OI'filfolllft~t'i!

il/"
'!iHI 1'1:111 ""t~~ ~<:[.
~)l0{

~t ~"111
I

~l{"!!Jtl1" ~lftlftil

~tc:"II", ~tf\5 f<ft; ~~t~ ~

(formalized) <jI'~1l s-rn

C9fl~

lithe

-n ifl,

l1I"11"lftl1l j~'1f.n:~ J

111 "~1 CQjt<f

Oft<Pt!:'!if~ 1It~'l
I

C'i5f\':T~ ClfO{

foi-<;:<j

"'<It

~f~ ~fi{

'ft~"t

''i~tr'1 o.!Ie:$!~tfei1 ~C1JfliitOl!i~"'It'1fll'l

,J)~iI

I ijjlwtC\5t:<j

f"llllf'i5ffN

f<mlll''1 9f~f'!i~.

c'!i1Olnf o.!I~1 PI> ~f~ ~Ci'f? fMlit~'!fnl" <fi~i "lit~ ~t1I lIt~'{1~t ? ~1~~ Cl:fltCi'ft~ <:2:fti ~f'i!i c~r.<fi,'l!i{iI~Jt~-'!!l~"" C'1j~~'01t"-t~' If-;tOl'1l ~~'5t w1~iS~t'1"O( 'iI~ ~~ C<fi~o(~? ~'lt!i (;'If~, ~~"I·~r .\ft1rl1l f"l~'i!i ~rn~ ~1 C'i!i11lt\i;!;'O~'1 ~~t~t~-'\!tl;<ii' i ~ Jj"'1.~~C:j1I!lfI9, flt'i!i C"lCi1C~ ~flI? C~ Jj!,."$t'l1"-stCi'f1 (Traces) C'i!i1Cl!f~"~ C'S11:~ t~ ~ 'JI~tr.ijfOO- f~ -'!it~~? ~~ ~:~'lOi l!~if ~t~ 'ft~ ~Hi C'!it'llmj \!i1!if c<Wf 'l'JtiI'1'i'I{ 1ft?! 1f5i11 f<'li' 1j?§'t, lf1 f<r-l1 o.!I~ m'Jf ~C~ igit"lO( -s f11~~'1 ? >SftPr wtf.l 'JIi'§"l!,' c'i!it'lftil' "fC'f OfIfl '\!Qftf"l fgj~ 0111 ~<I~, ~",il1 car'i!f1 ~~ ~R ClI ~tDt'! "11r:\11 il1 I ~R'M" ~1iJ'fc<!j'lj~ ~~1
[ iI"f1,

~n

,~r;"

o.!IT;t~ I

~fCi'f is II\"Ilt"l"OI' ?'!{1iJ'1Z If-..filfftlt1 '"Itm I 1,~lIm fill;'i~ $lfu'i!i ~ ~i11!-(;'<fit"lUlt~~~ If-.of;f fft~nt '5{r~rtif I \!11m 'lft-.ffi{<!l' G~i~tt\!i ~'i!i 'He' ~ <\J<{~ <rit~ I fO{W"Iti ~flf;plfj, ''lfi-.ff.r'f lftt~ 1.11'1:1' o.!I~ CQliflQJt1!l 'O{t~ C\1C~
~"f "I'i!i'li1 lfo{ciI!f o.!I<;i~ 'li;; ~~"IMf'i!i

m 'i!it ~

~tllni 'eI<rtfil ~w <n1

!I II \fI<fl1S "!I II ~)

f<l~1(t hrC~'lI ~i{ (,\j~ ~1l "1/1 ~t'ftil', ~"'I'Of1Clffl ~~J R1If"i~) W'{jI\!fllb 5$I~fllJ f"lr:u 'i!it<ll? ~r<ll? Cll 11<1' f<'l"~~ifl11 ~tt~O{, \!t'!1"1 ,J)~ '!l{~l1"1~i{t<filt<t, ~ flrn~ ~j(f W<{{!;~ fir'"l oJI~ lft~l{~l C<\IOI' ~l1t~ <11o.!I~ l{mG1, '¢lllft\! ftfi ~ I o.!I~ C~ l!ifff"lf ~<lI'I;ll{l~~ <1'!ifl ~f~, Ql" r""ll fi{~ f.1t:er l{tl1t~, mil ~~J1 ~C~t1?i o.!I<i'- W:1I"~~ ~1fiI 'Wil~~o:r 1!i(1~~Jt o.!I:<\I51 "Social fact" \!i~i{ "l~ oJI'lifi; <uf'&$[ ~lft\§ f"ll" ~Qf C~~ ~il{'SIl ~i{t'\!) Dt~~i t 'IrtCi{" '!{ffii "'<f~ ,J)'Pf 'fJf~$[ flft'li '¥_. I ""11.,1, o.!Il:'i!i'¢ll"liltclf'Sl' lfl;i{ <fim'~ "n'l ~ ClI,'eltfii Social facts C'1t"ll" erson ~~"' ~<'I''t' 'Ufs;~ P flft" ~~"II" "Ii!Pf~, ClI1{iI ~~""I ~t1I ~lfCO'!it l{C\!i1 1f!-.fRc~ <1>'<11: "a necssary condition of ascribing states of consciousness, experiences, to oneself, in the way that one does, that one sh )uld ascribe to them, or to be prepared to ascribe to them to others who are not oneself." o.!I~ <f~'1~ Person-a1l\Slrn ;gfj~i11f" '~1{ l{Ol' farllc~ "I"ft'!1"? 'ffu<'!'" 11N ~'l<'l<1"5fiTC\!iii 9jt~1I1 1I1!f, \5~Ci! <rif<t~ "fi{l'JI'll" (~-if~~lW'i!i) ~t~ ~01'C'!i Dt~C<'I"l ~rlf~ 'fAA f<fi{l ~ ~t~~ilCfl 'Sf~tf'i{~t'i{t'fl I f<!i', o.!I~ 'If,"" ~VI <!i1<'1rn f1tClT ~"II"~q·'i!I{i{t<n9 -SWI c~r<'ll"~ o.!I<f><J(stlllr~ "5l:af" ('fOl'lf: ~:i{l~ C5'!011 '"Itf<li "!11111it~' f.r4r~? <'IJf"& if1 "l{t~ r '!{t'JI{O'f ,J)~l:1:if1 ~"t~ ~l:<fl; 'JIl{~1-1I~"RU ,~ ~?§ r ~~ Of\Of ClfIIi{ \!{1'f1l'l-'5{i{'t'll;r, ~"M'!i<Ii ~1l:1fif; ~~ e'5'fC!lI <'I:rf'e>-.,~fl;~ 1if1l'~i

"rw

~m~

~~t'6'if1

~a;1 i5ft'l~1i1:t., 0 ~

~lm' ~f.P'f cQftCfiR:"f

~Jt"ttl1i;l ~

"f\!it<ll' c;'jftmi~

'iti1l.11 <'I~~iI!1i. lftCi{ ~ <!ftl!B~t~ o.!Ii;1 \5W11 ~t~ e"'tc'qJ Cl;f1ift~

f'f

~t'!1" ~'lftll

oJIf ~'''t-<:;'lti; ~~

~'l~~ ~1JIftii "Jj'Wf'i!i 'e(!j' ~t'li~ '@ 1S<!l'1I~ajt'\"'l I ~t'Sl ClI ~t"~ Cfint<l ~"I"'i{tr.(;f"~ ~r.'i!i1I'!f<fSMtJf''!1"o.!I~t~ CISC<,(, o.!ICiffr:;, ;:mil' <'II"til'~~1'tfQf R I <rn1'lU1 R:"flf 'liQtl ~'Sf <i'""ar C'll'PI"f "f'i!i:tWit c"IClI l!iftlt o.!I~r "t~'!1" <!I~ ~W\1 fiftil ~t"'Of1m -t!f1, lfKOl' 511'1 i!!f~\1 :I'l~ ~t~tSll <.!l~ i!!i'~i ~~. ~tI;'i!i ~lfSi

