111.!li.

Ti' II

~ .5 '( f
~
~

:'I:f ~

~sttQj~1 ~t-mC'lf~ ~~
1S1'foitfS"Hn;<f

_;'

~ hi ~ ~~ ~

~
~ -0!

~
~ ~~

!:ini§{~

C'i"f I ~~ ~i~ : ''5ft~1 f" ~~ Clft;5f~ Cl\ 'Of! <rof <1i~~ ~ ~RI 'Of!?, oj! ~ ~1:fJ ~ ~.~\'l: <\'i~1l{t~ r f«f~~t1 ~~

~'''rn ~

~~

f~~ ~~

~~~>

C~l~ fu'i!)

C~

Of~

~-~~

f~ ~~~ ~
~ '~~

C~ f'l1:"f.t~9 Q{"l'J

"Iifi:. ~
I

on

\!IN ~~9

0iplfJ

~f~1 ~~ ~N~ 1tnf f<lS \!iVl; nt-Oi "I'"Mnf ~ ?

Ul~

~9. ~
I

f<li ~i{ ~"U '€ci fo; ?

\!)~

'lim. 'i!t1.:1!i

f~

\9ft"l"W{

i~m ~~1 ~~{Q{iI I f~ fOif~~. ~iIim"t

<tIn;~

~~~t~
'5f~~9:

" .•. ~~~"i1" ~<IP.ii ~

~~J~
lj~~!f\,[
oj!~~

mnr

<t>nf'l
~

furor ~ c if"f1N f,tc~.

i!~ ~!:i

'S!W

1!fm1 ~'i\!i

f~
"2!69

f~,
~~"ftOl

<lttf1 ~'S'<lot <i'i1"'ft'i'f ~t'lJ ~~:rn~"l1' <ft~~ l{~

~;gtf~

m~'i.l{-c!l

lj~"2t!lflr

>!iftw i{<I%~

~nr
~

~~ \!i1it N'lftC<tS tJf~~ <f!fffi~ ~~

(I9ft'f @r;~
I 15ft'S! ~~ 15f~ '6 ~

mhr Q'lT;1

~*'~ f~
<fii;tf~
~~
~

<It'11 c9(Qi \!i~

~cl<ftiStfar"l1' If!:ot ell; I ~ I!ff~~

lf~i{ i!<jl"~

cmr
~"

<{q;

~-"ij<f6i

<e

fil"~'Tt~~ ~1

~lSt~

~cf
~~

CD!!
~

<p.!f&: Ql~1 ~mlf'll

"ij<{

m
~ ~

~r<f ~\!i

~jf

'!: ~~.., oj!

I
~.

Pfli, l{N
~lf'i'f' Clf~
Ul~

fo;~ ~

"<tS~~

.'!{tf~~
~

1 ... .4 '~.' ~
~
! ~..

m~
~:IIli1

<it~it ~J\!iTI!, oj!~ ~fari! 'ftf.iCi ~ ~~ ~~,~ '!ffi( ~ ~i{Jf~ 'lifTIt st"ti?l'1! \!('Ij~,
<Ii1~~

~tQl

"Imr ~R-f,{'R, ~-~'3 forfitl:~ m1tQ~I'<t>ClfM-~i{ <t'Th, ~ T ~ar~. ~

~AA1-~
<fIfil
\!)~ ~

~y

"<tS1T6. '<tt<l>-

~m-m ~
1{ft<J ~

m~

Jf~l\itlri{ on ~'1 1fIftlAl1 'ft ~ Tft~t'! "Formal Elaboration of social Hierarchy". (FESH)l

~-~
~

Ulilil"iljC~ I

~
I ~~-

~'<ft" f<i'"fl lfif""

-ei1

!)

)\':!/~tfil ~

'<!f~ct1 ' "'I't'Afli

lft"M,;t'j~
<'(i~~ ~

Offiffift ~\!i1/)

)~

"I~ ,sta'I,

e'?i ~ffi-f~

I.!:l,,$ '~~ Clf~l1(~

Caf~

"-!i{~ct

"~1, ~ ~~ ~
ffiaf ~ I.!:l'(;! I"~

c:sw c~t tt'S/

0f1~,

f\Sf;{ I?iIl!lft"R"~<!i ~<~ ~ ~~Of, <£I~ "'{<'f!'Rt<Ii" ~~'\! f'Sfm C'!ii C\!it~-~
I

~t~
~

~C"

.!j~ "~~-~tfil';

~fir

'

~t~il<li-~t"Z,

~",Iol:-~tol,

I!;~-f~

<l;'i{

lfC'\!)1<!I'r:i1~<tt'll: ""f'& 1!fti~~1 c'f1'& 'Wt!l fOl"t'\! I ~Itm ~'" Qj1, tl;~~'i{~ifT'91 (.1f'51r:<t' ~~~ <mtOl"'Sff1iJ~ ., rtr,t(<(c<!S ~~.'f ~r:~ ~'C'ft\!i~~ ,,~~~ ~,c:Jji;"j i!;9(f;n:'tI"r1'l (.'Il'till "J{ 1 Utli ~ ~tl t:;~11f I <f'if'-Rsti9ii{ ill''\!t\!l C"T15AA lf~ ~'Sf ~'\l ~ f~~11'( lliRcipline ) I!It'f ~-l!itt<ll" QiI"'Mf<tt~ fi!ji"l11~
'E

f~

OI"~,

f~~

"Itf<l? C'!itilt~ 'SItPl ;"It~-~l:\!i <11 f"l{;~ ]~ on, (ljilli C'!if'l(1~ ~1 ~, \!it~at 1 qqtm (-.,;1"1' ~ (l;jr~~ ~ c'51 ~ <£IJtf<m'i!l.J), CiI~ 'SIltf'!l~c<'II iltOlJ <m: ~1';{t" flff ( f<lt"\"f~ ) ~t~t~ Cift~
C!'f<f, ~
~G1 ~Zt\!i

(xenophobia) ~m ~~ C'!i~f.i ~<t CR{-el1 lf$l"~ C<!i f~ \ f<I-.j~Jt. C~c<l' ilm ~1I~, <l;i ClPl~ ~!f~<f lf~'{1 r OItf<li 'SItf~ ~1!1~ ~ 7 ~ (}5f.ill -..nT:. f~'l-<£I?I '"IJtt<\) 'SItfi{ c\5"I 'SI1l\ Ic<t'~ f'Ei~ "Itfit 01"1I -.n~nFl\l~~ illpfI,f c~~m-

Pi'\!tf~ ~1

~'\i-t'Sf

t!;"Ifuffltt1f~ Clflm\!i ~ flr<i.-<:5t~ ~~~t~ !It<f c~, \!it~ ~tCO{i (.1f~i{ Tf~~t~~ ~?

trltCOf 'SItnre <.!l~0I" ~ I .!jJt~i\ ~ ~<!il-~lftQI$l <!I'Q,f1rtSll ~~-'@t-fof f fll '6~T; "It~~tt'f?l ~tol'e ffl ~1 -.,;m f\ii~ ~~~ ~W, ~~tlf~ ~'\!JtN I ~ ~tOl"~ ~~ 'll'~t:1lt~~OI" 'Si~tl.l "iI~~14l"-1.!:l1l <!I'~~ <.!lt~ti: "ii\""1~ t11f'\!~(nt I <I~PII 'liI'11ffol-~TfttOfl (Discourse Reception Theory~$'6 ~ ift"f'Stt!?I ~<tlftOl" I)~ C~ ~2-fif~r:<\' ~~ar "ItGl f;{ I c~~t?l ~~'4 <f.~1f~ lfIi!i I <.!l1f\!i1~"l!ti§, "'!5(~ ft!rt!lol:, "'I;\!il!!" \!it~llj\!iJ"-<£I~'ll: ~i« <ttl)Of~~ ~1 01"1 ~t~. G~l~'""'t ~~~ C 0{1 ~, ~~ Clf~tt~ <¢ft'l\m ~~~ ~ "'IN '!5(tl%1 i9!lf't~ c£l~~ ~ift~ ~flf il!rt;t~1~~~,<;5{f1f?f ~ ~fal \!i't~t~ ~ ~ 1 Gt{ 'lf~ c£l~~~ "Ilft~~~ ~~,),[1 tcaf fltWt~, \!itSl ~ C'!ii ~\S!l:-$'{iI<ftlf \ c£l~tto{ ~-{'Iff<flfim Of~Q ~ ~ttil1 ~tiiji~1 f'S~ lffi4Hr I f~ (.1f tI~ ~\!i1 <mI .. ~ <tartll "I~ ~~ c'Sfl:~ ~ ~t'6n1 I ~~ oil~<t1lft 0f1 'Q,nl ,",Wi'!" ~'(oj~~ C¢t"f ~ I ~Qff~tm ~'f ~-~J'll: ~ ~ttoml "fC~ 0f1 I ~ 'f§1"I' "ftci 1!!1f11 Cl,{ 'll~~ (1.if~ ~t'l ~ ~t~, ~9 'i!it~ ~ttlf~ ~J c~<l1 <fm~O{ I <£1m "-!i{lPf ('\.!it w~ 1tm, "fQI'C'41 f1iP4; ~t"fi{1 ~r'fil11') filt'Sf'9 f-ft'Sf'll: f1iP-1; @1~hl ~~ ~\!i1'(oj C<f~ c<t'@ lSi'tt\!i ~t'll:Of, ~ I!IIt;j'~II5{~O{ 'WC~f~ Derivative f~, ~~ \!ijt1{i Alter

