Page --California eview--SeptemberBy Midge DecterThe itle f my alk an ardly ven e calledrhetorical uestion. veryone n this oom nowsthe est s n anger.hy lse, ndeed,re e ere fnot o ake ounselbout hat ery act? he ruth swe have ll ome, ven f y eparateoutes, o hesame ense f urgency. peaking or yself, wouldsay t s erribleense f rgency,red n he deacannot hake oose: hat e ave ever een loser olosing hat hich t has een ur nique istoricalprivilegeo be he uardiansf. mean, f ourse,nothing lse han ur ery reedom. hat reedom snowadays hreatened n many ays. gain, neednot ist hem ll n his ompany.There s, or nstance,o need o peak ere fSoviet eapons nd he lmost ninterrupted,ra-zen ncroachmentsf Soviet deology. ny eadingof one’s orning aper s a sufficienteminder fboth. or do I aim to speak f the dequacy rinadequacyf the resent dministrationrespond-ing o hose ncroachments.here live, t east -which ately eels o me as f it is n the huttlebetween ew ork nd ashington - we have eenspeaking f little lse or early year ow. urdisappointments n inverse atio o ur igh opes-- he irst n ecades- f year go. ut here redangers o freedom hat he eagan dministration,or any ther dministration,an o nothing bout,for hey tem rom ut- elationo ife nd eality-and t s ne f hese hat wish o all ttentionotoday.ht he nd, elievet s far ore ntractableridpossibly ar ore ivisive anger han ither heaggressivenessf ur nemy r he o ar ess-than-forceful esponses f our government o it. Thedanger ant eferringo is hat ontainedn a sim-ple, eadly, orrosive uestion. his uestion,spoken r nspoken,s in the ir ll round s. tinfuses ur uhure, t dogs he ducation l ourchildren,nd t eeps, nh’ss e are ternallyig-ilant, nto he ery arrow f our ),mes. t islil,eral uestion,mdamentally,ut alling ur-selves onservativesill ot. y itself,)rote(tfrom ts imple,eadly,orrosiveffectsn ur ri-
vate pirits nd n ur ublic ouduct.he uestionI mean s expressed n two hort ords hat, uttogethernd ombinedith he nterrogative,ight
nowadays ust e the wo ost otent ords n theEnglish anguage.hey rt’. So hat?" s in, ohnh,ves ary - so what? s in, precious onstitu-tional rinciple s being iolated - so what? swhen he ovel r fihn r play r music urrentlybeing outed s a profound asterpiecey our uhu-ral tandardbearerss ctually piece f eritriciousjunk - so what? One ould nowadays pply hisformulation n immediately ecognizable ays ojust bout very rea f life - private, ommunal,national, nternational;o sex, o amily bliga-tions, o uhurai tandards,o ur entandsn ub-lit fficials,o ur eading f heir emands n s,md o ur ense,r ack f ense,f esponsibilityo
Is the est n Danger?
the orld t arge.The est uropeansre n a course f surrender-ing hemselvesoluntarilyo he himate nroads fSovietization?ell, et hem. e an urely efendour wn orders. lectionshat o not roduce hedesired esuhs an e negotiatedway n he erviceof ublic elationsr social onvenience?ell, sthat ot he ay the orld eally orks nyway?Why kid ourselves? ach edding e now attendfeels ot ike sacramentalnitiationnto he idesand urrentsf man’s ruitfulojourn n arth, utrather ike throw f the ice? ell, fter ll, e¯ have new et f ocial elationseplacinghe ld.But here s ne rea f our ocial ttitudesnwhich he ynicism nd espair f "So hat?" eemsto me to have ecome ost articularlyervasiveand hreatening.his rea, suppose,s ffectedy
the resentovernment’sailureo ct. ut he peed
and ase, ith hich t ook ver ra he irst lacemust ell s something e cannot eny bout hedeeper ickly onditionf ur ationalthos.I am speakinghout he ear bliterationf whatwe refer o n he horthandl publi( iscussionsthe dea f erit nd ts ubstitutiony he dea fgroup r lass ntitlement.his ubstitutions not,and ever as een, s ts roponentslaim, n ssueof usticer ven, s any f ts pponentslaim, nissueofnjustice.t s, nd lways as een, matterof cynicism,lain nd imple. eare acing prob-lem aused y the aldistributionf achievementsand wards? ery ell, hen, e hall - y fiat -declare he ature f chievementull nd oid. nddo ot eceive ourselves;ffirmativection s notonly a matter of employment nd educationalaccreditation.omorrow,s e see, t ill ouch heelectoralrocesstself;ndeed,t s lreadyoing t),
and rom here t will ouch verything.hat s hya stroke f Reagan’s en. hough t would lakevery reat ifleren(e,ill ot y tselfufficeo id
