ~1'fl @11~1;1 <r<R <@f ''8]'?lb1 ~ \5f10l1~' ~ \!c)1~? .';J1('1 \3!~ ~'S
    !Z'Sm

    c"M:',

    Rs W
    ~

    C<iC\!?
    q)~,

    ('>WI? ~~'

    \5.fWf'<t \5fP11
    (-~

    ffi
    C<1

    f.f; ~
    ~
    ~-),
    ~>

    C<iM '~'
    ~~9 ~
    "11~'5l

    !Z'Sm? GfI~ ~~q

    <@J, \Q)'i:!l":Q ~
    ~ ~
    <Q

    fum "'I®I '5!l~

    C1"1 ~,

    Flv.:! ~
    15Il'i:!l":Q-6Wr

    -n 1 ~
    ~
    ~

    i83f.1 ~

    <Q<1Z

    oom ~;
    ~,
    ~ ~ ~

    '6nWt<Jl i&M' 00 <l'fu 1 'f'!, 'Bm ~ ~

    mv.:r

    ~)

    'T'lf11 '\ : <rI%5 ~'>Jj\b(1'


    ~'i HI's@?ll"1 8frp:j
    <!l~ ~ ~~

    \5q@f ~
    (6ff@-

    :Q\5Ji'<l1
    'B~ ~ ~ '?

    '1l ~

    '}fc>1 Vl1~<f1 ~,

    i \5f1~

    2i~ C9J(;\5 ~

    :Q'j% QPf<l @-.gl;


    .':>(£00

    '1>B- (~,

    "iMt1

    W
    ~

    ~~:Drn ~~'-'S
    )'ji:j..f<r; I ~ «ll<fI~,

    Df.9<r I's~l; \5ffI)ffq

    \5l1f.t

    cmr,

    ~~'}j

    <n I ~ ~~

    ..:F J

    ~
    ~ ~

    ~
    8 : 15f1~

    ~
    <!It<Ml@~'

    \5ll1~
    <fI~
    ::>ji:j ~

    ~9\~i\b{O~
    ~

    1!l~41

    C1"1

    '1)>;:n't<T? ~

    HI's@?lI'?1 (15'(;((:<;1(41
    \5f1~1 ~ (}r<llVH 1jJ.~

    01(\5 \5frU0'

    nTIJI ~ T'rl

    ~I
    '5f'<l~G<l

    1'@ .~ '{3~,

    iR<fl(;\5 11m, ~61l ~,

    \5i 1\Pi ~

    ~, "1\gC'4'

    ~f.1

    '1)~ ~~

    '1..~ I ~l'vtil"1
    r

    <;JlliGc'1
    1'Q,~ r

    'ii'<<1> ThZ' N@

    1f%f~ ~r

    ~
    11 ~

    \!5fIiiJ )'ji:j~
    ::>ji:j~

    <ffir 1 <1~
    1

    cS:l1' >:rf[> '{'1 Gro'i '5l1~

    ~';f.1 1'm ~ '5!l~

    c<P'I

    '5lIfit

    c!'l
    ~

    Rfu ~,

    <RlfC<P, '5T@r ~ 11~f\1 ~~-2i'fR-~ ~Z


    ~
    '<lJ1i:j '5f~

    <llfu
    ~

    \"iI(;\5 <W1 ~

    <1\~G
    cS:lJ'l0! ~

    ~, Of<!1.C'5f01

    <Xli '1)'.:~
    IT : -~

    '1<1 ~-~
    '5!B1-:;:C?lC'(

    'iT ZIT GRG'I


    ~ <!l"lZ ~
    ~ I~ ~ ~ ~ ~

    <Q<q5'i1ffl '6/G'i I >J<l'lC"1

    @l~ ~

    ~~ ~ ~

    ~f:Z ~
    '5j'.l.i15 -~
    ~,
    ~

    cS:lV'l <r1lJ <nl I <!l .~

    '5if1f'l'lQ

    m -"HM0'<;J
    ~ ~

    <W1 ~, 131 ~

    ~ ;rn j' '1l1

    ~
    ~

    <Wf, ~

    "1V ~ ~ ~
    ~

    "1V I ~
    'B~

    m~~

    ~G(.'1W ~
    '1)(3li"1Ri.q

    ~ -8M?
    ~Q

    <rs~

    2iR%1 mv

    \5Pl

    "'m~
    (£ :

    -ZYl'lbicwt;~'
    ~~

    ~;.

    M'f~
    '5fj'mi

    -.:r~
    ~~~ -

    RrJJ~ BW! ~
    ~ ~ 18M}

    ~
    I <Q~

    \!c)1~i-~/~/~11
    ~

    ~~,'&l~~~~I> l'iiM1M'4'

    <@f, 'Sl'<l! ~ ~ ~
    ~ ~

    <rRI~, ~~

    <1j~f<t(3Hb-s 1 ~

    G'fifq-""<lf1'U1 ~

    em

    'B

    <uW1
    I~

    c<l'\m ~ ~
    ~

    ~-~"I'~-c~,
    'm~

    ~~C-;jlBl
    ~<Q~~I' ~

    r.cr'<f0

    ~, ooP14'\:?!V1 1!l11'2i~, ~~oiI<[

    ~I~
    ~

    I' \5!Q?r~

    ''1TZG''ffil \SRI ~q
    \5B: 'Npl

    <i@

    'S I

    ~
    'B
    @11t';B

    ~,

    <l~

    ?fJl"B15 ~

    I!l~~,

    ~ :~

    'Nl~ ~

    <mt1 ~
    ("ffll1~~1'

    ~(}J

    mN-eb1RiG -~
    ~ ~ VHP4i ~ ~

    <Ur&"1\5 ~
    (2i)~) I

    -mf"iUl'>'[' <l1 'F1i~Plft~'~<f ~


    ("\(;\5.
    CQf[1'

    ~t<1S
    ~ ~'

    '5l@!
    ~ ~

    f.1g~

    1'i1'@, m] C1iGli' C'fIGi11'i ~,


    0Wn
    <!l~~:;:;(@

    '5!PfIm
    '1)~

    m~11fit

    0l"T'; "iRM, ~ 'saie'<brated <\Jfu,'{l,

    R:>f.i
    -~

    ~ i~ ~

    ~~ ~

    c<ii<!"l~-\!5fI'-.:[lm oiI"1Z (~ ~Jl~2i9jG'jRi!

    '\5t<l~<l\1'~'T;<1! c\!c)'iC<q5

    '@'Q

    ~tl

    <!lOiI$.CG'j<-j I

    '5lii'1 ~

    ¥
    ~

    ~l ~
    I '<ifJ1
    ,,<'0 ~

    \<:K~i
    1511..'1J'5l
    ~

    1'@ ~

    ifJ~

    'TIl I

    L,

    "li<{\
    '3{1{fj"(JJ

    :;'0

    <n""t~
    G1~, ~ ~?

    <jS'i"l~ '.2J~"i1g' ~,

    '1!Fl

    "'11~~(,\")

    ~ <fl~'"1jvd

    ~ ~, ~

    Wt1 <Pf<t I <Q~

    <QV\ ~

    I Jj}l\")<jS1GG1 ~, \3f1 \!)N4! 0<t I5lt1 C1?\~!G\5J

    '1?1, •

    :$I (surplus

    labour) ~ <11f.kl1 ~ ~ C~ "M ~I

    <jS@

    ~I

    "l1!p(.iillM>f.<i' )j_'i1G?\!)

    fi!v.:I

    ~
    'q>@

    'GMJ ~

    ;f.1\,::JR;<j~~

    ~SVH
    0.~.

    fum

    ~gR-2t,®9(

    m ~ ~I
    Z1'Jl ~
    tp] '1f\&()l

    <Q<J'l81 c>'\Rlt<;j

    i:5~

    RI ~
    ~ ~

    'biC'iJ'>l ~-~

    '<fl~ 1f3i!'{jru:1'~
    'iQ.1$1 ~

    Gft"lJ"ffil <!G'i2iVl1"1
    ~
    'q>@ ~~

    2j!.~1i8jCii'i1 <Q~ ~ ~
    ~

    ~q-~ \i5lc:\505J>iSJ!iiC'f.
    \i5~~

    ~
    ~ I~ <F'RS" ~

    «1 ~-~

    ~ I5!jM<6l'1 ~
    'f.'~

    <1'C?l~
    .~
    ~

    Tf<'M <!l'>fo1 <.Q~

    "'1Rl'1'>l.

    <w1CG1 \5i,¥JM>

    ("fm'<1 ~ 1GC:?lI9(-\5!1tA!1<1'I<1'

    ....

    <Qil\'l)~
    ~~

    ~
    Q.l)~

    :>f<r ~

    mt<!f ~

    ",WiD:!
    <iI'f.'

    ~<3i

    !<Q~

    I ~, 1<iC:W:<11

    ~ ~~' 0f.'
    ~

    1lFf.l ~~

    <iI~ <;JlQ-'i'?l,

    MN ~
    c<i

    i1~
    'G(J1 ~

    \5.l'lfu: I 1f<,!

    \3 ~~ ~;
    ~? \5n"Q

    ~MiEii~<i"

    \3~""P\51~ ~

    <Q'>fo1<Q~ ~

    \i5Q)"j

    Fnft"\ ~

    ~\~J1~

    "iii c<! ~

    f.Wffi
    "l"iT'i" ~
    (,15@l

    (.<I'M ~

    "<P1<l: ~
    0f'<.~,

    <!l':l'pf ~'<ft
    ~ ~~ ~

    <it

    fGKbc\i5 ~~~
    C<f. f<1"9f'lf-?

    $~
    ~

    <.QllGl~Hi
    ~
    ~9('Vf

    ~
    ~ 0'i~

    <i"l\sc<i" ~5jt
    ~ ~ ~I

    ~
    <Q'f.' \")<:1""\

    -n, ~
    \5f1ln'<;f 9fTC1Q •
    SMS

    2:i1\!>c<11:m I W(
    C~,

    i~
    C9fC$l

    (,<f. ~9J'lJ?,

    9J11'i1! ~
    <rm~
    D~~

    ~G~G1

    ll8n~
    I

    '["iJ 0JIVlG'I
    ~?f'ip ~

    ~"1' ~

    \,::J1CFlj\SH.'1~
    <Q~ 2t~~?

    \(3;;;;c.~ ~
    qf;1

    <mr?
    'fiSi'
    "l<i> ~

    ><tR~ ~
    ~

    0f<t
    '.(~

    \5lJ1G1fG
    I ~

    (<i"I<i1lj reality ~ c<l'f'<Il1!?

    show \5TBf ~

    irreal t

    ~'-I\!>H
    ~

    *th~ ~
    I ;j0f; <Q~ ~
    ;rt W-$

    C"'1i:n~
    ~

    f.k'i ~
    'it 0lm
    ".jr~'
    ~ 2)~~

    9fTC"lZ >fii\$ulRC"lii
    '""~ \5if>ll1 'it

    '1"f<'f~m ~/1'j~ '5[]"Pl 051 roH~ 'T!