,,~t\!i

~r<i'1 \C!rtfhr IlJ;C'Jflc I r.11'~fc;1 CIf'Oltor. ~t~ ~~~ ( ~<!i~t"f Of'll ) C:'1IfC~MR"""i-'SIlr"lli-'1lul f'ltJI "Itvt brttt9l"'l-c~-ms>f1lf·m ~ ~ R~'1 <fC\fOI tr. ('TO) Jt TI~"'·~o~~~t tjf~i'f*~ ("l) >Jt'll,'i!~ f<1:f~~ ~itmfit~ 1'PI1J f l' t "1 ( ) f.1~ f I'll ~1j f'1'5tl!3ii1' (lib) ~~\1 I!;~to{ '6 W~<£I'I,! .~ tlllt: 1 ljr. 1 lIC ~r.lJ 'I[",Pt"ll'1f t<r-lt~"tWPSEif ~\!'f.~ I ~tart<f ~~ C . '"1''11' • 1"llof1 "'I't'$ ji{ 0{ tC'T '5~tcqr~1<!S'\'tf~, C:Jj~ '~~' <!St~~ • "1r.·H~·l ~i;c 11l~ '1!;~i1$ CO{~ I ~t-:if\1'1 ~lllltlfi'1 ftt:<li '!'I<ffr:\!i Pt~tlf ,~'1 !J 111"1tc~ r.'I "ft~1 ~ c~tlli~'lI'~, "~~ <utt'lf ~~" Tit~c~ ~~tl"iJf'in'tJI "~h'! ~01Il~ l!i1 om I "~q\!S", ..~~ .. ~tfu f<tt'l\fll'~~CEifi CDt~ 1jt~'If'\'t ~~tqi ati$J1V{1 ~'\!i, \!ltr:\fi'l' ~fu~ ~ l2!~t\!S~ '\i~ 01"1I ~ ¢~f\!i\'l; fil"l~ 1jtQ1 '\i~, ~'6 ~t~ C"\"f'€~t~ 12!~ ~"hI 0{11 ~<1't~ ~~~ -s «~, '~FfifQj' ~'\t~ i'!t')'[cafOl", ~\f ~~ '1_"1~~, Revivalist!

~~~ r,n

w.~

m~~~i

~ttlf1'l'
CJ(~ ~ti'1~~
(if,€'IfI

'J1~

~?;"f·r lfc!Pif\§1
lli~

~~Pl'1Clft'l\f,
~

.!jlfOl"~~
C~

<;§ftt'\!

~cif~ ~fimr f~,

'911:~

~~1t<t>'€ 1j~ CQf1/t$C<;i f~1t ~51f\!-I!;:jf~ ~0if~8 '1'lf~

~',~

~~ iRT ~

~tlf'tf.6"

~'Sf
\51~

~lit~rJf
'5Ci\'ti: I

C'i!~ "!'l~i'l'

1(1' <nt1l!f ~~, ll~OO

'!f'-li'Slc<i &!~'1 ~~

Pl'1f~"C;{~'\~
"1 trtt~"1
C1j

1'Itim 1!fIitt~~
fm~'i!il~ ~~,
~ C'lI' '~~ \!Stt<:!i ~rn ~r:<t>rn

~f~'ij '5Sh1:

0fl.:ilM <£I~ JJ~

C~~

lfi'if'If'{;~tart~
~~

<!l"ll1;1 C"'Ji~tOl"f~l1t<1

C~?;<'Ii ,'itt\ii I

f\!iR lft<1>J("11fl f~~t<t ~ ~~1 ~w

c<tr-tt<f ~<ml c~~
~~1{

~t~"' ~
~t~

'Iftt"l"f

~t~t~~~
~f~'ll:

fi{C'U', ,~ <!i~ 'iiSi't\!S

qqll\IC!f1'l <2fQ,jf'Sj:\5
~

~f~W!, "a>m~
f;rr:ltlii I '5f<Tt~

mw:

'lll ll~lC9jtc<iI C<l' ~OI" ~1

f lel,..{

fifrJ'l. f" W"t ~~

"It'lf' ~

f<l"~~
~~

OftWI' Ol"tfir<f1 ~
~~t'f{~

~I' )I~ i ClWI ~~

If'll j11l;1 ~ (, 'l.!~ q_~R
(\!iiI

$~tm' ~

fif~,

~'ff';{t<ff"t'-ti '!ilt~a;r o!l~lSlr:<t~ G\!l1 ~mlflQ ~C\!l ~~-~~ <Ii~~ <TtarOl" "Itt( l)JWt~"'\ 18 ~'§ 'D6111 I;Jt"l111'i;1~t~l;~ 1!!iJ1ISiC1{: '!I'tlf!l:1 < G~i

w.<rt~

'<t'"rn~
~"lo;\!l~

«~

~ '~fl[<li O!I:fI~' ~\51{ i I ~ ~ifo1fi; <{aJfwr

f~'l11!iIT"rY qqt"liDf!l:

a~

~ta;r

\!l{j':llt~~ glO{-

f"11:'Q(f~ ~

ti'lf!1 1~<:!i ~!,Jt"h1c~~~ l~~o{\!lt'l ~t~~ 1{tI{Jt~ <tt(-m1"f-C,fl\5"l\11 ~f~ \ti(tfir~rn f~ :ttt.~ ~t\!lill "Iti<f, c~a;r ~wl 9111'Sfti;'1 r;<'II'1!<fhi. C~1I(1 cllle,", t t'l1 (.1:I1I'tI C"!t1ti:",! <!l~ <!l'$l'-e l(~ 1IfSi~ m ~~"',

Discipline COl"~, l{#Jf-<dll\!i" Labour ~ Q\i;r-:l' '~flf'"ft~1' <£IC~ 'If"l'\!i1iJ'?"~

"~"I'.~~

} ~l:r1~11Itrn c~cr1
o!tf1{~-~~f'1'\!) ~~ Clf)~~~

C"fQ.l~

..r~1 ~'i!1/)
~~"I-e

)~

"R'!{'1o;f-'5~."
'e ~~ ~<m~r;a;tt~

0011, C'fR ambiguity-a

"11 c<rt~,
Ol:r~,

o..!!. ~1<!l~~

"11, ~'N: <!l. m ~~Of ~f~ ~m 7 'under erasure' ~ttl!i{ : ~~ l)t'>S

f<ll" 1R"I ~

trace C\i1 c"lt"'~ 'lItll! <£t~r~'\!) ~fif~'6m<ji <!l~~ \51"\1' <!llfif c~~ ~,lft'f--!I "'Ifuct~ <H1 <Ii"I ~Ilfr~ 'Ut"fl~ I C~ ~W:'1~ stt~ l)J~"'k<ji -s1'ffOTI;<1f"f~ ~~ ~<iilI -s f<llRr~t"rt1l'{li!lj'JIl\9tt~ ~~ fm ~~ f"lC"S~. iMl"l~~ ~1t ~t}{~ ~'iP,rc~ ~. ~ <fI'S ~Vli ~~ !~ ~fif"li~4 ~t<t-f~ C'!J," ~t~ilSi1I!ftm1f'.'l" mllJ;, '\!)i <!i1!i{'8 ~l ~~tf~ ~tf~. <fi1!i{'8 'f1 ~i~~ ~"'tti CIf~-f'Klf~ ~ "'tMr"ftf~ iitAmf <4tt"lS ~ti-I o..!! ~W'1ti ~tlf~ l{ti{ ~ ~t.,'\!itm ~f~<te '"1~ I e~ flft'"rta; ~<ji1;1 ~rG''''It<Ii ~ FJz:f\g ~U~l_~ ~ "'ft"51~ f~<F":Il1-A"grrO{ ort"f, f~f~ "'Itfo@l~ ~<t

f"'ti

~ Ofi

""t~

12I~'l:{<rtt'B!, 'B!1'jlf"t-r c;<fPl '8 ~~'B!ti{~ ffiill'e l{i ~<1ii <?$l~ <ffil"ifR' ~'i!"'tlf\5t<t~ \'!i{~~~~l'P!t~m:~ (.~Wi'S ~tii '6 ~~~'<I \'!iI'ka;1f'5'\!i ~i{ c!I~ '11<11~ ~~~ I f~15:( ~'Wt~ ('1f1il~ f!lilf,!,-UI ~ ,:('i'fi'1 «{filtll ~t~ c?I~tti{, ~ ~t\!irn "!.If!(J'fPi<t,~ ~fl&!{ (''4Ifllt~ f5fomr Clfi, .lj"f~ c~ ~1 ~t~t~ ~<ffit ~fI:~.!Jf 4t~ I ~~ C31~~'Jf, \5t~ <:rnfCi{, 1!(tiI)1'ff~ ~~ #l~"''6

~"'t~O{91it ~t~~1i{ (~~

\5~ ~ilr.'ijiI

I!ftf~

I ) o.

tt~

\!{fl{!l1 ~r;

'Itfil I

~~
<!l1ii:! oJ). JTji;I

f'1l

vrtill ll"m :Illal<srJ'1ltf1 W\!i~l)t4tif c*.<i' fo:!t~t<f 1l_te> ~~

cl,JfcQl''i{ "fto:( l)Jr1;t'B! '"'I
I

rtI~

~l'Sm'JIif

(II'

''<!i'f"ijjfOl<1i

~1f1f\!l

c'ft~l.('~If'~~

c~

~1f'

'<mtf;{<ll ~'fta;'-~~ ~~

~ ~~

fil'a;~ )-f;{ljtt~

wt<;!'1l1'\!i1-

