Professional Documents
Culture Documents
September2007
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 1
Acknowledgements
WegratefullyacknowledgetheIllinoisChildrensHealthcareFoundationfortheirgenerous supportofthisreport.
Wealsothankthefollowingadvisorsfortheirvaluableinputandfeedbackonvariousdraftsofthis report:
StephanieAltman,Health&DisabilityAdvocates KarenBerg,IllinoisMaternal&ChildHealthCoalition LisaBilbrey,IFLOSSCoalition JohnBouman,SargentShriverNationalCenteronPovertyLaw DianeDoherty,IllinoisHungerCoalition BlairHarvey,IllinoisMaternal&ChildHealthCoalitionandIllinoisCoalitionforSchoolHealthCenters GinaGuillemette,HeartlandAllianceforHumanNeeds&HumanRights JulieJanssen,IllinoisDepartmentofPublicHealth,DivisionofOralHealth,OfficeofHealthPromotion PatrickKeenanDevlin,SargentShriverNationalCenteronPovertyLaw MadeleineLevin,FoodResearchandActionCenter MeganMeagher,IllinoisCampaignforBetterHealthCare DawnMelchiorre,VoicesforIllinoisChildren SandraMills,NationalAssociationofSocialWorkersIllinoisChapter JulieParente,VoicesforIllinoisChildren JoelRubin,NationalAssociationofSocialWorkersIllinoisChapter MonaVanKanegan,HeartlandHealthOutreach KarenYarbrough,OunceofPreventionFund AmyZimmerman,Health&DisabilityAdvocates
September2007 Writing:AmyTerpstra,MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance Editing:AmyRynell,MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance Maps:HelenEdwards,MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance Printing:GraphixProducts,Inc. Suggestedcitation:MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance.(2007,September). BuildingonourSuccess:MovingfromHealthCareCoveragetoImprovedAccessand ComprehensiveWellBeingforIllinoisChildrenandYouth.Chicago:Author. This report can be downloaded from http://www.heartlandalliance.org/maip 2007HeartlandAllianceforHumanNeeds&HumanRights
BuildingonourSuccess
TableofContents
RealizingaVisionofChildandYouthWellBeinginIllinois TheRelationshipBetweenChildPovertyandHealth ExistingGaps&TargetedSolutions PhysicalHealth MentalHealth OralHealth ProperNutrition Insurance BuildingonourSuccess:WheretogofromHere Endnotes
2 4 5 6 8 10 12 14 16 17
ThePovertyMeasure
Income poverty is defined by the federalgovernmentusingfoodcostasa basis.Each year, amonetarythreshold commonlycalledthefederalpoverty line(FPL)isset,andfamiliesaswell as the individuals who comprise those families are considered poor if their family income falls below the threshold for their family size. In 2007, a family of four is considered poor if their gross annual income falls below $20,650. Income poverty is also discussed in terms of percentage of the FPL. Extreme poverty is defined as half the povertyline,or50%FPLlowincomeis defined as twice the poverty line, or 200%FPL.
RealizingaVisionofChildandYouth Well-BeinginIllinois
Childhoodisanimportanttimeofemotional,physical,cognitive,andsocialdevelopment,andeach playsanimportantroleinhelpingchildrengrowintohealthy,productiveadults.Illinoishasmade initialinvestmentsinthehealthanddevelopmentofchildren.Mostnotably,Illinoishas takenimportantstepstoensurepublichealthinsurancecoverageforallchildrenregardlessof incomeandstatus.
th Asrecentlyas2003,Illinoisstatechildrenshealthinsuranceprogram,KidCare,ranked39 inthe nationwithonly18percentofeligiblechildrenenrolled.Duetoconcertedoutreachefforts,Illinois th rankimprovedto18 bythefollowingyearwith35percentofeligiblechildrenenrolledthe 1 secondlargestincreaseofallstates. InJulyof2006,IllinoisimplementedtheAllKidsprogram, whichabsorbedchildrensMedicaidandKidCareandoffershealthinsurancecoverageonasliding feescaleforeverychildinIllinois.AllKidsestablishedIllinoisasaleaderinextendingcoverageto children,andasofApril2007,50,000previouslyineligible,uninsuredchildrenhadcoverage 2 throughtheprogram,withatotalof1.3millionIllinoischildrencovered.