    ~
    I 1'j~<ro

    <JW, ~
    \!)!Q..(Cij

    '<wi'; \5fI~ ~

    't?j~<!N' I ~

    ~
    ~

    o:m~Wi?ZG! ~
    1'jZ<i"l]'Gl 'l<il03 ~

    <QZ ~~~

    m f4(.\!)~,

    'Cf)

    <[Wit (~
    '~

    I <Q~

    "m("'I~
    ~

    '1tFf GP1'1' (q@ijJ;t<1"ii 15!ji;,1'1~1dj41


    ~

    ~'

    Ti"'l"11~~,

    ~
    ><j\3l~><i ~

    <ffi1 'f<ll~
    <If.l ~

    ~9T
    ~ G'{'i3 ~
    ~

    ;n (\,::J(<l
    >'['\<»((;1
    '8

    <Q'i~ ~

    9. 0

    <rfflVi1 Q,f!t<!>,

    \3)~

    R:.\rri' ~
    lff.1j, ~

    Uj1>fG fu"1~
    I @151m

    2l<l:1.1 '<liCl1
    \5jf9i1\i)\') ~ ~

    eiGI
    ~~ ~

    "P1-~-(,~jql'

    cmS)~"f

    ~~qjb <QZ C~Tr.<G'[, ~


    'Gl ~~

    t1~

    I \;:1~V~?l

    «1

    <fu5m
    <JlRG1

    \5fIOMI ~

    2t1~(.<i' ~ ~

    NC'ilW I ~r~m llVi


    CiQ?'"lG"PiTbl (\,::Jv1R S)~

    f.'r.:1'>f.nXj<f.
    '~'
    \')<Wf

    "1l~, ~'<fR1
    15I<f ~.
    ~ (~

    ~
    C'tl!1r,'!l ~

    'M1 ~~

    <n ~
    ~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    NG
    I i5jQGfj

    ~)
    '~~

    f.hs

    ~<1 ~ ~'

    <Q<ffi:'i .2J~ ~, c<'f"tr!',

    JF9111 <r%1~ l!t~ f.j&\") ~ I h c\,::Jc~kl'iT'Yi?l (9\11~ ~, <!lW '~13


    ~
    1"1C1-i

    '~DJ'fffi C""~',
    0'1) '~'
    <;j"~

    m, ><i9(', "'1jCij(<i<1
    ~m
    ~
    '8~,

    : §iP;-r~r

    i1fiS~IU~

    ~fl141

    J;t(,~, ~

    11 firslH 2t'eRl
    ~~

    rsrj .?1B

    '<ffi1.._vrn1

    <J1I<11

    9(lib<!H"2[!1 '~' ~

    "I<1J

    ~
    ~
    "'3!l"l@!

    c<W!"~
    ~
    ~

    :;:j1'~C:'!l

    <!l'5 JF9l11 1>~ ~, ;;f)~

    vR
    ll'l"V

    Nrn

    Gl

    'Bffi"1i"<1 ~

    c<J .~

    ~ ~<1'

    "R<1J '1"4I,,\,::J!C'1
    'f?[<~

    I J'f'\~

    l:f.i~

    (BWl ~
    ~

    m, ~
    ~'

    Uj<l'ff<ff.

    9f'1\!)lf;i<f.'!li\3

    \5'1\3
    <;j"1~

    ~'l[ ~)

    ~m
    ~

    ~I.tp.z~

    irct>l1l'f"m
    ~

    \3 'Ti-~'t"1 \s\,::JC$B'J'Q.. '$TI I <Q~ <Q<R ~

    C\,::J1c:~ CiQ\!tI(flj~

    f.i~i'1 1>@
    \3)~

    I <Q~ ~

    I 'M1
    '5~l

    I (5iwnt"P ~13l
    ~

    ~j

    "l

    '>\~

    9ffn;'8

    \5l1<iG1iisjlVl~

    ff."F"'fTf.?:! ~ "R~
    '15l~'-"?l

    0<t <!l"<i' ~ @~'!l

    ~'!l"1rn~~1

    <£t<l'fG

    (}f«tl)';j I '? '<[

    'i'\-~
    ~9('Vfs

    ?ffrGs

    ¥:~<i'l,

    ~~
    \")\!) ~

    ~<>J?:G
    ~'<i'1l ~ j;!(.~~ I ~

    <iC"1f<:lr?g

    f~ ~,
    ~

    ~,

    \5l\3<Q'i <l'5 "'1'i<'l


    ~

    C<ij\b<f.'!ll~

    <l1~(,<'i~ '<l'lt4, <f.1<fc,*co.Q 131 "l"<1J I ~


    "'l'1Sl<1\'TI ~B

    01T"r ~'

    (~\?t<»1<{1~)-0f.'
    <fl \5fI~

    ~."Qum5j

    ~01<f (~G1<i'I'il1\3') ~! f\fvJ >,[~~"1m ~ ~~


    'q>@

    \5fI'8V'i

    C<f.'i~ ~ ~, (-fDr~)

    "'lIW>iq';'U<l1 ~

    (~1l~ <lwM ~.
    '8 2)<f<R<WR

    q'!l)'0

    C'1fi<i

    \5[1'1~1;j<» 'TIl)

    9flfG<M~

    \3 ~

    c<r~

    rrl~"MJ ~~:rOr~-@liG-~",~-~

    BM} ~

    c:R I \5fI~

    ~-~-2:j~<l:t;k'1'Ol

    rm:rr I <i'MlH I <m, ~

    C<f.{R~<Rfu ~

    ~'1>t ~

    41"1~ <WI I

    M '5ffGf,

    <!l1ll "'lTtV! <F11> ~


    t

    <>l1n50f.04

    <iic:tim?l1 open secret

    euphirnism

    c.!l<iR1M \£1"4 ~' <!!~ ~

    +
    ~

    -mi51~IT\bMq ~-'~'

    ~i?tc§

    <:j\5 ~~-~

    C1~ ~ ~f'1~

    ~-M
    :

    \5lB! <W0C"Ici{;Q '5I<rt~'t;m ~:~

    !\.bf.;

    '5j"~

    ~
    ~ ~ ~

    \31V3 ?\11<l~'
    <£1G! ~ 0 ~

    Q'lti ~ ~ ~ I \5If\b~'i1 <lG1(P1<i, '111 \5ff9j"ffir op<j '9j¥<t \5RBrIV1 RG'l <JfV'11' \£I'i)1Dn "''iil~ '~'~Q
    ~qlJ'i1fG~ ~
    ~I ~ Cjij ~~, ~-~-

    ~C1 ~

    B1"1' <R?I ~ \5l"41<:j


    l:{@

    fB:z.(.<i' "1N
    <!l<1"1> ~

    \5l"f"ffi\

    GhG1t~
    \5IBf
    ~~

    I!5MJ ~,
    ~

    ~~"<iJfGl".Pl <W1~~

    Pwn~ ~
    I '5!"UNC4 ~'

    1119fD> J'j~~~ c~8 ~ ~,


    7,d~ ~
    ~'1 (~

    ~ A!Qj ~)

    ~
    'B

    f.'pJo;{

    2l~f3

    ~-l:f.'l<rt'1-~'i1~

    9f1Th ~

    fo'lg
    \'5!TmfI

    (.<li!-

    <!l~ '\5I'(l\5

    <n
    ~~

    I <!!~
    J'j~41; ~?

    J'j~<f.G

    t· c { .(

    (jj'/
    U

    I p! ~
    ~ J'fl~

    ~7,<i>

    M>.jP')~j<i1 jlndividualistic c!1'¥z~-<QQ

    ,.,
    ~

    (.{bstract objectivism)
    <E'"-li~lJ
    ~ 'flr;:n{.9jR.~{,<{Q ~

    "S'f1~;

    m-r ~
    ~

    ~,
    r, ,

    ';F-:11

    m"<:i

    "S'f1~

    DM 'ii, ~ ~

    Wl ~
    ~

    ~
    .,.-..

    ;~bjeC~i~ism) "'it.!f1> I .
    ~ ~
    cQ<V<f. ~

    \5l1~

    ~()'K4 OlFI ~? '<.~<!'l"1(1S1~ ('1<ih(<i'i1 ~


    '!J.

    cqFf 'i1 05i I ~ 9ft\5i


    ~1<:fi8 <!!~
    8.

    <f'lt9

    <i>1"t;1c:t{'-?i'3;rn, ~ ~ ~

    ~
    I~ '<!l4'1>' ~

    ~-;n
    ~

    I~

    ~
    .(5'g-j

    <11Rv.J
    <TIl-

    'lI"l"R ~

    \9t~ ~
    m'<lrn
    ?il.

    1~-~

    9;1~, <U~; ?j\fi;

    c<J 9ft\5tlJ ~~
    ~?\'1 ~. 1514'hI.0 ~;

    ~-~-4N'!ili:S,1\

    ~m
    ~

    "lTc:~

    "Jj~qn9f ~
    ~ <i>~

    "Jj\G1i~' ~
    -.Q<pf5

    AGl~ \3r~
    ~
    ~
    ~'S

    (~9j0-) I

    \gP0~ \5l1t"l"<:i

    I Qi~t(\:~ 'J'j~~J.G'fi

    : ). {~

    >i1-'~101-~1.~
    't.

    ~;
    0-. ~;

    C'1l"PIrSJ\;

    ~"W;
    ~;

    A>m (~)
    01
    ~

    l]P0Q ~~
    ~-

    >3-rn

    d>t"l ~
    ~fG~j
    ~

    ~-r.?f1-m-~
    ~9jI% ?f1
    ~

    if. ~;
    )0.

    'b.

    "1!<.~ <fftfl; '<£1~>\<j ~ ~ ~~

    ~<i-~;
    'B

    ~N>01("N~ ~9ff3 ~ ~ Ff.? ~ <l"l"4, ~


    08f
    ~ ~ iSICG1 ~ I~

    '6i<llHC01

    't.dj1>1~11 ~ ~
    c!1Vl .•

    )). wn'4(t~ ~C"11<Jl1 'iT'lI~


    F-1(,t>~1~ 0i'l(

    )~. j=j'Z"j"l-~

    ~firl
    1

    ~ .

    '5lR>cdiif.$1> ~i:rf<:l

    1!rG"fivn~ 0
    ~

    ~~,
    ~

    <J~k "1'1ThCI!3

    'iT C'f.'1, <ilft


    ?\Q$ ~

    ft\:?!<i ?ffUf

    m~
    '~, c}J"1RG1<i
    <.Q~

    I \5lfm?i ~ (~

    c<l ~I::!C"114',~

    f~ ~
    '3~

    \5ff?\'1 ~. ~

    <mJ 8! ~

    f.1~,~?j1i1 m~lJj
    ~
    :l'j~ 'B~

    c~
    ~9f.1
    I'

    '5!N>cdflM><1' ~ MC~ ~

    <If:¥~b,* '0i''0h1~1~ (<llC1>

    ltR:>c~ 1«M..j ~

    cmm ~ ~
    0-5fll
    0f'f

    c!14'1> ~~,

    \5lR'Jt) ~ 0ffi'f ~
    c!1<1>RC~ <l>Q_I1~ I

    ~ ~
    ~

    05fE>
    \5J1'l ~

    t:>l'ZC~,

    1...<nWf ~

    ~
    c!1~

    ...
    <TIl CWlI

    <if <1>§: C'Fr " \5fi'1l"?r ~


    :q'0119f ~

    'm?i <£1<1> ~,£jSj~"11,

    L;1t:1> p.1 'li6f1vn~ ~<.rR-<il<i

    "4Qjj SJ~<i, '(Pi 9f\?1)

    c!1<rf<i f\bH'B ~

    -.:ro,

    GfK'i"f<1 ~<i

    ~'f!;.qrC'f
    ~fZb"l(.{;(4~

    -c:~
    '&R"i

    (~
    GI"i, @rr51~ <f.>i<i9'3 @f'i)'r.'f'if-"1 (<il~ @tt'>'M' C<!'lVff ~ ~~ c<lR.s( ~,

    Ff. n-~~

    W~ ~
    I 5j'~C4

    I£T.~ ~
    ~ ~9f

    QJ3I ~ 9J~

    zr.q

    cl~

    '3jjt<'l4W ~

    c;rn1 <l"l"41 \5ll'T1'<i c!1~

    Sft1~ '?f1?jG'j' ~

    metaphor-a }j~f.L;(4 CD"<if?i ~

    'm9fT\B
    ~~

    <1'?iC~ ~)

    00 HC~ ~
    '3 "S'fZ~ ... I

    >j1ic~~ ~
    "4@

    I \5IQj<f~,~-:l'j~%,

    ~-<m0
    C~ ~

    <lFi'

    ~ \5f.ll ~ ~""t;,<f <U1?fRl, ~


    -.rr.<1f'Z~
    C4? '3j9f@<i

    ~III$U'~Sjl~C~
    "'lJ\;<ll1R

    c!1~ <!l~

    '9f1Th'-C1>
    <:f."l?

