SCC 33888 Factum of Interveners CAUT_CFS 1637092

Court File No.: 33888BETWEEN:

IN THE

SUPREME COURT

OF

CANADA(ON APPEAL

FROM THE

FEDERAL COURT

OF

APPEAL)

THE

PROVINCE

OF

ALBERTA

AS

REPRESENTED BY

THE

MINISTER

OF

EDUCATION AND OTHERS*

-and-

THE

CANADIAN COPYRIGHT LICENSING AGENCYOperating as "ACCESS COPYRIGHT"

-and-

APPELLANTSRESPONDENT

CANADIAN PUBLISHERS' COUNCIL, ASSOCIATION

OF

CANADIAN PUBLISHERS, ANDCANADIAN EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES COUNCIL, CANADIAN ASSOCIATION

OF

UNIVERSITY TEACHERS AND CANADIAN FEDERATION

OF

STUDENTS, ASSOCIATION

OF

UNIVERSITIES AND COLLEGES

OF

CANADA AND ASSOCIATION

OF

CANADIANCOMMUNITY COLLEGES, CMRRA-SODRAC INC., SAMUELSON-GLUSHKO CANADIANINTERNET

POLICY

AND PUBLIC INTEREST CLINIC, CANADIAN AUTHORSASSOCIATION, CANADIAN FREELANCE UNION, CANADIAN SOCIETY

OF

CHILDREN'SAUTHORS, ILLUSTRATORS AND PERFORMERS, LEAGUE

OF

CANADIAN POETS,

LITERARY

TRANSLATORS' ASSOCIATION

OF

CANADA, PLAYWRIGHTS GUILD

OF

CANADA, PROFESSIONAL WRITERS ASSOCIATION

OF

CANADA

AND

WRITERS UNION

OF

CANADA AND CENTRE

FOR

INNOVATION LAW

AND

POLICY OF THE

FACULTY

OF

LAW

UNIVERSITY

OF

TORONTO

INTERVENERS

FACTUM

OF THE

INTERVENERS,CANADIAN ASSOCIATION

OF

UNIVERSITY TEACHERS ANDCANADIAN FEDERATION

OF

STUDENTS

TorysLLP

79 Wellington Street West, Suite 3000

Box

270, TD CentreToronto, ON M5K 1N2Wendy MathesonAndrew BernsteinTel: (416) 865.0040Fax: (416) 865-7380E-mail: abemstein@tm:ys.comCounsel for the Interveners,Canadian Association

of

University Teachers andCanadian Federation

of

Students

Osler, Hoskin

&

Harcourt

LLP

Suite 1900,340 Albert StreetOttawa, ON

KlR

7Y6Patricia

J.

WilsonTel: (613) 235-7234Fax: (613) 235-2867E-mail: pwilson@osler.comOttawa Agent for the Interveners,Canadian Association

of

University Teachers andCanadian Federation

of

Students

TO:AND TO:AND TO:AND TO:AND TO:

REGISTRAR

Wanda

Noel

Barrister and Solicitor5496 Whitewood A venueOttawa, ON K4M IC7Tel: (613)

794-II7I

Fax: (613) 692-I735E-mail: wanda.noel@sympatico.ca

Fasken Martineau DuMoulin

LLP

1300-

55

Metcalfe StreetOttawa, ON

KIP

6L5

J.

Aidan O'NeillAriel A. ThomasTel: (613) 236-3882Fax: (613) 230-6423Solicitors for the Appellants*(See Schedule "A")

Norton Rose

OR

LLP

Suite 2500I Place Ville MarieMontreal, Quebec H3B

IRI

Neil Finkelstein (McCarthys)Claude BrunetTel: (5I4) 847-4539Fax: (5I4) 286-5474Email: david.collier@nortonrose.caSolicitors for the Respondent,Access Copyright

McCarthy Tetrault

LLP

P.O. Box 48, Suite 4700, T-D BankTowerToronto-Dominion CentreToronto, Ontario M5K IE6Barry

B.

SookmanSteven

G.

MasonDaniel

G. C.

GloverTel: (4I6)60I-7949Fax: (4I6) 868-0673

Norton Rose

ORLLP

Suite I500

45

O'Connor StreetOttawa, Ontario

KIP

IA4

Sally

A.

GomeryTel: (613) 780-8604Fax: (613) 230-5459Email: sally.gomery@nortonrose.caAgent for the Respondent, AccessCopyright

Cavanagh Williams Conway Baxter

LLP

1111

Prince

of

Wales Drive, Suite

401

Ottawa, Ontario K2C 3 T2Colin

S.

BaxterTel: (613) 569-8558Fax: (613) 569-8668E-mail: cbaxter@cwcb-law.comAgent for the Interveners, Canadian

AND TO:

AND

TO:Counsel for the Interveners,Canadian Publishers' Council,Association

of

Canadian Publishersand Canadian EducationalResources Council

Hebb

&

Sheffer

1535A Queen Street WestToronto, Ontario M6R 1A7MarianHebbWarren ShefferTel: (416) 556-8187Fax: (866) 400-3215Counsel for the Interveners,Canadian Authors Association,Canadian Freelance Union,Canadian Society

of

Children'sAuthors, Illustrators and Performers,League

of

Canadian Poets, LiteraryTranslators' Association

of

Canada,Playwrights Guild

of

CanadaCounsel for the Interveners,Professional Writers Association

of

Canada and Writers Union

of

Canada

Osler Hoskin

&

Harcourt LLP

340 Albert Street, Suite 1900Ottawa, ON

K1R

7Y6

MarcusKlee

Glen A. BloomTel: (613) 235-7234Fax: (613) 235-2867Email: mklee@osler.comPublishers' Council, Association

of

Canadian Publishers and CanadianEducational Resources Council

Michael

J.

Sobkin

90 blvd. de Lucerne, Unit #2Gatineau, Quebec J9H 7K8Tel: (819) 778-7794Fax: (819) 778-1740Email: msobkin@sympatico.caAgent for the Interveners, CanadianAuthors Association, Canadian FreelanceUnion, Canadian Society

of

Children'sAuthors, Illustrators and Performers,League

of

Canadian Poets, LiteraryTranslators' Association

of

Canada,Playwrights Guild

of

CanadaAgent for the Interveners, ProfessionalWriters Association

of

Canada andWriters Union

of

Canada

Osler Hoskin

&

Harcourt LLP

340 Albert Street, Suite 1900Ottawa, ON K1R 7Y6Patricia WilsonTel: (613) 787-1009Fax: (613) 235-2867Email:· pwilson@osler.comAgent for the Interveners, AUCC andSolicitors for the Interveners, AUCC ACCC

andACCC