",'<I1-f~

,J)"lf01' 'JI<'I 1I~1 ti{ 1{t""ll{l:if <,fi'<lr~ <~

f1ci- Dt~

(1.f,

f~i~

9fr~f~ 011I

'1'f:if1 ~t~,

~tl{lt:<lI' 'IIfIt'1iftsol'tJ:! cj'8i;1

~t'i!i

<lim

lftQj

~~ul~~
<I't~

lfTI;01' ~~

~l~ fw lilil't'1i;f ~Iil' ~~ if1

J[f\!i1JJ

fi;t~

C~

'Ift-..ffi{"~1~t~Of 1 o.!I<flJ1 C't"t ~<\;tl;~f)"jf~t~ m"l"hf o.!IrsRt\ ~1Il C'lG 'liit<lil ift-.ffo.T'l'itl···"fI, ""11, I51:tflf If"ftilil C'tltt<'r (~ t '·1 ~ to{ f"i .,t~ 1 ood"~I <n t<>tt~;1 ~~il. 1

"II"tl fJftll~ (lit\!

Wt I <!IlIftil elf,Of 'Sft"lif1"ij1 11'1{ h.tfol"ll"-~"f\T~

<l'f~

,\!1m
o.!I'i~
(;"i{~

JI'C'i

Dtaj"~ I

C'1ift'f <itar f"ltllj'Q lft>off.rcCfii'f lftl <ut~JtQ, Ci!!ft'ftl¥ 1JC5~

<1IQ{tI;1 ~9

f~r~~ lFt-..ff.t"

..,~n:r

~"Iortvrl1 ~~(;r ~~fi; lJ~H[ ~f'i!il;'I{lf"l filt<'l"JfOl' <i'"rn I ~$I' o.!I~ \!{t"l::tttlfSl lft~ lf1'1(f'!1"i, ~t~ fOl'f~ 'Sftf'"l, f'Sft'\"PI <'II1l:t<{01'~t<::, ~7;<nPT "'01' I '!l{rflf ~l{tl1 'iit<!i1~'JI!;". mt01' f1ff'"l f<ll'i1i ~1~ f<f
o.!I"i!!fil, "lI~'1 «5t$l" <if<>r -~t~ C"FI

r"l

'\5ftR"!littu, I.!llll'l'l <:[CQlt~'" j<!i1~wti'f' <fWi{ f'Wlt~-1f-.ftO{'!f lftl lpfe.,$[ lffu "I"'1iR :ljt~t -o.!I"lf-"{fl;., ~ ~l:lIlp(" f~l ~ ~m~ <\Jnt I5{iD 'Sftll"11 c~rt"- 1~1J, "lltW'J o.!I'Jj<{ C!if~«>" I ~"f "f\5t~

)'j~~

~~11'1

)8/lf-afi{-·~if-.ofCOj

rt"t ~
that there can be progress ,that I have. achieved in philosophy.

~t~~'1tt'110 ~[;1l'11 \!!(tQftlf1 ~'~I(:ll, ~rtt:'lI:" c:'<t~ ~art1ft ~~ "I'"R~ I 'l1nt-5 fi:rQ1m<f~ '\5{tc:iiltD-it'X ~t~t~ ~ ~~t~ ~t~ fOj I ~<{t~ i1fUi'" C5~~ ~~ 'l{.tm ~1'\I2l'f~'Il\ c"lt~ I ~W'Ia; ~§ (5tllt~';f, ''il,f'\!i<\l\!i~ Tf~· ~~t\j.n f1fC~,C~~ ~f~l1. ~f~~ C~ ~i'Gi;\lf~ ~t~ 'l{~t'Q'I ~t!lf I "'It'1t1t Of"1_'il" f<1'''M~t~ 'l{iI~~ ~J. ~fil$'\!i I oJi~'!it~"TI1 if"ft'il,'1

It may, however, appear

f'!if~ <it1 <fft~! f.v dl\!'4'~

just the opposite ."

~.-m~
~'"

f'fW~ l[~~rlf-~<tJl
'!!f'l'$ ~'f-.. c"f~ '>!I'~'5"I

1tlf

~~m'l,{

flt~1 .t11 tZ'IA ~

r~

~tc~ \'!l. c!1~ f1'''t "f~C'<f~ C1l lft'l{t6f ~~1 ~"1f~ I \5t~ f<f't~\ lite;{ c~t~'-'l'tl~f\!r;~~ <ft~'lI'<rt~ ....

2fi~1 .. li\' ~

M"f
1l<J;

"f'\!itfl

~Qj1J

~C1'j'i

"1.'1:~ '6rl1~~~~i!3,-~"~1

<\~~

~Dli I

<5{i"imf..lf~ "'(tst'llo{ ~t'l{1lr Cl{ 'fiT <roIt~ Cil <\lo:t1 ~<il1 ~orr I ~~ ~t"'ll~~m: '2!~~ I <£ld 'lI'ro:ll 1!:jtS\'1·1I'1'11-f<J;ftl1ii~nl 'O(~J1 Jl.'tcOj 1{t$l lItll \!i~iI 'l{tto{~~ <tifil ~tcli\'l'5*{~ ~<{g CJI~ <ti~t\.ii fstt1{, I51tlftt~

f*1.l

"Gl'

~~

\!!("'~~

c"i~ ~1fOifC\!j ~~ ~t~~t~ "1"'''''* ~t'l.lm ~ f'l' ll!~ ~'lI:, is!t~\!i Dt~~i.. CJi H'!lai ~~l;j f~! oJi~ f<il'tll ~11"it~, '"5{tf1{ ~~Qf ~tM, 'l{ttfl ~~ f'f, ~tf~ mJfQ\-~~~ift I Ji'tifrl{ri;t~R~ ~tc"lG1f~~ >:!ij''l.~CI ,,~ ,<,!{1N
\!!(t\i';i; Qjt~",1;1flMt"f
dl<tSII
I

'1~ 'll\fi(f~~~ 'I5!i:!!tll f;jti ~~ ~'f<ftfl ~f'lt 'I~tre 'SR. ~ttorn <.!I ,<'II t"l ~t~ Ci{~! '!iftf'li dilS :Q'jl; <frl"~. '>!I"tfil R"t "I'\!C«l'~ ~ ~'fltrf~ ~igH pr~,'3{~U'J~<t1t1f~ ~~ dl<t~ '!{ffir ('I;[t~~ ~1'tl'!Z' Oltf~~'\!ttJ; f;r'lff~~, G)jt~~ itt~1 ~f;:jow-~'l.~-<11"iQ\ iSj~~ DtiI ~ elt~ <1tfl? f'rt' f<>ff~ ii1~1f1 1 C'1mtfoi'<f <:!ifil"fi'lf >$ttlfll ~~ m--dl~l ~ ~11fi~ <fC9f~I t "t\!it~ll f<t.KO{~ 'S/~~t~tll TIft~ ~ti'.:'a(~~, 'It'lflf. ~i\!lflif,1fJt'f~1"Sttr;-.!II1l['C\!ilc~c"Stf~ ~wmrtifll'l~~JtQij' I '1'1 ...f;;;y;mtl!!1l'

"ift"!! :

n..

