Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.
See Premium Plans
 
COMMONWEALTHOFMASSACHUSETTSSUPREMEJUDICIALCOURTSUFFOLKCOUNTYNO.SJC-11052CHARLESDIORIO,Petitioner-Appellant
V.
FIRSTJUSTICEOFTHEQUINCYDIV.OFTHEDIST.COURTDEP'T,Respondent-AppelleeTRUSTEESOFBOSTONUNIVERSITYd/b/aWBUR-FM
&
OPENCOURT,IntervenerBRIEFANDADDENDUMFORTHEPETITIONER/APPELLANTONRESERVATIONANDREPORTOFTHECASEBYTHESINGLEJUSTICETOTHEFULLCOURTJOHNFENNELBBO#666159ATTORNEYFORPETITIONER/APPELLANTCOMMITTEEFORPUBLICCOUNSELSERVICESPublicDefenderDivision44BromfieldStreetBoston,Massachusetts02108(617)482-6212jfennel@publiccounsel.netOctober,2011.
 
-i-TABLEOFCONTENTSTABLEOFAUTHORITIESiiiISSUESPRESENTED.................................1STATEMENTOFTHECASE............................2STATEMENTOFFACTS.....-..........................3SUMMARYOFTHEARGUMENT10ARGUMENTI.THETRIALCOURTJUDGEDIDNOTPERFORMHISAFFIRMATIVEDUTYTOMINIMIZEPRE-TRIALPUBLICITYTOPROTECTDIORIO'SRIGHTTODUEPROCESSOFLAWANDAFAIRTRIAL,VIOLATINGARTICLE12ASWELLASTHEFIFTH,SIXTH,ANDFOURTEENTHAMEND-MENTS13A.ThetrialjudgedidnotprotectDiorio'srighttoafairtrial13B.TurningoffOpenCourt'scameraandrecordingdevicewouldnotcontravenethepress'sfirstamendmentrightofaccesstocourtproceedings25II.BYALLOWINGOPENCOURTTOBROADCASTLIVEFROMTHECOURTROOMOVERDIORIO'SOBJECTION,THETRIALCOURTJUDGEUNDERMINEDDIORIO'SRIGHTTOTHEASSISTANCEOFCOUNSELUNDERARTICLE12ANDSIXTHANDFOURTEENTHAMENDMENT29III.THEDECISIONTOALLOWOPENCOURTTOPOSTDIORIO'SHEARINGSONTHEINTERNETWASANABUSEOFDISCRETIONBECAUSETHEREWASGOODCAUSEFORIMPOUNDMENTOFTHERECORDINGSANDREMOVINGTHERECORDINGSFROMTHEINTERNETISNOT"PRIORRESTRAINT"38
 
-ii-A.TheQuincyDistrictCourtisentangledwith
OpenCourt
38B.TheproperanalysisforwhetherOpenCourtrecordingsshouldberemovedfromtheonlinearchiveas"impoundment"analysis,not"priorrestraint"analysis40C.Therewas'goodcause'toredactDiorio'simagefromtheOpenCourtrecording42D.Evenif"priorrestraint"analysisapplies,thejudgeabusedhisdiscretioninnotpreventingOpenCourtfromarchivingtherecording
online
44CONCLUSION46ADDENDUM47CERTIFICATEOFCOMPLIANCE63
Search
Search History:
Searching...
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
  • p.

    • More From This User

    3 p.
    Commonwealth vs. Shubar Charles and Commonwealth vs. Hector Milette
    WBUR
    140 Reads
    1 p.
    Death certificate for Boston Marathon bombing suspect Tamerlan Tsar...
    WBUR
    222 Reads
    17 p.
    Criminal Complaint Against Robel Phillipos
    WBUR
    5022 Reads
    17 p.
    Criminal Complaint Against Azamat Tazhayakov And Dias Kadyrbayev
    WBUR
    7162 Reads
    9 p.
    Transcript: Dzhokhar Tsarnaev Bedside Court Hearing In Hospital
    WBUR
    3507 Reads
    11 p.
    Federal Charges Against Suspected Marathon Bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev
    WBUR
    2256 Reads
    12 p.
    Found Samples - Jamaica Plain Drug Lab
    WBUR
    1026 Reads
    3 p.
    HPC Informational Calculation - Surcharge Payor Assessment
    WBUR
    696 Reads
    1 p.
    IMG_9947
    WBUR
    580 Reads
    10 p.
    Supreme Judicial Court Justice Rules in Favor of OpenCourt
    WBUR
    1078 Reads
    11 p.
    Judge Stearns Decision On Bulger Trial Recusal
    WBUR
    1138 Reads
    5 p.
    Book Excerpt: "Monster" By Dave Zeltserman
    WBUR
    1344 Reads
    19 p.
    The Decision of Suffolk Superior Civil Court Judge Peter M. Lauriat.
    WBUR
    830 Reads
    19 p.
    Decision from Suffolk Superior Civil Court Judge Peter M. Lauriat
    WBUR
    437 Reads
    19 p.
    Decision from Suffolk Superior Civil Court Judge Peter M. Lauriat
    WBUR
    969 Reads
    19 p.
    Decision from Suffolk Superior Civil Court Judge Peter M. Lauriat
    WBUR
    381 Reads
    24 p.
    Quincy Court Justices Opposition Filing (SJC-2012-308)
    WBUR
    987 Reads
    1 p.
    Gov. Deval Patrick's Statement On Mass. Crime Bill
    WBUR
    658 Reads
    82 p.
    OpenCourt Supreme Judicial Court Exhibits -- 07/27/2012
    WBUR
    935 Reads
    22 p.
    OpenCourt Memo to Supreme Judicial Court -- 07/27/2012
    WBUR
    1094 Reads
    6 p.
    Supreme Judicial Court Ruling Recognizing Vermont Civil Unions
    WBUR
    491 Reads
    2 p.
    Boston Superintendent Johnson Letter To Union On 'Project Promise' ...
    WBUR
    703 Reads
    17 p.
    District Attorney Complaint for Injunctive Relief
    WBUR
    980 Reads
    17 p.
    Da Complaint for Reliief
    WBUR
    430 Reads
    34 p.
    CPCS Complaint for Injunctive Relief
    WBUR
    629 Reads
    Notes
    Load more