Court File No.: 33888

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF CANADA

(ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF APPEAL)

B E T W E E N :

THE PROVINCE OF ALBERTA AS REPRESENTED BY THE MINISTER OFEDUCATION (AND OTHERS*)

Appellants (Appellants)- and -

THE CANADIAN COPYRIGHT LICENSING AGENCYOperating as “ACCESS COPYRIGHT”

Respondent (Respondent)- and -

CANADIAN PUBLISHERS' COUNCIL, ASSOCIATION OF CANADIANPUBLISHERS AND CANADIAN EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES COUNCIL,CANADIAN ASSOCIATION OF UNIVERSITY TEACHERS AND CANADIANFEDERATION OF STUDENTS, ASSOCIATION OF UNIVERSITIES ANDCOLLEGES OF CANADA, ASSOCIATION OF CANADIAN COMMUNITY COLLEGES, CMRRA-SODRAC INC., SAMUELSON-GLUSHKO CANADIANINTERNET POLICY AND PUBLIC INTEREST CLINIC, CANADIANAUTHORS ASSOCIATION, CANADIAN FREELANCE UNION, CANADIANSOCIETY OF CHILDREN'S AUTHORS, ILLUSTRATORS ANDPERFORMERS, LEAGUE OF CANADIAN POETS, LITERARY TRANSLATORS' ASSOCIATION OF CANADA, PLAYWRIGHTS GUILD OFCANADA, PROFESSIONAL WRITERS ASSOCIATION OF CANADA ANDWRITERS UNION OF CANADA AND THE CENTRE FOR INNOVATIONLAW AND POLICY OF THE FACULTY OF LAW UNIVERSITY OFTORONTO

Interveners

MEMORANDUM OF ARGUMENT OF THE INTERVENERSTHE

CANADIAN PUBLISHERS’ COUNCIL, THE ASSOCIATION OFCANADIAN PUBLISHERS, AND THE CANADIAN EDUCATIONALRESOURCES COUNCIL

(

Pursuant to Rule 37 of the

Rules of the Supreme Court of Canada

)

McCarthy Tétrault LLP

Suite 5300 Toronto-Dominion Bank Tower Toronto, ON M5K 1E6

Barry B. SookmanDaniel G.C. Glover

Tel: (416) 601-7949Fax: (416) 868-0673E-mail: bsookman@mccarthy.ca

Solicitors for the IntervenersCanadian Publishers’ Council, theAssociation of Canadian Publishers,and the Canadian EducationalResources CouncilCavanagh Williams Conway BaxterLLP

Suite 4011111 Prince of Wales DriveOttawa, ON K2C 3T2

Colin S. Baxter

Tel: (613) 780-2011Fax: (613) 569-8668Ottawa Agent for the Interveners

ORIGINAL TO:

THE REGISTRAR

COPIES TO:

PartyCounselAgent

The Province of Alberta asrepresented by theMinister of Education (andothers*),

AppellantsFasken MartineauDuMoulin LLP

Suite 130055 Metcalfe StreetOttawa, ON K1P 6L5 J. Aidan O’NeillAriel A. Thomas Tel.: (613) 236-3882Fax: (613) 230-6423aoneill@fasken.com

Wanda M. Noel

5496 Whitewood Ave.Ottawa, ON K4M 1C7 Tel.: (613) 794-1171Fax: (613) 692-1735wanda.noel@bell.net The CanadianCopyright LicensingAgency Operatingas “AccessCopyright”,

RespondentNorton Rose OR LLP

Suite 25001 Place Ville MarieMontreal, Quebec H3B 1R1

Norton Rose OR LLP

Suite 150045 O’Connor StreetOttawa, Ontario K1P 1A4Claude Brunet Tel.: (514) 847-4539Fax.: (514) 286-5474claude.brunet@nortonrose.comSally A. Gomery Tel.: (613) 780-8604Fax.: (613) 230-5459sally.gomery@nortonrose.com

McCarthy Tétrault LLP

Toronto Dominion Bank Tower66 Wellington Street, Suite5300 Toronto, ON M5K 1E6