us f this piritualancer. basi, rincil)leis-mantled ill. ike uml)ty umpty, ot o asily it’put ogethergain. nd he asic rincipleere oesdeeper han quality f pportunity,hough his nitself s he ne ruly evolutionaryiscoveryf hemodern orld - our ation’s iscovery,y irtue fwhich e have een he ne enignly evolutionarynation n odern istory. evertheless,he rinci-ple oes eeperven han hat. t s, ike he uestionthat mderminest, hlindinglyimph’ rinciple:that reality ounts or omething. hat t hasweight hat t as eaning,nd ill ot e enied.I ave aid hat ffirmative(tion,he ost erfectexample f "So hat?", s not eally matter femploymentnd ducation.hat was eferring ois the nderlyingessage f this olicy, messagetaken o eart ll ver his ociety;hat verythingsa fraud, racket, deal, n arrangement.ork snothing; tanding s verything.hat ne eeds nthis ife - nti here s ot n ssue f women’smagazine, or nstance, hat oes ot omewherecarry n rticle r a passage f an rticle ointingthis ut - is not mbition,nergy, raining,ndthat ne ndispensablend completely ncommen-surable rait or uccess alled, here come rom,"moxy." ne oes ot eed hese hings. hat neneeds s n%work - ld-boy,ld-girl,r racial.Look t any ist f rants warded y major oun-dations.ook t any ist f literaryr ournalisticprizes, f honorary egrees, f appointments oboards, f wards hat arry old laques, nd ouwill ee he ork f a committeehich y now oesnot eed o calculate ercentages,or they reimprintedn the ery ervous ystem. oes ll hismatter? here s that nsidiousuestion gain. tmatters - nothing ore. Take something, orexample, hat ight ot ound ery mportant.achfavorable eview f a book he eviewer imselfkr~ows o be bad ut s the ork f a woman, r ablack, r homosexual,r ust n nemy f rdinarylife and e ee uch review,omewhere,very ay)is a blow t he ropositionhat here s good ndbad, orthy nd nworthy, ealthy nd nhealthy;in short, blow t the ropositionhat ife sweighty nd as onsequences.ach low t thisproposition roduces nother ivorce, notherdeserted hild, nother ecision o abort he etusthat mniocentesiseveals o be mperfect,notherimpulse o pull he lug n a sick arent, notherhomosexual, nother ugging.Am I being xtreme? ll his rom ffirmativeaction?es. ll his rom he ame ense f ife hatmade ffirmativection easibleolicy.ll his, n
other ords, rom So hat?" ut hat, ou ightask, oes his ave o o ith he act hat 00 S-20’sare ointed t urope; hat new oviet leet ailsthe even eas; hat ur uropeanllies re, ithoutsaying o, onsideringhe ossibilityf urrenderand hat n order o heedle hem nto econsideringwe disastrously end negotiators o Geneva rVienna; hat he oviets ave aunched he ostmassive ropaganda ampaign ra hree ecades odisarm s and hat e have ad o stand y sheep-ishly s this ampaign as wept cross ur wnshores nd hrown ur opulace nd ur oliticiansinto eep onfusion?he nswer s -- verything.thas verythingo do ith hese hings. hose ovietmissiles,hips, nd ies re eing rmed n all hemore eadly ashion y our wn ecay. e have ot-- not et - applied ur o dangerousuestion othe rospect f Soviet onquest,ut e are omingclose. do ot hink n he nd e ould o o - ut"in he nd" s oo ate.A few ears go, he ew York imes arriedstory bout n antidraftemonstrationt PrincetonUniversity. think t was ntidraft.he ccasionwas orgettable,lendednto o many thers ike t.What was unforgettable, owever, as the newsphoto hat ccompaniedhe tory. t as f a youngman - healthy,ital, rivileged,anned, o oubt,by he uns f kiing n Vermont nd eaching n heVirgin slands. e was arrying placard m whichwas crawled he motto. There s nothing orthdying or." e is our child, hat oung an. edesperately o not ish or im o die. ut hisannouncementn that lacard s an announcementabout ore han he raft, ore han uclear ea-lions, ore han ar. e who ays here s nothingworth ying or ays here s nothing orth ivingfor.We, s a society, ave ome easure f esponsi-bility or he essage n that lacard,or he actthat young merican - the ealthiest,uckiest,most enderly reated oung an n history, t theheight f is hysicalnd exual owers, archingaround hat retty, retty own n a day f brightsunshine- e ave onte esponsibilityor he actthat ie ould ind othing f value ave is wnskin; either other, or ather, or ith, or in,nor tmntry, or od. ietzsche aid hat e whovalues nly taying live as he ind f slave.Until e take t upon urselveso make hat oyfree nan - oth: ree rrd man - the ontinuedsurvivalt ur wlr reedoms nalion ill ol ieassured.This peech as iven t the nnual eeting fthe /uladelphiamietv n Chicago pril 7, O82.Midge ecter s the xecutiveirectorf The om-m ittee or ire ree orld, omposed[ hum er ]eminentitthorsnd ~,holar.~n oth ~ides [ ire
Atlantic.ormerly he enior ditor [ Basic ooksand xecutiveditor [ arper’s,iss ecter s theauthor ] The ew hastity nd Liberal arents,Radical hildren.First rinted y the ock]ord nstitute’scca-sional aperseries.September--Californiaeview--Page