~~~

~t1frn <r~ <!l<1it"'t~ ~ ~~

~~1 ~ ~,ft~ orq;flfOf, lft\'l" :Ilt!Jf '5f1lf'1'1'~~fi ~r~i' ~~~ ~~~c<II" ClM_.i{ ~Qj~1 C~1:"li I c'1c~I'~", ~1Q0f I firip[:~il: <ffi<1; ~ ~~ "'It~tfu <!llfOf ~1., f<!i ~a;11ft~ ? ~ o..!! ~'!I ~~-fl!i'mt~ti ~ ~,ft c"'IUf~ ~1S'81l1iS Cl1lf-c<ll'S I ~1fort<tf-r~\1' ~~C'.'l" ~l)J~GJJ1'-~ :Il~~ C'!J," ~ ~fir""ijj A~'f ~ -~~ C:lllf-~ll' ~'\!) c~-r;<f fi{~t~ "'Inrf.! 01tci;~ I ~mi{ fol~t'l1f ~ "litll ~i{~mft :Ilt~Of1 ~tl1~~ <2frl)Jf~m-~~ fifm11f ell" ~nn ifOf ~1 C'fIf (Jff?ltJC~o{ ~i{-~nr '!i{~~~I ~~ ~~~1:!.f~ ~ f<rrol <f~ ~~'i{ e~~.rt f~&;lif I"' {_r;"Ifo!~t:"'r'f f~ <iuR ~ ~fif'\!) ~, ~-~pr~O{ ~t~~ ell" w~'Wtf~\!i ~~, <!l~ WI f<1'~ "'i'~~IC'" )j~ <l'C~, '\!)1~~;;§ ~~ C'1~ <1'~ ~f"ci{i{ (\!)<srf"(Ol'1 I 1f!i'i! ~<1il-'l1lf-<!lit <rt~r'1t~~ ~tfi;~ ~ \f~1J;1I 0li1"t':tj"~ ;!{C\!il ~5Jf.1WPf~ Pt"'ti!.S7"1<1i lJOIi~! C'1f.<u:~ "It~ ~~fiWr't~'"f~ 1IC\!i1~ mf~cy~fm~ <ut'1<f !ft;;;t~teI'1 I ~~tlfl ~t<sroitf\!i c~ofut 'Si1.:({J~ ~A~~"1i{t~~1 ~tat~J'1flf ~l{ttlf~ ""(!li, f~ 'l1.~ 1ijfol~ >Of .. I <!l~ ~<li't<f f~ 'liftt~ts"ll <roli{ ~f"t~ I ~sorfu<iWClf.:l 0\ l.fI<fiiil lIRfiiw f-Nt't <:5!tC'li, ~ <f!lf1 f\!ifo:! "i[$l ..~ <1'00 OR ':(f.1~ ~Nr~t~f'lW\ i{~, 'i_~r'1 -M~ (mythograpby ) ~DCIl' I~ m'l, f'<lS'1fa\" ~~cw>1 ~ ...~~ :Il~ f~'i! ~ 1 ~ ~t1l ~~-f~utll"~ i{i, 1ItO{tft'r:l~~" ~i(f~-f~ ~fiI~~ ~r~·f~ ~~~J ~'I:j'll ~r:qoWi ~f"f~ CW'lr<t>li ~~5f\!

f~~ ~ ttti{'1frn "6rwPl'il f~~ "11 I

I ~~If.:l

tlf7I)'l,lt~,,~ ~ar;r m9ft~i{f~ ~f~tc"lf~ ~. ~l!lc"l sort6 ~: "If nationalisms in the rest of the world have to choose til ir imagined community from certain 'modular' forms already
to them by Europe and the Americas. what do they have

~tt'\!)

left to imagine ?,,):. "~1" (II' '".iIt'lfi( '6:!'jf'lfi( ('!ift~ <J;f~~iit~ '"tt<f~l C~l~' fii1tt<t ",~flii,"'Sm" t'<l~ fo:!~lt '5ftarm <ll~ft. ~~lit ~Ij" ~\!im ~. 'i1<l1tCif'6 e'<l~ ~tt~ ~I@mc<ll"f~~ lft"'ll; I ~t~m ~i{f'e
~i

available

~t~ ~t<mT <li t1 <f~~ m.§~ ~)f~O{wrn ,'fto1t'1~~ I" ~ tffltOfil: '5ffif'lltif ot'Sm~ ut~~l f<1i" f<l"~'\!) "f\!)~ ~c<5t~ ~t& Ig~ '>'f1rnR I ~t"li1 ~J <m:t~, ~~ "ff~ ~~« ~f~ ~'Sfffi nf'tu '1_tU om ~~ -.fI~ ~~tc'llJ~ A?:i!I~ "rf'er;<f <jitt1l~ ~ I ~~ ~~<!i ~f!f<fnr ( Linguistic Human Right ) ~t&9J.~-~w~ f<li., ~\!iI '6im ~t~'f'\!i mml;! (FESH) C~~~ ~~ if1 f<i'? C'!J," ;qi1tt~~r( ~<1i flf~\.ii'1l ffi o..!! sttif, '\!it~ "'ViifJRttlt <!l<'ll"1.~'!litf\!l<fC<ff~ l ~

~f~i!i ~$fi{1, 'N'lI ift1.l1~ 'Stif~ ~\'l" I ~ lft<ft c~ m I c~ lft<ft C'<lc<ll"~ c~

-em

~ti

"'6~"If~" ~1

..~

~ m:, ~ ~~

"6~, ~te\5ta;

'1t., c'$ftl 'SciO{ :

filst1Ul1; C<i'MtR I
Capitalism"-~::r
f.l~

«f;r?

~f.rn-

<T1ftijf

<!l"lim ~~ 'S1«r;\.ii" ~« "Electronic

<.!l'Qfi{

'~\!l
~

C"fo{~H'S~~~
~

"Print Capitalism"-<!lil: <!i~!