Additionally,Illinoiswasthefirststateinthenationtoofferhealthinsurancecoveragetothe parentsofchildrenwhoareeligibleforthestateschildhealthinsuranceprogram.Throughthe 3 creationofFamilyCare,parentalcoverageincreasedby227percent. Thiscoverageincreaseis significantinlightofresearchthatshowsthatlowincomeuninsuredparentsarethreetimesas 4 likelytohaveuninsuredchildrenasinsuredparents. Researchalsoshowsthatparentenrollment inMedicaidincreasesenrollmentofchildren,andthatwhenparentsareinsuredtheirchildrengain 5 betteraccesstocare. Alongwiththeseexpansionsofpublichealthinsurancecoverageareeffortstomovetowarda medicalhomemodelofcarethatemphasizesprimaryandpreventivecareforbothchildrenand adultswithpublichealthinsurancecoverage.6 Thismodel,calledIllinoisHealthConnect,aimsto achievebetterpatientoutcomesandincreasethecosteffectivenessofhealthcareservices. Whiletheseeffortsarevitalfirststepsinhelpingchildrenandyouthrealizehealthylives,theyare indeedonlyfirststeps.TheeffectsofpovertyexperiencedbymanyIllinoisfamilies translateintoahigherriskfornegativechildhealthoutcomesandmoredifficulty accessingthehealthcarechildrenneedtothrive.Childrenfrompoorfamiliesarestillless likelytobeinsured,andBlackandHispanicIllinoischildrenare2.5timeslesslikelytohavepublic 7 healthinsurancecoverageasWhitechildren. Lackofhealthinsurancecoveragegreatly contributestounfavorablehealthoutcomesformanypoorandminoritychildrenandyouthand diminishestheabilityofpoorfamiliestoadequatelyrespondtotheirchildrenshealthneeds.Illinois mustcontinuewitheffortstoenrollpoorandminoritychildrenintheAllKidsprogramasafirst stepinhelpingimprovehealthoutcomes. Forthosewithcoverage,manypoorandlowincomefamiliesfaceagapbetweenhavinginsurance andaccessingthecaretheirchildrenneedtobecomeandstayhealthy.Thenumberofdoctors, dentists,andmentalhealthprofessionalswhoacceptpatientswithpublicinsurancefallsfarshort ofmeetingthedemand,andinmanyplacesinthestatethereisaseverelackofproviderswho acceptpublicinsurancewithinareasonabledistancefromwherefamilieslive.Fillingthisgap requiresconcertedeffortstoexpandthenumberandgeographicdispersionofhealthcare professionalsacrossthehealthspectrumwhoacceptpublicinsuranceandisacriticalstepin ensuringchildrenandyouthcanleadhealthylives.
BuildingonourSuccess
FamiliesinIllinoisnotonlyexperiencedifficultyfindinghealthcareprofessionalsthatacceptpublic insurancefortheirchildren,buttheyalsohavetroubleobtainingregularandpreventivephysical healthcare,gettingmentalhealthneedsmet,accessingoralhealthservices,obtainingnutritious food,andforolderyouth,acquiringinsurance. Helpingchildrenandyouthbecomeandstayhealthyrequiresaholisticapproachinwhichallthe componentsofhealthareaddressed.Healthismorethantheabsenceofdiseaseitencompasses completephysical,mental,andsocialwellbeing.Inordertorealizecomprehensivechildandyouth wellbeing,thefollowingcomponentsneedtobeinplace: Affordablehealthinsurancecoverageforthosewhoneeditthatcoversprevention,early diagnosis,andtreatment Acoordinatedandstreamlinedhealthsystemthatminimizesbarrierstoaccessingcoverageand care Healthcareprofessionalswhoacceptpublicinsurancewithofficesincloseproximitytowhere peoplewiththatinsurancelive Medicalhomesforallchildreninwhichthedoctorknowsthechildsmedicalhistoryandwhere parentsknowtheycantaketheirchildrenforneededcheckupsandtreatment Preventivecareandtreatmentforphysical,mental,andoralhealth Nutritionalsupporttopromotehealthydevelopment Appropriateinsurancecoverageandcareforparentssotheycanmaintainhealthylivestocare fortheirchildren Whatfollowsinthisreportisadescriptionofaccesschallengesintheareasofphysicalhealth, mentalhealth,oralhealth,propernutrition,andinsurancecoverageforolderyouth.Inaddition tothecriticalstepofenrollingadditionaldoctors,dentists,andmentalhealth professionalsinMedicaid,Illinoiscanimplementthefollowingconcrete recommendationsinordertoachievethecomponentsofcomprehensivechildandyouth wellbeingoutlinedabove.Theserecommendationsarerealisticnextstepsthatcanbe implementedinthenearfuturetohelpIllinoisenhanceitsstatusasaleaderinthefieldofchild health.
BuildingonourSuccess:WheretogofromHere
Expandexistingschoolhealthcenters,andestablishnewcentersincommunities ofneed. EngageinoutreacheffortstoenrollLicensedClinicalSocialWorkersas MedicaidprovidersandeducationeffortsaimedtowardfamilieswithMedicaid enrolledchildren. Expanddentalsealantprogramstoreachmorelowincomechildrenand increaseMedicaidreimbursementratesforrestorativeprocedures. Implementuniversalschoolbreakfastindistrictswithhighpercentagesoflow incomestudents. ExtendeligibilityofAllKidstoincludeyouththroughage24.
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 3
TheRelationshipBetweenChild PovertyandHealth
Alone,povertyorhealthproblemscanhaveseriousconsequencesforachild.Butthe realityisthatpovertyandhealthintersectinachildslifepovertyisexacerbatedby healthproblemsandhealthproblemsareintensifiedbypoverty.Theeffectsof povertyexperiencedbymanyIllinoisfamiliestranslateintoahigherriskfornegative childhealthoutcomesandmoredifficultyaccessingthehealthcarechildrenneedto thrive. Growingupinpovertyhasadverseeffectsonchildrensphysical,cognitive,and emotionalhealth.Comparedtotheirnonpoorcounterparts,poorchildrenare: Morelikelytobelowbirthweightandhaveagreaterriskofinfant 8 mortality. 9 Twiceaslikelytobeinpoorhealth. 10 Threetofourtimesaslikelytosufferleadpoisoning. 11 Morelikelytohaveunmetmedicalanddentalneeds. 12 Morelikelytoexperienceinjuriesfromaccidents. Morelikelytoexperiencedevelopmentaldelaysandlearning 13 disabilities. 14 Atgreaterriskforsufferingfrombehavioraloremotionalproblems. Theintersectionofpovertyandhealthinachildslifeisfurthercompoundedbythefact thatpovertyoftenlimitsoptionsandopportunitiesforadequatelyaddressinghealth issues.Poorfamiliesarelesslikelytohaveemergencyfundsavailabletorespondto healthcrises,andpoorchildrenarelesslikelytohaveamedicalhome,morelikelyto relyonemergencyroomsforroutinecare,anddespiterecentinvestments,areless 15 likelytohavehealthinsurancecoverage.