    9f1\!:li 0f1 'Tt j'9f\W' (\5ff) ~ ~


    @ll'R

    <p)<lS 'iT ~

    ~?f

    <Jrml>t

    00~

    ~
    \5l~

    ~
    Q1~
    -.Q~

    ~
    ~.8.

    srrt<i ~

    '9J1"1'a1' ~
    \£Iff

    W
    :q~~

    ;qj I 2t~ ~,

    (\51) Vf 9(1"i~ ~ (i5RJ/'5l90)


    ~

    ~k<1'

    <iN ~
    >'j~~~

    ?f1'i)'G'j 4IH{,l'r~ '<f1V1>, "1M(~ ~ 'iT? ;ro I 0<i1

    (Jj

    .AmY

    ~
    {.l'f~?i<l
    'i@

    ~~.
    'iBf'11

    9jVf ~
    C~1?l> c<mf81

    ~~
    \5f)~

    ~~rr; <f0~~lFll
    W61'3 ~ ~
    ~(j'1(:'G$l

    ~:qC"1R~ Gl01~9J'Vf '1f"~ ~


    .:z(.fl~ C~

    I <.Q\:\5 \5l1"l1

    "4R, '\5f<ri'-~
    ~,

    ~-~
    ~

    ~iJ
    \5l1'"?i ~<T>>S7<i

    <m~'Ptm~TP'ffC0 GM

    <l)R<1'j<'Fil"<:i \5lPJG'I'---~

    f<kxi<l0
    i.'il8 <!!<1>R

    £1

    ~m

    .~

    :q1\iJ<j(trQlP'f1 >1~~9j-~

    "':iI'l(c~lfe;

    11

    ~<iJ

    ~""4i <lj%,<'SJl (full


    cQ"4"1>

    of sounds and I
    clW

    fury, signifying
    '"':iI,>\'\5' <!01 ~
    '-5

    nothing) ~ Of'Sm <rfc<T ;n' (non-discursive ~'c<'f1

    ~q
    'g'5f03~

    ~f\b<lf'1 ~
    (QJCf.

    R>'?£.i.\!)~1

    <rffi \'5iR"1"<:i
    ~ \5l~

    6Mif.1

    <iF~"ij<~TFf1

    ?Wl C'i)~ I
    <m9li~7,<i>

    formation) GP'i I '1i'~'

    %fi?;"i <i'tl:1>? <Ti~


    ~"1"(0

    W1-<!1C'ff"4Y<i ~

    0 <!5'<l1 \5l1>fQ1 J'j.r€ir<i..>jSJL'lF ~

    9f1«,¥~ '11, 01 '1G1'¥"1

    (<!l"f.1

    l1'Sl'!li~Gi

    jqU) MUI(::\ti_., ~

    M~m~ <:P'<l<1 <n:i-<w:'<l19f<f.:'<l<11


    "1~<n
    r-», '""

    <Q"f.1 J1~G'i1~ ~

    <rn on

    >'i~ 'l1'S)
    <rl~

    I '!li:(t"1

    '<nm'-<il ~~'1

    <Rfi <n1!,
    -;nj

    ~
    ~ H?l:i\"t ~ ~

    ~fil
    \5l-~
    4'@

    fi<f'jf.12i~~R ~ 8 1C\!}ffi "ITJ1 ~ ~


    ~,

    <TI ~-~-~ "R<1J ~


    ~

    ~)

    I <i!~. ~ ~

    c<P41? C"r<J' ~-~

    m<r'1
    ~

    <TI

    <Q<:PP

    <rrn,
    ~"'i"'?l

    ~'<f(-~-mm-

    <!1
    <n:i

    J'j"iJ'b'ri)<l'

    <l'<1iG'Sl"1 \5W1J1 I eil,":I'i1flB\'J/ei1f'8


    <r(p'j

    <l"1C<l"'10"..,_~'

    ~/~

    Heteroglossia
    <l)i<l''SlC"n

    I--.:rvi Qi~

    -e \:?1<1;flfib:::1 ~9(\')J
    C~-<.QQ

    'iliG'?(\Si?l ~ ~

    ~~:

    ~ I '?l-&4'il11

    ('!IN, I
    ~

    mcn-e

    fi1V1'
    9@

    ~"i~ C~
    <!l~

    i1<f!

    Q1 <w:'<l1"1<f.'<l<11 '\51<l1'i3IM<fi'

    <Wf ~
    <il~ ~

    '~'
    c<fi'l <il~

    ~,""lfri<;J1

    ~IN- ~
    C~
    ><j<Nj<l()k'1 ~~'':l ~,

    ~,
    <TI C~
    ~

    'i3[<f ~

    :>rr<R'h:r 00
    <flI1

    )'j~G1t~ ~
    \5)<rj-'1\,§'Sl \'iffi:~

    .~
    ~

    2imnfui't
    C~

    c<lFI,

    C''i~

    ~~

    r:§1

    L· ( .

    f2!G;C"1ISj\s

    C<ifi<f

    '

    'i3f<:j'9f"'?l '5M4J ~ 1fI~ .\5fIG'I1l1i ~ 1;l~{P1'1 "111 ~


    fibf.; <1"1("1"1 ,Dispotif ~-~ WjJ~ CJ'i~ ~? ~? <!I~ c'$'f-'5l"<l11

    \5lR ~

    ~-~m ~~
    ~ ~
    1fI~

    tW1

    \5f1<i ~

    V
    (I

    '{3\5?.zI1\5 QJ;l' C'$'f I\.'"

    IfIQ <i>qr-8~ C'i'{if( ~fG1t311 ~ <!I~ ~ ~ ~I ~«Ii

    \5l1"'?l '1'f-~
    -e~ ~
    <~'

    >j'~%311fi1(J1N"1~, ~
    '1"11"1 ~ <fl<l'('<fl1'!3t ~

    WI
    <Q~

    ~~/\:?('"1IP1'i\:?~[1ri "5i~om:?ffi ei~

    ~t~'1,

    (~'ZI~~~~~ '!l<lti ~<l'~ ~


    I~ "Kl1)

    ___ ~

    \5ff~

    C~<i'~o ~~ ~lZ.i'14ll> J1,i:'fIq-

    <Mi'
    I

    ~a
    <nN

    N ~~
    ~ ~7.if\1
    ~ ~

    m~~
    N
    ~

    <;J>'<l1<i0'l f.k\!)

    (Wf~~

    <TIf.W:r ~ 8~~ ~~ ~
    "1~

    ~
    I~ <:P«li-'WHll

    ~-f.Wpt

    <l''Sl(~~

    : <:P«li-@«'~

    !8i ('l'l1c:<T <!I'm C2ii\Sin:\:?


    '9j§<:j~'1'

    L'

    Gl1~ <r1 ~~ ~)---<.Q'm


    4'«Ii-~ 4''<fi-<wfiN <wfi<i~"1C<l'
    ~

    'c4li~4"
    "1:(<f '$l? ~

    2i-r.!r~I,

    <J1

    fi1V1 ~~-~
    ~ ~ ~ ~ I8

    >TIfl1'i3
    ~t~?
    ~

    ~
    ~
    ~ ~'

    ~?

    ~~<Y11
    1fI~ ~@j~

    ~9Jfi:\'5
    ~

    c<r"JC:~fl0P '5!-<t>'<f(~

    ;n-~

    '5fIf@, ~

    ~1<ffil (fporia)
    ~

    1fID1 :;J~<1"'l1l1C?11 ~~-'5lG!J..Q>~

    <.->'I~~"'i"'?l 1f14'

    I C<Pt'<l11i

    9fT<! ~~
    ~ 1flN <i0'l, \'51(;ql),

    J1'ZG'ffi."'i"'?l-.:mG? '5l1\!}¢l>I~ 1CG4"I, ~ C<ifb'f'!l ~ ('1f-;<1iD<1> ful1ll <f1~ ~'1" <1i\\?"1 , C'!l"lH '9f1~'----<!l~
    ~'

    <Q~ 4'«Ii-'Wl0

    :-$I \5l~Vl '\5[?8!' ~ ~ <!l<m'l' !@1<i ,¥G4(iOl,? '3l~

    ~ <nN
    (~ ~

    <!I C~>i'!?J\!}m?

    <il~

    ~'<!3ffi!
    ~"#iT

    ~ <TI<f! ~ ~«'9fi'R

    ~? ~C~'?l
    ~

    \5l!<f1f 4''<fi-'Wl0 4''<-~ ~ <:fI~ ~qP4>C\!) 4'qt <l'~~

    ~'{3m

    cqN '1t
    \5Gf{i'iG'j ~'

    \5f1I"11 Q1
    "11H{}l <n'(;<jl I
    c<Mif(

    <i''<J1-

    I '1!fo'l ~ CJ'i ~

    \:?l'1C\!) ~ <:P«li ~ ~ CJ'i<fl~

    @«,~

    "Kl1} ~

    <iI ~
    4''<l1-fl

    on I
    4'@?

    1<1 ~ f.T\5"'?)
    ~~G119N3 ~
    ~Z"1,

    !t1

    :... <r'f<:<!> \\?


    <Q~

    <!l~ {'<ifib<t-'?lc.'f 'Jjql~'-'{j' if('j\:? 9@

    WM ~
    ~.

    f.if~~' ~
    '<j~ '{3~

    ~
    Z"f

    ~;
    i~

    1"l-<!l~

    ~
    ~-e ~
    <'1~G'j ~

    @~9Jm

    ~<>frn 8<fl~

    f~~l~,

    M<lU11}'("1 "Rl1}

    <l>j~

    CZ\SG4l~

    TRP~

    '9f1~' "1(;"11

    <filwP I
    <il~
    @~~-<;4]~

    ~«, <fl'Fi C=<J:c:<i'

    ~-<fiG1t-~

    J1'{ffl"'i ~

    6flT«!

    *t
    <r1

    'mv.:r'
    @«,~

    ~<f!

    C9fDT-e "<jJi\'5 <;J>'<f(~

    :Z"1~I
    ~

    1"l ~, ~
    <j'l@? ~

    <fi'<fi <1"1'1 ~
    ~ *<1"1~11?i'?l

    4'Qfi <rc:G4

    \5f1"'?l ~?

    4'@?

