Read without ads and support Scribd by becoming a Scribd Premium Reader.
See Premium Plans
 
UNITEDSTATESINTERNATIONALTRADECOMMISSIONWashington,D.C.20436BeforetheHonorableDeannaTannerOkunChairmanIntheMatterofInvestigationNo.337-TA-710ERTAINPERSONALDATAANDMOBILECOMMUNICATIONSDEVICESANDRELATEDSOFTWAREREPLYCOMMENTSOFTHEASSOCIATIONFORCOMPETITIVETECHNOLOGYINRESPONSETOTHECOMMISSION'SSEPTEMBER21,2011REQUESTFORWRITTENSUBMISSIONSONTHEISSUESOFREMEDY,THEPUBLICINTERESTANDBONDING
 
TABLEOFCONTENTS
LINTRODUCTION1II.THECOMMISSIONPLAYSACRITICALROLEASGATEKEEPERAGAINSTUNFAIRIMPORTS3III.REPLYTOGOOGLE'SSUBMISSION
.4
A.
Google'sSubmissionAskstheCommissionToBroadenItsAnalysisofthePublicInterestBeyondtheBoundariesofSection337
.4
B.
Android'sPurported"OpenPlatform"StatusDoesNotJustifyIgnoringthePatentLaws8I.AndroidIsNotan"OpenPlatform"9a.AndroidHoneycomb'sSourceCodeIsClosed9b.Android"CompatibilityRequirements".102.OpenSourceIsSubjecttotheSamePatentLawsasAllOthers
in
theMarketplace12C.TheInterest
in
ProtectingPatentRightsOutweighsAnyConceivableHarmtoCompetitiveConditionsandthePublicHealthandWelfare.l41.GoogleFocusesontheHarmResultingfromUndefined"InjunctiveRelief'NottheHarmthatWouldResultFromtheSpecificScopeofanExclusionOrder152.AnExclusionOrderWouldNotHarmCompetitionintheSmartphoneMarket153.AnExclusionOrderWouldNotHarmthePublicHealthandWelfare.....17IV.REPLYTOHTC'SSUBMISSION.18
A.
HTC'sClaimthatIts4GMobileProductsAreIrreplaceableIsFaulty181.HTC'sClaimthat
It
Manufactures50%ofAll4GHandsetsIsMisleading,as40HandsetsRepresentaNewMarketandThereIsMuchDebateastoWheretheDividingLineBetween"3G"and"4G"Stands.182.Evenasthe40MarketCurrentlyStands,HTCImproperlyAssertsthatits40ProductsLackCompetitiveSubstitutes.19B.Like,orDirectlyCompetitiveAlternativestoHTC'sAndroidPhonesareReadilyAvailable19
11
 
1.HTC'sArgumentthatCompetitors'OfferingsCannotReplaceHTC'sPortfolioofDevicesIgnoresthatSmartphoneMarketSharesEvolveRapidly
19
2.HICFailstoConsiderthatSuitableAlternativestoHTC'sAndroidDeviceAlreadyExist
21
V.
CONCLUSION22
III
Search
Search History:
Searching...
Result 00 of 00
00 results for result for
  • p.

    • More From This User

    41 p.
    13-05-13 Google (Motorola) Reply Brief in Posner Appeal
    Florian_Muelle_439
    309 Reads
    7 p.
    13-05-09 Order Granting Apple Motion to Compel Google to Provide Se...
    Florian_Muelle_439
    366 Reads
    22 p.
    BlackBerry Amicus Brief on FRAND Issues (Appeal of J. Posner's Ruling)
    Florian_Muelle_439
    126 Reads
    34 p.
    Nokia's Amicus Curiae Brief on FRAND Issues (Appeal of J. Posner's ...
    Florian_Muelle_439
    227 Reads
    7 p.
    13-05-07 Apple Opposition to Google Et Al. Amicus Curiae Brief in S...
    Florian_Muelle_439
    1054 Reads
    23 p.
    13-05-03 Nokia Amicus Brief in Apple v Samsung Injunction Appeal
    Florian_Muelle_439
    181 Reads
    10 p.
    13-05-03 Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter Re. Breach Damages
    Florian_Muelle_439
    129 Reads
    3 p.
    13-05-03 Exhibit 6 to Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter
    Florian_Muelle_439
    115 Reads
    4 p.
    13-05-03 Exhibit 5 to Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter
    Florian_Muelle_439
    109 Reads
    3 p.
    13-05-03 Exhibit 4 to Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter
    Florian_Muelle_439
    108 Reads
    6 p.
    13-05-03 Exhibit 3 to Microsoft Response to Motorola Letter
    Florian_Muelle_439
    131 Reads
    5 p.
    13-05-03 Exhibit 2 to Microsoft Response to Motorola
    Florian_Muelle_439
    113 Reads
    3 p.
    13-05-03 Exhibit 1 to Microsoft Response to Motorola
    Florian_Muelle_439
    96 Reads
    8 p.
    13-05-01 Motorola Letter Re. Microsoft Damages Theories
    Florian_Muelle_439
    131 Reads
    7 p.
    13-05-01 Exhibits J-K to Motorola Letter Re. Microsoft Damages Theo...
    Florian_Muelle_439
    98 Reads
    77 p.
    13-05-01 Exhibits a-I to Motorola Letter Re. Microsoft Damages Theo...
    Florian_Muelle_439
    120 Reads
    4 p.
    13-05-01 Declaration in Support of Motorola Letter Re. Microsoft Da...
    Florian_Muelle_439
    133 Reads
    74 p.
    13-05-01 Apple v. Samsung Permanent Injunction Appeal Responsive Brief
    Florian_Muelle_439
    237 Reads
    3 p.
    13-04-29 Apple-Samsung Case Management Order (Limited Retrial Etc.)
    Florian_Muelle_439
    376 Reads
    3 p.
    13-04-25 Microsoft v Motorola FRAND Rate FoFaCoL - Unofficial Table...
    Florian_Muelle_439
    821 Reads
    207 p.
    13-04-25 Microsoft-Motorola FRAND Rate Determination
    Florian_Muelle_439
    2269 Reads
    10 p.
    13-04-16 Apple Declaration Regarding Patent Reexaminations
    Florian_Muelle_439
    514 Reads
    64 p.
    13-04-10 Apple v. Samsung Claim Construction Order
    Florian_Muelle_439
    944 Reads
    2 p.
    13-04-09 Order Denying Case Management Conference and Extending Mar...
    Florian_Muelle_439
    694 Reads
    2 p.
    13-04-02 Apple v. Samsung Case Management Order
    Florian_Muelle_439
    792 Reads
    Notes
    Load more