<Ii"'1Jl;til: f.rn1ll\!i H{ictS>f ~1 ~ ~ll!:lii/~~, <!l pr~ ~m'!ll, ~tt'5 ~\!ifG ~ I I f~f.'irn! \5ttlf~ 1'flii'lfm~<i' 'fil,;fip[9\'I3~ 1>ftc<l, 19J llTIfif <fi~ "Ij t'1 I r'11:~?;~ <1.:ff~ '\!)~ ~ Panoptieon 'f~l(~ :Il,~f~~ ~ I In; f<lC<f~ <rt~t~ ~tCi{f~ \!i-rf~1f :if~C<f c!!~ "C1\(t~"l C~'~, C~~ (;lr'A~" ~'1 I1't~~ <fiI~ ~ I ;:ern 1\tCif f<Is, ~~ cyberspace-<!l~ netwQrk~
IIS~l.l 'f1 ~iffi"'lt

I!fllf<l"~ts/O{c~~ f'fC1l

H·/~

C:~l'fl

c:'1nTfti

i{f.;r.Tt ~~I

::> ~ ::>

lft<t') ~~ ~o;r? '!1 rn~~~i, C<!f~'!~ ;iftt4' 5Qitc~1 ~ {~ citizen-c!1!t <Ilft'i Q{ netizen ~fl <RI, Q{ 'Sf"fi!tf~F!~ 'ft~1{ '1\ ~'Sff.~-f~ IStGtlJ<f'l( ~~t'ifi<i <!f1 hyperreality c~fil: <!iClf, ~ "M!':<I't~ ~tt;nr lj!l{Jc1t~1 '<Itc", C~<IIlt-rn ~~t~ ~oH s C~~i1 1{i9ft~1 c!1~~~ I ~ "~C~~l ~ '1j.{t;tll: <21~ c!1~i1 D'{Qi <.!l'Of I ~ 'f~1 I'fll'ftl, ~tf1{ C"I ~ c!1~9 <TiQfl ~~, CJI <nrtr-{'€ ~r:<:fl @'1"f'il5 ilf\!i;{\501"-! 1{f<tic:~tm '!{ito;rt5"l11l ~~ ~1·~ ~ 'Sf't<p.{m C~'SftC'lft'Sf fou:~ "M~ <Ti?,fi<l'~1 ~U~ I

~ fu~!!l""'m:~~R

'tf6f'ffi;~

~ <ITa; "~.f"6f<tl' ~~", '\!tc'\! :f!'\!')~~ ~i <.!11{~ dI~i f.t;l ~ ~ '~I~f~" (Jrt~o:t ~filf ~ ~ f,,!) IS~~ ~ OO<tiJj\lf~ ~~ m ~·@ll<jifl\,N:1{ ~'i{ ~fl!i"I ~tffi ' ' 'mar ~fi '11 G'Il;C'Ofi<f, ft~<f . C~ ~t'Jf <n'~, f~f'li~ ~Jtfir ~t"f~) ~tflf 'l~ ~-~ ~"9\t<llif r.rf.~~~ C.~"111 Of!"l~iftfir <f1 '5t@fo:!~~ (centre's gaze ) r.r~\!" ~W I <.11~ ~~·~f~ ~t<mr '!lftficr., ~f\!~ tw ~ <m; c.1'f?J1il"

~:!!f~tc~Zl ~clfol f~~ f~ '\1'-rn~ lf11Il ~t~, C\!i~;ft C'f,(;if"l OfRr:~i1, "Commonwealth literarure">" "It"l<'li c~tt"'t'\l1{t>'[J '1.,ut f<'list!:<\" ~~~ ~ ~~~~ f<I;~ ~tf~ I dlt'tt<'II" C\!i13iMoTI is.,f-{C1\:''ft'n .,tf'$~~l fill'f~ fu~ clf~r;~ I ~!11). ~~ c~ ~ Of?Jtil, ~<Ti ~ Ii~ ~ <2IfilF'.ll c!1~ '\!~~15 ~W f~lf ~t'1" ~til'l c<ftt~ lJtf~ "ftci- lfI W;m-?iT~ s>tlZ <2ffu;~tl CQlt'lS 'I1;t~ I ~~ i!l:~ c~1 ~ ~'l$ C~l~'f1 'lS11 ~ ".iI~j <!I~ ~~ "~~J" (~i1 ~st~~ 'f1 ~r;m~ti1 mf~J <Q<!f~15~) ~ i1t1{<\\' #j'Mlljofl~ I Cll~ ~o:t, ~1{S'1
<.!l~

f~~~~r;~tt~

<.11"11

dI'f~

c~t1'~

~rn ~

~~""IlIi

c~

f~

@~~"'t~
cort<f·'!i{·C'Of~
~ ~

~ c!1~
~

f"\'l'; fm~ ~HJ

<1'1

'!ftt'f

.m I

Myth

c!1~ ift'li~9 <1>lf1 ~ I~~ '!ft~ 0I5i'1 .!rf~t~ ~<?tato:tr~f·i{<SIli<2l~1¥f "f<1fto;rt"'t (~Q '€ #j!Jff\!»
'f!:1{

~~<\iQ(i{

'!1 ~o;r "'Ethnic" ~,;f,! I '!flllt1:lrQ '!ft1fcn J1'''Iit #j!Jf'tl(! '€tlf~" 'e"l\ta{ " <.11~ Ethnic C~~ ~~r;'IS ~~ I c!1'lf.. Ul~ ~ Ul~ '~"Ifi{C~1lf'. '@"'\fu<!"'t<i1If' 'f'!l'f~, c!1l:tc<fe '!i'tN'IS <!f~~ifCCI Ul~ f~"t~ coqji""l '!'<li "fJt~tii;f os>J..C!1 Ciftil <I'!f\ ~~ ~ ~'<Im~!1 "f1i~~ I '~ '6I11M Colonialism filC~ ~t1:iil1 ~~ 1 '@~ 'SitOlii11<!Jt~r!1, ~t!1 ~" ~r"1' <.!1'<f 'f!l:C01s Ghetto cl5fi '!i\t~ f«i I C\!i'Sff"if;f't~!{ H~~ ~~lf <lit'll"'l ~~ ~ 0'[7;!lf <.!11{i{<l'~ 'ff<l'!'1 'lSttlltt'lfS :fIt~ ~tf.~ "~Of, lfl 'Sit'littlfl 'f.t<uf "Iici~ ~~t~ ~~tSf-( dI ~~1 mo:tC'lat WlfJt"ttEf'Tht'9 <\I13K~*l I ) \t1{t-1lV ~f~J\!il;"J1I" JrtOjlfM -n ~ ?fif1t;l:'i Ghetto <fC~ i.!l~ or<l'ior 1!{f'B'Sl\!itlf fwhlf'W11)Ofl ~ <Al ~m:Ofi I \5\1l'1tOf "I<forr4"!1 "I<t~~!\ <1l<f~ ~ ~'\!iJ~"J, ~'!i~ l~tt"1f 1{1W'lftflf" C'1' 'lfI<fc\!" ~t<i ~'lt'" MJ l@i~ f'f[ClI f.iC6f'S, c!1;if01' 'li~~~J~ c\!ia ~CQ\~, ~sS'Col'l1lf') ;jttDtc~ ~Cll <fC'Ol f<f~ ~i"I~~ ~1 <s>ttfl!i ~~~, <2ftfig~\!i1 ~nflr f~f~'il '1Tt"li~~J191t~ '@:{f\5' '~'ff\!i'-'!f ~<m:t~ ~~'&tt<li <2j'~ <!i1\lt~ ~'Sf <lir~ flfC',j~ I C~l\!i'j{)~ ~~ c!1fifC~ '\5{tCi.'\to:O{1 ~O{, '!i~o:t ~f<I: ~~C'\I' ~< \! "<RSOl, .i~f\!i~tl1 ~'6f OIt~ "Im.,- ~~, <!l 'l!.~\~ts~ ~ WstSj~ 'iil1I1" ~f~~t~~"5ons c<ft*f ~fo:!~~ "'1_<f~<f1f~ "tJtC<{i'Sf '1~0l <f~ <!~ f~~ ~ C'\1'4~ fil~,fu C'Il; ~f'!i~:f! 1)&\ ~ m"t·;-"tt~~C~~1, \!ifC\!) '\5{,\!"<>$''5fC'1~ m.~l ~. f-{1['1i';~ "lt~!t inner doma in I c!1 "IIQ,/1~1 m~ls <l'C3iC~o{ "'tN, ~ q f<fi§ m~i -~<ft6i:-nr.'<t'Q "M~f~!1t!ft ~f~~ Rl&ts \1I~ltOf '6l''Of~I .m 1 '<!ilijft~1i'-c!1s 'll:ii:!!fo:tt'lf Ql1{i{ Cltf'IItC.'lf~CO!"i1,". if/"l:ilrn st'sit'!l 'li~'R<!fl!1 \~.t. ''Of'€, ~l!\\!l<!>Jt".i ~~ ~ ~t~W1 <f1 ~t9· ~1l"~1 ~1Jli\!i C~4i 'Int. C'ib'll"fo:t 1t<ifll: inner domain Ulllii ~"<ji ~l:o{l?ffoltqt>o!<li ~~ lljl\l'Sf1 c\!im <li(~ CiHl I co;Jl\!i'li i1<11t~ "<!i{!\o:t, \11~