    '\5f1!jJ<11"
    <P'?l<f
    @(~

    "Kl1}

    ~'
    ~,G:,

    ~,

    '<5fi11M' \5I'fI ~? ~

    ()3j \5l981-R ~GJ\!) I

    '5l:?f1"

    {<i> ?-6iC'P

    m ~?

    (!!j~QMl 9f~ ~

    ~'f3
    m~

    *t

    4'@?

    ei1f%
    ~

    ~'ZG1T9f <!I~ @«,9fI'11i{ ~

    -e ~

    9J'W5 ~

    "6'B1
    J'j'\il"11 <Pl~

    <il'4' '5lfib4'i'0

    C. C

    o (

    (?) ~,

    Q<fl"Gl ~

    't\ialogue :~

    \~ithO~t l~anipula;ion'
    '3l<i

    ~1r.n""'?l ~

    ~P1'c.<,j tc.<l'J'B.

    <!I1'Qfi, '3lZ

    ~~'1"
    Oih'l\')i1

    C\:?C<!I~Cif(" <i>'<l1-I519QJ1)
    '5!-~

    ~"R

    (Discourse
    ~

    :>rr~ ~~

    "!<:lJ<l01

    ?(~
    , ,_/ ~

    CD'm
    Gn~

    m
    ~

    ~i~~
    \5ll)jJ'1l @ot?! ~,
    &(9 ~

    0Ui\W1
    'i3~

    m I ~'
    ~ ~ (!<!'t<P I '511~

    "'I~

    C<n<m"1' 9f"'?l CQjV{S-<i~


    ~

    CD'm

    <ffill ~ C~'t<P ~ ~

    ISj'W4'<) C~<TI

    '5l:1V'f9f1v'l ~

    ~R>f~<:j81'!l

    ~-6Pfif.T"1'

    {non-discursive
    '5fI?l~

    formation)
    ~ I

    1'ff9ftil1
    \'3riif(~

    I \Qi"1'rn 'ijT1JJ \5Im

    Wz; ~.
    ?~

    ~-~
    9flv~.1 ~

    '~'

    '5l'i"lm ~
    ~i'R'i"1 ~~

    f.TI;\5 9fffil: .~.


    (State ~~)

    "1G4C~"

    Apparatuse)

    <fi'<fi '?pressive
    <r1'!?i1ii1f-;'1?1<l'

    <r! '5l<1kj"1<1"lG4?

    (C<l~",

    '{3 ;de010gical

    ({.<!''IT"'1, ~

    L'Y;! t, c-

    I '&i1JJ'5j~

    ~1!"'1TIl
    'Wf[

    ~1Fk'~

    '5l'@i ~7.if\1

    "<Jfib?l M ~

    ~(.~ I <i>l<i '4'1"<1 '5fV3f ~

    \5A ~~

    I '5l'i)'Sl1

    C1?l', C1' ~

    ~TI c<1't\'5 9f@ f<i; 'YJlfu '11m-m-~-.lrli1-m-f9fV1-Bffl:-

    0R.-<!I~i$<

    9f!M<lIf11' <n;g@j',
    '»~'xf(;?jiU ~

    ~
    ~

    ~9f"i';TI ~,
    9jGI5~

    Wl1'B"

    <QG1 ; '5fi'U-\5fffiOTI

    '-'1~

    <l(."'l11(X'!l ~~
    'qn-j9f'? r:<f"1 ~
    .C<j~~?
    <Q~

    .~
    ~

    ~
    ~,

    '-'1<R ~ll

    '\':)I~0'HJ', ~

    \5fI~

    fu

    <Q~ ~

    '5G1"1'J <.tn~1tt?t ~ _~
    ?tGq'1f '54~

    cen',i11?

    <1>~C~ ~ ~ ~?

    .:zl.m.~' ~
    z;5 I

    o'3fdic<i>F'l ~

    f.WM rrN3m?1

    1tJ ~
    c..--

    .......

    '51<fl1>1

    "@9f'
    1"1' ~

    <n

    ?M:

    2il!:! ,¥dlC"'1'l, '~ 9f1<l" ~ ./I'/!m? ~


    ~?
    '~'11'Q[j

    ~
    \5jQj<lj

    ~:V'1Pl'"l

    \'lff'<[1'f1
    ~

    w,f1:;c~?
    ~?'

    ~V1? :!'j~OO

    <l~11
    ~

    (.''i'cdl ~~ <n~

    "(11"1"(i'Sm1

    ~.

    '~I~II,

    ~~~,_ 9fjf'11-~n:

    ~ ,~,...._ ~' ,~, '<:31"'1 1:11"11"'1,<QtJ11 1'1ltkZ!1~I<l~ ""~I""I '5481((\01


    ~ ~'iJD-j

    c~

    <Q'dI ~

    GT19fI'-!l'-!l <ff~TWf qfum;t

    M8J ~
    ~? \5l<ff~ 1
    <Q~ ~~

    ~
    '54]f;j. ~ <r~
    .zi1f10iMl'

    I <Q~ fuQ_>GI'54@l Cq~

    <wlG1, \5fI<m'r \58 ~


    <Q"R)

    ?fM19f1M /I\dli9f
    \5(;<1 ~ ~

    ~t'!
    l<j<>f-iFz~\Yl1

    (.<l>

    '5I<rI~ ~-~,
    <Q~ ~

    f.W:! "lfu ~
    ~

    c"i&

    C\5I
    ~?

    \5l3i, (\;'<31I*=' , <::~*=', ~"i"jl?


    i5l<rl Z'S,

    ~'-!lJIf.1 \':)1fi11' ~

    I 'C\5flmI

    c'-!l!'1i ~ <lfi1 ~
    c<Fl ~

    ~p <l5'-Wl

    f. "-

    ~
    m~?'
    <Q~

    ~? ~ R-~

    <!It'! f.T- 4'9\··ll<'1 9lf'f3?


    \5jlc"tWH ~1i.lIf\bM1'
    Wl'oi <Q~?Fff ~

    2i~

    "U:~'S

    ~'1

    -::j'-//I-9fi':l1S
    ~';

    m <Q~
    ~-~

    "1fuC1l~
    ~

    ~
    ~

    <Q"1' ~ ~

    \':)1"'1~~ '5l"Ji<Q"1'\5Ifu~s

    '~-f<Km~',
    \5IT.<l" "i~

    'R~'-!lI<lI1fl',
    1'$!t'\5

    Dlfdi8Jffi:"1i:J
    ,zjj)~

    I ~ifl\5<l({
    1~ ~

    m
    ~

    m "?fWf\5

    @'>j~j:b

    :!'j'1'U 1 \!iTI~ <Q~

    "i~l"1iC1'~

    'JnRN'
    (.\,:)'-!lC~

    I <!l1t~CISIS ~,

    1!l;tOSIS ~
    Vi"'l~~

    ~-~
    ~

    :2l"f1Jf'IC'-!l \5"<1<1 J1~'iJl'-!l


    \5"<1<1

    >!(;:lIMQ?:I>Gl'
    I

    ~'-Gm
    'MM}1'-!lrWi\'
    <Q<fi

    c?f1<l· fl

    ~
    <QW

    \5ll~

    m'Z ~
    1'8l

    "'1F&~ <WSf, ~'-~

    '1'lBll'(5H

    1 \5j··UM(}'P ~ ~'-OM

    "l1iT
    >iV>f I

    <Ql:1'Q 9f?l

    ff0
    C\5l?

    Qf0 ~
    ~-C~

    ~1'(;'!l1))~1 ~
    .~ \5j9f1-~

    ~ ~
    ~~

    '6\'i,1'1'1 ?f111'f'-!l ~-~

    <QtJ11 ~

    J.11&i ~I1'\!) \':)1r:1' ~~m/21~


    f.'Ief ~
    \5R1 ~ '54'<f\'Z, <Q~~t<'l
    ~

    i:fIOIG1 ~ C9f'<l '1'1&.1 ~


    ~ .~ ~

    ~I

    9f1'i3'11~~ 11;g; <r<r.=l ~

    ~~fVit'

    \5q;j

    <Q'1, ~11Nf.1

    ~1"1?! C\5I '5[['>! /I\G1fC?t 'lTl\51-kk"Q '54TC'>! 1'~

    c-mr!
    1f@!~

    G'<!?:1' ~:~

    m'Z 0'1 zv.t


    ~ ~ ~

    ~I

    ~f\!,<lrm
    (<Q"i~ ~~'S

    ~~
    <QtJ11

    ~ ~

    ;rn, "T11Ic:1' ~

    1'(1

    m~

    ~
    MAUll'>!
    "IT:~

    ~
    1,<\':)~n 'il(»('~1

    c~
    <Q~

    fol-;1 ~
    ;n ~
    ~
    <!l~ '-'1~

    :2l-~

    \5fI~1

    <m~ <n~1

    GJ1Wj "1''lj1 <lt~

    <m9f1~ I mlo1
    <Q<NG :!'j~L<I>

    m'Z~
    (1'!lfG'j

    VlR>1'~ ~
    "'"l19f (~
    I5lBRrn ~

    ~
    ~
    <Q1Ji?! ~' ~

    '!iTI1'S ~

    1'G
    _"1'5('''']. ~

    ~I
    ~

    '11~ \58 ~

    ~~
    \5j9f1-

    lK'4J

    ~TII "to
    ~

    '<8fI51 1'G) ~
    ~~

    G2iP!clSf4j~
    '<ff~01t',

    <fd>, ~
    \5lJR5I~
    ~1! ~

    ~9f"i?-~~
    <q>l<,~

    'Glffl'i5lt<l:
    \5jic~R1'1

    /I~'<i1i3

    0'[(,~

    1'C"1iM ~

    '1''-!lGI'!iT-<n~C'fI?

    'B1Wm-~
    ~ ~

    00 :~
    ,""o-'W "i1@

    <Q1' I <Q"i\ '5M"1~

    ~~I9f

    C'<!?:1'

    ll7.\51

    <n~:rW!, iffl <n"1',


    ~400
    '3~m

    "i\5i\"l

    ~,
    'i_'GH ~

    ~""G~Jlf~~1
    <Q\Z i51<fI-'6\ic:<1-T1"i(f11 ~

    '1'im3 mutual C'5iG1 ~

    "i1@, ~

    <11;gtfc1 ~-J51'i)~f$

    (<ffi:<lS

    <WI
    ~

    m,
    ~

    intelligibilary) ~o-~o "']'\51\"'11 "5l<!1' 'TI~ \5lB[ P,(G4jt-oi'1J'>l'TIc$


    <Q~ '5l<rl-m"1l:1' '5l<rl ~I ~ C~
    \5f1i{~

    1'1<f~

    '3 ~
    1

    'l<R ~

    '<11\011'1 '%9f'\51~

    ~1\51~
    ~

    ;rn,
    i51<fI

    ~
    ~ \51 ~~?1

    ~
    ~~
    I~
    <Q1'<ffi1

    ~
    ~

    ~m
    9j'ffi1'1 ~
    1

    2l<IT<Rl lmagiNATION-1'rn'-!l ~ <l'I~"l~'~ ~ ~ ~ ;n 'N.~~ ~ ~ ~, \5<R ~'Z~ <Q1'1J1 ~


    nation-~
    C1'<l ImagiNATION

    (.''1'r''11'i~m

    6M"'1~

    ~-m1=;fi'

    '-'1~ ~

    <Wl1
    ~
    ~,

    '1'0I-~'-!ll"'1f

    ~9f1<-~"<lI1 '11"""11"1 '3 (.1111'-!l"l ·i!~<lIC;t;.q


    '5l<rl-"'~ 'S ~\G'-!ll
    'I:)

    ~~

    2li1X!i, ~_

    1~fi5~1 <IBn
    ~

    '>j!.~ffi.G1I,_"i$i

    <1G1R
    ~nit(.'-!l

    "@9f' .:zC"'1'"1,~

    I '1'''1'1'1%11 'T'1"1"1 ~~ '1:Z1{j\51f! C\5T1 ~ i51<fI~


    .