ChildandYouthPovertyinIllinois
16 Overhalfamillionchildrenliveinpoverty. 17 1in5childrenliveinlowincomeworkingfamilies. Childrenaredisproportionatelyaffectedbypoverty, makingup25%ofIllinoispopulation,but35%of 18 thoseinpoverty. 19 1in5youthages18to24liveinpoverty. 15%ofyouthages18to24arenotenrolledin school,arenotworking,andhavenodegreebeyond 20 highschool.
BuildingonourSuccess
ExistingGapsandTargetedSolutions
Thefollowingpageslookatchildrensphysical,mental,andoralhealth,aswellasnutritionissues andinsurancecoverage.Ineachofthefollowingsections,thesetwoquestionsareposed:
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 5
PhysicalHealth
Q:
Whatarethebarrierstoachievingahealthylifeforpoorandlowincome childrenandyouthintheareaofphysicalhealth?
A:
LowerincomeIllinois childrenarelesslikelyto beinexcellentorvery goodhealththantheir higherincome 23 counterparts. Thereareanumberof healthoutcomesandrisk behaviorsthatemergeas childrengetolderthat highlighttheimportance ofprevention:
ParentsReportingtheirChild'sHealthtoBeExcellentor VeryGood,byIncome
93.2% 89.7% 79.0%
50.0% 31%ofIllinoischildren 099%FPL 100199%FPL 200399%FPL 400%FPLand andteensfromage10to over 24 17areobese. 52%ofIllinoischildren 25 andteensdonotexerciseregularly. 26 Youthages10to19constitutenearly40%ofIllinoisChlamydiaandGonorrheacases. Inthepastmonth,ofallIllinoisyouthages12to17:141,000haveusedtobacco,190,000 27 haveusedalcohol,147,000haveusedmarijuana,and50,000haveusedotherillicitdrugs.
BuildingonourSuccess
PhysicalHealth
Q:
Whatcanwedotoensureallchildrenandyouthhaveaccesstothecarethey needtobecomehealthy,productiveadults?
A:
Expandexistingschoolhealthcenters,andestablishnewcentersin communitiesofneed.
Schoolhealthcenters(SHCs)provideprimarycare,mentalhealth,oralhealth,and preventivehealthcareservicestostudentsandarelocatedonschoolgroundsornearby. Thesecentersofferaffordable,comprehensive,andageappropriatehealthservicestochildrenand youthandsignificantlyincreasestudentsaccesstocare,particularlyamonglowincomestudents whomayotherwisehaveadifficulttimeaccessingcomprehensivemedicaltreatment.Research showsmanyhealthbenefitsofSHCs: SHCshavedemonstratedthattheyattracthardertoreachpopulations,especiallyminorities andmales,andthattheydoabetterjobthancommunityhealthcentersorHMOsatgetting 31,32 themcrucialservicessuchasmentalhealthcareandhighriskbehaviorscreens. Therecanbesignificantincreasesinhealthcareusebystudentswhouseschoolhealthcenters 33 comparedtothosewhodonothaveaccesstoaSHC. SHCmedicalservicescanhelpdecreaseabsencesby50%amongstudentswiththreeormore 34 absencesina6weekperiod. StudentswhoreceivementalhealthservicesfromSHCscanexperiencedramaticdeclinesin 35 schooldisciplinereferrals. Schoolhealthcenterscanreduceinappropriateemergencyroomuseamongregularusersof 36,37 schoolhealthcenters. Elementaryschoolhealthcentershaveshownareductioninhospitalizationandanincreasein 38,39 schoolattendanceamonginnercityschoolchildrenwithasthma. 40 SHCscanreduceMedicaidexpendituresrelatedtoinpatient,drug,andemergencyroomuse. FiftytwoschoolhealthcentersoperateinIllinois,andthereare10morecentersintheplanning stage.Inthe20042005schoolyear,*38SHCsreportedenrollingover82,000studentsand providingover102,600healthcarevisits.Thecostislessthan$39.00perstudenteachyear.
41 EachyearinIllinoisSHCssaveanestimated: $233,000to$342,000byreducingasthmahospitalizations $1.77millionbyprovidingimmunizations $2.50millionbyreducingemergencyroomvisits
*Thisisthemostrecentyearforwhichdataareavailable.
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 7
MentalHealth
Q:
Whatarethebarrierstoachievingahealthylifeforpoorandlowincome childrenandyouthintheareaofmentalhealth?
A:
ManyIllinoischildrenandyouthdonothaveaccesstoneededmental healthservices.
Mentalhealthisacriticalcomponentto overallchildandyouthwellbeing. Mentalhealthproblemsinchildrencan manifestaspoorweightgain,slowgrowth, delayedcognitiveandphysicaldevelopment, aggressiveorimpulsivebehavior,sleep problems,andinconsolablecrying.Anyof thesecanleadtoanumberofnegative outcomesincludingpersistentfearand stress,schoolfailure,teenagechildbearing, 42 unstableemployment,andviolence. ManyIllinoischildrendonothave accesstomentalhealthtreatment,yet withoutearlyintervention,manymay facemuchmoreseverementalhealth 43 problemslaterinlife. 37%ofIllinoischildrenwithcurrent emotional,developmental,orbehavioral problemsdidnotreceiveanytypeof mentalhealthcareintheprevious 44 year. 1in10Illinoischildrensuffersfroma mentalillnessthatissevereenoughto needtreatment,butinanygivenyear, onlyabout20%ofthemreceivemental 45 healthservices. HispanicIllinoischildrenarelesslikelyto receiveneededmentalhealthservices: 71%didnotreceiveneededservices 46 comparedto33%ofwhitechildren. Illinoishasashortageofmentalhealth serviceprovidersforpeoplewithpublic insurance.Only16percentof psychiatristsandpsychologistsin 47 Illinoisacceptpublicinsurance.