I.!l<m

~~rn

~m~

!iltll'lt'lf C5~<\i

~tO~~i'lf C~1'Sf1~!1

C'lf~

I cart~!Jft\!"
~

~1

~i 'f,(K<ii. '\;1 f'lS'SWl iB6D~1~ (c!P<I~~

"clP1ft" ~"'9j"CIf

1l'!f'!r ~ f ifil
~:Ij''fflf
r,<jl

~;lf·~ri;t1{

(bricolage)

<fn~1 0iI'ifl ~t~ )-c!1~ OI~ ~i 'Ed' ~rtfirltrtar, ~11R zt'f:~·~~"'$ <f1s~miB~9 ~ 'JIt'li\!" <lCO!~ I~ B <!f'n~~ ~~ subsumption-~1{ <!i'.!fl #j"lj'';;.'''ttc~!1 "Il <;fco!~o:r, ~t<Il~ ~<rtQf ~~, coercive selying~(!': <iSf C<J! "~.' ~ ~~ subsumption

«lf~

f~(, I
'iIIG

~fic~i<rt'Y I,jr~q:tlf <fQl <li"!i ~~~ I C~~l( "fq.f'\!~ 'I'i:<tfol~m'\! ~t~ ~1 f~'i <fiCS! 'l.c<tf firc~ '5'fOI" "Ii$1r.,fu'ff!1 <f1 f'\!~-.Tk~S'
c!1 6St~ #j~
~l{",~

I C'1''Sf1OfIClf!{ file'Y

'!i~~~

"C~i~lJ~,f~ i1f\l!f!1 JtG~

'DS\"·s

c-rem I
'5tCf I

~m'1 "~ ..
'€

C~"f

C'!ifill "tt"lt"ttf.or Ul~ ~~!1<1

I"["f! "'Iii nr'it'l iI'I I II r ,r.'1I" c,,~cttc"f

(

<.fIW Cl{lf~~ <litt'Sf'Sl

-F1'ft'!!I'1

'!{tf\€'f!19

~-e <11 ~C:'!i

Q{

:ij~o:t
<!ftlfJ

11,Ii 11'1111111I'!.'

"fti'J, C"Illil'

~C'1o:t

~f~ f~ll: ~1

!ulll

C'i,

,q·r:.

'!f1lrtClf!{ c!1~"I' Clf'i'iI' cort"-<!i{·CQf1~ ~t~f'Sf ~ ~~ ~~ \5ft'litorn ~-Ci(t,,-~\,f\!" "-eClfit" iE-mor c~

~i"Pt ~,

1·1~1 1 I~I \

11l"tt
lejl

1!I{<f~ ~C!1'Sf <f"?li 'f1 0{t~'ii ~~, l'Il~t"f ~tfif~ f"Wi, ~fttl(!rn tll'lJf'O{ C'lfc<'(i fllf'llitlf l!{~iI' r.'l '1lhi''f ll"5o:t1 'fC!1", 'l!i1 '!{t1{tClf!1" 1)oiff\! N'lft"'''ft!1" :Jftllf

Disciplines~i.!'li'l' ~ <TiQ)1<1~ dlC'5ft~) I

~:t :t

I~t~tfir c'2l~'tI c<mrf~

"i1 I .

fi{a;c<{

fi~f{
I

~.ft,(Ol~t&1

mOl

~~~

~"t~~.

f"'f'l'ft~. 'f~-~"t"ITt~ <fWHf tfItfQj'\; ~iif1-~VW\1 f"l:fif~ Dtiift-T <A'1 ~. ~ '6 "f~l\!ilr" ~w CJf'8~1 ~-fi~1 ~C~ &wt5"l ~ I <!I'f-. 'il::t~ii w'<l1 fitf~'6 ~ 5Qjf\!i ~'11\1t\'l' ift\'l'<Rt~ <iitt~ I c~"ttCGiBl ~1?tt\!i mttsr'i1 ~1)1;it. f"'f<rt~1RtWffl <l\"t!tit ~ mv·'6 \'I'fgr'fC\1"~ ~'1'J-<fIf~ I f~~1 ~~ em @~iJl't~'i\ <ruI'Ol 'I1'!~Ji~Jttil\'l' <\>ffi~'! »tm C'!Isr~1 C~~ m'\ii»tt~ 1!ifV~ f5f;mr m f"f<lt~\'I' <2ff~ "tti I 'l'f1f'!1'€ ~"t~'\;
~~-~~\'I'

flfC"lar ~1

f~~iJ

~ C1I'5tt<{ 'l'flt~-

II~II ~'-i CII' ~~ ~if ~t~~

~tt<\SM ~~,

c~ C1{

'R ~~ '6ir~ ~t'l:f!l{J/~'ifli\!i1\!i'<l1 ~'ifli'!il

~'®l:,n't'1~ 1\~WIjf - <.!11;i ~rn1 iJ?lijil'GtiI fm 'Wf ~<l,' ? ~~~ '!{i"l1 <HIt<{1, ~1" '1r*'(til;\!il~ <il~ f;!'\11~ '~rf\!ii{ ~f'li<lttlf. ~ ~<{5r;'1f'i1 csr"fl '${tlftDfll ~ifi1tif 'liftc~1 mf'SfrAI t\fC<l, ~1 c~ il;;;ftOl ;'t]e.srtt"t lltfo;mr (Ift'l, ~t~t "1Jir. ~i!~""I~ I f11!1, Of<{1:§1, ~ ~sr '{C'illrtf.ror qj~
"l'1 'll11\'1', ~

r"

rn\!i

~~

~i\!~

.it 1ftf~c'f Ctri-I

f~~

c~~
~ ~)

C<{fqcv ~:Jj

Q'I~~\;i c<r'f 'SIClf ~1 fir~1\'I' ~~"lt~ ~R!-~t<t1 <ft«J\!i~ ~~1f !

I <!I;q; <!I'llJr-r

<!I~ ClI1t16t~ 11<111 ""1fi-, ~~'itRl 5t~ '1_~~'\;1 ~ Ci\'~~ >JR!9 <1Sr.,«, ~CO!C<f f11c 9{tr~O!, 1Jl« f~r.1fJ"r ~t\! C:~'f @~~ ~tljfOfC<fi '1l~ Of'6~lii ~'81;il; lIt-em, ~~1~ ~1C<II~ ? <{1i'11\'l~1 c<l51f'i\?
<q1 ~

~~
cllft<!S

~
~~-

9f'tCi!<{ ~~

Clfit t
~~c<fi

<!I~ ift!fJ~W ( ~<'R;n lI't~ lfC!fJ~ fiIVc1f\1JI~ '8 JI~ <rt~J\;'t C'l;f'i\Vt~ ~'frIf~ :uI'1I~'\'\'I' ~lWTI1~;f~ ~w '!i{i\mt~ "'I~ st<f'fT.'<'lS C'5Ci!O ~\'I' '!i{~-"11Pn'~\'I'J[~~ C1f~ C!ifl:iJ ':Jj@ CSftI?i"{ tfI<TIaf t

~'hI m~
~ ~'@~~

\!itt
'6

i§~~f.:"l1I'
~1f

~tt5'l\'l' ~f.:~,

\!lft<f\'l'~

CitW

'!IRtm ~1 '!i{!cQ'lif<f'\!
~\; '6C~~~-'\;~
~\'I'~1f

iii C'l:ft~ ~~ ~W ~;ln:'\ii "11fil Ofi <!Ii;J ~~

'!i{tt5f tfI<rtiif

<Jf~

induction-deduction exduction.cae ~1 ~\'I''1 ~~~

~ttQ'ltf~
~K\5 ~

'{tf.<mr

m, ~

c!l~o:{

ilf~;t1f1
<.!1~ol

~tm
CiR

I iif1'11" C'lf1 Spark C'!fi.

1

or! ';[1;0l1

c-wtm

'lff~, 'f1jf~~~
~\!itW1

JI~~

'1m<rt~

'!{j«~,
~it

C:Jj~jfr11 ~1j~ 1iAA!' ~~ 'Stll:'!i ~~~

~"Jj"I~

l!{iftWm~~CfJ

iii '!i{~t\'l'~

~ ~<f1 ~t'Sf1 'i11C~i\t f"f<1t~ c"l~ Oft~"l' ~~ lf1f~. <1JJ<Ill1'l ~ ~\'I'str4't9j'tf-r I) <:!t1t~ ~l:1't~ I$:[t~

~su:'1 ~\'I' Gramar/'Uffl'1-'\5ftf<f'$iC<f\'I' 'ff~Sf1 'Ut<Hlt~\'I' :rJitf.a ft:~~'l

'it?lii

'S(I~ ICIf\'!' ~"",M7;<{1.:lIf

~'5Oifs.t$t~ I

C~\'I't~

fiotc\11~'fll.' ~iif jrfu-~t:~ ~ "lFrTll\!irn <1~~ ~~ c'l~C;O:{ Clft~ ~~1f

!I!.i{'ll"(.~'!:l

1m

m'ill COFf I

~m,.,\'I'
JI~~

'5t~!J ~~ <.!1~ ~~\'f

\!ift"l'trlfsr

~tFtrn

1S1<l1;

~t~tDf\'f

~,;f\!i

~'i1

I£t'j_f~ ~

~.,1

'5l'l:f1 ~ ;rt'OT1 Ifl~ Ifl'!ffi\'l' "l't<1f~ ~Tiif :Jftur.r ~ ~'§ I~0

lfCOi ~C\!l"tttl1

"tl:(t\! m I ~tf5\!i-"C<1iOl

<lftm-~
'5t~
~'!r

C:~l1 c~ I ~nl, f;r~l~ ~iif! 1tfo:rfil'-9{l!lIfiif-<ft\!iJl1(o1 ~'1I51'i,ij ~1 9{flS~ ~~f~ <I*~ ~~ ~,., "<at"t_~~11 I <;s~fi 11'!f\!i'5t11 ~sr c*I'G'tii'ifil', '1~. "C"iji~"-Spark! "~b't"l''' "~IO"-dI Iil~~~f~ 1fr;~ 'ljitlftQ'li I orr~r."t\'l' Col1tf1ftt:1Rt <fAA '51P!tl C~?;i1J\1 '5f'&' ~CiT I 1i1~1 t'ltmOil '1IWOI' s \5ft~ Cilft:<f firnt<mI <11' ~~9 (formal C~ non formal) I '3l1<1f;Pf'5t'i1 ft~ll'~ ~1' ~ ~'(g~-'!i{f~~ 'li(~~'ll ~ '!i{f<ffo1w <1tf"lfil C~. ~~~''Slt{~ '11 C~1{ C<I.!t<\I ~ ; <f1 Q,\;rN c'<ft<liCQI!iJJ ; '1'1 \!.IO!tJl"l' C~ <lim'i1 "till \!it<f C~

~t<t>t\'l'-<Jf'&-~~,