    <p!8~'5i1

    m
    ~

    ~f
    /'

    cqM,

    '-'1"1' ~

    'Z:G\g~ ~
    9f?l ~, ~

    c<r<'1' ~ '~~-GGtl'
    ~

    ~
    ~I

    '>iW

    furc'ijpf-Wc"1Pi ~

    l<l1-1jJf?:T6lH;
    9i~

    <Trn C1'j:m
    C9j~I~~

    C~
    ~'1

    <Q~

    \5~\5

    m1=;fi' '5l<rl1 "IT:<1J

    /11311'1 ~

    r:1'lli:-21m

    ~~q>~('1~

    . '3~ 'l:)4C"1I"1' c<f'lfo11'1'G<Q>IM GMI-~1t1'


    1'(1

    ~,

    "l'i,-?'-::?I<:1i><]\!)1' ~

    Pl> C1'iU1f

    ~?

    (.4@~ ~ ~?

    "f>'f.:1

    <iR, fW

    ,,:]'01'0

    ~-@<nC<f' 9iifu:-'l'i'Sl<1''''1i

    ~9j1R5 <l<j~ "ilG<i

    c<lISI~

    I ~~

    <n o$t? ~
    ~,

    ;n

    2f~

    'bj<fll:J ~I_<li-~

    f\b:1'~i<:jhl ".~1t-9jt;'Jj C"<'fC<j> ~

    \5~

    \51

    Mother

    Tongue

    \54f~<f!-~
    'tQ~~

    C'>\\!5, -;n-~

    '5fl11 051, ~

    ~I"

    c<1>lVi! C41BI

    ~l'8jN®~ '5fl1:il~
    rem(a)inder

    2)"»:! '¥tC-iC~'"l,
    q>$;~i

    f<i; ~

    P,,!-~~-C'f"f ~ ~
    ~ ~

    <l1!h"l' N~

    ~
    'W<Tl~

    c<nt ~
    ~

    '3~\Fi1

    '3~ '5l<r1l:! ~

    '39f4l ~ <fl~
    ~ L"~ ,~

    \5IT@f9f

    '51-I:?,<l,jl\!)1Ri4 "<J>1Qt'f ~'

    ffi~?

    C'fil81

    \5"RFTI-~"1'?! ~ '5ll'i:IT?!
    ~""?f

    f-i8c4
    '()'fflJ' ~

    \!ifff-r ~
    •

    <rJ1~
    ~H~R>~ ~

    o:rr-4f1:\5 9fj~f.i ~<>ffl'3 ~I


    ~
    ~
    ~

    ~?

    <Q~RAz ~?G1!'&iiJ-\5fI~<n

    "\5411:fr1" "ftBl ~

    om-\5I"U-~
    '5I<rl

    ~ @:FF'! ~
    tQ~ ~

    ~\!)
    'B

    ~ \51<l~I~i'1 ~
    ~

    o <!G'\2)TIff9f

    '5fiN?f\'5J
    J'j~~~

    m
    ~

    '>!fu I "'41~
    ~!P-C"l'8t'1'
    (~ " ~

    m~
    ~

    <hbi-:n
    ~~

    ""1'finxl ~ ~

    ~, ~ rnT<l1

    C'i'B<TI B1<ml ~""?f


    '5f\5<.!1<f ~ ~

    cd~!8),
    <is@

    c:st~
    ~, ~

    ~'lfIJ

    c\!)rn ~,
    ~~

    G'ft"iG'i1
    ~ ~

    <f>QftlJ
    1;j~(,dj

    tQ~

    "05f519f1f~ <Q~
    ~

    ;qft;, ~ ~

    "iG'fi ax;"!
    ~-<.!1~

    B1 WI
    ~

    zrn'

    '&i'Bm

    I" ~ <Q<fi1 \5fi~ <f>.j3~ 81 ~~

    <.!1~

    >i::I.>i::I.

    ~"''-1iUBl
    ~

    ~<rr
    ~m!

    I '~'
    <J>G1-'1_~ ~'

    f.k~ VP'R (jGt ~


    (expansion)
    '3 ~9jB ~I

    C'fo'1 tQ;q;fIT <.!1;q;fIT<f>.j3~ ~,:>j<{d1~

    m~
    "l8
    ~C:MI_ ~~

    2)<fi1fi'R:; ~----t.~r<l>m

    <f>.j3~

    *(
    I

    ~~'1
    "~

    ~OfW ":>J1?1N"1li
    0 C'f<I ~ C~

    ~-0f0l

    \!)1i\;40i!1

    4@ 1

    ':t~fili'1

    4'<11 ~
    tQ~

    <Q~

    ~<l>1C1C~~ ~

    1!8 ~

    I~

    \!l'<}<l'~

    m~ ~
    ~

    on? ~
    C~

    ~
    \5MJ'0

    ~1<lIN<BF'l>
    \5R.G1i~1C<l ~ I 15{<li\!)(.'G'?l

    liBl"ff?
    "~
    ~
    ~<j

    need-demand ~ I

    ~~ ~ "!~C\!)
    "ll~RctQ"?f

    9fTI'<11<iC\!)'fTlflj>\!) ~
    ~
    <rri'9)'<p

    cQm ~ ~ ~
    9j~

    desire-<Q~
    '5~'B

    M"i
    ~

    ~fJl:?i<1"fi\B~l~ ~"

    C<Pi~<qliN~tr<f

    gfu; <r<R ~
    \5l1'8f ~
    <Q<f~~

    \5Bl <mj~ • i;fjR>?1lc$~

    <fRW11 ~

    <.!1~ ~
    '61r.<'lq>\{oi<i' ~'

    m]
    ~

    9j1'3~

    \!il1'<1'ffi:

    C<r'i'3t <n';fR fiR ~~,


    <ili;1-C9fc1? ~
    ~'1_~

    '1 '0'If-C31''1 9f<:f ~l1'\!)

    ~
    ~

    ~---~ ~

    m ~'Gt
    ~
    ~'i
    '>\\!5~

    ~
    ~

    m~
    I ~

    \'5ft'm'?l ~ ~"n.l1
    ~\ ~"l'"?f
    cQ~

    en~

    9fIf~
    iW19fc1 ~

    2)'5f<! ~

    '5'<R ~

    \!)i'1C<l" ~ '5F"K\!) ~I<rc:\!)~ "S18 ~


    ~ ~

    <Ji'G~ ~~
    qiQj"j ~

    <r>Qf11 '11~R\1(\!)

    <fSdj)'ti-~
    ~ (''if.\!)liliol~, "l''<lI <Q<q~ ~

    C"'lV''loi, \5W3 '!5IWI'8!"l\!)I?1 ~

    <Q~ ~

    \54f((Gf"lm
    cQ~ <l>@

    t(

    WID ~

    m~
    ~""?f

    I. ~

    W!~

    ~'f?

    ><iml <Fl"<l1 <n7:<t ;n ~1<ff?l 2l~ ~


    I

    k
    ~

    <m9fR, c<R'ii INm 05i

    fu.G1

    :~

    I 7.tM~1J ~

    \5i'3m'Q:m 9frn,
    ~~ ~

    D'lf ~~
    1'f~

    erm ~

    ~rm

    ~~
    'm:<f) 9f'G~

    WID 1flWl?'i"

    Off.<f

    :qof.n ~
    ~

    'c<r.1'
    '~\1'\!l'

    mr~

    ~"1Bl

    <r>@1

    : ~~,

    ~,

    f9j><j)15 ~\!)J1rq '5l"ilSJ\!)(Y11 :?j\5 c'<f<:<f>


    (-Q<l>qM

    cQ<Wr

    ~~<lll1

    '5f'31JiQ:m C';f@ VTV1 C'>Wi ~ ~ ~,

    C'<f<:<f> I ~
    '((Moij,

    \5f1m ~? 'lI,

    ~
    ~-~~ 'SlE<1J

    ~~
    ~ <fl'"R1~

    'qfuf.hH"'?l\5'
    <rro<i'l""?f"<l1'11

    ~lG1t}
    ~
    Z]05

    ('<f(J'l>

    <®: 4m) B01zq;

    <l'it!'{J ~

    C"M '5'<R I ~

    <Q~ "fr~'l>I~~
    <f@j,

    17mi~R?j \5ic:<!> c<f?::l:! $fj~t'3 ~C<1~ ~

    I <il4 ~

    '5'Pfl-~\~~
    1J1Q

    <l>1~"f'r
    '5j>.j37Fi ~

    1J19\'BW1 ~-.:rrn ~
    \QM

    <¥'t

    ~'?

    '\5i

    05i

    6flTri
    ~

    (<rf~ <%ffiI

    \!ijt."lJ 9fii1 ~

    \5f1m
    qi~ ~

    C9f@

    ~J
    ~

    <Q"?f?G1~

    mR1\'j~

    f<ivn~ ~
    \54fb>jRi1dj<l>~rc:<r ~ <Q~ ~ ~I~ ~Z~

    ~-CGfo1-~~)
    ~"1~

    ~ T'
    !?_~ 1 ~

    ~
    It)\!l<'lj,

    <.!1<fZ ~~

    -&jq"i g<>fOl9f, ~

    c<M" tQl'?l'1>01'?l I
    ~,

    ":>jt<m~ '31 ~
    (\i5j

    m~E~ eJm ~, C\!)~H ~ mm $.WI I 'C~


    ~
    cQ>j7f

    ~t}111'5l1~)j<T ~,

    ~~1<l,jl\!)C~41
    iffil

    \S3R9fRJ @li9fTG

    ;n ~?'

    \51'V3

    \5fi~
    4~

    R<118
    '5lf6:>jGi-,~dj,* ~
    "'S ~~

    i '21f0 ~:zj'Z

    9fi'B<:Jm ~9111? "<mI,


    ~

    I~ I' ~ ~

    'W1, '<r>Q)t 05f '5\7.G'l1


    '5jj2)1"1 ~,

    <m<f-"?f~
    9j~ ~"i

    '<lff.f <:5T!"lI<:f 9Jc:'l? ~ 0<IG'f1 ~ qH'¥\!) ~ ~


    >f1'1 ~ I ~

    "

    C\'li <iBl1'>f '6i<ffil" q;-~ ~ ~"1!?<1> "~ <rJ1~


    <.!1~ I '~1C"1r

    \QM '5l1~

    <i>'<J1 ~

    I "<{>'<11 <l"1C\!) ~

    eDt, <i"*'111 CtM"1j(.4: xf'!1 f.1nl '{)!~14 <fl"<fSJ ~

    m.. ,

    \5!<rm e<rr<m<!Br
    ~'Sj

    ~ ~ ~

    ;n

    I eJ~

    \.5In'~'-fzf1 ~"'6'-fz~
    '5l\!)J~

    ~ ~

    <Wi>J"1m ~
    hWll

    '5l<n '<iBl1"!'