~\.iil

\!!(t'1'flt'!l1~~nl

\r;. Of"1." I

~fitf.rw" 'Ifl~"f~<f I !rr'llRtJfttlrl ~tf'lf ~tlf N1tti, 'lftf'B!,;{TI>I~~\S, <f'!l:Wi

~tli\'

1ft-t,Cl:l1f 'fiR!' I
'l{t~~ I

~"Io;f~ ~
~t~, "I'l{j~ -s
~ II

~f~:~('ij~~fiRIi?f'1 (

I >5l~1'I'" lr".fll'l;l"",'9'l. ~"St, '6 ~'l1'1<it"' ~ti'.:'1' ~'f~~, absolute presupposition-e, ~;, ".l~ QHj~ Clt'il I Cl'I~ '1Nf~' onll<li l'I~Stl:~ '9fc<fci; '1..~ ffi'!ll~ ~Clfi'i \!i~R'1 ~f5'\!J ~~ I ~tll f~~i'1' ~Jt"it~i '!5{W "it~ :'rtf'll, "1'~ iftl', m"i <ft,,~ dl~, .!I1'T;, <tttif 'l(Uc\!i1 l!{1'lt~ lfJl"1 f1~~rn-

-<1'tt{, \!.~ ~"lI'\;1 ('INi <IIt'!l'! ~t~

~l'~<f~'f{R'slu

l'I'l1'wtl1

>5l~m

nr~

Gl(

~tclj1Jj·l~~~iHft{-

1fti1\'

""Itll~Oj~<Ii

~'Sj' '6 "ftil<l' 2!\!iJ'i.'f

'!ft'ft~ ~~~9
Jj~t~

"i~ (f~ 1fR-t

"~~C<fi

C"it~i;{ ~m"tlfQif~tJ1fi'1' (Q1t~

"fi I
"itc'!!

'~l'l{~l;t~"
I

"Adventures
'Pj'~

of ideas" <{a(1 ~~~

CJJ~, C~iil

~1
I

Of "t.<f.'ta(, ~f.lr;ofll\.iil

'3{ttfj<fTIJ

l['C~1 ~l"tTlst~<f!T'1 11 csffl'fii>C'f"\~

'If.,~.

-f\.iiil

II

~~1f

ISI'-tt'f

C6'!iill, 1{ii, ~~1 'l{tfl<{'l5(f~~

'",f\!i<f·~

\!51 fir".fJ1 tttlftM\.ii ~CY C~ ~(;f\;1 ~, \~COfO\ f<i;ifl r)

tf~

f1<'1or~ 'lfC~J

~m:".S1~'1~iif~l$[15 '
""Itt$[ I
I!{~

'ljitf~ C"'~ ~l[t'Sl'

'3{ll!1~

C"tTC1ifR ;jflH:~~

~~

Oft~~ \'lR\!i ""It~~,

~if'i{ <ltc~r:OF.l '8(tts~~t~~1;1 C~"\

"t~~W

'1lfir'5 'l'iflR, ~J·(~t~ .,tiSlC\!i

'''iii ~~~Ifift 1fT'@~1

"'!"it'!i l'Itc~~ c!l~ Falsification f'f0{1 ~t'l{t~ ~tl:ll <S1<l<{t~ ·-~~n~<ttf1(~,. "f\!it~

~Mc~ f<t"'f
~f~t~-rn

C'1~ I

ifpffo:r<f

~t~f~,'€01G "'1tSI1;,€ <t>~!l:f~I 1{1~'il,f'l''"I1. ~tt~ fft fifnl ~r~1 ~ts-<{-~ c!lf*i c~;~ f<f~1. ~1:t ~ f<f I f~ ,,.tf~ Of~ 11l~ ~f~i ~'{3'i1\
~1 Jj1{1~lIt6) ~lfi
~'lI

ift><f~~~1 ~~fI ~Jt<1I ~t<{t~ f", 'l{"'r~ 1 ~ ~CiIil;

"t~CSt9f <!'!!t<;1ii ~1\f'fl-I!l~ti

l[~

Q.(

<2t~n~

~r:«.:or \!iJ ~tfjjf ~tftn:~ ~t)],'-\51 C1f ~Hllf'ilfilc.." "'I1<IPl' ~ C~C~, c~nI't~~ '~~{j> ~ f~fl11f1?:<tlCi1~llt<r","'hl 6'lf""<:fltO!' ~$f\sJ1;
f~'Ct(~t~ <tm"O{, ~t'11'tt<f 'lIi{t?l' ~'<f "'SlC<!fii~ '1:'~H;:qif I
j:ft~Jjli\' "'~'l{

mlfi'~'{91P-l'I'\!iJ
~tt"1S1, ~1"tT1-

<f'"ltJ\9ij-\!i1~

f"

c~'1I!l~t~~fSlt'lJ; lIti

Cl{

1I1t~ ~ttli . 1:li'6'l11·frfJV;'l' lli'em ~tlf~1 ~1I.fI'fj ~~lW!~

C<ftO!

<!l(~~tlf

<fC~ 'l\.iiJlJ:_i1J

~m <1m

f9~f~f"OfI... I c!1l('i{ filfi{ c!lmil: iJtr~~,i.lf.1 f<fii11 'l{f'fI ft"t "f'®'C~ f 1f>f~'tifjli1 ~f~~J~~:C?jt:~ii, f1~ '€<>rn ~t~l~ fol~~~ f~i11. Jj<J;tbt~ c~f--f,
Q!~ c!lit« Jjtt~1f'6

~a(

<Iit~

C'lfQjt<iOl, "1 emba~k

d
In

on. this
t

'philosophical stand points with the avowe

en

tion

review of of showing

lflat"J 'lCOif C1l''"It(;fO{, <f1t'<liJ:1I Syntax: - ~'51U.~ t~ ~{lt (;'fi1C<{"l ~~\!itt<l' I ,"rll ""f~, ~t~f~ C<f'-'lta,O{.'$j« ~<;en~<rti1 Jj"1ito{~ f'Sf~q1il~ RGrN'r~PI cllte" 1IJ..,€, iJ1l' I mJiGij' clf~tlft'lO{, ~'~<fi~,;{ C'fta\'<\Stl!'t<ttll) <f<ill:G1f11f<t C'ft~~'It~ filt~m"'?l ~t~ ~t'U t'ti if'!!t"fll' ~<>f1f~t"'!lf' ~fi1 <1iC'ilI ml!'J~ fillI'(fr6"?l ( "fRo{ ~~ ) fOitli 'Sf~t:'I1' II:'[ C11:" ''Sf~l

