Welcome to Scribd, the world's digital library. Read, publish, and share books and documents. See more
Download
Standard view
Full view
of .
Look up keyword
Like this
4Activity
0 of .
Results for:
No results containing your search query
P. 1
Save Dimmeys. VCAT ORDER. P623 2011. Richmond Icon Pty Ltd v Yarra CC

Save Dimmeys. VCAT ORDER. P623 2011. Richmond Icon Pty Ltd v Yarra CC

Ratings: (0)|Views: 90|Likes:
Published by Save Dimmeys
VCAT P623/2011. FINAL ORDER. DETERMINATION OF APPEAL.
VCAT P623/2011. FINAL ORDER. DETERMINATION OF APPEAL.

More info:

Categories:Types, Business/Law
Published by: Save Dimmeys on Nov 09, 2011
Copyright:Attribution Non-commercial

Availability:

Read on Scribd mobile: iPhone, iPad and Android.
download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
See more
See less

07/22/2013

pdf

text

original

 
VICTORIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALADMINISTRATIVE DIVISIONPLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT LIST
VCAT REFERENCE NO. P623/2011PERMIT APPLICATION NO. PLN10/0734
CATCHWORDS
Application under section 77 of the
 Planning and Environment Act 
1987; Yarra Planning Scheme;Business 1 Zone; Heritage Overlays HO335 & 360; Proposal to Refurbish Heritage Building andConstruct New Buildings containing dwellings and offices extending 2-8 levels above the existing building with associated car parking and loading facilities; The acceptability of the glass tower; Internalamenity; Railway noise and vibration; External amenity impacts; Car parking provision; Traffic impacts; Need to design for possible derailment of train; Need for environmental audit; ESD detail.
APPLICANT
Richmond Icon Pty Ltd
RESPONSIBLE AUTHORITY
Yarra City Council
REFERRAL AUTHORITY &RESPONDENT
Director of Public Transport
RESPONDENTS
VicRoads, A Harris for Save Dimmey’s, R.Pinnell, D. Yeomans, B.J. Donaldson, P.Connole, J. Sturzaker, D. Dorow, R. Dunphy,A. Duffield, L. Moloney, P. Kollatos, S.Claney & R. Rixon, J. Grimwade, S. Duffield,C. & G. Katsabis, M. Phillipson & C. Pelham-Thorman, P. Tratt, A.& J. Tratt, Almost French(P. Chhor & K. Kouch), M. Drost for PlanningBacklash, D. Cousins, L. Reeves, J. Pearce andM. Fernon.
SUBJECT LAND
140-160 Swan Street, Richmond
WHERE HELD
Melbourne
BEFORE
Rachel Naylor, Presiding Member Michael Read, Member 
HEARING TYPE
Hearing
DATES OF HEARING
30-31 May, 1-3 June and 29 June 2011
DATE OF ORDER
8 November 2011
CITATION
 
VCAT Reference No. P623/2011 Page 2 of 55
ORDER
1
 
The decision of the Responsible Authority is set aside.2
 
In permit application PLN10/0734 a permit is granted and directed to beissued for the land at 140-160 Swan Street Richmond in accordance withthe endorsed plans and subject to the conditions set out in Appendix A. The permit allows:
 
Construction of a building and construction or carrying out of works,and use of land for the purpose of dwellings and offices (described inthe proposal as lofts) in B1Z; and
 
Reduction of the standard car parking requirement for the residential,office and retail land uses.Rachel Naylor 
Presiding Member
Michael Read
Member
APPEARANCES
For Richmond Icon Pty Ltd Mr N Tweedie, barrister instructed by BestHooper solicitorsHe called the following witnesses:
 
Mr A Biacsi, town planner of Contour Consultants;
 
Mr R Deutscher, architect of Woods Bagot;
 
Mr J Walsh, traffic engineer of CardnoGrogan Richards; and
 
Mr T Marks, acoustic engineer of MarshallDay Acoustics.The evidence of Mr J Wilkinson who preparedthe photomontage images was accepted by the parties so he was not called to present hisevidence.
 
VCAT Reference No. P623/2011 Page 3 of 55
For Yarra City Council Ms S Brennan, barrister instructed by Ms MMarcus of Maddocks solicitorsShe called the following witnesses:
 
Mr C Czarny, urban designer of HansenPartners;
 
Professor (Ms) D Reed, architect;
 
Ms C Dunstan, traffic engineer of TraffixGroup.For Respondents Mr S Lanza for VicRoadsMs E Bergin of Victorian GovernmentSolicitor’s Office for the Director of PublicTransportMs T Acreman, barrister by direct brief for Mr A Harris of Save Dimmey’sMr A McAllister for Swan Street TradersAssociationMr R PinnellMr L MoloneyMr M PhillipsonMr T Golding for Almost FrenchMr A DuffieldMs M Drost for Planning Backlash.

You're Reading a Free Preview

Download
scribd
/*********** DO NOT ALTER ANYTHING BELOW THIS LINE ! ************/ var s_code=s.t();if(s_code)document.write(s_code)//-->