    I5Pfi <KPl ~

    !8)

    ;n I

    '~'1'

    m~

    ~'4mZ"i

    ~c:\!)~ "'lIB 0

    c<J 1«q,,*-\SjtaJ~, \3l""?f 'Sll~

    '3~

    <l'<R ooS1 ~~~~

    ~
    ~ ~

    <ro: <ro: ~
    (15l9f 8li9f <j>'<I1 ~

    C'1>c'G C'f<ff <1fG'i<!ib5iOt<l


    abstrac. ~

    ~ <<!iG1i<1ii9Jo11·G1;~1) 1.!.1"<j"~ '5!(:~ tjonj-~ I mr,"1 05t ~ <j>~


    <!1'lfol 05"(;\§"[C?l 1.~'1"l"3 ~@f8l
    ~ 9;~ ~

    ~l:!tnalytiCal

    t- c /

    ~
    ~

    '011"11'

    lWIl

    "1\~
    ~
    I

    <Q~

    1i'1-<.IRi<i''!llt'1' <i>'<I1 <rii!t

    '<%SiC'!l

    ~~'-<!1?1

    "1 C'!l I

    2ilR>\!:>II<l;q; ~ \5110& ~ ~
    ""

    C'5t ~ %IT:9f'lf.1
    05"(;@f8l

    1R<rJ '{?'!:f iJf<ff "<j"j ~

    m~ ~
    <Ji@ ~

    (~
    I~

    ~
    \5'>i<Wl

    0fM <n 1
    ~

    <l''<I1-<f.1'19: <j>'<!1 ~

    C'31 eJ'yf\!,-<2l\5nJ ~
    ?B! <lJj-q>''W=f<l" ~ ~),

    vR1:ft~
    11"'1(,'1
    ~
    _h. '""

    >t,,?C<J>1

    \"1 '@"1CGI).1
    I

    c!i~ 'mtl ~

    <11 ".i1i<1fi4-q><j>~

    c<RI <1@1
    ~

    c:<!
    <j>Q{j

    '~'1Rf 1 \511fT\ ~<11(!l1~<i'11 <!I~ ~

    (~-~-~-2i"3J1J
    (~

    '31. ~

    <jG'ffii ?f@ <fI", ~<Q~~?

    C'fGm
    ~

    c!i~ ~ c!i~

    ~Ri ZlI'!l.l"1 '!l 'iil1J1 ~


    ~"Il"'6

    f.ID1<r"f
    (.If""<fj'6

    \5I'<f!«.. '~"<)TIl'
    C~ C'!l~ ~

    <fI <>t@ ~

    0illI)

    1~

    ""1"$1, ~t1 \5!iC"1~


    'Z"<l"'5

    ;rn, 9fW ~
    I.!.1<fiB ~Z9f1 Q,\1l~IG'J

    I "<!!~ 9fW ~
    ~
    1

    ~1!
    >TC~

    r.~

    ~:i
    firQ.)J1 I
    ~ ~-<Q<.i

    1.!.1~ '&"1"

    <Q'lfol ~Qj"j<j"

    m-~1~-~
    ~ ~
    \5I1t9f }j"lI~15 ~

    f.:u.6f<Fi'i'1

    <fI0'l>1 ~
    i"51@Rf ~
    'B ~

    4{'18:C'"1"11 c:<! ~

    fik?1~{.iij"1 ~ ~Z~ >fiP1Ji fu:iil <n ~


    (7j

    1~

    '51~ "111

    f.t'<lJt1 ffi '1i Jj~"f ~ c!i'lfol 2i<p~"1i c!i~ "l~ \51f<i411l'1 ~


    ~ (\'iI-)<p~ c!i?! ~ ~
    ?j~
    1

    \5T?J"5

    PlQ.)J1 ~

    \5l~G'J'.ii"1"1I<QI ~'1!zMc!i~

    ffivJ
    ~

    ";1{.~ JK""lZ ~ ><f!f <n~


    ~
    1

    "l'<l1
    ~<:f

    f.T8l1 .'311i<>l<l"
    <l'@? ~

    'X1l1'l-'X1li'l ~
    ~<:f"11,
    c!i~
    ~-<:j~

    I <Q<fiB M'Y"!l 2l1Ccrn.. .'~?J'ii

    ~<1\11 1.!.1'TG m«(

    <l1<!>J-~2J
    ~ ~

    C~ (~

    ~
    ~, 1~-

    H'1'C'!l<l

    i%:1
    ~ <Q~

    <Q"9 ?-~q;

    ID" <l"b<-ii.1 (~
    ~ ~

    W
    ~I

    <JF1~

    \5IQ)" ~"t

    ~V'M ~ ~) ~

    "tV>f<l"
    ~

    <Q<fiVl 6i19f1 ~ '1\i@jQ)" ~

    mli ~ erm">lM
    ~

    c!iW<l "Jf1<Am 9f'<t ~9;~


    <Q?!

    ~j(:"1 <r1Vf.J 'C'{

    <rn, ~

    ~Z~'
    ~

    <j>'<Jt ~

    \5I;sj9fP11<:R) 1 \5lG",!<{(3~ "IBf<J" 'If


    I

    "I'~

    <r1 om?TI
    ~\5j"'q3G'f

    \5I1G1l'fj-\5I1G1l"lti ~:Z"1,
    <Q~ ~

    <l'@ ~~'6

    'If, <fiV1'J'B 15l~<:f ~


    formation)
    <!iQ{j :z!\("Hfl1J ~.

    'If ~~

    <fit! cQ<WJ ~~:1j-<r1


    \5ll~
    1

    ~
    c!i~

    fz!i.G*lG {'3'<Jt<!Sf~

    non-discursive C'31 (~I~


    ("'<flU ~

    e!<Jlf.k'!l'B

    \5I~l:j
    '3G ~

    ~-~-""Jl¥fl
    ~ C\5l1 ~
    1

    ~CC4erCG1 <Q~
    ~ ~

    <j>~iT "<JG1I ~
    >'i~;.£Q;(.<j> <:f1~9 ~?

    'ffiJ, ~

    '1'Z1:
    :(_$l?

    <!1m
    b~

    Sl"1l">l&\ C~
    {I5"i1 <Ji@ ~

    'P11~ ~
    ~ ~

    11
    1

    ~,

    <n-~,
    I

    \5rr~r-:;l:-c<T~

    ~
    ~

    ?If' )) :J1 (/ L

    \51f.'\C'!ll'Q \511~-H'!lJ'!lrn QTIT1, ~

    C<J1<r ~n
    <Q~ ~ ~

    ~~~ ~

    1.!.1?! ~.'~' I "fi<1~-2if\b\!:>j$J

    'B-lt)
    <lJ<J:(_IN<ll

    <im

    NGJ

    <!l<F c!i~

    f;1f.fQ;
    D.!t'

    'B ~ C5'f

    ~<rf@

    c<M
    $_

    c~,e..,-. I~

    1'1(.~ ~

    '5 3~

    $l'ifli1(31 C"'il"'(<..'!l

    "'f0CG'I c!i"f<1 ~">ll$l J'f1<Rii1" ~ ~ ~ ~


    ~)

    <l(pf~. c!i~ ~

    \5lf.hJ'!lfC<l' C'1'lf.it<1I5I?11

    \51l9;[\5-f.i'!ljGi?1

    \5l'<ll5 ~,
    <Q~

    ~,

    <l1"t~)"1 ~
    <l"1("!l ~, (15lBf "Jf1~
    \5"%1 ~

    c~
    QT\'!'I"... ~ :?!lffi

    <ffiJ

    \5~

    c<J ~
    1 c!i~
    9;'"R

    >51'!lj'0 ~\~

    ~Q"K<i 2J'!lJ'lf.

    ~~<:i:f~?1

    '&l<l"?fl Z$J, '!lll'!l


    ~ 9fR'?

    '~

    1.!.1 Wi.-2il'i,

    <>R~~ 'b!f\;"1<1~~
    05(;\§ ~

    ;:5m '<ftR'-<fI!1 Rm"f ~


    <t-1<JJ/>ilR'!lJ<l>i \5lji;,~

    \5IiijZ~-"liGl!
    ell1J ~~, ~
    <l'@ ~

    I \5IG'l '@«..?/fu

    11"fffi ~

    ~,
    9f1~

    '.
    ~

    <j$'.j"1{1·"·P1G'J

    <rn,
    ~~

    '<ftR'
    ~

    (~-?! ~/~

    <;<If.:r ~
    C~ I

    ~
    ""1"11 ~cf ~~zfu<l

    '1)'di"1' ... 1 ~ ~
    ~~

    t>C..Q>'1

    f.iiq%>j\m
    ~, Ciil1<JS \5l1V'R,
    j'f~3~

    <rn) ~
    '3f"l ~
    ~<ft(;9j

    c<J \5I~"!l'lf-"1'1 ~

    C~
    f.T8l

    \5[ \51<17i

    '5lfi1<JS11l ~Q[.

    ~z
    ~~
    ~

    ~1ZM'1i
    ~

    \51f6'i<l~~n
    9;~

    ..fIR>ZlI<i~~
    <:rcii! ~
    <Q~ <l"iij"<J"

    Wr ~
    ""1"$J

    <i'C~"1, "l~

    '5lf~
    9fI';{ ~

    ~<m:?l

    'QI1i: ~
    ~

    \5l"f~
    ~<ffi1l

    c!i~ N<!('"1I~

    ?iT1"<J c<T \5l 1

    I~

    6i9(~~"11

    (Jf<11

    0lllM "lJ1?!"BW1

    C<JIqfj

    m, ~
    <il~,

    <rnF!

    c<J ~,

    C6f111i~ I.!.1V1 CiilC'>1"VZ/: I


    <Q~

    "11'81Ji1" l>l'rl ~

    ~<fr'111l

    ~~'?z ~

    ,¥<J<1 (!f[iij, rn_1YfI"G'f \5l1"VZ/: 1 ~

    /.

    ~~z111
    <m'1'~~

    "R'31

    «r;nRb<:<f'~
    i51<iI'!l\~~f

    <i5l~

    cw.9f

    C~14

    <j<P<J<J>~

    fir~
    <F"1I<1I~r~ ~

    ~~
    ~I f.iC$J ~~

    ~.1:r.

    c!i~ '1J<1-<.dfi"" (c<T~


    '6

    ~%i~'1' ~

    frr.'l) ~

    'l"lw" \5Iif.:!
    ~~~~?

    GI 'f<l~i"i'"l' ~ .. ) ~ "11,<.f!l"3

    <.f!"<j"Z <m"1Wl

    (~

    'Sf9f~-6i12«..

    ~'<IJl~?