NumberofPsychologistsandPsychiatrists AcceptingMedicaidbyCounty,2006
BuildingonourSuccess
MentalHealth
Q:
Whatcanwedotoensureallchildrenandyouthhaveaccesstothecarethey needtobecomehealthy,productiveadults?
A:
Childrenandyouthneedbroaderaccesstomentalhealthservicesinordertosucceedin schoolandhavehealthyrelationshipswiththeirfamiliesandpeers.Halfofalllifetime 48 casesofmentalillnessbeginbytheageof14. Delaysindiagnosingandtreatingmentalillness canleadtoamoresevere,moredifficulttotreatillness,andtothedevelopmentofadditional mentalillnesses.InvestingadditionalresourcesinthementalhealthofIllinoischildrenandyouth todaywillsubstantiallyreducefuturespendingonmorecomplexproblemswhentheybecome adults. Therearenearly9,000LicensedClinicalSocialWorkers(LCSWs)inIllinoiswhoarelicensedto 49 providementalhealthservices. Mentalhealthisthespecialtyofapproximately37percentof 50 LCSWs. LCSWsholdmasterdegrees,areprofessionallytrainedtooperateunderacodeofethics, arelicensedandregulatedbythestateofIllinois,andhaveaprofessionalcommitmenttoserving underservedpopulations.UnderfederallawandrecentlyunderIllinoisstatelaw,LCSWscanbe directlyreimbursedbyMedicaidfortheirservices. TherecentchangeinIllinoistoallowLCSWstobedirectlyreimbursedfortheservicestheyare licensedtoprovidewillsignificantlyincreasethenumberofmentalhealthprofessionalsavailableto childrenandyouthwithpublicinsuranceandwillexpandtheserviceproviderandservicesetting optionsfortheirfamilies.Implementingthispolicychangeholdsparticularpromiseinareaswhere thereareshortagesofmentalhealthproviderswhoacceptpublicinsurance. However,achangeinlawissimplythefirststepinexpandingaccesstomentalhealthcare.This effortssuccessdependsontheextenttowhichLCSWsareawareoftheirexpandedoptionsfor billingandfamiliesareawarethattheycanaccessmentalhealthservicesfortheirchildrenin additionalsettings.Increasingaccesstomentalhealthservicesforchildrenandyouth mustincludeoutreacheffortstoenrollLCSWsasMedicaidprovidersandeducation effortsaimedtowardfamilieswithMedicaidenrolledchildren.Sucheffortswillfacilitate greateraccesstothementalhealthcarelowincomechildrenandyouthneedtodevelopinto healthyadults.
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 9
OralHealth
Q:
Whatarethebarrierstoachievingahealthylifeforpoorandlowincome childrenandyouthintheareaoforalhealth?
A:
ManyIllinoischildrenhaveuntreatedoralhealthneedsandlack preventivecare.
Achildcannotbe completelyhealthywithout havingsoundoralhealth. Untreatedoraldiseasesand conditionscanhavea significantimpactonachilds qualityoflife.Thepain associatedwithmanyoral diseasesandconditionscan renderconcentrationdifficult, leadingtodiminishedschool performanceandincreased daysabsent.Additionally,oral diseasecanpresentbarriersto speaking,chewing,swallowing, cancontributetolossofself esteem,andcanultimately leadtoworseoralhealth 51 problemsasadults.
PercentofIllinoisChildrenwithTeethinFairorPoorCondition, byIncome
25.0% 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% 5.0% 0.0% 099%FPL 100199%FPL 200399%FPL 400%FPLand over 5.9% 3.7% 21.0% 14.2%
PercentofIllinoisChildrenNotReceivingallNeededDentalCare, byIncom e 14.4% 12.1% 3.3% 4.0% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% 8.0% 10.0% 12.0% 14.0% 16.0%
Preventionisthesurest measureinthefightagainst childhoodoraldisease,yet28 percentofIllinoischildrendid notseeadentistforroutine preventivecareinthepast12 months.Researchhasshown thatchildrenwhoarepoor andminoritychildrenare morelikelytohaveteeththat areinfairorpoorcondition andarelessabletoaccess thecaretheyneedto maintainhealthyteethand 55 mouths.
10
BuildingonourSuccess
OralHealth
Q:
Whatcanwedotoensureallchildrenandyouthhaveaccesstothecarethey needtobecomehealthy,productiveadults?