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii Iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii ii iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII I IIIIII I II II IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
Letters
Dear r. Young:Congratulations.t s lively,iterate,nd un o
read. ll he est o ou.Yours ordially,William . Buckley, r.New YorkCaliforniaeview,I think our ublications urely nd tterlytu-pendous. he it, umor, nd iting hastisementsof he eft re nequaledn ny ublication haveencounteredately. eep p the ood ork.Thank ou,John MabieSan DiegoP.S. am currently ttending an iego esa ol-lege nd ill e at CSD or he inter ession extyear. am ooking orward o y transfernd lan oparticipatectivelyn he niversity’sonservative
movement. lease ontact e with nformation npresent ndeavorsnd uture lans f he aliforniaReview nd he College epublicans f UCSD.Viva onservatismlGo ReaganP.S.S. hanks or he ip n Glider’s ook; t wasgreat.Dear ric,Thank ou or ending e the alifornia eview.I read very ord nd as elighted. thoroughlyagree ith our tand n affirmative ction ndthought t as ery ell xpressed.nd was nter-ested nd mused y other rticles. here id ouget he Cruikshank rawings?Love,GrannyBurge lantationMansfield, eorgiaDear Mr. Young,We ope or he uccess ,[ our ew ublication.My husband s scientistngaged n ancer esearch(mon(x;Ionalntibody nd umor ntigen) t ScrippsClinic.Many cientistselieve hat nly iberalsupportresearch.e would ike o orrect hat mpression.My husband nd would e happy o contributeshort rticleo our aper. lease all s f ou reinterested¯Best egards,G.L. eisfeldLa JollaAn Open etter o the aliforniaeview.We find your attempt t right-wing, seudo-satiricalournalismo be tastelessnd utless n
additiono its dmittedlitist,acist, exist,nd
ageist iewpoint.While ou obviously hink that hin uise ofhumor ill emper he erocity f your emarks efind hat his ather eeble ttempt t satire nlyemphasizes our lready rchaic ttitudes. our"President" nd Editress" ounded he aper opreserve he "American ay." his questionableattempt t ournalismertainlyarries his ut. oupreserve he merican ay f blindnessnd nepti-tude n ealing ith he est f tbe orld.We cannot all or ou o ease ublication.e,thankfully,o ot ave hat ight. ut e an all nanyone ho reads our eriodical o leave ourstacks f papers ntouched pon ublication. fyour dvertiserso ot ee ny ignificantircula-tion hey ertainlyand opefully)ill iscontinuetheir upport. e also all pon ll CSD tudentsand taff o oycott our dvertisers:onoco an ilconglomerate),ee ory ift tore, a Jolla arber-ing nd tyling, he oggery hop, illy ulitzerresortwear,nd oors an ppressiveutfit o eginwith).We are ending opies f this etter o the ewindicator nd o the CSD uardian. hile e maynot lways gree ith heir tance n issues, eknow hat hey elieve n equal ime.Jean anglerDean H. HaasEditor’sote:Californiaadicalsre miserableot. or long
time his ampus as been he urf f ideologueblockheadsith esigns n replacingur onstitu-tional ystem ith heir ighschoolerm rojects.Leftistsre, nderstandably,hreatenedy he ros-
pect f more nformationeaching heir heep. oy-cotts, amecalling,bscene hone alls nd therMcCarthyactics,owever,on’t arry ny ntellec-
tual eight.What akes hese olks fraid?s t ecausehey’rewitless? he urrent isdom s that olzhenitsynwas nvented y the IA.--ECY
alifornia
(;redo:We few, e happy ew, or ie ho icks pthis aper oday hall e ~, rother,e hene’er o vile, his aper ill entle iscondition.E. lasenoung ..............................residentH.W. rockerlI .....................rigadierditorC. randonrocker..............usiness anagerContributingditors:Suzanne . Schott, ruce acdonald7ontributors:Jeffrey art, teve elley, reg edmond,ichaelLitt, mmeline e Pillis, atthew ayne, obMcKay, raham ottola, hristian earnJohn BridgemanCorrespondents:Lisa ullivan............................ashingtonAlisonoung ....................................SCVito arker................................ew YorkNicholaslden orehouse...............hicagoThomasiegand................................aleAdam achtel.................................assarLake orest ony dvisor:James impson llChie[ aloon orrespondent:Michael ’TooleExecutive istributionoordinator:Mark P. DiamondLegal ounsel:The reen eretsPlease ddress ll ’tter.~,anu.wripts,nd lanJrheckso."(;alilorniaeview¯ 8.t6 arrlo ;rarldeDel ar, A 921)1,1A conservative ournal s a terrible hing owaste. Give to the California eview, not-for-profit organization. All contributionsare tax-deductible.
Add a Comment