    C<!>'1

    <Q1>1~

    <jJ<iOlii.'1 $C~"i I <Q<fi"fol

    "i,¥"10P

    \51("'lC'1'11~ "'1"8 ~

    9f101" c:<! \511~

    \5l"f~

    '3 '<:?1'1<lro

    -q~B

    G~

    I ~,

    <Q~ ~

    D'f "l'f<!

    f.tffi

    <u1~

    '5fIOfi'1 ~

    \5:i-"li~

    9fVl? ~

    I \5fI'P! '<:?j,,&i{l

    1!l'q(.1' ':JIz.i7f'lt ~

    r:WI <l'~8: ii8i I ~ ~~ c<i ~ <!t1'J f.'r~fk"@ ~-~-~<J." g'<,f) '5fi'51 ?jl't ~ ('\5nl<f' \5lQ,1~ ll c~ ~ ~ cQ"R cQ1' \5l-~ f.'r;fiZq, c<i~ ">Pf ~ ~ \Sq(J) <mr, Wi'»1 ~ <1Hr ~, ~ ~ <mr Wi9fi; ~' ~ (letter) ~ G1'4H'ljfi1 'l1J, ~ mv:l ~~ ~ I ~ <Q"R ~Z<j ~ 0f"{j <JI'fi? "<:[1'3'Tf '5!11 ~ ~ I~ Q31
    ~ <l1WiB \5fI~1 ~ \5fI~ ~ \5fI-.mI ~ ~ 0Bl, \51~ ~ 1''<ff-<{G'f! ~"i-QJ1~

    ~
    cfIM1

    '1W1 (.~
    11 ~ ~

    C9JtG'f, cfI~

    15'f~

    '<:?I<ll ~ ~

    I5T~l-("1f(;(c!1J!1

    ("l.l1"1Jl arbitrary

    11 i5l<!1l:1 ~

    \5<ft/,
    ~
    ~

    "1f~
    <:ff'1 ~ ~9j'U

    <i1\5
    '{3

    "1f~ ~
    ~ ~
    ~

    C\51 \5l@! 1IZ,01i) (;r..:0t-~


    ~"(j{<i, ~ <Q~

    'TIJ I

    \5lf,;I.\5J1

    C:<;JI'fI'I:Ef'iS'!!m<furr ,¥m$l '9i~)

    C<lf(;(j!H1 ~~

    <m~
    I~

    9f1'8i

    \51%

    ;'1'4fit(J{1 ~.
    ~ ~

    ~
    \g1I1!l ~ ,,/

    'ff ~

    fiW1
    ~

    ~-<Q

    c9ft~m-~

    -~

    <!I ~

    ~
    ~ 1''<ff ideal) ~, ~

    ' 1'1\6 <TI I R>~


    ~ 8~

    ~1 ~
    HGI!l ~
    ~

    ~<lG1'iQnSi?

    Tower of Babel I

    ~ftii,
    ~~~ ~<i

    ~
    2l~

    <Pm >1'&<1 'TIJ, cQ"R '\5ltv,.cf' {regulative


    1f3i5![<j<J>I'$
    ~), ~ Q()~

    ;51'Pl11'S CI!l>1H ~

    ()t(j{

    f.kd1'S cQ~ ~
    (.*,0{

    C~
    «lSiQfjSi? (~ ~~

    i) Y

    &t~
    :

    1%:1

    9fQj-~

    411Z@<f.1!l11

    'T~ 'fi1c5I1 I
    [1'1"(i!1

    Wf~
    ~
    ";1~1i"41

    ~I-<!i

    ('<:?/:<l0l?l ~Rl'f\9

    ~<[f"i'i
    L')r;<f. ~

    9ftrn ~
    ~

    11 C9ff-<rf8 ~

    'J'f!11 ,<:?!11!l ~'1 ~


    ~ 'R~ i!lf9J:f!Qj (sic)

    1) I
    q"<,i.j

    '5P1J"<i~<i~ "Iel!lj
    G'1@l~

    'B!IHCI!l"i <!I~

    ~
    ~ G9ff~ ~

    15j9f'1
    ~ ~ ~

    051'\519fM
    "111 ~

    \5l8" ~ ~ ~

    "iG'ft TR:9f ~ c<i ~ ~

    ~'<R

    'Un tn'
    ~
    "11, ~'<R 81 \3ffi

    'l"'{) ~ 'ff ~ '&['<f


    ~
    ~ G!'!Bg91'i ~ ~I(~~~)I

    t~~)
    ~ ~

    I~

    ~'1
    I ~rzrm
    ~

    (}1'¥<t~

    ~,

    '11:'f
    ~~ ~

    "ffij, ~
    <!I1't1 \S1!MGI!l'i,

    'Jjf\1?l1~G"1O{ ~ f.tviI<i I~

    !?.Ulfu!;11 <!I<W1 .~

    '"l1~'-'5Pfj I C"lI"'fTi7f : '~~

    .D'f1>1 ~
    <Q"lfol <Q9 ~

    ~
    ~
    '5f(;<l

    \5'fC<l>
    ~I'

    ~ <l1Wt ~

    ~0f"iJ
    '<fC1

    <Wm1'{3

    I5'flOfr01"1

    ;n I ~!:zlm M~,
    ~

    ~
    'Jf~

    ~'m
    ~

    m ?j~-"~
    ()Wl'ffi,

    ~
    'M~'I!l'~\51'3

    wi I <Q~
    2lZ'ii.·d

    \5IMI ~
    '"5j~~ ~'ZCI

    "1~IU1"1 ~

    '@.T'i)1 C'<[<li" 81 ~'

    <[j

    <rt<ll!

    -. m.
    C1G'!~

    "li~n

    ~,

    ~9
    4#n.".
    ~

    ~>J~

    ~.

    ~i<'1"_,.,." •• ,'"
    .'51<f! ~~--<Q".511 cQMm"1 ~

    ",1'>o1<iJ

    f<11'I!l~J'?r

    G1~'S
    q'<[.l

    I!li![q,

    @"1(.'G1 fi1<r C'<[<li", \5l~9f10l"l

    '5l%1

    9fffl: I
    <l1Wt ~
    ~

    ~r
    ~<j

    "il~
    ~'41

    C--1i\!!<Jlb1'\51 <l"1(.1!l f'iiD1 cfI"}{rl <j>'<ff ~

    I 9f1Vl ~

    ~-\5:isBl
    13~

    2iR>CZtloi'f) ~~
    '~'

    9fG'!1 Wt:9f ~
    (inclusive we----<!l~ ~' 9f@ I

    ~,

    \5fIOfl<f ~mZ~f<:V5f<f! '<:?j"li ~.


    '{3

    c<it>t 000 ~,
    <1"1(.1!l ~

    \51 C\51 ~-.il'1

    ~
    @G'f

    &t~, ~ "5t<f! ~G'R'


    ~"1IG'! ~~11 :
    ~

    ~
    f,k~

    G1'1>j'<!difl <Q9 '"l1~'-'51<f!! ~ 'fsBl' ~-<l~-9f~-~-'~)


    <pn"'l~11!l \5iiVl! 2j<f$"L"1<J> ~ C1'6lri, 'lll-~t<l1'i'0 C9f9ff1

    '?r167'tif\b4

    '1J'<f 'I'ffip'1-'l<l

    cfI<1> 2!W1i' 91C\5 f9frn! ~I

    C\51 \5l@! ~

    Hr%f

    I~
    cfI~ 15~i7f 11

    :?/

    EF\5~

    11 C1ji'T<l1";j ~9
    Q31

    <:rt fq~1!l ?jl@ "11, 9f1V:l ~


    c'l~ c'lVf) 15'f~ ~

    'tt1{C"l{lIN®1/~-<f;;m '5j1iJ<11 c<! ~


    I cfI\Yj

    "'"' ,-_

    9f'·n1f1'?-<Q1 "lil;fi

    R./

    '>Ji~
    (~

    (Theory ~'i91~1

    .~

    and

    Praxis)

    9Jt"1 C'ifTYf ,~
    \3j

    '3i
    ~

    fq({l~ ~
    ~ ~

    "If.pf cQq;jf<:f'4 '<:?1"Ii{l <1>'41~,


    ':JI~G'ffi:9f ~

    <11'i)~,

    I5'fR,<;JI"1l!lluliG'f ~

    ps>f

    0'l:<f1, ~
    "11,

    <J>o{<:flc~'§j w) ~ ~<l:

    "1"1(."1 'C\51 ~

    ~z.~

    '>Ji~ <Jffi 'Ttl ~. iSHJ~ '"5j~G'f19f~


    't'1'iF1IJ'!1

    ~.

    \5(l\bffiI!lGi ~I

    ~"1(:,1

    <n

    I, ~

    ~~

    C'ffl'Tf-ImagiNATION ~? ~ @~<j

    \5fI0fl7:l'f<'i

    <u19ff1 05f \5fIUi.1 \5fI<lM ~~:t\5

    I~

    m- "1,:"1(\5 0'ff<!»l~~~

    C\51 cfI<f>

    <!I'<l'f(j{ ~

    \51 <l01 (\51) ~~ ~

    Fr
    ~

    15'fl~-lmai;!:iNAT10N 'f'Z(.'il"1i <Q1~ \5~~

    f>1ftiil[ :
    'dfGl"lm ~ I
    I

    zc<ll "ID~;qf''<1\5
    '<fl11'-<!l1

    G1{'t®GlOloill ~
    (aquatic

    "",~I« ,iF!~ ~~

    'f'<I1~ ~

    <lj<1'<JA<:>

    ,rc'ifG'! (celestial sphere), ~('5i1G'! <Q1~ ~";j

    region) <Q91'fi1~ ~

    I,

    ."!'

    <·n51~
    ()TG'l1~

    fu<r

    ~Z~ body
    ~

    (constellation) ('5fI) of holy


    ~ ~

    I3qr
    <fI~'ft

    m~
    :~ ~

    i'lWl-~~

    <Q~

    fijG'H<''l'l'<!l ~;
    <Q'Z>~

    ~~

    ~-m'Q
    ~

    0Rl"Xj
    (~

    (fragmented

    mother)
    ~

    <il'Z ~9f1C"1~ ~ \~*i:.C"1 I

    BIBLIOGRAPHY
    ~

    'V!1~ ~

    ~t.9()t<nI
    ;ro,
    ~ <!l~

    ~/"['5/~
    ~~

    VJM??! .~
    <1>@

    2j'§'!l1~<"1' ~ \5'<1<1

    'C'1 ~

    ~c'JnG'j ~~
    <'Rl~ml thenn--c!1?l C<181<:TI ~; ~\!l
    <Q"l{'l

    '*ff\i5:q; ~ ~
    t

    \51~'8

    :q;Q1 ~)

    <Qm
    ~
    ~

    <Q~

    Bandyopadhyay, D.1996a. "A Dialogue on Linguistic Creativity" ......... Aligarh Journal of Linguistics Vol. V, No.!. (pp.72-64) Aligarh,
    Bandyopadhyay, D.1996b."The Crippled Creativity- A Brief Theoretical Perspective." International Journal of Communications. Vol. VIa, No.1-2. (pp.93-103). Delhi.

    8l'<,~ "W31)-~ ~)

    0~\:ii ~

    Q1~WI11 ~
    cQ"T;:;

    'K.'1J

    <:IN
    ~"'i<i

    iso-corporal (iso~
    \5fI~
    cQ:q;

    ",fu 5r.n 'ffiJ 05! \5i"W'f '~'

    "l~<'!lblC<fl <1'D ~ \51

    'lT3
    I

    ~1
    ~

    03Bl

    <f.~m \SwrPr\5 ~
    0"l'<i I
    cQ~

    ''5fi~lDl<'!'

    ImagiNAT!ON~
    ~ ('>11Fl ~ ~

    <n ~

    w;m9lrn WI ~

    Bandyopadhyay,

    C<J?<{'~ ~ (21~

    \5l1Vl '\5fI'1iVBl' <Wf-2j~'l:f 4C'!l! MG1tPt\!lt ~ ~ ~

    ~m 9/Qj
    @G'j~,

    \5fl~ \5KGjC<ij<f~, cil<f~ ~

    :Jf

    Philosophy March

    /97.