~~~a ;

~~~<R. ~,.,

t~'fi{ 011

'!i{f~.t;~S!-~t~

~t:1~ C'1I~

Oft"ft';iirn":<ll1.:\'l'

Qi'ro<fi'{-

~~<1isr

~C\1~

~\'0~?"

(,\!ii <{if ~~; C~ c~~ 6t<{C\!l '1tC\'l'"l If,~~lr ~.a .,latSjT<ltlf-~"'Ifort<l"f~ttlf'i1 ~C\!1 <If ~t<li<rtt'i1~ ~"'If~-\5f11l ~ 1T,-TcIfQ i\t~-lf1"ll ~~, ~1 C\!l1 ~ \!l"ft<fi'1\!i "~"'If.lwr \!i~" "1f~\!i! ~? ~~~1~? ~t~i<liS>ft~ i§3fi{j1:f., 1T,~if $vgsr lI''Sf'Sl c~tsf~ Wt:\'I', ~'1iIiSf ~f",\i; ;;rt$l, 1.!l<1~ ~\;1' 1T,~if ~~ 11'1P,!i ~mTIl' ~'5fti{ C'Sft~~. \!i'ill01' ~R<!l~-I.!ll1 ~JI<ftIf'1 C'lft~ ~~1'<!i\'f;;r ~ ~-W~ (~ 1t~-'1l'~ort ~ <il~l'[<l ~M\!i"Ii~ ~"tf.lt<l,'f"t~ ~~\!i 5R R1'llf\'l' f.lt:'SI~ ~1 ~~, "lji~-~f\!i"ilfll''''''sr ~~ ~1tm~-~<r~WoI. ~r'1l' ~ Wt:'1l'~,c\;~ c"trn ~ if'! f~ \!i'illif T

~~~1~\$ ~~

~tf.Q1l:1',

~'111

~"l!!

ort-\5ft1.fi1"'1I, ~'8'i1-'li(t'{R'f "lft'\!il 41 @r:o\lt\;l 1

@,€~F~t~\!i1
\'!I{~~

Jl<rt~ C'\;l 'l'f~1'i1 C~ ~1fo{~~~

('!i{tlfh'r

C~<f-<4t9j'~

1'1 .n~'\ii1·
~

R~"ftii

'5{tOffi<fi~ ~ I:l\~

(''S('t'IfIQ''~''~

C1tOl I lllS'll t1.i!1

<li~t:'1 'SItR I ~t ~ ittN ~'!I ~ f<fC=rf=rf'lil~ '!i{1'fl{l'C<!I' ~ 'l"Mf~ 't;"'1{Sj' ',5Ff'n~ c<i'CS; ~it, \'!I{>lrt"¥ <f1l'0i!1<1>t"¥ 1fI'lf (;'3tr;sror, ''3J'.ifit1{3 f~Oil Oft ll;~ I

lQ'f ~~9j'c;o:{)

~~-~'1f.t~

<fitOil-

c'<1it'lft~ c"'f'fSl ?'.

1')jlTlt<\'tfE ~tsr'1\5'&

h~~mf~ 1C~.,.

'ft~~ ~~!

f\:jf~ ~
'1{${

IIff ~ ! I!l~ 'S(tWl ·rf,,&'i1 ~~ ~l{rOjl? c<t>t'¢111c4t:i["l' f'\iifil ? "11, ~Ml ~~1 «1"~tf5 $~$~, ~, ~!'-I.!l '!Itfit' C"l~ I C'l~ 1 1"1 C'l'~ ~~ &Of ~. c~ .2tN c1f'tmtc~ <!I~~"1'~

<I\"C~

~ :!,

8/C'\5t~tfi C<£t~'t1 c"'Itm

~

oITilfoTl l!1~~/~H f<li I ~~<f1 ~

~lI"~ f"ff1ff::~t~O{

Clf1{~ lIt'f ~'f-dl~ f"t"R'-<tli ~G~r<\ !

~1VfQ.