~~I1f..f.t·~~
~~~<!i~r~."

§"f ~

ilfiWi{1 l(t~~/::.'

~tfi{ ~~j~ ~ 9ftR? ~ 'l!I<n:1Iif~e ~~ lj~_I;!~~ 1Ift~f~~,?J:t1 "If\!? 'l(tflr-~tt~~ ~~ ~fiOt!Ic<\ ~t"{\ UlC~ f~tt~ ~~ "~'9f",," "~t'!i" I!lftflf @~~ <fi~' ~m~~ ,IIfC" ""C?J:~ ':iI_f'&'i(~ ~tlI1lI, ,~c~~ '!ft'l(t~ '9fl~ C'ftfi"i 'l(1t'l~ 'ltQ'l filt1f~, c<liOl0{1.Jl~ ~~'!iJt~ '3'<1"1<:ff~t<\ 1ItCo{ evidences (~~~ OM_iI', ~flr ~ 1Nit~ ~11tl;j Ql;1{~~ '¥~ C1{~ f'IfC'll:f~ ) '!ft1{tt<fi ~~f~ <R;C'3 ~<I;, ~ ~~f1S11f '11 fili'$" ~6"'{nt ilifiJ1 f<f5t~t01j'.{ ,\"Jjt\ij ~-~lj<l"~ if! <lQ'lC"if ~1Jf? 1t\ ""iff~~'I(, '5tlJ1-f~c<\ ~~pf;J{lI ~ C~IC~ '!ltt~Q'[. ,mt"t'iSc;[,

~ttll ~f1tCl" ~W,~~

'::I I

~~

te tf JlIOl>j~ f<f:lj~ ~t~ ''fil fO{t'i ~n["flt c~t~il ~~~ ~~tt\6 9ftstt'{1l ~
$f ..... :

l!~r

0{11

1!5ft-rl ",fl

~) ~t~~ rII~t..

Jfti'l.m ,~t~
~t "ffO{ 'fQ'[t<qi{. fi{J'['if"
~\!i

~'t8il. ~ I~ ~ r. <II i{ ..,-t gt '1 CIfIt<f <fit"! ,~?

~~,
~t"1ll:Hr

,r.o1

~'!l

Cln~t\.ij

W~lI ~lf't

Jj"!iJ\.iilt<fi ~"fC'l{tf~~

~tlI

'IlIt<fi ~

,t<t

~t~~OIf~.,..!fr~.Ii{S~l ~~t'''tl i <fiU~ '!5{Vrr.:!!i---41{~t~1 ~'i1 "1lf.,.. '! I5ttijfl 'lfl<f11i ".'I1ll' ~tf'<li T efc 11~H Iii Jf'l{l Ct{ <£l~ 011:, ~1Iti{~$ ~ ~~''1t~ f~1 ~tlJf ~tlfttlril

I.!I~'

f.it'3

-~"~1ltbW!'l <Teaf~ 'fG'I

~i1t1!cortilf~. ~<f1lf,

~~-.JI1f

~'1t1f'

5~~
~ I

("l{1 ~"IC'll~. 'i5t~ ~'!J") "!it'S ~ fj{lIfJt~ifh ~~t~t'!lttil ~~ 1t c2!Jt'l~$~~ <IIt'9f ~ 0{11 'Il1lf'5 (I!i~~ Jj~m !'Cash-Value

"i;$t~ '5t~f~r.Q'lo{ \
'!{~1 ~ lil& 'lft~"Il;t~ <fil:!l ill <!ilfi.~? iltft; ~~1 N"I ill .,tiil~ \'j;t'1t~ '"tC~ '!{t'III~ <ft~ ~r.'i\? 1!5\"tflj'O{t!l:l l1fiCifi'l, .Jl~ ~t"l;:l, l.flt<J fi;t'IJ: ~ttil f.'I(t~ f~.'!5{t'9fC~ \!{1tQ'It'5irt~ - ~ll'll1t~~ 'llfif"l' '!{tt'l, 'l\teo{ ~i'll: Ni"l' lIt'l'l
'Iltt'>t ~t~

1iI11t"!1 I co{ ~tClf{ 'ti[t~ "5!JfT C'II<£l" ~"lf "l',{-l.!It'51 <T"It~ ~~~J I C"'o1c1!~.rt<'ff~ <II"l~ 1(~1 ~'1i I ~~ "'5\'c~$f~$t\! f,rr.:'{ ~1 1I1(~ f"OIl t'I~ <maIi{-'IJ!<T~~ fitl9t<fi:tjO{-~~~~ ~~ t-l'!{t~<f-

,~~r;~
I '~~

"<II ~r!ftcl& ,,~

ell ~
ti!f'(1{

nr<J"~

01 "I'!fr!fl{," 'UiiI ''Ii:~ cq ~'4i{fi;:<f '5ftIlllC'i!i (1)~ f~t")J:il~

,"C\Ii 'titt'" (;ijjt~C'ii ~<f I

'!l""~~l~1

( <1"1 "5t~t~ "5fiSCI:!l) ,,,t"l' 'f~!l" 'l~CiI' t1m c1)~i{~ - I

7{t'S'I

'!{<!.... 1

f'l"5miili{

"''li:J~ ~'{

1.'i:ji-'~ ~Jt"tt!ltl

"'t<ft\S~ ~'!f

"what can be said can be said clearly, and what we cannot talk about we
C~"I?

<m~ ell ~IIfJ~t'1

~i'll:?

<£l~ofI~'1\!il c<fiOl? ~C'I'It'1 <!i{K~. ~ f<fi ofl~~tl,l

C<J C.lfol <f~~C'i:"l'

C"'Oi'~ oTt~ ~Q'[ T

~

f'ft

'>mt'!i ~

~01j

on

C1fC~ ,~

,7I'eafi{ 0!Q' Co{11"'t1Httff I ~tCi{

<ttij '!It~ ClI '@tttll''!I ''II ~ ~U

'f'lf\ 'I'ifl

~v ("~"ft~
1~~iill

~l{Q{i ~rtfw'S 0{1 ), C11~ ~1f, <t~ '5fPf\11 '!f1QijJ <£l~~

C!l"~cn ~l'1

~i{Otfitl

'@..,.~

R:~tr;",1f ~-c~f1tc'9fl

'1l.tJf1 'it'ftCI:!l

must pass over in silence."

f" ~~iI
~~
'l!t~

<fi'4'l ~1f f'lili'f ~ COlIt<li~h1 CS'l!131, ~

~1

\!~ <li!l(l ~

'1t~t"!l~ c.~"l' !f~tu

~~CO{.

<Ii~'"

~~1?
~~"f

.. $(~=I'! C

~t'¥tC\! ~'i!iC'!l" ~~1lI1'e \!itllfttil'

I
m~1ftilR"

'<11111 l{t~ ~1 T iltf<fi

C'!!i<1

'IJ!*'\!i C;)C'!i
~r.:'S(

lfi<f -~~\!

1{t~ <t~ ~

<:fI'!t ~t~f~ <eft1i1tt"lf~

'ij~ ij~ <£l~\!i~J~t-e ~tfi(t'.I ~t",f~ C~

f!'i!i nltJ 'lfti{~l!t\&Jt'II'Sf ~lftCli1ft~ <t~,~ f5fC'!I, "ft!f:lIto{R'f I5ft'ftC'!l '5t~ '!Il~t\!) fm 0"1" \1f"to'f "1f1ll'-c<I'ORl
1I1?1C<fC; ~liiftil
t",C<.f

~t'lt~t!f r;~'ili-.JI"Ii{ >11" <:ff~Jtll

<?l: ~t<fit~

'i5t~ ~(~~ ~1I"1 '''til l{"i~ f<l.""tWhlf"l' ClI c)J ofI~· ~~, ~tt<{ I <!I1[i!f", 'i5t~ ~~ CQ'[~t'S Iifl ~Cl C'1~ ,~ l'j~1I ~'ifr~ ~f~<1ita'l "ff~~';;~1 i[t~t5t~ <fit~C!liil- f<A ~tl:"lfJ Q{f~~ '\!J{f~t-y C;f{lf<l ~m f<li'\.~ ~~J\!;l ~~t~ <!i~1lItt f"l' I <£l~ C1{~~Jl~ JjtC,lf:ii'i't ~l1"ft~t'@ ~i!!\!i~\J1 ~ll:il ~f""'!fir":rtaT c1l, l'j;(\ fi{gt., Cfl,"~tr-1 <fil{{~~TII<\~ilI <:rtf'!i'ij "fit~ fil~. <!I~~ ~l\il .Jl~~1 ~gto1" ~ f~ill <£l~il\S"'5\'N <fi~<!itl~'" !:lUi C'!l(<l:I~ \ ~t~ il!!'iJi <!It"!' "f~ ~~ ,c:l:!~ '!{t~ -m1l.flZi,~ I!ft"\'ili'!l1 -R:C,<r5ort fi~ clflO1" ~<f'V-"'5\'tll:ft1ri1 ~t6i 1I~1 ~~ ~t'e't~-1!{~'It < "ft'51Q'1 ijt<lJ~ <fit1:il I

;ft\1.~t~ C<fit.,

C1{f~<fiJlQj~Jt~J1 "'It'@ll 1I.t'{

iii. ~~ ~"fC~

'1f'l~1

~?f

1{Wi f~JjC'1 t{t:lj fil~, m ''fII~1, m ~Q{ concreteness-a l.'1f'i 'l~C'fti! ~tt'i

"fIfWoi -!fI1'i{ fl9 . ..!iO{', ~1 <II'Ift~. \6tt",'S '(f<r~ ~of ~~tQ'l '!Itlftt'!l' '~If C1Rilf~ '\!ite.. I <JI~

'~l:if

