Third, , disputed issues of contractualinterpretation or intent cannot be resolved on a motion to intervene.
Mendenhall v.M/V Toyota Maru No. 11 v. Panama Canal Co.
, 551 F.2d 55, 56 n.2 (5th Cir. 1977) (all non-conclusory allegations must be accepted as true when considering intervention). The motioncannot be stayed pending discovery, as Lodsys argues, Opp. at 4-5, because “the factualallegations of the complaint are assumed to be true,” and as a result, “discovery on [the] claims before ruling on the motion to intervene is as irrelevant as itwould be if made in the context of amotion to dismiss pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6).”
Pin v. Texaco, Inc.
, 793 F.2d 1448,1450 (5th Cir. 1986).
Factual issues concerning the construction of this provision must beresolved on the merits, not at the pleading stage on a motion to intervene.
II.Apple Has Met the Requirements for Intervention of RightA.Lodsys Concedes That Apple’s Motion Was Not Filed Too Late
Lodsys’s argument that the Motion is premature is similarly flawed. First,Apple’s interest in the litigation is far from speculative. Indeed, Lodsys does not even disputeApple’s statements that its technology lies at the heart of this case.
Opp. at 5-7. Thecircumstances here are, therefore, far different from those described in the cases cited by Lodsys,
Lodsys’s reliance on case law regarding non-exclusive licensees’ standing to assert the patents is irrelevant.
Frazier v. Map Oil Tools
, 2010 WL 2352056, at *4 (S.D.Tex. June 10, 2010) (finding movant seeking to intervene as plaintiff in infringementaction lacked standing due to non-exclusive licensee status). Apple seeks to intervene to protect its rights under the License, not to assert the patents against any thirdparty.
Lodsys also contends that Apple has “repeatedly refused to provide information relevantto its request for intervention.” Opp. at 5. But Apple provided a complete copy of theLicense as Exhibit A to its supporting declaration.
Sanders Decl., Ex. A.
Case 2:11-cv-00272-TJW Document 35 Filed 08/08/11 Page 3 of 7