    D.1997a. "Towards a Praxis of Anti-Grammar." and Social Action. Vol.23, No.1 (pp.33-42). JanDelhi. . _

    <.<m~
    ~

    ~
    <f\'Fl

    Wtt<n ~
    '1)\8,' ~

    ~)_'<i'GV-~
    j

    <lV1,

    ~
    ~

    '5l1'N ~ on 05!!
    <>m
    C<l'Q

    <11fu ...'
    ~

    ;izCGi Jj<1iSTC<1<l

    Bandyopadhyay, D.1997b. "Chomsky and Haberrnas via Nyaya Theory of Debating". Language Forum. XXIII: 1-2 (pp. 115123).Delhi.

    f.l~~

    ~ M~
    :J4.{i51(j'l'?l

    cil7YR <il<fZ

    <lm ~,
    ~
    '~
    ~

    ~
    <!I<i' Lan~':

    Bandyopadhyay,

    "TC<iJ I cilqqf<w \5j'<:frn ~~

    f.WT ~
    '!l'l ~,
    <!l<i'/cQ'1>if<i<i>

    guage for Wider Communication


    8J

    :~

    I~

    D.1997c. "A Dilogue on Computational and Chomskian Linguistics". Indian Journal of Applied Linguistics. Vol .xXIII, No.2 (pp.29-42). Delhi.

    <len
    <il~

    ~1l ~.~ '>'i5f'!Ji{A'i

    '1'''Ii ~
    ~ ~Gi,¥f1

    ~9)Q/~'ij

    t1lJ. ~-

    ~I
    ./"

    <il~ 'SMJ... I

    t;::

    ;n <iZ<'!, '1''<lBl <!Im<l>1~ <>\Br<! ~?!C'!ll, '5l19/1'!l\!l ...


    I

    Cf1ii6<1115'f.'!lj ~,
    l

    m~

    ~I

    Bandyopadh ray,_D.1997d. "Towards a ~ fosop y and Social Action. VoL23:4(pp.19-27)

    Delhi.
    iflV

    ~.B~~ lopadhyay, D.1999. "Modern Lingu~~tics: An Obituary" A\Ulstlc~~(p'jJ.)T-S1 1 oar 1.

    D .2001 a. "(M)Other Tongue Syndrome: From Breast To Bottle." Kumar, R. ed. Studies in Sociolinguistics and Applied Linguistics. (pp. 87-106) Hyderabad: Booklinks. Bandyopadhyay, D.200 I b. "Psi-Properties: Language, Psyche and Society." indian Journal of linguistics. XIX: 1-2 (pp .36-46). Kolkata. Bandyopadhyay, Rabindrabharati

    Bandyopadhyay,

    tion into the Kamtapuri

    D. 2001 c. Linguistic Terrorism: A n interrupLanguage Movement. Kolkata: University.

    ?
    Bandyopadhyay, D. 2003. "Creative Cogito and Disturbed Corporeal" Language and Cognition. Department of CognitiveS-cience, Jadavpur University and Department of Philosophy, Bethune College. (pp. 1-41) Bandyopadhyay, D. 2006 "Linguistic Cybercolonization" Globalization, Language, Culture and media. Eds. B. N Patnaik, S.f.flasnain, 'Sirn+a Institute of Advanced Studies.{pp.146'187)fSBN8-l-79-86-061-2 Barthes, R. 1,973. Mythoiogies. St. Albans: Paladin. Chomsky, N.A. 1995. The Minimalist Program. Cambridge MIT Press. Chomsky, N. A.2BOO. The Architectur-e of Language. (ed. Mukherji, N., Patnaik, B.N, Agnihotri, R.) Delhi: Oxford University Press. Chomsky, N. A.200L Beyond Explanatory Adequacy Working Papers in Linguistic'S. Cambridge: MIT. Dasgupta, MIT .... :

    Barthes, R. 1975. The Pleasure of The Text. Oxford, CamiJridge: BiackweH. Baudrillard, J. 1975. Simulations. (Tr. Foss, P., Beitchman, p.r9.83). New York: Serniotext {e). Bohm, D., Pear, D. ! 989. Science, Order and Creativity.
    London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

    P. 1~88. "The External reality of Linguistic-description." Canadian Journal {~f Linguistics. 33:4 (pp.345-.65). Dasgupta, P.1984. "Some Socio-linguistic Aspects of Communication". Indian Journal of Linguistics. Vat .Xl.No.I. Kolkata. (pp .31-43) Oasgupta, P.19E8. -Review article in the Indian Linguistics. Vol .49, Nos- 1-4 {pp.121-130) Pune. Dasgupta, P. 1989. Projective Syntax: Theory and Application . Pune: Deccan College.
    '-

    Carson, R.c., Butcher, J.N., Coleman, J.C.1988. Psychology Illinois: Scott, Foreman & Co. Jevanovich.
    Chomsky, N.A. Temple Smith. 197(). Reflections

    Abnormal

    Ch-omsky, N.A. 1972. Language and Mind. New York: Brace

    Dasgupta, P. ,1993. The Otherness of English. Delhi: Sage. Deleuze.G, Guattari,F.1977. Anti-Oedipus: -Capitalism and Schizophrenia. Tr. P. Hurley et al. New York: Random House.
    Derrida, J. 197-611994. Of Grammatology . .(Tr. G'C. Spivak) Delhi: Motilal Banarasidas, Derrida, 1. 1978. Writing and difference. Chicago: University Press. University of Chicago Press. Derrida, J. 1984. "No Apocalypse, Not Now (Full speed Ahead, seven missiles, seven missives" Diacritics. Vol. .Xx (pp. 2D-31) J. ·199£. Monolingualism of the Other, Dr The Prothesis of Origin , Stanford: Stanford University Press. Derrida, Chicago

    on Language.

    London: Great Brit-

    Chomsky, N.A. 1980. Rules and Representations. ain: Basil Blackwell Pub. Ltd. Chomsky,

    N. A. 1980. "O~ Binding". Linguistic Inquiry II (pp,


    N.A. 1986. Knowledge 0/ Language.

    1-46)
    Chomsky,

    lew York:

    Derrida, 1. 198-1. Dissemination. (Tr. B. Johnson). Chicago:

    Praegar,
    Chomsky, N. A., Lasnik, H.. 1991. Principles and Parameters Theory. Mimeographed copy. Chomsky N. A. 1992. A Minimalist Program for Linguistic ThBOIY. MiT Working Papers in Liuguistics.Cambridge, : MiT.

    Dews, ·P. L987. Logics of Disintegration. London: Verso. Feyerabead, P. 1988. Against Method. London: Verso. Foucault, M. 1973. The order of things: An Archaeology Sciences. New York: Vintage Book.

    teenth Century Agenda and Its Implications. Kolkata: K.P. Bagchi and Co.

    0/

    Foucauit, M .. 1973. The Birth ofthe Clinic: Archaeology of Medical perception. London: Tavistock Publication,
    Foucaulr, M. 1977. Power/knowledge: Selected interviews. Ed.

    Habermas, J. 1970. "Towards a Theory of -Communicative Competence", in Dreitzel, H.P. ed. Patterns of Communicative Behavior. New york: Macmillan. Heredia, C.R. 1990. "Social Medicine for Holistic health: An Alternative response to present-crisis."Economic and Political Weekly.XXV:4E-49 (pp.2673-78) Hollis, M. "1994. Philosophy of Social Science. -Cambridge: Cambridge University Press: Kristeva, J. 1973. "The System of Speaking Subject". London: Times Literary Supplement, 12 October 1973. {1249-S0).
    Kristeva.T, 1986. "A Question of Subjectivity: An Interview" in Rice, P., Waugh, P. Ed. A lvfodern Literary Theory: A Reader.

    Gordon, C. Random House, Inc.


    FDtlCauh, M. d 979. Discipline and Punish: The Birth qf the

    Frison. New York: Vintage Book. Foucault, M. 1988. Madness and Civilization: A History of Insanity in the age of Reason. New York: Vintage Book. Foucault, M.19R8. The History of Sexuality: -an Introduction. Vol. I. New York: Vintage Hook. Foucault, M. 1988. The use of Pleasure: Sexuality. Vol.2. New York: Vintage Book. The History of

    London: Edward Arnold. Lakatos, 1.1976. Proofs and Refutations. Cambridge: CUP. Marcuse, H. 1956. Eros and Civilization: A Philosophical Inquiry into Freud. London: ARK paperbacks. Marcuse, H.1964. 'One Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrialized Society. London: ARK paperbacks. Matilal, B. K. 1985. Logic, Language and Reality. Delhi: Motilai B anarasi das,
    Medawar,P. 1986. "Scientific Writing." Dear, I.CB. compiled Oxford English. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press. (pp.553-56)

    Foucault, M. 1988. The Care of the Sell The History of Sexuality. VoL3. New York: Vintage Book. Foucault, M. 1988. The Archaeology of Knowledge and Discourse on Language. New York: Pantheon Books. Freud, S. i 9JO:Civlization and its Discontent (Tr. Joan, R.). London: The Hogarth Press Ltd. Gadamar, H-G. i975. Truth and Method. New York: Continuum.

    Gouldner, A.W.1979. The future oj"Intelle-ctuals and {he rise of the NeHI Class. London: The Macmillan Press Ltd.
    -Guha, R. 19"83. Eliminatory Aspect of Peasant Insurgency in -Colonial India. Delhi: Oxford University Press.

    Naipal, V.S. 1978. India: A Wounded Civilization. New York: Vintage Books. Nietzsche, F. 1956. The Genealogy

    0/ Morais.

    New York. Penguin.

    Guha,

    R. 1"9"8'8.. An Indian Historiography

    of india: A Nine-

    Orwel·l, 1949/54 Nineteen Eighty Four. Hermondsworth:

    .-.=.'......

    1...".

    r~<••.

    I"_::~

    ~:r-..::.!":".J

    ~l(:~·

    _J

    ~' Palmer, F 1983. Grammar. Hermondsworth: Penguin Pattanayak, D.P. 1981. Multilingualism and Mother-Tongue Education. (With a Forward by Ivan Illich). Delhi: Oxford University Press. Peck, J. (Ed..) 1987. The -Chomsky theon Books.
    Penrose, Reader_New

    York: Pan-

    R. 199.0. The Emperor s New Mind. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Peerose, R. t994.shadows versity Press. of the Mind. Oxford: Oxford UniImperialism.

    PhiHipSOll, R. 1992. Linguistic University Press.


    Books,

    Oxford: Oxford

    Rabinow, P. (Ed) 1984. Foucault Reader.


    Radford, A. 1"9gU86. Transformational -Carnbridge University Press.

    lew York: Pantheon Syntax. Cambridge:


    -Creativity. Kolkata:

    Rao,

    c.R. 1987: Uncertainty, Indian Statistical Institute.

    Randomness,

    Russell, B.1950. An Inquiry info Meaning and Truth. London:


    Unwin.

    Sarrre, J.P. 1956. Being and Nothingness. ington Square Press.

    New York: Wash-

    'Singh, R. 1988. "Do we really want a syntax organ? A note on Phonology, Morphology and Autonomy thesis". Indian Linguistics. YB1.49, Nos.- 1-4 -(pp. l09-H4) W'ise, D., RDSS, 'LB. 1964. lnvisible Government. New York: Bantorn BDOks, Random House. Volosinov, V.N. :1986. Marxism and the Philosophy guage. Cambridge, Mass.: Havard University Press.
    of Lan-

    You might also like