A:
Toothdecay,aninfectiveandsometimespainfulcondition,canlargelybepreventedbyproviding allchildrenandyouthwithaccesstotimelyexamsanddirectinterventionsthatincludeeducation topreventdecay,appropriateamountsoffluoridesupplementation,anddentalsealants.Dental sealantsconsistofathinplasticcoatingappliedtothechewingsurfacesofmolarstopreventtooth decayandareaprovencavitypreventioneffort.Furthermore,dentalsealantsarecosteffective: 56 onaverage,adentalsealantcostsoverthreetimeslessthanafilling. Therateofschoolagechildrenreceivingdentalsealantshasrisenoverthepastseveral 57 decadeshowever,therehasbeennoincreaseforchildrenfromlowincomefamilies. 58 Only27%ofIllinoisthirdgradershavedentalsealants. TheIllinoisDepartmentofPublicHealthoperatesaDentalSealantGrantProgram,whichprovides grantstolocalcommunitiestoimplementdentalsealantprogramstoservelowincomechildren. Thedentalsealantprogramoperatedin44ofIllinois102countiesinthefiscalyear2007,reaching 50,953childrenandapplying53,019sealants.Increasingavailablefundstosupportthedental sealantprogramwillhelpmaintainandbuildneededinfrastructuretoreachmorechildren. Manychildrenhaveoralhealthneedsthatarewellbeyondthatofdentalsealants.Childrenwith existingdecayneedrestorativetherapies,suchasfillingsandothermorecomplexprocedures.The currentlowrateofMedicaidreimbursementdoesnotcomeclosetothecostofprovidingsuchcare anddiscouragesdentistsfromacceptingpatientswithpublichealthinsurance.Consequently, childrenandyouthwhoneedtheseproceduresoftenfacealargegapinongoingoralhealthcare. ExpandingtheDentalSealantGrantProgramandincreasingtheMedicaidreimbursement rateforrestorativeprocedures,coupledwitheffortstoincreasethenumberofdentists inallareasofthestatewhoacceptpublicinsurance,willresultinmorelowincome childrenreceivingtheproperoralhealthassessment,treatment,andpreventiveoral healthcaretheyneed.
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 11
ProperNutrition
Q:
Whatarethebarrierstoachievingahealthylifeforpoorandlowincome childrenandyouthintheareaofpropernutrition?
A:
Providingpropernutritionisdifficultforlowincomefamilieson limitedbudgets.
Propernutritionisavitalcomponentofhealthyliving forchildrenandyouth.Yetwhenfamilieshavelow incomes,itcanbeastruggletopurchase enoughfoodforthefamily,letalonethemore costlynutritiousfoodthatchildrenandyouth needforproperdevelopmentandrobust immunesystems.Over12percentofIllinois householdsexperiencefoodinsecurityor 59 hunger. Familiesareincreasinglyrelyingon supportstoensurethattheirchildrendo notgohungry: Nearly820,000Illinoischildrenreceived FoodStampsin2006makingupnearly 60 halfofallIllinoisFoodStamprecipients. 46%ofIllinoisstudentsreceivedschool lunchesin2006throughtheNational SchoolLunchProgram,afederally assistedmealprogramoperatingin schoolsforlowincomechildrenupfrom 61 42%in2001. Familieswhoarestrugglingtogetbyare oftenforcedtotakemeasurestomakefood lastlonger.Thismaymeanskippingbreakfast beforeschooloronlyeatingbreakfast sporadically.Missingbreakfastand experiencinghungerleadtoavarietyof negativehealthandeducational outcomes: Childrenexperiencinghungerhavelower mathscoresandaremorelikelytohave 62 torepeatagrade. Behavioral,emotional,andacademic problemsaremoreprevalentamongchildren 63 experiencinghunger. Youthwhodonoteatbreakfasttendtohave ahigherbodymassindex,anindicationof 64 beingoverweightorobese.
PercentofChildrenReceiving FoodStamps,2006
12
BuildingonourSuccess
ProperNutrition
Q:
Whatcanwedotoensureallchildrenandyouthhaveaccesstothecarethey needtobecomehealthy,productiveadults?
A:
Implementuniversalschoolbreakfastindistrictswithhigh percentagesoflowincomestudents.
TheSchoolBreakfastProgramreduceshungeramonglowincomechildrenwhile improvingtheirhealthandnutrition.Childrenandyouthwhoeatbreakfasthaveincreased schoolattendance,aremoreattentive,havehigheracademicachievement,fewerschoolnurse visits,fewerclassroomdisciplineproblems,andarefarlesslikelytobeoverweightsinceskipping 65 breakfastisassociatedwithobesity. TheNationalSchoolLunchProgramandtheSchoolBreakfastProgramareimportanttoolsin guaranteeingthatlowincomechildrenhavenutritiousfoodintheirstomachstogetthemthrough theschooldayandmaximizetheirlearningpotential.InIllinois,theChildhoodHungerReliefAct mandatesthatschoolswithover40percentofstudentseligiblefortheLunchProgramalsooffer eligiblestudentstheoptionofbreakfast.Despitethismandateandthewelldocumentedbenefitsof ahealthybreakfasttostartachildsdayoffright: LessthanonethirdofIllinoislowincome(i.e.freeandreducedpriceeligible)studentswho 66 receiveSchoolLunchonanaveragedayalsoparticipateintheSchoolBreakfastProgram. Betweenthe20042005andthe20052006schoolyear,thenumberofIllinoislowincome studentsintheSchoolBreakfastProgramgrewbyover13%,yetIllinoisstillhasthesecond 67 lowestpercentageoflowincomestudentsparticipatingintheprograminthecountry. IntheChicagoPublicSchoolsystem,only29%oflowincomeSchoolLunchstudentsparticipate 68 intheBreakfastProgram. Implementingauniversalbreakfastprogram,ratherthananoptionalprogram,inIllinois districtswithahighpercentageoflowincomestudentscansignificantlyincreaselow incomestudentparticipationintheprogramsinceitreducesstigmaandeliminatesfee barriersformanylowincomefamilies.Schooldistrictsthatofferbreakfastfreetoallstudents aremoresuccessfulinenrollinglowincomechildrenwhoaremostlikelytoneedbreakfast.Low incomestudentparticipationrisesevenmoreindistrictsthatmakebreakfastpartoftheschoolday 69 byservingbreakfastintheclassroom. RaisingparticipationintheSchoolBreakfastProgramwillalsoincreasefederaldollarsgoinginto schooldistricts.Forexample,iftheChicagoPublicSchooldistrictraisedparticipationintheSchool BreakfastProgramto70percentoftheLunchProgramarealisticachievementifuniversal breakfastwereimplementedthedistrictwouldreceiveanadditional$25.3millioninfederal fundingandwouldserveaneedednutritionalbreakfastto116,080additionallowincome 70 students.