"t~

'"I"l&t,"I' ~011-Q'li'5 <fi~t'ii ~t~

~f<If, ~t'i!
c<fri;'f

~tf<i·'!{~t" "j~t'!f~
~~
i!!i*,t<fi

<fi'!ltT;l ClIC<J~

Ih

1ItOI ?{Ct1ii allacy of misplaced f

'!{t1l''!l'1I

~lI'O{

~Cl(

C-.il1lr C~

'<ftlll<Gt~\&~~ ~Tf<lIit.,. ij(~'e 'ij~ ~ ''ffT€ \!lft';l{'!l't'~hl~C~1!I <£l~ c~t'!tJfl;l C~'ll:ti{ <fiC~t~i{ I f"" ?{CQ'[ ..~C<iC'IItilili'C1I' f for rna I ize d on <!n:t"if <eft "'I:i{t!l"~ ;q-l ~tilt 101 'lfii{? 'bsi-;q--'!i{'l.-~~t~fJ 'll ''ft'ltl<Gt~ ~ '!i{t~-<!I~ '1i1CQ'[ '1C<iil ortf" ~"fiInn? ~ .Jlf;;::;tlS~ '5t~ c~l
'S{t"filttlf!l" - '!i~ "11 ?
I§l~

~tn. \!i~
..!i~ (Jf~ "'fi~(~ ~~

~~ <vPf~,til:Cj f~!l'\!il '<1i~ <fit'!! ~'" <!i'4111 fi!lll" ~il < ~~OIT;tt<f~ ~
<II!lt<fO{

~~Q{1 ?
c;1{tS

flft1J:f~ I

.Jl\!i <I<\>'1<fi

'!!fil"Sttt~ t"l"'tmt'9f~ ~ilt'!l

lI'rn~ "~1 <srtCiII

'!i{filc91\!i1
~0Ii'!l

f~<f

"~1~1~1 Dt~

'!i{ftJl I

i{1l!ftfil-,S(·pml1lt<f'

I '<Rill

~~t

~c"'ttSf-lIf1f

1{~C~~

-~

lft~

Clf i1'~U "'"1-f§f~

ill,

~tl

~ I:rJlI'>f.l". '!1;1""kO{ f~"f\!~

I ~1:'e:{tfif '!1;1"lt'!f ~~ G'ff~~\lirJ;nr ~~~'I$l" m~ cis'\!lt'!f (lft..r~t"f C'\!l1<llt~~ "ti!!if-c~\;1 C:~ C<f'O{ ~t-a<f ~l~ I f<\'i\fi 1{r-f '!fl~ "l1i"'1\.rr'!f1, <$fffl/111 ~f~, ~lt~ ~~ C'S'i!t'!f ~t'!f ilf~'\!Of ~~f'i! ~~ I c.!1~ ~"'(if" f'fi ~<I'~ ~'\!l 'tirllf~~1iJ1, llftO{ being-for-itself-a ~~ ~f~ "!!I1 I ~~
'I.fti{

r
~ II 'Stl

ilfOlfOl'1 ~t~Jt\!l1/n
I

m'1m~~lfMf.ffiI;1 ~~

~t1I-e ~~ f<1li illrtfol Oft·.. ~fti{ ~tlt f<f'" fu~t'l1Ojl\'it~ "'t!ilO{, 1ft~'\ej11 ~~t~J '''l111 f"l~ 1J~ t~i\ I ~\sil 1I"1i\' PfroT 1(tu, \!l~"I-e I6{f"f WT<lif'll{~~"'P{"1J c'<!'" ~1'Ijf.••

:Jf11t"r'~ ~ ~f1n
~fir ,ijt1l c~fDt1 fo.It~ c."!t"jj c~. "tti'<II~ ~l;"4 c9f) ~C"l1 Jft-;r ~rn 'ift~tc~ I O\-lii C\!il-rnPlcqrf'i
'i.t~ ~~ C;<!iif 1
DfQ!"JI ljlGr~( "'Irt:f!'~

Cti~fuo;f1

I f~ ~~ ~1
f<1ll "l1l(tll

1II~

If".

","{fOlfo{

~"'ItO{ lIfif

-em
I

m '11'l!Ifl~1 'a/\li ~~ ~iJ._0{ !

'<It~. '\!l1~QI (.'i!t
C'!ft"l~'!f ~~

-\-11[, <1I){iI "'lfl'l~1

'j

~lf<fit~

Reified 1llr-f ~~

~lI ~-\!l(111'!f~

<J1~ ~<fi~ 11~1 ~i ~~ I

Cti~~1 7!{nf nothingness

~1fl"f'i! ~

.JI"~ ~

~t~i ~'lttifsr

~lf,,< ' tt<r '>fitor ~11:\! "'11 llllc'fj , C"!tlfl§ <fi~ ~tfc; mt"'lil-c!11i1

~if G:fI 11<f

~II~

f~;;;'t ~flr C\!1

c]fC$ ,(<Ii '"f\!li'lr1 ~t\li I

f~J:'i!imf
~~f~1

'!(f~'{tr ..nl "f~. 1ft"!' '{CSfI C:f! m~ o.fIC:fI~'ftt"'1 'Nothingness' \!C1'!f<fi'!ft'\!i 'ft'i I ~Jjtlif..!l~ f CliIi~'1 ell f'fl 'l(tll ~,
«i'!ft~-~r<f<lr~:n ..!I<{I\ lj1f!J clift" ilt~"~t'l{ ~1lR-<l~ f.l'C1I \!tc'" f~ ~'3 f~'\!l ~f~1 ill, ~1r;\! \!it!1 wft'J ~ll lit'll, ~ m 1ft'll, i1l"ll\ CMI<f ~ '~ra!1' -m"'l~1 ~~ ~tll I <.!I~CIf,iI fif" ~tcar1"!f l1t'tf l6{ioI"Ifc" fllfort\! ()1iOif~-~tl l1R~"l if6'It'lOf, "Naturalistic fallacy" f~ C'{~~, f"tJl C'{ 'fit' ~<f 'if1 "lR1-:fjt<ft\!l~ fallacy, l'It~C\!i~ paradox! o.fI~ c!('ft~:fI '!I{1'!f R~t<ft~ f.l'ct "f~O{ ~rn ~i'ti1l{l1-'\!l~ cQlt<\'il71~til C:'Sj'if I OflR '<t1I ~t'!f ('Sj'if I ~ 1ftti{ ~~ ~ I ~1 ~~ 'l{tc", ~t~Hf (*'Ii C~~ ( f~'fC1:i\;1~", ) ~t'!f C:~.f~1 ~ 'Il1{;"1 ~1~1 flft1l ~~ <l5l~"l-m <15m 'lJt"'lt§ ~ ( ~$:if ) I c f~~ ~<tS17t~~ '!(t:f!t~. ~flI ~ ~"fOrI{;~ <ftfi c~, mr;~ '5f!~i;CiI~tO{ <ef1Ii f'liar ;fJ1K'II. tf"lf ~at<; ~AA ~iI1~ f"t"Y c!1iJ._" '''if? ~ c!1T;lli1t~ (~t1l "5~f~~ CIflCi1{;'!i, \~~iI I DlIf~ <lCQIiJ, ~r~n5t~1~tlfil lItorn <m~ I C<I"I' "~1, ~~ ilf\!i~'[;l C'!\ <fitth'11i (1'(1;, "lftii..~ ~1 I f'rijf"lt~" !1~i7[ :fItc"'(<I ~~f~ ~t"'lf~ ~ijI{t'li{, ~Qlt~ 'll'lZC'!f'!f ~t:~J 't:\!l' (Ghost in the machine)

~~R1r ~

~i1.:"l1I

f~..
~.

'6 141,"1

C'{lfe. ..

f~~'ifl~ m<;lj ~<fui el{ Dfl <1't?lil't"1', -ett~~~"l. Cll'~~~, '€cT;1 i!U~t~, ~iI, <fl~,~t"" CS'fJhTt\5ijf <f('t~'!f ljt~5~ <il~ c'!11rnf'5"!i Qlf~ ~f~~f~,!!!1{ ilit'lf! <fQjl <{l~OiJ, ~"tlil filii'll <fl~"l'S mtJICiI 'E c~t~t~\;c~Cii'!f ~~n,~tQI1~ ~t"f "'I~f~ I 1'Iit7!'C"I'!{ lI'{o{-!fh1t"f!( 'l!ll1I.~11 ~tCljC~1'I "!f~~tijf <.!lJt\;f'j{i9f,~ ~ ~" t(~~ lltt"l <>till f~~~ij:i\;'t~c"{§ ~lt\3 I c~t!rt~t~'!! ~'lnl DCSi<ll''j{f<f~lC''rn lft-ff"T<fi ~'rrn! \!i1:<f ~~il \!l(ifJ "'Ifqm1'l ( <flS'f":fi, ~~'O{, ~trSr'f]ft'OTIf ) ~c... \!lnt P;m1il"lfOl" ( '6 ll~~tllf '<IIc;1~\!1 ) fl;fjtom I!i'!fi~ nar '5!~"l'~ I Q11~QR1 <;1i~il31 '3l~!fJlO{~ 'b:If'i!i'<ll~1'I '!fWfc1:'5til '6 ~t<{<lic~ ~'~"i{ I ~;nfif(", ~flg~f\!i<ftlf\ lj\~jpr._ijfJ·~(t~"§ljlt"'lt'l'f' ~~f'l ~if "t1{"trn~r'lfif I

~t"~

",fstmf~'f11Jfif

f<I:'i'ir~'cd 'ftW '61.:3

~m<fi1~

