Firm Aura Lopez Sandra Garcia Kamal U.

Howlader Bevmax Office Center Spartan Instiutional Research Stamell, Tabacco & Schager PUC Midwest Acquistion Integrated Strategies Trading Technologies International, Inc. Maria Fiorini Ramirez,Inc. Stamell & Schager, LLP Berkery, Noyes & Co Brookfield Properties Hyperion Capital Management Generali - US Branch Flemming Zulack & Williamson FolksAmerica Holding Company Generali-U.S. Branch WFP One Liberty Plaza LP Flemming Zulack & Williamson New York Life Care Health Plus Arch Insurance Company FolksAmerica Holding Company Zurich American Insurance Company Cleary, Gottlieb, Steen & Hamilton Royal Bank of Canada NASDAQ

Amount of Subsidy $287 $878 $2,310 $7,000 $10,500 $14,101 $15,750 $16,510 $65,000 $70,459 $79,162 $82,250 $160,000 $227,500 $242,500 $300,000 $300,000 $300,000 $300,000 $315,000 $607,000 $703,500 $785,000 $1,600,000 $1,700,000 $3,000,000 $9,666,000 $20,570,707

Address 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza 1 Liberty Plaza

Dates(s) awarded 2002 2002 2002 2005 2004

Agency LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC

2002 LMDC/ESDC 2004 LMDC/ESDC 2003 LMDC/ESDC 2005 LMDC/ESDC 2002 LMDC/ESDC 2002 2004, 2006 2003, 2005 2002, 2004 2002, 2003 2002 2002 2002 2003 2004 1996 2003, 2005 2002, 2004 2005 2002 2002 2004 LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC IDA LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC LMDC/ESDC IDA

* BRG - Business Retention Grant (program administered by the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation/Empire State Development Corporation) Sales Tax - These tax breaks were awarded by the Industrial Development Agency SFARG - Small Firm Attraction and Retention Grant (program administered by the Lower Manhattan Development Corporation/Empire There were no subsidies recaptured from firms at 1 Liberty Plaza.

Type of subsidy * BRG BRG BRG SFARG SFARG BRG SFARG BRG SFARG BRG BRG SFARG SFARG SFARG SFARG BRG BRG BRG BRG SFARG Tax breaks SFARG SFARG JCRP JCRP JCRP Tax breaks

Brookfield

$160,000.00

$300,000.00

$460,000.00

Firm Abdul Ahad Faiq Alice's Fashions, Inc. Ark WFC Corp Authentidate,Inc. B & B Sushi WFC Inc Beacon,LLC Brookfield Financial Properties, LP Brookfield Financial Properties, LP Business Data Conversion, Inc. CADWALADER, WICKERSHAM & TAFT

Amount $834 $3,400 $300,000 $163,465 $47,793 $20,252 $390,000 $300,000 $20,597 $5,789,000 $29,119 $22,500 $40,091 $1,700,000 $1,175,369 $53,417

Address One New York Plaza 1 New York Plaza 2 World Financial Center 225 Liberty Street 4 World Financial Center 225 Liberty Street 3 World Financial Center 3 World Financial Center 4 World Financial Center One World Financial Center Four World Financial Center 2 World Financial Center 2 WORLD FINANCIAL CENTER Two World Financial Center 3 World Financial Center

Date(s) Awarded April, Sept 2002 10/11/02 02/12/03 09/20/02 11/25/02 07/30/02 2003, 2005 12/03/02 09/18/02 2/19/2004

California Burritos Co. Cardworld LLC COLORTEK IMAGE WORLD INC. COMMERZBANK AG Computer Generated Solutions Corporate Coffee Connection Corp.

Aug, Sept 2002 2004, 2006 Feb, Oct 2002 11/26/2002 8/19/2004

Cosi, Inc. Deloitte and Touche Denise Storck and Co., Inc. Donald Sacks WFC Operating Co. Inc. DOW JONES Dow Jones & Co Downtown Photo, Inc. Earth Tech, Inc. Elixir WFC, LLC Financier Patisserie, LLC

250 Vesey Street 12/30/02 3 WFC, Store $72,500 S303/Street Level, 200 Vesey 2004, 2006 $13,000,000 One World Financial Center * $12,650 $110,000 $1,072,862 $1,000,000 $2,295 $400,750 $97,050 $38,500 250 Vesey St. 12/24/02

220 Vesey Street 2004, 2005 World Financial Center 11/26/2002 One World Financial Center * 1 New York Plaza April, Nov 2002 One World Financial Center 2005, 2006 2 World Financial Center 01/16/03 3/4 World Financial Center 2005, 2006

$5,480 Fountain Of Juice Inc. One New York Plaza $42,000 Four O Nine LLC 250 Vesey St Four World Financial $27,547 Center Florist Inc. 250 Vessey Street $770,000 One NY FRIED FRANK HARRIS SHRIVER & JACOBSON Plaza Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. $437,000 1 New York Plaza Hill, Betts & Nash LLP J & A Enterprises,LLC Kevin Grady Liaqat Ali Merrill Lynch & Co., Inc. Michael C. Wamp Morgan Stanley Morgan Stanley N W Coffee Inc. New York Plaza Florist,inc. OPPENHEIMER FUNDS $102,500