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 13
Insurance
Q:
Whatcanwedotoensureallchildrenandyouthhaveaccesstothecarethey needtobecomehealthy,productiveadults?
A:
ManyolderyouthinIllinoislackhealthinsurancecoveragewhich limitstheirabilitytoaccesshealthcare.
Inrecentyears,Illinoishasprioritized insuringchildrenages0through18, yetyouththroughtheageof24 arenoteligibleforpublichealth insurancecoverage.Manyofthese youthdonothaveaccesstohealth insurancebecauseiftheyarenot enrolledinschool,theycannot typicallybeontheirparents insurance.Additionally,youthwhodo nothavechildrenoftheirownordo nothaveadisability,aretypicallynot eligibleforpublicinsurance.Manyof theseyouthareworkinginlowwage orentryleveljobsthatdonotoffer healthbenefitsorthatrequirethemto paysubstantialportionsofthecosts whichtheycannotaffordtodo. 19to24yearoldIllinoisans havethehighestrateof uninsuranceofanyage group.Whiletheseyouth compriseonly9percentofthe Illinoispopulation,theyrepresent 17percentofIllinoisuninsured population.Youthwithlow incomesaresignificantlymore likelytobeuninsuredthan 71 higherincomeyouth.
RatesofUninsuredIllinoisansbyAge,2006
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
30.0%
UninsuredIllinoisYouthAges19to24,2006, byIncome
50.0% 40.0% 30.0% 20.0% 47.2% 41.6% 27.9% 18.6% 13.0%
Whileconstitutingarelatively 10.0% healthygroup: Therateofinjuryfor18to24 0.0% yearoldsis19%higherthan 099%FPL 100% 200% 300% 400%FPL thatof0to17yearolds, 199%FPL 299%FPL 399%FPL andover 32%higherthanthatof25to 44yearolds,and102% higherthanthatof45to64 72 yearolds. Uninsuredpeoplewhoexperienceaccidentalinjuryarelesslikelytoreceiveanymedicalcare 73 andiftheydo,theyaretwiceaslikelytonotreceiveneededfollowupcare. 18to24yearoldsaretheleastlikelyofanyagegrouptohaveausualplacetogoformedical 74 care. 14
BuildingonourSuccess
Insurance
Q:
Whatcanwedotoensureallchildrenandyouthhaveaccesstothecarethey needtobecomehealthy,productiveadults?
A:
ExtendeligibilityofAllKidstoincludeyouththroughage24.
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 15
TheMid-AmericaInstituteonPoverty (MAIP)isthepolicyandresearcharmof
HeartlandAllianceforHumanNeeds&HumanRights.MAIPprovidesasourceofreliable informationanddatatoelectedofficials,governmentagencies,media,nonprofits, communitygroups,andotheradvocatestopromoteeffectivepolicies,programs,and systemschange.
HeartlandAllianceforHumanNeeds&HumanRights championsthe
humanrightsandimprovesthelivesofmen,women,andchildrenwhoarethreatenedby povertyordanger.Formorethan100years,Heartlandhasbeenprovidingsolutions throughservicesandpolicythatmoveindividualsfromcrisistostabilityandonto success.Heartlandsworkinhousing,healthcare,legalprotections,andeconomicsecurity servesmorethan100,000peopleannually,helpingthembuildbetterlives.
