writing of the hadith, you can sense merit and integrity in the told stories; in addition to that,you should also see clear compatibility with Quran. However, when you read the second part,you should sense the opposite, i.e. sensing non sense, manipulations and incompatibility withQuran, and even incompatibility with the first part of the same book by the same author.Of course that Mushrik author concluded that the Man Made hadith should be written,otherwise he would have convicted himself and all his hadith worshipping pals in his ownbook.Today, I am going to walk you through the first part; but in the second part, I will only showyou the only evidence they presented from the Quran to support their allegation for writingthe hadith. The reason of not replying to their evidences from their hadith supporting thewriting of the hadith should be known by all who read my criticism, you al
l know that I don’t
reply to evidences presented against me from their Man Made rubbish books of hadith, on theother hand, myself as a complete hadith rejector and denier has the luxury to use such crapagainst its worshippers from among the kafirs and their fellow Mushrik Muslims; the kafirsand Mushriks will never have such luxury against me, THEY CAN ONLY USE QURANAGAINST ME.The first 17 pages in this Man Made book takes us through the time of the prophet, then itmoves to the time after his death (very early Muslims), then it moves to a later time after that,
the time of the followers of the very early Muslims. So let’s get the ball rolling:
1- The hadith from the prophet prohibiting writing the hadith:
ٝ ٚ٤ِػ ٠ِ ٢ُ٘ا ٕإ ،١سُا ٤ؼع ٢أ ٖػ٢ٗـُا ٍهٝ ٕشوُا ٟٞع٤ ٢٘ػ اٌٞ ٍه ِْع
ٚذٔ٤ِك ٕشوُا ش٤ؿ ٢٘ػ ً ٖٔك
Abi Saeed Al-Khadri said that the prophet said: Do not write anything from me exceptQuran, and whoever wrote anything from me except Quran, he should Erased it.
The above compelling proof from their own Man Made book is directly from prophetMuhammed and is repeated in this book through different chain of narrators 8 times, i.e.Mutawatir hadith (popular and is circulated orally a lot between the sahaba). We have seenalready that Ahmed Ibn Hanbal listed it in his Man Made book 5 times through 5 differentchains of narrators.---------------
2- The hadith in which Abi Saeed Al-Khadri asked permission from the prophet towrite the hadith but was refused:
ِْك ٣ذُا ًأ ٕأ ٢ُ ٕر٣ ٕأ ٚ٤ِػ ٠ِ ٍٞعس تٗرعا ٍه ١سُا ٤ؼع ٢أ ٖػ،٢ُ ٕر٣
.٢ُ ٕر٣ ٕأ ٠ك ١سُا ٍهٝ
Abi Saeed said: I asked permission from the prophet to write the hadith, but he did notallow me to do it.And Bukhari said it: He refused to allow me to do it.
.The above hadith is repeated 3 times through different chains of narrators, in one of thosethree times, not only Abi Saeed who asked permission from the prophet to write hadith, but