~~~
I.!ltl'l

Wilytl{ C~Jf,

<5(f(:fjtl'l'1

foir~~Jf

f.I''l~qi 1'ItC:fl!il I

f'iff'9f"J1fQ'{t!i~

~-'t~ - filfQt'frtQ'[ I 'iW{ ilt~ 1itc~-e <.!It~ 9J..urt1.fii 1li"'l<1'~ il1-'Ur'1nrl;r~ c~t~"1~lt'l .tjiillftt:~ ~~t<lot-~iD~tll1lT 'fOft<;§ st~t"i\' I t1Wi\', ~I "~1 "fCil. 1i~G'f <{roT"I, ~tl{it:1f!1 ~ ~~1 ~"'P\~~~if "inner life" "'tar <11 "n:ental process" 'ROf f<!i~~~t .. iJ1 I il~tifSl. <.!I<Ii~l ~t~'l<ftift '!If~tmf~tr.:If\i lIiif I5R-tJ~ I f<ll~~~ ~ 1li"1<{'~~'"m'r~l'i\t<f,~tl:''' flff~ 15t1lty '!iI~ <mf f'iff~ - c!1!i lieu physicalism, physica1ism T;~"'t 'flii "'It-e'i1l{tt~ I
<ut"'lt'll{;~ 'l"It:<lif

'Silli ~'lN1'I Q'I~C'.ll1'l '.2I~tJf 5t~1tif1 I '.2Imlj't: 61\5, ~Jjil, ~~~ '6 c'!!f5l8l1~ I wt'~-a<f '!f<;"U f~;{ ~~C<fiWt ~tirn ~ <{Jt~J1 ~r;~ 1>l{tijfi{ I Ci!fiftti"l'l" ',!.j~ t!j'Stf<i~ '<IIf~~19 'l:I1;"l1 <IIllCQli\' fol'i'\f', ~f\!i~lj '(3 "t~"lf '.2Ii1~~'fKl ~'li I (.~O{t~Ciltarf~~ f~'S~flI ~fli\!i~ c~tti{l '6 ~C""f' --.!I~ for;f~ I '!:!:t~t:lflltl1(~~ '\!It'li§~ ~~tto1~ f~tQ I ~"S'f ~t~lii!t~~ 1:Ill!91-~f~~t'l1 '!i{r'lfJt~: '!iIf'i'i"lllf I TSf'1 "'I~ Jj)<$, ,~<;
9;'Sj'<; '6 ')!ij:l1

:IIRif"i9frf'3, <liM' I

~~i'I"f1lj;,

cstfJlt~ar'lftCJf""'I

~~J.F~~il ~ ~

Qtl"1t~

1I1<fc'B( ~~tll

"'ftel1l1t<tS, ~'lmrf~<f'i!1 cqjt<f l!iftf"lf il'¥t<{\ 'ifl. t'J"'ii~m1 c!I4t<t' '!iI1f~~flll 0{1-~ ~~ "tffi~CIf cl!1 ",'Il~1 <l5t11ct ~ ~~t~§ f'<ll ~ijf, I.<A ~CiI, c-t'll "I1f~ 'lll1fir lftC01 '!("f§ f~...1lilfot "Ill ~~ "VI" <Rffi, c!1\!

';5{ C'II'f~

~rn '~r"''i'itr.:1fil 't.Pf<fil ~CIil~J I '!ft1'IC1f "{t"1t"1 fp,gt~ "tCllit~ I c.Oi1f"lif·~t-e-.ttt~Pl~ lic'!1 lIfif ~f~li;.1iI~ ~l<f~" I:\tmy ~tt'if'l1 fD.t"fQ( C'I!fu "G'lC~"" C\!i~fi{ '1~j'5, ( 'lf~\1r-l Cltl~l{JR, ~t{t~,'!i{tCil~'a/t!t~ lIt'!il \!ltf~<fi1'l1 lft<f~y "!t~ll iI<{\!if ~"'tp.", ~QIi I6{f~tlf
~;!.<.!l1

f~-.c "t~

"'JloIJIOl f1fr~K~"iI
~I~
~'li

iR~i{ f~t"l

~0\111 ClflQlt"! ~~

-r\!l'1i~

~f~C$f\§<l11f'!iftil

) • •fir'f;t. '!I1f>fcol: rt"t "t~ '11?"l'"5t1!!l~ ~lI! iiflt'5'fif"f" fffi~ ,'Vtit~r.i{, C~~i{ "~lftc1f~
'll'JiifI