16
BuildingonourSuccess
Endnotes
Rich,R.F.,&Elkins,C.L.(n.d.).ChildrenshealthcareinIllinois:Whereareweandwherearewegoing?InC.Herring(Ed.), ThestateofthestateofIllinois,2006 (pp.7088).Chicago:Instituteof GovernmentandPublicAffairs,UniversityofIllinois. 2 Coughlin,T.A.,&Cohen,M.(2007,August). Aracetothetop:IllinoissAllKidsInitiative.WashingtonDC:UrbanInstitute&KaiserCommissiononMedicaidandtheUninsured. 3 Rich,R.F.,&Elkins,C.L.(n.d.).ChildrenshealthcareinIllinois:Whereareweandwherearewegoing?InC.Herring(Ed.), ThestateofthestateofIllinois,2006 (pp.7088).Chicago:Instituteof GovernmentandPublicAffairs,UniversityofIllinois. 4 Schwartz,K.(2007,June). Spotlightonuninsuredparents:Howa lackofcoverageaffectsparentsandtheirfamilies.KaiserLowIncomeCoverageandAccessSurvey.WashingtonDC:KaiserCommission onMedicaidandtheUninsured. 5 KaiserCommissiononMedicaidandtheUninsured.(2007,February). Healthcoverageforlowincomeparents.KeyFacts.WashingtonDC:Author. 6 Bouman,J.,Cohen,F.H.,Chizewer,D.J.,Altman,S.,&Yates,T.(2007,MayJune).Litigationtoimproveaccesstohealthcareforchildren:LessonsfromMemisovskiv.Maram. ClearinghouseReview, JournalofPovertyLawandPolicy,41,129. 7 U.S.CensusBureau,CurrentPopulationSurveyAnnualSocialandEconomicSupplement20052007,calculationconductedbytheMidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance. 8 Gershoff,E.T.,Aber,J.L.,&Raver,C.C.(2003).ChildpovertyintheU.S.:Anevidencebasedconceptualframeworkforprogramsandpolicies.InR.M.Lerner,F.Jacobs,&D.Wertlieb(Eds.),Promoting positivechild,adolescent,andfamilydevelopment:Ahandbookofprogramandpolicyinnovations (pp.81136).ThousandOaks,California:SagePublications. 9 Ibid. 10 Ibid. 11 Ibid. 12 Ibid. 13 Duncan,G.J.,BrooksGunn,J.,&Klebanov,P.K.(1994).Economicdeprivationandearlychildhooddevelopment. ChildhoodDevelopment,65,296318. 14 Ibid andKalil,A.K.,&ZiolGuest,K.M.(2006,May8). Lifetimeincomelevel,stability,andgrowth:Linkstochildrensbehavior,achievement,andhealth.Chicago:CenterforHumanPotentialandPublic Policy,TheHarrisSchoolofPublicPolicyStudies,UniversityofChicago. 15 U.S.CensusBureau,CurrentPopulationSurveyAnnualSocialandEconomicSupplement20052007,calculationconductedbytheMidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance. 16 U.S.CensusBureau,AmericanCommunitySurvey2006, calculationconductedbytheMidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance. 17 AnnieE.CaseyFoundation.(2006). Kidscountstateleveldataonline. RetrievedMay2,2007,fromhttp://www.kidscount.org 18 U.S.CensusBureau,AmericanCommunitySurvey2006,calculationconductedbytheMidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance. 19 Ibid. 20 AnnieE.CaseyFoundation.(2006). Kidscountstateleveldataonline. RetrievedAugust7,2007,fromhttp://www.kidscount.org 21 NationalSurveyofChildrensHealth. (2003).IllinoisStateProfile.RetrievedMay31,2007,fromhttp://nschdata.org/DataQuery/ 22 Ibid. 23 Ibid. 24 AnnieE.CaseyFoundation.(2003). Kidscountstateleveldataonline. RetrievedMay31,2007,fromhttp://www.kidscount.org 25 Ibid. 26 IllinoisDepartmentofPublicHealth.(2007,April).Adolescentsatrisk:StatisticsonHIV/AIDS,STDs,andunintendedpregnancy. RetrievedAugust10,2007,from http://www.idph.state.il.us/aids/materials/adol_hiv_fs.htm 27 U.S.DepartmentofHealth&HumanServices,SubstanceAbuseandMentalHealthServicesAdministration,OfficeofAppliedStudies.(2007,April). NationalSurveyonDrugUseandHealth,2004and 2005.RetrievedAugust10,2007,fromhttp://www.oas.samhsa.gov/geography.htm 28 NationalSurveyofChildrensHealth. (2003).DataQuery. RetrievedMay31,2007,fromhttp://nschdata.org/DataQuery/ 29 Ibid. 30 NationalSurveyofChildrensHealth. (2003).DataQuery. RetrievedMay31,2007,fromhttp://nschdata.org/DataQuery/,calculationconductedbytheMidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartland Alliance. 31 Juszczak,L.,Melinkovich,P.,Kaplan,D.(2003).Useofhealthandmentalhealthservicesbyadolescentsacrossmultipledeliverysites. JournalofAdolescentHealth,32S,108118. 32 Kaplan,D.W.,Calonge,B.N.,Guernsey,B.P.,Hanrahan,M.B.(1998).ManagedcareandSBHCs.Useofhealthservices.ArchivesofPediatricandAdolescentMedicine,152(1),2533. 33 Kisker,E.E.,&Brown,R.S.(2002).DoSBHCsimproveadolescentsaccesstohealthcare,healthstatus,andrisktakingbehavior?JournalofAdolescentHealth,18,335343. 34 Hall,L.S.(2001).FinalReport YouthandFamilyCentersProgram20002001 (REIS011722).Dallas:DallasIndependentSchoolsDistrict,YouthandFamilyCentersProgram. 35 Ibid. 36 Key,J.D.,Washington,E.C.,Hulsey,T.C.(2002).ReducedemergencydepartmentutilizationassociatedwithSBHCenrollment. JournalofAdolescentHealth,30,273278. 37 Santelli,J.,Kouzis,A.,etal.(1996).SBHCsandadolescentuse ofprimarycareandhospitalcare.JournalofAdolescentHealth,19,267275. 38 Webber,M.P.,Carpiniello,K.E.,Oruwariye,T.,Yungtai,L.,Burton,W.B.,&Appel,D.K.(2003).Burdenofasthmainelementaryschoolchildren:DoSBHCsmakeadifference?ArchivesofPediatricand AdolescentMedicine,157,125129. 