March, Sept 2002 2005, 2007 Feb, Sept 2002 8/1/2002

1 WFC, 200 Liberty St 2004, 2006 $6,523 One New York Plaza July, Dec 2002 1 World Financial $17,126 Center July, Sept 2002 $730 200 Liberty Street 12/18/02 $27,640,000 World Financial Center North 1 World Financial $48,854 Center,Tower 1 June, Oct 2002 $54,065,000 1 New York Plaza $13,050,000 One New York Plaza 8/15/2005 $9,736 1 New York Plaza July, Sept 2002 $21,558 Mar, Sept 2002 9/18/2003 Feb, Dec 2002 2005, 2007 12/23/02 2002, 2004 06/28/02 2005, 2007

1 New York Plaza Two World Financial $4,030,000 Center $25,506 Optometric Arts 200 Liberty Street 3 World Financial $80,000 P.S. Food Group, Inc. Center 3 World Financial $179,046 P.S. Food Group, Inc. Center Pacific American 2 World Financial $68,250 Corporation Center Pacific American 2 World Financial $300,000 Corporation Center PJ Clarke's On The 4 World Financial $182,000 Hudson LLC Center Two World Financial $510,000 Platinum Underwriters Center/ 225 Liberty Reinsurance Street Prudential Securities, Inc. $23,066,000 One New York Plaza 2 World Financial $25,920 Results Organization,Inc. Center Richards Kibbe & Orbe One World Financial $418,250 LLP Center $45,500 Ronin Capital, LLC Rosenthal Collins Group LLC Rosenthal Collins Group LLC $70,000 $100,306 1 World Financial Center (200 Liberty St) 2 WFC-225 Liberty, 620 2 WFC-225 Liberty, 620

2004, 2006

06/26/02 2003, 2005

2005, 2006 2005, 2006 05/02/03

S. W. Bach & Company Salvatore Men's Barber Shop ,Ltd Southern Garage Corp. Southwest NY LLC Southwest NY LLC Steven R. Goldberg, ESQ Sunglass Hut International Inc. Sunglass Hut International Inc. Tahari Store WFC Co,Inc. THACHER PROFFITT & WOOD Weiss, Peck & Greer, LLC WFC Custard, LLC WFP Tower A Co. LP

$141,750 $10,500 $56,922 $500,000 $290,000 $28,463 $39,260 $20,111 $115,354 $1,400,000 $150,000 $27,844 $92,500

2 World Financial Center 1 New York Plaza, Concourse Level 1 New York Plaza 2 World Financial Center 2 World Financial Center

2004, 2006 02/17/05 08/29/02 2002, 2004 Feb, Sept 2002

1 North End Ave. #1201 World Financial Center March, Sept 2002 225 Liberty Street 3 World Financial Center 2 World Financial Center Two World Financial Center 1 New York Plaza 2 World Financial Center One World Financial Center One World Financial Center World Financial Center 200 Liberty Street 1 World Financial Center 2 World Financial Center 11/11/02 11/15/02 June, Dec 2002 8/21/2003

10/31/02 10/25/02 2003, 2005 01/08/03 2/20/2003 09/26/02

$300,000 WFP Tower A Co. LP $906,626 WILLIS NORTH AMERICA ,INC World Financial Center $24,788 Florist, Inc. XL Insurance Company of New York, Inc Yasuda Fire & Marine Insurance Co. $365,750 $300,000 $155,977,144

2005, 2006 07/25/02

Total subsidies less recaptures:

BROOKFIELD PROPERTIES Subsidies for tenants of One Liberty Plaza including Brookfield Properties Subsidies for tenants of WFC and 1 New York Plaza including Brookfield Properties Subsidies to Brookfield Properties and its tenants in Lower Manhattan

* BRG - Business Retention Grant (program administered by the Lower Manhattan Developm Corporation/Empire State Development Corporation) SFARG - Small Firm Attraction and Retention Grant (program administered by the Lower Ma Corporation/Empire State Development Corporation JCRP - Job Creation and Retention Program administered by the Lower Manhattan Developm Corporation/Empire State Development Corporation) GJNY's recent analysis of this program Sales Tax - These tax breaks were awarded by the Industrial Development Agency

Recaptured Funds

Agency ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC

Type of Subsidy BRG BRG BRG BRG BRG BRG SFARG BRG BRG

Brookfield

$390,000.00 $300,000.00

JCRP ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC LMDC/ESDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC SFARG JCRP BRG SFARG JCRP JCRP BRG SFARG BRG SFARG BRG SFARG BRG JCRP JCRP BRG

ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC $0

BRG SFARG

BRG ESDC/LMDC JCRP IDA BIR Energy Incentive ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC SFARG BRG

BRG ESDC/LMDC BRG IDA Commercial Incentive 503,000.00 ESDC/LMDC BRG IDA BIR Energy Incentive ESDC/LMDC JCRP ESDC/LMDC BRG ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC IDA ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC SFARG ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC SFARG BRG SFARG IDA BRG SFARG BRG JCRP BRG SFARG BRG SFARG BRG SFARG

ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC

SFARG SFARG BRG SFARG BRG

BRG ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC ESDC/LMDC SFARG ESDC/LMDC $503,000.00 BRG $1,082,500.00 BRG2 BRG2 BRG JCRP BRG BRG SFARG BRG JCRP BRG $92,500.00 $300,000.00

$155,474,144.00

uding Brookfield Properties (see sheet 2) - $20,570,707 Plaza including Brookfield Properties - $155,474,144.00* nts in Lower Manhattan - $176,044,851*

nistered by the Lower Manhattan Development

nt (program administered by the Lower Manhattan Development

nistered by the Lower Manhattan Development GJNY's recent analysis of this program is here. e Industrial Development Agency