Olf'i¥oft ~~'i!il/)·
"'~

~~~t~1

,":qrlmc\;t'f
'8

~fi:!7;.f1'!t~

cpt; <.!lCll
(I)(-~~

'8181{Jii{

~1ln:~1if
,I!{~

iPf

'11~

'!IftJjt~ f" ~1JT;fl ~t~tf ..f;{i!i'l·~1{~'il ~ J1\!)t~Jjf'tit.,lft>6 C'( ~'f~'f~ ~~ 1fTlI ~ "1(1 '8Ittifil iil e2f '1<S" I :f[~J ~f~rn c:*~, lj\!iJ ~,C'Sf "HI \ t <t>~c.<r1,:ijt\!J\'I 'aliJJ ~t~tt"lI·l2ftf~-fofwt'ifitlif ~ ~t1t'11, c:'1m1"1fl "It'11t'l1 <.!ll!t, "'~!;'<ji

~~ Ci{1~

::etlf"ltl

Clr7;~

f,«'Ploft ~fSi"t"lt~

<1itt':!i Q{t'Sf1Pf1i{1

C<fti{ ..fl~~11f'IDl"',~~,,'

0'11,

far~tlf l(tt"l~~
1)f~l:~Ol I

""'I~~~
fw

( Q{<1i -~l:ijfR~ )

~1fQ{:qr "'Iftf1f\~"i{t<f>6

~m

~t'W1 <H~ 1f'il~tl::qr tl:~ 1>\t'8~1. 'l,ftli "l1 I ~~'ftll ~t~ ~~:rr.{f:ij'Q't"'01 ~~i~

-99ftlftf;{",

~t""1,(<t~ "e(~~t~
1f~

~9\"
1f'il '8 ~~

,~t~
~rAA

1S'll.1l'

~tf"!l'i~tf'lUl
value!
'!{l'illi

"it

fO{C~ Igr~tCfll -c:~

-'!{t(Qlt"1~~
~t:!.li

f~'Jnr 1>\t!;;J[11 t~l ~J'il 'i_"f l!{1>\tl\!i ~ ~ ~~t1?1 ~~ f",~ ~1 ~~~ ~Ic~ 7 ~ C'!1 s>!tl? If''f'Coni ;!lj<ftfi{~-C~~~ '4~~~ Wii{ lft~~ cash
1.11'1,

~ar,

<f'3f('5t~ ~~

f"'l
'~l:1'

~tti

"lif",

~ttlfl?
'5(af

If<{ '~pn\"~

f~~l:ar C<1'ijl:~ f'SfclJ ~~tt~1I1~ <jl~l:'il C581 <i''ilca;1<!£\!lJ'It~'t:" <rl@ I!{t~ fll'arflr

'll.rn Oft

?
1!I{J~"~ 'If..~~~t*"111n;~Jt·<.fl~,

~n{m~f( ~~~ 'iij~r~i{ I

lIttO{ C:<l~

l;jtl' li{R!i1FlI "~C\!i I

'Sftlfl'lft~

()j~

~vtt:ij

\!i'l_

~~i{'8

I!{l:i{<'(i '1'( -sa;1 <1:tf" ..

~ II ~~<T'-~qt~ \;~"t "f'§C"'~ ("'f1;{ljteS! ~m11c:'5'ft-aro{ ofl<;tll I ~~

C'Sfl:'!ti{~'1iJ1C" I

~Il~~t"\ fif'lffllllf~ ~;!" 'i!it~ ~t@~"l C'i!irn <ftFf. -!jt'1 ~ If'ftl ii1it 0{<f-i1 ~ ~ <l't9f C"I ~~"f'ffli; l[t\!il I f~ f" ~ _t#fr.<iOl f~"'tiittlf~ ~ll-<riWtlf! ~1~ Clf''!It'il1<fltc~~ ~'i!il <.!lJi"ltr"l\iC<'\i oJl~ 'Sta,0{ - ~Mr <{If ~mt~l ~<ritfit~ ~f~~~ \§t:'~ \!ftlflol~1fROl 'Sf~ '8i1 r!;<'ftfS!tt'f Clt'<l:l9Q1~ ~~~t~ <ftC'!!! '!{tc:if on I ~'il ~~ '€i'\ '!I'C~<ti11}'jC1~fi;'5l1.'8 ;ff'frRfoffh ~lft~~ ClI' ~C;Pft~ ~ t.!!<l' ~~ f~ lIf,,<i''1 f<t~~. 12t'T~C<li~ \5\t1.f,{<ji~t~ \!i1 Dt"l1 'ItW C'1GWI ~'lff;

~r.~i~~

"t~

.n~~ <.!l<l'
("~, f<I"f
Cf( ~F'(

~~~l'!'

('<I'C1;C'Sj'Q{ ffh1' I!{tc(" < t.t<l'1 I

~<I'

~f"f'§f!i

<liW~-Plt"lQ{

~t~<t>"t~

'll{tt-q f~"l "1.."' <liGl l~~tV C'fir lIt~~1l1i1'{f(~-rn ~~fijt~

c<mt1;n:~~

aortt'fhl1 ~~ Il!i{COl<I'~t<t>I5H'§"W

1fCif

,~C'\!

~~f~l:I ~'>l foI I

1ft<ftllM "e(~~\!iJ1 'i>~Ci>i1 If{Ol-<.!l<[tll '1!i{iJ'l1.rr "Sit<l' Clf~1f1' ~t~tlf~t~ Being ( bieng "I~ ) "5t:6't c'1"1 under erasure I ~~ 1fJi-11(11I'l1fomt lS1l;Ji11 ~~ij'jl c~ta; '5«!f~tajl"e(tc~t'f1>\<ft ~ ~1~1jJt"l fOl~td'IIj'~

"f'lf~K~11I

lfici{ c~

~'foIl:1I- ~~t~qjJ1i{

11<:!1{,
(i\~

'lf~

ljl:~

1:5t~ Clff(!(, W!;Po:m-<l'tf"f\ft1f "5~t'5M, <5fillflftlf ~t~il'l, ~~~ ~~torrifR"f ~~ ~~t'fN\! f~"t'!lC<fi <'fC:if~ ~1;i{<1!tt... ~ ~~ tftt"lt'Sf ~~ - ~'lf5 ~f1!iff;f~~·'I!{ti:!1't"i" '1t"5t"51 'If"f'i{ ~n;(<1' '-1't~ '1!i{t:i{<lit'fi C~" f'1!iiC'Sf (.<[f.'TI:lJ !(t~tti I ~~ ~tfar C:Jj~ ;Jj't'l!"l 511l1?nlf11 C<l~V UiI'l <i't~~ ~r-. I I!{~""~ <flt"f'<;i '<;i1cijfl Dt~l '€ "1t~) I o:rt~klf'~ f"l~Of~ "'<t1 f'<ji ",til' ",,{COl c9fT~ 011 ?

~t~"
*

Ciill<l5'8~ I

~'t<;;!t<f\1 'l]_i!i'ltlftt~ 1fr~~<tt'!l: '~tC'i{' 'lllCiI;' ~Wi. (.~~~n:"l4 ClI'

flfttp~t~-~~

-";Q(l-(Qf'1jt~ ClI1}jt'!{ (lfl;tt'!l "~tcot

C'fi7f-'1ft!Oi ' 11' f"f~to:r
~~ 1ftC"l

C~IoI-~~1;~
1

~t~' ..
"!\!C~

fi:c~~ ~tf~
tti~~<ji

Btl ~t~1'lt~

f"t~~a; 0Trlftl

f'tt1,

~tR

~~q> C6t.'1

Cf[C~Ol ~><f

c~ ~~ f,,~~ ~t"lC\§ 1>\ "l'1 tfil:

1mii' "111
~1f"lf<f Col~

"<ji'2l1 fo1~l1lj~tt.,.tf<q"C\§ Cll' 11" t~ "<ji'ljl 't{ij'jil', c.'l1~ 1f"1~ J1"Pf!:~ I '<!i{t1f\f1-<lii!l9 Jf ~f'&!l' ~~c1i f<jiJt~ 'I\"It~ ;Jj11tJ 'i!~ ~t~ I hfol ;Jj~111 '<;i'<f1 "5tt'<R, '1I'If~t~ 'S!$1}j~11I <Ii\'fl "5tt'l0{ "11 - \5\~lfj 1Ili11f:ij\9t$' (\!i1 C"1~-:if'tl1l' -..flll ..!I1fOfi;'5Dt~"\ f\!lfi{ 'J!~, '"'Ii '<;iU!' <li>ft~
1f~~ lJ~