39 Lurie,N.,Bauer,E.J.,Brady,C.(2001).AsthmaoutcomesinaninnercitySBHC.JournalofSchoolHealth,71(9),916. 40 Adams,E.K.,Johnson,V.(2000).AnelementarySBHC:canitreduceMedicaidcosts?Pediatrics,105(4Pt1),780788. 41 IllinoisCoalitionforSchoolHealthCenters.(n.d.). Reducingcosts,improvinghealth costsandbenefitsofIllinoisschoolhealthcenters. Chicago:IllinoisMaternalandChildHealthCoalition. 42 Melchiorre, D.(2006,November). Childrensmentalhealth.SpecialReport.Chicago:VoicesforIllinoisChildren. 43 Ibid. 44 NationalSurveyofChildrensHealth. (2003).IllinoisStateProfile.RetrievedMay31,2007,fromhttp://nschdata.org/Content/StatePrevalence.aspx?geo=Illinois 45 VanLandeghem,K.(2003,April). Childrensmentalhealth:AnurgentpriorityforIllinois.FinalReport.Chicago:IllinoisChildrensMentalHealthTaskForce. 46 NationalSurveyofChildrensHealth. (2003).DataQuery. RetrievedMay31,2007,fromhttp://nschdata.org/DataQuery/ 47 VoicesforIllinoisChildren.(2007). Illinoiskidscount2007:Thestateofchildrenshealth.Chicago:Author. 48 NationalInstituteofMentalHealth.(2005,June6). Mentalillnessexactsheavytoll,beginninginyouth.PressRelease.RetrievedAugust20,2007,fromhttp://www.nimh.nih.gov/press/mentalhealthstats.cfm 49 IllinoisDepartmentofFinancialandProfessionalRegulation.(2007,June22). RosterofLicensedClinicalSocialWorkersinIllinois.Onfile withauthor. 50 Whitaker,T.,Weismiller,T.,&Clark,E.(2006). Assuringthesufficiencyofafrontlineworkforce:Anationalstudyoflicensedsocialworkers. Executivesummary.WashingtonDC:NationalAssociationof SocialWorkers. 51 nd U.S.Departmentof HealthandHumanServices.(2000,November).HealthyPeople2010.2 ed.WashingtonDC:U.S.GovernmentPrintingOffice. 52 Ibid. 53 IFLOSS.(2007,Spring). OralhealthcareinIllinois:Comprehensivecareforchildren&families.TheIllinoisOralHealthPlanII.Springfield,IL:IllinoisDepartmentofPublicHealth. 54 Ibid. 55 NationalSurveyofChildrensHealth.(2003).DataQuery. RetrievedJune15,2007,fromhttp://nschdata.org/DataQuery/ 56 IFLOSS.(2007,Spring). OralhealthcareinIllinois:Comprehensivecareforchildren&families.TheIllinoisOralHealthPlanII.Springfield,IL:IllinoisDepartmentofPublicHealth. 57 nd U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.(2000,November).HealthyPeople2010.2 ed.WashingtonDC:U.S.GovernmentPrintingOffice. 58 IFLOSS.(2007,Spring). OralhealthcareinIllinois:Comprehensivecareforchildren&families.TheIllinoisOralHealthPlanII.Springfield,IL:IllinoisDepartmentofPublicHealth. 59 Nord,M.,Andrews,M.,&Carlson,S.(2006,November). HouseholdfoodsecurityintheUnitedStates,2005.EconomicResearchReportNumber29.WashingtonDC:U.S.DepartmentofAgriculture EconomicResearchService. 60 IllinoisDepartmentofHumanServices,BureauofResearch&Analysis(2007,June). Countof personsreceivingFoodStampsduringcalendaryear2006.Onfilewithauthor. 61 IllinoisStateBoardofEducation.(n.d.). Nutritionprograms,FreeandReducedPriceMealeligibilitydata.RetrievedDecember6,2006,from http://www.isbe.state.il.us/nutrition/htmls/eligibility_listings.htm,calculationconductedbytheMidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance. 62 FoodResearchandActionCenter.(n.d.). Breakfastforlearning.ChildNutritionFactSheet.WashingtonDC:Author. 63 Ibid. 64 Ibid. 65 Levin,M.(2007,August). SchoolbreakfastinAmericasbigcities.WashingtonDC:FoodResearchandActionCenter. 66 Cooper,R.,Levin,M.,Adach,J.,Parker,L.,&Weill,J.(2006,December). Schoolbreakfastscorecard2006.WashingtonDC:FoodResearchandActionCenter. 67 Ibid. 68 Levin,M.(2007,August). SchoolbreakfastinAmericasbigcities.WashingtonDC:FoodResearchandActionCenter. 69 Ibid. 70 Ibid. 71 U.S.CensusBureau,CurrentPopulationSurvey20052007AnnualSocialandEconomicSupplement,Microdata,calculationconductedbytheMidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance. 72 CenterforDiseaseControlandPrevention,NationalCenterforHealthStatistics,HealthDataforAllAges.(2007). Healthcareaccessanduse,Injuryvisitstotheemergencydeptbyintentandmechanism, allages:U.S.,20022004.RetrievedJune11,2007,fromhttp://209.217.72.34/hdaa/ReportFolders/ReportFolders.aspx 73 Hadley,J.(2007,March).Insurancecoverage,medicalcareuse,andshorttermhealth changesfollowinganunintentionalinjuryortheonsetofachroniccondition. JournalofAmericanMedicalAssociation, 297(10),10731084. 74 CenterforDiseaseControlandPrevention,NationalCenterforHealthStatistics(2007,June). Earlyreleaseofselectedestimatesbasedondatafromthe2006NationalHealthInterviewSurvey Usualplace togoformedicalcare.Hyattsville,MD:Author. 75 Hadley,J.(2002,May).Sickerandpoorer:Theconsequencesofbeinguninsured.WashingtonDC:KaiserCommission onMedicaidandtheUninsured. 76 Ibid. 77 Dorn,S.(2004,September). Towardsincrementalprogress:Keyfactsaboutgroupsofuninsured.WashingtonDC:EconomicandSocialResearchInstitute.
MidAmericaInstituteonPovertyofHeartlandAlliance 17