<-'11fOf O{lJ."I' '!l.~ ~'eon~t<fI

~'lfO{

foI~ I 'fi:<:!1I"tti;1f'f'IPt"t"tit

<-'1~~"I <Iit~

~O{

"<mart

f~

~~lj<1;

Gf~0{-ClI"'Si1t"1-'\2f~-!Z111'f<1i.

ftt-~fif~ilJ<RJ1

~~Jtfir <Ko;f~

'!{tlftrn fo{t'S/C<:P"I1 051:1 'Il;f'lf C<li1ij) "'tfff \Stft r ~1~ o.Q~~ S1~~ "tN~. l'rt~ -u~ OIl ~ "tt"fC"'t~, OIl ~ CQiij-R~tt"f$! fflf<{il; <tl fe'J'fl? '-'.l~ ~onijj'f~~,\I1, "'Ifr<ll"~ C"!i1~lf'Si'§'i't1i1 'l'1alf ~~~ Gr.~n ~ "tR'<1i 1~11 4f'lf<ll~i'fC<t' ?£: ~'lI filCU <raIt\!i "tWI': " ... 'it"l ~ c.,~ ~ M~ "'tt~ll I"
Ilf~1J <.Q~c\Sl c;llfiro:{ '\5ftilm ~<l' ( ~'!) <ri,Ji C'ff&:Oif 1~

c~tll'1l "Il~1·1, 'll'l~ \!lCi!J Gft"lfI~<Ii ~<:f5f <.!I<i't, I!llt~<jS W~ "!l\r{liiC<Iifl Amhivulonce (Lq~t'l3·~JtP.~~ <IJai ! ) ~~1 "'It~ 0{1 f<filt I ~ "I~ ~~tll" 5t'''1 '1'1( • ~(1\11,~·J! '!;j '~J ttotfo:l~ i!ffiIm~ &Of 11:111 I Clf~'ii
f~l']C<Ti!ljC~~ ~'iit!![

mJ

<.Q~~

'l"~o{

t<Ii "l1f~~ ~q <f~~J, ~"nt SJ11)1'"1hl ,,,,to{ f"l~~l1 ~ ~~i1 liM fq on ljtOW~ I, fJ;c'<f\-brIT-' 1f-IC'ij!! '!l"~~'tt'l1"ca;t" ~.,f\!j"-C<ii @"tRt'W't'!l

<!I~,~

({Jt~C4ffi

<:fI~\!i~"

'f.""1.I~t\l ,M.tt' f.
,,'11'"1

"1111"1 r.tll~ ~~~1ir·<tril[~rn-~'1~,-~~fff ~~1.

\'1

G9fiiltll!C~:1
1:!I{t-!fi:1Ltj'l

\1 ~II

'1 (Ollf Wf<1li~ "itt~1~'TQ

C'-f~tto{ \N.~

ClWt c:mO{tt!1: '5{tiilttiRl" 'll'?Jf"it 'i!)Q)I ~~; ~t'(5~1 (O{~ I (Jj~ ~rn ~tt9fif;lt \8"19

~,

f4~i~"!f

f.{t~ 'fjl:)jJ <lI"tl!! "i1irn I

'ilfl(ft"t<p-"1i1~ ;sri]] a1 f<li'lt\!l ffrr« ""tftt~ r$"tt~fst <firn "t?fT~1~f;r(\!i r5tw, ~t~ijj'?{rn
'i!ltQ ~OfQl m

R"tR~

tfw.!

~$fC"" 'i!lil'( C'i!lii!iI ~#{1

Oftij), ~~"I'

l?I~tco1 '1.~
Clf~ '!1"~ 'i!)t~ijj'

.*"

'lie

t'1 wilt· •

J\ ntj'()1

11111 C'iit~"' Cilt~'" lIj-w 1t"Ito{: 'l't"lf.(I·~-f.lra"« lj1W~. 111 ~ UIJlIL.' Irnmrnllr, o.!Iii1 Oftf'1 'ilfPim
\!q 'ti!. '1~9

II
'It·

l ~ 'Ii'

"II' I

(~.1f!l~

j 1> ""4'll

~C<lit, ~ttqf

o;tf<t>,
~~i

"l~ I

t:l)j\lj.r"·~

~I \ "~ J kdgn ''''' Do sign 'fC?l~! ~-I'1l'~C!!llf<f'\5 ~I • OH 5~f~\'I 1B1>f<1iCWl!! "11f~"f'lf.... "1I1ftOftf'Sl<ll"~~'ii.,i!!fij ~
~QC~ CO'fi'{

~JP!!111 !!I'Ilt'l

? ~C1J{ f<fi S*'Dt~ ~~ ~'iiW~"ft~ ~~ ~ 'iil. {s"t1t"'f"i{ <rI ~ri? dl<t~ (..,~ljt'lf~ "'iIfw"1~\!i ~11, ~hl lIFoll ~t~ ~C:.<f ~~~ "tJttQtf\5 I ~tflf <:SiS1 o.fl~ fm~-lt 'lft~1 ~ <1"1t,D1[i'ftl!l ~~Jto{ QQ.\1 ~ ~ ~lm,. ~!Jf I ~1 ~ <m1~"1 ~~~a;lt 'The Mimic Man'-<.Q$T ~.f~~!![ I!!{~<f: "we pretended to be real, to be learning, to be preparing ourselves for life, "we mimic men of the New world, one unknown corner of it, with all its reminders of till'!' corruption that came so quickly to the new."")
"'8CI{Q"

.J11;J-r1 <f(Sl,

.rm 'e~tQ"

~t~·1'l'1 <-'1~ ff~:lf1ili ,~tf;p:f\!it~Q ~ ~ t 1 <tl~"'f o:srt~'Dttil1 r.m~ (<fi~ "'~ ~tia~
J1Q'flI

<lI"~~ q~i!lO{"11 I ell" ~\!Hf-'5{t!_f.1'f'\i5t'€

dil <fiR

~1;

.m·\Y<1f"1~<1"'I<Tjlf \

~~-~tifl, ~tl(-QJ;1«fl
II 5rn

~1l"

fi1~ ~t~~ R"'tlf !

II

.J1<lll;1<fJt"ft?1 ~ ~~~ '1'ttlt I l{'S ~<J: NRI ~ Globe trotter-ore '1"l~ m~1"1<.!I~ I ell ~1; ClrfinmlfQ ~ ~'1'f"i1t~"t <.Q<fi ~"f'M

~9ff~f~, ~~ '6'i~ R~
<P.1t~'1 1.!I~1lj<\"
I

"litll~ fO{!!'f(;~ f.{'lft'tt"ll

~'4Lij'{

.I {g91"U"t"ifC<li 1j'ft~OiflEio:{t

'-'.It<fi'TIti'! If"?!Jf"

~~art NRI

Rc-Ill'm~l!1f -

~~1 I '"'ttf~-;urf<f' 'Jj'ta;t'ft~ 'e C~~ ~'I.l 1 ~,1f'5~ lj~ "I~ 'lfW ~ ~ ~1fill:m~ ~t;Df"Ci11 ~'ff~ R~ ~, ~ Q~ "QC~ s-rtCQR \!i(lm<f~ 1 I!lltiS! tihl1 ~~~10{'l:t'if~r'f\l "lttstc'lf 'frsr <m~, ~ffi1 f<ti ~~ ~

~i~m1'[11; ~'lfO{ Mimic Man ~ "tRQ"R I f<l'~ 't{'eitQ Cfjg, <lI"C~flii~ "' I ~Jf.~~ t~"!1 filCi ~!iirt ~t~'~Q C"lft"t 'Dt<t>f.<r~c~ f'fnT ~f~~

*~

~o:{ <.Q~ "'lli"lt. C1'[~ '5i1'01Q1 C"l<1.ll Mf~ or"!'1- Rm~ ~!fJ i' C<tl1S f<:!i ~~~'ii 0{1 'l>fJtUTtflS? ~~<tit~ \tt5" ~tr6 C5C"l'flfC~C1~ 1'[t~ "Ii f<l' ~~'G1 Ph.D t ~<r-. C,,!~ ISt::S1-'fN'" 'SJtt;stCil1 f~ @"'I~\!i ~C~ Oli. ~toI~l<f~ 't~t"f li~ ('\5Jt;~ ~"I' ~tt'Jj' on, <-'11;J ~'5\ \!i(t1f1'tlr\'f

\!l~"~

'~~'!I"
<i1~ ~~

NRI I~r<.t~ ~~t<I' f~l'i'1 1.!I<!i~'!I"! ~-~tr{'~ f~t!f, f\!iif "I~ ~~t~ fo{{tf'l'~ iil~~1 (lft~i Fanon-<.!IQ <ll'<lt1 "wretched of the earth" ) ~"1;J ~ il"tm1 Qft~ <rn~ "I"tftI" I ~l'5t~ 'iii, ~k"tc"tQ ~'4n!/ ~~, Clff<flfi <2f~t~ ~~~-'Oft~<li ro~t\!l" "<!I~ ~ ~~ C'fta; ~-'5{<rn<rm'1 ~~J ~~ ~'[.! ~cf <lim ~~ ~1. <1'$''f}$ ~<Ii~1~ ~'If.~1tt"!i I" H ~ ~1r;"tC"fQ ~1 "!l\t'llKIi'!:1 'll~1
c$.rt~ I

f~"fjOJ'''l,f'J q?!11fhl ~
<-'1~

lR~

\51 ~~e fif <1a;«,{j,

f\!'~ "1'1~ ~fol~tll o.Q'<fi'tfir~ <Ii1t'Sf )~~1 {gll(f~'S r' mWll1

5Jtl''I'S1 fl<9\wrtt'H 'lft~l ~~<lI"1·f'1.t?!t;ft f<U:~f3 faj"~t~ ~"I'", <t'!l!1: "Why should we listen to Derrida, Foucault, klein? Because, they have seen 'only the Enlightenment' from close up. We cannot and must nor do without the fruits of the IEnlightenment. The point is to use But that is another stOTY"~~

~fO{cw~O{

I)

them from below.