"ftt'?i ~f1f W'!~ I CCfiron ~~ ell: @fi:t f<ri!l!ltl:0I~ "f"l'l!j-," 'I!i{.'<tl~~ <II1lfI ~ ClI'~, ~'<;it~ <ri~~Of, ...,-mt1S'1l6tS11 lJ:~<R.~ IfCar~i1-~'lJIi}J~ f'!i til 'I!i{~';~ <fij;<1J(if~ C'l:1 I '>!itl'!' Ift5f lj,Ul1"f 51"<1Tt:\!i ~Oi! <;:!itCQ{,\ art'1!:~l "lItcO( <.!l~ '<!i{~ f<l"" ~{",<f'i!11 ~~"I'.tc( ~'fl:'f ( ~Ttlfll'lIr:Jj ) lfl:!Jf '1;'Sft"f -dilItt'i!1 ~~'l1:t~ <r1 ~'lltt~"i1 ~mrn'<ji~l-~\SCl~ 'IlI1<11HI <Ii~OI-lf~Q{j"f ~r~l ",~mtJ'l1 clICi;"l1 I Ns' ~~ ''!i"~' 'Ut1~ ~t~t~ '!{t<rtll' ~fiI:'f1fJ 0{'!1 I '!Iftt"f 'IlIt"l"tlf "~~":ijC"l"il ~iarl ~'!i" ,\!~'<1i~ )[14t01" I <.!l1lii 'ilItR. C"I CJj "Jfi<ftot m'Sf 0{1" 1 filS!t'1 f", '<;i~, "fiJiOicmlfOl
11 11'1I~'T ~~
'IIj'?r~t<li

~'lftfi1 ~<r"ik<rn

on~rn

f~:«'5!I: ~"\it~,
~Jt~l{~\':Jj1
'!I{OJJ

C~{1?

t~ili<JItlf,

:if~~

<1:JtllJt~ I
C"t<l

"ftil'i{ilitlf(ot i>f~~

~~

Cll'

'!fi1ftt1nl:
-~

tilt'(lfo:rr.~
1fC;;tif""iI'

il'filti!\Sft'{ ~~:iI

,,18 <IIt~ ~<l',

'8 JJ1ft'!!j~, f.!t~ '1'l;.t-fl!Fc~"Sl-~c"r~l ell.' I!{ltijff'6i1;l"~ (~ar "'t~ti ,f!'<1:~t"!l 'lJI'ttfitt\!) ?

ofIH ~rn cit1l-~t~

~ll'HI

C*~

"$1J!'1!l-"~~1"
I

I 'It"f01 ~~

~~ftg ~C'5'f15111

"*"
~

<'fJ'<f ~~
(f(\;1

(~lfi'l

51"f1 "It'{j-)

'l!!{i'lftff

~tlfl1t

'¥ftf~ CCilt1>\ "'tt'll

C"5~ ,

C"!i1 l!l~1;{~-~t~ ~'tt~ ~t~ ;Jj'lfii'f I ,:I\clftv ( oft;t~\'l '<ji'ift~ internalization)

~. ~/lf~-'lpf~ii

~"t "I,"

f~~iff~lf fffi"f. '!ft'{rn '!\ij)' 'fIlf<:5m'1' "!lttii I ~~m.:<f!l: elf o;e11&!~ <fi~ f~ <{1;i!O{, ~tt<lf ~fo1 ~'1,tf'1'\§ <ffi\ii ii1 cmtli'{ I .!l~ 'i!if~~f~ '~rt"'l'rtlfil: Rf"'lJ;\!i ~t!l-c<Rii1 ~~1tIrf ~~·wt~ ~'U 'll.tll C'l~ '$I~~f~ ~~-/'1~ "~ii I ~1 l;f~fo1 'liI't'lfttlfil: CIf~~ Qf€1!1 ~ ii1 I iitf~ '~~",-'1~lf ~1Jl~ (~~? If''fb:I~ ~~:'!JTI1: ~tfii iitf~-et;, l'
C11:~<!
~'f~

~l5wt1'
~~

~~lf <!t'f1 ~

~ lf~

f;H::~

bt-l' ~~~~m.:<H\,

9<rtfOf,.

'\§~ Clf~
~1~lI'tcj~

"1i<f1ft-1~'fi 'lfcO{ ~
C\!i1~J1

'Iffi11 "fi;~-'Stl'f1 c~t<ii Jft<!~tii \"

(.lfn1'lrrn

!
~2f ~

'1~ ~ .!l~ C'"flil' ~ ii1, Rfilri ~~ '1~ I C<f'ifol:1 "<i('1C"1f o.!l\!'I!f' ~1 ~Tlf,
",elf c'lf€~1 ~<f

f~,

\!Wfi' 'C"f~' ~

f1I-"tt~
~'l

'5ffu .-~'!lltii1

~~f.i I

~J

~~

~1 '6~i$ w<ll ~~ Mi7ilor, 'The end' iil,

THE DECONSTRUCTION tS1511"

-9ft'l fi;f?t
~~t~ lft"'fP,<!ilf1 ~~

~f!<!i, ~ 'ftil'1 f<t~'~~~1 fift" ""~"llti:iii1 '<IfC~C§iii-mll:~~C:tl!l r('IIl!_'i; <~l"t~ I Cll~ '!{t<f~N<If ~ir<!i~1l' C"fl! ( ·~t~ l{:!-~1M f.f~~ ~tfiitii 1['» ) I ~\!'iltt(~Ji~ ~ii<flt'W ''!fl~JttiI, ~~-<!I"liltlJl '13 tg~-~ipf~1Jl I "'c~ ~u-f-rtl1:til!l i7i'1ii1rCtlliilll' lftol<!{ -s il1-~ii<! m~iiI'!l ~j~ "flf'fffil i1f''''1[Wo{ C"fliil ~11'-.!l~ c~1, ..!l~ ''l~}f\!i"1 flO1<TIof 'f"f til, <.!l,,~r(-- ;~~~ f"fW' +-Death Ind nstry ! i,

R"f "f\Wl'lf

'R~w

~?fi't ( fil~rfs'i!l)

Ayer, A.l. 1982. Philosophy in the twentietb Century. London: Unwin paperbacks. ~"Ift"'ttl{ml. ''If"l'a1 t;'iI~ 1)~""'8; f.l;~"f "I~1"Ir1~ '1t"5f'l.J If~o:r
~'~i1 :: '1f-61[<f'lf' ~t~l ~<II 9f~ I Frolov, I. ed. 1984. Dictionary of Philosophy.

Moscow:

Progress.

~N~O{
\,!I~.

:11"'9\1.

~IIIH. I

~t'6] '0

"ft"5t~ 1f1l{~ ~f'i!l~~I c<t>t1i!~:

RoutledgeLondon::
UlllTIr

fo1-

)j~<ft~ I.llJt~ lj'ff~:

fOf:

Russell, B. 1927. All Outline of Philosophy London: --_-'. 1946. A History of western Philosophy. Unwin paperbacks.

( "n:~

'~tt~-<lStC?l'-'1t~llt-'lI:rn' 'Jff~illJ ,~
~tQ'[ "<i(~

"l'iiii ~r<li%~'{ [If'E1l1 ~iiI 'ilti!l I

-s '!lWlOir~ ~f'i!l~r:Jj ~~f11 ~

'6 ~\I31h~>(oPltlf

I31fOf",l f*1f1t'1' ~~it I

"lt~~<f I ffl

~t~~<frlf. I!If'nt'f