H\';I/Nt~tf.~ Otl'ii"'11
<f~ ~l(~'1

c9ftif.!f

il'Pf clftC!If f'I1i'jii\" il'1 I Sexuality ~!lftr;i{ C'Wflt~1 <1!m.:~

~m~$
fiI?f1~

\5te<{

®<>f~,

~tI1'

f~

I \ftt~'"t"?{ ~tl(r~ "1~'\; ~<fI or~Jcfll <l5{fiI;<>fM\'5'6 ~1; I *'PI"tl <ft~ 1tlflil'fTi 'fI ~i]fI5f'<!D Birth of the Clinic,
c!l~

m~<f

1:),

ill'ro ~
';):O17~ I

B.

Nationalist

C~ ~

History of f~if"'_ ~1m1<l5{t~ :lrtlftf~

Thought and Colonial World: Derivative Discourse ? London: Zed Books

A
~'i-

15f-rn C'l."'Ifi\1 f.t~ ~ e<{~t~ I <£I~<i 'fQ[l ~r<f1 \Wt~i{ if!, <ftQ'1 <:!it?! 15ff'5m~tll: 1ft~~?f f~ \!l~ -91fO{C«<-r"<f fi:I..ft~it 'SIi'11 ~~ '<J:r-ft i!!fTilt \'5 O{, I!!(tT(~ ~'ftfu
'\;161 ~i!1

It.

~~!ru I

"'llI"'~, ~I"'t

~t.,f

I1t~ :
I

·~"'fif~'l:f"f<f \5t~t~ ~'ft~

~'0 g )
I

'B

I" '!ltr(~'1

"'t?f
~

~~~1j'!f
~~ ~\!)

l(~"<f

ii\"-rt~, ~~tii\"

anatorno-politics ~
"C~Cl?iOj c<r'"t I
'5rn'! ~~ I

I;<j~m~~

\';I.
"II 11'.

)):11\1'

"'" I i' I 1\1 'J:'.'1' 1 I"

'''''1 nll'llatloll,

'll'qlt'1~ I and Rise of English"

bin-politics

.. ~1I1 8 ~ ';. ). I

c!l~ C~

~t'<tJ !

ICnlonialism

f"f<tt~ '\;f,,~f&rn

'\S~1"
~'?J~' lfC!!~

f"1tmn~ <:!in

l<et~1~
~"ft6i~

fOO{"to;f~ t!;<f"tt'1i!~i{~ ~'filstc" 1§'1f~~ c>.t WI \5~c<1i'8 ~~J flftlJt~ ~~~tf'1'\; 1l0lf~ f<lt~c"~- I f<mr lfi( <fiQjtt'lS~ I 'l{fcart,,~"!:q'\!I: 'i!iT~ '1lftrPIt1;<f 'Wf1 ,~P.t~hit I ~~ <l5{tta;rt<ii'i;f~ ,g<W!C"If'"l'<ll" >ltf1'lti{ ~~'i!i <fiC\Wii <.!lfinl1-<I5{tf3l;'V1 a[jf'\;i! ~1 'f1 I ~!Iftt~ ~~ ~er iBftl'11 ,~~ ~ ~C!Jf ~Of~ I ~t"fiW~ ClI111w'1rn '1t-ei{', c'f111 ~ fo1~ro:rSl: l5f~m'\i.i11 c£1"'1t~ ,,~\t1 '{9~ ~~ I ~<fI <!t~'i!i '1t~~ ~0If~ f~<t ~w ~ I ':fQ11~ ~~it f'fo2J1'f I fOKfj w"ib~'\;'1ttifu ~ ~~<fl?f l§'1Mf~ "Sf"'J 'fSfi{ ~ u•••.• , o{~!l: ~t~ "I~"Sf ~"'" 1I't~ -e ~t~l?f nf~'i{ ftfu~wr~-e'1it, c m<otlf ~W"' eiI01~S!Iil"-~~tfiri!i ~~ -e I5\1{fOj<fi' '>If~1'\;:ij <S'if.mf-t'f Ul<1, '1ii<1~<ffiiiI" ~~ st~~ ~ i!!ft"Sf ~'«ffi '1'm~ I ~~c; 1:;;;[~, ~,<1trf~, <ft<{l1~-t ~".8.1, ~Jj~ ..~t'&tit-ref<lS~~ft'~1; ~01"I\1lJt't<t0{1, cll.f~r;~'"ti{, ~t~OfiI, '!{tifi{'l' f"f$[ t;c;<ftlltO{ C'fOff.'101I!!t1\ ~'li0j ~ f~il" '11;'1:1, Sfm~t'tm -~~J'!~ Itjf'\'5irtrom f<r"flf ~f~t~B ~~ '~t<1l!Ml;f.f $1'Rs'Si','-c£1'll: f<f1:f~ ~ti '1\?6i I"a C"I1f ~.,tMit <IS~tC'\i.i~ I ~~ ~tt~Hi~ Ul~ 'f~~~ f13R fQft~~, '<\5t<'{ ll,.mtl{~ '1t'1f w'1t:'fits11 lfj ~1 (~!lftll: 'Sft~, f"tt!lf cil"B~1

'l~~f~O{ ~~

~r:~~ 'a;~
'<I5{'l1'-DfQ

q~ii\"1 \i;~ lftwl' 15{-rn 'f~~"'f1U~ I5{t~C6i \i;<f'l1t'f '1i:~t~

rrw,
I" 1

V: IS

'I'h(

III! 1mntc HlICII1Y, OUl'.

~"?f

I5{ttm~

W~

Nationalism. OUP. ) \ • (~:a::t 11') I A ltctnati ve Sciences, OUP )~, )) ~ ~I Til Nations and Its Fragments. OUP ~. ):;,). I "History Really Begininng t Compulsion of PostColonial pedagogy." EPW . XXV: 15
)1II II
)\!l.

I '1'lIl' 1.lll'~itlnlllcy

or

~):;.t

~~Jt~tifJl~,

m'~~lf I Folklore
I

and Folk language

Myth or Reality?
) 9.
)to

Kalyani University

"rt'~
m

':I:O'01t
) ,.l;rb-

I
I
\ '!I '!I

~~~w.n
~t(f;{
'B

-e~'lff'\'5

I Indian Linguistics. 49 : 1-4. I

)~.
)~.

):;,:;.9

f;r"fti{ I ~(C1t~

;}'f~<fJ

)'11'.

);:,,:;.) I

~'i1"1tQj"'S11~t6f ~;;pflft'f: '"l1~<:SJ I '1J'tf'1~t'f I

t;9ffilX~'lt1f

'S

oft~iif1

f"t"""

~,

'i!iCif"{

:t...

ari<u)
Rami BhaBha. )<lb-S I "of Mimicry and Mao: Ambivalence of Colonial Discourse,"
»)OI~

~~.

The
I

:n..

I ..~~~t~

~~J
: :t

7 ~f'Sf, '1'tPl,,;f\5
I Breast Stories.
I

'B

~f~~ ~if11t
mUt<fl-IT

~"%~tconl" 'l'ti!!f I" ~gj"\'jlg ~"lft~~

:t.".
~s.

<!{:(l1. ~'b
)~~'1

'2{~tct~

(.lf~

~fir<ftit"
~0Ii I

) :11:0IT 1

f;j'!l'«~* ~~

~tii\"<fit'\'5i:

).
~.

);a'"
))"IT)

I Otherness of English, Sage.

I

1!I{i'foi~

'l'JI't'!l' ~r:-f6i ~<fIl

f~:I'{l,

~. : ~ I